What do you think?
Rate this book
The Roman Holiday Rule: A No-Spice Magical Realism Rivals-to-Lovers Contemporary Romance Set in Italy
Lexi Walker has finally committed to the Italian adventure that she and her late mother dreamed of for years--complete with a meticulously crafted itinerary, four sealed letters to open at Rome's most romantic sites, and her mother's final painting to present at the art festival Lexi is helping organize. She's ready for the perfect Roman getaway. What she doesn't expect is for her mother's artwork to start manifesting in real life, turning her carefully planned trip into something unpredictable.
Italian-American architect Mark Russo has sworn off American tourists after having his heart broken, and he's certainly not about to let another one distract him from winning the restoration bid that could reunite his estranged father with his grandfather. But when the captivating woman next to him on the flight to Rome proposes a photography challenge--whoever captures the heart of Italy in five days wins--Mark can't resist the bet and her charm.
As Lexi follows the letters from her mother around the city, she encounters Mark everywhere she goes. Their competitive banter turns to undeniable chemistry, but they both know the cardinal rule of holiday You can't fall in love with someone who lives somewhere else and expect a happily-ever-after. Will a little magic--and a lot of mishaps--break the Roman Holiday Rule?
Andra Loy serves up a delightful blend of witty banter, swoon-worthy romance, and sparks of magic in a love story that's as enchanting as Rome itself.
Italian-American architect Mark Russo has sworn off American tourists after having his heart broken, and he's certainly not about to let another one distract him from winning the restoration bid that could reunite his estranged father with his grandfather. But when the captivating woman next to him on the flight to Rome proposes a photography challenge--whoever captures the heart of Italy in five days wins--Mark can't resist the bet and her charm.
As Lexi follows the letters from her mother around the city, she encounters Mark everywhere she goes. Their competitive banter turns to undeniable chemistry, but they both know the cardinal rule of holiday You can't fall in love with someone who lives somewhere else and expect a happily-ever-after. Will a little magic--and a lot of mishaps--break the Roman Holiday Rule?
Andra Loy serves up a delightful blend of witty banter, swoon-worthy romance, and sparks of magic in a love story that's as enchanting as Rome itself.
329 pages, Kindle Edition
Published August 4, 2026
About the author
Andra Loy
1 book109 followersAndra Loy writes hopelessly romantic rom-coms where love bends reality, and her pre-published works have won numerous awards. Andra moved to Europe to teach English, where she hitchhiked, was sworn to secrecy about a secret mushroom hunting spot, and fell in love with the only American man in her small Czech town. Now, she lives in Michigan with her husband and three teens, teaching English, playing piano, and reacquainting herself with the American library system.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 181 reviews
Want to Read
May 30, 2026🍧🌸💕 𝓹𝓻𝓮𝓻𝓮𝓪𝓭
my bae audrey hepburn better be in this
my bae audrey hepburn better be in this
August 4, 2026
FULL REVIEW
4.5 stars, rounded up for Goodreads
My Quick Takes:
- 4.5/5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️✨
- Genre 📚 contemporary romance
- Language 🤐 none
- Spice ❤️🔥 kisses only
- Content 🤔 past death of parents, grief
Super cute book, perfect for a summer read.
This book had all the things I love: Travel, art, and Rome! The different moving elements and plot points throughout were really fun. Before you think this is just another romcom, Andra Loy strikes a good balance of banter and puns with grief and heartache. Written in dual point of view, both main characters are quickly endeared to the reader. I personally love a dual point of view!
4.5 stars, rounded up for Goodreads
My Quick Takes:
- 4.5/5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️✨
- Genre 📚 contemporary romance
- Language 🤐 none
- Spice ❤️🔥 kisses only
- Content 🤔 past death of parents, grief
Super cute book, perfect for a summer read.
This book had all the things I love: Travel, art, and Rome! The different moving elements and plot points throughout were really fun. Before you think this is just another romcom, Andra Loy strikes a good balance of banter and puns with grief and heartache. Written in dual point of view, both main characters are quickly endeared to the reader. I personally love a dual point of view!
May 30, 2026
Review of advanced copy received from Netgalley
This book was truly okay, in every sense of the word.
Lexi was okay—I almost never wanted to smack her in the face, but I also didn’t really care if she lived or died for most of the book. Mark was okay—nice enough guy, I don’t have much to say about him. I didn’t think I would like either one of them, but by the end of the book, I can say that I genuinely did.
The romance was okay. I’ll admit they were endearing enough to eventually scratch my indifference, but it took a while. And by the time I started to care, I was majorly bored.
My first impression of Mark was that he was very much “not like other girls.” I begrudgingly warmed up to him, and to Lexi. At first, I hated that he called her Lexington. Because Lexi is such a nice name. And Lexington is so... not. It’s very cute that it’s what her mother used to call her, and I warmed up to the nickname over the course of the book. But I fear it didn’t make the name any less unfortunate. I will admit, the one and only moment he called her Lexi did hit as intended, so kudos there.
The side characters were probably the best part of the book, so it’s a shame they weren’t better developed. I really liked Nonno, Luca, and Mr. and Mrs. Gallo. They were a cliche older couple, but they served their purpose. I was even a fan of Katie, who we knew for like five seconds.
Remember when I said I almost never wanted to smack Lexi in the face?
The Katie misunderstanding was a dumb assumption to make. I understand that an obstacle for the romance was necessary, but it truly did not need to go on for as long as it did. Especially when they already had a worthy boulder between them that Lexi could have been harping on. But I wouldn’t say that warrants a smack in the face. Maybe a nice shove.
What really irritated me was the whole “we can’t be together because-“ shit at the end. Like girl, please get a grip. Not only was she severely overreacting, but also very much dragging it.
Oh, and the fact that she and Mark or his family “coincidentally” run into each other l i t e r a l l y everywhere she goes? Are Mark and Mark-adjacent people the only residents of Italy? And the envelope-picture coincidences? Please, there’s only so far I can suspend my disbelief.
Like its characters, this story was corny from start to finish. There were moments that made me smile, parts that made me roll my eyes, and (many) stretches of boredom. I don’t think I would reread it, but I’m glad I did. The epilogue was wonderful.
. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁ ⟡ ݁ . ⊹ ₊ ݁.
thank you to the publisher for the arc♡
This book was truly okay, in every sense of the word.
Lexi was okay—I almost never wanted to smack her in the face, but I also didn’t really care if she lived or died for most of the book. Mark was okay—nice enough guy, I don’t have much to say about him. I didn’t think I would like either one of them, but by the end of the book, I can say that I genuinely did.
The romance was okay. I’ll admit they were endearing enough to eventually scratch my indifference, but it took a while. And by the time I started to care, I was majorly bored.
My first impression of Mark was that he was very much “not like other girls.” I begrudgingly warmed up to him, and to Lexi. At first, I hated that he called her Lexington. Because Lexi is such a nice name. And Lexington is so... not. It’s very cute that it’s what her mother used to call her, and I warmed up to the nickname over the course of the book. But I fear it didn’t make the name any less unfortunate. I will admit, the one and only moment he called her Lexi did hit as intended, so kudos there.
The side characters were probably the best part of the book, so it’s a shame they weren’t better developed. I really liked Nonno, Luca, and Mr. and Mrs. Gallo. They were a cliche older couple, but they served their purpose. I was even a fan of Katie, who we knew for like five seconds.
Remember when I said I almost never wanted to smack Lexi in the face?
The Katie misunderstanding was a dumb assumption to make. I understand that an obstacle for the romance was necessary, but it truly did not need to go on for as long as it did. Especially when they already had a worthy boulder between them that Lexi could have been harping on. But I wouldn’t say that warrants a smack in the face. Maybe a nice shove.
What really irritated me was the whole “we can’t be together because-“ shit at the end. Like girl, please get a grip. Not only was she severely overreacting, but also very much dragging it.
Oh, and the fact that she and Mark or his family “coincidentally” run into each other l i t e r a l l y everywhere she goes? Are Mark and Mark-adjacent people the only residents of Italy? And the envelope-picture coincidences? Please, there’s only so far I can suspend my disbelief.
Like its characters, this story was corny from start to finish. There were moments that made me smile, parts that made me roll my eyes, and (many) stretches of boredom. I don’t think I would reread it, but I’m glad I did. The epilogue was wonderful.
. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁ ⟡ ݁ . ⊹ ₊ ݁.
thank you to the publisher for the arc♡
July 30, 2026
What an absolute dream. From the moment I picked the is book up (and read a random chapter and random page in the middle of the book to see if I wanted to read it lol don’t judge me I do it all the time and you can learn a lot if you do it, always works out for me) I decided to take the chance and read a book I’d never heard about and an author I hadn’t seen before. But you know what? That chance I took paid off because this was just what I was looking for.
A sweet, fun, swoony romantic book that had kisses and all the sweetness, but no explicit romance.
I really loved how the two main characters were attracted to the other by the first meeting, but before they had a relationship, they got to really know each other. Good, bad, and indifferent. They developed deeper feelings over real time and I think it was developed well.
The plot was cute and not too cringy while also not being boring or flat. The characters were in motion, but took time to rest and settle in scenes that held me in a warm embrace.
I would definitely recommend!
Content:
A few kisses
A sweet, fun, swoony romantic book that had kisses and all the sweetness, but no explicit romance.
I really loved how the two main characters were attracted to the other by the first meeting, but before they had a relationship, they got to really know each other. Good, bad, and indifferent. They developed deeper feelings over real time and I think it was developed well.
The plot was cute and not too cringy while also not being boring or flat. The characters were in motion, but took time to rest and settle in scenes that held me in a warm embrace.
I would definitely recommend!
Content:
A few kisses
June 1, 2026
The Roman Holiday Rule by Andra Loy
Upcoming Release | Pub Date: August 4, 2026
Published by Haven
I received a complimentary copy and was under no obligation to leave a positive review.
The Roman Holiday Rule made me want to book a flight to Rome.
One of the strongest aspects of this book was the immersive setting. Andra Loy truly painted Rome beautifully. The food, culture, architecture, and atmosphere made the city feel vibrant and alive, and I loved getting swept into the experience alongside the characters.
Mark’s family was a standout part of the story for me. Their presence added warmth, depth, and emotional weight beyond the romance, and I appreciated how important those relationships were throughout the book.
The witty banter, chemistry, and touches of magic added charm to the story, and the Roman backdrop gave everything a wonderfully cinematic feel.
Lexi was a more complicated character for me. While I appreciated her emotional journey and the connection to her mother’s dream, I personally found some of her choices and behavior frustrating at times, which made it harder for me to fully connect with her.
I also enjoyed seeing the book club discussion questions included at the end.
Upcoming Release | Pub Date: August 4, 2026
Published by Haven
I received a complimentary copy and was under no obligation to leave a positive review.
The Roman Holiday Rule made me want to book a flight to Rome.
One of the strongest aspects of this book was the immersive setting. Andra Loy truly painted Rome beautifully. The food, culture, architecture, and atmosphere made the city feel vibrant and alive, and I loved getting swept into the experience alongside the characters.
Mark’s family was a standout part of the story for me. Their presence added warmth, depth, and emotional weight beyond the romance, and I appreciated how important those relationships were throughout the book.
The witty banter, chemistry, and touches of magic added charm to the story, and the Roman backdrop gave everything a wonderfully cinematic feel.
Lexi was a more complicated character for me. While I appreciated her emotional journey and the connection to her mother’s dream, I personally found some of her choices and behavior frustrating at times, which made it harder for me to fully connect with her.
I also enjoyed seeing the book club discussion questions included at the end.
July 30, 2026
Lexi travels to Rome to fulfill her artistic late mother's final wishes, armed with four letters, a detailed itinerary, and one final painting. Meanwhile, Italian-American architect Mark is determined to win a career-changing restoration bid—until a spontaneous photography challenge keeps bringing the two together across the city.
This is what Lizzie McGuire dreams are made of!! Trevi Fountain, Vespa rides, cafés + pastries, picturesque piazzas, serendipitous encounters—this romance is one glamorous tourism montage, just as Lexi knew it would be!
Mark, on the other hand, is not wowed by the iconic sights (except Lexington, ofc!!). Don't think of this as a bad sign, though—Lizzie's Paolo was fully mesmerized by Rome, and we all know how that turned out... Instead, Mark is honest, intentional, kind, and incredibly talented. And as Lexi coincidentally spends time with his family, she quickly sees why.
The push and pull between these two—their bet, their pranks, their banter!!!—brimmed with possibility the entire time. If you enjoyed DRAWN TOGETHER's mysterious connections, magical city feel, and Fletcher's brooding mixed with Flora's optimism, I've found your new favorite book!!
Now eat some pasta, put on Lizzie McGuire in the background, and prepare to finish this in one sitting.
Thank you @havenfiction @uplitreads for the book!
Perfect for you if you like:
A touch of magical realism
Serendipitous spirit of adventure
Flirting rivals
Similar:
Drawn Together by Juliana Smith
Not What We Pictured by Becca Kinzer
Sometimes You Stay by Liz Johnson
🌶️closed door romance (kisses only)
⚠️previous death of parents, grief
This is what Lizzie McGuire dreams are made of!! Trevi Fountain, Vespa rides, cafés + pastries, picturesque piazzas, serendipitous encounters—this romance is one glamorous tourism montage, just as Lexi knew it would be!
Mark, on the other hand, is not wowed by the iconic sights (except Lexington, ofc!!). Don't think of this as a bad sign, though—Lizzie's Paolo was fully mesmerized by Rome, and we all know how that turned out... Instead, Mark is honest, intentional, kind, and incredibly talented. And as Lexi coincidentally spends time with his family, she quickly sees why.
The push and pull between these two—their bet, their pranks, their banter!!!—brimmed with possibility the entire time. If you enjoyed DRAWN TOGETHER's mysterious connections, magical city feel, and Fletcher's brooding mixed with Flora's optimism, I've found your new favorite book!!
Now eat some pasta, put on Lizzie McGuire in the background, and prepare to finish this in one sitting.
Thank you @havenfiction @uplitreads for the book!
Perfect for you if you like:
A touch of magical realism
Serendipitous spirit of adventure
Flirting rivals
Similar:
Drawn Together by Juliana Smith
Not What We Pictured by Becca Kinzer
Sometimes You Stay by Liz Johnson
🌶️closed door romance (kisses only)
⚠️previous death of parents, grief
June 23, 2026
I absolutely loved the lush Italian setting! Sights like the Trevi Fountain really came to life in the pages of the story and it was fun to visit them on page. I also loved all the Roman Holiday references, like riding about Rome on a Vespa. The main character loved the movie and talked about it a lot which I enjoyed as well.
However, I didn’t love the romance. Mark was very antagonistic toward Lexi simply because she was a tourist, which seemed like a very minor thing for him to basically become unhinged toward her. I did like seeing their relationship evolve over the course of the story and how Mark became more comfortable with her as the book progressed.
This is a completely clean read and overall a fun debut. The cover is just adorable as well. I will keep an eye out for this author’s next book.
Thank you to the publisher, Haven, for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
However, I didn’t love the romance. Mark was very antagonistic toward Lexi simply because she was a tourist, which seemed like a very minor thing for him to basically become unhinged toward her. I did like seeing their relationship evolve over the course of the story and how Mark became more comfortable with her as the book progressed.
This is a completely clean read and overall a fun debut. The cover is just adorable as well. I will keep an eye out for this author’s next book.
Thank you to the publisher, Haven, for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
August 4, 2026
When Lexi and Mark meet at the airport, life for both will never be the same.
Lexi is delivering a mystery, original painting done by her well known Mom, the artist. She donated this piece to her fans in Rome and Lexi will present the canvas and make a speech at the 2 day art festival co-produced by her marketing and event planning company and the Roman Department of Cultural Affairs.
Mark is waiting to find out if his bid to renovate an historical mansion is accepted by the Italian Heritage Society and property owners. Winning this bid will have major implications for his entire family: healing a broken heart, three years of guaranteed income, restoration of long stressed relationships and an opportunity to build his company and reputation.
While on the planes to Italy, Lexi and Mark enter into a few bets with each other. Time is short for Lexi. Her return flight is in 10 days and she’s also got to solve the mystery waiting in the 4 envelopes given to her by the executor of Mom’s will. Everything in Mark’s future is hinged on the bid, even his tenure in Rome.
Will Lexi solve the mystery left by Mom?
Will Mark win the bid? Foster healing for the family?
How does all this affect the contests between Lexi and Mark?
Does anyone win?
THE ROMAN HOLIDAY RULE is author, Andra Loy’s debut novel. It’s a RomCom in all the best ways: endearing characters, snappy dialogue, scenes that you’ll see coming pages ahead but will enjoy them immensely, a bit of magical realism, charming romance and wonderfully varied humor.
It’s hard to say what my favorite part is. The tour of Rome and its historical landmarks is right up there. Even tho’ this isn’t my usual genre, Loy has made me a fan. She has a way of storytelling that engages and entertains. Her characters are easy to care about; enough to want to see them in another book!
Clear of foul language or sexual content, readers 14 and older will enjoy the story. Recommended for readers of clean romance, RomComs, Italy, and really fun, well written stories📚
I received a copy for review purposes. All opinions are honest and mine alone.
Read and Reviewed from a NetGalley eARC via Kindle with thanks to the publisher and author.
Lexi is delivering a mystery, original painting done by her well known Mom, the artist. She donated this piece to her fans in Rome and Lexi will present the canvas and make a speech at the 2 day art festival co-produced by her marketing and event planning company and the Roman Department of Cultural Affairs.
Mark is waiting to find out if his bid to renovate an historical mansion is accepted by the Italian Heritage Society and property owners. Winning this bid will have major implications for his entire family: healing a broken heart, three years of guaranteed income, restoration of long stressed relationships and an opportunity to build his company and reputation.
While on the planes to Italy, Lexi and Mark enter into a few bets with each other. Time is short for Lexi. Her return flight is in 10 days and she’s also got to solve the mystery waiting in the 4 envelopes given to her by the executor of Mom’s will. Everything in Mark’s future is hinged on the bid, even his tenure in Rome.
Will Lexi solve the mystery left by Mom?
Will Mark win the bid? Foster healing for the family?
How does all this affect the contests between Lexi and Mark?
Does anyone win?
THE ROMAN HOLIDAY RULE is author, Andra Loy’s debut novel. It’s a RomCom in all the best ways: endearing characters, snappy dialogue, scenes that you’ll see coming pages ahead but will enjoy them immensely, a bit of magical realism, charming romance and wonderfully varied humor.
It’s hard to say what my favorite part is. The tour of Rome and its historical landmarks is right up there. Even tho’ this isn’t my usual genre, Loy has made me a fan. She has a way of storytelling that engages and entertains. Her characters are easy to care about; enough to want to see them in another book!
Clear of foul language or sexual content, readers 14 and older will enjoy the story. Recommended for readers of clean romance, RomComs, Italy, and really fun, well written stories📚
I received a copy for review purposes. All opinions are honest and mine alone.
Read and Reviewed from a NetGalley eARC via Kindle with thanks to the publisher and author.
August 5, 2026
Happy Release Day to The Roman Holiday Rule!
I knew I was going to love this book the second I heard what it was about and I absolutely did! It was the perfect summer romcom for me. Honestly, it felt like it was written just for me.
We follow Lexi as she fulfills her mom’s dying wish by traveling to Rome with four unsealed letters from her mom. She opens each letter at one of Rome’s most romantic spots while also sharing her mom’s final painting at an art festival. While there, she keeps running into Mark Russo and the rest is history.
I LOVED Lexi. She’s one of my favorite FMCs of all time. She had me laughing out loud so many times. Her inner thoughts were hilarious. And the puns! The romance was so sweet. Mark was an absolute gem. The banter and chemistry were absolute chef’s kiss.
This book was even more special to me because my husband is Italian. His grandfather came to America when he was six, so I kept thinking about all the stories Grandpa Frank has shared with me over the years. It made me want to plan a trip even more. My dream is that one day we’ll get to visit the town where Grandpa Frank grew up and eat all the amazing food.
ALSO- I can’t tell you how many times I’ve watched Roman Holiday. And if you grew up loving The Lizzie McGuire Movie like I did, you definitely need to pick this one up. It has all those dreamy Rome vibes that made me fall in love with those stories in the first place.
I loved this book so much. Andra is definitely a new favorite author, and I can’t wait to read more from her. Definitely pick this one up!
Thank you so much to Andra + Haven Fiction for the gifted copy!
I knew I was going to love this book the second I heard what it was about and I absolutely did! It was the perfect summer romcom for me. Honestly, it felt like it was written just for me.
We follow Lexi as she fulfills her mom’s dying wish by traveling to Rome with four unsealed letters from her mom. She opens each letter at one of Rome’s most romantic spots while also sharing her mom’s final painting at an art festival. While there, she keeps running into Mark Russo and the rest is history.
I LOVED Lexi. She’s one of my favorite FMCs of all time. She had me laughing out loud so many times. Her inner thoughts were hilarious. And the puns! The romance was so sweet. Mark was an absolute gem. The banter and chemistry were absolute chef’s kiss.
This book was even more special to me because my husband is Italian. His grandfather came to America when he was six, so I kept thinking about all the stories Grandpa Frank has shared with me over the years. It made me want to plan a trip even more. My dream is that one day we’ll get to visit the town where Grandpa Frank grew up and eat all the amazing food.
ALSO- I can’t tell you how many times I’ve watched Roman Holiday. And if you grew up loving The Lizzie McGuire Movie like I did, you definitely need to pick this one up. It has all those dreamy Rome vibes that made me fall in love with those stories in the first place.
I loved this book so much. Andra is definitely a new favorite author, and I can’t wait to read more from her. Definitely pick this one up!
Thank you so much to Andra + Haven Fiction for the gifted copy!
August 2, 2026
This was a delightful debut from Andra Loy! As someone who has been to Rome, I loved reading about the different sights I visited while I was there (and it made me want to go back!). I loved the rivals to lovers dynamic between Lexi and Mark, and they had the best chemistry and banter (and cheesy puns). I also thought the little ✨magical✨ elements of this story were really fun. All in all, this was a solid romcom debut, and I’m excited to see what Andra writes in the future!
Content Notes: No spice (just kisses) or language. Trigger warning for past death of parent (cancer) and estranged family members.
Thank you to Haven Fiction for sending me a free copy of this book! All thoughts and opinions above are my own.
Content Notes: No spice (just kisses) or language. Trigger warning for past death of parent (cancer) and estranged family members.
Thank you to Haven Fiction for sending me a free copy of this book! All thoughts and opinions above are my own.
Did Not Finish
July 27, 2026The writing was....ok? The puns made me physically cringe and I found the FMC (and lowkey the MMC) a bit too grating to like so I didn't want to read more into their story. Something about it all just felt a bit juvenile.
I don't really care for the miscommunication trope, but I ackowledge that it's a thing adults do as not everyone knows how to properly communicate in relationships. But it was ridiculous in this case and I just got too annoyed to continue so I'll be dnf'ing at 35%
I received a digital copy from NetGalley, all opinions are my own
I don't really care for the miscommunication trope, but I ackowledge that it's a thing adults do as not everyone knows how to properly communicate in relationships. But it was ridiculous in this case and I just got too annoyed to continue so I'll be dnf'ing at 35%
I received a digital copy from NetGalley, all opinions are my own
July 30, 2026
"The Roman Holiday Rule" by Andra Loy is such a cute rom-com and surprised me in the best way with how much I loved it! This charming contemporary romance has some hints of magical realism and lots of humor and heart. Although the main character is grieving the loss of her mother and going on a trip to Rome that is connected to her mom, the grief is never too heavy or focused on too long, which I appreciated. As a huge fan of Audrey Hepburn and the movie “Roman Holiday,” I loved all the nods to those things in this book. The writing is witty, the plot fast paced and the romance super cute! The banter and chemistry are top tier! I love how the main characters leave notes to each other in Jane Austen novels and quote (or mis-quote) Star Wars references to one another. Will their Roman Holiday end better than Audrey Hepburn’s? This is the perfect escape or beach read. I highly recommend this charming book and cannot wait for whatever Ms. Loy writes next!
Content: I give this book a PG rating. Some examples of the content and trigger warnings are loss and grief.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
Content: I give this book a PG rating. Some examples of the content and trigger warnings are loss and grief.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
Read
June 1, 2026Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for the arc☆
August 4, 2026
Do you know the Roman Holiday rule? You can’t fall in love with someone who lives somewhere else and expect a happily-ever-after. Lexi and Mark know this, but they can’t help themselves. It’s been like fighting gravity from the moment they met. I loved this book!
Mark is an Italian-American architect living in Rome. He cares immensely for preserving Italian architecture. But he's still an American in the eyes of the Italians which creates challenges in his career. Lexi is an event planner visiting Rome to represent her deceased mother’s art at an art festival and to enjoy the vacation the two of them were supposed to take together. Her mother gave her a set of envelopes to open in specific locations. These envelopes bring a touch of magical realism to the story.
Roman Holiday Rule is full of mirth and mischief. I laughed so hard when they were keeping their friendship a secret while at lunch with his family and throwing inside-joke barbs at each other the entire time. Their banter is next level. So witty. So hilarious.
I wanted to savor this book. The setting in Italy probably has some to do with my obsession with this book, but these characters could be put in any setting, and I would still be obsessed with them. The writing is incredible. The descriptions put me in Italy—and so much amazing food! It's a good thing I can get authentic gelato where I live.
Thank you to the author and Netgalley for an ARC of this book. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own.
Mark is an Italian-American architect living in Rome. He cares immensely for preserving Italian architecture. But he's still an American in the eyes of the Italians which creates challenges in his career. Lexi is an event planner visiting Rome to represent her deceased mother’s art at an art festival and to enjoy the vacation the two of them were supposed to take together. Her mother gave her a set of envelopes to open in specific locations. These envelopes bring a touch of magical realism to the story.
Roman Holiday Rule is full of mirth and mischief. I laughed so hard when they were keeping their friendship a secret while at lunch with his family and throwing inside-joke barbs at each other the entire time. Their banter is next level. So witty. So hilarious.
I wanted to savor this book. The setting in Italy probably has some to do with my obsession with this book, but these characters could be put in any setting, and I would still be obsessed with them. The writing is incredible. The descriptions put me in Italy—and so much amazing food! It's a good thing I can get authentic gelato where I live.
Thank you to the author and Netgalley for an ARC of this book. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own.
June 26, 2026
The Roman Holiday Rule… OH. MY. GOSH. I don’t have enough good things to say about this book! Lexi and Mark are absolutely perfect, and somehow even more perfect for each other. The found family, the swoony romance, and all the little moments had me completely hooked. The lira necklace in the fountain, the movie quotes, the palazzo job, and then the lira necklace at the END?! 😭 If you know, you know. Every piece of this story came together so beautifully. I absolutely loved this book and couldn’t put it down.
Thank you to Haven and Andra Loy for this ARC! ❤️📚
Thank you to Haven and Andra Loy for this ARC! ❤️📚
June 19, 2026
I received an advance review copy of this book. I was under no obligation to leave a positive review, and all opinions expressed are my own.
This was such a delightful read! Here are the things that stood out to me:
1 The strong sense of place. I felt like I truly got to know Rome—the food, the neighborhoods, the people—all through the lens of one wonderfully lovable family. The setting became a character of its own.
2 The touch of magical realism. I loved how Lexi processed the grief of losing her mom. While this isn't really a book about grief, it beautifully captures the feeling of remaining close to someone you've lost, especially while visiting a city that meant so much to them. That thread added so much heart to the story.
3 The memorable side characters. They brought so much humor and warmth, especially with all the playful pranks woven throughout the book. Those moments weren't just entertaining—they also introduced readers to Rome's culture and traditions in such a fun way.
4 It's completely clean and closed-door. I always appreciate finding a well-written romance that I can confidently recommend to my teen daughter. It's proof that a story doesn't need explicit content to be heartfelt, funny, and deeply romantic.
5 It's a true rom-com with a satisfying happy ending. Yes, there's some angst along the way, but it's balanced with hope, laughter, and all the things I love about the genre. One of my favorite author notes is Katherine Center's preface to The Shippers, where she talks about why she loves romantic comedies. Rom-coms are magical because they remind us that love is worth rooting for and that hope is never a bad thing. This book absolutely captured that same magic for me.
If you're looking for a heartfelt, funny, clean romance that will transport you to Rome while leaving you smiling, this one is well worth picking up.
This was such a delightful read! Here are the things that stood out to me:
1 The strong sense of place. I felt like I truly got to know Rome—the food, the neighborhoods, the people—all through the lens of one wonderfully lovable family. The setting became a character of its own.
2 The touch of magical realism. I loved how Lexi processed the grief of losing her mom. While this isn't really a book about grief, it beautifully captures the feeling of remaining close to someone you've lost, especially while visiting a city that meant so much to them. That thread added so much heart to the story.
3 The memorable side characters. They brought so much humor and warmth, especially with all the playful pranks woven throughout the book. Those moments weren't just entertaining—they also introduced readers to Rome's culture and traditions in such a fun way.
4 It's completely clean and closed-door. I always appreciate finding a well-written romance that I can confidently recommend to my teen daughter. It's proof that a story doesn't need explicit content to be heartfelt, funny, and deeply romantic.
5 It's a true rom-com with a satisfying happy ending. Yes, there's some angst along the way, but it's balanced with hope, laughter, and all the things I love about the genre. One of my favorite author notes is Katherine Center's preface to The Shippers, where she talks about why she loves romantic comedies. Rom-coms are magical because they remind us that love is worth rooting for and that hope is never a bad thing. This book absolutely captured that same magic for me.
If you're looking for a heartfelt, funny, clean romance that will transport you to Rome while leaving you smiling, this one is well worth picking up.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
With summer just beginning, this was a delightful book to read. Although it was clear to me right from the start that the romance would centre on these two characters, the book still managed to surprise me as I read it. I really liked the setting in Italy (Rome), and I recognized several places in the story (of course the tourist attractions). I thoroughly enjoyed reading the story. I also found the movie quotes and references scattered throughout very entertaining. Several times, it brought a huge smile to my face. This book put me in a good mood, and it was a pleasure to read. I'm already looking forward to going on vacation to Italy and discovering the heart of Italy!
Thank you to Netgalley for this eARC in exchange for an honest review.
Thank you to Netgalley for this eARC in exchange for an honest review.
June 14, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
- Vacation Romcom with magical realism
- Closed door, just kissing
- Dual POV
- Serendipitous happenings
- Punny jokes and misquoted movie quotes
- Picturesque setting and details that make the settings vivid
- Pranks and mishaps
✨ a few of my favorite things:
- The book is just so whimsical and fun
- their easy banter and their similar sense of humor
- The meetcute
- The book
- The bet
- The big Italian family
- All of their adventures and run ins
- The sweet letters
- The ending 🥹
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Ahhh I can’t even with this book. If you need a wholesome good time, read this book immediately. I immensely enjoyed myself and could not put the book down.
All of the characters felt like real people. They didn’t feel like copy and paste. They had layers and struggled but found joy. They were just so real. The setting sounds absolutely dreamy and stunning, making me even more obsessed with Italy. I adored the family so much and all the side characters were great honestly.
The MCs both struggled and grew in the book. Mark struggled greatly with hurt from past relationships and overcoming his reluctance to open up. Lexi was fighting her own grief and desperately trying to keep a tight hold on controlling her life. They softened each other and lit each other up. The MCs brought the best out in one another and made amends when they messed up. Their dorky jokes and inside jokes made me smile so big.
It was seriously the sweetest story and I had THE BEST time.
This is a closed door romcom with no cursing and just kissing.
**Thank you so much to Andra for letting me read this gifted ARC via NetGalley. No positive review was required. All thoughts are my own.**
Song :
Until I found you by Stephen Sanchez
Anyone by Justine Bieber
Rest by Dean Lewis & Sasha Alex Sloane
Dreams by The Cranberries
God Knew by Michal Leah
- Vacation Romcom with magical realism
- Closed door, just kissing
- Dual POV
- Serendipitous happenings
- Punny jokes and misquoted movie quotes
- Picturesque setting and details that make the settings vivid
- Pranks and mishaps
✨ a few of my favorite things:
- The book is just so whimsical and fun
- their easy banter and their similar sense of humor
- The meetcute
- The book
- The bet
- The big Italian family
- All of their adventures and run ins
- The sweet letters
- The ending 🥹
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Ahhh I can’t even with this book. If you need a wholesome good time, read this book immediately. I immensely enjoyed myself and could not put the book down.
All of the characters felt like real people. They didn’t feel like copy and paste. They had layers and struggled but found joy. They were just so real. The setting sounds absolutely dreamy and stunning, making me even more obsessed with Italy. I adored the family so much and all the side characters were great honestly.
The MCs both struggled and grew in the book. Mark struggled greatly with hurt from past relationships and overcoming his reluctance to open up. Lexi was fighting her own grief and desperately trying to keep a tight hold on controlling her life. They softened each other and lit each other up. The MCs brought the best out in one another and made amends when they messed up. Their dorky jokes and inside jokes made me smile so big.
It was seriously the sweetest story and I had THE BEST time.
This is a closed door romcom with no cursing and just kissing.
**Thank you so much to Andra for letting me read this gifted ARC via NetGalley. No positive review was required. All thoughts are my own.**
Song :
Until I found you by Stephen Sanchez
Anyone by Justine Bieber
Rest by Dean Lewis & Sasha Alex Sloane
Dreams by The Cranberries
God Knew by Michal Leah
August 3, 2026
Thank you to Haven Fiction and Andra Loy for a gifted copy of The Roman Holiday Rule. All opinions expressed in this review are my own.
I've been chomping at the bit to read this and it exceeded my expectations! I feel like it was written especially for me. Like Lexi, I too am a type-A planner with an affinity for Italy, vintage clothing, and bad puns. ✨ If you like Annabel Monaghan and Katherine Center, you’ll LOVE this book!
To fulfill her mother's dying wish, Lexi Walker travels to Rome with four sealed envelopes. She'll open them at Rome's most romantic sites and present her mother's final painting at the art festival she's organizing. Lexi's meticulous plan goes askew when she keeps crossing paths with Mark Russo, an Italian-American architect. With her mother's artwork manifesting before her eyes, are the letters pointing Lexi towards something bigger than herself?
I adored this book. I lived in Rome for three months and reading this felt like coming home (although I sat on the Spanish Steps *before* it was illegal). From the Roman street food to Trevi Fountain, each part of my favorite city came alive on the page. The dash of magical realism added another layer to the story and Lexi and Mark's journey.
Lexi had such a strong sense of voice. I laughed out loud often as she processed the serendipity surrounding her Roman adventure. I loved Lexi's commitment to her job (she's a total girlboss) and to her mother's legacy. The humorous yet heartfelt writing style worked for me!
As for the romance... if anyone ever asks what my type is, I'm going to say Mark Russo from The Roman Holiday Rule. I love a man who would help me fill out customs forms. While I typically don't enjoy dual POV in romance, it worked well for this story. I enjoyed Mark's perspective and learning about what makes him tick. His family was so fun!
All in all, I'm happy to have discovered a new favorite author and I can't wait to see what Andra Loy writes next! I'll be first in line for a copy.
I've been chomping at the bit to read this and it exceeded my expectations! I feel like it was written especially for me. Like Lexi, I too am a type-A planner with an affinity for Italy, vintage clothing, and bad puns. ✨ If you like Annabel Monaghan and Katherine Center, you’ll LOVE this book!
To fulfill her mother's dying wish, Lexi Walker travels to Rome with four sealed envelopes. She'll open them at Rome's most romantic sites and present her mother's final painting at the art festival she's organizing. Lexi's meticulous plan goes askew when she keeps crossing paths with Mark Russo, an Italian-American architect. With her mother's artwork manifesting before her eyes, are the letters pointing Lexi towards something bigger than herself?
I adored this book. I lived in Rome for three months and reading this felt like coming home (although I sat on the Spanish Steps *before* it was illegal). From the Roman street food to Trevi Fountain, each part of my favorite city came alive on the page. The dash of magical realism added another layer to the story and Lexi and Mark's journey.
Lexi had such a strong sense of voice. I laughed out loud often as she processed the serendipity surrounding her Roman adventure. I loved Lexi's commitment to her job (she's a total girlboss) and to her mother's legacy. The humorous yet heartfelt writing style worked for me!
As for the romance... if anyone ever asks what my type is, I'm going to say Mark Russo from The Roman Holiday Rule. I love a man who would help me fill out customs forms. While I typically don't enjoy dual POV in romance, it worked well for this story. I enjoyed Mark's perspective and learning about what makes him tick. His family was so fun!
All in all, I'm happy to have discovered a new favorite author and I can't wait to see what Andra Loy writes next! I'll be first in line for a copy.
May 31, 2026
This book will stay with me for a long time - it was so beautifully written and it made me feel everything.
Lexi is the most wonderful lead character, from the opening in the airport to the way she carries herself through the emotional journey she faces in Italy, to her final decision, she’s so inspiring and brave, I loved every minute of her journey and though the decisions she made at times were heart wrenching, I completely agreed with her and felt so much for her when she returned from Italy.
For someone who’s always dreamed of a close loving family, seeing this on the pages was bittersweet, but it made me love Mark’s family so much more. Mark’s family is introduced in the most organic and simply stunning way, especially Nonno, what a character!
Mark is the most perfect love interest, he’s a little jaded after having his heart broken by another tourist American so he’s reluctant to jump into anything with Lexington (swoon), but fate has another plan, the pair are continuously in each others orbit, when Lexi thinks she’s experiencing things alone (the Spanish Steps), Mark is watching from a window.. it’s just so perfect.
I loved each side character, Julie is the perfect BFF for our lead, slightly overstepping when the meets Mark but knowing it comes from a place of love, and then to Mark’s family, from Luca in his restaurant to Marielle and her instant friendship with Lexi, so Kathryn, Katie, and her wonderful scheming ways. I really hope there’s more to come from the Russo family, as I’d drop everything to read more about this beautiful family
Lexi is the most wonderful lead character, from the opening in the airport to the way she carries herself through the emotional journey she faces in Italy, to her final decision, she’s so inspiring and brave, I loved every minute of her journey and though the decisions she made at times were heart wrenching, I completely agreed with her and felt so much for her when she returned from Italy.
For someone who’s always dreamed of a close loving family, seeing this on the pages was bittersweet, but it made me love Mark’s family so much more. Mark’s family is introduced in the most organic and simply stunning way, especially Nonno, what a character!
Mark is the most perfect love interest, he’s a little jaded after having his heart broken by another tourist American so he’s reluctant to jump into anything with Lexington (swoon), but fate has another plan, the pair are continuously in each others orbit, when Lexi thinks she’s experiencing things alone (the Spanish Steps), Mark is watching from a window.. it’s just so perfect.
I loved each side character, Julie is the perfect BFF for our lead, slightly overstepping when the meets Mark but knowing it comes from a place of love, and then to Mark’s family, from Luca in his restaurant to Marielle and her instant friendship with Lexi, so Kathryn, Katie, and her wonderful scheming ways. I really hope there’s more to come from the Russo family, as I’d drop everything to read more about this beautiful family
August 6, 2026
Thank you to @andraloy and @havenfiction for the #gifted e-book.
A romance set amidst the enchanting landscapes of Italy drew me in.
The charming tale of Lexi and Mark tugged at my heartstrings, especially with the magical realism that kept bringing these two characters together in unexpected ways. As Lexi delves into letters from her late mother, she continuously encounters Mark at every corner of her travels, sparking a blossoming friendship.
What truly made this book stand out was its richly immersive setting. The author vividly brought Rome to life. The bustling streets, exquisite cuisine, stunning architecture, and vibrant atmosphere made me feel like I was right there alongside the characters, experiencing every moment.
Told from both Lexi and Mark’s perspectives, the story offered a delightful insight into their inner thoughts and feelings. Mark’s family was particularly heartwarming; their immediate acceptance of Lexi added layers of warmth and authenticity. The story concluded with a perfect ending for this special couple, leaving me with a smile.
A romance set amidst the enchanting landscapes of Italy drew me in.
The charming tale of Lexi and Mark tugged at my heartstrings, especially with the magical realism that kept bringing these two characters together in unexpected ways. As Lexi delves into letters from her late mother, she continuously encounters Mark at every corner of her travels, sparking a blossoming friendship.
What truly made this book stand out was its richly immersive setting. The author vividly brought Rome to life. The bustling streets, exquisite cuisine, stunning architecture, and vibrant atmosphere made me feel like I was right there alongside the characters, experiencing every moment.
Told from both Lexi and Mark’s perspectives, the story offered a delightful insight into their inner thoughts and feelings. Mark’s family was particularly heartwarming; their immediate acceptance of Lexi added layers of warmth and authenticity. The story concluded with a perfect ending for this special couple, leaving me with a smile.
June 1, 2026
2★
Thank you to NetGalley for this Arc !!
I read this book because of the description: summer travel, Italy, romcom, the banter.. but honestly I struggled to get to the end….
Sadly I didn’t really get attached to the characters through the books…
I felt like the author tried to deliver way to much information too quickly at the start to directly set it up, and then it was slow and then rushed again…kind set me off during the whole book…
Netherless, I loved the cute and funny relation between Lexi and Mark and their chemistry. It’s still was a cute and easy read.
Thank you to NetGalley for this Arc !!
I read this book because of the description: summer travel, Italy, romcom, the banter.. but honestly I struggled to get to the end….
Sadly I didn’t really get attached to the characters through the books…
I felt like the author tried to deliver way to much information too quickly at the start to directly set it up, and then it was slow and then rushed again…kind set me off during the whole book…
Netherless, I loved the cute and funny relation between Lexi and Mark and their chemistry. It’s still was a cute and easy read.
May 31, 2026
4 stars⭐️ I was looking for a cute rom-com to kick off my summer reading, and this one definitely delivered! The story follows Lexi as she embarks on a new adventure while navigating themes of grief, healing, and unexpected connection. One of my favorite aspects of the book was the banter and chemistry between Lexi and Mark. Their competitive dynamic and pranks they played on each other added to the story and made it feel fun. Overall this was a entertaining romance with lovable characters and plenty of laughs to balance out the lighter moments. There was also a Vespa mentioned I was secretly hoping it would be included🤭
I received an advanced review copy of this book from Netgalley. All opinions are my own.
I received an advanced review copy of this book from Netgalley. All opinions are my own.
August 6, 2026
Thank you to the author and NetGalley for my gifted copy. All opinions are my own.
If you love armchair travel, architecture, and the film "Roman Holiday", this is a must read! First, the cover is gorgeous! I love color scheme! Second, this book is a joy to read! There is so much depth to the characters. I like that it is Dual POV. Santino is probably my favorite character in the book. The book is engaging from page one. This is a beautiful story of healing. I highly recommend!!
If you love armchair travel, architecture, and the film "Roman Holiday", this is a must read! First, the cover is gorgeous! I love color scheme! Second, this book is a joy to read! There is so much depth to the characters. I like that it is Dual POV. Santino is probably my favorite character in the book. The book is engaging from page one. This is a beautiful story of healing. I highly recommend!!
June 1, 2026
I received an advanced copy from NetGalley of this book.
This spice free romance is definitely a cute story following Lexi and Mark through the historic sites of Rome. I enjoyed reading this book, however there is some predictability in the novel.
The novel reminds me of a Sarah Adams book with a touch of PS I Love You. I think it was very sweet and I loved watching Mark’s character soften up throughout the book.
Tropes include: found family, grumpy sunshine, and a touch of miscommunication.
This spice free romance is definitely a cute story following Lexi and Mark through the historic sites of Rome. I enjoyed reading this book, however there is some predictability in the novel.
The novel reminds me of a Sarah Adams book with a touch of PS I Love You. I think it was very sweet and I loved watching Mark’s character soften up throughout the book.
Tropes include: found family, grumpy sunshine, and a touch of miscommunication.
June 19, 2026
I really enjoyed reading the Roman Holiday Rule. It made me want to book a flight to Rome just to experience being in the city and maybe finding love myself. I loved all of the FMC’s and MMC’s jokes and puns and Star Wars references. I couldn’t put it down. I did give it a 4.5 star rating mostly because it had no spice. I thought it was just a really slow burn, but there is 1 almost kiss and 2 actual kissing scenes. But overall, it’s a really cute, feel good book.
July 17, 2026
This is a very cute, clean, emotional story. It’s a quick read told in dual POVs, and charming. It didn’t completely wow me, or was extra memorable, but I enjoyed it.
August 3, 2026
Such a cute summer romance. And an Italian romance 🤌🏼 Makes you take a good long look at what’s really important in life.
May 28, 2026
The Roman Holiday Rule by Andra Loy is a dual POV, fast-paced novel with a very touching tale.
Lexi flies to Rome to solve the mystery of her parents’ romance with the help of her late mother’s letters. She encounters mystical “coincidences” and wishes at Trevi Fountain that seem to guide her as if led by her mom. A chance meeting with Mark at the airport opens a fun, friendly rivalry between the two, and their witty banter is a major highlight.
I loved the humor shared by Lexi and Mark, Mark's lovely family and Lexi's best friend Julie. This is the right balance of emotional depth, playful romance and Roman charm!
Lexi flies to Rome to solve the mystery of her parents’ romance with the help of her late mother’s letters. She encounters mystical “coincidences” and wishes at Trevi Fountain that seem to guide her as if led by her mom. A chance meeting with Mark at the airport opens a fun, friendly rivalry between the two, and their witty banter is a major highlight.
I loved the humor shared by Lexi and Mark, Mark's lovely family and Lexi's best friend Julie. This is the right balance of emotional depth, playful romance and Roman charm!
May 29, 2026
Only One Vespa!! I adored this story of two strangers meeting at the Boston airport and then continuing to magically run into each other in Rome. The story kept me entertained and on my toes. It was a sweet/clean romance and I cannot wait to read more from this author in the future. Recommend if you enjoy clean/sweet romance, meet-cute, found family. Trigger - the main character is grieving the recent loss of her mother.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Haven via NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Haven via NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 181 reviews