A transformative and philosophical investigation into how we ask questions, full of practical advice on how we can harness the power of questions for ourselves
We live in a world that wants answers. Answers provide solutions to our problems, teach us about the world, and help us navigate our lives. But we rush toward answers forgetting, that it is questions that set the course.
Questions are a form of power, as well as a vital, everyday tool. After all, if you don’t ask the right questions, you won’t get the right answers. In Q, philosopher Lani Watson examines the history of question-asking, analyzes our answer-oriented present, and offers a path forward toward a question-oriented future. Along the way, she asks us to consider what a question is, why we ask the questions we do, when we first start asking questions, and where we want our questions to take us.
The shift from prioritizing answers to focusing on questions is not easy, and it requires careful attention and practice. Q also includes practical tips called Q Tools, inspired by the historical, philosophical, and cultural material of each chapter that offer readers exercises and advice for becoming better question-askers. There are real-world benefits to creating a question-oriented future, and it will require a personal, social, political, philosophical and technological transition. In Q, Lani Watson provides us with the knowledge and tools that we need to implement this change in our own lives and communities.
I came to Q: The Hidden Power of Questions in a World That Wants Answers by Lani Watson via a Guardian piece by Zoe Williams, headlined something like "if you're just interested in answers, you are missing out". That line stuck with me, and I went in expecting to have my thinking properly shaken up.
It's well written, no question there. Lani Watson covers the topic area competently and clearly knows the field inside out. I did pick up some genuinely interesting material along the way, particularly around evolutionary biology and child development and how questioning fits into both. That part alone was worth the read.
But I think I was after something more hard-hitting overall. By the end I felt like I'd worked through a philosophy study guide, exercises and all, rather than read a piece of social philosophy that was going to push me somewhere new.
It's all there. The arguments are sound, the ground is covered properly. I just kept waiting for the moment that broke new territory, and it never quite arrived.
3 stars. Solid and thoughtful, just not the eye-opener I was hoping for.
Non-fiction is not usually my go-to, but I found the concept of this book intriguing enough to want to give it a read. At its heart, the book highlights just how important questions are in a world that seems increasingly focused on finding answers.
In chapter one, I was asked to count how many questions were in one passage. The answer and the explanation that followed blew my mind. I made my partner try it too, which resulted in a 20-minute-long debate about our differing opinions on the matter.
Never again am I going to be able to think of a simple question as just that. A simple question.
I also liked that the book had space in the appendix for me to write notes and questions as I went through it. Ironically, I found myself with an awful lot of questions after finishing the book, and I can’t seem to stop thinking about it even now.
Lani Watson’s book Q: The Hidden Power of Questions in a World That Wants Answers was different from what I expected. I expected it to be about communication techniques to elicit better information more easily. Instead, the book was more a history of questions. Which is okay.
I enjoyed Watson’s philosophical discussion of what a question is and her account of how we progress from asking lots of questions as children to asking only a few as we grow older. She also discussed power dynamics: who gets to ask questions and who gets to answer them.
I never thought much about questions as a topic before. Watson related Jane Goodall’s remark that what makes us human is the ability to ask questions. To our knowledge, we are the only species that does.
Even though this book was not what I expected, I still enjoyed it and rated it five stars. If you are looking for a book on how to have better conversations using questions, this might not be your book, though she does give some exercises at the end. If you are more interested in the topic of questions itself, then you are more likely to enjoy this book.
My attention wandered a bit in this one but it was an interesting discussion of the role of questions in our society and how we interact with others using questions and how technology limits questions. Interesting easy to digest thoughtful discussion.
Speed read the book at Waterstones. Provides good direction for people to gather more by asking questions. I specially liked their “10 tools for questioning”
The basic assertion of this book is that we are in a world which is becoming more and more answer oriented and that this is not good. Most good comes from being question oriented. I think she is correct. And the book helps you see this truth and provides ways to implement it in your situation.
There were many parts of this book that I found very interesting. As a retired science teacher, I found the part about teaching enlightening. Schools generally have an answering mindset rather than a questioning mindset. Most of the questions asked in class are asked by the teacher, while many fewer questions are asked by students. Lani Watson proposes changing this dynamic so that teachers encourage students to have a questioning attitude to enhance their education.
Apparently, when you ask questions, there are chemical changes in your brain that facilitate learning. There are neurochemical benefits of pursuing questions about which one is curious, which extend beyond simply learning the answers to the questions. When the reward regions of the brain associated with asking questions are activated, people are better able to remember the answer to the question. This learning benefit occurs both before and after the heightened curiosity of asking questions.
I particularly enjoyed the section about types of questioners. There are knowledge seekers (investigators and interrogators), assumption testers (provocateurs and philosophers), relationship builders (engagers and persuaders). The author describes the style of questions asked by each of these types of questioners. I am a questioning person by nature, and I knew exactly which type of questioner I am after reading the descriptions. The author includes a link to a 64-question test used to determine the type of questioner you are. My results were as I expected.
There are also chapters on how questions show we care and who gets to ask what questions. Worth the read.
How-to and Why-to for deliberately directed discovery as the framework method in paying attention and making informed decisions on the best action to be taken. Appreciated - the metaquality: book qustioning the nature and origins of questioning. Fun fact: some penguins have a higher information-seeking capacity than loads of self-proclaimed "educated" people, for they won't merely rely on the ready-served bits of knowledge for survival, they'll take to exploration expeditions by `choice (!). Be like the penguin - wander, explore, find out, act, and reap the fruit of quality livelihood! I.e., agency.
The concept is nice; we're so focused on getting answers that sometimes we're not asking the right questions, or we're not asking questions at all - which is even worse. The book explains the importance of asking questions and refining our questioning abilities. Gives a few examples and "templates" to follow in order to improve ourselves, and inspires us to ask more questions, be curious, and not settle with the answers we have. I enjoyed reading this book, and it made me more curious on some aspects of my life; I'm trying to follow the tools to be a better questioner: I am a naturally curious mind so it comes easy, but on subjects I'm not interested about, this is very hard work for me.