Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

It Starts with Anger: A Punk Beginning. An Afropunk Ending

Rate this book
From the award-winning filmmaker and graphic novelist, comes the untold origin story of the multi-million-dollar AFROPUNK festival—beginning not with big stages or brand sponsorship, but with one mixed-race teenager’s search for belonging in the nineties New York City punk scene.

In 1991, fifteen-year-old James Spooner arrives in New York’s West Village, hopeful that he’s finally escaped the extremist racism of his Southern California desert town. Still, a question looms large over his cross-country What will New York City make of this tartan plaid-and-leather-clad, mixed race, Black kid with a mohawk? Will he find his people? Thus begins Spooner’s insider’s account of the nineties downtown New York punk and early aughts pre-Giuliani nightlife scenes. In the city’s legendary rock clubs, squat basements, and DIY art spaces, he finds his way to creating zines, starting a record label, and promoting parties, while falling further in love with punk rock’s distorted guitars and politically progressive lyrics. Happy to have left a world of Nazi skins behind he must still navigate the casual racism and bigotry of a seemingly all-white echo chamber; a world stubbornly resistant to his Black/punk identity.

Intent on carving a space for young, Black, politically radical punk rockers like himself, Spooner undertakes a whirlwind tour of the country, collecting the stories that will become his acclaimed documentary, Afro-Punk, and eventually lead to the wildly successful music festival of the same name. But what begins as a way to chronicle the joys and heartaches of being Black and punk rock soon spirals into a multimillion-dollar corporate endeavor. Spooner is forced to ask In setting out to galvanize an underground movement, has he in fact given rise to the least punk rock thing of all—a brand?

Illustrated with a vibrant mix of comics, spot art, and punk ephemera throughout, It Starts with Anger is at once a coming-of-age story about found family, a compelling capitalist cautionary tale, and a raucous celebration of the indelible, rebellious spirit of Black punks.

384 pages, Hardcover

Published August 4, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

James Spooner

4 books76 followers
James Spooner is an award winning graphic novelist, filmmaker and tattoo artist. His debut graphic novel, The High Desert was named “Best of 2022” by Publishers Weekly, The Washington Post and The New York Public Library. The High Desert is the 2023 recipient of the American Library Association's Alex Award and the Cartoonist Studio Prize.

Spooner co-edited an anthology of Black punk writers and comic creators entitled, Black Punk Now. Available now, the book was named in the top 10 Music Books of 2023 by Pitchfork and received a Kirkus star. Pantheon has recently acquired his forthcoming second memoir, set for publication in 2025. He was recently commissioned to adapt a story  by the Scottish Book Trust and is  regular contributor to RazorCake Magazine.  

Spooner directed the seminal documentary Afro-Punk which premiered at national and international film festivals, including Toronto International and The American Black Film Festival. James also co-founded the AfroPunk Festival, which currently boasts audiences in the hundreds of thousands around the world.

​Spooner’s work has been recounted in various publications, including NPR, The Los Angeles Times, Vice, The Village Voice, The New Yorker, MTV, NBC News and Variety. He was a recipient of the ReNew Media Rockefeller Grant. He is an ongoing guest curator for the Broad Museum in Los Angeles, and previously programmed for the Brooklyn Academy of Music.

James continues to screen Afro-Punk around the world, giving talks on punk, comics and Black identity.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
19 (70%)
4 stars
7 (25%)
3 stars
1 (3%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews
Profile Image for Monica.
Author 8 books39 followers
September 12, 2026
This is such a great book! James Spooner’s story is a fascinating one, and he tells it in engaging prose and drawings.
Profile Image for Abbey.
1 review
November 6, 2026
If there was any justice in this world this book would be required reading in schools. It’s a priceless time capsule of downtown NYC in the 1990s and the roadtrips and friendships across America that followed. The tale of someone finding their voice as a teen when moving to a city where everyone already knows who they are, building something beautiful, having that co-opted by corporations and then finding their voice again. In this age of AI, finding community is more important than ever and James Spooner has been doing this for decades (pretty sure I ran into Razzle back in the day in Washington Square Park). Highly recommend.
Profile Image for A. Thomas.
3 reviews
September 26, 2026
You can tell a documentarian created this book. It Starts With Anger constructs a full universe that you fully occupy when reading. In this book, James Spooner recounts his experiences and thoughts during his time as a punk rocker/hardcore kid/scenester/organizer. Prose, photos, illustrations and comics are blended together like a deluxe, quadruple, super-Black issue of Maximum RockNRoll. This is a different format but a natural continuation of his first book, The High Desert. It’s an immersive trip back through time but not in a shitty nostalgic way. It’s thorough, thoughtful and reflective.
Profile Image for Alexandre Amaral.
8 reviews
October 18, 2026
I will say up front: You should read this book.

That's the shortest I can summarize my review, in a single sentence, but I will go on to add a great bit more detail!

I purchased this book at a screening of "Afro-Punk" the documentary made by the author James Spooner and which he talks about creating in the book.

I really loved the documentary, available on James Spooner's website here:

https://www.spoonersnofun.com/afropunk

And after the event he had this book available for sale and even signed my copy! The only thing he said was "we need goodreads reviews so..." so here is my first goodreads review! I signed up for an account after finishing the book.

There are many angles that make this book fascinating, and any number of them could pique your interest: hearing about Spooner growing up in the deserts of California surrounded by literal racist self-identifying-as-Nazi skinheads and having to embrace racism to survive, to embracing alternately his white and black identity, including a fascinating series of journeys including interstate-road trips across the nation exploring various punk houses with a lot of famous musicians, to traveling to St Lucian to meet with his father and see where he was from and learn about "being black" in many ways he describes in the book better than I can here, he describes the turmoil of identity of being mixed race and moving through white and black spaces and experiencing nagging feelings of not belonging, but also finding connection and identity as well. He talks of his father visiting him and seeing how he had made a life of club promotion in New York and eventually he pulls together a series of black-punk shows into a movement he creates with the others he finds in the space, and the result is many different series of concerts and shows including the "Liberation Sessions" with intentionally curated anti-racist spaces and musicians to create safe spaces for LGBTQIA+ people, this book includes positive representations of trans people and other marginalized figures in society and generally humanizes everyone in the space as James Spooner provides a vivid and deep reflection on a lot of inner feelings about the people with whom he interacted throughout the years. It goes on to detail how he came to the idea of a documentary and in a whirlwind of inspiration and community outreach managed to collect hundreds of interviews and boil them down into the documentary I saw, he talks about the problematic title he later changed, he talked about how the whole documentary was inspired by the thoughtless casual racist slur usage of a white punk that set Spooner off on a quest to represent Black Punk from a first person pespective from the people living it and in the know. And he talks about how eventually the AfroPunk movement became corrupted by the involvement of a business manager who put profit before people, and sold out to racist acts where James Spooner stormed on stage and gave a clear denouncement of the bigotry and homophobia, but ultimately was shut out of his own movement before that manger lost everything due to clear embezzlement found after he tried to sell the company and spend the funds on himself and his wife, when those funds were intended to be invested into the company. But now Spooner owns his own documentary again!

Worth the read, a whirlwind tour, deeply emotionally gripping, a real clear portrait of America, Los Angeles, New York, St. Lucian, and what it is like to grow up and live life as a black man in America who is also a white man in St Lucian, but whose identity is clearly that of American Historical Figure for his movement building, documentary, and books. A highly prolific artist and human being, worth the read.

Also the book is full of comics, which are vivid in black-and-white and lend a lot of emotional depth to much of the writing. Many passages are told in the format of comic strips, which is a nice break from walls of text and makes it a surprisingly breezy read for a book that's over 300 pages!

I think this is an important work of historical record that reflects a lot of the dynamics rarely talked about. Nazis in the deserts of California are a real thing, and rarely talked about. The racism James Spooner speaks of is always worth talking about, and he talks about his unique situation as a mixed race person for experiencing prejudice both "for being black" as well as "for being white" depending on the perspective of the person discriminating, which is highly illuminating as a narrative record of the social climate of the time. James Spooner's work can be read as describing the social climate of the 1990s through the 2020s, which when read with other works more focused on dry history, provides a more emotionally connected way of seeing these situations the same way as someone who experienced them, for someone who has never experienced such things it is incredibly valuable to have such an emotionally connecting experience as these narratives and comics that really engage the reader and tell a story beyond your typical autobiography or history book.

James Spooner talks about his process with the Documentary and I found that incredibly inspiring. He talks about learning to make zines and I find that incredibly inspiring. I think James pulled of a feat of creative Herculean strength by pulling the documentary together, and the books, and the zines, and the concerts and festivals and continued screenings.

I think this is an incredibly inspiring book for anyone to read and it made me want to try a bunch of new things, it's exciting to see how James learns as he grows up in Punk, and how he figures out how to make things work to create the spaces people want and need and still figure out how to survive on his own making art and eventually becoming a prolific writer, producer, and artist of many mediums

Worth the read, inspiring and informative, it's a true punk that can write an entire book summarizing his own vision of the world in all its complexity and antiracism and create an entire movement around the radical punk intersectional acceptance that James Spooner embodies and creates for others in his spaces, especially from a guy growing up having to survive by placating literal racist Nazis in high school, it's honestly an impressive journey from end to end and a thrilling and insightful read every page.
1 review
September 1, 2026
I had no idea how badly I needed this memoir. It Starts with Anger takes you on a walk with James through adolescence and into young adulthood as he labors through the process of self-realization, ultimately building the community he was seeking. There are challenges, but also many beautiful and entertaining pit stops along the way, providing expansive opportunities to the reader for self-reflection.

Aside from the critical life lessons found throughout, readers will love the deeply authentic recollections of the early 90's NYC punk and hardcore scenes as well as the late 90's club and party scenes. If you were there, or wish you could have experienced it, you will delight in just how immersive this read is. Allow this memoir to inspire and awaken the dormant punk ethos that exists in all of us.
Profile Image for Greg Allan Holcomb.
280 reviews9 followers
August 16, 2026
I did not have the time when this arrived on my front steps. Over my quick skim through I went from wanting to work on my zine to having the first two issues 3/4 done, third issue half, fourth 2/3rds done. s

_IT STARTS WITH ANGER_ reads like a memoir zine that grew to fill the space of a book. .The art and photos are integrated into the text flaelessly, you don't have to search for what the pics relate to.

When Spooner namedrops lists of names I have to wrack my brain to figure if I have any connection to them. When he mentions venues I was counting them on my fingers.

I won a copy of this book from the firstreads giveaways. Actual people can win even after the bots found out how to enter drawings.
Profile Image for Carolyn Haynes.
3 reviews
August 19, 2026
Reading this voice felt so familiar. I had memories of the slightly older punk siblings of friends flash in my head as I read about the 90s vegan straight edge movement. I absolutely have so much drive to get back to basic communication - zines, mailing letters, message boards. It was inspiring to read the humble moments, the written-down confirmation that the goal should not be to expand and claim as much as possible, but to sustain and cultivate the core of your idea/community - you can still inspire others to share beyond your reach. The 1979 Village Voice article he mentions is a great follow-up read and absolutely watch his documentary if you haven't. You cannot support those around you without first listening to their experiences.
1 review
September 25, 2026
Aside from wanting a rum & coke and seeing Cipher live, I appreciate the candor - frank, funny, and uplifting. Spooner did a lot of things with community I had dreamed about but abandoned. He created space that connected people, expanding their capacity to connect with more people, to create more space; a physical and infinite reverberation. Something metaphysical and beautiful. Community building. World building. It’s awesome. I didn’t know his entire trajectory from punk to Afropunk. The years only crumbed second hand tales. No matter how down he got, he somehow centered himself positively. It’s refreshing…

The book is a meditation/alarm on what you make and what you lose and what makes you yourself.

Up the punk rockers!
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews