What do you think?
Rate this book
Wicked Trilogy #1
His Wicked Reputation
From New York Times bestselling author Madeline Hunter comes the first novel in a stunning regency romance trilogy about three irresistibly attractive brothers...Gareth Fitzallen is celebrated for four his handsome face, his notable charm, his aristocratic connections, and an ability to give the kind of pleasure that has women begging for more. Normally he bestows his talents on experienced, worldly women. But when he heads to Langdon’s End to restore a property he inherited—and to investigate a massive art theft—he lays plans to seduce a most unlikely lady. Eva Russell lives a spinster’s life of precarious finances and limited dreams while clinging to her family’s old gentry status. She supports herself by copying paintings while she plots to marry her lovely sister to a well-established man. Everyone warns her of Gareth’s reputation, and advises her to lock her sister away. Only it is not her sister Gareth desires. One look, and she knows he is trouble. One kiss, however, proves she is no match for this master of seduction.From the Paperback edition.
351 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 3, 2015
307 people are currently reading
2301 people want to read
About the author
Madeline Hunter
102 books2,106 followersMadeline Hunter is a nationally bestselling author of historical romances who lives in Pennsylvania with her husband and two sons. Her books have won two RITA awards and seven nominations, and have had three starred reviews in Publishers Weekly. In a parallel existence to the one she enjoys as a novelist, Madeline has a Ph.D. in art history and teaches at an East Coast university.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 355 reviews
June 4, 2019
3.5 stars
I'm not really in the mood for writing a review so this will be short.
This was different enough to be enjoyable - a hero that was born out of wedlock and has an interesting extended family; a heroine who is enjoys art and is very independent without being obnoxious about it. My only real qualms was that the small 'mystery' was laughably easy for the reader and that the heroine way too easily got involved in an almost purely sexual relationship with the hero.
I'm not really in the mood for writing a review so this will be short.
This was different enough to be enjoyable - a hero that was born out of wedlock and has an interesting extended family; a heroine who is enjoys art and is very independent without being obnoxious about it. My only real qualms was that the small 'mystery' was laughably easy for the reader and that the heroine way too easily got involved in an almost purely sexual relationship with the hero.
September 10, 2016
I've given this a B- at AAR, so 3.5 stars, but I'm rounding up.
This is the first in a new series from Ms Hunter featuring three ducal sons, two of whom are legitimate and a third who is not – and this is his book. It’s an entertaining story; the central characters are likeable and intelligent, and there is an intriguing secondary plot surrounding the possible art theft the hero is asked to investigate. But when I finished the book, I couldn’t help feeling there was something missing, and I can’t quite put my finger on what it was.
Gareth Fitzallen is the bastard son of late Duke of Aylesbury. His father openly acknowledged him and he shares a strong bond of friendship and affection with two of his half-brothers, Lance and Ives. The eldest brother, Percy, who assumed the dukedom upon their father’s death, has also recently died, and it’s no secret that none of the brothers is inclined to mourn him very much. While Gareth’s relationship to Aylesbury has undoubtedly opened some doors to him, he’s pretty much made his own way in the world, making his his living as an art dealer and broker. Now Percy is dead, Gareth has hopes of being at last able to take possession of a property left him by his father, his claim to which the unpleasant and malicious Percy had deliberately tied up in legal knots in Chancery.
Travelling to the Midlands in order to take possession of his inheritance, Gareth is not far from the house when he accidentally manages to run a young woman into a muddy puddle. Naturally she is not best pleased, but refuses his help when he offers to carry the rather large package she is struggling with, and her acerbic reaction to him piques his interest.
Eva Russell lives with her younger sister in greatly reduced circumstances, thanks to their late brother’s profligacy. She generates a little extra income by selling paintings, but rather than selling her own work, which she doesn’t think is very good, she instead paints copies of the far more skilfully wrought and attractive works she discovered stowed away in the attics of the seemingly abandoned house that is her nearest neighbour. So she has good reason for not accepting help with her burden - it’s a painting she has “borrowed” from Gareth’s house.
Shortly after his arrival, Gareth is called back to London by Ives, and asked to assist with the investigation with which he has been tasked – to track down a number of priceless artworks which were supposedly moved to a place of safety when it looked as though Napoleon might invade, but which were never returned to their original location when the war ended.
While it’s fairly obvious where things might be headed in terms of that particular plotline, the mystery element of the story is nonetheless intriguing and unfolds at a good pace. I suspect some readers may feel the mystery overshadows the romance somewhat, but I thought the balance was just about right.
Gareth and Eva are intelligent, appealing and determined characters who are very strongly attracted to each other even as they are wary of emotional entanglements. Gareth has a reputation as a womaniser, a man whose sexual prowess is such that he has women falling over themselves to warm his bed, and who never want to leave it once there. But he’s a decent man, generous, perceptive and, it has to be admitted, deliciously hot – one who adheres strictly to his own set of rules; he doesn’t seduce innocents, and a lady’s wishes are always to be respected. By his own strictures, Eva should be off limits, but her mix of confidence and vulnerability intrigues him and he can’t stop thinking about her. He knows Eva is not as immune to him as she would have him believe, and that she experiences the same heat of desire that he feels whenever they meet. The attraction between them won’t be denied and it’s not long before they embark upon a no-strings-attached affair which allows them to explore the passion between them and enjoy being close to another person without the potential for any deeper emotional involvement. Or so they think.
When Eva insists that their sexual relationship has to come to an end, Gareth abides by her decision, but says that he will always be a friend to her. One of the best things about the story is the way that friendship develops, and how Eva and Gareth come to know and depend upon one another almost without realising it.
There are a number of well-developed secondary characters in the book, not least of which is Eva’s beautiful sister, Rebecca, a crusading free-thinker who deters unwanted suitors by quoting Voltaire and Plato endlessly at them! Then there are Gareth’s brothers, Lance, who is now the Duke of Aylesbury, and Lord Ywain, who prefers to be called Ives, one of the finest legal minds of his generation. They are both intriguing personalities and their relationship with Gareth is one of the highlights of the book; the three of them obviously share a deep respect for each other, and there’s a lovely undercurrent of familial affection between them.
I said at the beginning that I came away from the book feeling there was something lacking that I couldn’t quite identify – and even as I come to the end of writing this review, I still can’t describe it. On paper, His Wicked Reputation has everything – two likeable central characters, sexually-charged verbal-sparring, humour, a good storyline, hot, sensual love scenes, and a well-drawn set of secondary characters. So perhaps this is a case of “it’s not you, it’s me”. Don’t get me wrong – I did enjoy the book and will certainly go on to read the next in the series, but this one didn’t wow me as I’d expected it to.
This is the first in a new series from Ms Hunter featuring three ducal sons, two of whom are legitimate and a third who is not – and this is his book. It’s an entertaining story; the central characters are likeable and intelligent, and there is an intriguing secondary plot surrounding the possible art theft the hero is asked to investigate. But when I finished the book, I couldn’t help feeling there was something missing, and I can’t quite put my finger on what it was.
Gareth Fitzallen is the bastard son of late Duke of Aylesbury. His father openly acknowledged him and he shares a strong bond of friendship and affection with two of his half-brothers, Lance and Ives. The eldest brother, Percy, who assumed the dukedom upon their father’s death, has also recently died, and it’s no secret that none of the brothers is inclined to mourn him very much. While Gareth’s relationship to Aylesbury has undoubtedly opened some doors to him, he’s pretty much made his own way in the world, making his his living as an art dealer and broker. Now Percy is dead, Gareth has hopes of being at last able to take possession of a property left him by his father, his claim to which the unpleasant and malicious Percy had deliberately tied up in legal knots in Chancery.
Travelling to the Midlands in order to take possession of his inheritance, Gareth is not far from the house when he accidentally manages to run a young woman into a muddy puddle. Naturally she is not best pleased, but refuses his help when he offers to carry the rather large package she is struggling with, and her acerbic reaction to him piques his interest.
Eva Russell lives with her younger sister in greatly reduced circumstances, thanks to their late brother’s profligacy. She generates a little extra income by selling paintings, but rather than selling her own work, which she doesn’t think is very good, she instead paints copies of the far more skilfully wrought and attractive works she discovered stowed away in the attics of the seemingly abandoned house that is her nearest neighbour. So she has good reason for not accepting help with her burden - it’s a painting she has “borrowed” from Gareth’s house.
Shortly after his arrival, Gareth is called back to London by Ives, and asked to assist with the investigation with which he has been tasked – to track down a number of priceless artworks which were supposedly moved to a place of safety when it looked as though Napoleon might invade, but which were never returned to their original location when the war ended.
While it’s fairly obvious where things might be headed in terms of that particular plotline, the mystery element of the story is nonetheless intriguing and unfolds at a good pace. I suspect some readers may feel the mystery overshadows the romance somewhat, but I thought the balance was just about right.
Gareth and Eva are intelligent, appealing and determined characters who are very strongly attracted to each other even as they are wary of emotional entanglements. Gareth has a reputation as a womaniser, a man whose sexual prowess is such that he has women falling over themselves to warm his bed, and who never want to leave it once there. But he’s a decent man, generous, perceptive and, it has to be admitted, deliciously hot – one who adheres strictly to his own set of rules; he doesn’t seduce innocents, and a lady’s wishes are always to be respected. By his own strictures, Eva should be off limits, but her mix of confidence and vulnerability intrigues him and he can’t stop thinking about her. He knows Eva is not as immune to him as she would have him believe, and that she experiences the same heat of desire that he feels whenever they meet. The attraction between them won’t be denied and it’s not long before they embark upon a no-strings-attached affair which allows them to explore the passion between them and enjoy being close to another person without the potential for any deeper emotional involvement. Or so they think.
When Eva insists that their sexual relationship has to come to an end, Gareth abides by her decision, but says that he will always be a friend to her. One of the best things about the story is the way that friendship develops, and how Eva and Gareth come to know and depend upon one another almost without realising it.
There are a number of well-developed secondary characters in the book, not least of which is Eva’s beautiful sister, Rebecca, a crusading free-thinker who deters unwanted suitors by quoting Voltaire and Plato endlessly at them! Then there are Gareth’s brothers, Lance, who is now the Duke of Aylesbury, and Lord Ywain, who prefers to be called Ives, one of the finest legal minds of his generation. They are both intriguing personalities and their relationship with Gareth is one of the highlights of the book; the three of them obviously share a deep respect for each other, and there’s a lovely undercurrent of familial affection between them.
I said at the beginning that I came away from the book feeling there was something lacking that I couldn’t quite identify – and even as I come to the end of writing this review, I still can’t describe it. On paper, His Wicked Reputation has everything – two likeable central characters, sexually-charged verbal-sparring, humour, a good storyline, hot, sensual love scenes, and a well-drawn set of secondary characters. So perhaps this is a case of “it’s not you, it’s me”. Don’t get me wrong – I did enjoy the book and will certainly go on to read the next in the series, but this one didn’t wow me as I’d expected it to.
February 18, 2022
I am giving this book a 3 stars because it had many things that I liked but even more things that were questionable. I am sorry if there are some spoilers however.
First, it was very weird how everybody in the new town accepted the hero's birth, like it didn't matter when it very much mattered back then.
Second, how can she not think of the consequences to her impoverishment and to her sister? Let alone about herself doing so many reckless things with the hero.
This brings me to another point, they had no sense. I absolutely hate when the main characters keep courting scandal with every move they make. They were so incredibly indiscreet that it boarded on unrealistic. They had many love scenes in the open where anyone could come upon them. They spend many nights in closed doors by themselves and no one was the wiser. It was very uncomfortable having to be thinking constantly that a scandal was brewing.
Lastly, things were not well solved. Were the hero's thoughts in the end in fact what happened? Did the heroine's sister got engaged? What happened to the guys in the end? There are so many things that I am not sure the answers to.
And an extra complaint... I personally dislike when a writer waits until the last page for there to have a marriage proposal. For me it feels like an afterthought. Something not so important after all.
But don't get me wrong. The book was nice, the characters were nice, the heroine's sister was wonderful boring the hell out of everybody with her philosophical talks. It was just all VERY unrealistic.
First, it was very weird how everybody in the new town accepted the hero's birth, like it didn't matter when it very much mattered back then.
Second, how can she not think of the consequences to her impoverishment and to her sister? Let alone about herself doing so many reckless things with the hero.
This brings me to another point, they had no sense. I absolutely hate when the main characters keep courting scandal with every move they make. They were so incredibly indiscreet that it boarded on unrealistic. They had many love scenes in the open where anyone could come upon them. They spend many nights in closed doors by themselves and no one was the wiser. It was very uncomfortable having to be thinking constantly that a scandal was brewing.
Lastly, things were not well solved. Were the hero's thoughts in the end in fact what happened? Did the heroine's sister got engaged? What happened to the guys in the end? There are so many things that I am not sure the answers to.
And an extra complaint... I personally dislike when a writer waits until the last page for there to have a marriage proposal. For me it feels like an afterthought. Something not so important after all.
But don't get me wrong. The book was nice, the characters were nice, the heroine's sister was wonderful boring the hell out of everybody with her philosophical talks. It was just all VERY unrealistic.
March 1, 2022
I think my GR friend @Luana has given an in-depth review on this book and I agree with everything she’s written.
The characters were lovely, the mystery part was intriguing, the tidbits on the art seem solid but unfortunately, everything else was very UNREALISTIC.
I can’t get over how blasé the heroine was on embarking a sexual affair with the hero. She was a virgin spinster living in a small town during the 19th century where even a hint of impropriety can make you a social pariah. They just visited each other’s abode in broad daylight without a chaperone present. The hero, Gareth and the townspeople were also very indifferent about his status as the illegitimate offspring of a duke. You don’t disclose this sort of information even in this day and I’m very sure you won’t bandy this sort of information back in those days.
I also feel that the dialogues sounded way too American. I just couldn’t get the characters to sound English in my head. This, unfortunately, took me out of the book as well on top of the other things.
I’ll probably read the other 2 books in the series sometime in the future but it won’t be anytime soon.
Steam factor: Middle steam. Ms Hunter has a way of making the intimate scenes sensual even though they were not very explicit.
The characters were lovely, the mystery part was intriguing, the tidbits on the art seem solid but unfortunately, everything else was very UNREALISTIC.
I can’t get over how blasé the heroine was on embarking a sexual affair with the hero. She was a virgin spinster living in a small town during the 19th century where even a hint of impropriety can make you a social pariah. They just visited each other’s abode in broad daylight without a chaperone present. The hero, Gareth and the townspeople were also very indifferent about his status as the illegitimate offspring of a duke. You don’t disclose this sort of information even in this day and I’m very sure you won’t bandy this sort of information back in those days.
I also feel that the dialogues sounded way too American. I just couldn’t get the characters to sound English in my head. This, unfortunately, took me out of the book as well on top of the other things.
I’ll probably read the other 2 books in the series sometime in the future but it won’t be anytime soon.
Steam factor: Middle steam. Ms Hunter has a way of making the intimate scenes sensual even though they were not very explicit.
February 2, 2017
I just can't finish this. I have so many in my TBR pile and I just cannot get into this one. It's not that the writing is bad or the characters are undeveloped. The writing is good, there is some mystery in the plot, and attraction between the characters, but I just don't like it. The writing style is too "and then this happened and then they went here and then they were apart for a while." There are sex scenes galore but they never feel romantic to me. The hero is a bastard son and has been a form of a man whore most of his life. He then uses these whiles on the heroine. Everyone stops and stares at him because he is so attractive. The heroine has been so careful all her life and then just throws it all to the wind because she cannot resist our hero (his brothers are sleazy too and some of their comments about women do not endear them to me). It just didn't work for me. Not bad writing, but just not my thing.
Note to self: there are also some f-words thrown around in this book.
Note to self: there are also some f-words thrown around in this book.
December 15, 2025
Romance was a footnote at the end
───〃⟡ ⋅ The plot
・
・
・
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
🕮⋆˚࿔✎𓂃 𝐣𝐨𝐢𝐧 𝐦𝐲 𝐜𝐨𝐦𝐦𝐮𝐧𝐢𝐭𝐲 𝐟𝐨𝐫 𝐦𝐲 𝐟𝐮𝐥𝐥 𝐫𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐞𝐰
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
───〃⟡ ⋅ The plot
・
・
・
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
🕮⋆˚࿔✎𓂃 𝐣𝐨𝐢𝐧 𝐦𝐲 𝐜𝐨𝐦𝐦𝐮𝐧𝐢𝐭𝐲 𝐟𝐨𝐫 𝐦𝐲 𝐟𝐮𝐥𝐥 𝐫𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐞𝐰
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
July 26, 2015
I found this quite difficult to rate. It's probably a bit under four stars in truth. There's much to like here. Hunter's books feel very period-appropriate; the setting, the language and the dialogue are all well done. I liked Eva, a self-possessed single woman trying to manage everything in difficult circumstances. She was well-drawn and likable. Gareth could've had a bit more flesh on him, I think but his character development improved towards the end of the book. The sex was pretty great and I liked the secondary characters. The portrait mystery sort of lagged In the middle but built to an interesting finale. With all that said, there was something fundamental which bothered me about this book and I've spent ages trying to figure out what it is. I think it comes down to this: Gareth and Eva weren't a great couple. Their relationship is sort of built on insta-attraction and sustained by that attraction. They don't have any great dialogues or witty banter. By the end of the book they've fallen in love but I wasn't entirely sure why. That said, there's much to admire and I enjoyed the book so much so that I've already bought the next in the series (which is, admittedly, about a barrister and consequently Right Up My Street).
September 27, 2015
This review was originally posted on Addicted To Romance
Summary
Gareth, is well known for his charm and his seductive ways in the bedroom. He has certain connections that make him a target for women everywhere. Gareth knows a woman's body just as much as his own and enjoys the pleasures of it. After his brother Percy is killed, Gareth and his two other brothers are the prime suspects. As Gareth and his brother try to investigate and clear their names, there is also missing artwork, that they are trying to find and also the thieves responsible. Gareth, has regained the property that was denied him for so many years, as he works to restore it to its former glory, he meets an unlikely match but like bee to honey, he can't resist the temptation. Eva Russell, is a spinster, and even though they are considered "gentry", she and her sister are struggling to keep their home from being taken away from them. Eva is talented and created, and uses her talents as an artist to copy paintings and sell the work. In an unlikely meeting, she and Gareth stumble across each other and soon Eva realizes what temptation really is. Gareth with his handsome looks, his seductive ways and his charming manner, she knows he is dangerous for her and not what she wants. And even though she is trying to settle a match for her younger sister, she is drawn to Gareth and doesn't know if she will be able to resist him.
The Hero
Gareth is considered to be the "bastard" son and brother of the brothers. He grew up with a loving mother who adored his father. Even though his parents loved each other, they couldn't ever be officially married. Gareth was a interesting character. We see what a rake he is in the beginning, he definitely isn't ashamed of who he is. He has a kinship with his two other brothers. Even though he hated his brother Percy, he never wanted him dead. On the surface Gareth seems to be the type of man that only is interested in women and drinking. But we see how his childhood shaped him into who he has become. He is a bit cynical especially when it comes to marriage and love. In his mind its just a reason to have sex. Gareth has depth you don't expect when you first read this story. Its with each chapter, we see a bit more of the truth Gareth, and it isn't until you get to the "artichoke heart" of his character that you really begin to understand him. Gareth's character surprised me in those little ways that added more pleasure to reading this story.
The Heroine
Eva Rusell, is the oldest of the two sisters. Eva has had to resort to creative thinking in making sure she and her sister survive, thanks to their brother's foolish decisions that have cost them just about everything. Eva is the protective one, she is a spinster and is content with her position. She doesn't feel the need to marry, but she knows it's what her sister wants and needs. Eva is a talented artist, and she uses those abilities to create a somewhat steady income for their needs. But Eva knows that she has to be careful. Eva is very talented, but cautious especially when it comes to men. She doesn't trust Gareth or her feelings for him. What was most fun about Eva's character was seeing her personal growth. I love how firm she is with Gareth, and she stands up to him and his seductive ways. She is intelligent and creative, and a very endearing character.
Plot and Story Line
His Wicked Reputation is the first book in the latest series by Madeline Hunter. This is an author I have had on my TBR pile for years, probably ever since I started reading romance, since she has been writing for quite some time. I wonder why I haven't read her before now. I picked this book up, because I had read some positive reviews on it, and since it was available at my local library, I decided that I needed to grab this one up. From the first few pages, I was slowly hooked onto this one. I love this authors writing style, very engaging and I didn't have a hard time getting into it. In the middle, the pace of the story was a bit slower, but then it picks up again. I had quite a enjoyable time with His Wicked Reputation, because of the characters. There was so much more to them than meets the eye and I loved seeing more depth of layers to their characters than you expect to find at first.
The plot is evenly paced, we do have a couple of mysteries in play in the story, but they aren't a driving force of the story. The actual center of the book, is the romance between Eva and Gareth. These two are one of those unlikely matches. Gareth is used to experienced women in the bedroom, but Eva is opposite from all the women he has been with. She is something different. They had a easy going bantering that was entertaining and this is what really keeps the reader involved in the story. I loved the chemistry....oh what chemistry these two have. Makes me want to find my own wicked regency man because Gareth was delicious to read. The secondary characters played a pivotal role in the story as well. I loved the sisters and their relationship, they are very close and I loved their friendship and easy going manner with one another. Its very light hearted and carefree and so fun to see them interact with each other. Then we have the brothers, and boy are they lively when they are all in the same room. Each brother is different, but they are as close as brothers can get. You see the close ties they have, despite their different views on handling life.
The love story between Gareth and Eva was charming and sweet and sensual. I just couldn't get enough of seeing them in action, and the building of their relationship. There is a instant spark of physical reaction, but with our hero being cynical about love it takes some time for him to open himself up more emotionally to Eva. But I loved seeing them grow together and it was very interesting seeing their relationship blossom with the other variables of the plot. It was simply a blast reading Gareth and Eva's story and I can hardly wait to grab up the second book.
The Cover
I do love it, with the relaxed but confident posture. Almost a "come hither" and see what I have to offer. Love the tones of gold and grey blue in the background.
Overall View
His Wicked Reputation is a sensational read that will leave you wanting more from Madeline Hunter. An author writing at her best...historical romance with flair, passion, and mystery. Guaranteed to make you fall in love. AN INTOXICATING ROMANCE!!
Summary
Gareth, is well known for his charm and his seductive ways in the bedroom. He has certain connections that make him a target for women everywhere. Gareth knows a woman's body just as much as his own and enjoys the pleasures of it. After his brother Percy is killed, Gareth and his two other brothers are the prime suspects. As Gareth and his brother try to investigate and clear their names, there is also missing artwork, that they are trying to find and also the thieves responsible. Gareth, has regained the property that was denied him for so many years, as he works to restore it to its former glory, he meets an unlikely match but like bee to honey, he can't resist the temptation. Eva Russell, is a spinster, and even though they are considered "gentry", she and her sister are struggling to keep their home from being taken away from them. Eva is talented and created, and uses her talents as an artist to copy paintings and sell the work. In an unlikely meeting, she and Gareth stumble across each other and soon Eva realizes what temptation really is. Gareth with his handsome looks, his seductive ways and his charming manner, she knows he is dangerous for her and not what she wants. And even though she is trying to settle a match for her younger sister, she is drawn to Gareth and doesn't know if she will be able to resist him.
The Hero
Gareth is considered to be the "bastard" son and brother of the brothers. He grew up with a loving mother who adored his father. Even though his parents loved each other, they couldn't ever be officially married. Gareth was a interesting character. We see what a rake he is in the beginning, he definitely isn't ashamed of who he is. He has a kinship with his two other brothers. Even though he hated his brother Percy, he never wanted him dead. On the surface Gareth seems to be the type of man that only is interested in women and drinking. But we see how his childhood shaped him into who he has become. He is a bit cynical especially when it comes to marriage and love. In his mind its just a reason to have sex. Gareth has depth you don't expect when you first read this story. Its with each chapter, we see a bit more of the truth Gareth, and it isn't until you get to the "artichoke heart" of his character that you really begin to understand him. Gareth's character surprised me in those little ways that added more pleasure to reading this story.
The Heroine
Eva Rusell, is the oldest of the two sisters. Eva has had to resort to creative thinking in making sure she and her sister survive, thanks to their brother's foolish decisions that have cost them just about everything. Eva is the protective one, she is a spinster and is content with her position. She doesn't feel the need to marry, but she knows it's what her sister wants and needs. Eva is a talented artist, and she uses those abilities to create a somewhat steady income for their needs. But Eva knows that she has to be careful. Eva is very talented, but cautious especially when it comes to men. She doesn't trust Gareth or her feelings for him. What was most fun about Eva's character was seeing her personal growth. I love how firm she is with Gareth, and she stands up to him and his seductive ways. She is intelligent and creative, and a very endearing character.
Plot and Story Line
His Wicked Reputation is the first book in the latest series by Madeline Hunter. This is an author I have had on my TBR pile for years, probably ever since I started reading romance, since she has been writing for quite some time. I wonder why I haven't read her before now. I picked this book up, because I had read some positive reviews on it, and since it was available at my local library, I decided that I needed to grab this one up. From the first few pages, I was slowly hooked onto this one. I love this authors writing style, very engaging and I didn't have a hard time getting into it. In the middle, the pace of the story was a bit slower, but then it picks up again. I had quite a enjoyable time with His Wicked Reputation, because of the characters. There was so much more to them than meets the eye and I loved seeing more depth of layers to their characters than you expect to find at first.
The plot is evenly paced, we do have a couple of mysteries in play in the story, but they aren't a driving force of the story. The actual center of the book, is the romance between Eva and Gareth. These two are one of those unlikely matches. Gareth is used to experienced women in the bedroom, but Eva is opposite from all the women he has been with. She is something different. They had a easy going bantering that was entertaining and this is what really keeps the reader involved in the story. I loved the chemistry....oh what chemistry these two have. Makes me want to find my own wicked regency man because Gareth was delicious to read. The secondary characters played a pivotal role in the story as well. I loved the sisters and their relationship, they are very close and I loved their friendship and easy going manner with one another. Its very light hearted and carefree and so fun to see them interact with each other. Then we have the brothers, and boy are they lively when they are all in the same room. Each brother is different, but they are as close as brothers can get. You see the close ties they have, despite their different views on handling life.
The love story between Gareth and Eva was charming and sweet and sensual. I just couldn't get enough of seeing them in action, and the building of their relationship. There is a instant spark of physical reaction, but with our hero being cynical about love it takes some time for him to open himself up more emotionally to Eva. But I loved seeing them grow together and it was very interesting seeing their relationship blossom with the other variables of the plot. It was simply a blast reading Gareth and Eva's story and I can hardly wait to grab up the second book.
The Cover
I do love it, with the relaxed but confident posture. Almost a "come hither" and see what I have to offer. Love the tones of gold and grey blue in the background.
Overall View
His Wicked Reputation is a sensational read that will leave you wanting more from Madeline Hunter. An author writing at her best...historical romance with flair, passion, and mystery. Guaranteed to make you fall in love. AN INTOXICATING ROMANCE!!
April 30, 2018
3.5 stars; would have been higher except for social implausibility
I thoroughly enjoyed this, not least for the unusual and plausible plot, involving art works hidden during the Napoleonic Wars. It didn't hurt that the H&H were engaging too. Their relationship felt convincing (with one caveat) as it progressed from attraction to lust to friendship, via enjoyable banter and several opportunities to indulge in discreet hanky-panky. The HEA felt deserved, and I devoured the book in oner on a lazy Sunday morning.
There are more secondary characters than I normally look for in a romance (I like the focus to be on the H&H), but Madeline Hunter handles the cast excellently - they all have a key part to play and are well-differentiated, from Eva's philosophical sister to industrialist cousins in Birmingham (nice to see Trade being treated seriously in an HR, with solid detail explained).
However, I think Madeline Hunter "cheated" a little in the story line in order to give Eva and Gareth every chance to pursue their illicit relationship. Eva and her sister live alone, with no servants or chaperones (yet are accepted as "gentry" - down on their luck, but gentry none the less) so Eva can sneak out to visit Gareth, and he can spend the night with her. Moreover, Gareth contrives to invite Eva and her sister to London to stay with his ducal brother; while their cousin (whom Gareth barely knows) comes along to play propriety: the invitation and the cousin's accceptance of it just feels unbelievable. Part of what I look for in an HR is whether a realistic relationship can be constructed against a background of more or less accurate social reality. Here, I'm pleased by the relationship but it comes at the partial expense of realism.
I thoroughly enjoyed this, not least for the unusual and plausible plot, involving art works hidden during the Napoleonic Wars. It didn't hurt that the H&H were engaging too. Their relationship felt convincing (with one caveat) as it progressed from attraction to lust to friendship, via enjoyable banter and several opportunities to indulge in discreet hanky-panky. The HEA felt deserved, and I devoured the book in oner on a lazy Sunday morning.
There are more secondary characters than I normally look for in a romance (I like the focus to be on the H&H), but Madeline Hunter handles the cast excellently - they all have a key part to play and are well-differentiated, from Eva's philosophical sister to industrialist cousins in Birmingham (nice to see Trade being treated seriously in an HR, with solid detail explained).
However, I think Madeline Hunter "cheated" a little in the story line in order to give Eva and Gareth every chance to pursue their illicit relationship. Eva and her sister live alone, with no servants or chaperones (yet are accepted as "gentry" - down on their luck, but gentry none the less) so Eva can sneak out to visit Gareth, and he can spend the night with her. Moreover, Gareth contrives to invite Eva and her sister to London to stay with his ducal brother; while their cousin (whom Gareth barely knows) comes along to play propriety: the invitation and the cousin's accceptance of it just feels unbelievable. Part of what I look for in an HR is whether a realistic relationship can be constructed against a background of more or less accurate social reality. Here, I'm pleased by the relationship but it comes at the partial expense of realism.
March 6, 2020
This is the first book that I've ever read by Madaline Hunter - I was actually planning to grab The Wicked Duke when I saw it advertised a while back, but changed my mind once I realized that there were two previous books in this series. Well written and with an art-mystery to be solved, His Wicked Reputation was a fast-paced and satisfying read full of entertaining dialogue and a couple of unexpected twists and turns.
Gareth Fitzallen is the bastard son of a duke. But in spite his illegitimacy, he enjoys a good relationship with his surviving half-brothers. Doors to ballrooms are open to him, and the women can't seem to get enough! But when he inherits a run-down property and becomes involved in the search for a missing art collection, it's not a wealthy society lady who draws his attention, but a spinster struggling to ensure her sister's future.
Eva Russell's life has been a struggle since her brother's death. Especially since she's determined to keep her property and get her younger sister suitably settled. A passionate artist, she scrapes her income together by copying famous paintings with no expectation of ever doing anything more. But then Gareth arrives in town and her world turns upside down, not only because of her undeniable attraction to him, but because the paintings she's be copying are his - borrowed from the attic of the house he's just inherited.
I found this to be a delightful read. Gareth and Eva were wonderful characters, and I especially liked them at the end when they owned their mistakes and trusted each other instead of getting angry and throwing accusations around, because it could easily have gone that way too. Instead, I found the resolution to be perfect and Madeline Hunter's writing style and plot extremely enjoyable. I will definitely be grabbing the following books in this series!
Gareth Fitzallen is the bastard son of a duke. But in spite his illegitimacy, he enjoys a good relationship with his surviving half-brothers. Doors to ballrooms are open to him, and the women can't seem to get enough! But when he inherits a run-down property and becomes involved in the search for a missing art collection, it's not a wealthy society lady who draws his attention, but a spinster struggling to ensure her sister's future.
Eva Russell's life has been a struggle since her brother's death. Especially since she's determined to keep her property and get her younger sister suitably settled. A passionate artist, she scrapes her income together by copying famous paintings with no expectation of ever doing anything more. But then Gareth arrives in town and her world turns upside down, not only because of her undeniable attraction to him, but because the paintings she's be copying are his - borrowed from the attic of the house he's just inherited.
I found this to be a delightful read. Gareth and Eva were wonderful characters, and I especially liked them at the end when they owned their mistakes and trusted each other instead of getting angry and throwing accusations around, because it could easily have gone that way too. Instead, I found the resolution to be perfect and Madeline Hunter's writing style and plot extremely enjoyable. I will definitely be grabbing the following books in this series!
June 17, 2015
Also posted
HERE
.
I did myself a huge disservice with this book. As excited I was to read this one – and I did drop everything to start it – I was so overwhelmed with review books that I put it aside at 9% and didn’t get back to it for a few months.
However, it is a great book, and even with the big gap I really loved it.
Just as with contemporary romances, it sometimes seems there are only so many stories you can write set in the Regency era. However, in contemporary romance in amongst the sea of bakers and wedding planners marrying the ex-SEALs-turned-cowboys, there are authors who can do something fascinating and original and not clichéd.
This is the case with authors like Madeline Hunter. She has the talent to take a well (over)used time period (Regency England) and create fascinating stories that have not been done before.
One of the best aspects of this series is that neither hero nor heroine sits at the top of the social ladder. Gareth is the son of a duke, but the bastard of a duke. Eva is gentry, but has no fortune and no hope of a fortune. We get a glimpse into the top layers of society, but this is more about the characters.
I also like the mentions of Chatsworth and the Duke of Devonshire, as I’m tired of every Jane Austen-themed show implying that a mere Mister (Darcy) would live on such an important property!
The theme of this book is art, and I love all the research that went into it. I’ve spent a lot of time in national galleries, so this was probably a more interesting topic to me than it will be to some. However, the way the mystery and the crime involved were worked through the plot was very smart. This is an excellently-plotted book.
The one thing that always drives me crazy about Hunter’s books is that the same mistakes always pop up. If your characters are sitting on their ‘asses’ they’d bloody well better be riding donkeys! Annoying that the version I read wasn’t even the US edition, and it still had those mistakes in there!
Otherwise, I loved this book.
I did myself a huge disservice with this book. As excited I was to read this one – and I did drop everything to start it – I was so overwhelmed with review books that I put it aside at 9% and didn’t get back to it for a few months.
However, it is a great book, and even with the big gap I really loved it.
Just as with contemporary romances, it sometimes seems there are only so many stories you can write set in the Regency era. However, in contemporary romance in amongst the sea of bakers and wedding planners marrying the ex-SEALs-turned-cowboys, there are authors who can do something fascinating and original and not clichéd.
This is the case with authors like Madeline Hunter. She has the talent to take a well (over)used time period (Regency England) and create fascinating stories that have not been done before.
One of the best aspects of this series is that neither hero nor heroine sits at the top of the social ladder. Gareth is the son of a duke, but the bastard of a duke. Eva is gentry, but has no fortune and no hope of a fortune. We get a glimpse into the top layers of society, but this is more about the characters.
I also like the mentions of Chatsworth and the Duke of Devonshire, as I’m tired of every Jane Austen-themed show implying that a mere Mister (Darcy) would live on such an important property!
The theme of this book is art, and I love all the research that went into it. I’ve spent a lot of time in national galleries, so this was probably a more interesting topic to me than it will be to some. However, the way the mystery and the crime involved were worked through the plot was very smart. This is an excellently-plotted book.
The one thing that always drives me crazy about Hunter’s books is that the same mistakes always pop up. If your characters are sitting on their ‘asses’ they’d bloody well better be riding donkeys! Annoying that the version I read wasn’t even the US edition, and it still had those mistakes in there!
Otherwise, I loved this book.
March 12, 2015
Originally posted at Smexybooks
http://smexybooks.com/2015/03/review-...
Gareth Fitzallen is the illegitimate son of a Duke and. Unlike most noblemen of this period, Gareth’s father not only maintained an amicable relationship with him but also encouraged a relationship between him and his legitimate sons. When the oldest son (and current Duke) dies under mysterious circumstances, Gareth is summoned home at the bequest of his other brothers. A broker of sorts for the autocracy, Gareth’s connections are needed when he is charged with finding some missing artwork that disappeared during the French war. On his arrival to the family estate, Gareth inadvertently runs a young woman into a water filled ditch when his attention wanders to the scenery around him. He is intrigued when his normally winsome charm and good looks don’t produce the reaction he is used to.
“Won’t you allow me to help you carry that? Or better yet, give you a ride to where you are going? It looks like a heavy package, and those shoes must be uncomfortable now.”
“No thank you, I will manage.”
“You dont have to be afraid. I promise to behave myself. I am utterly harmless.”
[…]
“I would not accept a ride with you even if I had five miles to walk. Please, be on your way and I will be on mine.”
Eva Russell definitely doesn’t want Gareth’s help as the package she is carrying is a painting she has stolen from his newly inherited home. A poverty stricken spinster, she supports herself and her younger sister by painting copies of famous paintings. Made desolate by her father and brother’s lack of financial know how, Eva loses her fiance and essentially her freedom when she is forced to become the head of the household. A free spirit with a poetic heart, Eva’s goals are more straight forward now-make the money they need to secure her sister’s future. Though her tone and manner are slightly acidic towards Gareth at first, she is not as immune to him as she pretends to be.
She smiled all the way home. How bad can a poor spinster’s day be when the most beautiful man she has ever seen in her life flirts with her?
His Wicked Reputation is the first in Madeline Hunter’s newest trilogy that follows a trio of brothers on their journey to true love. Set up like a traditional historical romance, the infectious balance of humor, wit, decadent love scenes, and hints of suspense and intrigue makes this a unique read in a tried and true genre. Steady pacing, engaging dialogue, and a strong initial storyline setup gives readers pertinent information without overburdening with unnecessary filler. A humorous meet cute sets the stage for the beginning of a friendship that swiftly leads to a glorious romance for the first brother-Gareth Fitzallen.
Gareth manages to insulate himself into Eva’s life rather quickly, using the excuse “I’m new to town and you’re my neighbor” to appeal to her inbred good manners. She introduces him around town while giving the residents a warning that everything that disappeared from his abandoned estate over the years needs to make its way back there pronto. The sharp chemistry that was ignited at their first meeting burns brighter with each new meeting until they are unable to ignore it anymore. Eva begins to find him as irresistible as every other woman.
“Do you always enter homes when their owners are gone?”
Such an unfortunate question. “I am sorry. I should never have entered.”
“Do not apologise. I am glad you came.” His hand fell from her shoulder. Finally. “Come inside. I will show you the improvements.” A slow smile formed, but he looked no friendlier. “Several chambers still require new fabrics and such. You can advice me.”
“I…really cannot…That is, it would not be…appropriate for me to…” Her words died in her throat. He stepped closer. That put her nose at most six inches from his chest.
“Come now, Eva. if it was appropriate for you to enter the house, and appropriate for you to watch me wash-”
“I did not watch you wash!”
“Correction, watch me dress. Even after that you can hardly quibble about your setting foot inside to advise on the drapery.”
Gareth and Eva entertained me from first meeting. Both are strong, intelligent, feisty, and good natured despite their less than stellar upbringings. Neither use their backgrounds as excuses to mope or act the put upon fool. Humorous banter and lush sexual tension keeps the storyline and their relationship flowing smoothly forward.
Neither Gareth nor Eva believe in true love or the all the trappings that come with it. Gareth’s reputation as a hedonistic lover leaves him in much demand but his parent’s own illicit romance showed him that love is a fleeting emotion that causes more pain than pleasure. While Eva does believe in romance, she believes security is more important as she was taught that love can be easily cast aside when circumstances change. Unable to stay away from each other, they begin to engage in a sex only affair, giving each other the passion they crave without the commitment they both seek to avoid. Two wounded souls finding one another is a trope I love and Hunter masters it, developing not only a decadent love affair but a friendship that builds into a true soul match. I enjoyed that the sex isn’t off scene nor inundated with an abundance of flowing purple prose. Though Eva seeks to keep Gareth at arms length, he is a confident, experienced lover who uses his body and mind to trap Eva in her own desires.
She knew, even as she succumbed, that his goal was to master her will.
She did not care.
As their assignations heat up, so does the mystery of the stolen paintings. Gareth’s investigations show him that Eva is involved though the depth of her involvement is yet to be determined. Slow and steady, Hunter intertwines the romance and mystery, allowing them to play off one another and develop at their own pace. Though the mystery is the weaker of the two story lines- it was pretty easy to figure out exactly what was happening- the intrigue lays in the various individuals involved and the ramifications.
Delightful secondary characters add to the depth of the story. I loved the frank speech between everyone involved. Hunter does a fantastic job of creating characters we can relate to. Gareth and his mother are close, as are he and his brothers. I enjoyed their scenes together. All three are an adventurous lot and look forward to their stories. Rebecca, Eva’s sister, provides much entertainment as those around her discover her exceptional beauty hides a razor-sharp mind and tongue. I do hope this ambitious crusader gets her own story.
The main conflict resolves itself admirably (as I stated earlier, it was all very easy to figure out) and the story ends in a delightful and quite unorthodox manner. Ms. Hunter certainly proves her reputation with her latest historical offering and I look forward to reading more about these wicked brothers.
RATING: B
http://smexybooks.com/2015/03/review-...
Gareth Fitzallen is the illegitimate son of a Duke and. Unlike most noblemen of this period, Gareth’s father not only maintained an amicable relationship with him but also encouraged a relationship between him and his legitimate sons. When the oldest son (and current Duke) dies under mysterious circumstances, Gareth is summoned home at the bequest of his other brothers. A broker of sorts for the autocracy, Gareth’s connections are needed when he is charged with finding some missing artwork that disappeared during the French war. On his arrival to the family estate, Gareth inadvertently runs a young woman into a water filled ditch when his attention wanders to the scenery around him. He is intrigued when his normally winsome charm and good looks don’t produce the reaction he is used to.
“Won’t you allow me to help you carry that? Or better yet, give you a ride to where you are going? It looks like a heavy package, and those shoes must be uncomfortable now.”
“No thank you, I will manage.”
“You dont have to be afraid. I promise to behave myself. I am utterly harmless.”
[…]
“I would not accept a ride with you even if I had five miles to walk. Please, be on your way and I will be on mine.”
Eva Russell definitely doesn’t want Gareth’s help as the package she is carrying is a painting she has stolen from his newly inherited home. A poverty stricken spinster, she supports herself and her younger sister by painting copies of famous paintings. Made desolate by her father and brother’s lack of financial know how, Eva loses her fiance and essentially her freedom when she is forced to become the head of the household. A free spirit with a poetic heart, Eva’s goals are more straight forward now-make the money they need to secure her sister’s future. Though her tone and manner are slightly acidic towards Gareth at first, she is not as immune to him as she pretends to be.
She smiled all the way home. How bad can a poor spinster’s day be when the most beautiful man she has ever seen in her life flirts with her?
His Wicked Reputation is the first in Madeline Hunter’s newest trilogy that follows a trio of brothers on their journey to true love. Set up like a traditional historical romance, the infectious balance of humor, wit, decadent love scenes, and hints of suspense and intrigue makes this a unique read in a tried and true genre. Steady pacing, engaging dialogue, and a strong initial storyline setup gives readers pertinent information without overburdening with unnecessary filler. A humorous meet cute sets the stage for the beginning of a friendship that swiftly leads to a glorious romance for the first brother-Gareth Fitzallen.
Gareth manages to insulate himself into Eva’s life rather quickly, using the excuse “I’m new to town and you’re my neighbor” to appeal to her inbred good manners. She introduces him around town while giving the residents a warning that everything that disappeared from his abandoned estate over the years needs to make its way back there pronto. The sharp chemistry that was ignited at their first meeting burns brighter with each new meeting until they are unable to ignore it anymore. Eva begins to find him as irresistible as every other woman.
“Do you always enter homes when their owners are gone?”
Such an unfortunate question. “I am sorry. I should never have entered.”
“Do not apologise. I am glad you came.” His hand fell from her shoulder. Finally. “Come inside. I will show you the improvements.” A slow smile formed, but he looked no friendlier. “Several chambers still require new fabrics and such. You can advice me.”
“I…really cannot…That is, it would not be…appropriate for me to…” Her words died in her throat. He stepped closer. That put her nose at most six inches from his chest.
“Come now, Eva. if it was appropriate for you to enter the house, and appropriate for you to watch me wash-”
“I did not watch you wash!”
“Correction, watch me dress. Even after that you can hardly quibble about your setting foot inside to advise on the drapery.”
Gareth and Eva entertained me from first meeting. Both are strong, intelligent, feisty, and good natured despite their less than stellar upbringings. Neither use their backgrounds as excuses to mope or act the put upon fool. Humorous banter and lush sexual tension keeps the storyline and their relationship flowing smoothly forward.
Neither Gareth nor Eva believe in true love or the all the trappings that come with it. Gareth’s reputation as a hedonistic lover leaves him in much demand but his parent’s own illicit romance showed him that love is a fleeting emotion that causes more pain than pleasure. While Eva does believe in romance, she believes security is more important as she was taught that love can be easily cast aside when circumstances change. Unable to stay away from each other, they begin to engage in a sex only affair, giving each other the passion they crave without the commitment they both seek to avoid. Two wounded souls finding one another is a trope I love and Hunter masters it, developing not only a decadent love affair but a friendship that builds into a true soul match. I enjoyed that the sex isn’t off scene nor inundated with an abundance of flowing purple prose. Though Eva seeks to keep Gareth at arms length, he is a confident, experienced lover who uses his body and mind to trap Eva in her own desires.
She knew, even as she succumbed, that his goal was to master her will.
She did not care.
As their assignations heat up, so does the mystery of the stolen paintings. Gareth’s investigations show him that Eva is involved though the depth of her involvement is yet to be determined. Slow and steady, Hunter intertwines the romance and mystery, allowing them to play off one another and develop at their own pace. Though the mystery is the weaker of the two story lines- it was pretty easy to figure out exactly what was happening- the intrigue lays in the various individuals involved and the ramifications.
Delightful secondary characters add to the depth of the story. I loved the frank speech between everyone involved. Hunter does a fantastic job of creating characters we can relate to. Gareth and his mother are close, as are he and his brothers. I enjoyed their scenes together. All three are an adventurous lot and look forward to their stories. Rebecca, Eva’s sister, provides much entertainment as those around her discover her exceptional beauty hides a razor-sharp mind and tongue. I do hope this ambitious crusader gets her own story.
The main conflict resolves itself admirably (as I stated earlier, it was all very easy to figure out) and the story ends in a delightful and quite unorthodox manner. Ms. Hunter certainly proves her reputation with her latest historical offering and I look forward to reading more about these wicked brothers.
RATING: B
August 6, 2024
Review from 2015
A- for narration / B+ for content, 4.5 stars.
When I read His Wicked Reputation a few months back, I enjoyed it, but came away from it feeling as though there was something missing I couldn’t quite put my finger on. As any regular listener to audiobooks will know, there are times when listening to a book rather than reading it can enhance the experience and enjoyment of the story, and I’m pleased to report that his was one of those times. Thanks in no small part to another excellent performance by Mary Jane Wells, I enjoyed the story even more this time around.
The wicked reputation of the title belongs to Gareth Fitzallen, the bastard son of a duke, and it relates entirely to the fact that, apart from being drop-dead gorgeous, he is purported to be able to give a woman such incredible pleasure in bed that they are willing to do absolutely anything to keep him there! Gareth makes no bones about his skill in that direction, but he is always faithful and discreet in his liaisons; In fact, he’s rather a wonderful man – intelligent, deeply honourable and kind – obviously, the appellation “wicked” only applies to his activities between the sheets!
Although acknowledged by his father, Gareth had to make his own way in the world, and now makes his living as a successful art dealer and broker. He shares a strong bond of friendship with his half-brothers, Lance (now the Duke of Aylesbury) and Ywain (Ives), although none of them were at all fond of their eldest brother, Percy, a particularly nasty individual who went out of his way to make life difficult for others and especially for Gareth. His most recent piece of unpleasantness concerned a property their late father had willed to his illegitimate son, but now Percy is dead, Gareth hopes that Lance will set aside Percy’s objection to his inheritance, and in anticipation of taking possession, travels to the Midlands to inspect it.
On the way to the house, he accidentally runs a young woman into a muddy puddle and finds himself intrigued by her caustic reaction to him. He offers to help her with the rather large package she is struggling with, but she refuses and goes on her way.
Eva Russell realises she has had a narrow escape. The sister of an earl, she and her younger sister are living in the reduced circumstances occasioned by their late brother’s profligacy, and Eva earns a little money by selling her paintings. She does not, however, sell original works; instead she paints copies of the famous paintings she “borrows” from the attics of the deserted house that is her nearest neighbour – the house she now knows is owned by the gentleman she met in the lane, who would no doubt be furious if he knew what she was doing.
Shortly after Gareth’s arrival, he is summoned back to London by Ives, who has been asked to investigate the disappearance of a large number of valuable works of art. Some years previously, when the threat of an invasion by Napoleon and his forces was a very real one, several noblemen packed up their art treasures and had them transported to a place of safety in the north of England. These paintings were never returned to their owners after the war ended, and questions are now being asked. Ives asks for Gareth’s help, knowing his brother’s knowledge of art and of who owns what will be invaluable in such a task.
It’s not hard to work out the direction the story is going to take, but that doesn’t take away any of the enjoyment in listening to how things play out.
Having been intrigued by Eva’s reaction to him, Gareth soon seeks her out, and even though she knows such marked attentions from a man of Gareth’s reputation can only lead to one thing, Eva can’t help but be strongly attracted to him. She’s on the shelf – and in any case, believes that her passion for painting precludes her having such things as a husband and family of her own. Yet as she comes to know Gareth, to know his kindness and the truth of the man behind the wicked reputation, she finds him increasingly difficult to resist.
One of the best things about the book is the way in which the relationship between Eva and Gareth develops into a true and deep friendship, with them coming to know and depend on each other almost without realising it. Their romantic relationship is lovely, too; highly sensual, but with an element of caring and thoughtfulness on Gareth’s part which shows him to be not only well-and-truly smitten, but a genuinely good man. I also enjoyed the interplay between Gareth and his brothers, which is often funny, and which leaves the listener in no doubt about their fondness for one another.
Mary Jane Wells is a favourite narrator of mine, and her performance here more than lived up to my expectations in every respect but one. It’s not something that spoiled my enjoyment, but it struck me as rather odd that she has opted to give Eva a less-than-upper-crust accent. Eva has fallen on hard times, it’s true, but she’s the sister of (and therefore the daughter of) an earl, and I had expected to hear her voiced accordingly; but instead Ms Wells gives her an accent I can only describe as slightly “cockney”, which didn’t fit the image I had of her. The rather bright edge given to her tone works, given Eva’s sometimes acerbic pronouncements, and the way she brings out the emotional nuances in Eva’s speech is also excellent – I was just confused by the choice of accent. In all other aspects, however, Ms Wells’ performance is faultless. All the characters are clearly delineated by use of a variety of tones and timbres; Lance, Ives and Gareth are easy to tell apart, as are Eva and Rachel and the two sisters who are their friends and neighbours. While Eva’s accent gave me pause for thought, all the others Ms Wells adopts are terrific, from the accurate “Brummie” used for Gareth’s servant, to the utterly hilarious hybrid Italiano-Scottish one she employs to portray one of the art dealers under investigation. Her interpretation of Gareth is especially good; she makes him sound masculine and sexy by adopting a slightly lower pitch and a measured delivery that conveys an impression of quiet competence which is very attractive.
All in all, His Wicked Reputation proved to be a thoroughly enjoyable listening experience. The romance is well-developed, the protagonists have great chemistry and the mystery element doesn’t overshadow the love story. I’m really glad I gave the story another chance, and am now looking forward to listening to the next book in the series.
A- for narration / B+ for content, 4.5 stars.
When I read His Wicked Reputation a few months back, I enjoyed it, but came away from it feeling as though there was something missing I couldn’t quite put my finger on. As any regular listener to audiobooks will know, there are times when listening to a book rather than reading it can enhance the experience and enjoyment of the story, and I’m pleased to report that his was one of those times. Thanks in no small part to another excellent performance by Mary Jane Wells, I enjoyed the story even more this time around.
The wicked reputation of the title belongs to Gareth Fitzallen, the bastard son of a duke, and it relates entirely to the fact that, apart from being drop-dead gorgeous, he is purported to be able to give a woman such incredible pleasure in bed that they are willing to do absolutely anything to keep him there! Gareth makes no bones about his skill in that direction, but he is always faithful and discreet in his liaisons; In fact, he’s rather a wonderful man – intelligent, deeply honourable and kind – obviously, the appellation “wicked” only applies to his activities between the sheets!
Although acknowledged by his father, Gareth had to make his own way in the world, and now makes his living as a successful art dealer and broker. He shares a strong bond of friendship with his half-brothers, Lance (now the Duke of Aylesbury) and Ywain (Ives), although none of them were at all fond of their eldest brother, Percy, a particularly nasty individual who went out of his way to make life difficult for others and especially for Gareth. His most recent piece of unpleasantness concerned a property their late father had willed to his illegitimate son, but now Percy is dead, Gareth hopes that Lance will set aside Percy’s objection to his inheritance, and in anticipation of taking possession, travels to the Midlands to inspect it.
On the way to the house, he accidentally runs a young woman into a muddy puddle and finds himself intrigued by her caustic reaction to him. He offers to help her with the rather large package she is struggling with, but she refuses and goes on her way.
Eva Russell realises she has had a narrow escape. The sister of an earl, she and her younger sister are living in the reduced circumstances occasioned by their late brother’s profligacy, and Eva earns a little money by selling her paintings. She does not, however, sell original works; instead she paints copies of the famous paintings she “borrows” from the attics of the deserted house that is her nearest neighbour – the house she now knows is owned by the gentleman she met in the lane, who would no doubt be furious if he knew what she was doing.
Shortly after Gareth’s arrival, he is summoned back to London by Ives, who has been asked to investigate the disappearance of a large number of valuable works of art. Some years previously, when the threat of an invasion by Napoleon and his forces was a very real one, several noblemen packed up their art treasures and had them transported to a place of safety in the north of England. These paintings were never returned to their owners after the war ended, and questions are now being asked. Ives asks for Gareth’s help, knowing his brother’s knowledge of art and of who owns what will be invaluable in such a task.
It’s not hard to work out the direction the story is going to take, but that doesn’t take away any of the enjoyment in listening to how things play out.
Having been intrigued by Eva’s reaction to him, Gareth soon seeks her out, and even though she knows such marked attentions from a man of Gareth’s reputation can only lead to one thing, Eva can’t help but be strongly attracted to him. She’s on the shelf – and in any case, believes that her passion for painting precludes her having such things as a husband and family of her own. Yet as she comes to know Gareth, to know his kindness and the truth of the man behind the wicked reputation, she finds him increasingly difficult to resist.
One of the best things about the book is the way in which the relationship between Eva and Gareth develops into a true and deep friendship, with them coming to know and depend on each other almost without realising it. Their romantic relationship is lovely, too; highly sensual, but with an element of caring and thoughtfulness on Gareth’s part which shows him to be not only well-and-truly smitten, but a genuinely good man. I also enjoyed the interplay between Gareth and his brothers, which is often funny, and which leaves the listener in no doubt about their fondness for one another.
Mary Jane Wells is a favourite narrator of mine, and her performance here more than lived up to my expectations in every respect but one. It’s not something that spoiled my enjoyment, but it struck me as rather odd that she has opted to give Eva a less-than-upper-crust accent. Eva has fallen on hard times, it’s true, but she’s the sister of (and therefore the daughter of) an earl, and I had expected to hear her voiced accordingly; but instead Ms Wells gives her an accent I can only describe as slightly “cockney”, which didn’t fit the image I had of her. The rather bright edge given to her tone works, given Eva’s sometimes acerbic pronouncements, and the way she brings out the emotional nuances in Eva’s speech is also excellent – I was just confused by the choice of accent. In all other aspects, however, Ms Wells’ performance is faultless. All the characters are clearly delineated by use of a variety of tones and timbres; Lance, Ives and Gareth are easy to tell apart, as are Eva and Rachel and the two sisters who are their friends and neighbours. While Eva’s accent gave me pause for thought, all the others Ms Wells adopts are terrific, from the accurate “Brummie” used for Gareth’s servant, to the utterly hilarious hybrid Italiano-Scottish one she employs to portray one of the art dealers under investigation. Her interpretation of Gareth is especially good; she makes him sound masculine and sexy by adopting a slightly lower pitch and a measured delivery that conveys an impression of quiet competence which is very attractive.
All in all, His Wicked Reputation proved to be a thoroughly enjoyable listening experience. The romance is well-developed, the protagonists have great chemistry and the mystery element doesn’t overshadow the love story. I’m really glad I gave the story another chance, and am now looking forward to listening to the next book in the series.
January 11, 2023
Very very wallpaper-y, but I was in a mood!
I haven't read a romance novel in two weeks (too busy Bleak House-ing) and I needed a break. I'm sure there were things in this I would normally be annoyed by, but it was cute. I would definitely return to Madeline Hunter again. I think she may kind of be in the Amanda Quick, Tessa Dare lineage? Solid 3 star books that I have fun with when I want them--that's a 3 stars (laudatory!) not 3 stars (derogatory).
Some people complained about a lack of historical accuracy, particular with regards to Eva's eagerness to have the affair and the couple's lack of discretion, asking for "consequences." I don't know! I believe that people have always had sex and have always wanted to have sex and Eva is an older heroine who doesn't have many prospects and Gareth is not even particularly anti-marriage, like many rakes. He's open to marrying her if she gets pregnant and she is open to marrying if she gets pregnant! That isn't even why he ends up proposing. Maybe I'm just in a moment where that not being the conflict was refreshing.
I haven't read a romance novel in two weeks (too busy Bleak House-ing) and I needed a break. I'm sure there were things in this I would normally be annoyed by, but it was cute. I would definitely return to Madeline Hunter again. I think she may kind of be in the Amanda Quick, Tessa Dare lineage? Solid 3 star books that I have fun with when I want them--that's a 3 stars (laudatory!) not 3 stars (derogatory).
Some people complained about a lack of historical accuracy, particular with regards to Eva's eagerness to have the affair and the couple's lack of discretion, asking for "consequences." I don't know! I believe that people have always had sex and have always wanted to have sex and Eva is an older heroine who doesn't have many prospects and Gareth is not even particularly anti-marriage, like many rakes. He's open to marrying her if she gets pregnant and she is open to marrying if she gets pregnant! That isn't even why he ends up proposing. Maybe I'm just in a moment where that not being the conflict was refreshing.
August 9, 2025
I would’ve never picked this book, but one of my book clubs did and it was surprising. I really enjoy stories that involve art forgery, even though the artist in this one wasn’t deliberately forging.
The mailman character and his brothers are described as horrible people in the beginning, and that almost made me DNF, but I’m glad I stuck with it. You definitely have a reformed rake situation here.
The mailman character and his brothers are described as horrible people in the beginning, and that almost made me DNF, but I’m glad I stuck with it. You definitely have a reformed rake situation here.
March 4, 2015
His Wicked Reputation by Madeline Hunter- Wicked Trilogy #1 is a 2015 Jove publication.
My review:
The art theft thread was very cleverly plotted and adds a bit of danger, and intrigue, which is always on the table where an art theft is concerned. There are a few tense moments here and there as Gareth connects the dots and the investigation really heats up.
The art theft, and the hunt for a husband for Eva's sister, takes a backseat to the passionate affair between Eva and Gareth. Gareth is just dreamy and certainly lives up to his wicked reputation. I enjoyed seeing Eva come to life in Gareth's skillful hands and, of course, getting her very own happy ever after.
So, to sum it up, if you like historical romance with a little humor, served with a side of danger or mystery, you should give this one a try.
This review is the copyrighted property of Night Owl Reviews. For the full review please visit http://www.nightowlreviews.com
My review:
The art theft thread was very cleverly plotted and adds a bit of danger, and intrigue, which is always on the table where an art theft is concerned. There are a few tense moments here and there as Gareth connects the dots and the investigation really heats up.
The art theft, and the hunt for a husband for Eva's sister, takes a backseat to the passionate affair between Eva and Gareth. Gareth is just dreamy and certainly lives up to his wicked reputation. I enjoyed seeing Eva come to life in Gareth's skillful hands and, of course, getting her very own happy ever after.
So, to sum it up, if you like historical romance with a little humor, served with a side of danger or mystery, you should give this one a try.
This review is the copyrighted property of Night Owl Reviews. For the full review please visit http://www.nightowlreviews.com
April 5, 2019
3,5*... Oh pah, porque é que o GR já deixa dar meias estrelas... É que sendo 0.5 já arredonda para cima... Pelo menos na minha matemática... Pf!
Começo a pensar que a culpa está nas traduções, já li dois livros da autora e... Raios não consigo ter empatia com o personagem masculino, acho os amores deles são superficiais, sem chama, sem nada! Não sei o que pensar da autora, tenho que ir à caça de um livros traduzido cá, em que depois de troca-troca como coelhos, não se tratem como toda a formalidade, como se não tivesse andado a rebolar na relva e a ajoelhar para rezar! -_-
Grrrr!
Começo a pensar que a culpa está nas traduções, já li dois livros da autora e... Raios não consigo ter empatia com o personagem masculino, acho os amores deles são superficiais, sem chama, sem nada! Não sei o que pensar da autora, tenho que ir à caça de um livros traduzido cá, em que depois de troca-troca como coelhos, não se tratem como toda a formalidade, como se não tivesse andado a rebolar na relva e a ajoelhar para rezar! -_-
Grrrr!
January 23, 2022
Identificado novamente o problema com estes livros (para mim), quando os leio de seguida.
Soam iguais.
Desde o retrato que fazem da personagem principal (irresistível, com imensas amantes, muito experiente e requisitado pelas senhoras), ao retrato da personagem feminina (bonita à sua maneira, ansiosa por explorar a própria sexualidade, com uma atividade que lhe permite ganhar alguns trocos, pouco inclinada ao casamento) até à relação que se desenvolve entre os dois. Tornou-se um espelho do livro que li há dias Nobre e Poderoso, na forma como se conhecessem (por acaso, sozinhos), no modo como falam um com o outro, no modo como a relação evolui para um caso amoroso com bastante naturalidade e, mais evidente ainda, como tudo se conclui com grande naturalidade, e o "amo-te" e o "casamento" tornam-se opções lógicas e não grandes decisões tomadas. Gostei bastante, atenção, mas não varia grande coisa de uns para outros.
Nota para o enredo de fundo, quadros de coleccionadores particulares extraviados. Achei que a autora teve mestria a enjorcar essa história. Saiu-lhe muito bem embora, em certas partes, algo maçadora.
Seria 4* se não tivesse lido o outro há dias, embora me saiba a 3* porque li. Sou justa e dou-lhe o 4.
Soam iguais.
Desde o retrato que fazem da personagem principal (irresistível, com imensas amantes, muito experiente e requisitado pelas senhoras), ao retrato da personagem feminina (bonita à sua maneira, ansiosa por explorar a própria sexualidade, com uma atividade que lhe permite ganhar alguns trocos, pouco inclinada ao casamento) até à relação que se desenvolve entre os dois. Tornou-se um espelho do livro que li há dias Nobre e Poderoso, na forma como se conhecessem (por acaso, sozinhos), no modo como falam um com o outro, no modo como a relação evolui para um caso amoroso com bastante naturalidade e, mais evidente ainda, como tudo se conclui com grande naturalidade, e o "amo-te" e o "casamento" tornam-se opções lógicas e não grandes decisões tomadas. Gostei bastante, atenção, mas não varia grande coisa de uns para outros.
Nota para o enredo de fundo, quadros de coleccionadores particulares extraviados. Achei que a autora teve mestria a enjorcar essa história. Saiu-lhe muito bem embora, em certas partes, algo maçadora.
Seria 4* se não tivesse lido o outro há dias, embora me saiba a 3* porque li. Sou justa e dou-lhe o 4.
August 15, 2025
Eva Russell gave up most of her freedom to care for her dying brother, and now is one disaster away from financial ruin, hoping to help her sister marry a gentleman. She paints replicas of paintings she finds in the attic of the neighboring estate and sells them for shillings to make ends meet. Gareth Fitzallen is the bastard son of a duke, and his reputation for enjoying the finer things in life proceeds him. His inheritance is the estate Langdon's End, and he's out to seduce the beautiful young neighbor, only spinster Eva is the one who catches his eye.
This was an enjoyable, but perhaps not a standout historical romance read. Madeline Hunter creates interesting characters, and this class difference romance between an aristocratic bastard and an impoverished gentry-woman has a lot of interesting components. The art forgery/art theft plot is perhaps the most interesting of the story. Otherwise, the relationship was fun, and it's always amusing to see a rake who will never marry fall for anyone.
As an aside, I've liked but not loved the two Madeline Hunter books I read. I'm only disappointed that her medievals are not available as audiobooks!
This was an enjoyable, but perhaps not a standout historical romance read. Madeline Hunter creates interesting characters, and this class difference romance between an aristocratic bastard and an impoverished gentry-woman has a lot of interesting components. The art forgery/art theft plot is perhaps the most interesting of the story. Otherwise, the relationship was fun, and it's always amusing to see a rake who will never marry fall for anyone.
As an aside, I've liked but not loved the two Madeline Hunter books I read. I'm only disappointed that her medievals are not available as audiobooks!
March 23, 2015
3.5 Stars
This is a historical fiction.
Not sure how to describe this romance. It was not insta-love, but you knew immediately that the hero and heroine liked each other. Gareth is a bastard and his reputation for ruining the reputation of women is known everywhere. Eva Russell is a spinster. She takes care of her almost 19 year old sister. Eva makes money by “borrowing” paintings and copying them. One day as she is “borrowing” a painting from what she thinks is an abandoned house when she is almost run over by a horse ridden by Gareth. Eva and Gareth exchange a few words and Gareth is a bit captivated by Eva. Eva finds out later that the painting and the abandoned house belongs to Gareth. One day when Eva is returning the painting, she again runs into Gareth and from there a friendship and much more develops. People warn Eva about Gareth, but not for her to be careful, but for her to watch her sister and protect her from him. No one assumes that Gareth visits Eva’s home to see her. Gareth has no interest in the sister and he makes it obvious the first time he visits.
I am not sure if I misunderstood this part while reading this book, but I felt like Eva already had so much on her plate with taking care of her home that why was finding a suitor for her sister her responsibility Her sister was a grown woman and I felt that it was always Eva giving up everything for her sister. Gareth buys Eva something and selfless Eva thinks how she can make it into something for her sister. The author tried to make the sister appear bright and “kind” but I did not buy it. This is just my own rant about the book.
There is a bit of mystery/suspense in the book as to a painting, Eva’s brother’s accident that happened that later lead to his death, and then who is breaking into Eva’s home. Gareth and Eva have a very odd relationship. They are intimate, but more than that they are best friends. Gareth is very protective of Eva and Eva makes Gareth feel good about himself since everyone just thinks he is just the “bastard” of the town. Those scenes with them just together and talking were some of my favorite.
There were some scenes that I felt dragged and could have been shortened. Overall, I enjoyed the story even though it took me sometime to understand what was going on.
A copy was provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
This is a historical fiction.
Not sure how to describe this romance. It was not insta-love, but you knew immediately that the hero and heroine liked each other. Gareth is a bastard and his reputation for ruining the reputation of women is known everywhere. Eva Russell is a spinster. She takes care of her almost 19 year old sister. Eva makes money by “borrowing” paintings and copying them. One day as she is “borrowing” a painting from what she thinks is an abandoned house when she is almost run over by a horse ridden by Gareth. Eva and Gareth exchange a few words and Gareth is a bit captivated by Eva. Eva finds out later that the painting and the abandoned house belongs to Gareth. One day when Eva is returning the painting, she again runs into Gareth and from there a friendship and much more develops. People warn Eva about Gareth, but not for her to be careful, but for her to watch her sister and protect her from him. No one assumes that Gareth visits Eva’s home to see her. Gareth has no interest in the sister and he makes it obvious the first time he visits.
I am not sure if I misunderstood this part while reading this book, but I felt like Eva already had so much on her plate with taking care of her home that why was finding a suitor for her sister her responsibility Her sister was a grown woman and I felt that it was always Eva giving up everything for her sister. Gareth buys Eva something and selfless Eva thinks how she can make it into something for her sister. The author tried to make the sister appear bright and “kind” but I did not buy it. This is just my own rant about the book.
There is a bit of mystery/suspense in the book as to a painting, Eva’s brother’s accident that happened that later lead to his death, and then who is breaking into Eva’s home. Gareth and Eva have a very odd relationship. They are intimate, but more than that they are best friends. Gareth is very protective of Eva and Eva makes Gareth feel good about himself since everyone just thinks he is just the “bastard” of the town. Those scenes with them just together and talking were some of my favorite.
There were some scenes that I felt dragged and could have been shortened. Overall, I enjoyed the story even though it took me sometime to understand what was going on.
A copy was provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
December 6, 2019
(...)Este primeiro livro da série Os Libertinos, traz-nos a história de Eva e Gareth. Ela, uma jovem artista que se vê obrigada a algumas transgressões de modo a poder sustentar a irmã mais nova e a manter a casa que têm.
Sendo uma artista com muita qualidade e talento, Eva geralmente vai ao sótão de uma casa vizinha que está abandonada há anos e traz de lá quadros verdadeiros de artistas conceituados. Não que fique com eles. A ideia é levá-los emprestados, fazer cópia deles para poder vender e depois devolver ao sítio onde pertencem. A questão é que até ao dia em que a casa foi novamente ocupada pelo seu respectivo novo dono, Eva vê-se entre a espada e a parede pois à medida que os dias vão passando, maior é a dificuldade de continuar com esse seu esquema que, bem dita a verdade e apesar do talento e da qualidade das cópias, Eva não recebia o muito que devia receber pelas suas pinturas, mas era melhor que nada e sempre ia dando para sobreviver.(...)"
Opinião Completa no Sinfonia dos Livros
Sendo uma artista com muita qualidade e talento, Eva geralmente vai ao sótão de uma casa vizinha que está abandonada há anos e traz de lá quadros verdadeiros de artistas conceituados. Não que fique com eles. A ideia é levá-los emprestados, fazer cópia deles para poder vender e depois devolver ao sítio onde pertencem. A questão é que até ao dia em que a casa foi novamente ocupada pelo seu respectivo novo dono, Eva vê-se entre a espada e a parede pois à medida que os dias vão passando, maior é a dificuldade de continuar com esse seu esquema que, bem dita a verdade e apesar do talento e da qualidade das cópias, Eva não recebia o muito que devia receber pelas suas pinturas, mas era melhor que nada e sempre ia dando para sobreviver.(...)"
Opinião Completa no Sinfonia dos Livros
June 15, 2016
Full of Mystery, Adventure and Love
His Wicked Reputation by Madeline Hunter was a great book full of adventure, mystery, match matching and love. I highly enjoyed this historical romance. I listened to the audiobook, and I was so impressed with the narrator, Mary Jane Wells, who does so many different British accents with different dialects. The heroine, Eva, is quite the spinster with a creative and adventurous side lurking underneath and Gareth can't get enough of Eva from the moment he meets her. She challenges him. They are neighbors and their lives keep intertwining with each other. There is quite a charming and passionate love story here but also a mystery element which had me guessing "Who done it?" until the end.
This book is the first in a trilogy about 3 brothers. One is an art broker, another is a lawyer and the third is a Duke. This book was a charming, adventurous and light read.
His Wicked Reputation by Madeline Hunter was a great book full of adventure, mystery, match matching and love. I highly enjoyed this historical romance. I listened to the audiobook, and I was so impressed with the narrator, Mary Jane Wells, who does so many different British accents with different dialects. The heroine, Eva, is quite the spinster with a creative and adventurous side lurking underneath and Gareth can't get enough of Eva from the moment he meets her. She challenges him. They are neighbors and their lives keep intertwining with each other. There is quite a charming and passionate love story here but also a mystery element which had me guessing "Who done it?" until the end.
This book is the first in a trilogy about 3 brothers. One is an art broker, another is a lawyer and the third is a Duke. This book was a charming, adventurous and light read.
July 25, 2016
I thoroughly enjoyed this book and the art theft mystery kept me on my toes! All the pieces and parts fell together in a very intricate way, which I appreciated. The characters were great. Ms Hunter writes with a quiet and understated power, her characters are richly portrayed and likeable, especially her secondary characters. Eva was wonderful. A great, strong character. The relationship between Eva and Gareth is sweet and tender. I also liked the camaraderie and affection between Gareth and his brothers.
A good start to a new series and I can't wait to read the next one, Tall, Dark and Wicked.
A good start to a new series and I can't wait to read the next one, Tall, Dark and Wicked.
July 1, 2021
I liked this; I wasn't convinced of the romance between the two leads, but it the general plot was entertaining and the characters were likeable.
June 15, 2016
Audible title: “HWR was decidedly well-earned!”
ಌ
Minor spoilers alert!!!
★¸¸.•*¨*•★Unabridged Audiobook Info★•*¨*•.¸¸★
Narrated by: Mary Jane Wells
Length: 9 hrs and 46 mins
Release Date: 03-03-15
Publisher: Blackstone Audio, Inc.
Writing style: 3rd person POV
Cover design: I love both the e-book and the audiobook covers which differ greatly in their color palatte (rich dark colors versus light blue and neutral tones respectively) and the design’s historical setting location (sitting room versus a passageway respectively). Both cover models (or is it the same model?) are handsome and definitely look appropriately wicked and irresistible. I'm proud to have both versions to gaze upon in my Kindle and Audible collections.
Overall rating: ★★★★1/2
Mary Jane’s Performance: ★★★★★
Story rating: ★★★★1/2
ಌ
Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?
Yes, unequivocally! Narrator Mary Jane Wells had great voices for both female and male characters as well as excellent delivery. I'm a little bummed that she isn't narrating the next 2 novels in this trilogy.
What did you like best about this story?
I love when MCs get to spend a decent amount of time interacting, and Eva and Gareth do despite the societal restrictions placed on them.
Which scene was your favorite?
She took several minutes to collect herself, then held his head and looked into his eyes. “That may be the most unusual proposal a woman has ever received.
“Thank you. I thought it inventive.”
“It will be hard to describe when friends ask for the particulars, however. Did he kneel, Eva? Did he wait for a glorious sunset? Actually, no, Sarah. He proposed while his tongue was making shocking explorations of my private parts.”
He pecked a kiss on her check. “At least you will never forget it.”
Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?
I liked the moment of reflection Gareth had after he'd insisted Eva stay the night for her safety.
Any additional comments?
The art mystery was a nice added element that played an important role in bonding these two delightful characters. Up next in my buddy read of this series will be Tall, Dark and Wicked (Wicked Trilogy, #2).
ಌ
Minor spoilers alert!!!
★¸¸.•*¨*•★Unabridged Audiobook Info★•*¨*•.¸¸★
Narrated by: Mary Jane Wells
Length: 9 hrs and 46 mins
Release Date: 03-03-15
Publisher: Blackstone Audio, Inc.
Writing style: 3rd person POV
Cover design: I love both the e-book and the audiobook covers which differ greatly in their color palatte (rich dark colors versus light blue and neutral tones respectively) and the design’s historical setting location (sitting room versus a passageway respectively). Both cover models (or is it the same model?) are handsome and definitely look appropriately wicked and irresistible. I'm proud to have both versions to gaze upon in my Kindle and Audible collections.
Overall rating: ★★★★1/2
Mary Jane’s Performance: ★★★★★
Story rating: ★★★★1/2
ಌ
Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?
Yes, unequivocally! Narrator Mary Jane Wells had great voices for both female and male characters as well as excellent delivery. I'm a little bummed that she isn't narrating the next 2 novels in this trilogy.
What did you like best about this story?
I love when MCs get to spend a decent amount of time interacting, and Eva and Gareth do despite the societal restrictions placed on them.
Which scene was your favorite?
She took several minutes to collect herself, then held his head and looked into his eyes. “That may be the most unusual proposal a woman has ever received.
“Thank you. I thought it inventive.”
“It will be hard to describe when friends ask for the particulars, however. Did he kneel, Eva? Did he wait for a glorious sunset? Actually, no, Sarah. He proposed while his tongue was making shocking explorations of my private parts.”
He pecked a kiss on her check. “At least you will never forget it.”
Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?
I liked the moment of reflection Gareth had after he'd insisted Eva stay the night for her safety.
Any additional comments?
The art mystery was a nice added element that played an important role in bonding these two delightful characters. Up next in my buddy read of this series will be Tall, Dark and Wicked (Wicked Trilogy, #2).
April 6, 2015
I enjoyed this story. Gareth was the bastard son of a duke. He made his way in the world as an art broker and was on the Continent when his half-brother, the duke, died. He hurried back to London to discover if he still had the house and land his father left him. His late brother had been contesting his father's will and, though unsuccessful, had tried to ruin the house left to him near Birmingham.
Eva was a spinster living with her beautiful younger sister. They had lost most of their fortune when their brother died. He had lived extravagantly and carelessly. So Eva earned money by borrowing paintings from Gareth's abandoned house and copying them. She would return the originals and sell her copies locally as copies. She never claimed they were the originals.
Gareth returns to check out his property not aware of what Eva and others had been doing with the contents of his house. They meet and are attracted to each other.
The Prince Regent has hired Gareth to locate some stolen paintings which provides the mystery for the book. It's all woven together and is somewhat predictable. But I think it is supposed to be. It's easy for the reader to see what is coming. But the how and the result is worth the read.
Gareth and Eva have a very sensual relationship and end up with a wonderful HEA. A different kind of story and a good one.
Eva was a spinster living with her beautiful younger sister. They had lost most of their fortune when their brother died. He had lived extravagantly and carelessly. So Eva earned money by borrowing paintings from Gareth's abandoned house and copying them. She would return the originals and sell her copies locally as copies. She never claimed they were the originals.
Gareth returns to check out his property not aware of what Eva and others had been doing with the contents of his house. They meet and are attracted to each other.
The Prince Regent has hired Gareth to locate some stolen paintings which provides the mystery for the book. It's all woven together and is somewhat predictable. But I think it is supposed to be. It's easy for the reader to see what is coming. But the how and the result is worth the read.
Gareth and Eva have a very sensual relationship and end up with a wonderful HEA. A different kind of story and a good one.
January 1, 2016
Opinião completa em http://pepitamagica.blogspot.pt/2015/...
Eva é uma artista bastante boa, que só é reconhecia pelas suas cópias de grandes obras (mesmo assim não recebe quase dinheiro nenhum por elas). Gareth é um homem da nobreza que lida com arte e colecções privadas. Era praticamente impossível não se cruzarem quando Gareth se muda para a mesma pequena vila que Eva.
(...)
Gostei particularmente que Gareth não duvidasse de Eva, que acreditasse nela, no matter what - já ando um bocado farta de livros em que o problema que impede o happy ending são as eternas desconfianças e traições- mesmo quando tudo poderia indicar o contrário. E porquê? Novamente porque eles são mais que amantes, ou apaixonados, são amigos que desenvolveram uma confiança mútua devido às suas acções.
(...)
Para terminar, porque custa-nos escrever mais sobre os livros que gostamos do que sobre os que não gostamos, foi um livro rápido, querido e amoroso, com amizade, amor, quadros roubados, mistério (que nós acabamos por resolver rapidamente, mas mesmo assim), todos os ingredientes que fazem deste livro uma história a reler. Ah, e já referi que vamos ter as histórias dos irmãos de Gareth? Só para vos aguçar a curiosidade, já comecei também o segundo livro, em breve deverei ter mais novidades :)
Eva é uma artista bastante boa, que só é reconhecia pelas suas cópias de grandes obras (mesmo assim não recebe quase dinheiro nenhum por elas). Gareth é um homem da nobreza que lida com arte e colecções privadas. Era praticamente impossível não se cruzarem quando Gareth se muda para a mesma pequena vila que Eva.
(...)
Gostei particularmente que Gareth não duvidasse de Eva, que acreditasse nela, no matter what - já ando um bocado farta de livros em que o problema que impede o happy ending são as eternas desconfianças e traições- mesmo quando tudo poderia indicar o contrário. E porquê? Novamente porque eles são mais que amantes, ou apaixonados, são amigos que desenvolveram uma confiança mútua devido às suas acções.
(...)
Para terminar, porque custa-nos escrever mais sobre os livros que gostamos do que sobre os que não gostamos, foi um livro rápido, querido e amoroso, com amizade, amor, quadros roubados, mistério (que nós acabamos por resolver rapidamente, mas mesmo assim), todos os ingredientes que fazem deste livro uma história a reler. Ah, e já referi que vamos ter as histórias dos irmãos de Gareth? Só para vos aguçar a curiosidade, já comecei também o segundo livro, em breve deverei ter mais novidades :)
August 24, 2015
I feel like I might be going on a Hunter binge read. There's just something grounded and rich about her characters and plots. Like I said in my last MH review: her stories contain plots with substance. And I love that. I love the feeling of a satisfactory, solid read.
Surprisingly, the romance is more, ah, descriptive here. And maybe a little too often. Usually, MH is metaphorical writing her love scenes. I mean, I'm not complaining (mostly), it's just something that stood out to me. Another odd thing I noticed was that our hero, Gareth, had literally no faults in his character. I know he is a hero, but really, none at all besides him being a bastard (which he has no control over) and a rogue (which is never presented as a fault of character). Again, no complaints but it is rather odd, nonetheless.
Surprisingly, the romance is more, ah, descriptive here. And maybe a little too often. Usually, MH is metaphorical writing her love scenes. I mean, I'm not complaining (mostly), it's just something that stood out to me. Another odd thing I noticed was that our hero, Gareth, had literally no faults in his character. I know he is a hero, but really, none at all besides him being a bastard (which he has no control over) and a rogue (which is never presented as a fault of character). Again, no complaints but it is rather odd, nonetheless.
March 11, 2015
First book in a trilogy.
I have been reading Madeline Hunter for a longtime. She has a way with her characters that make them more than just the words written. They are real. multidimensional people. I am just the sort of reader that gets more involved with characters than the story. The story in His Wicked Reputation is fine but Gareth and Eva and the brothers will have me buying the next two books.
I have been reading Madeline Hunter for a longtime. She has a way with her characters that make them more than just the words written. They are real. multidimensional people. I am just the sort of reader that gets more involved with characters than the story. The story in His Wicked Reputation is fine but Gareth and Eva and the brothers will have me buying the next two books.
did-not-finish
September 8, 2018I saw this today and realized I tried this one on audio book years ago and never finished it. My main problems were:
- Sex scenes with OW
- TONS of OW drama
- Predictable plot that had me rolling my eyes.
- This just was not my cup of tea.
- Sex scenes with OW
- TONS of OW drama
- Predictable plot that had me rolling my eyes.
- This just was not my cup of tea.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 355 reviews