I recently picked up all four of these seasonally themed — at least in name — short story collections from Agatha Christie. Tackling this one first at random, I found the stories in Autumn Chills extremely enjoyable, and now I can’t wait to read the others.
You would think that the Poirot stories included — all of which I’d read previously — would be the highlights. While one might say they anchor this particular collection from Christie, and are perhaps the main draw for most fans, I have to say that a few of these other stories are at least as good, and a couple were very memorable.
The Poirot stories included in Autumn Chills:
Murder in the Mews
Triangle at Rhodes (a personal favorite)
The Lemesurier Inheritance
Four-and-Twenty Blackbirds
All four are of course enjoyable for Poirot fans, with each person probably finding one they love a bit more than the others. Murder in the Mews stands out, but Rhodes has always been a favorite of mine, and it was nice to have it included here.
Miss Marple:
Death by Drowning
Tape-Measure Murder
Though in long form, I actually prefer Patricia Wentworth’s Miss Silver to Christie’s Miss Marple, in the shorter form I found these two Miss Marple stories incredibly entertaining. I loved Death by Drowning, and really enjoyed Tape-Measure Murder a great deal. One of the two ended a bit too abruptly for me, but it wasn’t enough to keep me from making a mental note to return to this collection at some point down the road and reread it.
Tommy and Tuppence:
The House of Lurking Death
I’m not a huge fan of Tommy and Tuppence in long form, but in short story form they work so well — particularly in this story — that it prompted me to pick up a copy of Partners in Crime, a collection of Tommy and Tuppence short stories. Some of them are included in the other seasonal hardcover volumes, but not all. Based on how much fun I found The House of Lurking Death to be, I’m glad I now have Partners in Crime there to read when I’m in the mood.
Parker Pyne:
The Case of the Rich Woman
I’ve read a few Parker Pyne stories before, but not this one. While some might label it one of the weakest stories here, I suspect that’s due to it being much less a traditional mystery than it is a life lesson, courtesy of Christie, and her man, Parker Pyne. It’s actually quite enjoyable, and perhaps a glimpse into how Christie herself felt about the trappings of wealth.
Mr Satterthwaite and Mr Quin:
The Bird with the Broken Wing
The Voice in the Dark
While I thought the ending to Voice in the Dark a bit too tidy, I must say it was a terrific story. The Bird with the Broken Wing however, was atmospheric and enthralling. It is, to my mind, tied for the most memorable story in the collection with one I will get to shortly. I had yet to read a Satterthwaite and Quin story, but find myself eagerly looking forward to the other five which are scattered among the four seasonally themed collections I now own. I’m very much looking forward to reading Broken Wing again somewhere down the line.
The final two entries which round out the dozen are stand-alone stories bereft of a famous series detective creation. The Witness for the Prosecution is well known of course, due to the play, and the film this short story gave birth to, and it’s a good one. For me, however, While the Light Lasts ranks with The Bird with the Broken Wing as the most memorable in Autumn Chills. It is not a traditional mystery, there is no murder to solve, but rather a sad and quietly moving story of lost love, lifestyle choices, and the tragic consequences when comfort becomes more paramount than love.
Whether you’re a Poirot fan, a Miss Marple fan, or just an Agatha Christie fan, it’s hard to go wrong in any way with this fabulous gathering of stories. A fine cross-section from a vast canon that proves Christie was no one-note writer, despite the massive — and deserved — popularity of the little Belgian. Great stuff.