What do you think?
Rate this book
The Hannah Rule
Olivia Bowes is officially done with dating.
After years with an almost-fiancé who “wasn’t ready” for kids (right up until he had them with someone else) rule-following psychologist Olivia is over it. Over men who can’t commit. Over apps. Over pretending she has infinite time. With her rescue greyhound Hannah as emotional support and a fertility clinic on speed dial, Olivia makes a new solo motherhood via sperm donor.
Finn Kelly. The barefoot, sun-bleached, infuriatingly laidback stranger who is absolutely not part of the plan.
Officially, Finn’s an emergency nurse. Until he finds himself accidently agreeing to a side gig as a birth doula for Olivia’s pregnant best friend. He’s brilliant with panicked parents-to-be and brand-new babies, but ask if he wants kids of his own and he’ll tell you (very firmly) no.
Six months later, when Olivia and Finn run into each other at her best friend's baby shower, she accidently agrees to coach him how to handle “big feelings” in labour. She's definitely not noticing his easy smile or tanned forearms or the way her dog gives him heart eyes. What starts as professional-ish coaching turns suspiciously like dating… inconvenient, given Olivia is actively choosing her sperm donor and Finn has built his whole identity around not being anybody’s dad.
But as IUIs turn into IVF, as two-week waits blur into hope and heartbreak, Finn becomes the one person who makes the whole messy, medicalised, occasionally McDonald’s-fuelled journey feel bearable. He's also the biggest threat to Olivia’s carefully protected heart. Because falling in love was never on her spreadsheet...
The Hannah Rule is a funny, big-hearted contemporary romance set on Sydney’s coastline, perfect for readers who
romcom banter with real emotional stakes
fertility and IVF storylines handled with care
soft, caretaker heroes and fiercely capable heroines
sisters, found family, and one very good rescue dog
Olivia is ready to have a baby on her own. She just wasn’t expecting to find her person on the way.
After years with an almost-fiancé who “wasn’t ready” for kids (right up until he had them with someone else) rule-following psychologist Olivia is over it. Over men who can’t commit. Over apps. Over pretending she has infinite time. With her rescue greyhound Hannah as emotional support and a fertility clinic on speed dial, Olivia makes a new solo motherhood via sperm donor.
Finn Kelly. The barefoot, sun-bleached, infuriatingly laidback stranger who is absolutely not part of the plan.
Officially, Finn’s an emergency nurse. Until he finds himself accidently agreeing to a side gig as a birth doula for Olivia’s pregnant best friend. He’s brilliant with panicked parents-to-be and brand-new babies, but ask if he wants kids of his own and he’ll tell you (very firmly) no.
Six months later, when Olivia and Finn run into each other at her best friend's baby shower, she accidently agrees to coach him how to handle “big feelings” in labour. She's definitely not noticing his easy smile or tanned forearms or the way her dog gives him heart eyes. What starts as professional-ish coaching turns suspiciously like dating… inconvenient, given Olivia is actively choosing her sperm donor and Finn has built his whole identity around not being anybody’s dad.
But as IUIs turn into IVF, as two-week waits blur into hope and heartbreak, Finn becomes the one person who makes the whole messy, medicalised, occasionally McDonald’s-fuelled journey feel bearable. He's also the biggest threat to Olivia’s carefully protected heart. Because falling in love was never on her spreadsheet...
The Hannah Rule is a funny, big-hearted contemporary romance set on Sydney’s coastline, perfect for readers who
romcom banter with real emotional stakes
fertility and IVF storylines handled with care
soft, caretaker heroes and fiercely capable heroines
sisters, found family, and one very good rescue dog
Olivia is ready to have a baby on her own. She just wasn’t expecting to find her person on the way.
Unknown Binding
Published December 13, 2025
5 people are currently reading
9 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 29 of 29 reviews
November 17, 2025
I don’t read a lot of romance books but so glad this one came up.
I was rooting for Olivia and then for Finn and then greyhounds were brought into the story too. And as we have one obviously I was rooting for the greys to just be in the book anyways.
This story had a lot going for it, likeable characters, good back stories and a great link between them all. (And obviously the hounds)
There was some spice, written so well and believable.
Family life and sadness touched on too.
A great all rounder to be honest.
If you fancy a good escape read, you’d do good reading this
I was rooting for Olivia and then for Finn and then greyhounds were brought into the story too. And as we have one obviously I was rooting for the greys to just be in the book anyways.
This story had a lot going for it, likeable characters, good back stories and a great link between them all. (And obviously the hounds)
There was some spice, written so well and believable.
Family life and sadness touched on too.
A great all rounder to be honest.
If you fancy a good escape read, you’d do good reading this
November 24, 2025
THE HANNAH RULE by APRIL JAMES
After wasting years on a relationship that was going nowhere, then enduring endless dating app disasters, psychologist Olivia has come to the conclusion that the only way to get the family she so desperately wants is to do it alone. She embarks on her solo fertility journey with a confidence that is only rattled when she unexpectedly meets the infuriatingly upbeat man who crashed her lonely table after her last (and final) date failed to turn up.
Annoying, scruffy and barefoot, surfer dude Finn is the complete opposite of everything Olivia wants but when nurse Finn asks her to help him navigate the emotional needs of a patient the pair slowly get to know each other. As time passes, Olivia finds herself fighting between determination to continue her solo parenthood journey and her undoubtedly growing attraction to Finn. Finn slowly breaks down her barriers, blurring her rigidly organised, colour coded plans until she finds herself softening the lines, easing her grip on perfection and letting him in and what started out as a casual friendship suddenly becomes something much more….
———————————————
This was my first book by April James and I have to say it definitely won’t be my last. I loved her writing style. I read an ebook copy. At around 460 pages, I admit that I was a bit concerned at the start, for me to read a book that long by an author unknown to me, it has to snag my attention IMMEDIATELY. Well ‘The Hannah Rule’ grabbed me firmly by the scruff and refused to let go! I started reading and by the time I came up for air I was 40% in. I have to say, there are very few books that have had me so invested.
This isn’t a light fluffy romance, this book is an emotional journey. Told in a dual POV, we live through all the frustrations, pain, hope, misunderstandings, love and finally glimpse the future.
As a single mum myself although not through choice and related to someone who endured the IVF path (thankfully successfully), I really felt for Olivia during her journey and this book only cemented my utter respect for the strength of women (and men) who choose to travel the parenting road alone.
Finn was the perfect foil for Olivia’s obsessive, controlling personality. It was lovely to see him patiently, gently break down her rigid walls. Opposites really do attract. Alone they both had struggles but working together they smoothed each others edges. The whisper of a possibility at the end I will admit, had been running through my mind for a fair amount of the book.
There is a small amount of spice but it is extremely tastefully done, and certainly not gratuitous but rather to show the relationship progression. It is not an open or closed door but rather ‘slightly ajar’.
There are also references to suicide, separation, cancer, surrogacy, IVF…. So please proceed with caution if any of these subjects affect you.
Thank you to April James for an early read of this delightful book.
👶🏼 Slow Burn
👶🏼 Friends to Lovers
👶🏼 Surrogacy
👶🏼 IVF
👶🏼 He Falls First
👶🏼 Loss , Grief and Healing
After wasting years on a relationship that was going nowhere, then enduring endless dating app disasters, psychologist Olivia has come to the conclusion that the only way to get the family she so desperately wants is to do it alone. She embarks on her solo fertility journey with a confidence that is only rattled when she unexpectedly meets the infuriatingly upbeat man who crashed her lonely table after her last (and final) date failed to turn up.
Annoying, scruffy and barefoot, surfer dude Finn is the complete opposite of everything Olivia wants but when nurse Finn asks her to help him navigate the emotional needs of a patient the pair slowly get to know each other. As time passes, Olivia finds herself fighting between determination to continue her solo parenthood journey and her undoubtedly growing attraction to Finn. Finn slowly breaks down her barriers, blurring her rigidly organised, colour coded plans until she finds herself softening the lines, easing her grip on perfection and letting him in and what started out as a casual friendship suddenly becomes something much more….
———————————————
This was my first book by April James and I have to say it definitely won’t be my last. I loved her writing style. I read an ebook copy. At around 460 pages, I admit that I was a bit concerned at the start, for me to read a book that long by an author unknown to me, it has to snag my attention IMMEDIATELY. Well ‘The Hannah Rule’ grabbed me firmly by the scruff and refused to let go! I started reading and by the time I came up for air I was 40% in. I have to say, there are very few books that have had me so invested.
This isn’t a light fluffy romance, this book is an emotional journey. Told in a dual POV, we live through all the frustrations, pain, hope, misunderstandings, love and finally glimpse the future.
As a single mum myself although not through choice and related to someone who endured the IVF path (thankfully successfully), I really felt for Olivia during her journey and this book only cemented my utter respect for the strength of women (and men) who choose to travel the parenting road alone.
Finn was the perfect foil for Olivia’s obsessive, controlling personality. It was lovely to see him patiently, gently break down her rigid walls. Opposites really do attract. Alone they both had struggles but working together they smoothed each others edges. The whisper of a possibility at the end I will admit, had been running through my mind for a fair amount of the book.
There is a small amount of spice but it is extremely tastefully done, and certainly not gratuitous but rather to show the relationship progression. It is not an open or closed door but rather ‘slightly ajar’.
There are also references to suicide, separation, cancer, surrogacy, IVF…. So please proceed with caution if any of these subjects affect you.
Thank you to April James for an early read of this delightful book.
👶🏼 Slow Burn
👶🏼 Friends to Lovers
👶🏼 Surrogacy
👶🏼 IVF
👶🏼 He Falls First
👶🏼 Loss , Grief and Healing
November 20, 2025
Spice: 🌶️🌶️
Friends to lovers, slow burn
This book is set in beautiful Sydney, Australia. It’s about a single psychologist who wants a baby and is taking steps to do it on her own. Enter the surfer who is opposite of what she thinks she needs and you have a great beginning for a romance story. It is a dual POV which I loved. It makes the story so much more interesting and relatable. The story is detailed, with some hard topics like cancer, but also funny. There are only a few spicy scenes, but they aren’t over the top, just believable.
FMC: Olivia, a psychologist who really wants to be a mom is trying to navigate the IVF world. She is doing it solo by choice. She is very type A, knows what she wants in life, but also sweet.
MMC: Finn, a surfing nurse came home to take care of his mum who has cancer. He is definitely a cinnamon roll, full of sunshine guy but has things in his past holding him back and making him question everything.
Unforgettable Supporting characters: There are several supporting characters. They are all intricate to the story line and developement of the main characters. FMC side is her best friend Grace, her sister, Brooke and her mom, Susanna. There is quick wit and serious talk to try and help Olivia find her way. MMC side is his mom Juliette and his best friend Callum who know his past and try to help him overcome himself.
April did a great job at developing each character. She took several hard topics and laced them with real life. She shows how you don’t always get over it, but you integrate it. There is easy banter laced with fear and memories of past hurts.
I was given an advanced reader copy of this book and I am voluntarily leaving a review. Thank you for a great read April James.
Friends to lovers, slow burn
This book is set in beautiful Sydney, Australia. It’s about a single psychologist who wants a baby and is taking steps to do it on her own. Enter the surfer who is opposite of what she thinks she needs and you have a great beginning for a romance story. It is a dual POV which I loved. It makes the story so much more interesting and relatable. The story is detailed, with some hard topics like cancer, but also funny. There are only a few spicy scenes, but they aren’t over the top, just believable.
FMC: Olivia, a psychologist who really wants to be a mom is trying to navigate the IVF world. She is doing it solo by choice. She is very type A, knows what she wants in life, but also sweet.
MMC: Finn, a surfing nurse came home to take care of his mum who has cancer. He is definitely a cinnamon roll, full of sunshine guy but has things in his past holding him back and making him question everything.
Unforgettable Supporting characters: There are several supporting characters. They are all intricate to the story line and developement of the main characters. FMC side is her best friend Grace, her sister, Brooke and her mom, Susanna. There is quick wit and serious talk to try and help Olivia find her way. MMC side is his mom Juliette and his best friend Callum who know his past and try to help him overcome himself.
April did a great job at developing each character. She took several hard topics and laced them with real life. She shows how you don’t always get over it, but you integrate it. There is easy banter laced with fear and memories of past hurts.
I was given an advanced reader copy of this book and I am voluntarily leaving a review. Thank you for a great read April James.
December 8, 2025
It’s always so nice to see a story from my corner of the world. Yes, it’s set in Sydney, and I’m on the other side of the country, but the Australian setting is always welcome.
Olivia, fed up with the dating scene, and reminiscing about the boyfriend who wanted everything, but just not with her, is waiting not so patiently for her date...
Finn crashes her date. He's just so nice, and happy, even when he's hiding his pain. Having recently returned to Australia after his mother’s cancer diagnosis, he’s intrigued, and braves the wrath of an impatient woman waiting on her date…
Honestly, I did have a hard time with her. She was rude, arrogant, judgmental and a little condescending in the beginning, but she grew on me.Finn is a cinnamon roll, a golden retriever, if you will.
The connections between them weren’t readily apparent, then as it progressed, the drip feed of information started to make it a little clearer. Such an interesting way of doing it.
I loved her sister - she was OTT, dramatic and a breath of fresh air. And when her troubles hit, it proved she was still human, and not just the fun-loving older sister.
Callum was the male version of her, and I enjoyed every scene that he was in.
This was unputdownable. I was invested. not only in Olivia’s journey towards parenthood, but in Finn, and his discovery of Olivia. He’s the ultimate MMC - almost too good to be true!
Thankyou April James, for the opportunity to provide my thoughts on your book.
Olivia, fed up with the dating scene, and reminiscing about the boyfriend who wanted everything, but just not with her, is waiting not so patiently for her date...
Finn crashes her date. He's just so nice, and happy, even when he's hiding his pain. Having recently returned to Australia after his mother’s cancer diagnosis, he’s intrigued, and braves the wrath of an impatient woman waiting on her date…
Honestly, I did have a hard time with her. She was rude, arrogant, judgmental and a little condescending in the beginning, but she grew on me.Finn is a cinnamon roll, a golden retriever, if you will.
The connections between them weren’t readily apparent, then as it progressed, the drip feed of information started to make it a little clearer. Such an interesting way of doing it.
I loved her sister - she was OTT, dramatic and a breath of fresh air. And when her troubles hit, it proved she was still human, and not just the fun-loving older sister.
Callum was the male version of her, and I enjoyed every scene that he was in.
This was unputdownable. I was invested. not only in Olivia’s journey towards parenthood, but in Finn, and his discovery of Olivia. He’s the ultimate MMC - almost too good to be true!
Thankyou April James, for the opportunity to provide my thoughts on your book.
November 20, 2025
ARC copy
Olivia is a psychologist who has given up on relationships and decided to go it alone to be a mum.
Finn has come back to native Australia to support his mother who has been diagnosed with cancer. He is a nurse in the emergency department when Lydia comes in final stages of labour so Finn is on hand to deliver her baby and support Lydia and her husband James is so impressed she starts praising Finns skills as a doula and recommends him to her friends.
After meeting Olivia, Finn asks Olivia for psychological guidance with his newly founded skills as a doula in return she leans on the fact he is a friend who can guide her through the IVF process. Along with the support from her sister Brooke and mum, Susanna.
There are a lot of side issues going on from their pasts that merge well with the story. From the death of Finns friend (the reason he left Australia), his brother and husband going through the surrogacy route themselves and of course Finns mothers cancer.
Not forgetting Hannah.
A really nice informative read with a lovely theme and I must admit I can usually preempt the outcome of stories but I missed the end twist in this one. Thoroughly enjoyed this book
Olivia is a psychologist who has given up on relationships and decided to go it alone to be a mum.
Finn has come back to native Australia to support his mother who has been diagnosed with cancer. He is a nurse in the emergency department when Lydia comes in final stages of labour so Finn is on hand to deliver her baby and support Lydia and her husband James is so impressed she starts praising Finns skills as a doula and recommends him to her friends.
After meeting Olivia, Finn asks Olivia for psychological guidance with his newly founded skills as a doula in return she leans on the fact he is a friend who can guide her through the IVF process. Along with the support from her sister Brooke and mum, Susanna.
There are a lot of side issues going on from their pasts that merge well with the story. From the death of Finns friend (the reason he left Australia), his brother and husband going through the surrogacy route themselves and of course Finns mothers cancer.
Not forgetting Hannah.
A really nice informative read with a lovely theme and I must admit I can usually preempt the outcome of stories but I missed the end twist in this one. Thoroughly enjoyed this book
November 21, 2025
⭐️4.5 🌶️2
Tropes:
🏄♂️ Male nurse/doula/surfer
👩⚕️ Slow burn
🏄♂️ Friends-to-Lovers
👩⚕️ Dating while pregnant (not the father)
🏄♂️ Cinnamon-roll MMC
👩⚕️ Grief/healing
🏄♂️ Rescue dog
This book interested me from the beginning because I’ve never really read about an IVF journey. I also loved the fact that it was based in Australia my home country.
Olivia is a psychologist who is tried of going on dates that lead nowhere and decides to start a family on her own through IVF.
At the beginning of her journey she meets Finn who isn’t usually her type - he is a surfer nurse who has a side job of being a doula.
They begin as friends but they have a connection and underlying chemistry which eventuates into a slow burn romance.
Finn is always happy to please being the typical cinnamon-roll MMC and wants to support Olivia on her solo journey to motherhood but will Olivia allow him fully into her life?
Finn is also dealing with grief of his own and the medical diagnosis of cancer for his mother so we also get an insight into that part of his life.
This was a sweet story of healing, grief, hope, love, new friendships and support from family and friends.
Special shout out to Olivia’s rescue greyhound dog Hannah who was always ready for a cuddle.
Tropes:
🏄♂️ Male nurse/doula/surfer
👩⚕️ Slow burn
🏄♂️ Friends-to-Lovers
👩⚕️ Dating while pregnant (not the father)
🏄♂️ Cinnamon-roll MMC
👩⚕️ Grief/healing
🏄♂️ Rescue dog
This book interested me from the beginning because I’ve never really read about an IVF journey. I also loved the fact that it was based in Australia my home country.
Olivia is a psychologist who is tried of going on dates that lead nowhere and decides to start a family on her own through IVF.
At the beginning of her journey she meets Finn who isn’t usually her type - he is a surfer nurse who has a side job of being a doula.
They begin as friends but they have a connection and underlying chemistry which eventuates into a slow burn romance.
Finn is always happy to please being the typical cinnamon-roll MMC and wants to support Olivia on her solo journey to motherhood but will Olivia allow him fully into her life?
Finn is also dealing with grief of his own and the medical diagnosis of cancer for his mother so we also get an insight into that part of his life.
This was a sweet story of healing, grief, hope, love, new friendships and support from family and friends.
Special shout out to Olivia’s rescue greyhound dog Hannah who was always ready for a cuddle.
Review of advance copy received from Author
The Hannah Rule, written by April James, is a heartwarming romance. This is my first book by this author, and I totally jumped on board because there is a greyhound in the book! LOL!
The book follows Olivia and Finn. Olivia has given up on men and wasted time on ridiculous relationships that go nowhere. Olivia wants nothing more than to be a mom, so she decides to go at it alone using IVF and a donor. She unexpectedly meets a scruffy, surfer dude while waiting for a date to show up. He is nothing like anyone she has ever been attracted to. Over time, the two strike up a friendship, and the attraction grows, and Finn helps her let go of her overly organized life and her rigid rules.
This isn’t your typical romance - it has a lot of depth. It did stir up a lot of old emotions for me and my unsuccessful journey with IVF. In the end, it shattered my heart. I could relate to Olivia a lot through her frustrations, undying hope, and resilience. I wish I had someone as supportive as Finn by my side. This topic is challenging for many people, but I am so glad I read the book. Thank you, April.
Thanks to April James for gifting me an eARC of The Hannah Rule. I am leaving this review voluntarily. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
The book follows Olivia and Finn. Olivia has given up on men and wasted time on ridiculous relationships that go nowhere. Olivia wants nothing more than to be a mom, so she decides to go at it alone using IVF and a donor. She unexpectedly meets a scruffy, surfer dude while waiting for a date to show up. He is nothing like anyone she has ever been attracted to. Over time, the two strike up a friendship, and the attraction grows, and Finn helps her let go of her overly organized life and her rigid rules.
This isn’t your typical romance - it has a lot of depth. It did stir up a lot of old emotions for me and my unsuccessful journey with IVF. In the end, it shattered my heart. I could relate to Olivia a lot through her frustrations, undying hope, and resilience. I wish I had someone as supportive as Finn by my side. This topic is challenging for many people, but I am so glad I read the book. Thank you, April.
Thanks to April James for gifting me an eARC of The Hannah Rule. I am leaving this review voluntarily. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
December 4, 2025
I received a digital ARC, this is an honest review.
So, I’m a doula who went through IVF. Obviously, I had to read this book. And here’s the tl;dr version of my review: This author has such a fun, engaging writing style. I really enjoyed this book and I’m going to be watching this author very closely for more releases so I can read those too. Read it if you like straight forward, cute romance stories and independent female leads.
Now, here’s my longer, spoiler-free review:
I spent the first third of this book hating Olivia. She is one of the most snobbish, judgmental main characters I’ve ever read. I almost didn’t want to finish it I disliked her so much, because I am the kind of person she’d look down on for sure. But what kept me going was 1) the author’s writing style was so fun and inviting I couldn’t bring myself to stop and 2) she had these very human moments that kept me thinking “okay, maybe she’s not THAT bad” every time I was about to quit.
Finn, on the other hand? Loved him immediately. And because I loved him, I was able to slowly begin to enjoy Olivia. Seeing our female lead through the male lead’s eyes was a treat, and before I knew it I loved her too.
The birthing aspects of this book were honestly lighter than I was hoping for, which for a regular person is probably a good thing lol. As a birth worker I really wanted them to go deeper, but I totally get why the author chose not to and honestly it’s probably best for the flow of the story.
The fertility aspects of the book I found a bit more frustrating. Olivia’s journey with IUI had some inaccuracies that again, for the average layperson is truly not a big deal at all, but for me who’s done it all I raised an eyebrow once or twice. I felt the difficulties of IVF were a bit glossed over, not ignored but I didn’t feel Olivia’s experience as deeply as the way the author took us on her journey of falling in love. I would have liked a bit more exploration of what she felt, what those moments are like, as opposed to mostly just being told they happened. That being said, overall everything was pretty accurate and realistic.
I adored all the side characters in this one, which is great because the last few romance books I read the side characters felt so underbaked. The whole cast was delightful and I wasn’t glossing over their scenes waiting for the main couple like I often am with these kinds of books.
The ending was satisfying, adorable, and tidy. I do have one glaring thought in the back of my mind though, one I can’t share without spoiling something. So all I’ll say is that I’d be very interested in the review of other people who have been on the IVF journey, and also children who have been conceived the way Olivia chose to move forward.
I thought it would take me a while to read this book because I have a baby myself, and I finished it in barely a week because I couldn’t think of anything else when I had down time. I hope other doulas and other IVF graduates read this so I can talk about it with them, but it’s a worthwhile fun read for any romance lover who also cares about having children.
So, I’m a doula who went through IVF. Obviously, I had to read this book. And here’s the tl;dr version of my review: This author has such a fun, engaging writing style. I really enjoyed this book and I’m going to be watching this author very closely for more releases so I can read those too. Read it if you like straight forward, cute romance stories and independent female leads.
Now, here’s my longer, spoiler-free review:
I spent the first third of this book hating Olivia. She is one of the most snobbish, judgmental main characters I’ve ever read. I almost didn’t want to finish it I disliked her so much, because I am the kind of person she’d look down on for sure. But what kept me going was 1) the author’s writing style was so fun and inviting I couldn’t bring myself to stop and 2) she had these very human moments that kept me thinking “okay, maybe she’s not THAT bad” every time I was about to quit.
Finn, on the other hand? Loved him immediately. And because I loved him, I was able to slowly begin to enjoy Olivia. Seeing our female lead through the male lead’s eyes was a treat, and before I knew it I loved her too.
The birthing aspects of this book were honestly lighter than I was hoping for, which for a regular person is probably a good thing lol. As a birth worker I really wanted them to go deeper, but I totally get why the author chose not to and honestly it’s probably best for the flow of the story.
The fertility aspects of the book I found a bit more frustrating. Olivia’s journey with IUI had some inaccuracies that again, for the average layperson is truly not a big deal at all, but for me who’s done it all I raised an eyebrow once or twice. I felt the difficulties of IVF were a bit glossed over, not ignored but I didn’t feel Olivia’s experience as deeply as the way the author took us on her journey of falling in love. I would have liked a bit more exploration of what she felt, what those moments are like, as opposed to mostly just being told they happened. That being said, overall everything was pretty accurate and realistic.
I adored all the side characters in this one, which is great because the last few romance books I read the side characters felt so underbaked. The whole cast was delightful and I wasn’t glossing over their scenes waiting for the main couple like I often am with these kinds of books.
The ending was satisfying, adorable, and tidy. I do have one glaring thought in the back of my mind though, one I can’t share without spoiling something. So all I’ll say is that I’d be very interested in the review of other people who have been on the IVF journey, and also children who have been conceived the way Olivia chose to move forward.
I thought it would take me a while to read this book because I have a baby myself, and I finished it in barely a week because I couldn’t think of anything else when I had down time. I hope other doulas and other IVF graduates read this so I can talk about it with them, but it’s a worthwhile fun read for any romance lover who also cares about having children.
Read
November 25, 2025DNF @ 25%
This was my first ARC from this author, and the premise really did draw me in. A woman in her thirties choosing single motherhood and navigating all the emotional complexity that comes with it. I loved the Australian setting, and I could see what the story was reaching for in terms of theme.
But... I just couldn’t connect with Olivia or her emotional arc. Her decision to have a child felt more like pressure from circumstance than something rooted in deep personal longing, and because of that, I had a hard time understanding or caring about her choices. The writing also stayed pretty surface-level for me, so I never really felt inside the characters the way I’d hoped.
That said, this feels like a taste mismatch more than anything. I can see the intention here, and I think the right reader, especially someone who resonates with Olivia’s stage of life or inner landscape, will likely connect more deeply.
Grateful for the ARC opportunity. 💛
This was my first ARC from this author, and the premise really did draw me in. A woman in her thirties choosing single motherhood and navigating all the emotional complexity that comes with it. I loved the Australian setting, and I could see what the story was reaching for in terms of theme.
But... I just couldn’t connect with Olivia or her emotional arc. Her decision to have a child felt more like pressure from circumstance than something rooted in deep personal longing, and because of that, I had a hard time understanding or caring about her choices. The writing also stayed pretty surface-level for me, so I never really felt inside the characters the way I’d hoped.
That said, this feels like a taste mismatch more than anything. I can see the intention here, and I think the right reader, especially someone who resonates with Olivia’s stage of life or inner landscape, will likely connect more deeply.
Grateful for the ARC opportunity. 💛
November 21, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️🌶️
Tropes:
* Friends to Lovers
* Found Family
* Forced Proximity
*Ivf and fertility
* based in Australia
*Grief and Healing
Wow this book was absolutely incredible I was hooked from the get go right up until the end. I loved that the FMC Olivia was very relatable as she faced issues that a lot of women also face as well when it comes to fertility. I loved Olivia personality as well as how strong minded she was through out the whole book. The MMC Fin had a great personality as well as having the patience of a saint. The banter that fin and Olivia I loved it. I love seeing there relationship go from friends to lovers. The patience Fin had with Olivia while Olivia worked things out he never pushed her he just wanted to be there for her it was so sweet. These two were made for each other.
I received this book as an ARC in return for my honest review
🌶️🌶️
Tropes:
* Friends to Lovers
* Found Family
* Forced Proximity
*Ivf and fertility
* based in Australia
*Grief and Healing
Wow this book was absolutely incredible I was hooked from the get go right up until the end. I loved that the FMC Olivia was very relatable as she faced issues that a lot of women also face as well when it comes to fertility. I loved Olivia personality as well as how strong minded she was through out the whole book. The MMC Fin had a great personality as well as having the patience of a saint. The banter that fin and Olivia I loved it. I love seeing there relationship go from friends to lovers. The patience Fin had with Olivia while Olivia worked things out he never pushed her he just wanted to be there for her it was so sweet. These two were made for each other.
I received this book as an ARC in return for my honest review
November 30, 2025
Thankyou April for allowing me to read "The Hannah Rule". I found the story very beautifully written and their were parts of the plot that broke me emotionally with the MMC Finn's past history trauma.
Now, the story follows Olivia a psychologist who has had enough of relationships and she also wants a baby. Olivia decides to map out her choices and goes with a Fertility Clinic route. Olivia is a very regimented individual.
Now enter Finn a Surfer/Nurse who comes home to help his sick mum, meets Olivia, asks for her help and things develop from their without spoiling to much of the read.
I took away a strong message that sometimes life is so unpredictable and doesnt follow the rulebook so relax and enjoy every moment.
Everyone please read you will love this book!
Now, the story follows Olivia a psychologist who has had enough of relationships and she also wants a baby. Olivia decides to map out her choices and goes with a Fertility Clinic route. Olivia is a very regimented individual.
Now enter Finn a Surfer/Nurse who comes home to help his sick mum, meets Olivia, asks for her help and things develop from their without spoiling to much of the read.
I took away a strong message that sometimes life is so unpredictable and doesnt follow the rulebook so relax and enjoy every moment.
Everyone please read you will love this book!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 20, 2025
3.5/5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️✨ (rounding up to 4 on Goodreads because it deserves more than a 3)
The Hannah Rule was a sloooooow burn—almost infuriatingly so at times—but still a story I’m glad I read. While the pacing tested my patience, the emotional payoff and character work made it worthwhile.
I loved the MMC from the very beginning. A barefoot surfer nurse turned doula? Honestly, what’s not to love. He brought such warmth and a grounded energy to the story.
April James also did a wonderful job handling some very sensitive topics, including IVF and solo parenting, with care and respect. Overall it was a nice read, always refreshing reading a book based in Australia.
Thanks for the ARC April James.
The Hannah Rule was a sloooooow burn—almost infuriatingly so at times—but still a story I’m glad I read. While the pacing tested my patience, the emotional payoff and character work made it worthwhile.
I loved the MMC from the very beginning. A barefoot surfer nurse turned doula? Honestly, what’s not to love. He brought such warmth and a grounded energy to the story.
April James also did a wonderful job handling some very sensitive topics, including IVF and solo parenting, with care and respect. Overall it was a nice read, always refreshing reading a book based in Australia.
Thanks for the ARC April James.
December 1, 2025
An ok story about a woman who doesn’t have any character growth in the book.
Sad about the self centred nature of the characters, other than a mum facing health battles, which meant the conclusion was only going to be satisfaction, not growth and development.
Some lovely aspects of the setting and the way his job is described. And the writer has a maturity in form, but sadly not in character.
I also didn’t appreciate the spice. It pulled the tone of the book down, out of exploring the lives and thoughts of the main characters. It wasn’t in the description given, including not in the content info that seemed comprehensive and helpful.
Sad about the self centred nature of the characters, other than a mum facing health battles, which meant the conclusion was only going to be satisfaction, not growth and development.
Some lovely aspects of the setting and the way his job is described. And the writer has a maturity in form, but sadly not in character.
I also didn’t appreciate the spice. It pulled the tone of the book down, out of exploring the lives and thoughts of the main characters. It wasn’t in the description given, including not in the content info that seemed comprehensive and helpful.
December 18, 2025
I absolutely loved this book! I laughed, I cried, I was thoroughly drawn into the story and couldn’t stop thinking about the characters even after I finished it!
I loved all the relationships in the book, not just the main romantic one. It is a great romance novel with depth to the storyline. I found the medical components to be very well researched and accurate which I really appreciated, and while I don’t know much about an IVF journey or psychology those aspects appeared very well done too.
It was a very enjoyable read and I definitely recommend it!
I loved all the relationships in the book, not just the main romantic one. It is a great romance novel with depth to the storyline. I found the medical components to be very well researched and accurate which I really appreciated, and while I don’t know much about an IVF journey or psychology those aspects appeared very well done too.
It was a very enjoyable read and I definitely recommend it!
November 30, 2025
Was given a digital ARC to give my honest opinion.
Let me simply say this was the BEST first works from an author I’ve ever read. I adored each character and found myself giggling out loud multiple times. I loved the banter and witty conversations between specifically Brooke and Olivia. Easy to follow and was a real page turner.
Lovely book April! Let us know when you write your next one. I’ll be the first in line to read it!
Let me simply say this was the BEST first works from an author I’ve ever read. I adored each character and found myself giggling out loud multiple times. I loved the banter and witty conversations between specifically Brooke and Olivia. Easy to follow and was a real page turner.
Lovely book April! Let us know when you write your next one. I’ll be the first in line to read it!
December 8, 2025
ARC Reader Confessional – The Hannah Rule
The Hannah Rule hit me with an emotional punch I wasn’t expecting. April James brings a rawness to this story — the kind that pulls you straight into the characters’ inner worlds and makes their struggles feel personal. The chemistry here isn’t just surface-level; it simmers, builds, and hits with a quiet force that kept me locked in.
Hannah’s journey is messy, vulnerable, and deeply human, and the way the romance unfolds has this intense, slow-burning energy that I really loved. Their dynamic is charged in a way that feels both tender and gripping, and when the emotional moments land, they land hard.
There were a few places where I wanted just a bit more depth or development, but even with that, the story held me from start to finish. It’s heartfelt, powerful, and full of moments that linger long after you close the book.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The Hannah Rule hit me with an emotional punch I wasn’t expecting. April James brings a rawness to this story — the kind that pulls you straight into the characters’ inner worlds and makes their struggles feel personal. The chemistry here isn’t just surface-level; it simmers, builds, and hits with a quiet force that kept me locked in.
Hannah’s journey is messy, vulnerable, and deeply human, and the way the romance unfolds has this intense, slow-burning energy that I really loved. Their dynamic is charged in a way that feels both tender and gripping, and when the emotional moments land, they land hard.
There were a few places where I wanted just a bit more depth or development, but even with that, the story held me from start to finish. It’s heartfelt, powerful, and full of moments that linger long after you close the book.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
December 5, 2025
This book has completely blown me out of the water and im obsessed I wish there was so much more to this story because im addicted. I loved reading an Aussie setting and these characters were so relateable and also so genuine and charming. Don't even get me started on the incredible tension the two main characters had it was epic ! Every aspect of this book just made my heart happy and i immediately want to read it all over again
December 13, 2025
I really enjoyed this book. As an Australian, it was wonderful to read a book set here. I enjoyed getting to know the characters and learning more about their lives and back stories. The FMC annoyed me at times, but that's a sign to me that I'm into the book and getting closer to the characters.
I thought the ending was very well done. The author made some great choices and paced it well.
I highly recommend this book for romance lovers who enjoy something a little bit different.
I thought the ending was very well done. The author made some great choices and paced it well.
I highly recommend this book for romance lovers who enjoy something a little bit different.
November 29, 2025
So glad I gor to be an arc reader for this book! As soon as I starter I couldn’t pur it down! A type A and an apparent “go with the flow” type with chemistry at first meet both so real and well written that you’ll fall in love with them too. Not the typical romance trope kind of love story, but really heartwarming and lovely. Highly reccomended!
Review of advance copy received from Author
I really enjoyed this book. It had such a good strong fmc. This is definitely a slow burn. Then while there may be a bit of spice it is not descriptive, so perfect for those who do not like that sort of spice. I love the fact that nothing gets in Olivia's path except maybe Finn. he was meant for her..
January 15, 2026
A good mix of entertaining and well researched storytelling. April’s insight into modern life takes the reader on a journey while using correct terminology which still flows. Unexpected events keep the pages turning. I am familiar with the places so it was like meeting an old friend at home. Well written April and a pleasure to read. Brilliant ending. Is there more?
November 22, 2025
All I can say is wow! I was hooked on every page and absolutely could not put this down. What an incredible journey captured through a very well written story. Well done April, 100% would recommend to everybody to read. Thank you for the opportunity to read and review
December 4, 2025
what a great book!! As someone who went through IVF, I was pleasantly suprised of how well the author did her research on fertility treatments, it made the book so much better to have accurate information. Definitely recommend!
December 15, 2025
I was unable to put this book down. It was quirky and a bit different to your usual couple meet and fall in love story with a few curve balls. It delicately discussed different matters like suicide and being a solo Mum via IVF. I loved it.
December 5, 2025
Loved this book and I couldn't put it down. I sad to say goodbye to Finn and Olivia when I did finish it! Short, easy read that was beautifully written.
December 13, 2025
Loved the characters and the story. Fast pacing, kept me hooked!
December 18, 2025
This was a lovely, gentle romance. Although I think Olivia was pretty quick to want to break things off whenever the going got rough (as she's a psychologist, my mistake was in expecting her to be more introspective and patient), there was never any doubt that she'd end up with Finn. Their attraction to each other never wavered.
Finn is what my mom would've called "a catch" - endlessly patient, handsome, a caregiver to everyone (a nurse by profession, too), always says the right thing and never loses his temper. Too good to be true, maybe.
Because it was the title of the book, I wish the Hannah Rule had been given a little more importance (no spoiler, sorry!).
As to the most (in my opinion) important plotline, Olivia's path to becoming a mother by artificial insemination, I thought all of the proper steps and emotions were there. Everyone's choices and experiences with fertility treatments are different but as Olivia reflected, "The hormones and injections, the waiting, the hope that rearranges your insides, the grief when it doesn't take, the quiet, astonishing joy when it does.", this is the same for everyone. April James has definitely done the research and Olivia's thoughts and feelings throughout the process of choosing to become a single mother ring true. Finn this time: "Brave isn't the right word. It's clear-eyed. You saw what you wanted, and you stopped waiting for someone else to hand it to you."
[Thank you to the author for the ARC]
Finn is what my mom would've called "a catch" - endlessly patient, handsome, a caregiver to everyone (a nurse by profession, too), always says the right thing and never loses his temper. Too good to be true, maybe.
Because it was the title of the book, I wish the Hannah Rule had been given a little more importance (no spoiler, sorry!).
As to the most (in my opinion) important plotline, Olivia's path to becoming a mother by artificial insemination, I thought all of the proper steps and emotions were there. Everyone's choices and experiences with fertility treatments are different but as Olivia reflected, "The hormones and injections, the waiting, the hope that rearranges your insides, the grief when it doesn't take, the quiet, astonishing joy when it does.", this is the same for everyone. April James has definitely done the research and Olivia's thoughts and feelings throughout the process of choosing to become a single mother ring true. Finn this time: "Brave isn't the right word. It's clear-eyed. You saw what you wanted, and you stopped waiting for someone else to hand it to you."
[Thank you to the author for the ARC]
November 15, 2025
A buttoned up psychologist meets a surfer/nurse - this warm romance contains deeply emotional topics and realistically flawed characters, great pacing, fun moments, and strong writing. My favorite characters are the adopted greyhounds, but I loved all the characters and could not put the book down!
(I received an advance copy; this is my honest review.)
(I received an advance copy; this is my honest review.)
December 12, 2025
Thank you April James for the chance to read this incredibly sweet ARC book. An amazingly adorable opposites attract romance, this friends to lovers story is perfect for anyone who enjoys likeable characters, excellent back stories, and a greyhound who really steals the show- a great all rounder book to escape from reality!!! 4⭐️
Tropes
- She’s having a baby on her own
- Opposites attract
- Friends to lovers
- Instant attraction
- He falls first
- He falls harder
- Slowburn
Spice level- 1.7/5🌶️
Tropes
- She’s having a baby on her own
- Opposites attract
- Friends to lovers
- Instant attraction
- He falls first
- He falls harder
- Slowburn
Spice level- 1.7/5🌶️
Displaying 1 - 29 of 29 reviews