One thing about Riley Sager novels is that each is going to have it's entirely own feel. It is the best thing about reading a book by him. Nowadays, each book by an author feels the same with only slight differences. The Unknown cannot really be compared to his other works, and that is the best compliment.
I am a supernatural media hater, usually. However, I actually really enjoyed the supernatural elements in this book. It was done so well, and I was never annoyed by it as I previously had been.
The premise is very interesting, and it will make you want to read from the first chapter. Five women disappearing from an island twice?? You want to know what is going to happen/leads up to the events. Getting both the present-day portion and the 1926 piece of the story was great. You were able to slowly piece parts together, and it broke up the repetitiveness a bit.
This book is not rated any higher because the first half did feel sort of slow. I was not completely engrossed in that portion as I would have wanted to be in a mystery thriller. It definitely picked up in the second half.
Thank you NetGalley, Dutton, & Riley Sager for an ARC in exchange for an honest review. The Unknown is released on August 4, 2026!