The murder of a young Pueblo Indian woman sets the stage for a novel which flip-flops between the points of view of Bernadette's younger sister and the white woman for whom Bernadette kept house
When I was looking for a novel I chose a mystery, so I'd have a mystery read in December for the mystery club that I participate in.
I learned about Apache and Navajo beliefs and practices from this book. Bernadette Lefthand and her family are Apache. I wondered about the origin of the Lefthand surname. Perhaps the first Lefthand had a dominant left hand.
A Navajo hand trembler makes an appearance toward the end of the narrative. I was fascinated by the phenomenon so I did some research, and learned some additional background for hand trembling.
I did find the mystery aspect predictable though the resolution was dramatically intense and quite tragic.
This book was especially interesting to me because it closely related to several things I'd recently learned about Native American beliefs through both an art history class as well as a world music class. I did find the voice of the 16-year-old (Gracie) to be a bit annoying after awhile, even though I can understand why it was used in the way it was. In all, a very interesting read.
When I read on the back cover that Louis Owens considered the book an announcement of the "emergence of a major new Native American novelist," I was sold. It was an interesting intellectual exercise to read about Navajo witchcraft from a 15-year-old Apache girl's perspective invented by a Choctaw author. I think it takes a certain talent to talk about how white, Apache, Hopi, and Navajo people can believe different and/or similar things depending on the individuals involved and the situations that present themselves and that Querry does a decent job of tackling these conversations in layman's terms, although I was always kind of hoping for wittier characters. I found the juxtaposition between innocent ignorance and plotting evil to be quite delicious, although the pacing of the plot left something to be desired.