What do you think?
Rate this book
Chestnuts: A Why Choose Romantic Comedy
Four hearts. One messy, beautiful chance at forever.
Noah Kelly thought Henry was the love of his life, but after a night of sharing his boyfriend with his best friend, Meghan, he discovers his heart is big enough for two. Though their relationship might be unconventional, the three of them find something Noah had only read about in books—real love. Still, even the happiest of hearts can ache for something more.
***
Owning two thriving restaurants and loved by two incredible men, Meghan James believes she has it all. Until Dean Thomas skates into her life. Each time the cocky hockey team owner comes to town, his visit always ends with asking Meghan on a date. When she finally gives in, it’s a little too easy falling under Dean’s spell. Despite Henry and Noah encouraging her to pursue something real with Dean, juggling her new relationship with the one she already treasures turns out to be more complicated than she anticipated. The only thing she knows for sure is loving the three of them completes her.
***
When Henry Adams lands his dream gig touring as a drummer for one of his favorite bands, he never imagined his passion for music would pull him away from the people he loves most. The distance tests them all, and forces him to question how much longer he can survive without Meghan and Noah. Giving up his dream doesn’t feel like an option, but big decisions will need to be made to ensure everyone’s happiness—especially his own.
***
Dean Thomas always gets what he wants, so it’s no surprise when he falls hard and fast for Meghan, he’s willing to do whatever it takes to make their relationship work. That is until he discovers she’s in love with two other men, turning his world upside down. He’s never been one to share, but if Dean can let go of old ideas about love, he won’t just gain a partner… he’ll gain a family.
Chestnuts is a deliciously spicy MMFM romantic comedy intended for mature audiences.
Noah Kelly thought Henry was the love of his life, but after a night of sharing his boyfriend with his best friend, Meghan, he discovers his heart is big enough for two. Though their relationship might be unconventional, the three of them find something Noah had only read about in books—real love. Still, even the happiest of hearts can ache for something more.
***
Owning two thriving restaurants and loved by two incredible men, Meghan James believes she has it all. Until Dean Thomas skates into her life. Each time the cocky hockey team owner comes to town, his visit always ends with asking Meghan on a date. When she finally gives in, it’s a little too easy falling under Dean’s spell. Despite Henry and Noah encouraging her to pursue something real with Dean, juggling her new relationship with the one she already treasures turns out to be more complicated than she anticipated. The only thing she knows for sure is loving the three of them completes her.
***
When Henry Adams lands his dream gig touring as a drummer for one of his favorite bands, he never imagined his passion for music would pull him away from the people he loves most. The distance tests them all, and forces him to question how much longer he can survive without Meghan and Noah. Giving up his dream doesn’t feel like an option, but big decisions will need to be made to ensure everyone’s happiness—especially his own.
***
Dean Thomas always gets what he wants, so it’s no surprise when he falls hard and fast for Meghan, he’s willing to do whatever it takes to make their relationship work. That is until he discovers she’s in love with two other men, turning his world upside down. He’s never been one to share, but if Dean can let go of old ideas about love, he won’t just gain a partner… he’ll gain a family.
Chestnuts is a deliciously spicy MMFM romantic comedy intended for mature audiences.
320 pages, Paperback
Published November 9, 2025
6 people are currently reading
17 people want to read
About the author
Irene Bahrd
53 books186 followersIrene Bahrd is a feisty Capricorn and one of the most avid readers you will ever meet. Her favorite genres to read or write include romantic comedies, political romance, romantasy, and the occasional contemporary dark romance.
She started her writing journey as a dare from a friend, after recounting dating stories from her early twenties. They inspired her to write spicy romantic comedies and parodies that feature a variety of book boyfriends—though most are cinnamon roll golden retrievers. Many of her stories contain LGBTQIA+, disabled, and neurodivergent characters.
Irene can be found on Instagram and TikTok under @irenebahrdauthor
She started her writing journey as a dare from a friend, after recounting dating stories from her early twenties. They inspired her to write spicy romantic comedies and parodies that feature a variety of book boyfriends—though most are cinnamon roll golden retrievers. Many of her stories contain LGBTQIA+, disabled, and neurodivergent characters.
Irene can be found on Instagram and TikTok under @irenebahrdauthor
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 54 reviews
December 6, 2025
I...didn't love this one. I've sat on it for a few days and I'm still not sure I can quite articulate why exactly. I guess, mainly, it was not what I was expecting. I was expecting a funny, why choose romance based on the tagline and it was, well, neither. I wouldn't label this a romcom by any means, I don't think I came even close to finding something humorous once. And, it's not that it's not why choose but...I don't know. It says it's MMFM and, I guess technically it is? I think it would be better described as MMF + FM. The boyfriends have a girlfriend and the same girlfriend has a boyfriend but they remain separate relationships. I think the openness and desire for the partner to be happy, even if some of that happiness is found outside of the relationship, was a beautiful sentiment but it didn't connect enough with me. I didn't find much depth in the FMC (or any of the characters really) so I struggled to connect with her relationships with the three guys. I think there was a lot of telling versus showing which contributed to my disconnect.
I listened to the audio of this and, while I didn't love the story, the narrators all did well. I probably would have tapped out if it weren't for the narration.
Thanks to Luna Literary, High Gravity Productions, and the author for the ALC opportunity.
I listened to the audio of this and, while I didn't love the story, the narrators all did well. I probably would have tapped out if it weren't for the narration.
Thanks to Luna Literary, High Gravity Productions, and the author for the ALC opportunity.
December 6, 2025
3.5 ⭐️ rounded up.
I listened to the audiobook version of this story and I have a lot of mixed feelings about it. The story had great moments, especially those between Henry, Noah, and Meghan. They felt right together and I loved how understanding Henry and Noah were of Meghan, and Dean, both together and individually. The story also had some great spice that had me begging for more. That being said, whenever Meghan was with Dean, it truly felt like she wanted him to think she and the guys were just roommates, like she wanted to hide their relationship from him. Dean just didn't do it for me. His whole attitude felt wrong and him not wanting to be with them while they were all together didn't do it for me. I get poly-relationships are complicated and not straightforward at all, but it just didn't feel right to me. Although the male narrators did a good job, a lot of times it felt like acting more than natural conversation. That being said, Stephanie Rose did a phenomenal job with Meghan's character. All in all it's an enjoyable story, especially for those who like less of the "everyone is with everyone" kind of why choose stories.
I listened to the audiobook version of this story and I have a lot of mixed feelings about it. The story had great moments, especially those between Henry, Noah, and Meghan. They felt right together and I loved how understanding Henry and Noah were of Meghan, and Dean, both together and individually. The story also had some great spice that had me begging for more. That being said, whenever Meghan was with Dean, it truly felt like she wanted him to think she and the guys were just roommates, like she wanted to hide their relationship from him. Dean just didn't do it for me. His whole attitude felt wrong and him not wanting to be with them while they were all together didn't do it for me. I get poly-relationships are complicated and not straightforward at all, but it just didn't feel right to me. Although the male narrators did a good job, a lot of times it felt like acting more than natural conversation. That being said, Stephanie Rose did a phenomenal job with Meghan's character. All in all it's an enjoyable story, especially for those who like less of the "everyone is with everyone" kind of why choose stories.
December 10, 2025
A multiple-POV MMFM romantic comedy, performed by dual narration with Stephanie Rose, Lance West, Simon Dornet, and Brandon Francis. Noah owns a bookstore and is in a happy relationship with Henry, the drummer for a famous band. Meghan owns two restaurants and joins Henry and Noah in a throuple. But then things get really interesting when Dean, the owner of a hockey team, falls for Meghan.
This was a quick, fun and spicy listen with some fabulous, lovable characters and fantastic narration. One of the best parts of the book was the banter between Meghan and Dean.
Huge thanks to High Gravity Productions and Irene Bahrd for the ALC copy!
This was a quick, fun and spicy listen with some fabulous, lovable characters and fantastic narration. One of the best parts of the book was the banter between Meghan and Dean.
Huge thanks to High Gravity Productions and Irene Bahrd for the ALC copy!
November 4, 2025
Arc Review
4🌟
4🌶️
What to Expect :
❤️Why choose
❤️Friends to Lovers
❤️Spicy
This is my First time reading anything by Irene and it won't be my last.
I was hooked from the very first page until the end
It was such a fun and quick read.
The chemistry between them was spicy and hot
I love why choose romance and this being a rom com was Awsome to read
Thankyou for allowing me to be an arc reader
4🌟
4🌶️
What to Expect :
❤️Why choose
❤️Friends to Lovers
❤️Spicy
This is my First time reading anything by Irene and it won't be my last.
I was hooked from the very first page until the end
It was such a fun and quick read.
The chemistry between them was spicy and hot
I love why choose romance and this being a rom com was Awsome to read
Thankyou for allowing me to be an arc reader
November 16, 2025
Rating ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Noah and Henry invite Meghan to join their relationship they had no idea how well she would fit. But something seems to be missing still. When Dean pursues Meghan both guys encourage her to follow her heart.
But Dean thought an eggs was joking when she said she had 2 boyfriends and he hates liars. When he finds out the truth will it break them?
#chestnuts #irenebahrdauthor #whychoose #bookboyfriendsdoitbetter #idratherbereading #risareads221 #risareads221reviews
Noah and Henry invite Meghan to join their relationship they had no idea how well she would fit. But something seems to be missing still. When Dean pursues Meghan both guys encourage her to follow her heart.
But Dean thought an eggs was joking when she said she had 2 boyfriends and he hates liars. When he finds out the truth will it break them?
#chestnuts #irenebahrdauthor #whychoose #bookboyfriendsdoitbetter #idratherbereading #risareads221 #risareads221reviews
November 20, 2025
Not bad! A lot of spicy scenes and also sport talk
Not your usual MMFM where all three guys are with the female.
- MMFM
- found family
- friends to lovers
- insta love
Not your usual MMFM where all three guys are with the female.
- MMFM
- found family
- friends to lovers
- insta love
December 3, 2025
💫🔥 Four hearts discovering that love doesn’t divide — it multiplies when you let it. 🔥💫
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ (4/5)
Spice-meter: 🌶️🌶️🌶️☆☆ (3/5)
Audiobook: 🎧 Duet
📚 Standalone
Chestnuts is a lively, tender, and surprisingly thoughtful why-choose romance that blends humor, heat, and emotional depth without ever tipping into chaos for chaos’ sake. It follows Meghan, a woman thriving in her career and relationships, and the three men who love her Noah, the steady heart; Henry, the passionate dreamer; and Dean, the unexpected spark who pushes their world open just wide enough to let love evolve.
Instead of leaning on shock value or relentless steam, Irene Bahrd builds a story about connection, trust, and the courage it takes to expand your definition of love. The pacing is quick but intentional, balancing spice with sincerity. With multiple POVs and a multi-year timeline, the narrative explores longing, distance, reconnection, and the delicate art of choosing each other, not just once, but over and over again.
It’s not a story about replacing anyone or fixing what’s broken. It’s about making space, honoring emotional truth, and recognizing that sometimes the heart wants more because it finally feels safe enough to ask.
The Story
Meghan lives a full, content life running two successful restaurants and loving Noah and Henry with her whole heart. Their triad works stable, warm, intimate until the universe throws Dean Thomas into her orbit. Cocky, charming, relentlessly persistent, Dean brings an energy that unsettles her in all the right ways. What begins as harmless flirtation soon becomes undeniable connection.
Noah and Henry, instead of reacting with fear or possessiveness, support Meghan’s journey even when it challenges the balance they’ve built. Their love for her is wide, not fragile, and that foundation gives the story genuine emotional weight.
Henry’s tour with a band adds strain and distance, forcing him to question what it means to chase a dream while missing the people who make him whole. Noah’s steady presence grounds the group, while Dean’s entrance complicates and enriches everything at once.
Across time jumps, shifting dynamics, and big emotional choices, the story asks:
How do you protect what you have while making room for what you didn’t see coming?
The result is a warm, spicy, and surprisingly heartfelt poly romance that treats every character with respect and emotional depth.
🎧 Narration
Narrated by Stephanie Rose, Brandon Francis, and Simon Dornet, the audiobook is a standout. Each narrator brings clarity, warmth, and personality to their roles, grounding the emotional shifts while giving the spicier moments the confidence they deserve.
Stephanie brings Meghan’s wit, vulnerability, and strength to life.
Brandon and Simon handle the male POVs with nuance never exaggerated, never flat, always emotionally aligned with the scene.
The duet format works especially well here, creating a smooth dynamic that keeps the multi-POV structure easy to follow and engaging.
What I Loved
✔️ A beginner-friendly why-choose romance with real heart
✔️ Spice that enhances the story instead of overwhelming it
✔️ Multiple POVs that feel balanced and purposeful
✔️ Narration that elevates emotion and chemistry
✔️ Honest exploration of distance, dreams, and evolving love
✔️ A surprisingly tender approach to poly dynamics
✔️ A fast pace without sacrificing plot
Tropes & Vibes
✔️ Why-Choose
✔️ Poly Romance / Sharing
✔️ Found Family
✔️ Established Relationship Expanding
✔️ Multi-Year Timeline
✔️ Medium Spice (not constant)
✔️ Light Angst + High Heart
✔️ Minimal Group Scenes
✔️ Character-Driven with Humor
Final Thoughts
Chestnuts is a fun, fast, and emotionally grounded poly romance that balances spice with sincerity. While the novella length brings a touch of insta-love and a few time jumps that skim deeper emotional layers, the story still delivers a warm, charming, and refreshingly human journey.
For readers curious about why-choose romances or anyone craving a lighthearted, spicy story with a beating heart at its center this is an ideal pick. It proves that love doesn’t get messier when it grows; it simply becomes more honest. And sometimes, more people means more strength, more joy, and more reasons to stay.
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ (4/5)
Spice-meter: 🌶️🌶️🌶️☆☆ (3/5)
Audiobook: 🎧 Duet
📚 Standalone
Chestnuts is a lively, tender, and surprisingly thoughtful why-choose romance that blends humor, heat, and emotional depth without ever tipping into chaos for chaos’ sake. It follows Meghan, a woman thriving in her career and relationships, and the three men who love her Noah, the steady heart; Henry, the passionate dreamer; and Dean, the unexpected spark who pushes their world open just wide enough to let love evolve.
Instead of leaning on shock value or relentless steam, Irene Bahrd builds a story about connection, trust, and the courage it takes to expand your definition of love. The pacing is quick but intentional, balancing spice with sincerity. With multiple POVs and a multi-year timeline, the narrative explores longing, distance, reconnection, and the delicate art of choosing each other, not just once, but over and over again.
It’s not a story about replacing anyone or fixing what’s broken. It’s about making space, honoring emotional truth, and recognizing that sometimes the heart wants more because it finally feels safe enough to ask.
The Story
Meghan lives a full, content life running two successful restaurants and loving Noah and Henry with her whole heart. Their triad works stable, warm, intimate until the universe throws Dean Thomas into her orbit. Cocky, charming, relentlessly persistent, Dean brings an energy that unsettles her in all the right ways. What begins as harmless flirtation soon becomes undeniable connection.
Noah and Henry, instead of reacting with fear or possessiveness, support Meghan’s journey even when it challenges the balance they’ve built. Their love for her is wide, not fragile, and that foundation gives the story genuine emotional weight.
Henry’s tour with a band adds strain and distance, forcing him to question what it means to chase a dream while missing the people who make him whole. Noah’s steady presence grounds the group, while Dean’s entrance complicates and enriches everything at once.
Across time jumps, shifting dynamics, and big emotional choices, the story asks:
How do you protect what you have while making room for what you didn’t see coming?
The result is a warm, spicy, and surprisingly heartfelt poly romance that treats every character with respect and emotional depth.
🎧 Narration
Narrated by Stephanie Rose, Brandon Francis, and Simon Dornet, the audiobook is a standout. Each narrator brings clarity, warmth, and personality to their roles, grounding the emotional shifts while giving the spicier moments the confidence they deserve.
Stephanie brings Meghan’s wit, vulnerability, and strength to life.
Brandon and Simon handle the male POVs with nuance never exaggerated, never flat, always emotionally aligned with the scene.
The duet format works especially well here, creating a smooth dynamic that keeps the multi-POV structure easy to follow and engaging.
What I Loved
✔️ A beginner-friendly why-choose romance with real heart
✔️ Spice that enhances the story instead of overwhelming it
✔️ Multiple POVs that feel balanced and purposeful
✔️ Narration that elevates emotion and chemistry
✔️ Honest exploration of distance, dreams, and evolving love
✔️ A surprisingly tender approach to poly dynamics
✔️ A fast pace without sacrificing plot
Tropes & Vibes
✔️ Why-Choose
✔️ Poly Romance / Sharing
✔️ Found Family
✔️ Established Relationship Expanding
✔️ Multi-Year Timeline
✔️ Medium Spice (not constant)
✔️ Light Angst + High Heart
✔️ Minimal Group Scenes
✔️ Character-Driven with Humor
Final Thoughts
Chestnuts is a fun, fast, and emotionally grounded poly romance that balances spice with sincerity. While the novella length brings a touch of insta-love and a few time jumps that skim deeper emotional layers, the story still delivers a warm, charming, and refreshingly human journey.
For readers curious about why-choose romances or anyone craving a lighthearted, spicy story with a beating heart at its center this is an ideal pick. It proves that love doesn’t get messier when it grows; it simply becomes more honest. And sometimes, more people means more strength, more joy, and more reasons to stay.
December 14, 2025
Chestnuts by Irene Bahrd, narrated by the talented ensemble of Stephanie Rose, Lance West, Simon Dornet, and Brandon Francis, is a beautifully layered and emotionally charged romance that dives deep into love, loyalty, and the complexities of the poly lifestyle. This "why choose" standalone is an excellent introduction for readers new to the trope, offering a story that is spicy yet balanced with a well-developed plot.
The narrative centers on Meghan, who is invited by Noah and Henry to join their established relationship. Though the initial throuple dynamic quickly clicks, bringing Meghan into a life where she is loved by two incredible men, something still feels incomplete. Noah and Henry, the stable, intimate, and often scene-stealing duo, genuinely love each other in every way, and they only want Meghan's ultimate happiness.
Their existing bond is soon tested by the arrival of Dean Thomas, a cocky hockey team owner and the story's wildcard. Dean aggressively pursues Meghan, and both Noah and Henry encourage her to follow her heart with him, believing he might be the missing piece. Dean beautifully clicks into place for Meghan, completing her. However, Dean is initially unaware of her existing two boyfriends, believing she was joking—a problem since he hates liars. When he discovers the truth, the core tension is whether his traditional views on love can stretch to embrace an unconventional family, letting go of old ideas to gain a partner and a family.
Irene Bahrd does a great job of showing how, in this MMFM romance, the addition of more people to the equation, while potentially messy, is made almost seamless by the characters' honesty and loving commitment to one another. Each character brings unique wants and needs, resulting in relationships that are all distinct and different, yet emotionally charged and balanced. The relationships between Meg and Noah, Meg and Henry, and Noah and Henry are all well-established before Dean is introduced, a fact that sometimes creates a subtle division between the throuple and Dean.
The audiobook narration, featuring the brilliant performances of the ensemble cast, is a must-listen, perfectly capturing the depth of the characters. While the story delivers medium spice and avoids being gratuitously packed with group activities or spice on every other page, it has a solid plot.
My main critique is the pacing: I wished the reader was given a little more backstory on the initial relationships. Also, the timeline felt rushed towards the end, jumping quickly from Spring to December and then two years later. While the author perfectly captures the essence of this complex, found family dynamic, I wanted to see the natural growth of all four relationships during those time gaps.
Chestnuts is a heartfelt exploration of love in all its forms—messy, passionate, and profoundly real. It’s a rewarding read that challenges convention, showing that four hearts can find one messy, beautiful chance at forever. Though not a holiday book, the festive season is sprinkled into the background. For readers who crave romance that celebrates connection, trust, and the courage to love freely, this story is a perfect match. I hope to see future stories exploring this wonderful found family as they continue to grow through the years.
Disclaimer: I received an advanced review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The narrative centers on Meghan, who is invited by Noah and Henry to join their established relationship. Though the initial throuple dynamic quickly clicks, bringing Meghan into a life where she is loved by two incredible men, something still feels incomplete. Noah and Henry, the stable, intimate, and often scene-stealing duo, genuinely love each other in every way, and they only want Meghan's ultimate happiness.
Their existing bond is soon tested by the arrival of Dean Thomas, a cocky hockey team owner and the story's wildcard. Dean aggressively pursues Meghan, and both Noah and Henry encourage her to follow her heart with him, believing he might be the missing piece. Dean beautifully clicks into place for Meghan, completing her. However, Dean is initially unaware of her existing two boyfriends, believing she was joking—a problem since he hates liars. When he discovers the truth, the core tension is whether his traditional views on love can stretch to embrace an unconventional family, letting go of old ideas to gain a partner and a family.
Irene Bahrd does a great job of showing how, in this MMFM romance, the addition of more people to the equation, while potentially messy, is made almost seamless by the characters' honesty and loving commitment to one another. Each character brings unique wants and needs, resulting in relationships that are all distinct and different, yet emotionally charged and balanced. The relationships between Meg and Noah, Meg and Henry, and Noah and Henry are all well-established before Dean is introduced, a fact that sometimes creates a subtle division between the throuple and Dean.
The audiobook narration, featuring the brilliant performances of the ensemble cast, is a must-listen, perfectly capturing the depth of the characters. While the story delivers medium spice and avoids being gratuitously packed with group activities or spice on every other page, it has a solid plot.
My main critique is the pacing: I wished the reader was given a little more backstory on the initial relationships. Also, the timeline felt rushed towards the end, jumping quickly from Spring to December and then two years later. While the author perfectly captures the essence of this complex, found family dynamic, I wanted to see the natural growth of all four relationships during those time gaps.
Chestnuts is a heartfelt exploration of love in all its forms—messy, passionate, and profoundly real. It’s a rewarding read that challenges convention, showing that four hearts can find one messy, beautiful chance at forever. Though not a holiday book, the festive season is sprinkled into the background. For readers who crave romance that celebrates connection, trust, and the courage to love freely, this story is a perfect match. I hope to see future stories exploring this wonderful found family as they continue to grow through the years.
Disclaimer: I received an advanced review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
November 20, 2025
Thank you to Irene Bahrd and Luna Literary for the opportunity to read Chestnuts as an ARC. This is the first book I have read written by this author. She has a long backlist that I am going to jump into. This is a standalone read and is a perfect "beginner" if you are entering into the why choose or sharing tropes. It was an easy read and the characters are well developed. This book is spicy, but not too spicy. If you are looking for medium spice this is the one for you. There are not too many group activities.
Each character brings their own wants and needs to the complexity of this why choose romance novel. Meg is the lucky lady who gets loved by three men. The relationships are all unique and different from each other. Henry and Noah also love each other in all ways. In my opinion, this duo stole the show at times. They are emotional, intimate, and a stable force. Dean is the wildcard and gets thrown into the mix well after the relationship between Meg and Noah, Meg and Henry, and Noah and Henry are well established. He is the piece that was missing for Meghan and he clicked into place beautifully. Noah and Henry just want Meghan to be happy. I do wish that the reader was given a little more backstory on how everyone came to be.
Things can get messy really quickly the more people you add the equation. These characters were honest and loving to one another, which made the addition almost seamless. That being said, I did feel the division between the throuple and Dean at times. I am used to reading more sharing type why choose books. It doesn't negate the fact that the story is balanced and emotionally charged. Also, the timeline seemed rushed a bit towards the end. For example, in one chapter it is Spring and the next it is December, then the next chapter it was two years later. I wanted to see all of the relationships grown in between those time gaps.
This book has an actual plot and is not full of spice on every other page. So, if that is your jam, then this is a perfect read for you. I would not call this a holiday book but the holidays are sprinkled in there. They are not the focus of the storyline. Irene did a great job with these characters. Even though it is deemed a standalone, there could be other stories written for this found family as they grew through the years.
Each character brings their own wants and needs to the complexity of this why choose romance novel. Meg is the lucky lady who gets loved by three men. The relationships are all unique and different from each other. Henry and Noah also love each other in all ways. In my opinion, this duo stole the show at times. They are emotional, intimate, and a stable force. Dean is the wildcard and gets thrown into the mix well after the relationship between Meg and Noah, Meg and Henry, and Noah and Henry are well established. He is the piece that was missing for Meghan and he clicked into place beautifully. Noah and Henry just want Meghan to be happy. I do wish that the reader was given a little more backstory on how everyone came to be.
Things can get messy really quickly the more people you add the equation. These characters were honest and loving to one another, which made the addition almost seamless. That being said, I did feel the division between the throuple and Dean at times. I am used to reading more sharing type why choose books. It doesn't negate the fact that the story is balanced and emotionally charged. Also, the timeline seemed rushed a bit towards the end. For example, in one chapter it is Spring and the next it is December, then the next chapter it was two years later. I wanted to see all of the relationships grown in between those time gaps.
This book has an actual plot and is not full of spice on every other page. So, if that is your jam, then this is a perfect read for you. I would not call this a holiday book but the holidays are sprinkled in there. They are not the focus of the storyline. Irene did a great job with these characters. Even though it is deemed a standalone, there could be other stories written for this found family as they grew through the years.
November 21, 2025
This is a great “starter” read if you’re dipping your toes into the why choose or sharing tropes. It’s an easy read, the characters are well fleshed out, and the spice level hits that sweet spot—definitely there, but not overwhelming. If you’re looking for medium spice, this is right up your alley. And for those wondering, there aren’t a ton of group scenes.
What I really liked is how each character brings something different to the table. Meg is the lucky one here, loved by three men, and each relationship feels unique. Henry and Noah? They completely stole the show for me. Their bond is emotional, intimate, and steady—they’re the heart of the story. Then there’s Dean, the wildcard who comes in later once Meg’s relationships with Noah and Henry (and Noah and Henry’s relationship with each other) are already solid. He’s the missing piece for Meg, and when he shows up, he fits right in. Noah and Henry just want Meg happy, and that dynamic really worked. I just wish we’d gotten a little more backstory on how this whole found family came together.
Adding more people into a romance can get messy fast, but these characters are honest and loving, which makes the addition feel pretty seamless. That said, I did notice a bit of a divide between the established throuple and Dean at times. I’m used to reading more “sharing” style why choose books, so this felt different—but still balanced and emotionally charged. My only other gripe is the timeline. Toward the end, it jumps around a lot—spring to December to two years later—and I wanted to see those relationships grow in the gaps instead of skipping ahead.
One thing I really appreciated is that this book has an actual plot. It’s not just spice on every other page, so if you’re into stories with substance, this one’s for you. The holidays pop up here and there, but they’re more background than focus, so I wouldn’t call it a holiday read. Irene did a great job with these characters, and even though it’s labeled a standalone, I could totally see more stories coming from this found family as they grow over the years.
What I really liked is how each character brings something different to the table. Meg is the lucky one here, loved by three men, and each relationship feels unique. Henry and Noah? They completely stole the show for me. Their bond is emotional, intimate, and steady—they’re the heart of the story. Then there’s Dean, the wildcard who comes in later once Meg’s relationships with Noah and Henry (and Noah and Henry’s relationship with each other) are already solid. He’s the missing piece for Meg, and when he shows up, he fits right in. Noah and Henry just want Meg happy, and that dynamic really worked. I just wish we’d gotten a little more backstory on how this whole found family came together.
Adding more people into a romance can get messy fast, but these characters are honest and loving, which makes the addition feel pretty seamless. That said, I did notice a bit of a divide between the established throuple and Dean at times. I’m used to reading more “sharing” style why choose books, so this felt different—but still balanced and emotionally charged. My only other gripe is the timeline. Toward the end, it jumps around a lot—spring to December to two years later—and I wanted to see those relationships grow in the gaps instead of skipping ahead.
One thing I really appreciated is that this book has an actual plot. It’s not just spice on every other page, so if you’re into stories with substance, this one’s for you. The holidays pop up here and there, but they’re more background than focus, so I wouldn’t call it a holiday read. Irene did a great job with these characters, and even though it’s labeled a standalone, I could totally see more stories coming from this found family as they grow over the years.
December 8, 2025
Chestnuts by Irene Bahrd
⭐⭐⭐ 🌶️🌶️
MMFM * Poly * Miscommunication * Found Family * 322 pages * 🎧6h50
I have some mixed feelings on this one, so let’s dive into it.
This story introduces a throuple who function beautifully together. Strong communication, trust, respect, and each thriving in their own careers. When a new guy comes to town and keeps asking our FMC, she starts to wonder what if", though she’s not willing to give up her two boyfriends. When they finally encourage her to go on that date and see what happens, things naturally get a bit messy (as they often do in poly dynamics).
The poly aspect itself? I adored it. No two poly relationships are the same, and this book showcased that well. Our FMC and her two boyfriends are all fully dating each other, but the new MMC only wants to date her which can absolutely work in poly relationships when there’s honesty, clarity, and respect.
Where it fell apart for me was the lack of clear communication from the FMC toward the new guy. She was honest, but not convincingly so, which created predictable tension. And while all four characters had distinct personalities and decent page time, something about them didn’t feel fully fleshed out, they all lacked depth.
I listened to the audio, narrated by Stephanie Rose, Lance West, Simon Dornet, and Brandon Francis. Midway through, I had to pause to figure out why I wasn’t connecting. Their performance was wonderful, yet still... It felt more 'told' than 'shown'. We were missing the soft touches, the emotional build, the subtle romance moments. In the end, I think it was more story based than a performance one.
Romances under 100 pages often struggle because of limited time to create depth, but even at 322 pages, juggling four POVs and multiple relationship dynamics made it feel too short to fully explore the poly relationships or give each character the development they deserved.
⭐⭐⭐ 🌶️🌶️
MMFM * Poly * Miscommunication * Found Family * 322 pages * 🎧6h50
I have some mixed feelings on this one, so let’s dive into it.
This story introduces a throuple who function beautifully together. Strong communication, trust, respect, and each thriving in their own careers. When a new guy comes to town and keeps asking our FMC, she starts to wonder what if", though she’s not willing to give up her two boyfriends. When they finally encourage her to go on that date and see what happens, things naturally get a bit messy (as they often do in poly dynamics).
The poly aspect itself? I adored it. No two poly relationships are the same, and this book showcased that well. Our FMC and her two boyfriends are all fully dating each other, but the new MMC only wants to date her which can absolutely work in poly relationships when there’s honesty, clarity, and respect.
Where it fell apart for me was the lack of clear communication from the FMC toward the new guy. She was honest, but not convincingly so, which created predictable tension. And while all four characters had distinct personalities and decent page time, something about them didn’t feel fully fleshed out, they all lacked depth.
I listened to the audio, narrated by Stephanie Rose, Lance West, Simon Dornet, and Brandon Francis. Midway through, I had to pause to figure out why I wasn’t connecting. Their performance was wonderful, yet still... It felt more 'told' than 'shown'. We were missing the soft touches, the emotional build, the subtle romance moments. In the end, I think it was more story based than a performance one.
Romances under 100 pages often struggle because of limited time to create depth, but even at 322 pages, juggling four POVs and multiple relationship dynamics made it feel too short to fully explore the poly relationships or give each character the development they deserved.
November 20, 2025
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐.5 rounded down
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️
Chestnuts is the story of how a polycule adds another membet to the team, while the new guy still keeps his relationship separate from the others.
I felt a bit disconnected from the romance, there's a lot of talk about feelings but to me it felt sterile, just words on a page and not something I really felt, or a situation I was able to connect. There are multiple relationships taking place at the same time, and we cover a lot of time, so maybe that's part of the problem.
We see the beginning of the romantic relationship between Megan and Noah, and while we know there's Henry somewhere, we don't see him at the beginning. then we jump a couple of years, and the poly relationship between Meg, Henry and Noah is well estabilished. Enters Dean, and there's an almost insta-love connection between him and Megan. Again, we see their relationship develop over a couple of months, but while there are some ILUs, these feelings aren't shown, just narrated.
My favourite part was probably the discussion of boundaries, and how a relationship between four people that are not all in a relationship among themselves can work.
There's plenty of spice, but again, some of it felt more like a description of a spicy scene, not something we were suppose to feel or emotionally connect. The only true moment I felt linked to the story was the third act break up, and I usually hate those. For once, it was well deserved, but not what i want to remain to me after a love story.
Overall, while there are some interesting themes, and this is definitely different than other why choose you can encounter, I didn't connect with the story, and the whole thing felt dry and difficult to relate to.
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️
Chestnuts is the story of how a polycule adds another membet to the team, while the new guy still keeps his relationship separate from the others.
I felt a bit disconnected from the romance, there's a lot of talk about feelings but to me it felt sterile, just words on a page and not something I really felt, or a situation I was able to connect. There are multiple relationships taking place at the same time, and we cover a lot of time, so maybe that's part of the problem.
We see the beginning of the romantic relationship between Megan and Noah, and while we know there's Henry somewhere, we don't see him at the beginning. then we jump a couple of years, and the poly relationship between Meg, Henry and Noah is well estabilished. Enters Dean, and there's an almost insta-love connection between him and Megan. Again, we see their relationship develop over a couple of months, but while there are some ILUs, these feelings aren't shown, just narrated.
My favourite part was probably the discussion of boundaries, and how a relationship between four people that are not all in a relationship among themselves can work.
There's plenty of spice, but again, some of it felt more like a description of a spicy scene, not something we were suppose to feel or emotionally connect. The only true moment I felt linked to the story was the third act break up, and I usually hate those. For once, it was well deserved, but not what i want to remain to me after a love story.
Overall, while there are some interesting themes, and this is definitely different than other why choose you can encounter, I didn't connect with the story, and the whole thing felt dry and difficult to relate to.
November 7, 2025
Chestnuts by Irene Bahrd is a beautifully layered and emotionally charged romance that dives deep into love, loyalty, and the complexities of the poly lifestyle. The story follows Meg, a driven and successful restaurateur who’s worked hard to build her independence, yet finds herself drawn into a world where love doesn’t fit traditional boundaries.
For Henry and Noah, who have been together for over a decade, their bond is unshakable — but they both know something, or rather someone, is missing. When Meg enters their lives, the chemistry is undeniable and the emotional pull irresistible. Just as she begins to find her place between them, Dean Thomas, the charming and determined owner of the Dynasty hockey team, sets his sights on her. What begins as a simple invitation to a game turns into a single, world-shifting kiss that threatens to change everything.
Bahrd masterfully balances desire, vulnerability, and self-discovery, showing that love isn’t always straightforward — but it can be honest, respectful, and deeply fulfilling when handled with care. Each character feels authentic and flawed, making their struggles and connections incredibly human. The emotional tension and slow-burn intimacy keep you hooked, while the question of whether all four can truly find a shared happily ever after lingers beautifully until the end.
Chestnuts is a bold, heartfelt exploration of love in all its forms — messy, passionate, and profoundly real. It’s perfect for readers who crave romance that challenges convention while celebrating connection, trust, and the courage to love freely.
For Henry and Noah, who have been together for over a decade, their bond is unshakable — but they both know something, or rather someone, is missing. When Meg enters their lives, the chemistry is undeniable and the emotional pull irresistible. Just as she begins to find her place between them, Dean Thomas, the charming and determined owner of the Dynasty hockey team, sets his sights on her. What begins as a simple invitation to a game turns into a single, world-shifting kiss that threatens to change everything.
Bahrd masterfully balances desire, vulnerability, and self-discovery, showing that love isn’t always straightforward — but it can be honest, respectful, and deeply fulfilling when handled with care. Each character feels authentic and flawed, making their struggles and connections incredibly human. The emotional tension and slow-burn intimacy keep you hooked, while the question of whether all four can truly find a shared happily ever after lingers beautifully until the end.
Chestnuts is a bold, heartfelt exploration of love in all its forms — messy, passionate, and profoundly real. It’s perfect for readers who crave romance that challenges convention while celebrating connection, trust, and the courage to love freely.
December 10, 2025
Chestnuts is an extraordinarily delightful why choose romance between Henry, Noah, Meghan and Dean. Noah and Henry have been together for years, Meghan is their friend. One day, they are a threesome. They are happily in love and then along comes Dean. When Dean meets Meghan he is immediately interested and asks her out every time he is in town with his team. They finally begin to see each other and fall in love. How will this complicated relationship work out? Can Dean learn to share? Sit back, relax and listen to this fabulous audiobook for this sweet, funny, heartwarming story about love and family.
The narration by Stephanie Rose, Lance West, Simon Dornet and Brandon Francis was absolutely phenomenal. Stephanie Rose was brilliant as lovable, sassy, beautiful Meghan. I could feel all of her hurt, uncertainty, heartbreak, genuine happiness, passion and love through her voice. Lance West was delightful as charming, kind musician Henry. Simon Dornet was perfect as kind, sweet, thoughtful bookstore owner Noah. They have a beautiful, solid relationship with each other and Meghan. I love how they encouraged Meghan to pursue a relationship with Dean. Brandon Francis was divine as “Hockey Daddy” Dean. His sexy, sultry, alpha tone was positively swoon worthy. These four talented voice actors brought this story to life magnificently. I highly recommend listening.
Thanks to the author and High Gravity Productions for this ALC.
AUDIOBOOK REVIEW: Story 5 stars Narration 5 stars
My favorite quote “She’ll always be ours, but right now, he needs her to be his”.
The narration by Stephanie Rose, Lance West, Simon Dornet and Brandon Francis was absolutely phenomenal. Stephanie Rose was brilliant as lovable, sassy, beautiful Meghan. I could feel all of her hurt, uncertainty, heartbreak, genuine happiness, passion and love through her voice. Lance West was delightful as charming, kind musician Henry. Simon Dornet was perfect as kind, sweet, thoughtful bookstore owner Noah. They have a beautiful, solid relationship with each other and Meghan. I love how they encouraged Meghan to pursue a relationship with Dean. Brandon Francis was divine as “Hockey Daddy” Dean. His sexy, sultry, alpha tone was positively swoon worthy. These four talented voice actors brought this story to life magnificently. I highly recommend listening.
Thanks to the author and High Gravity Productions for this ALC.
AUDIOBOOK REVIEW: Story 5 stars Narration 5 stars
My favorite quote “She’ll always be ours, but right now, he needs her to be his”.
November 28, 2025
I really enjoyed this book! It was a little short in my opinion, I wish I could have had more of the relationships in the story. I loved the representation! There were multiple ethnicities, neurodivergent characters, and LGBTQ+ relationships. This author really knows what they are doing when it comes to making it inclusive!
I enjoyed the instalove between Dean and Meghan, and the fact that they had to learn how to navigate their relationship while Meghan is already in an existing one. It posed some unique problems, and made the story very interesting! I also love that Meghan had her own career outside of her men, it feels like the women are always so dependent on men in these types of books, and that was not the case for this one! I also really enjoyed how hockey was definitely a part of the plot, but it didn't override it. It just felt like a small part of the story, with most of it focusing on the characters rather than the sport.
While it was a short read, the author really did a good job making the characters feel like real people. I absolutely loved some of the side characters, and hope there will be future stories based on them. Overall, I would recommend this story if you're looking for a why choose, lighthearted story with an independent FMC.
I enjoyed the instalove between Dean and Meghan, and the fact that they had to learn how to navigate their relationship while Meghan is already in an existing one. It posed some unique problems, and made the story very interesting! I also love that Meghan had her own career outside of her men, it feels like the women are always so dependent on men in these types of books, and that was not the case for this one! I also really enjoyed how hockey was definitely a part of the plot, but it didn't override it. It just felt like a small part of the story, with most of it focusing on the characters rather than the sport.
While it was a short read, the author really did a good job making the characters feel like real people. I absolutely loved some of the side characters, and hope there will be future stories based on them. Overall, I would recommend this story if you're looking for a why choose, lighthearted story with an independent FMC.
December 21, 2025
Love the unique relationship dynamic
Format: Audiobook - Dual narration by Stephanie Rose, Brandon Francis, Lance West, and Simon Dornet
Series / Standalone: Standalone
Tropes: Why Choose, Friends to Lovers, Second Chance
I really enjoy any poly romance, but this one in particular because it had a relationship dynamic that’s out of the norm. Noah and Henry have the longest relationship but the addition of Meghan came in the prologue. A couple years later, enter Dean, the owner of an out of town hockey team that has been trying to win a date with Meghan for a long time. I loved the way this one progressed. Even though there was a slight miscommunication, it wasn’t the main plot point and played out in a way that made a lot of sense for the story. These are great characters with independent lives and know and speak up for exactly what they want.
I loved that we get four narrators for this audio. They did an amazing job with the dual-style narration. Every one of them differentiated characters so well it was easy to keep everyone straight. It was an easy audio to listen to straight through.
Format: Audiobook - Dual narration by Stephanie Rose, Brandon Francis, Lance West, and Simon Dornet
Series / Standalone: Standalone
Tropes: Why Choose, Friends to Lovers, Second Chance
I really enjoy any poly romance, but this one in particular because it had a relationship dynamic that’s out of the norm. Noah and Henry have the longest relationship but the addition of Meghan came in the prologue. A couple years later, enter Dean, the owner of an out of town hockey team that has been trying to win a date with Meghan for a long time. I loved the way this one progressed. Even though there was a slight miscommunication, it wasn’t the main plot point and played out in a way that made a lot of sense for the story. These are great characters with independent lives and know and speak up for exactly what they want.
I loved that we get four narrators for this audio. They did an amazing job with the dual-style narration. Every one of them differentiated characters so well it was easy to keep everyone straight. It was an easy audio to listen to straight through.
November 9, 2025
3.5 ⭐️// 2.5 🌶️
Chestnuts is a fast paced why choose romance about Meghan, Noah, Henry, and Dean. The story takes place across multiple years as we see the beginnings of the original trouple (Meg, Noah & Henry) then the change when Dean comes into the picture.
I think this is the first MMFM book where one of the MMCs has blatantly refused to be a part of the group moments? And listen I am 100% here for boundaries, personal space, recognizing your feelings, and know when you’ve had enough. All of that to say, it took me out of the moment and I wish there was a better way to label their relationship. It’s very MMF + MF vs MMFM if that makes any sense at all.
I found the characters to be likable and Noah & Henry were extremely understanding and accepting of Meghan’s growing feelings for Dean. Truly, Noah and Henry were the shining stars of this book for me and the most redeeming quality.
Thank you Luna Lit for the ARC! All thoughts are my own.
Chestnuts is a fast paced why choose romance about Meghan, Noah, Henry, and Dean. The story takes place across multiple years as we see the beginnings of the original trouple (Meg, Noah & Henry) then the change when Dean comes into the picture.
I think this is the first MMFM book where one of the MMCs has blatantly refused to be a part of the group moments? And listen I am 100% here for boundaries, personal space, recognizing your feelings, and know when you’ve had enough. All of that to say, it took me out of the moment and I wish there was a better way to label their relationship. It’s very MMF + MF vs MMFM if that makes any sense at all.
I found the characters to be likable and Noah & Henry were extremely understanding and accepting of Meghan’s growing feelings for Dean. Truly, Noah and Henry were the shining stars of this book for me and the most redeeming quality.
Thank you Luna Lit for the ARC! All thoughts are my own.
November 17, 2025
This was a nice book to read. It is very quick and hot, yet remains very effective in building the relationships and characters. I personally loved the relationship between Noah, Meghan and Henry. Their help and contact were sincere and emotional. Then there is Dean that adds some kind of tension with his dislike of sharing and enriches the story. Although the romance is developed in fast-paced, there is work and development in the relationships which I liked.
The one thing that struck me was a distinct set-up. You do not frequently get a polycule that is already in place and then observe them as they make new connections and deal with difficulties. The author did a magnificent work in depicting the intricacy and affection in these relations. Although this book is a book in a bigger world, I still read the book not knowing the other stories and I was not in any difficulties to follow. All in all it was a steamy, fun read that was also hearted.
ARC REVIEW
The one thing that struck me was a distinct set-up. You do not frequently get a polycule that is already in place and then observe them as they make new connections and deal with difficulties. The author did a magnificent work in depicting the intricacy and affection in these relations. Although this book is a book in a bigger world, I still read the book not knowing the other stories and I was not in any difficulties to follow. All in all it was a steamy, fun read that was also hearted.
ARC REVIEW
October 30, 2025
“She’ll always be ours, but right now, he needs her to be his.”
The dynamics in this why choose is so different from anything I've read before, and I absolutely loved it.
I loved how they just kept adding to the relationship to meet any of the partners' needs and how beautifully this story portrayed that no two poly relationships are the same, and as long as the people in the relationship agree, nothing else matters.
I feel like I could go on for hours talking about this book and how much I loved them as a polycule and as individuals, but at the same time, I feel like I would be giving too much away. So, just go and read it and thank me later.
Quote: “The three of you love one other, but you and I also love each other. So, let us love you in our own way. Separately, but equally.”
The dynamics in this why choose is so different from anything I've read before, and I absolutely loved it.
I loved how they just kept adding to the relationship to meet any of the partners' needs and how beautifully this story portrayed that no two poly relationships are the same, and as long as the people in the relationship agree, nothing else matters.
I feel like I could go on for hours talking about this book and how much I loved them as a polycule and as individuals, but at the same time, I feel like I would be giving too much away. So, just go and read it and thank me later.
Quote: “The three of you love one other, but you and I also love each other. So, let us love you in our own way. Separately, but equally.”
November 18, 2025
ARC Review
This is my first read by Irene Bahrd. I love a good Why Choose romance, and I believe Chestnuts respectfully delved into the polyamorous life and spent the right amount of time sharing what each character felt and experienced during this relationship, so I can appreciate how Noah, Henry, & Meg respected each other.
I think the hardest part for me in this story is when Dean comes along. I do feel that Meg could have been more upfront with her relationship, and truly communicated who Noah & Henry were to her. She stated they were her boyfriends, and that was that. I think full transparent communication to ensure all parties know what they are getting into would have made this story better for me.
Overall, I still really enjoyed this story and I think I'll continue to check out the author's other works!
Thanks to LunaLiterary for the ARC!
This is my first read by Irene Bahrd. I love a good Why Choose romance, and I believe Chestnuts respectfully delved into the polyamorous life and spent the right amount of time sharing what each character felt and experienced during this relationship, so I can appreciate how Noah, Henry, & Meg respected each other.
I think the hardest part for me in this story is when Dean comes along. I do feel that Meg could have been more upfront with her relationship, and truly communicated who Noah & Henry were to her. She stated they were her boyfriends, and that was that. I think full transparent communication to ensure all parties know what they are getting into would have made this story better for me.
Overall, I still really enjoyed this story and I think I'll continue to check out the author's other works!
Thanks to LunaLiterary for the ARC!
November 8, 2025
🌰 Why choose/poly
🌰 Friends to lovers
🌰 MMFM
🌰 Age gap
🌰 Instalove
🌰 Rom-Com
🌰 Found family
🌟🌟🌟🌟/🌶️🌶️
This was a fun, short, sweet, and spicy romantic comedy. It was light hearted but with heart if that makes sense. I like that no time is wasted getting into the story. I love the acceptance and openness that this found family has for each other. Henry and Noah fully love and support Meghan. In every possible way. I love how they helped her through tough times and cheered her on constantly. They encouraged her relationship with Dean and saw that she needed him. I appreciated the way that Dean brought them all together in the end. I really enjoyed how they took care of each other. I’m a sucker for a care giver and Meghan has 3 amazing and loving caregivers.
Recommend to any one looking for something sweet and spicy.
🌰 Friends to lovers
🌰 MMFM
🌰 Age gap
🌰 Instalove
🌰 Rom-Com
🌰 Found family
🌟🌟🌟🌟/🌶️🌶️
This was a fun, short, sweet, and spicy romantic comedy. It was light hearted but with heart if that makes sense. I like that no time is wasted getting into the story. I love the acceptance and openness that this found family has for each other. Henry and Noah fully love and support Meghan. In every possible way. I love how they helped her through tough times and cheered her on constantly. They encouraged her relationship with Dean and saw that she needed him. I appreciated the way that Dean brought them all together in the end. I really enjoyed how they took care of each other. I’m a sucker for a care giver and Meghan has 3 amazing and loving caregivers.
Recommend to any one looking for something sweet and spicy.
November 8, 2025
This is a fast, fun and spicy read but without sacrificing the plot. I absolutely loved the dynamic between Noah, Meghan and Henry the unconditional support and love was beautiful. Then you add in Dean who doesn't like to share, complicating his relationship with Meghan. The way their relationship developed and the things they had to work through made this book so much more enjoyable to me. I appreciate that there is definitely a fast paced love connection because this is a short read but there's also work that goes into making their relationship work. Overall great read and the spice was definitely yummy!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
December 1, 2025
Irene has officially nailed her first why choose book. I love a good why choose, and I absolutely devoured this one. It was a quick, fun, and spicy read, where the romance is definitely the plot. This is intended to be a standalone, but there are cameos from some of her other work, and that just enhanced the whole experience for me. I love Meg, Henry, and Noah's dynamic so much. I love when the boyfriends are actually boyfriends as well. Their relationship was already so perfect, but when Dean entered the picture, it just got that much more better. I think Irene done an amazing job conveying the trials and tribulations of being in a poly relationship. The found family aspect of the story was top tier! Definitely worth the read.
December 6, 2025
Chestnuts is a warm, spicy, and heartfelt MFMM romance that absolutely shines in audio. Megan, Noah, Henry, and Dean each bring something unique to this beautifully messy, emotionally rich love story. The relationship dynamics feel genuine, tender, and full of charm, with just the right amount of humor and heat.
The four-narrator cast makes this audiobook a standout. Stephanie Rose, Brandon Francis, Lance West, and Simon Dornet deliver distinct, immersive performances that perfectly capture each character’s heart and personality. Their chemistry pulls you right into the center of this unconventional but deeply loving relationship.
If you enjoy poly romances with strong emotion, great banter, and plenty of spice, Chestnuts is a fantastic listen.
The four-narrator cast makes this audiobook a standout. Stephanie Rose, Brandon Francis, Lance West, and Simon Dornet deliver distinct, immersive performances that perfectly capture each character’s heart and personality. Their chemistry pulls you right into the center of this unconventional but deeply loving relationship.
If you enjoy poly romances with strong emotion, great banter, and plenty of spice, Chestnuts is a fantastic listen.
November 1, 2025
What a gorgeous story of relationship dynamics within a polycule. Honestly, I don't think I've read something like this before, starting with two men already in a relationship before add in a woman and then supporting her as she discovers another relationship with a single man. I truly enjoyed this story and how it was beautifully told.
'Chestnuts' is absolutely a standalone, but it seems to include characters from other books by this author. I hadn't read any of them and was able to fully enjoy this book.
Thank you for gifting me an advanced reader copy. Review reflective of my personal opinions
'Chestnuts' is absolutely a standalone, but it seems to include characters from other books by this author. I hadn't read any of them and was able to fully enjoy this book.
Thank you for gifting me an advanced reader copy. Review reflective of my personal opinions
November 6, 2025
Rating ⭐️⭐️⭐️💫/5
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️/5
Thank you so much to Luna Literary and the author for the opportunity to read prior to release!!!
This one was a lot of fun while also packing a lot of difficult deep emotion into 275 pages. I read a fair amount of why choose books and I haven’t read one with a dynamic like this before. I loved how supportive Henry and Noah were of Meghan and her needing more. Dean’s character was so fun and so down bad 😅😅 their relationship dynamics were complex and they dealt with real emotions instead of just being all in. It was refreshing to see something different.
Due to its short nature, you definitely get some insta love but it made sense for the story. I do wish we had gotten additional description and fewer time jumps to add to the emotion, but overall this was a fun lighthearted little romcom!!!
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️/5
Thank you so much to Luna Literary and the author for the opportunity to read prior to release!!!
This one was a lot of fun while also packing a lot of difficult deep emotion into 275 pages. I read a fair amount of why choose books and I haven’t read one with a dynamic like this before. I loved how supportive Henry and Noah were of Meghan and her needing more. Dean’s character was so fun and so down bad 😅😅 their relationship dynamics were complex and they dealt with real emotions instead of just being all in. It was refreshing to see something different.
Due to its short nature, you definitely get some insta love but it made sense for the story. I do wish we had gotten additional description and fewer time jumps to add to the emotion, but overall this was a fun lighthearted little romcom!!!
December 23, 2025
ARC/ALC Review: 4.5⭐️
Chestnuts is a why choose romantic comedy featuring Henry Adams, Noah kelly, Dean Thomas & Meghan James.
Henry, Noah & Meghan have been in a relationship for years. They live together and are each other’s biggest cheerleaders.
Dean is a hockey team owner in Canada and always comes to Meghan’s restaurant when they’re in town. He’s attempted to ask her out many times but she never agrees to his advances. Dean however is persistent and doesn’t give up until she gives in.
The two have extensive chemistry and things start to sizzle up. However when Dean finds out she’s actually dating Henry & Noah, he flees quickly.
Will Dean realize his mistake and attempt to be with Meghan regardless of the other men in her life or will the thought of his girlfriend having boyfriends cause him to run ?
This book was fantastic; it was super fun and of course Irene brought the usual spice! The audiobook was narrated by Lance West, Simon Dornet, Brandon Francis & Stephanie Rose and I can’t say enough good things about it !
I highly recommend checking out this book and grabbing the audiobook! Thank you to Irene & High Gravity for the ARC/ ALC opportunity !
Chestnuts is a why choose romantic comedy featuring Henry Adams, Noah kelly, Dean Thomas & Meghan James.
Henry, Noah & Meghan have been in a relationship for years. They live together and are each other’s biggest cheerleaders.
Dean is a hockey team owner in Canada and always comes to Meghan’s restaurant when they’re in town. He’s attempted to ask her out many times but she never agrees to his advances. Dean however is persistent and doesn’t give up until she gives in.
The two have extensive chemistry and things start to sizzle up. However when Dean finds out she’s actually dating Henry & Noah, he flees quickly.
Will Dean realize his mistake and attempt to be with Meghan regardless of the other men in her life or will the thought of his girlfriend having boyfriends cause him to run ?
This book was fantastic; it was super fun and of course Irene brought the usual spice! The audiobook was narrated by Lance West, Simon Dornet, Brandon Francis & Stephanie Rose and I can’t say enough good things about it !
I highly recommend checking out this book and grabbing the audiobook! Thank you to Irene & High Gravity for the ARC/ ALC opportunity !
November 2, 2025
Super sweet, fun, and spicy romance about wanting the people you love to have the all people they love. Meghan, Noah, and Henry are happy together, but Noah and Henry recognize that there’s just a little something missing for Meghan. Dean has been coming into Meghan’s restaurant periodically for years and flirting with her. After taking to her guys, she finally takes the plunge and agrees to meet up with him. Their chemistry is off the charts, but will Dean fit into their lives. There’s a bit of miscommunication and a small third act breakup. Spicy and funny and romantic. Loved it!!!
November 7, 2025
If you love stories that include why choose, friends to lovers, and rom com, read this book! It is a super easy read! Since it is a short book, under 300 pages, there was a bit of a time jump in the first few chapters. When I started this book, I felt like we missed a lot of the story development between Noah, Henry, and Meg but some of their storyline is filled in for us later on in the book. The spice is mild/moderate but the plot is great! This was the first book I’ve read of Irene’s and I’d definitely read more.
November 21, 2025
Wow… just wow! Noah, Meghan, Henry, and Dean completely stole my heart! This has all the heat, and deliciously messy romance you could hope for. I loved watching Noah and Henry navigate their love with Meghan, and Dean’s cocky but sweet charm added the perfect spice. Bahrd does such a fantastic job exploring unconventional love with warmth, humor, and just enough tension to keep you hooked. By the end, I was smiling, crying, and cheering for this beautifully complicated family. I can’t recommend it enough!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 54 reviews