Reviewed by Mom (Annette), age ?, 3/22/21
This book was recommended to us as a read-aloud by a fellow dance mom. She warned us that it was very long, but that her kids loved it. I did not spend much time questioning whether to read aloud: all of my kids are desperate for long, chewy books they can enjoy during the library semi-shut-down. Both girls, age 7 and 10, devoured it in a matter of days and also enjoyed the sequel.
When it was my turn, it took me a few moments adjusting to the illustration style (which both girls also struggled with). But I quickly began to appreciate both the line drawings and the story itself. Very, very British in its absurdist humor, we learn to accept wind-up wings, cheese hunts (on "horses" made up of two men in a horse costume!) machine loving box trolls, vegetable loving cabbage heads, and kindly retired lawyers without twitching an eyebrow. We should not, then, have been surprised at the talking rats who comprise half the crew of the Laundry ship, but somehow I was anyway! There's something sillier around every corner as Arthur and his newfound allies work to prevent Snatcher from unleashing his great, gooey revenge on the entire town of Ratbridge.
Well worth a read even by adults, and one I would happily place on my permanent shelf (should I find a nice, second-hand copy, of course!)
Reviewed by Lucy, age 7 3/4, 2/27/21
Main Character: A boy named Arthur.
Other characters: Box trolls. Arthur’s Grandpa. Willbury. Snatcher and his crew. Rats and their master that work in the Ratbridge Laundry, which is a pirate ship.
Setting: Ratbridge. This world is very weird because it has freshwater sea cows, wild cheeses that live in bogs, box trolls, cabbage heads, and rabbit women.
Inciting Incident: Arthur gets caught by Snatcher who steals his wings. But in the end Arthur gets away without the wings and meets Willbury. Willbury is friends with box trolls, cabbage heads, and other “underlings.”
Rising Action: They try to get the wings back from Snatcher and find out what he’s doing.
Now if you want to find out more, Read the Book!
I thought this was a good book because I just like books with things from the underworld and small children who get into difficult-to-get-out-of places and situations and have to have to go on a big questy-journey-thinkamabob to get back. In other words, exciting books.
I did not like the pictures very much.
One sneak peek: A giant rat explodes and covers everything in cheese. Don’t come back at me for spoilers because if you read the back of the book you would know.
Reviewed by Grace, age 10, 3/20/21
Once upon a time there was a boy named Arthur who lived underground with his “Grandfather,” who was an inventor. That boy lived in a strange and fascinating world with trolls that live in boxes and cheese wheels that run around and are about as easy to catch as dead sheep. A little while ago, eating cheese had become illegal. This is because the Cheese Guild was selling poisonous cheese.
One day Arthur was out to get food for him and his grandfather, who wasn’t really his grandfather, but close enough. He made some noise while he was stealing bananas and a lady walked in and whacked him with a big stick, damaging his wings which Grandfather had made so he could fly. So he flew away – because his wings still worked a little bit – and stopped on top of the Cheese Guild Hall. Suddenly he saw men on horses capturing cheese! So he followed them – and got into trouble! When he got away he met a nice, kind lawyer (retired) named Wilburry. He took care of Arthur and they tried to find a way to get him home. Wilburry had a couple of friends: three boxtrolls and a cabbagehead. They could not get Arthur home, but they made friends with a bunch of pirates who do laundry, and some rats. They discovered a terrible plot to release a huge cheese rat into the town and had to foil it.
He got back to his grandfather. He’s happy – until the next book.
The End
What I liked about this book: It was hilarious. The entire plot of the book and the ridiculous situations were funny.
What I didn’t like about this book: It was a little weird. Maybe a lot weird. I wasn’t exactly a huge fan of the drawings, but he (the illustrator) definitely knew what he was doing.