Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

My Darling Girls: A Novel

Rate this book
In 1904 Chicago, where secrets cling as thickly as the soot on every windowsill, Jo earns her living by photographing the dead. The work is quiet and cloistered, allowing her to hide from a past that haunts the grief over her husband’s mysterious death, a spiraling addiction, and the guilt she carries over the things she’s done to survive.

When a notorious crime family hires Jo to make a final portrait of their daughter Millie, it stirs up a spirit that refuses to rest. In opium-fueled dreams, Millie lures Jo into a realm called “the courtyard,” where the dead burn to tell her their half-finished stories.

As Jo investigates Millie’s murder, she forms a fragile bond with her sister, Grace, who’s desperate for an escape of her own. Amid the whispers of the dead is a truth Jo must confront if she is to free them all from the shadows of the past.

251 pages, Paperback

Published October 20, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Marina Scott

7 books110 followers
Find me on Twitter and Insta. Also, you can find me here: marinascott.com

Marina Scott was born and raised behind the Iron Curtain in Vilnius, Lithuania. She graduated from a local university with a Master's degree in library science, but a short stint in a Soviet library changed her mind about being a librarian in the U.S.S.R. She immigrated to the United States in 2000 and now resides in Salt Lake City.

THE HUNGER BETWEEN US, is out November 1, 2022 with Macmillan/FSG.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
47 (23%)
4 stars
109 (54%)
3 stars
33 (16%)
2 stars
10 (5%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 131 reviews
Profile Image for Heidi Zuva.
796 reviews50 followers
Read
October 10, 2026
An atmospheric supernatural horror set in Chicago’s underworld right after the turn of the 20th century.

Premise - in 1904 Chicago widow Jo earnd her living photographing the dead, but when she takes a job for a crime family, photographing their deceased daughter, Millie, she finds herself slipping between words. Millie’s ghost brings Jo to “the courtyard” where she convenes with lost souls. Jo teams up with Grace, the sister, to investigate Millie’s death.

I enjoyed the atmosphere best in this book. There were some really vivid descriptions that placed me right in this world I know so little about.

There was one significant plot point in Jo’s past that relied on very unfortunate blocking and I couldn’t quite picture it, so it was a tough buy for me, but definitely not out of the bounds of twists you see in thrillers.

I listened to the audiobook, narrated by Kristyna Zaharek. She did a great job with the read, I’d recommend.

Thanks, NetGalley and Brilliance publishing, for the audio ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Mateusz.
Author 18 books45 followers
March 26, 2026
I loved Scott’s previous book, so I was really looking forward to this one—and I’m happy to say it didn’t disappoint. If you enjoy gloomy, dark, supernatural mysteries with a touch of romance and family drama, you’ll love "My Darling Girls." While reading, I kept thinking that this novel needs to be adapted for the screen. Set in turn-of-the-century Chicago, the story explores the struggles of women at the time, and many of the themes still feel surprisingly relevant today.
Profile Image for The Chapter Chaser.
113 reviews9 followers
November 11, 2026
Rounded to 4 “An intoxicating atmosphere, a fascinating premise, and a world where the living can be far more monstrous than the dead.”

Set in early 20th-century Chicago, My Darling Girls is a fast-paced, haunting blend of gothic horror, grief, guilt, and the supernatural. Struggling with addiction and desperate to survive, Jo reinvents her late husband’s photography business by capturing the dead, only to discover that communicating with them will force her to confront the darkest secrets of her own past.

This was my first book by Marina Scott, and I really enjoyed it! BUT… and this is a big BUT… please check the content warnings before diving in!

I actually came very close to giving this book only 2 stars, mainly because of how drug addiction was portrayed. At times, I felt the story came dangerously close to romanticizing substance use, presenting it almost as a means of reconnecting with a lost loved one while barely addressing its devastating consequences. And the way Jo seemingly overcomes her addiction in the space of a page? That really didn’t sit well with me.

Still, there were aspects of this book I genuinely loved, and they ultimately outweighed my frustrations.

Thank you to NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing for providing me with an advance reader copy (ARC) in exchange for an honest review!

🖤 What I loved most:

The setting and atmosphere: Early 20th-century Chicago provides a fascinating yet deeply disturbing backdrop, shaped by social inequalities, rigid expectations, and deeply rooted misogyny. It is a world where women are subjected to the authority and violence of men, whether fathers, uncles, priests, or other figures of power, leaving them with little independence, control, or protection. Dark, oppressive, unsettling, and deeply melancholic, the atmosphere perfectly complements and amplifies the gothic premise, creating a constant sense of unease that makes the supernatural elements even more haunting. For me, this aspect was exceptionally well executed!

The premise: One of the strongest aspects of this book! A woman photographing the dead while being able to communicate with them, all against a backdrop of addiction, grief, guilt, and unresolved trauma? Such an intriguing and original concept, with so much potential for a dark, psychologically complex story!

The female-centered narrative and its many portraits of women: The story brings together a remarkable range of female characters, each reflecting a different facet of womanhood in a deeply patriarchal society. There are victims of violence and abuse, women trapped by their circumstances, prostitutes and brothel madams, but also abusive mothers and women who become perpetrators of the very cruelty they have endured or witnessed.

What I found especially compelling is that these women are not simply portrayed as innocent victims or admirable heroines. They can be vulnerable, resilient, cruel, manipulative, compassionate, or deeply flawed. The best and the worst of human nature are represented, creating a complex and often disturbing portrait of women’s lives, their struggles, and the ways they survive, resist, or perpetuate oppression.

And I think this is ultimately what pushed my rating closer to 4 stars. I appreciate stories that aren’t afraid to explore both the beautiful and the ugly sides of human nature, without trying to make every character likable or morally redeemable.

A little touch of romance: Well… more like insta-lust than actual romance! 😂 But it does add a little spice to the story, and I found it enjoyable, especially considering how things eventually unfold (no spoilers here!). Was it absolutely necessary to the story? Probably not. Did I mind its inclusion? Not really! It was a nice little addition, even if it wasn’t particularly essential to the overall narrative.

🥀 What didn’t quite work for me:

The portrayal of drug addiction: This was almost a dealbreaker for me.

I appreciated the inclusion of addiction and understood its narrative purpose, particularly in relation to Jo’s ability to communicate with the dead. However, addiction is such a devastating and complex subject that I wished the author had explored its consequences far more thoroughly.

At times, Jo’s substance use seemed to exist primarily as a means of accessing the supernatural, almost turning drugs into a gateway to communicating with the dead. While I understand the appeal of this concept within horror, I was uncomfortable with how little attention was given to the physical, psychological, and emotional destruction that addiction can cause.

And perhaps what bothered me most was how quickly Jo appeared to overcome her addiction. Something so deeply rooted and destructive cannot simply be resolved in the space of a page without undermining the gravity of the subject.

For such a heavy theme, I wanted a more nuanced, realistic, and impactful exploration rather than what felt, at times, like an overly convenient narrative device.
Profile Image for Danielle B.
1,484 reviews234 followers
October 14, 2026
MY DARLING GIRLS is a mysterious story, filled with unexpected twists. I liked that it was fast paced and how everything came together at the end. This is the second book from this author that I have enjoyed. I highly recommend it, if you enjoy books that keep you guessing.

Many thanks to Marina Scott for my gifted copy.

This review will be shared to my Instagram account (@coffee.break.book.reviews) in the future.
Profile Image for Hester Fox.
Author 10 books2,193 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
April 28, 2026
Moody, raw, and suspenseful, My Darling Girls plunges readers into the gritty alleys of early 1900s Chicago, and takes them on an unforgettable journey through the spirit world and into the darkest recesses of the human mind. I absolutely loved it.
Profile Image for Niniane.
541 reviews12 followers
October 23, 2026
It was a pleasant read, who surprised me at times. The execution of several key points was, however, lacking.

I loved the atmosphere and the idea of a woman who photographies the dead. It was perfect for dark and disturbing moments. And the narrative delivered. The mystery around Jo truly surprised me. The revelation took time to happen, but it was really worth it.

The story was heavy with misogynistic violence, giving an accurate picture of women's place in the criminal underworld. There was nonetheless solidarity between women and a true glimmer of hope at the end.

Jo's writing was the main flaw for me. I never got a full picture of who she was as a person. Sure, we know her past and the way it shaped who she is today. However, that wasn't enough. She was very contradictory: sometimes assertive, others very passive and also extremely naive given her past.

So many things were told instead of shown. For example, I would have liked more flashbacks with her husband to understand why she loved him so much. What we see of him isn't very sympathetic. Except that he is presented (and not only through Jo's biased perception) as the best man ever.

Same when she attempts to stop taking opium. It was an important point ! But it is just told in once sentence and that's it. It deserved more depth or impact.

Finn's character barely made sense as a man raised in a criminal organisation (I mean, he cooks for her at some point). Neither did Jo's attraction to him. She knows what Finn does! She has seen first hand what happens in this family! I didn't buy any of his lame excuses and...

Turned out I was right!



Profile Image for Melissa (Nissa_the.bookworm).
1,310 reviews103 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 15, 2026
𝐑𝐄𝐀𝐃 𝐓𝐇𝐈𝐒 𝐈𝐅 𝐘𝐎𝐔
📸 love to take photos
👻 believe in ghosts
🔍 would make an excellent sleuth
🪦 are fascinated by post mortem photography

• 𝐖𝐇𝐀𝐓 𝐈𝐓’𝐒 𝐀𝐁𝐎𝐔𝐓

In 1904 Chicago, where secrets cling as thickly as the soot on every windowsill, Jo earns her living by photographing the dead. The work is quiet and cloistered, allowing her to hide from a past that haunts her: the grief over her husband’s mysterious death, a spiraling addiction, and the guilt she carries over the things she’s done to survive.

When a notorious crime family hires Jo to make a final portrait of their daughter Millie, it stirs up a spirit that refuses to rest. In opium-fueled dreams, Millie lures Jo into a realm called “the courtyard,” where the dead burn to tell her their half-finished stories.

As Jo investigates Millie’s murder, she forms a fragile bond with her sister, Grace, who’s desperate for an escape of her own. Amid the whispers of the dead is a truth Jo must confront if she is to free them all from the shadows of the past.

• 𝐌𝐘 𝐓𝐇𝐎𝐔𝐆𝐇𝐓𝐒

This was a fun, supernatural novel that explores death photography, something I’ve always been fascinated by. Back then, a lot of families couldn’t pay for portraits when their children were alive, but if they died suddenly from illness, a lot of them would scrounge up the money to get a photo of them, even if it was in death, to remember them by. Jo has taken over her husband’s photography business, but instead of following in his footsteps, she decides to photograph the dead. She is also addicted to opium, and it begins to affect her real life. I loved watching this mystery unfold. I wasn’t sure what was real or imagined, and I felt like Jo wasn’t entirely sure of that herself. The twist at the end was out of left field for me, something I never saw coming. If you’re into dark, spooky, gothic mysteries, pick this one up ASAP!
Profile Image for Callie Beth.
22 reviews16 followers
March 27, 2026
Thank you NetGalley and publisher for this advance copy a chance to read and review.

Enjoyable story with good character building. A littler mystery, a little supernatural. Emotional and sad at times with some heart warming moments as well.
Profile Image for Herbibliomaniac.
254 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
October 10, 2026
3.75 🌟

This starts out with delightfully spooky vibes. It's a haunting tale with ghosts and opium induced dreams that lead to the other side.

Our main character Jo photographs the recently deceased for their loved ones. But sometimes they move or speak to her. She starts to investigate the murder of young girl apart of a powerful crime family. She befriends the ghost's living sister as she works to uncover the cause of her death.

Taking place in historical Chicago, this story is set in a time where women still had to fight and prove themselves in a world made for men. Jo refuses to let that stop her. There's a bit of woman's rage, especially every time someone asks for her (deceased) husband assuming he is Jo.

The haunting themes create an atmosphere that is dark and eerie.

The Audio itself was done very well. The narrator did fantastic bringing all the characters and emotions to life. It was easy to keep up with even at high speeds.

Recommended for anyone who enjoys a paranormal mystery, or just looking for spooky vibes.

Thanks to Brilliance Publishing/Brilliance Audio, Marina Scott, and NetGalley for sending for me an Arc to review.
Narrated by Kristyna Zaharek
Profile Image for Charlene (pageandplace).
517 reviews30 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 19, 2026
Thank you to the author, Marina Scott, Publisher Lake Union Publishing and Brilliance Publishing/Audio and NetGalley for the opportunity to listen to and read this book. I received a gifted copy and am leaving my review voluntarily.

1904 Chicago, Jo earns her living as a photographer of the d3ad. When a well known mafia family hires her to photograph Millie, their 15year old daughter, she gets more than just a photographic inquiry. Millie seeks Jo’s assistance in finding her kill3r.

During her opium fueled dreams Millie lures Jo into “the courtyard”- a place where the d3ad can tell the tales of their half finished stories. Will Jo be able to free Millie and the others from the shadows of the past?

The audiobook was narrated by Kristyna Zaharek and I thought she did great with this spooky season read of historical fiction blended with horror. The characters were captivating and the mystery/investigation had me turning pages! I thought the gothic, atmosphere and world building were a success to the overall vibe of the book. Overall, this haunting story of grief, addiction and the experiences of women during those times were very well done.
Profile Image for Beau.
156 reviews12 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 16, 2026
*Thank you to Brilliance for a complimentary alc of My Darling Girls. All opinions expressed are my own.*

My Darling Girls is a haunting, gritty blend of historical fiction, gothic mystery, and paranormal elements, offering an intriguing glimpse into the more ominous side of early twentieth-century Chicago. At its centre is Jo, who makes her living photographing the deceased, an occupation that surprisingly provides the perfect doorway into a story where the line between the living and the dead becomes increasingly blurred.

The setting and historical timeline are wonderfully written, creating an atmosphere that feels both immersive and distinctly gothic. There’s something wonderfully unsettling and alive about the world Scott builds, and at times I genuinely felt as though I could smell the streets coming off the pages.

The audiobook, narrated by Kristyna Zaharek, adds another layer to the experience. The narration is just as clear, atmospheric, and wonderfully immersive as the written copy, making it incredibly easy to fall into the story and difficult to pull yourself away. Marina Scott’s prose shines throughout, and the combination of mystery and paranormal elements works seamlessly, complementing rather than drowning one another out.

I particularly appreciated how Scott incorporates some of the more difficult realities of the time, including addiction, into the narrative. Jo’s unusual profession, which was a norm of the time, becomes more than simply an interesting historical detail; it serves as an intriguing way to introduce the paranormal elements and gives the story a premise that feels both distinctive and meaningful.

Following Jo as she investigates Millie’s murder also brought an emotional depth I wasn’t quite expecting. Beneath the haunting atmosphere and mysterious circumstances lies a story with a surprisingly compelling emotional core, making the journey all the more engaging.

My Darling Girls is exactly the kind of historical gothic horror I love getting swept away by: atmospheric, haunting, and rich with mystery. If you’re looking for something that blends historical intrigue with a touch of the paranormal, I strongly recommend picking this one up.
Profile Image for ☽。⋆ Shells (jlreads_).
1,377 reviews85 followers
October 20, 2026
another disappointing execution. compelling premise wasted in a poor setting up. preferred this to have focused on the plot the way it seems to be so obsessed with the opium induced hallucinations.

don't get me wrong, the fmc is intriguing. the whole mindspace moments were fun. but again, it should have also handled the plot more meticulously or more the same with how it focused on the fmc.

not even the plot twist could save this novel. the romance or the brief affair, on the other hand, was so dry. never cared for it. again, the premise was really interesting.

like the whole haunting and murder mystery that never to really got so good or delved more the potential of that plot. i'm glad they found freedom and were able to move on at least, though. 2⭐️.

thank you, brilliance audio for the alc via netgalley.
Profile Image for Amanda Hopwood.
723 reviews40 followers
October 19, 2026
I have received the advanced listening copy from NetGalley for my honest review and opinion


I am NOT a historical fiction person …. But after reading this I have discovered I am however a historical horror fan … who knew !

Imagine being a women in the 1920s with your own photography business, you take pictures of people who are passed ( this was custom back then)

But one day you are taking photos and the deceased man starts taking to you ……

This was full of twists, eerie ghosts and a bit of sapphic romance as well . I enjoyed !
Profile Image for Barbi Funes.
142 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
October 17, 2026
It wasn't what I expected at all. The mysteries were important, in the sense that although the story went on I needed them to be solved. They caught my attention. There were many details at first I thought were extra or irrelevant and made it feel slow, but there's a point for each of them to become crucial to realize something about the main events.
51 reviews
March 22, 2026
3.5 stars

This book explores a gripping and dark story about a post mortem photographer set in 1904. The initial description caught my immediate attention and left me wanting to unravel the story. After the mysterious death of her husband, Jo continues his work as a photographer, but rather than photographing the living, she photographs the dead, which was not an uncommon practice that occurred within the Edwardian times. And on top of this Jo is able to communicate with and see the dead, giving the story a cool and dark side to the plot unraveling. I enjoyed learning and understanding this side of photography told through such a dark and gothic manner.
Jo is hired by a well known crime family to photograph their daughter Millie who tragically passed away. However, Jo comes to realise that Millie’s death may have been more than just a sickness which took her life. Jo gets brought into another realm through the use of opium which she uses to help her sleep, and comes across the Millie who cannot rest or leave this space in the realm known as the ‘courtyard’, where the dead linger until they are able to accept and reflect on their life in order to move on, Millie refuses to leave this place until she knows who was the cause of her death. Asking Jo to help her uncover the truth.
As Jo begins to unravel the events that led to Millie’s death she forms a close bond with Grace, Millie’s sister who is living in her own silent prison which Jo wishes to release her from and save her. As Jo also has known what it is like to feel trapped, as the story also explores Jo’s past and her memories coming to light in order for her to move on.
Jo’s journey through facing the ghosts of her past as she seeks to finally be released from her past that haunts her and to seek a future that for once is her own.
The story explores the processing of grief, redemption and escaping from the past that haunts you. The story shines light on the women and girls in this story who are trapped unable to have freedom and wish to make a life for their own.
I felt the relationship between Jo and Finn the man who first seeks her out to help photograph Millie was too fast paced at the beginning and I felt lacked more of an emotional build up to make sense of their dynamic.
The story comes with an enlightening twist towards the end that causes you to realise you cannot always trust the narrator of the story.
This story felt very atmospheric, dark and a gripping tale. Even though there was multiple different timelines and plots within plots occurring the structure and writing was done well that enabled me to keep track and piece all the pieces together.
Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for allowing me to read this ARC and explore this story.
And I look forward to when this book is released.
Profile Image for Suzanne Leopold (Suzy Approved Book Reviews).
505 reviews265 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 10, 2026
This one pulled me in at the first chapter! The protagonist is cleverly developed throughout the book and her story comes together at the end! It is an eerie, unique and engaging novel.
Profile Image for Lizzy Brannan.
393 reviews30 followers
October 17, 2026
Tastefully macabre and beautifully mysterious, Marina Scott has crafted a unique historical work of fiction about a female photographer who earns her living by photographing the dead in Chicago, 1904. For lovers of Starling House, this one is your October read.

Determined to bury a past that haunts her, Jo hides behind her camera photographing the dead. It’s 1904, Chicago, and a woman photographer is practically unheard of. But there is a crime family wanting to hire her to capture a final portrait of their daughter, Millie. Only, when she sees the girl, she realizes she has seen her before. She’s spoken with her. Yesterday. But in fighting an opium addiction, Jo thought Millie was just a dream when she came to speak with her. Millie has asked Jo to find her killer. If she does, Jo will have a wish granted. But it’s not that simple as she searches for answers. Sparks are flying with Finn, a member of this family. And Jo realizes, as she becomes familiar with Millie’s sister, Grace, that the bruises she is seeing mean Grace is in need of rescue.

I was pleasantly surprised at how much I enjoyed this book. It’s the perfect October read. I was captivated by the genre-bending styles of historical horror mixed with ethereal magical realism. The characters are deeply developed and fascinatingly flawed. I found the ending satisfying and empowering. Paired with a dark academia playlist, this is the ultimate October experience.

I read this alongside the audiobook and must say that Kristyna Zaharek’s voice was perfect for this genre. She carries this story with shuddering mystery and her breathy voice timbre brings a soothing beauty to the macabre storyline.

Thank you NetGalley, Marina Scott, and Brilliance Publishing for this amazing ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for Susan Ballard (subakkabookstuff).
2,995 reviews106 followers
November 5, 2026
Jo is a widow who makes her living photographing both the living and the dead. Jo is haunted, and by more than grief.

The idea of photographing the dead is eerie and macabre enough! 𝗠𝘆 𝗗𝗮𝗿𝗹𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝗚𝗶𝗿𝗹𝘀 is a Gothic mystery that is filled with feverish opium dreams, unsettled spirits, dark secrets, and murder.

Set in 1904 Chicago, the atmosphere is a haunting blend of the gritty historical with a dark Gothic feel. With gangsters and ghosts, shadows and secrets, this mystery will keep you on edge right up to the very surprising end.

🎧 Thank you @brilliancepublishing for the gifted audiobook. Kristyna Zaharek's narration, with the breathiness and chilling qualities of her voice, added to the eerie feel of this story.

Thank you @suzyapprovedbooktours and @marina_v_scott for this gifted book. #mydarlinggirls

Profile Image for Kirk.
548 reviews20 followers
October 23, 2026
I was drawn to My Darling Girls after reading The Night Guests by Marina Scott last year. However this audiobook gave me the creeps in another way. Some romance elements, opium addiction, a crime family and the wrong kind of ghosts turned me off. I will continue to check out the author’s books but this one didn’t work for me. The excellent narrator, Kristyna Zaharek, kept me listening. ALC was provided by Brilliance Publishing/Brilliance Audio via NetGalley. I received an audiobook listening copy for free and I am leaving this feedback voluntarily.
Profile Image for Jennifer Smith.
826 reviews17 followers
October 27, 2026
A perfect spooky season read, I loved the dark shadowy Chicago setting with supernatural spirits who refused to stay silent until their murders are solved! Jo was the perfect protagonist for this type of amateur sleuthing role. She has her own hidden past, and her struggles with opium dreams, grief, and penance made her a compelling yet unreliable narrator which escalated the suspense! With short impactful chapters, I blew through this story, and Scott’s prose is both lush and haunting. If you are a fan of darker murder mysteries with morally gray characters, you should add this to your TBR! Come for the gothic and ghostly vibes, and stay for the sisterhood and resilience themes!
March 16, 2026
Thank you Netgalley for this ARC.

My Darling Girls by Marina Scott explores a dark and unusual premise centered around postmortem photography, which immediately caught my attention. Set against a historical backdrop, the novel follows Jo, a photographer who takes portraits of the dead—a practice that was not uncommon in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The eerie concept, combined with the supernatural element of Jo being able to communicate with the deceased, gives the story a unique starting point.

The book moves between timelines, gradually weaving together past and present to reveal the full mystery. I appreciated how the narrative slowly built layers around Jo’s life and the secrets surrounding her. The exploration of memory, grief, and forgiveness added emotional depth to the story, especially as Jo begins confronting parts of her past while trying to uncover the truth behind a murder.

That said, while the premise was intriguing and the atmosphere was strong, the pacing and character interactions didn’t always fully land for me. Some moments felt slightly awkward or uneven, which occasionally pulled me out of the story. Still, the originality of the topic and the unfolding mystery kept me interested enough to see how everything would connect.

Overall, My Darling Girls is an interesting historical mystery with a very distinctive concept. While it didn’t completely work for me in every aspect, the unique subject matter and layered storytelling make it a worthwhile read for those who enjoy darker historical fiction with a supernatural twist.
348 reviews64 followers
October 20, 2026
This was a thrilling, fast read for me. I delighted in the atmosphere and really felt for the FMC. The writing was outstanding. I will look forward to reading more by this author in the future.
Profile Image for Courtney Pityer.
1,275 reviews77 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 2, 2026
I have to admit I really enjoyed reading this book because it covered a dark side of history that some historical fiction novels have a tendency to avoid. Overall I was quite impressed with how this book played out as it gave readers a sense of female empowerment and adventure. I have to say I really admired the main fmc Jo as a character as she goes through so much in this story. You would think that she would have it easy with just a simple job as a death photographer. In this book you read more than that you get to see her struggles with loss, addiction, and her investigating some of the rough areas of her living environment. I have to say this book was quite the adventure to read.
Profile Image for hannah ⊹ ࣪ ˖.
909 reviews20 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 20, 2026
My Darling Girls by Marina Scott is a dark, atmospheric blend of historical fiction, gothic horror, and supernatural mystery that pulled me into its 1904 Chicago setting. The story follows Jo, a postmortem photographer struggling with grief, addiction, and secrets from her past. I found the concept of photographing the dead especially fascinating, because I don't think I have ever read something like it before, and the addition of spirits, opium-induced dreams, and the mysterious courtyard gave the story an eerie quality, and the soot-stained streets and shadowy atmosphere made it easy to picture the world Jo was navigating and living in.

In particular, I enjoyed how the mystery surrounding Millie’s death intertwined with Jo’s own journey toward confronting her past. The novel explores grief, guilt, addiction, and the difficult realities women faced in a society that constantly underestimated them. Jo is a flawed but compelling character, and her growing connection with Grace adds an emotional layer to the darker elements of the story. I also appreciated the uncertainty surrounding what was real and what might have been a product of Jo’s addiction, which kept me guessing as the secrets gradually unfolded because I was constantly questioning Jo's perspective.

While I loved the gothic atmosphere and intriguing premise, I would have enjoyed a little more development in some of the relationships, as a few connections felt rushed. Other than that, though, the supernatural elements, historical setting, and mystery more than made up for it, and the story delivered some unexpected revelations along the way.

My Darling Girls is a perfectly haunting read with plenty of secrets, unsettling moments, and emotional depth. If you enjoy gothic historical mysteries with paranormal twists, complicated characters, and strong themes of female resilience, this is definitely worth adding to your TBR, and it makes a perfect choice for a spooky season read!

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing for this ARC!
Profile Image for Sue - Recos and Reads.
400 reviews47 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 2, 2026
A haunting tale of secrets, lies and supernatural elements, with a strong FMC desperately trying to find her place in a world where she can finally be free.

Following the death of her husband, Jo (Josephine) takes over his photography studio, an unusual position for a woman in 1900s Chicago. But when a notorious gangland family asks her to photograph their dead daughter, the request opens a door to a past Jo has worked hard to keep buried. As her dependence on opium grows, Jo begins to believe she can communicate with the dead. Whether the opium is causing her mind to play tricks on her or she really is being called upon by the dead to uncover their truths, even Jo isn't entirely sure. What she does know is that she is being forced to confront the mistakes and secrets she's spent years running from.

As the story unfolds, complicated relationships and painful secrets from Jo's past slowly come to light. I particularly enjoyed the way the novel explores the lives of women in the early 1900s, the restrictions placed upon them and what happens when a strong-willed woman refuses to accept the path society has laid out for her.

The supernatural elements added a wonderfully mysterious layer to the story, and I found myself constantly questioning what was real and what might be a result of Jo's addiction. The story also took an unexpected turn that revealed truths I hadn't considered, and I enjoyed seeing how those revelations changed my understanding of what had come before.

Atmospheric, emotional and filled with secrets, this was a fascinating historical mystery with a supernatural twist that left me surprisingly emotional by the end.

Many thanks to the author for providing a NetGalley widget to listen to the audiobook. The narrator, Kristyna Zaharek, does a fantastic job of bringing each character to life and adding to this atmospheric story.
Profile Image for Magdalena (magdal21).
760 reviews92 followers
October 24, 2026
This was so much better (and more complex!) than I expected.

Set in 1904 Chicago, the story follows Jo, a woman grieving the murder of her husband while trying to make ends meet as a photographer of the dead. When she’s hired to photograph the deceased daughter of a notorious crime family, whose death is shrouded in suspicious circumstances, she finds herself drawn into a world of dark secrets and increasingly unsettling discoveries. There are some supernatural elements present, but they’re woven into the story so naturally that they only add to its already eerie atmosphere.

What I appreciated most in this book was how complex and multilayered Jo was as a protagonist. Her internal struggles, contradictions, complicated feelings, the secrets she carries all felt believable and thoughtfully explored. I also found the portrayal of her high-functioning opium addiction particularly interesting. I don’t think I’ve come across that perspective in historical fiction before.

My only real criticism is that certain relationships and plot elements felt a little underdeveloped. In particular Jo’s relationship with Finn could have used more attention for the finale to have the emotional impact it was clearly aiming for.

Still, this was a much more gripping and layered read than I anticipated, with a fascinating protagonist, plenty of moral ambiguity, and an atmosphere that only grows more disturbing as the story unfolds. Definitely one that exceeded my expectations.
Profile Image for 2manybooks2littletime.
443 reviews62 followers
November 3, 2026

1. 𝐃𝐞𝐚𝐭𝐡 • Photographing the dead was not something that I was really aware of. It was so interesting to see how much those photos meant to the families and how much care Jo took to make them perfect with the intricacies of taking and developing them.

2. 𝐆𝐡𝐨𝐬𝐭𝐬 • Each time Jo had her visions, whether chemically induced or not, the eerie undertones mixed with the mysteries truly upped the tension. The desperation was always evident in the dead, and Jo felt her obligation and followed through until she got to the truth.

3. 𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐌𝐨𝐛 • The Snakes fit the mold of a notorious crime family. From torture to coercion to manipulation, Jo sees all of it but doesn’t shy away because of how much Millie needs her. The ladies she meets are also an interesting addition and another way for her to make peace with herself.

4. 𝐒𝐞𝐜𝐫𝐞𝐭𝐬 • Both Jo and Millie end up having the same shared secret in a way. I think that’s what pulls Jo into it even more, and when she finally figures out the truth, it is tragic in more ways than one.

5. 𝐋𝐨𝐯𝐞 • Familial, romantic, found family, friendship - we see a plethora of love throughout even though there is the overtone of anger and hate. I would say that love definitely overcomes by the end!
Profile Image for Kayleigh.
1,008 reviews9 followers
October 21, 2026
My Darling Girls brings us to 1904 where Jo makes her living photographing the dead, which gives a great cover for her hiding from her past. Every so often, the dead that she photographs appear or speak to her and that leans easily into the opium induced dreams she’s been having. When one of these ghosts asks for her help in discovering her murderer, she gets tangled up in a crime family who wants to silence her.

There was pretty solid character development throughout the book and while some of the supernatural elements were a bit hard to visualize, I think they worked for the most part.

I listened to the audiobook, narrated by Kristyna Zaharek. She did a great job with the read, I’d recommend.

Publish Date: October 20, 2026
I received an advanced copy from Netgalley and the publishers in exchange for my review.
Profile Image for Booksandcoffeemx.
2,658 reviews169 followers
October 7, 2026
Haunting, dark, and compelling, a combo I can’t resist.

This deeply atmospheric gothic story took me to 1904 Chicago in a story that was a little unsettling yet captivating.

Jo is a photographer who captures the dead, and when she’s hired to photograph a young girl from a notorious crime family, she finds herself pulled into a mysterious and haunting story involving her death.

I loved the dark atmosphere and the unusual concept of post-mortem photography, and the supernatural elements made this such an intriguing read.

If you like gothic historical mysteries with a little darkness and the supernatural, this one is definitely worth picking up.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 131 reviews