What do you think?
Rate this book
The Fear Of #3
The Fear of Drowning: A Chilling Psychological Thriller
A missing girl. A cult above the law. A truth buried in the desert. The Hannah Jacobs story continues.
With no other options, Hannah’s estranged mother pleads for her help in finding her missing stepdaughter, Emily. Last seen at the secluded Seven Day Saints compound in the desolate Utah border town of Echo Canyon.
Reluctant at first, Hannah agrees to take the case and soon discovers that Seven Day Saints are ruled by one man, Kenneth Pratt—a maniacal leader with absolute power over his followers and influence that makes him nearly untouchable by the law. Under his control, the community is plagued by violence, polygamy, forced marriage, and accounts of sexual abuse.
With the help of another investigator, a reporter, and a former member who barely escaped with her life, Hannah goes undercover in Echo Canyon, determined to find Emily and expose the dark secrets of Seven Day Saints.
With no other options, Hannah’s estranged mother pleads for her help in finding her missing stepdaughter, Emily. Last seen at the secluded Seven Day Saints compound in the desolate Utah border town of Echo Canyon.
Reluctant at first, Hannah agrees to take the case and soon discovers that Seven Day Saints are ruled by one man, Kenneth Pratt—a maniacal leader with absolute power over his followers and influence that makes him nearly untouchable by the law. Under his control, the community is plagued by violence, polygamy, forced marriage, and accounts of sexual abuse.
With the help of another investigator, a reporter, and a former member who barely escaped with her life, Hannah goes undercover in Echo Canyon, determined to find Emily and expose the dark secrets of Seven Day Saints.
217 pages, Kindle Edition
Published January 27, 2026
8 people are currently reading
34 people want to read
About the author
S.C. Sterling
6 books108 followersScott C. Sterling is the author of
The Fear of Series,
crime thriller trilogy. The Hannah Jacobs journey began with with his debut novel,
The Fear of Winter (January 2023),
and continued with
The Fear of Fire (May 2024).
The explosive third book in the series,
The Fear of Drowning,
a dark psychological mystery, was in released in January 2026.
Non-fiction books include Teenage Degenerate, a memoir about drug addiction and growing up, and 33 Percent Rockstar: Music, Heartbreak and the Pursuit of Rock Stardom is a music autobiography about the vast majority of musicians who never achieve rock stardom.
Ways to connect with Scott:
Email: sc@scsterling.com
Books: N/B Books
Books: scsterling.com
Site: thefearofwinter.com
Site: teenagedegenerate.com
Non-fiction books include Teenage Degenerate, a memoir about drug addiction and growing up, and 33 Percent Rockstar: Music, Heartbreak and the Pursuit of Rock Stardom is a music autobiography about the vast majority of musicians who never achieve rock stardom.
Ways to connect with Scott:
Email: sc@scsterling.com
Books: N/B Books
Books: scsterling.com
Site: thefearofwinter.com
Site: teenagedegenerate.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 60 reviews
January 26, 2026
Book 3 in the Fear of series continues to follow PI Hannah. This time she’s approached by her estranged mother who says her step sister Emily is missing. At first, Hannah is hesitant to help, but she does have a soft spot for Emily since she’s the only family member who attempted to befriend Hannah. But after a meeting with her stepfather, she realizes she isn’t missing, but has joined a very dangerous cult.
Hannah meets with a former PI, Roger, who worked the case for quite some time. He gives her as many details as he can, while warning her not to visit the community. But of course, we know she’s not going to listen!
Just like the rest of the series, this was a very quick paced read. I don’t know that I’ve ever read a continual thriller series, but I’ve really enjoyed following Hannah & her cases! The Fear of Drowning could definitely be read as a standalone but I think you would appreciate it more if you read the entire series.
I really liked how this book focused on Hannah & her estranged family. The aspect of her stepsister joining a cult definitely intrigued me to read. Pacing was great & this is definitely a page turner. I only knocked down a star due to the predictability. I didn’t feel like there were any super great twists. I did however really enjoy the ending & felt like it wrapped up the series well.
Thank you to the author & Book Sirens for the arc.
Hannah meets with a former PI, Roger, who worked the case for quite some time. He gives her as many details as he can, while warning her not to visit the community. But of course, we know she’s not going to listen!
Just like the rest of the series, this was a very quick paced read. I don’t know that I’ve ever read a continual thriller series, but I’ve really enjoyed following Hannah & her cases! The Fear of Drowning could definitely be read as a standalone but I think you would appreciate it more if you read the entire series.
I really liked how this book focused on Hannah & her estranged family. The aspect of her stepsister joining a cult definitely intrigued me to read. Pacing was great & this is definitely a page turner. I only knocked down a star due to the predictability. I didn’t feel like there were any super great twists. I did however really enjoy the ending & felt like it wrapped up the series well.
Thank you to the author & Book Sirens for the arc.
January 26, 2026
I first want to thank the author for sending me an ARC of this book! I've never received an advanced copy from an author before so I was absolutely excited to day the least!
Hannah returns in this third installment of The Fear of series. In this book, we delve a bit deeper into Hannah's family ties when her estranged mother comes knocking and requests her PI skills.
Hannah wants to say no, being she wants nothing to do with her mother, but when she finds out her step-sister Emily -- the only person in this section of family who even tried to befriend Hannah -- is missing, she decided to agree to help. Her step-father fills her in on how Emily was last seen as the Seven Day Saints compound in Echo Canyon. A town ruled by the charismatic leader known as Kenneth. Hannah figures hes your average cult leader but as she digs deeper she learns just how dangerous this leader and town can truly be.
Sterling truly leaves you thirsting for more as you flip each page. Its a quick read and holds you interest. You meet several new characters and explore a slight romance theme as well as the mystery thriller theme we have all come to love with this series. You could enjoy this book as a standalone, without reading one and two, but I think you should read the first two to genuinely appreciate it and the characters. Everything is wrapped up well like a fine present, bow tie and all, and I always appreciate that when reading a story.
Hannah returns in this third installment of The Fear of series. In this book, we delve a bit deeper into Hannah's family ties when her estranged mother comes knocking and requests her PI skills.
Hannah wants to say no, being she wants nothing to do with her mother, but when she finds out her step-sister Emily -- the only person in this section of family who even tried to befriend Hannah -- is missing, she decided to agree to help. Her step-father fills her in on how Emily was last seen as the Seven Day Saints compound in Echo Canyon. A town ruled by the charismatic leader known as Kenneth. Hannah figures hes your average cult leader but as she digs deeper she learns just how dangerous this leader and town can truly be.
Sterling truly leaves you thirsting for more as you flip each page. Its a quick read and holds you interest. You meet several new characters and explore a slight romance theme as well as the mystery thriller theme we have all come to love with this series. You could enjoy this book as a standalone, without reading one and two, but I think you should read the first two to genuinely appreciate it and the characters. Everything is wrapped up well like a fine present, bow tie and all, and I always appreciate that when reading a story.
January 22, 2026
Some books pull you under slowly. This one grabs your ankles and drags you straight into the deep end with no lifeguard in sight.
The Fear of Drowning by S.C. Sterling is a dark, fast-paced thriller that had me holding my breath from start to finish. When Hannah Jacobs is asked to investigate a missing girl tied to a powerful desert cult, she knows the danger but steps in anyway. And once she goes undercover, the tension skyrockets.
The Seven Day Saints compound is chilling, and cult leader Kenneth Pratt is terrifying in a quiet, absolute-power kind of way. The themes of control, abuse, and secrecy feel disturbingly real, and I genuinely feared for Hannah as the truth slowly surfaced.
Gripping, emotional, and impossible to put down, this book left me rattled in the best way and eager for more of Hannah’s story.
✨️Thank you, S.C. Sterling, for sharing The Fear of Drowning with me!
The Fear of Drowning by S.C. Sterling is a dark, fast-paced thriller that had me holding my breath from start to finish. When Hannah Jacobs is asked to investigate a missing girl tied to a powerful desert cult, she knows the danger but steps in anyway. And once she goes undercover, the tension skyrockets.
The Seven Day Saints compound is chilling, and cult leader Kenneth Pratt is terrifying in a quiet, absolute-power kind of way. The themes of control, abuse, and secrecy feel disturbingly real, and I genuinely feared for Hannah as the truth slowly surfaced.
Gripping, emotional, and impossible to put down, this book left me rattled in the best way and eager for more of Hannah’s story.
✨️Thank you, S.C. Sterling, for sharing The Fear of Drowning with me!
February 3, 2026
I have never read anything by S.C. Sterling before and I must admit I was really quite surprised with how much I enjoyed reading this book. I believe it was because the story centered around a cult in the state of Utah. Reading about cults and polygamy have always fascinated me as to how seemingly good, normal people can allow themselves to become controlled and almost brainwashed by these leaders. This was a story that captured my full attention and there were parts that really had me on edge. It was filled with danger that kept me glued to my kindle. After reading this, I would absolutely love to read the other books in the series as I believe they each must be about different storylines but somehow connected. I’ll do further research to learn more about them. This is a book I would definitely recommend to others and I’d like to thank the author and NetGalley for sending me this story to read. I enjoyed it tremendously and I’m giving it a 5 star rating!
January 17, 2026
I was sent a free advanced reader copy of “the fear of drowning” by SC Sterling to read and honestly review! It is important to know that this book is third in the series and you need to have read one and 2 to understand elements of this book.
This book made me feel quietly uneasy the whole time, in a good way. There was this constant underlying tension I couldn’t shake which is exactly what you want for a psychological thriller.
The story centres around a private investigator named Hannah who is approached by her estranged mother whose stepdaughter has been missing for a couple of years. Without giving anything away, the book follows Hanna‘s investigation into a religious cult in search for her stepsister.
What really worked for me was the length of the book, only 244 pages. The plot is fast paced which means that there are no slow scenes. Every moment contains something pivotal to the plot or to character development.
If you love short and snappy psychological thrillers featuring a real FMC with her own array of mental and emotional damage then you’ll love the entire series.
Overall, this was a solid 4 stars for me and I would happily read more from this author!
I gave this review voluntarily and all views are my own.
This book made me feel quietly uneasy the whole time, in a good way. There was this constant underlying tension I couldn’t shake which is exactly what you want for a psychological thriller.
The story centres around a private investigator named Hannah who is approached by her estranged mother whose stepdaughter has been missing for a couple of years. Without giving anything away, the book follows Hanna‘s investigation into a religious cult in search for her stepsister.
What really worked for me was the length of the book, only 244 pages. The plot is fast paced which means that there are no slow scenes. Every moment contains something pivotal to the plot or to character development.
If you love short and snappy psychological thrillers featuring a real FMC with her own array of mental and emotional damage then you’ll love the entire series.
Overall, this was a solid 4 stars for me and I would happily read more from this author!
I gave this review voluntarily and all views are my own.
January 13, 2026
One of my favorite parts of the book was the timeline continuation from book 2, it really helped to seal together the ending of the last book and tie it into this one. Seeing her trying to find the victim's families and give them closure helped me appreciate Hannah more as a character. Since the second book helped her find the closure of her sister, I think that Hannah accepting to help her mother showed how much she had grown, even if the acceptance was a bit hard to come to terms with for her. I did like the cult's backstory and how much of an influence it had in Utah and how her step-sister was a part of it, but I wish there was a bit more detail about her sister's time in the cult and how badly the captivity affected Hannah. Overall I really enjoyed the read and I struggled to put it down.
Thank you S.C. Sterling for the ARC and every opinion I've given is my own.
Thank you S.C. Sterling for the ARC and every opinion I've given is my own.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 22, 2026
📚The Fear of Drowning
✍🏻S.C. Sterling
Blurb:
A missing girl. A cult above the law. A truth buried in the desert. The Hannah Jacobs story continues.
With no other options, Hannah’s estranged mother pleads for her help in finding her missing stepdaughter, Emily. Last seen at the secluded Seven Day Saints compound in the desolate Utah border town of Echo Canyon.
Reluctant at first, Hannah agrees to take the case and soon discovers that Seven Day Saints are ruled by one man, Kenneth Pratt—a maniacal leader with absolute power over his followers and influence that makes him nearly untouchable by the law. Under his control, the community is plagued by violence, polygamy, forced marriage, and accounts of sexual abuse.
With the help of another investigator, a reporter, and a former member who barely escaped with her life, Hannah goes undercover in Echo Canyon, determined to find Emily and expose the dark secrets of Seven Day Saints.
My Thoughts:
This book is creepy and a good page turner.. This is the third book in the series but can be read as a standalone. Hannah is a private investigator hired by her estranged mother and step father to find her stepsister, who has joined a cult, and bring her home. When Hannah reaches the compound where her sister is, she finds out she’s possibly bitten off more than she can chew. If you love short and psychological thrillers featuring a real FMC with her own array of mental and emotional damage then you’ll love the entire series.
Thanks NetGalley, No Bueno Publishing and Author S.C. Sterling for the complimentary copy of "The Fear of Drowning" I am leaving my voluntary review in appreciation.
#NetGalley
#NoBuenoPublishing
#S.C.Sterling
#TheFearofDrowning
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
⚠️Trigger Warnings:
ddiction, Alcoholism, Rape, Sexual assault, Torture, Violence, Kidnapping,Adult/minor relationship, Animal death, Confinement, Homophobia, Infidelity, Physical abuse, Self harm, Forced institutionalization
Animal cruelty, Sexism, Suicide, Stalking, Dark. Cult elements.
✍🏻S.C. Sterling
Blurb:
A missing girl. A cult above the law. A truth buried in the desert. The Hannah Jacobs story continues.
With no other options, Hannah’s estranged mother pleads for her help in finding her missing stepdaughter, Emily. Last seen at the secluded Seven Day Saints compound in the desolate Utah border town of Echo Canyon.
Reluctant at first, Hannah agrees to take the case and soon discovers that Seven Day Saints are ruled by one man, Kenneth Pratt—a maniacal leader with absolute power over his followers and influence that makes him nearly untouchable by the law. Under his control, the community is plagued by violence, polygamy, forced marriage, and accounts of sexual abuse.
With the help of another investigator, a reporter, and a former member who barely escaped with her life, Hannah goes undercover in Echo Canyon, determined to find Emily and expose the dark secrets of Seven Day Saints.
My Thoughts:
This book is creepy and a good page turner.. This is the third book in the series but can be read as a standalone. Hannah is a private investigator hired by her estranged mother and step father to find her stepsister, who has joined a cult, and bring her home. When Hannah reaches the compound where her sister is, she finds out she’s possibly bitten off more than she can chew. If you love short and psychological thrillers featuring a real FMC with her own array of mental and emotional damage then you’ll love the entire series.
Thanks NetGalley, No Bueno Publishing and Author S.C. Sterling for the complimentary copy of "The Fear of Drowning" I am leaving my voluntary review in appreciation.
#NetGalley
#NoBuenoPublishing
#S.C.Sterling
#TheFearofDrowning
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
⚠️Trigger Warnings:
ddiction, Alcoholism, Rape, Sexual assault, Torture, Violence, Kidnapping,Adult/minor relationship, Animal death, Confinement, Homophobia, Infidelity, Physical abuse, Self harm, Forced institutionalization
Animal cruelty, Sexism, Suicide, Stalking, Dark. Cult elements.
January 12, 2026
Adult thriller. I have a problem giving 5 stars to books whose content is troubling. This one is no different, what I’m saying is it is probably at least worth a 4.5 if not 5. I just can’t click that last star. Troubling, but written in a way that confronts the reader, but doesn’t grittily offend. This is a very readable book, that’s once I started reading I wanted to finish.
S. C. Sterling gives us an unsettling chill from the outset. A lot is wrong in Hannah’s life.
The author has created Hannah, PI, who has a very troubled past. I had previously read book one in this series, so I had some of pre-knowledge of Hannah’s back story.
This story starts with Hannah running from her last case - hunting her sister’s killer, running from herself - maniacally throwing herself into finding the bottom of many beer bottles, and running from commitment. Which isn’t surprising given what has brought her to this point. Her sister’s death and the rejection of her horrible mother and stepdad.
Two people who now want Hannah to save her stepsister from a cult. As in the past Hannah, for all her troubles, can’t help walking into danger to save others. That’s where she is headed as she a Utah cult conclave. Definitely foolishly, if not very naively too.
I know I’ve presented a review that sounds dark, and yes the story line is that. But as I previously said I didn’t want to stop reading this until I reached the end of a worthwhile, exciting and well written thriller.
Thank you to S.C. Sterling for the ARC. The views expressed are all mine, freely given.
S. C. Sterling gives us an unsettling chill from the outset. A lot is wrong in Hannah’s life.
The author has created Hannah, PI, who has a very troubled past. I had previously read book one in this series, so I had some of pre-knowledge of Hannah’s back story.
This story starts with Hannah running from her last case - hunting her sister’s killer, running from herself - maniacally throwing herself into finding the bottom of many beer bottles, and running from commitment. Which isn’t surprising given what has brought her to this point. Her sister’s death and the rejection of her horrible mother and stepdad.
Two people who now want Hannah to save her stepsister from a cult. As in the past Hannah, for all her troubles, can’t help walking into danger to save others. That’s where she is headed as she a Utah cult conclave. Definitely foolishly, if not very naively too.
I know I’ve presented a review that sounds dark, and yes the story line is that. But as I previously said I didn’t want to stop reading this until I reached the end of a worthwhile, exciting and well written thriller.
Thank you to S.C. Sterling for the ARC. The views expressed are all mine, freely given.
February 18, 2026
This was my first book by S.C. Sterling, and it caught my attention more than I expected. The focus on a cult in Utah immediately drew me in, as I’ve always been interested in how people can be influenced and controlled by those in positions of authority.
Despite being the third instalment in The Fear Series, it can be read on its own without any confusion. The author provides just enough background to understand the characters and their relationships.
The story follows Hannah, a private investigator asked by her estranged family to track down her missing stepsister, Emily, after she joins a cult known as The Seven Day Saints. Going undercover puts Hannah in a dangerous position, and it soon becomes clear she may have underestimated the situation.
The tension builds well and there are moments that feel genuinely unsettling. The darker themes are handled carefully and never feel excessive. However, the pacing is inconsistent. The opening drags in places, while Hannah’s time within the cult and what follows move too quickly. A slightly longer book would have allowed these sections to feel more developed.
Overall, this was an interesting and suspenseful read that fell just short of being great, but it has definitely made me curious about the rest of the series.
Despite being the third instalment in The Fear Series, it can be read on its own without any confusion. The author provides just enough background to understand the characters and their relationships.
The story follows Hannah, a private investigator asked by her estranged family to track down her missing stepsister, Emily, after she joins a cult known as The Seven Day Saints. Going undercover puts Hannah in a dangerous position, and it soon becomes clear she may have underestimated the situation.
The tension builds well and there are moments that feel genuinely unsettling. The darker themes are handled carefully and never feel excessive. However, the pacing is inconsistent. The opening drags in places, while Hannah’s time within the cult and what follows move too quickly. A slightly longer book would have allowed these sections to feel more developed.
Overall, this was an interesting and suspenseful read that fell just short of being great, but it has definitely made me curious about the rest of the series.
January 20, 2026
This is the third book in the series, however you can read it as a standalone and not feel like you've missed too much by not reding the others. Hannah is a private investigator hired by her estranged mother and step father to find her stepsister, who has joined a cult, and bring her home. When Hannah reaches the compound where her sister is, she finds out shes possibly bitten off more than she can chew.
The book was okay but I did feel like a lot of nothing happened for the majority of the book, then her time with the cult and the aftermath seemed really rushed through. At just over 200 pages, it really could have afforded being made a bit longer so that we got more detail. There is also a huge chunk at the start, where she is travelling around with some guy that she just met, that just seemed entirely pointless and didn't really add a whole lot of anything at all to the overall plot.
This book absolutey deals with some very dark themes, but the author has handled these incredibly well and in a way that does not come across as in yout face or offensive. The story itself was pretty good (once it got going!) but i definitely feel like it needed a bit more to make it great.
The book was okay but I did feel like a lot of nothing happened for the majority of the book, then her time with the cult and the aftermath seemed really rushed through. At just over 200 pages, it really could have afforded being made a bit longer so that we got more detail. There is also a huge chunk at the start, where she is travelling around with some guy that she just met, that just seemed entirely pointless and didn't really add a whole lot of anything at all to the overall plot.
This book absolutey deals with some very dark themes, but the author has handled these incredibly well and in a way that does not come across as in yout face or offensive. The story itself was pretty good (once it got going!) but i definitely feel like it needed a bit more to make it great.
January 21, 2026
I found this story engaging and intriguing from the very beginning. The characters were compelling and the writing did a good job drawing out emotion and keeping me invested in the outcome. The author does a good job of creating atmosphere and maintaining tension throughout the story.
The pacing is fast, which is expected given the shorter length of the book. My biggest reason for not rating this higher is simply that I wanted more time with the story and its characters. At times, I found it difficult to determine how much time had passed, particularly in the opening portion and again toward the ending. This may have been intentional, but a bit more clarity or additional detail around the passage of time could have further strengthened the buildup.
Overall, this was a great story and I throughly enjoyed it, and book three ended up being my favorite in this series. While it can be read as a standalone, I believe the story benefits from the context provided by the first two books. I would gladly read more from this author and would recommend this series to readers who enjoy fast paced thrillers.
The pacing is fast, which is expected given the shorter length of the book. My biggest reason for not rating this higher is simply that I wanted more time with the story and its characters. At times, I found it difficult to determine how much time had passed, particularly in the opening portion and again toward the ending. This may have been intentional, but a bit more clarity or additional detail around the passage of time could have further strengthened the buildup.
Overall, this was a great story and I throughly enjoyed it, and book three ended up being my favorite in this series. While it can be read as a standalone, I believe the story benefits from the context provided by the first two books. I would gladly read more from this author and would recommend this series to readers who enjoy fast paced thrillers.
January 27, 2026
Mr. Sterling is a new to me author.
I love getting to know new authors and reading their work.
Seeing their writing style and their characters.
And this author did not disappoint.
He is detailed oriented and his characters have depth to them.
The book is fast paced and suspense driven.
I have not read the previous books in The Fear Series.
But had no trouble understanding what’s going on or who the previous characters are and their relationship. There is enough information to fully understand this book.
Once I started reading I couldn’t stop.
I was gripped with the plot and storyline and invested in Hannah.
She is a PI and really good at her job.
Her estranged mother and stepfather beg for her help in finding Emily, Hannah’s stepsister.
So she goes undercover into The Seven Day Saints, a cult, run by a man so so much power and authority.
The story is thrilling and captivating and intense.
It’s nerve wracking and I was on the edge of my seat and my pulse skyrocketing many times.
Throughly enjoyed my time reading this cult thriller book.
I will most definitely be following and reading more by this author!
I love getting to know new authors and reading their work.
Seeing their writing style and their characters.
And this author did not disappoint.
He is detailed oriented and his characters have depth to them.
The book is fast paced and suspense driven.
I have not read the previous books in The Fear Series.
But had no trouble understanding what’s going on or who the previous characters are and their relationship. There is enough information to fully understand this book.
Once I started reading I couldn’t stop.
I was gripped with the plot and storyline and invested in Hannah.
She is a PI and really good at her job.
Her estranged mother and stepfather beg for her help in finding Emily, Hannah’s stepsister.
So she goes undercover into The Seven Day Saints, a cult, run by a man so so much power and authority.
The story is thrilling and captivating and intense.
It’s nerve wracking and I was on the edge of my seat and my pulse skyrocketing many times.
Throughly enjoyed my time reading this cult thriller book.
I will most definitely be following and reading more by this author!
January 28, 2026
The third installation in this series, and by far the shortest, and somehow it still takes the longest time for the story to get going.
We begin with a very gruesome scene (please pay attention to the trigger warnings!), then the story continues exactly where the previous one left off.
One of my biggest problems with the previous book, is that the ending was... missing? This is picked up here, when Hannah tries to get in contact with the families of all the victims from the previous book. It's nice, that we get this, but it feels out of place here
The writing style and storytelling both improved compared to the previous ones, though sometimes I still can't tell if the way Hannah throws caution to the wind and pisses every dangerous character off is something we should be finding charming or not.
I can't wait to see where the story takes her next, now that
I'd like to thank the author for the ARC. Thank you for letting me come along for this ride!
We begin with a very gruesome scene (please pay attention to the trigger warnings!), then the story continues exactly where the previous one left off.
One of my biggest problems with the previous book, is that the ending was... missing? This is picked up here, when Hannah tries to get in contact with the families of all the victims from the previous book. It's nice, that we get this, but it feels out of place here
The writing style and storytelling both improved compared to the previous ones, though sometimes I still can't tell if the way Hannah throws caution to the wind and pisses every dangerous character off is something we should be finding charming or not.
I can't wait to see where the story takes her next, now that
I'd like to thank the author for the ARC. Thank you for letting me come along for this ride!
February 1, 2026
I’m calling this a 3.5 star read, rounded up to 4 because I’ve genuinely enjoyed this series overall.
I liked the plot of The Fear of Drowning, even though it deals with some pretty dark and potentially triggering themes. I thought these were handled thoughtfully and sensitively.
The road trip at the beginning was a nice change of pace. Hannah is usually so focused on work and her habits, so it was refreshing to see her in a different environment and enjoying the outdoors.
Hannah’s mother appearing in this book really added another layer to the story. It’s easy to see how much Hannah’s life and personality were shaped by that relationship.
I enjoyed Anna as a character and loved her acts of rebellion.
My main issue was pacing in the second half. Hannah’s time in Echo Canyon felt quite rushed, and the ending wrapped up very quickly. I would’ve happily read a longer book with more detail and breathing room in that final stretch.
Overall, a solid addition to a series I’ve been enjoying, and I’m still keen to see where Hannah’s story goes next.
Thanks to BookSirens for the ARC of this book. This is my honest review.
I liked the plot of The Fear of Drowning, even though it deals with some pretty dark and potentially triggering themes. I thought these were handled thoughtfully and sensitively.
The road trip at the beginning was a nice change of pace. Hannah is usually so focused on work and her habits, so it was refreshing to see her in a different environment and enjoying the outdoors.
Hannah’s mother appearing in this book really added another layer to the story. It’s easy to see how much Hannah’s life and personality were shaped by that relationship.
I enjoyed Anna as a character and loved her acts of rebellion.
My main issue was pacing in the second half. Hannah’s time in Echo Canyon felt quite rushed, and the ending wrapped up very quickly. I would’ve happily read a longer book with more detail and breathing room in that final stretch.
Overall, a solid addition to a series I’ve been enjoying, and I’m still keen to see where Hannah’s story goes next.
Thanks to BookSirens for the ARC of this book. This is my honest review.
Read
February 10, 2026This is a psychological thriller that follows Hannah Jacobs, who became a private investigator to solve her sister's murder. In this book, which is the third of the series, Hannah is hired to rescue Emily, her stepsister, from a dangerous cult in an isolated town in Utah.
What I liked: My favorite part of the book was when Hannah was doing research about the Seven Day Saints and their leader Kenneth. Cults are a very interesting topic, which was my reason to read this book, so the research kept me hooked to the story and it made me wonder about similar cults in real life. I also really liked some of the side characters, like Anna, Bella, and Roger. The book was entertaining, easy to read, and I kept thinking about it, which is a must for a good thriller.
What I didn't like: The first part of the book is rather long. I enjoyed getting to know Hannah better as a character, but I was expecting to get to the cult part sooner.
(I received a complimentary ARC of this book, and I am providing an honest review voluntarily)
What I liked: My favorite part of the book was when Hannah was doing research about the Seven Day Saints and their leader Kenneth. Cults are a very interesting topic, which was my reason to read this book, so the research kept me hooked to the story and it made me wonder about similar cults in real life. I also really liked some of the side characters, like Anna, Bella, and Roger. The book was entertaining, easy to read, and I kept thinking about it, which is a must for a good thriller.
What I didn't like: The first part of the book is rather long. I enjoyed getting to know Hannah better as a character, but I was expecting to get to the cult part sooner.
(I received a complimentary ARC of this book, and I am providing an honest review voluntarily)
February 10, 2026
The Fear of Drowning by S.C. Sterling is a compelling psychological thriller that dives into the unsettling dynamics of cult influence, control, and identity. Cult-centered stories have always fascinated me, and this one definitely did not disappoint. It was a quick, gripping read that I finished in a single day thanks to the steady pacing and constant sense of tension.
Hannah was an excellent main character; her strength, vulnerability, and determination carried the story and made the emotional stakes feel real. Although this is the third book in Hannah’s journey, it works well as a standalone, with enough background woven in to understand past events while still rewarding readers who have followed the earlier books.
Overall, this was an engaging, suspenseful read filled with psychological tension and intriguing twists, especially recommended for readers who enjoy cult-focused thrillers with strong character-driven storytelling.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Hannah was an excellent main character; her strength, vulnerability, and determination carried the story and made the emotional stakes feel real. Although this is the third book in Hannah’s journey, it works well as a standalone, with enough background woven in to understand past events while still rewarding readers who have followed the earlier books.
Overall, this was an engaging, suspenseful read filled with psychological tension and intriguing twists, especially recommended for readers who enjoy cult-focused thrillers with strong character-driven storytelling.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
February 4, 2026
This was a fun book. A real page turner at the end. The story follows private investigator Hannah Jacobs as she goes undercover into a secluded religious compound in Utah to rescue her sister, whom she can’t believe wants to be there of her own free will.
Sterling’s portrayal of the “Seven Day Saints”- a fictionalized, extremist offshoot of the LDS faith- is chilling and incredibly well-researched. The atmosphere of isolation, absolute authority, and the dark secrets hidden behind a “saintly” facade kept me on edge.
The midpoint of the book is where the book turns from a slow simmer to a full-on sprint as Hannah gets deeper into the Echo Canyon community. She gets caught sneaking in and once the investigation becomes dangerous, the book becomes impossible to put down.
If you’re looking for a psychological thriller that actually delivers on its promises, this is it. Just be prepared to see the sunrise!
Sterling’s portrayal of the “Seven Day Saints”- a fictionalized, extremist offshoot of the LDS faith- is chilling and incredibly well-researched. The atmosphere of isolation, absolute authority, and the dark secrets hidden behind a “saintly” facade kept me on edge.
The midpoint of the book is where the book turns from a slow simmer to a full-on sprint as Hannah gets deeper into the Echo Canyon community. She gets caught sneaking in and once the investigation becomes dangerous, the book becomes impossible to put down.
If you’re looking for a psychological thriller that actually delivers on its promises, this is it. Just be prepared to see the sunrise!
March 1, 2026
There are some protagonists you read about… and then there are the ones you feel. Hannah Jacobs is firmly in the second category.
In The Fear of Drowning, S.C. Sterling delivers a character-driven psychological story that leans heavily into emotional realism, internal conflict, and the complicated architecture of identity. Hannah is sharp, opinionated, and willing to take risks — not reckless, but intentional. She doesn’t drift through the narrative; she chooses, and those choices carry weight. I love a woman who moves the story instead of being carried by it, and Hannah absolutely does that.
One of the most striking dynamics in the book is Hannah’s relationship with her distant, narcissistic mother. Sterling portrays this with uncomfortable precision — not melodramatic, not exaggerated, just painfully believable. The emotional push-pull, the subtle wounds, the long shadow of childhood — it all feels authentic, and it gives Hannah’s motivations real depth. This isn’t just backstory; it’s structural to who she is.
The supporting cast felt equally grounded. No cardboard personalities, no plot devices masquerading as people — just plausible, human characters who behave in ways that make sense within the emotional ecosystem of the story. That kind of realism is what allows the psychological tension to land.
And then… the cult.
Sterling absolutely nailed the tone, psychology, and quiet menace of the group and its leader. Nothing felt sensationalized; instead, it was controlled, believable, and chilling in a way that felt true. The manipulation, the atmosphere, the undercurrent of control — all very well executed. This was one of my favorite elements of the book because it never tipped into caricature. It stayed grounded, which made it far more unsettling.
The pacing is brisk — it’s a relatively short book that moves with purpose — but the final resolution came very quickly and felt a bit too neatly packaged for my taste. After such careful emotional and psychological layering, the sudden tightening of loose ends felt slightly jarring, almost like the story shifted into fast-forward. That being said, it didn’t diminish my overall enjoyment, but it did keep this from being a full 5-star read for me.
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐½ (4.5 stars)
A compelling, character-driven story with strong emotional realism and an especially convincing portrayal of cult psychology. While this book can absolutely stand on its own, readers who start from the beginning of the series will gain deeper insight into Hannah — what shaped her, what drives her, and what makes her such a fascinating character. I enjoyed this enough that I plan to go back and read the first two books.
If you are a fan of character-focused psychological fiction, complex female leads, and emotionally layered storytelling, this book will absolutely land for you.
The Fear of Drowning is for you if you appreciate:
*Quiet psychological tension rather than explosive thrillers
*Stories about identity, autonomy, and emotional survival
*Realistic portrayals of narcissistic family dynamics
*Cult psychology presented with nuance rather than spectacle
*Strong female protagonists who are flawed, perceptive, and self-directed
Readers who enjoy authors like Gillian Flynn, Lisa Jewell, or Tarryn Fisher — where character psychology drives the tension — will feel right at home here.
In The Fear of Drowning, S.C. Sterling delivers a character-driven psychological story that leans heavily into emotional realism, internal conflict, and the complicated architecture of identity. Hannah is sharp, opinionated, and willing to take risks — not reckless, but intentional. She doesn’t drift through the narrative; she chooses, and those choices carry weight. I love a woman who moves the story instead of being carried by it, and Hannah absolutely does that.
One of the most striking dynamics in the book is Hannah’s relationship with her distant, narcissistic mother. Sterling portrays this with uncomfortable precision — not melodramatic, not exaggerated, just painfully believable. The emotional push-pull, the subtle wounds, the long shadow of childhood — it all feels authentic, and it gives Hannah’s motivations real depth. This isn’t just backstory; it’s structural to who she is.
The supporting cast felt equally grounded. No cardboard personalities, no plot devices masquerading as people — just plausible, human characters who behave in ways that make sense within the emotional ecosystem of the story. That kind of realism is what allows the psychological tension to land.
And then… the cult.
Sterling absolutely nailed the tone, psychology, and quiet menace of the group and its leader. Nothing felt sensationalized; instead, it was controlled, believable, and chilling in a way that felt true. The manipulation, the atmosphere, the undercurrent of control — all very well executed. This was one of my favorite elements of the book because it never tipped into caricature. It stayed grounded, which made it far more unsettling.
The pacing is brisk — it’s a relatively short book that moves with purpose — but the final resolution came very quickly and felt a bit too neatly packaged for my taste. After such careful emotional and psychological layering, the sudden tightening of loose ends felt slightly jarring, almost like the story shifted into fast-forward. That being said, it didn’t diminish my overall enjoyment, but it did keep this from being a full 5-star read for me.
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐½ (4.5 stars)
A compelling, character-driven story with strong emotional realism and an especially convincing portrayal of cult psychology. While this book can absolutely stand on its own, readers who start from the beginning of the series will gain deeper insight into Hannah — what shaped her, what drives her, and what makes her such a fascinating character. I enjoyed this enough that I plan to go back and read the first two books.
If you are a fan of character-focused psychological fiction, complex female leads, and emotionally layered storytelling, this book will absolutely land for you.
The Fear of Drowning is for you if you appreciate:
*Quiet psychological tension rather than explosive thrillers
*Stories about identity, autonomy, and emotional survival
*Realistic portrayals of narcissistic family dynamics
*Cult psychology presented with nuance rather than spectacle
*Strong female protagonists who are flawed, perceptive, and self-directed
Readers who enjoy authors like Gillian Flynn, Lisa Jewell, or Tarryn Fisher — where character psychology drives the tension — will feel right at home here.
February 5, 2026
Fear of Drowning was just as intense, spellbinding, and captivating as the first two books in the series. Mr. Sterling knows his way around action and creating great characters. It is one of a few books that I'm not sure if I read or devoured. I didn't want to put it down and couldn't wait to get back to it when I was interrupted. The books in the series do not have to be read in order to enjoy them, but I think one sees more of Hannah's development when they are read in order. The main thing is to read them. They're that good.
I thought Mr. Sterling would go for another type of ending. He surprised me, but not in a bad way. In fact, after thinking about it, I enjoyed his ending better than what I was anticipating. I highly recommend it. If you have high blood pressure, you make sure you are up on your medications because some of these characters will make you livid. I received a review copy from the author via BookSirens, and this review reflects my honest and voluntary opinion.
I thought Mr. Sterling would go for another type of ending. He surprised me, but not in a bad way. In fact, after thinking about it, I enjoyed his ending better than what I was anticipating. I highly recommend it. If you have high blood pressure, you make sure you are up on your medications because some of these characters will make you livid. I received a review copy from the author via BookSirens, and this review reflects my honest and voluntary opinion.
February 5, 2026
Thank you to Sterling for sending me an ARC copy of this book!
After receiving the ARC I dove into the series following Private Investigator Hannah Jacob. The third book in the series, “The Fear of Drowning,” by S.C. Sterling is dark and fast-paced. Hannah is asked to investigate the disappearance of her step-sister by her disowned mother and step-father. Reluctant to take the case from her emotionally abusive parents, she remembers fond memories of her sister and decided to look into it.
The Seven Day Saints is the cult linked to the disappearance of Hannah’s sister. It is lead by an evil man suspected of heinous crimes. From the beginning of the novel you are sucked into the story, unable to stop until the end.
The only reason for 4 stars is wanting more! In this story you will scratch the surface of characters that deserve more spotlight. I cannot wait to see where Sterling takes us next.
After receiving the ARC I dove into the series following Private Investigator Hannah Jacob. The third book in the series, “The Fear of Drowning,” by S.C. Sterling is dark and fast-paced. Hannah is asked to investigate the disappearance of her step-sister by her disowned mother and step-father. Reluctant to take the case from her emotionally abusive parents, she remembers fond memories of her sister and decided to look into it.
The Seven Day Saints is the cult linked to the disappearance of Hannah’s sister. It is lead by an evil man suspected of heinous crimes. From the beginning of the novel you are sucked into the story, unable to stop until the end.
The only reason for 4 stars is wanting more! In this story you will scratch the surface of characters that deserve more spotlight. I cannot wait to see where Sterling takes us next.
Review of advance copy
This is the third in a series following PI Hannah. While this can be read as a standalone, I believe that if you read the first two, you will have the character backgrounds to enjoy this to its fullest.
This time, she is called to help her estranged mother. Her step-sister, whom she barely knows, has disappeared, and they fear she has joined a cult. Not a small cult for sure, but one that not only owns and controls the compound, but the town and its officials as well.
Hannah joins forces with another PI and a former member. Together, they hope to find and bring home Hannah's sister Emily.
The author writes at a fast pace, but also does not leave you wanting for details. Love the characters. As stated in the titles - fear is prominent in the writing of these stories. Thanks to BookSirens for the ARC of this book.
This time, she is called to help her estranged mother. Her step-sister, whom she barely knows, has disappeared, and they fear she has joined a cult. Not a small cult for sure, but one that not only owns and controls the compound, but the town and its officials as well.
Hannah joins forces with another PI and a former member. Together, they hope to find and bring home Hannah's sister Emily.
The author writes at a fast pace, but also does not leave you wanting for details. Love the characters. As stated in the titles - fear is prominent in the writing of these stories. Thanks to BookSirens for the ARC of this book.
February 2, 2026
I love this series.
Starting point, a Terrific lead character- Hannah. She is center stage in the third book of this series.
Hannah is a flawed character but you fall for her as she is human and she is the most interesting person on paper.
Hannah has suffered great loss and although this is a series this book does standalone.
The reader is caught up on the background and a new chapter begins. Hannah is a private investigator and is often called upon to help find those who are missing. When her estranged mother seeks her help to find Hannah’s stepsister, she takes on the assignment.
But this case takes her to a cult like facility led by a man who is not only bad but evil.
Hannah sets out to find her stepsister but this is not an easy task and her very life may be on the line. She finds herself looking directly at evil and she may have no way out of the situation.
5 stars
Starting point, a Terrific lead character- Hannah. She is center stage in the third book of this series.
Hannah is a flawed character but you fall for her as she is human and she is the most interesting person on paper.
Hannah has suffered great loss and although this is a series this book does standalone.
The reader is caught up on the background and a new chapter begins. Hannah is a private investigator and is often called upon to help find those who are missing. When her estranged mother seeks her help to find Hannah’s stepsister, she takes on the assignment.
But this case takes her to a cult like facility led by a man who is not only bad but evil.
Hannah sets out to find her stepsister but this is not an easy task and her very life may be on the line. She finds herself looking directly at evil and she may have no way out of the situation.
5 stars
February 11, 2026
I have really enjoyed this series over the years and was thrilled to get my hands on this.
Hannah is such a great character to follow with her complexities yet relatability and she gave me all the laughs and heartache once again on her mission to find a missing young woman.
Sterling is really great at tapping into family dynamics and dysfunction. I felt discomfort for Hannah in so many ways as she dealt with family members. On the flip side, those she can count on are the easy going, no pressure, loyal ones that are written so concise that you can’t help but count on them too.
Of course, this wouldn’t fit the series without keeping me on my toes, fearful and shocked at times, tense and dying for answers in other moments.
I love that these can be read as standalones but highly recommend the series!
Hannah is such a great character to follow with her complexities yet relatability and she gave me all the laughs and heartache once again on her mission to find a missing young woman.
Sterling is really great at tapping into family dynamics and dysfunction. I felt discomfort for Hannah in so many ways as she dealt with family members. On the flip side, those she can count on are the easy going, no pressure, loyal ones that are written so concise that you can’t help but count on them too.
Of course, this wouldn’t fit the series without keeping me on my toes, fearful and shocked at times, tense and dying for answers in other moments.
I love that these can be read as standalones but highly recommend the series!
January 20, 2026
This is the third book in the Hannah Jacobs, P.I. series. I've read the first two, and I think readers might benefit from reading them. I also think that it works as a standalone.
I don't cover the plot in my reviews, as it is readily available. Also, this lets me avoid spoilers.
The first section of the book did not thrill me and kept me from awarding a fifth star. Once the main plot begins, the story is fast-paced, chilling, and hard to put down.
The book is well written and proofread. I recommend it. But be warned that there are evil people and acts. That, plus a high degree of tension, makes it not for the faint of heart.
I received a free advance review copy, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I don't cover the plot in my reviews, as it is readily available. Also, this lets me avoid spoilers.
The first section of the book did not thrill me and kept me from awarding a fifth star. Once the main plot begins, the story is fast-paced, chilling, and hard to put down.
The book is well written and proofread. I recommend it. But be warned that there are evil people and acts. That, plus a high degree of tension, makes it not for the faint of heart.
I received a free advance review copy, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
January 21, 2026
(I received an advanced reader copy of this book in exchange for my review)
I really enjoyed this book! The build up was well-paced and kept me wanting to know what was going to happen next. Characters were decent.
I noticed some punctuation errors in the book, but not sure if it was due to the formatting as I was reading it on my Kobo Libra.
The ending felt too fast/rushed, and kind of filler-y.
After reading the first book and then this one (I skipped the second one as I don't have it), and the bridge between the first and third book felt fluid, although I did miss some important details from the second book in the series. I didn't mind, although other people might.
Overall, I enjoyed it!
I really enjoyed this book! The build up was well-paced and kept me wanting to know what was going to happen next. Characters were decent.
I noticed some punctuation errors in the book, but not sure if it was due to the formatting as I was reading it on my Kobo Libra.
The ending felt too fast/rushed, and kind of filler-y.
After reading the first book and then this one (I skipped the second one as I don't have it), and the bridge between the first and third book felt fluid, although I did miss some important details from the second book in the series. I didn't mind, although other people might.
Overall, I enjoyed it!
January 22, 2026
The Fear of Drowning follows Hannah into what may be her most dangerous investigation yet. S.C. Sterling’s descriptions pulled me right into the story, and I really enjoyed returning to a time without modern cell phones or today’s technology, which added to the atmosphere. While this book works well as a standalone, I think it’s even more rewarding when read as part of the series, since it gives added depth to Hannah’s past.
There were a few minor typos, but nothing that detracted from the reading experience. The story has a slow, steady buildup to the climax, followed by a faster ending, though all questions are answered and there are no plot holes. Overall, this is a solid, engaging, and quick read that fans of the series will likely enjoy.
There were a few minor typos, but nothing that detracted from the reading experience. The story has a slow, steady buildup to the climax, followed by a faster ending, though all questions are answered and there are no plot holes. Overall, this is a solid, engaging, and quick read that fans of the series will likely enjoy.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Thank you to S.C. Sterling for a digital ARC copy of this novel!
The Fear of Drowning was the perfect next step in The Fear of series from S.C. Sterling. Drowning picks up right where Fire left off in the plot. Hannah Jacobs, private investigator, continues to do her work of digging into the cold cases brought forward to her. This case being unique in that her step-sister has been drawn into a cult, not missing as in the previous books of the series. The story follows Hannah as she treks across the United States on the trail to infiltrate the cult to help her step-sister.
I really liked this book and found that it dug further into Hannah's insecurities and was very impressed with the historical references Sterling utilized to add more substance to the story.
The Fear of Drowning was the perfect next step in The Fear of series from S.C. Sterling. Drowning picks up right where Fire left off in the plot. Hannah Jacobs, private investigator, continues to do her work of digging into the cold cases brought forward to her. This case being unique in that her step-sister has been drawn into a cult, not missing as in the previous books of the series. The story follows Hannah as she treks across the United States on the trail to infiltrate the cult to help her step-sister.
I really liked this book and found that it dug further into Hannah's insecurities and was very impressed with the historical references Sterling utilized to add more substance to the story.
Review of advance copy received from Author
S.C. Sterling delivers a gripping read. It pulls you instantly into the world of thriller. The first scene had me squirming with fear for a brief period. But as a reader, I had to see things through.
Readers could tell that the author had done extensive research to help bring his storyline to life. You could feel the gripping tension from the characters. It felt abundantly real. The storyline haunted me and kept me fully engaged to know what happened next. Even the book’s ending left me completely satisfied. The conclusion didn’t leave loose ends. It was perfection. I enjoyed reading the book.
I highly recommend The Fear of Drowning to your “To Be Read” list. Outstanding storytelling!
Readers could tell that the author had done extensive research to help bring his storyline to life. You could feel the gripping tension from the characters. It felt abundantly real. The storyline haunted me and kept me fully engaged to know what happened next. Even the book’s ending left me completely satisfied. The conclusion didn’t leave loose ends. It was perfection. I enjoyed reading the book.
I highly recommend The Fear of Drowning to your “To Be Read” list. Outstanding storytelling!
Review of advance copy received from Storygraph
After the first two books in the series, I had high expectations for the third. It's a bit slower paced in some parts, but for me that just fed the tension and anticipation. It was a gripping story with well-developed characters and skilled handling of very dark themes. Hannah Jacobs is very realistically written, with flaws and weaknesses that are easy to identify with. I did feel a bit of a disconnect between the beginning section where she's traveling and the rest of the book, and after finishing it I wished there had been a smoother transition. Overall, though, I thoroughly enjoyed the book and hope for more "fears" from Sterling in the future.
Thank you to StoryGraph and S.C. Sterling for the ARC. All views are my own.
Thank you to StoryGraph and S.C. Sterling for the ARC. All views are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Author
The Fear Of series gets better with each book! As with the second book, this one is Hannah-focused, but this time with her stepfamily. Hannah's mother reaches out, asking her to help locate her sister who is part of a cult, and, being Hannah, she ultimately takes the case.
As someone who is fascinated with cults, this book just sucked me in! The situation and characters come across as realistic where you could see someone in your life or in a documentary. Like, some people *want* to be there and truly believe in the cause. I laughed, I grew frustrated, scared, and relieved. And that's what I like in a book, to feel things.
Overall, I really enjoyed this book and recommend for a cult-based thriller!
As someone who is fascinated with cults, this book just sucked me in! The situation and characters come across as realistic where you could see someone in your life or in a documentary. Like, some people *want* to be there and truly believe in the cause. I laughed, I grew frustrated, scared, and relieved. And that's what I like in a book, to feel things.
Overall, I really enjoyed this book and recommend for a cult-based thriller!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 60 reviews