An incredible and unputdownable YA thriller, with incredible twists and turns that will have you guessing until the very last page, from the author of "Silent Sister" – perfect for fans of Holly Jackson and Karen McManus.
When I first heard that the author of Silent Sisters was releasing a brand-new novel, I could hardly contain my excitement. I immediately hit that request button on NetGalley with all the enthusiasm in the world, practically begging the bookish universe to grant my wish. When the approval landed in my inbox, I didn’t even pause to read the synopsis—I dove straight in. The eerie, beautifully designed cover already hinted at the unsettling ride ahead. And the title Gaslit? A brilliant choice that works on multiple levels, reflecting both the literal danger and the manipulative emotional currents running through the story. From the opening chapter, I braced myself for sharp twists and dark turns—this author never delivers a straightforward mystery—and sure enough, I was hit with layers of intrigue, suspicion, and heartbreak.
The story follows Ella, a young woman already battling a devastating brain tumor diagnosis. Determined to stay strong, she cancels her New Year’s Eve plans with her best friend Sierra and agrees to help her beloved Aunt Julie by babysitting her little cousin Joey. But what seems like a quiet evening quickly unravels into a nightmare. The house is dark, the door is ajar, and a faint smell of gas lingers in the air. Ella discovers her cousins and aunt unconscious inside, dragging the children to safety—but tragically losing her aunt in the process.
Though authorities at first call it an accident, Ella’s instincts tell her otherwise. Wracked with grief, she begins investigating on her own. Her search soon collides with Dominic, the troubled next-door neighbor, who has his own conflicts with Ella’s teenage cousin Chris. Together, Ella and Dominic uncover threads of insurance fraud, family secrets, and motives darker than she could have imagined. Meanwhile, anonymous threats arrive, warning Ella to stop digging. But she refuses, driven by loyalty to the woman who was like a second mother to her—even as the strain worsens her health and pushes her to the brink.
What makes this story so compelling is its balance between external suspense and Ella’s deeply personal battle. Her migraines, exhaustion, and vulnerability mirror the claustrophobic danger of a house filled with gas. She’s a protagonist whose body may be failing, but whose spirit refuses to quit. That emotional duality is where the book truly shines.
Now, I’ll admit—I didn’t find Gaslit quite as jaw-droppingly clever as Silent Sisters. I guessed several twists and even spotted the culprit before the final reveal. But that doesn’t mean the journey wasn’t gripping. In fact, one late-game twist completely blindsided me, making me gasp out loud. The last quarter is where the book fully delivers on its promise, tying threads together in a way that is both shocking and satisfying.
Overall: Gaslit is a dark, chilling psychological thriller that left me unsettled—in the best way. It’s about grief, loyalty, and how far one young woman will go to uncover the truth, even when her own life hangs in the balance. While I still hold Silent Sisters as my personal favorite, this sophomore novel proves the author is no one-hit wonder. The writing is sharp, the pacing quick, and Ella is a heroine readers won’t easily forget.
A huge thank you to NetGalley and Random House Children’s Books / Delacorte Press for providing me with this ARC. I truly appreciate the chance to continue reading this author’s haunting, twist-filled stories—and I’ll eagerly line up for whatever comes next.
Oh man. This started off super strong, but got a little unhinged towards the end
What Worked: Megan Davidhizar's writing is definitely meant for writing thrillers. I found the overall narrative to be intriguing from the very beginning of the book. Typically, it takes me up until around the 20 percent mark to truly feel invested in both the stories and the characters. From the very beginning Davidhizar created an eerie atmosphere where the reader isn't exactly sure what to believe.
What Didn't Work: The reveals in this book felt slightly underwhelming and confusing. I believe that Davidhizar attempted to utilize the unreliable narrator trope in a way that felt jumbled or unorganized. She spent too much time attempting to confuse the reader to the point that it didn't land as well as intended. There also should have been a little more emphasis on the character development. Though I enjoyed the pacing, I do feel as though I would have rated this one a little higher if I better understood the characters.
Overall, this was a solid read and works well for those who are just getting into thrillers/mysteries.
• Unreliable narrator / questioning perception; • Psychological thriller; • Mystery investigation; • Red herrings and twists; • Small town / close community intrigue; • Personal struggle influencing truth-seeking.
Review:
"Gaslit" is an enthralling young adult thriller that captivates readers from the outset and maintains a high level of suspense throughout. The narrative centers on Ella Forrester, a high school student balancing the challenges of everyday life with the burden of a recent medical diagnosis. A seemingly normal babysitting evening spirals into chaos when she discovers her aunt's house with the door ajar, an odd smell of gas in the air, and her relatives unconscious inside. While she successfully rescues the children, her aunt tragically does not survive. What begins as an accidental tragedy soon raises suspicions of foul play.
One of the aspects I appreciated most about "Gaslit" is its ability to intertwine mystery with personal turmoil and emotional depth. Ella’s struggles with migraines and a brain tumor diagnosis are not mere background elements; they shape her worldview, alter her interactions with others, and impact her trust in her instincts. This internal battle adds complexity to the central mystery: was the gas leak truly an accident, or is there someone intent on harming her family?
The story unfolds at a brisk pace, complemented by enough red herrings and unexpected twists to keep readers on their toes. The first-person perspective immerses you in Ella’s thoughts, making the uncertainty feel palpable. There were several surprises that caught me off guard, and the escalating tension towards the end of the book was particularly engaging. While some elements may feel familiar to those well-versed in YA thrillers, the emotional core: embodied by Ella's grief, guilt, and resolve gives it a unique identity and distinguishes it from others in the genre.
In summary, "Gaslit" is a gripping, twist-laden read that keeps you engaged with both the unfolding mystery and Ella’s personal journey.
• ya psychological thriller • slow-burn mystery suspense • traumatic experience • brain tumor • grief • unreliable narrator • emotional family drama • single POV
My enjoyment as an adult reader who can still enjoy YA: 3 stars. What I feel it objectively deserves: 3.75 stars. This started strong but lost me in the latter half. Things got muddled, and I stopped caring about the outcome.
Thanks to Netgalley and Delacorte Press for the ARC!
Ella’s last-minute favor for her aunt turned into a nightmare the moment she pulled up to the house. Instead of a fun evening of babysitting, she discovered her aunt and cousins sprawled across the floor, rendered unconscious by a silent, deadly gas leak. But the nightmare didn't end there; it was merely the opening act for the chaos that followed. As the situation spirals out of control, a chilling question emerges: if the gas leak wasn't an accident who started it?
I absolutely love the use of an unreliable narrator! It constantly made me question what was real and what wasn’t. The story kept me on the edge of my seat from beginning to end, delivering twist after twist that completely upended my expectations. Just when I thought I had figured things out, the story proved me wrong again. The character development was especially compelling, and I felt a strong connection to Ella and her unwavering love for her family. This is a gripping, fast-paced mystery and a perfect recommendation for middle and high school readers looking for a thrilling read.
A twisty thriller that left me guessing with every turn.
It's New Year's eve and Ella, trying to not dwell on her recent diagnosis, has to miss the big party with her friends due to a migraine. But when it passes and she receives a call from her aunt to babysit her cousin, she jumps at the chance to still go out for the night. When she arrives at the house to meet up, what she finds it horrifying and shocking and pushes Ella to find out what happened.
This was an interesting mystery, layered with Ella's recent diagnosis muddying the waters. I liked the shocking start, the way I was never sure what was true, and the twists. I liked Ella as our narrator and the way she tried to hard to take care of her family. It was a quick read and I flipped this to an audiobook and the narrator was great. Another great YA thriller and a good summer mystery.
A huge thank you to the author and publisher for providing an e-ARC via Netgalley. This does not affect my opinion regarding the book.
Ella, who has a brain tumor, loses her beloved aunt Julie in a house fire on New Year’s Eve. Ella rescues her teenage cousin Chris and his seven-year-old brother Joey, wracked with guilt she couldn’t save Julie. Deemed arson by purposely cut gas line, Ella and Chris do their own shadow investigation. Their prime suspect, Julie’s boyfriend. Soon Ella doesn’t know who she can trust, including herself.
Megan Davidhizar’s sophomore novel, GASLIT, is every bit as good as her debut SILENT SISTER. Ella’s brain tumor adds an element to her already complex character, making me question her reliability at times. The secrecy surrounding her condition Ella insisted on keeping pushed friends away.
Davidhizar’s clever use of the title GASLIT made me wonder whether the word was meant literally, from the gas fire or figuratively or perhaps both.
What a dud. I honestly can't remember the last time I was this disappointed by a book. It started with such a creative, high-stakes opening that included a death by gas leak where Ella, the niece of one of the victims tries to save everyone in the house while battling the fumes herself. It had all the makings of a unique thriller but that promise evaporated quicker than the gasleak itself I'll tell you that.
We learn early on that Ella has a brain tumor which causes among many other things migraines, memory loss and hallucinations. She has to navigate these symptoms while acting as an amateur sleuth to determine if the leak was intentional or not. This could have been one hell of a layered, psychological mystery. Instead, it went off the rails the moment the investigation started. The "unreliable narrator" trope felt like a cheap cheat code here. Because Ella is hallucinating, the author could throw in far-fetched or illogical plot points and then just wave them away as symptoms rather than actual writing. It felt unfair to me as the reader as we didn't know what was real or not so nothing carried any real weight.
Beyond that, the characters were painfully dull. There wasn't a single interesting person outside of Ella and the suspects were so under-developed that I couldn't even bother wasting my time guessing who was actually responsible. There was also a specific misdirection with one of the characters that was blatantly obvious from the jump and it wasn't clever or creative, just distracting. The middle portion was a slow crawl through the mud that failed to take the main plot by the horns. There were so many cool directions this could have gone, even making Ella herself a more sinister part of the plot due to her deteriorating mental state but the author missed them all.
This story gaslights you into believing that it's more than meets the eye but ultimately fails to light the pilot instead.
OMG this book made me laugh and had my jaw on the floor it was so intense and everything I had a good time with this one it was so good and I felt for the characters but the stuff Chris did was honestly so shocking and surprising but I didn’t want him to die but going toward the end he’s going to face the punishment of murdering Blake for the rest of his life the last few pages of him crying out he has nobody is sad because he knows that he’s not a kid but an adult so his life would be in prison because Joey being the kid has Ella’s parents so he would cope with Ella but he wouldn’t be able be with brother again for life which is heartbreaking 💔
Davidhizar wrote a thriller that almost made you wanted to jump into the book and save these characters from the pain and trauma they’ve been going through and Ella was such a lovely FMC sometimes she made mistakes but I adored the brain representation of Brain tumor the way Davidhizar wrote it made me empathy for her I truly loved this book that I can’t wait to see what journey next Megan takes on with her YA thrillers because they’re honestly so good and gripping!
Absolutely loved the main character for multiple reasons: a) she was consistent, tried to get the most out of a situation and tried to find out the truth no matter the cost b) she had migraines!!! I loved the rep because unfortunately, lots of people deal with headaches and migraines on the daily so having a character that has to do a murder investigation while dealing with this seemed so real and "refreshing" c) she focused on her family instead of the romantic interest
The plot itself was unique and haven't seen one like this despite reading YA mysteries like crazy. Even though I guessed one of the big twists, there are so many of them that you're bound to be surprised in any case lol.
This is one of those books that after reading it the first time and then knowing what you know you want to immediately re-read it and have a completely different experience the second time through. Wowzers!
Great book! Plot was good, so was the pacing. Kept me interested and guessing. The one I thought was the murderer was not actually it, so good deception. A little juvenile but that’s refreshing sometimes. Very interesting!
Thank you to NetGalley for the opportunity to read this advanced copy.
My first read by this author and it did not disappoint.
Good character development and fast paced that sucked me in right away. I will definitely recommend to all my YA readers. Plot twists, psychological thiller and romantic interest. Perfect mix for my students.
4.5 Because I knew who it was, but I enjoyed this. And unfortunately I can’t tell you my favorite part because it’s a spoiler 🤦🏾♀️🤣 Real review to come to my blog.
This book was really hard to get in to. However the last 75 pages or so saved it. I did guess the twist early on, but not in the way it was eventually made out
sounded good, but wasn’t. took me ages to read this for one reason and another, but didn’t enjoy it. 2.5* . When a gas leak kills Julie and affects her two sons, it is seen as a terrible tragedy, but was the true gas leak the one they found? was it done on purpose? and who was meant to be the victim?
Gaslit by Megan Davidhizar is a YA psychological thriller about Ella, a teenager who survives a New Year’s Eve gas leak that kills her aunt and injures her cousins. Ella becomes convinced the leak wasn’t an accident and starts investigating on her own, all while dealing with a recent brain tumor diagnosis that affects her memory, energy, and sense of what’s real. As her symptoms worsen, the people around her insist she’s imagining things, making her especially vulnerable to being gaslit.
The premise is strong. A medically vulnerable teen who suspects something terrible while everyone else dismisses her is a compelling setup, especially for a story about who gets believed. Early on, the book does a good job showing Ella’s exhaustion, pain, guilt, and determination, and those elements give the mystery some emotional weight. Unfortunately, the execution didn’t quite work for me. The writing often spells things out instead of letting scenes speak for themselves, with a lot of internal monologue explaining Ella’s thoughts and suspicions. This becomes more noticeable toward the end, where clues and motivations are repeated, which drains tension instead of building it.
The structure is where the book really lost me. For most of the story, the plot moves along clearly: Ella investigates, adults don’t believe her, and her fear grows. Then, near the end, several twists come very quickly. Instead of feeling clever, they felt rushed and a bit messy. The final section stacks multiple reversals on top of each other, and rather than everything clicking into place, it felt like the book was trying out several endings at once. Because the main twist is hinted at so heavily, it was easy to guess well before the story treated it as a big reveal.
I also struggled with the characterization. Ella is clearly meant to be brave, determined, and flawed in a relatable way, but her voice often came across as self-righteous and frustrating. Moments where she might question herself or reflect on her own mistakes are usually glossed over, which makes her feel less complex than the story seems to want her to be. Most of the side characters exist mainly to serve the mystery, and their behavior shifts late in the book don’t always feel earned because we don’t spend enough time understanding them.
Thematically, the book takes on some meaningful ideas, especially disability, faith, and the way teenage girls are dismissed by adults. The disability representation is one of its stronger points. Ella’s illness and treatment affect her daily life in realistic ways, and for much of the book this feels thoughtful and grounded. The problem is that near the end, her condition starts to feel more like a plot tool than a fully integrated part of her character. The faith elements work better overall. Religion is present in a clear but low-key way that fits the story, and it never feels preachy.
Overall, Gaslit reads like a fast-paced YA thriller with a lot of heart but uneven execution. It has a gripping concept and moves quickly, especially at the start, but the over-explaining, crowded twists, and occasionally grating narrator kept it from fully working for me. That said, it’s clear the author cares deeply about the subjects she’s writing about, and she has a knack for high-concept ideas. With tighter editing and more trust in the reader, future books could really shine.
Even better than the author's first book! I met the author during events for Silent Sister and Gaslit. During the event for Gaslit, the author mentioned that she had originally written this book with two perspectives before switching it to one. I loved a single perspective. I think it made the story so much more suspenseful. I actually only kind-of guessed the ending of the book (which is quite good for me). I was off a bit and it was fascinating to see how everything was woven together. Now, I'll hand off this book to family and friends as many have already asked to borrow my copy.
4 Stars
Clean and recommended for teens
*I did receive a copy of this book while attending the event. This isn't my typical disclaimer, but I feel like I must add it.
It was good. The whole medical issue aspect mixed with a murder mystery is always fun. i I usually hate books when they make the female look like she's crazy but in this case... it was warranted. Being desperate for money can make people do crazy things.
Ella suffers migraines and has had a hard time getting people to take her pain seriously. She is fiercely independent and doesn’t want anyone giving her special treatment which is why hardly anyone knows that her migraines are actually caused by a brain tumour.
It’s New Years Eve and Ella agrees to babysit for her cousin Joey but when she reaches the house the door is open and she can smell gas. She tries to rescue both her cousins but fails to save her aunt.
With the help of a cute but dangerous neighbour she attempts to figure out who would try to hurt her family. But once people start to learn of her illness they begin to look at her differently. Can she fight to be believed while also fighting to survive?
The first half of the book will have you gripped trying to figure out what happened and who was behind it while the second half will keep you up all night second guessing what is real and what is in Ella’s head.
Fantastically written, you can’t help but feel connected to Ella as she starts to question everything she knows and wonder who she can trust. The frustration of not having her pain taken seriously is palpable and you really feel for her when even the people closest to her start to doubt if she’s even telling the truth.
The only downfall for me was the level of emotional intelligence the writer gives to the 6 year old boy in the story. His level of understanding of adult conversations and his calm placidness in the face of massive trauma just didn’t ring true for me and my experience with children. I feel like maybe if he had been older I might have believed his reactions more.
Despite that, I became absolutely swallowed by this story and could not put it down. The twists were brilliantly incorporated giving you just enough hints to create the same confusion in the reader as the characters are experiencing.