A NATIONAL BESTSELLER A Globe and Mail Best Book of Summer 2026 One of CBC's 'Canadian Fiction Books We're Excited About This Fall'
Bestselling, award-winning, Canada-Reads finalist (for The Hero's Walk) Anita Rau Badami showcases her extraordinary storytelling gifts in this entertaining tale set in India and Montreal.
Asha Mohan's backyard garden in Montréal, shaded by a cherished maple tree, has been her sanctuary since she and her husband moved to Canada from India decades ago. It is here that Asha finds refuge from the trials of her now-grown children, and exchanges gossip and advice over a shared hedge with Madame Brard, her formidable neighbour who took Asha under her wing long ago. The magnificent tree also marks the spot where—twenty years ago, on the evening of her 50th birthday—Asha was knocked unconscious by an unsavoury drug-dealing acquaintance of her wayward son. Now, as Asha turns 70, the maple tree has reached its end and must be cut down. In its shadow, Asha finds herself remembering the attack of twenty years back and haunted by an earlier, shocking tragedy in India, one that caused her to flee the country of her birth. As Asha re-examines herself, her reconfigured garden, and her relations with friends, enemies, and loved ones (“two children from the same body – mine – and each a complete stranger”), she unearths new clarity about who she is and what might be required of her now—a vision with the power to transform her life. Anita Rau Badami delights us in this big-hearted, compulsively readable and relatable novel about mysteries, ambitions, misunderstandings and miracles that ricochet and echo through a close-knit family and the woman at its centre.
This novel focuses on fierce and irascible 70-year-old Asha Mohan, Bangalore-born and immigrant to Montreal, coming to terms with herself and her family. The story opens with a beloved, now diseased, old tree in her garden being cut down and Asha’s decision to hold a party, not to celebrate or or commemorate the change, but to acknowledge a kind of acceptance of life as it has unfolded—of old age, past errors, and family members for being who they are: her manipulative and rivalrous cousin, Meru; her wayward son, Dilip (on whom she blamed the death of her younger son, Gautam, many years before); her husband, Surash (from whom she has become estranged); and her daughter, Anjali, an accomplished visual artist.
Badami provides the reader with Asha’s early story, which includes the childhood loss of her father to cancer and Asha and her mother’s being taken in by her mother’s brother, an act much resented by her vindictive aunt and jealous cousin. Key to the story is a traumatic event, which Asha endured in the garden of her Montreal home on the day of her fiftieth birthday twenty years before—an event linked to her ne’er-do-well son, Dilip. Badami enlivens her narrative by providing separate chapters from the perspectives of the other important players in Asha’s life. We even get the point of view of a former landlady, who saw in the younger Asha something of herself.
While I enjoyed this book enough to complete it, I had some problems with Asha in Her Garden and found the execution—especially the tone—slightly uneven.
First of all, a niggle about a persistent grammatical error: Badami uses the subjective relative pronoun “who” when the objective one, “whom”, is required. I’m surprised a copy editor did not catch this.
Second problem: there’s an over-the-top, intentionally farcical section about the main character’s son, Dilip, who is supposed to be babysitting a dog as a favour to a friend, the son of a wealthy couple. Dilip’s neglect is the cause of the animal’s death. I loathe books in which animal suffering is made light of (or, in this case, used in an attempt to create a comic effect). Badami’s description of the character’s stuffing the very ill animal into a large suitcase to transport it in a taxi (so it won’t foul the seats) is not at all funny; it’s just disturbing. Surely the author could have come up with a better plot device than this to expose the young man’s complete and total irresponsibility. We are later expected to believe that Dilip reforms, becoming the millionaire owner of a chain-store dog-grooming business named for the dog he killed two decades before.
Third, if a person is taken to the ER after a fall and a CT reveals a subdural hematoma, a neurosurgeon, not a neurologist, is immediately called in.
What I’ve identified as problematic may not bother other readers. However, I feel the novel was diminished by these issues.
Written with exquisite, painterly detail, this book is composed of the reminiscences of the matriarch, Asha, now in her 70s and content, about the storms of her life. Her life is cleaved into two time periods, marked by tragedy --. This event had longstanding ripples on her and her family's life, not least of all as it triggered her determination to uproot her family to emigrate to Montreal. Asha is a complex character, she was quite bitter and unsatisfied, but one of the many talents of this novel is it really helps us to see how her bitterness was justified even as it was directed towards many fronts: her traumatized and aimless surviving son, her mellow husband, her competitive cousin. It's a beautiful family saga anchored by a tree in their house, witness to the family issues, that's now scheduled for removal, for more trees and vegetable gardens to come, in a good metaphor for the adaptability of life.
Title: Asha in Her Garden Author: Anita Rau Badami Genre: Literary Rating: 3.25 Pub Date: August 11, 2026
I received a complimentary eARC from Penguin Random House Canada via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. #Gifted
T H R E E • W O R D S
Rooted • Vivid • Unstructured
📖 S Y N O P S I S
Asha Mohan's backyard garden in Montréal, shaded by a cherished maple tree, has been her sanctuary since she and her husband moved to Canada from India decades ago. It is here that Asha finds refuge from the trials of her now-grown children, and exchanges gossip and advice over a shared hedge with Madame Brard, her formidable neighbour who took Asha under her wing long ago. The magnificent tree also marks the spot where—twenty years ago, on the evening of her 50th birthday—Asha was knocked unconscious by an unsavoury drug-dealing acquaintance of her wayward son.
Now, as Asha turns 70, the maple tree has reached its end and must be cut down. In its shadow, Asha finds herself remembering the attack of twenty years back and haunted by an earlier, shocking tragedy in India, one that caused her to flee the country of her birth. As Asha re-examines herself, her reconfigured garden, and her relations with friends, enemies, and loved ones (“two children from the same body – mine – and each a complete stranger”), she unearths new clarity about who she is and what might be required of her now—a vision with the power to transform her life.
💭 T H O U G H T S
I was excited to get an early copy of celebrated Canadian author, Anita Rau Badami's highly anticipated 2026 release, Asha in Her Garden. Everything about this book screamed my name and I was excited to pick up a book set partially in Montreal. Despite this author having previously appeared as one of the contenders on Canada Reads, it was my first time picking up one of her books.
I'll start out by saying that I really liked the meat of this story. Asha was fierce and determined with an interesting history and I truly appreciated how her garden became her refuge and how the metaphor of cutting down the tree played into the narrative. It was both creative and reflective and there was depth of character and plot. It's a beautiful exploration of what it's like to build a life in a new place while continuing to carry the traumas of the past and the messy/complicated relationships between ageing parents and their adult children.
However, my biggest struggle with this book is how it is structured, which made for quite the bumpy reading experience. There are four main sections, with half a dozen shifting perspectives within each, but no real indication of these shifts. Oftentimes there are also shifts in space (Montreal to India and vice versa) but they weren't always evident. This book would have benefitted from a more structured style, which in turn would have made for a smoother ride.
It's unfortunate that the structure (or lack thereof) made Asha in Her Garden difficult to navigate, but it was hard to ignore. The story itself was filled with relatable family drama and reflections on a life lived. Despite taking issue with the structure here, I could definitely see myself picking up something by this author again.
📚 R E A D • I F • Y O U • L I K E • Anita Rau Badami's work • family dramas • immigrant stories
⚠️ CW: death, child death, grief, animal death, medical content, medical trauma, injury/injury detail, violence, drug trafficking, anxiety, strained familial relationships
I’ve read all of Anita Rau Badami’s novels (Tamarind Mem, The Hero’s Walk, Can You Hear the Nightbird Call? and Tell it to the Trees) and have enjoyed them all. Asha in Her Garden, the latest, after a 15-year hiatus, is no exception.
The novel begins with seventy-year-old Asha Mohan witnessing the cutting down of an old maple tree in her Montreal back yard. This tree shaded her beloved garden, her sanctuary since she and her husband Suresh bought the house after moving from India decades earlier. The tree’s removal serves as an impetus for Asha’s examining her life, all the way back to her childhood in Bangalore, its joys and sorrows, and her relationships with her family. She wonders if she can change those things she doesn’t like. Can she reconfigure her life just as the removal of the tree reconfigures her garden?
It is the character of Asha that is central to the book. She is a complex, authentic character. She is what would be termed “a force to be reckoned with.” From an early age, she decides “She would be loud and demanding, a force in a world where noisy and pushy and forceful equalled success.” And she is certainly successful in her career. Her son Dilip thinks of his mother as indomitable, noisy, and strong. Suresh fell in love with “her independent nature, her sharp mind, her strength and willingness to take chances.”
But we also see Asha’s flaws. She is a proud person who angers easily. Added to these is her inability to apologize. Suresh comments, “That was her problem. She could not bring herself to admit she was wrong.” As one would expect, these traits affect her relationships with her family, especially Suresh, Dilip, and her cousin Meru. Asha herself also comes to realize that her desire to be independent caused her to make some poor choices: “Now she resented everyone in her family because she had made the wrong choices – she knew it was unfair of her, but she could not stop being angry.” There is no doubt that she loves her family, but she is also often annoyed by them. All of this makes her relatable.
There are several themes. One is a lesson Asha is taught by her uncle: “’What you see . . . or hear . . . is usually not the true nature of a thing.’” She seems to learn this lesson, later commenting, “How you describe a thing depends on how you look at it, and there were as many ways of looking at a thing as there were leaves on a tree.”
What remains with me is the comments about life. Life is not easy. At times it can feel, like Asha’s garden, a ruined landscape, but at other times, “like her perennials which went down every year and then burgeoned back,” life brings joys. When faced with death, Asha decides, “Life was amazing. It was magic. It was this tiny seed of hope, converted into all manner of things.” Change is inevitable, but even when it seems undesirable it can be positive. For example, the cutting of the tree brings “a vast openness” full of potential. Life is all about “The keeping, the letting go. Breathing in and breathing out. You do these things to live when you have breath, and when your life is done, you let go.”
I enjoyed this novel. It’s beautifully written with many descriptions of flowers and trees which serve as metaphors for Asha’s life. And its comments about life are as relatable as is the character of the flawed but admirable Asha.
Note: I received an eARC from the publisher via NetGalley.
A book of life.. farewells, struggles, redemption, success and forgiveness and love. Masterful in telling . A great read to learn about human frailties and strengths enclosed it a beautiful life
This one is a challenge for me to review. It begins with a large diseased tree having to be removed from the garden of the house where 70-year-old Asha and her family have lived in Montreal since they moved from Bangladore forty years previously. That sad change offers the possibility of new and different life being brought to a space that will now be more sunlit, which can be seen as a metaphor for the book’s revisiting of the sudden and sometimes violent changes that have occurred in Asha’s own life and those of her husband and children. Somehow that metaphor didn’t entirely work for me.
I appreciate that Asha is a fully developed character with a fierce temperament and an inability to see her own faults, which makes her sometimes act very unkindly, out of anger - but it also makes it hard for a reader to like her. Her daughter, however, seems to be able to brush off her behavior with no problem. Asha’s particularly hard on her son Dilip, blaming him unfairly for the death of his brother when they were both very young, and Dilip grows into an irresponsible young man whose actions result in the death of a dog in his care. Maybe it’s the subsequent total change in Dilip that’s hardest for me to swallow because we never know him well.
Having said all that (in an attempt to work out my own reaction), the book is beautifully written, particularly in terms of its description of the garden and I continue to be a fan of Anita Rau Badami.
This is an interesting immigrant story. Asha is a very strong woman who is able to overcome a lot of adversity in her life including the loss of a son, a move from India to Canada that was challenging and people whom she had to support in so many ways. It is great that it is on the Giller short list. Clearly, the book required a lot of thought. There are many unique aspects to the book—that don’t always get presented in immigrant stories. Asha made the transition successfully. She had a strong mentor (and land lady). Her husband and son managed to turn their lives around. Her daughter was able to pursue her art. I don’t always like books that tie up all the loose ends. But for this book, it seemed important to conclude with Asha turning 70 and her and the readers both knowing that things could work out in a reasonable fashion. I like to identify themes in case I need them for a book group discussion. For this book, some of the themes might be: Life transitions, life and death of a tree as a metaphor, family love and loss, growth and change, neighbor/mentor support, dealing with imperfect family members, success and what success looks like at different times in one’s life and within one’s family. I wish Anita Raj Badami all the best re the Giller Prize.
Have I said how much I adore reading anything by Anita Rau Badami?
This one did not disappoint - I thoroughly enjoyed it. Indeed i loved it.
In this she does what she does best: Write about real people working through the complicated web of familial relationships impacted by the legacy of colonialism. In this case, against the backdrop of being a member of an immigrant community, in Montreal.
I’m so glad that the long wait is over. How long til the next title? Hopefully not 15 more years!
Thanks to the publisher and Edelweiss for granting me access to an early digital review copy.
No es que sea la historia más novedosa que haya leído, pero el hilo conductor está muy bien armado. Los personajes son muy humanos, y tienen dudas en cuanto a ellos mismos, sus relaciones familiares y su posición en el mundo que creo que cada persona se ha planteado en la vida. Tiene un final redondito, que trae paz. En ese sentido, parece como una "comfort reading". Y por último, me gusta leer otras perspectivas sobre una ciudad que conozco.
Story felt fractured and incomplete. Ultimately, the protagonist just didn’t seem clear or believable to me. What were her motivations? Maybe we aren’t supposed to really know but this didn’t really feel like that kind of a novel. She just seemed like she never really liked anybody fully and I felt really sad for her.
In Asha In The Garden I found the tree itself was symbolic and was a character on it's own. There was a lot of nastiness between characters- and although Asha makes peace in the end...which could be seem as life affirming - the book was not in the outstanding category for me. That's life - much like the book.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This book is just not striking the right chord with me. I think it is trying to be light as it describes the life of Asha, but it is not resonating with me, and I found it annoying. Life is too short to finish a book I don't enjoy.
3.5 stars for me. Canadian author with a story set in Montreal. It is well written with good characters although one of them stressed me out. It is funny how that character’s storyline turns out near the end, and another character is redeemed when the truth is revealed about a childhood incident.
Although well-written I didn't particularly like any of the characters and found that the plot dragged. The garden and tree were far more engaging. Everything wrapped up a little too neatly at the end