This volume is full of “meet-uglies” and bad first impressions.
What’s more satisfying than a happily ever after that started on the wrong foot?
Books are listed in the order in which they appear in the anthology, my reading order will be denoted beside the titles and will be highly subjective, greatly influenced by my familiarity with and love of the authors in question, followed by my interest in the offerings of those that are new to me (that is the method to my madness, I make no apologies).
Tent Poles & Tackle Boxes by A.D. Ellis - # candy hearts
Travis
Joey
Explosion of the Heart by BA Tortuga - # candy hearts
Dalton
Jack
(3) Always This by Becca Seymour - 5 candy hearts
1st person, present tense, dual PoV
Ant (39), office worker
Eli, school groundskeeper / furniture maker
Ooooh, I loved this one, which was an unexpected surprised since I typically don't gravitate towards single dad stories. I picked it to read third because it was highly recommended in the ARC group I'm a member of. This meet-ugly was actually kinda cute, I thought it was really clever and I adored the fact that this encounter was just the beginning for these two after Ant's son, Henry befriends Eli's nephew, Noah and they were able to further bond during subsequent play dates. The building tension and friendship felt very slow burn and not rushed at all, which is quite an accomplishment for a short story. I was cheering so hard when they finally came together. The supporting characters (kids and Eli's sister, Mel) were a great addition to the story, adding depth without overshadowing the main couple.
(2) Mugs & Kisses by Beck Grey - 4.5 candy hearts
1st person, present tense, dual PoV
Jake Butler (35), fundraiser for the Salem Art Foundation
Matt Ward, potter / owner of Pottering Around pottery studio
Beck is one of my favourite authors so naturally I read their contribution on the heels of Bix's. Knowing the theme of this year's anthology and the setup of the story from the synopsis I had to read the first chapter while peeking through my fingers and cringing. Oh my goodness, Jake really stepped in it and while his heart was in the right place it was hard to imagine him being able to recover from that first impression! Recover he did, with a pretty epic apology date and an even more epic Valentine's Day date. I loved the banter between these two (I hope you can appreciate some excellent puns!) and had a lot of fun reading their story.
(1) Magic Fate Ball by Bix Barrow - 4.5 candy hearts
1st person, past tense, dual PoV
Elton Johnson, human empath, book store manager / studying to be a therapist / content creator 'ejvibes' on Instagram
Rafferty, wolf shifter, pack alpha
I got my ARC copy from Bix (who wrote my favourite contribution to last year's anthology) so I thought it only fair to read her contribution first. It was no hardship though since I love her writing, especially her Wonderfall series. I'm not the biggest fan of fated mates, but enjoy how the concept is presented in Bix's world. When I do read fated mates I am a sucker for when a shifter scents their intended and goes all in trying to convince their (often human) intended that they are a great match.
Rafferty is such a goober in this way, trying waaaay to hard to win Elton over while trying not to overwhelm him while simultaneously doing faaaaaaar too much. It was immensely amusing to me and provided a great counterpoint to Elton's more somber personal journey and circumstances. Overall this story had a very hopeful tone - I love the way Bix blends any heaviness in her stories with sweet swoon-worthy moments and subtle humour. Fans of the author are in for a treat with a cameo from a character who's story is yet to be told. I'm a fan of this world, these characters and this story, it'll be hard to top.
tea & vodka by BL Jones - # candy hearts
Azrael, angel
Lilith, demon
Alexander and the Meet-Cute Potion by David Gray - # candy hearts
Alexander
Emerik
(7) Hiding Fate by D.C. Emerson - 3.5 candy hearts
3rd person, past tense, dual PoV
Jae, omega mandarin duck
Koda (34), alpha Kodiak bear
I wasn't the biggest fan of the writing style here. There was too much passive telling rather than active telling of the story. Maybe it's a word count issue but I'd rather read the dialogue of characters telling each other things than a paragraph stating they had a conversation about a topic. I can't immerse myself in a story that way. There were also a ton of side characters mentioned that made it feel very obvious that other stories were being set up or teased. Honestly, as much as I loved the idea of a duck x bear shifter mash-up and two fated mates finding each other on a F*ck Fate bar crawl I think I was more invested in all the platonic love and Jae's best friend, Hollis, than in the two MCs and their fated mate status.
Love Thy Neighbor by D. K. Sutton - # candy hearts
Jace (22)
Lannie (almost 30)
Beau’s Stormy Romance by E.J. Stoll - # candy hearts
Beau
Vincent
(10) Grounded by E.M. Denning - 4 candy hearts
1st person, past tense, dual PoV
Troye, video game streamer
Matthew Kincaid, game developer/owner of Gemstone Games
Ouf, these two had such a rough start that I wasn't sure how they would come together when all was said and done. This was a pretty quick, slice of life story. As much as I loved the light kink brat/tamer dynamic I also enjoyed the common ground these two established through their mutual professional interests and I became pretty invested in their shared success.
(9) The Baker and the Kraken by Ellie Ash - 4.5 candy hearts
3rd person, past tense, dual PoV
Adam, witch (32), baker at Devine Confections
Calder, kraken shifter (ancient), ocean conservancy
I am a... sucker... for a good hidden identity trope and the fact that Calder decides not to correct Adam's mistaken assumption that he's a witch as well brings some tension to the story as it's revealed that events in Adam's past make him reluctant to form a magical bond which would most assuredly happen were he to mate with a shifter. As these two get together and start to become friends and then more than friend it's evident how well suited they are for one another. I loved how accepting Calder was of all Adam's awkward clumsiness.
(8) Unsportsmanlike Conduct by Essie Sloane - 4.5 candy hearts
1st person, past tense, single PoV (Vic)
Vic Summers, history teacher at King’s Bay High
Jason, 3rd grade teacher
I didn't think I would enjoy this as much as I did, but I typically enjoy this author's writing so I bit the bullet and gave it a shot, winding up pleasantly surprised by the slow burn friendship turned more. I quite liked the way Jason's enthusiastic smack talk was described as something he enjoys as he roots for his team and isn't really vitriol directed at the opponents.
(5) Angel Kisses by Evie McGlynn - 4 candy hearts
Charlie Gallagher, bookstore clerk and research assistant at Time to Read bookstore
Hunter McLaughlin
I'm an absolute sucker for a size difference and protective MC. I also just have to complete my first aid recertification so a book beginning with a first aid rescue peaked my interest. There is a huge cast of secondary characters that are clearly from the author's other published works, which impeded my enjoyment a little bit as it's clear there's more going on than meets the eye but the reader is left wondering what is really going on at Time to Read as there is heavily implied magical dealings afoot. I did love the instant connection between Charlie and Hunter and would read more about the Angel Security crew
Fortune Candy by Madalyn George - # candy hearts
(4) The Weekend Boyfriend by Merry Farmer - 4 candy hearts
3rd person, past tense, dual PoV
Javier Rivera, owner of Rivera Talent agency
Desmond White
Man, this was so disappointing. Merry Farmer (or MM Farmer, one of her other pen names) is something of a comfort read for me. If I'm in a book slump I know she's good for a solid sweet swoony read. Honestly, this was well on its way to being a 5 candy heart read for me, but I just can't get behind a HFN half-finished story.
This had an epic beginning with Javier unknowingly delivering a saccharine signing telegram to Des on behalf of his toxic ex-. God, it was so unbelievably cringey in the best way. Des picks him up after that fateful encounter, they hit it off, and he enlists Javier's help to act as his date at an upcoming event to demonstrate to his ex-, Matthew, that he's moved on - delicious! Des falls ill and Javier nurses him back to health. OMG *swoon*. They connect so well. Their chemistry is palpable but more than that they read see each other. Let's cook together, garden together, watch a movie together... Yes, yes, yes, (and yes!).
BUT we never get to see the evil ex- get his just desserts, we never see Javier really succeed with his fledgling modelling agency, etc.
I'm bummed. I will read the full-length novel when it comes out but I feel cheated by this inclusion in the anthology. I'm trying really hard to rate the work as is and not have my rating reflect my disappointment. Teasing another work is forgivable (I hate it but understand that authors want to tease their other works to increase engagement and readership) but this hits differently.
What the Heart Wants by Minerva Howe - # candy hearts
Maverick Grainger
Graham, omega
Checked Baggage by Riley Long - # candy hearts
Dallas, museum curator
My Demon Boyfriend by Stella Rainbow - # candy hearts
Arnick
Ruff Day by Susan Scott Shelley and Chantal Mer - # candy hearts
Jaggar Michaels
Ian Vale
(6) The Tattoo Parlor by Vinni George - # candy hearts
Misha Zimov, omega
Tucker Sharpe, alpha
I was given an ARC and voluntarily wrote an honest review.