Amy Robach’s goal in writing this medical memoir was “to share not only the daily challenges (she) faced as a newly diagnosed cancer patient but also the evolution that occurred as (she) transitioned from patient to survivor . . . to thriver.” Or as Amy’s subtitle indicates, it’s a story of “how (she) let go of control, held on to hope and found joy in (her) darkest hour.” Robach has largely accomplished all that in this well told, tell-all journal.
It’s interesting to note that current ABC Good Morning America news anchor Robach published her cancer diary the same year, (2015), that former ABC Good Morning America host Joan Lunden released her own “memoir of (cancer) survival." In fact, between pages 144 and 145 of Lunden’s bio, “Had I Known,” you’ll find a picture of Amy Robach presenting the Komen Impact Award to Lunden. (This reviewer read both books simultaneously and his reaction to Lunden’s book is published elsewhere in GoodReads.) In fact, if you read both titles, you’ll discover Robach and Lunden not only shared basically the same diagnosis but some of the same oncologists. Most notably Doctor Ruth Oratz, who treated both women. Again, if you read both bios, you’ll also learn of the powerful influence Robach and Lunden’s mutual friendship with fellow cancer survivor Robin Roberts had on their joint recoveries. Finally, probably unconsciously, Lunden even subtly mentions Robach’s book title on page 280: “If we’re given the chance, all any of us can do is move forward with our lives and hope to do better, be better, love better and live better.” Robach took her title, by the way, from “Better,” a poem written by her oldest daughter, Ava McIntosh. The last line is a tribute to Ava’s courageous mother. “She’s a fighter just like her daughter. It has to get worse before it gets better . . . and trust me it will get better.”
While both women were given similar, life-altering medical news, Robach chose a radical different approach to treatment. As soon as Robach learned that she had “a tumor in (her) right breast” with apparently no lymph node involvement, Robach vetoed a lumpectomy, “the most conservative surgical approach.” Instead, from the get-go, Robach was “ninety-nine percent sure (she) wanted a double mastectomy.” Told she had “aggressive and fast-growing, triple negative breast cancer,” Lunden, on the other hand, chose to begin chemo treatments, followed by a lumpectomy and then radiation.
Robach doesn’t shy away from her critics. Within these pages, the ABC-TV anchor takes on Doctor Susan Love and others such as Peggy Orenstein and Dr. Peter Bach over the issue of “the best approach to how we discuss and treat breast cancer.” Robach also addresses the “metastatic breast cancer community” which allegedly opposes so much attention to early detection measures.
After eight full rounds of CMF, chemotherapy, and after an eight month battle, Robach believes she is now “a better wife . . . a better mom . . . a better daughter . . . better sister . . . a better friend.” On the next to the last page, Robach does mention “all the women and men who have received a breast cancer diagnosis.” However, the American Cancer Society estimates for breast cancer in men in the United States for 2015 are: About 2,350 new cases of invasive breast cancer will be diagnosed. About 440 men will die from breast cancer. Breast cancer is about 100 times less common among men than among women. For men, the lifetime risk of getting breast cancer is about 1 in 1,000. The number of breast cancer cases in men relative to the population has been fairly stable over the last 30 years. While it’s commendable Robach ever so briefly hints at male breast cancer in that one line on the next to the last page, had she painted the killer disease as more than a female issue and given more equal time to both genders, this could’ve been an even “better” book.