Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Below Stairs Mystery #9

Murder in Blackfriars

Rate this book
In Victorian London, valiant cook and amateur sleuth Kat Holloway must help the man she loves solve the murder that will finally uncover his mysterious past, from the New York Times bestselling author of A Silence in Belgrave Square.

Kat Holloway’s beau, Daniel McAdam, has always had a past shrouded in mystery. He knows nothing about his origins, only that a kind man rescued him from the streets all those years ago. So when a man claiming he knows where Daniel comes from turns up dead moments before meeting with them, Daniel goes on the hunt for the killer. It soon becomes clear that to see justice served, Daniel will have to figure out who he truly is and where he came from. When Daniel asks Kat for her assistance, she readily complies, knowing she’ll do whatever it takes to protect the man she’s come to love.

The quest takes Kat and Daniel deep into the East End, where they face dangerous foes from Daniel’s rugged past, many of whom aren’t happy that Daniel now works with the police and will stop at nothing to keep Kat and Daniel from uncovering their secrets. As Kat begins to learn things about Daniel’s history she’s not certain she wants to know, she fears that the darkest secret—his true name and lineage—will tear apart the tender bonds they’ve begun to form.

315 pages, Kindle Edition

First published August 11, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Jennifer Ashley

213 books7,418 followers
NY Times Bestselling author Jennifer Ashley writes historical, contemporary, and paranormal romance, historical mysteries, and urban fantasy as Jennifer Ashley, Allyson James, and Ashley Gardner.

Jennifer's novels have been translated into many different languages, and earned starred reviews from Booklist and Publisher's Weekly. More about her books at http://www.jenniferashley.com and http://gardnermysteries.com.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
373 (49%)
4 stars
267 (35%)
3 stars
102 (13%)
2 stars
15 (1%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 123 reviews
Profile Image for Jeannine.
1,201 reviews73 followers
August 1, 2026
This is the last book in the Below Stairs series for which Jennifer Ashley is contracted through Berkley. Just like when I started reading book 5, also the end of a contract, I went in thinking that this would be a story that quietly wrapped up the series. While the series-long mystery of who Daniel McAdam is was solved, this book was not a quiet conclusion, but rather a fantastic start to another phase in the story.

We have Jennifer Ashley‘s typical wit, charm and humor in this story. We have delightful scenes with beloved secondary characters. We have the ongoing tension that Kat has been navigating with her job. We have sweet and heartbreaking scenes with her daughter, who is now a young teenager. And of course, the beautiful romance between Kat and Daniel continues. All of this on top of a clever mystery. What a fabulous story!

I shed tears over the ending. While the murder was solved and Daniel has closure, this is not happily ever after for Kat. Berkley better give Jennifer Ashley a big, fat contract to keep this going…unless she wants to go fully indie. I’ll pay for the next book regardless!!!
Profile Image for SarahO.
329 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
February 12, 2026
I've been following this series since 2020 and every new book that comes out is like being hugged by an old friend. I absolutely LOVE these characters and their relationships. Every time one pops onto the page for their first appearance I can't help but smile.
Getting more Daniel and Kat is always a treat (especially since the last book) but I'm also loving that Kat now has her own network of people/informants to turn to: an old friend in the market and a new friend in a bookshop. She's come a long way since using Daniel and James as her only source for information.
Alongside Kat getting some heartbreaking news, someone comes forward with some possible information about Daniels shadowed past. This book had me smiling, crying, talking back to the characters, and I finished it in one sitting! (Okay, maybe a couple but all in one day!)
Profile Image for eyes.2c.
3,201 reviews123 followers
August 15, 2026
Who is Daniel McAdams?

Kat Holloway has come a long way from the Kat we were first introduced to eons ago.
Changes are looming. Her friend Joanna is moving out of London. Joanna’s solicitor husband has accepted a new post. Joanne looks after Kat’s daughter Grace, and for the time being Grace will move with them. Kat is heavy hearted.
Kat’s now fiancé Danial McAdams is still searching for his identity. His past looms over him. Kat’s help will prove invaluable.
There’s honorable rogues, a dangerous and sleek gang leader, ruffians and bullies, charming gutter rats and a host of beloved favorites.
Kat is indomitable when roused, loyal to her friends, and caring.
Another startling Victorian mystery from Ashley.

A Berkley ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
Profile Image for No Apology Book Reviews.
506 reviews44 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
February 25, 2026
Thanks so much to Jennifer Ashley, Berkley, and NetGalley for allowing me to read a free ARC in exchange for an honest review.

I love this series so much. I love the rich detail Ashley includes without getting too dry---historical, geographical, cultural, and baking-wise. I can't verify any of its accuracy, but Ashley's writing feels so intelligent that I have little doubt. I could see some readers saying they don't need detail on the level of turn-by-turn navigation and cooking class (things I've even said before about other books), but for some reason I enjoy it in Ashley's writing. It feels immersive, not like she's avoiding character development or fluffing word count.

I love the characters too. Honestly I don't need a murder in the plot, the social drama would be enough. I'd read these characters just to see them go about their lives. The cast having expanded, we can't spend as much time with everyone as I'd like, yet Ashley manages to give everyone organic cameos and touch base on their goings-on.



I can't wait for the next book!
Profile Image for Michelle Griep.
Author 42 books2,823 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
March 15, 2026
A murder. A long lost family. And--most importantly--scones! Plenty of scones...so many I think I gained ten pounds just reading this story. Probably my fault, though, as I continued baking them throughout my reading just to sit down with this delightful book with a steaming cup of English Breakfast and a Lemon Blueberry pastry.

But I digress.

Murder in Blackfriars is a twisty-turny mystery set in merry olde England. I love Mrs. Holloway and Daniel. They are perfect for one another. I won't give away the ending, but well . . . never mind. There are plenty of dastardly villains you'll love to hate and side characters galore to entertain. Really well done. Highly recommend.
Profile Image for Christina O..
152 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
February 19, 2026
"Murder in Blackfriars" is such a satisfying continuation of the Kat Holloway mysteries. There are some life changes for Kat in this book that push the overall story in some interesting ways, and we finally get some answers about Daniel's background. I love all of the side characters and the descriptions of Victorian London. This is definitely one of my favorite books in the series. I can't wait to see what comes next!
Profile Image for K McKenzie.
278 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
March 2, 2026
I credit this excellent series with rekindling a love of mysteries that had gone dormant while my kids were younger and there just never seemed to be enough time or energy to read. The characters, writing style, and plots had me hooked from the short story that serves as the prequel to the entire series, and so I am always excited to see a release date for another book. This latest one didn’t disappoint and shows the same knack for moving the lives of the main characters along as their relationships grow and develop while always introducing a new, well- plotted mystery. Kat and Daniel this time are investigating Daniel’s own mysterious past, and a related murder soon draws in old friends and foes alike. Thoroughly enjoyable. The ending of this one is a little less neat, but it seems very deliberate to set up the next installment. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an advance copy. All views are entirely my own and offered voluntarily.
Profile Image for Caroline.
1,608 reviews16 followers
June 30, 2026
This is the long awaited tale of Daniel McAdam’s backstory! I had not expected it to leave me teary-eyed, but alas, it did. Another wonderful installment, and now I really can’t wait for more! Thanks to Berkley for the arc.
Profile Image for Minna.
2,855 reviews
August 12, 2026
Big thank you, BIG, to NetGalley, Berkley, and Ms. Ashley for the opportunity to read an ARC of this title. An honest review was requested but not required.

If you're here at book #9 then you probably enjoy the series (no one has enough free time for 8 books they're only mid on), so I don't have to sell you on it. Let me just say, I would have been happy for this series to go on forever, BUT, this was a fantastic finish. OR WAS IT. ?? lol

Everything you've liked in books 1-8, we have here in book #9. Kat's cleverness, talent at forging connections, and quick thinking, the side characters (whether Kat's friends, found family, or her longtime coworkers in service) continue to be terrific, Grace is all grown up, and Daniel is 😚. *If*, and I do mean if, Ms. Ashley wishes, she could definitely continue with these characters. I really hope she does. I don't wish to spoil any of the actual story (you're welcome), but I can happily say that as a series closer [[[[[maybe!)]]]]] this 100% delivers.

Five easy stars. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Profile Image for ☕️Kimberly  (Caffeinated Reviewer).
3,745 reviews814 followers
Read
August 5, 2026
While each of the books in the Below the Stairs Mysteries contains a mystery for Kat Holloway, our Victorian London cook & amateur sleuth to solve with the help of her beau and friends you’ll want to read them in the order of their release. The characters and their storylines, including a slow-burning romance will pull you in as much as the mysteries.

An attempt to learn more about Daniel’s past puts them in the path of a murder and a dangerous faction of the city. While Daniel looks to solve the murder, Kat enlists the help of her friends, and a man of the cloth to uncover the secrets of Daniel’s past.

In the meantime, big changes are happening. Kat learns news that upsets her even as she takes steps to secure a better future for herself and her daughter. I loved all the threads and the unwavering love we see between Kat and Daniel. The story had some suspenseful moments and I found myself in awe of Kat’s fearlessness.

While this was supposed to be the last book, their story is far from over and whether Ashley continues the story through a traditional publisher or on her own, I will be there to gobble them up.

If you love historical mysteries, happens below the stairs, foodie books, and richly developed characters you will want to devour Murder in Blackfriars and the entire serie

This review originally published at Caffeinated Reviewer
Profile Image for Jen (That's What I'm Talking About).
1,846 reviews314 followers
September 9, 2026
It’s been a few months since the conclusion of the previous book. Daniel has given up working for Mr. Monaghan but still makes himself available to Scotland Yard. Kat and Daniel hope to marry within the year. However, he wants to discover where he came from first and she needs a bit more money to start her bake/tea stall.

Joanne tells Kat that Sam has been offered a promotion that comes with a larger salary and a big home. But it’s in the country and they will be moving before the end of the year, leaving London for good. It’s a few hours by train, which means Kat can only visit Grace on her full day off on Thursdays.

While Murder in Blackfriars is the final contracted book, Ashley assures fans that this will not be the final Kat Holloway book: https://jenniferashleyblog.com/2026/0...

I absolutely love Kat and Daniel as a team and how he allows her autonomy do figure out mysteries. How he supports her. I love how much Daniel has changed. He listens to Kat describe her interaction with Naismith, and although he’s still angry it happened, he acknowledges that she grounds him and helps him think clearly. That she makes sense when all he knows is chaos. I love that Daniel admires and respects Kat’s ability to get to the truth, to “solve crimes.” He wants to protect and keep her safe, but he knows she is happier helping and is good at it, too.

I love how the entire gang comes together to help Daniel find his family/history.

Overall the story was good and I enjoyed the happy ending. However, I had a few issues.. And I’m still upset about the change in narrator (see GR review here: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...).

The bulk of the story focuses on Daniel trying to discover information about his past and where he came from. The path to the end is twisty and filled with false leads. However, there is a point where a key character doesn’t speak up, and there is no explanation for why they kept quiet. Additionally, I found it odd that later, Kat sees something that she didn’t upon the first meeting. It felt contrived, and I was frustrated.

Second, Mrs. Bywater’s behavior is odd throughout the book. She’s on Kat’s case and being nosy. However, there is no explanation for why. Which leads me to a related issue: How does Kat still have a job with the Bywaters? She runs all over London, even when she’s supposed to be working. She finds time to start her own business. I know she’s an excellent cook, but it makes no sense.

In the end, I still enjoy the Kat Holloway/Below Stairs Mysteries, and I look forward to the day with Kat and Daniel can live out their dreams.

My Rating: B/B-
Profile Image for Grandma Susan.
773 reviews296 followers
September 16, 2026
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Murder in Blackfriars was another wonderful installment in Jennifer Ashley’s Kat Holloway mystery series. Set in Victorian London, this story combines an intriguing murder mystery with a much more personal mystery involving Daniel McAdam’s past. Daniel remembers virtually nothing about his childhood before the time when he was living as a thief on the streets. When Kat and Daniel arrange to meet a man who may finally be able to provide some answers, they arrive only to discover that he has been murdered. From there, the mystery of the man’s death and the mystery of Daniel’s identity become increasingly intertwined.

One of the things I especially enjoyed about this book was how personal the story felt. Kat and Daniel are engaged, so learning the truth about Daniel’s past matters to Kat for reasons that go far beyond solving another mystery. I was completely invested in discovering the answers alongside them, and I was very satisfied with the way everything was ultimately resolved.

There is also a particularly touching storyline involving Kat and her daughter, Grace. Circumstances mean that mother and daughter will have to live apart for approximately a year, although they will still be able to see each other twice a week. Their sadness over the separation added a very real emotional element to the story. The relationships between these characters are one of the reasons this series works so well for me—the mystery is important, but so are the people involved in it.

I listened to the advanced listener’s copy, and the narration was outstanding from beginning to end. The narrator brought the characters and Victorian London to life and made an already enjoyable story even better. I also had access to the Kindle advanced reader’s copy, which allowed me to experience both formats.

I was blessed to receive both an ARC and an ALC of Murder in Blackfriars. My thanks to NetGalley, Berkley Publishing, and Dreamscape Media for providing these advance copies. All opinions expressed in this review are my own and unbiased.
Profile Image for Pranav Bhatnagar.
506 reviews5 followers
September 18, 2026
There is something wonderfully comforting about returning to Kat Holloway, even when someone has been murdered and the people around her seem to be walking into danger. What pulled me into Murder in Blackfriars was not just the mystery itself. It was Kat. She has a way of looking at the world that makes even ordinary conversations feel worth reading, and I enjoyed being inside her thoughts as she tried to make sense of everything happening around her. This time, Daniel is drawn into a situation that quickly becomes much more serious than either of them expected. Kat naturally wants to know what is happening, but what I enjoyed most was seeing how she balances that curiosity with her responsibilities as a mother and as a cook. Her relationship with Grace also gives the story a warmth that works beautifully beside the darker mystery. The London setting was another highlight for me. Blackfriars, the Thames, the fog, the markets and the busy streets all make the story feel like a place where secrets could easily disappear. I also loved the way Kat's knowledge of food and household life becomes useful without making her feel like a detective simply because the story needs one. There is danger here, but there is also friendship, family, humour and a strong sense of community. Hannah was another character I was very happy to see because her conversations with Kat always bring something extra to the story. What made this work for me was how naturally the mystery and the personal parts of Kat's life sit together. I came for the murder, but I stayed because I genuinely cared what happened to these people.
2 reviews
August 14, 2026
I’m devastated by the change in narrator for the audio book. This has become one of my favourite series but I’ve listened to Anne-Marie Piazza narrate these characters for hours so bringing in a new narrator now means I don’t recognize any of the characters. I did read something that said Anne-Marie had scheduling issues and the publisher decided on and brought in the alternate narrator. I get the reasoning but it’s a wretched thing to do to a big fan.
Profile Image for Jen (That's What I'm Talking About).
1,846 reviews314 followers
Did Not Finish
August 23, 2026
I have listened to every Kat Holloway / Below Stairs Mystery, including the novellas when they are available in audiobook. Anne-Marie Piazza has always performed wonderfully, and after eight full-length titles she is familiar and embodies the characters. Piazza IS Kat Holloway.

So imagine my surprise when I started Murder in Blackfriars, the ninth and final contracted book in the series, and discovered that Piazza is not narrating the title. This is so disappointing. For an audiobook listener, changing the voice of a beloved character after so many books is a huge NO. I, for one, would rather wait for the audiobook to be published than for this to happen.

I cannot get past the changes to the characters voices and Cochrane's slower cadence. Unfortunately, I am going to "DNF" the audiobook at this point. This is breaking my heart. I will eventually read the book, but right now, I'm too disappointed and upset to tackle this one, especially because it may be the final full-length Kat book, at least for a while.

My Rating: DNF (audio only) - Completely disappointed
Profile Image for Anne - Books of My Heart.
4,091 reviews232 followers
August 15, 2026
This review was originally posted on Books of My Heart

I haven't listened to previous books on audio, but when I got denied on Netgalley I was able to get Murder in Blackfriars on Hoopla.  The Kat Holloway series is one of my favorites in the historical mystery genre.  We're well into the series now and I would read these books in order.


Daniel is mostly finished with the police and is looking to learn more about his heritage.  Kat continues to cook for the difficult Bywaters but also starts a market stall with the help of her daughter and Tess.  There are big changes happening and I worried throughout how they would manage them.

A man comes to Daniel with information about his parentage as they were with the same woman and then workhouse as boys and then he's murdered.  Daniel is arrested but mostly he is questioned. He and Kat go to work on solving the murder.   They talk to everyone who he might have had problems with.

Kat gathered from the brief bit he told Daniel that the boy Daniel had liked an old children's book with pictures of the sea. She starts research from that end.  She has Cynthia and Thanos searching records of births and deaths at Somerset House around the time Daniel was born.

Daniel does not seem very effective in his research but he has the disadvantage of being too close to the problem.  Kat is extraordinary at finding small clues which lead to more information.  They do solve the murder and the mystery of Daniel's history.  I wonder what he will do between now (October) and next June when the wedding is planned.  I guess he can figure out his next plans for earning his living, beyond the delivery business which provided cover for the police work he did.

I enjoyed the realistic aspects of how the changes happened and were managed by them.  Although they were both clever and lucky to get resolution.  I look forward to seeing how they put things together for their future.  And what about the friends and coworkers Kat is used to having in her daily life?

Narration:
I have not previously listened to this narrator.  Once I settled into the story, I found her voices to be very comfortable for the male and female characters with some accents (although I don't know if they were accurate for the region).  The only voice I found odd was Daniel. He seemed rather dull; I expected more life from the clever and risk-taking man he is.  I listened at my newer 1.75x speed.



Profile Image for QNPoohBear.
3,703 reviews1,577 followers
October 9, 2026
Daniel has a lead on someone who may have a clue to his true identity. He wants Kat to come with him to judge whether the informant is a man of character who might be telling the truth. Just as they were about to meet up with the man, he was brutally killed in an alley near the meeting point and Daniel is caught at the scene of the crime. Kat is determined to free her man and see justice done. Of course Daniel didn't do it and the police know that but they need information so they can catch who did. Kat and her friend Hannah scope out the man's apartment and meet another stranger who may have another clue to Daniel's past. Their search for justice leads to the most notorious criminal layer in the East End and the quest for information introduces Kat to a new friend. Meanwhile, changes are happening for Joanna's family and Kat will be parted from her beloved Grace for a time. How can she bear to go on when everything she has worked for has been for Grace? Well, she has her hands full with Daniel's mystery and a new market stall to keep her busy.

This story lacked suspense. I kept waiting for it and nothing happened. The story moves along in the first half, I read it in public while waiting for a festival to start. The rest drags a bit and then wraps up super quickly. The primary mystery is about Daniel's identity and I think the story he told Kat initially was different which led me to suspect the plot was not going in the direction it did. The search was a needle in a haystack yet the coincidences added up to success rather unrealistically. His story had rather a fairy tale ending but Dickens did something similar so I guess it happened.

Kat is so distracted and can barely cook. That's not like her. She's worried about Daniel but she's worried before and still done her job. She kept thinking about how she ought to tell various cooks how to make their food better. I confess, I always think what would Paul Hollywood say and think things like this isn't a proper croissant. where's the flaky layers from lamination? and I know why my mom's baking fails but she won't let me tell her so I keep my mouth shut until she asks. Kat is like a one woman Great British Baking Show. I want a Kat Holloway cookbook! I was drooling over her pastries! Hand pies, scones, apple bread! Yes please all of the above thank you. Only a penny? She isn't charging enough. Young Grace is shaping up to be as stubborn as her mother. She's a lovely young lady but growing fast and Kat is protective of her innocent daughter who knows nothing of unscrupulous men. Grace is innocent and Kat would prefer to keep her that way awhile longer. Forever really if she has her way but Kat knows realistically Grace must grow up and perhaps someday marry but preferably someone respectable. Joanna's sons are probably out, being raised together they're likely more like siblings. Joanna is a good woman and Sam is a lovely man. They're upwardly mobile and entering the middle class. (They're better off than the Cratchits).

Daniel has a carefully controlled temper and finally, Kat sees he is nothing like her first husband. Daniel may be frustrated but he never lashes out at Kat or takes his frustrations out on her. They talk like civilized people. He's still very sweet and kind. He knows what she's thinking and feeling and tries to help her. No matter what, he supports her and soon they'll be married and this season's trauma will be old news. My heart broke for him in the end, I feel sorry for Daniel but his past made him who he is today. He is who he is and he can't change that but move forward and I think his life will be enriched all that much more.

Mr. Davis grumpy and takes offense at stupid stuff. Kat's personal life is none of his business and when he tries to make it his business, he flip-flips and claims he doesn't want to know. He's stuffy but it's a front because he's afraid of losing people he cares about. Mrs. Bywater is extra nosy and Kat's job is hanging by a thread. Tess slips up and could have ruined everything. It was a mistake but still, she should be more careful. It sounds like a happy ever after may be in store for Tess sooner than later thanks to Kat's keen observation skills and Daniel's information.

Mr. Fielding is charming as always but also shows the rough edges that haven't quite been smoothed away. Hannah is cheeky and funny. She sees right though Mr. Fielding and sparks fly. He feels uncomfortable with her seeing through his genteel clergyman disguise to who he really is and it confuses him. Hmm... Hannah is not wrong about Kat but yes the market fluctuates and of course the other baker isn't happy about Kat honing in on her territory. That could be trouble for Kat. Best NOT to quit her job right now and focus on her business a little later once she has the stability of a second income.
Mr. Grimes may be a tough but he's a marshmallow underneath the tough exterior. He's done things the police can't forgive him for but certainly if they saw him with Kat and Grace they would leave him alone? No, I know... They'd punish him anyway but he's a man of sterling character. I like him very much.

I missed Cynthia, Thanos and friends. They appear late in the story and not enough. Bobby is MIA. Instead we have Hannah and Kat makes a new friend. I didn't understand why she was so quick to open up and trust this new friend. I would be more wary and cautious if I were her. Albie the urchin has a bigger role in this story. He's cute and cheeky but devoted to Kat because she not only feeds him, she cares about him and tries to mother him the most he'll allow.

Mr. Patterson is a sad old man. Is he telling the truth, the whole truth or is there more to the story? Is he telling the truth as he remembers it? Is it the actual truth? Is his information biased? Ruined by drink and years of hard labor, he seems to be something of a conspiracy theorist. He's prejudice against the upper classes and has a lot of ideas. He thought he was doing the right thing at the time and he did, in theory anyway but the reality of the situation was beyond his comprehension. He's a tragic character right out of Dickens. "Are there no prisons? Are there no workhouses?" kept running through my head. What sad, terrible mess. Mrs. Davies, the bookseller, claims to be an interfering busybody. She enjoys passing on the wisdom she's gained in her advanced years. She's bored with few customers and is eager for something to do. Her task is tedious and thank goodness for computers and spreadsheets although going through antique ledgers does sound kind of fun. I love the smell and feel of old documents and the beautiful handwriting and iron gall ink. I was surprised Kat was so quick to trust Mrs. Davies. I want to like her but I don't know if I fully trust her.

Mr. Banks isn't even in the story and what Kat learns about him could fit into a thimble yet she believes he was a good, kind man. She assumes he did want to tell Daniel a secret about his past and not just take the coin. Why not consider he wanted to tell Daniel something the police should know but was afraid to go to them? I think Mr. Ramsay, his neighbor, was the murderer. He knew Mr. Banks had something to tell Daniel and was excited about it. Mr. Ramsay seems more down and out, a drinker and a gambler, perhaps he murdered Mr. Banks for his coin and/or he's involved in something he shouldn't be and is afraid Daniel will find out if he gets close to Mr. Banks. Mr. Naismith, Daniel's longtime enemy, is a slick character. He's a gang leader, he knows how to lead with an iron fist but still be charming to his enemies. He's a very dangerous man and I was terrified for Kat and friends the whole time. Barlow and Draper are henchmen and striking out on their own as villains. They also seem to be dangerous if crossed. They grew up rough and have no morals, kindness or empathy. Was their past intertwined with Daniel's?

This is the last book in the series but I hope the author writes more novellas to wrap things up a bit more.
Profile Image for Debbie.
3,714 reviews100 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
June 8, 2026
"Murder in Blackfriars" is a mystery set in 1884 in London, England. This is the 9th book in the series. Street-raised, clever Daniel became incompetent in this book. A man offered to tell him information about his past. Daniel paid him but basically said, 'I need my girlfriend to tell me if you're telling the truth or not, so don't tell me anything until we can meet with her.' There was no reason why he couldn't have heard the information right then. Of course, the fellow was killed before telling the information.

Kate never met him but assumed he was a kind, well-meaning fellow and they should solve his murder. Even though the fellow said that it was seeing Daniel's teenaged son that brought the connection to mind, Kate assumed his information must be about when Daniel was a toddler. She also treated Daniel like a child, forbidding him from doing anything dangerous, though it was fine for her to do the same dangerous activity.

Kate was just so arrogant. She kept thinking about how she ought to tell various cooks how to make their food better. Though there was no reason for her to be involved and her presence could be used against Daniel, she insisted on confronting a criminal overload in his own home and not only insulted him but told him what he ought to do. Um, are you insane? How did that make anything better?

Most of the story was about Kate getting her food stand going and dealing with her daughter moving away for a while. Much of the investigation was handled by others while Kate suggested things to look into. It didn't feel much like a mystery but rather a historical fiction following the lives of all the characters from previous books.

Historical details were woven into the story. There was no sex. There was occasional use of of bad language. Overall, I'd recommend this historical to fans of the series as we finally do learn the mystery of Daniel's past.

I received a free ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.
Profile Image for Barb in Maryland.
2,162 reviews182 followers
August 29, 2026
4.5 stars, rounded down to 4 because of the ending for Kat.

A very convoluted murder mystery is entangled in Daniel McAdam's search for his family origins. A Mr. Banks has told Mr. Grimes that he knows something about Daniel's origins. However, Banks is murdered on his way to meet Daniel, Kat, and Grimes. Thus the two-pronged search begins--for the murderer, and for someone who might have known what info Banks had.
I had fun with this one--so many of our regular characters play a part in unraveling the mystery of Daniel's earliest life. I don't want to say too much about that part of the story, beyond saying that that yes, Daniel's quest is eventually successful.
The investigation of the murder of Mr. Banks inevitably crosses paths with the villainous Mr Naismith with several surprising developments there, as well.
As for Kat--she faces a difficult separation from her daughter, Grace. Joanna's husband has received a promotion, that comes with relocating 50 or so miles outside London. They want Grace to come with them; Kat and Grace herself know that Grace staying in London won't work out.
Kat will still be able to visit on her Thursdays off, but the journey to and fro will eat up precious time
with Grace.

I want one more book that will give Kat and Grace their happy ending!! I want to see the tea shop of their dreams. I am encouraged by the news of a new novella (The Ghost and Mrs. Holloway), due in October, and by a remark by the author that indicates she's not yet done with this series. I shall keep my hopes up and fingers crossed.
Profile Image for Ariana Ochoa.
366 reviews7 followers
September 28, 2026
I have loved this series since the very first book, and in this installment we finally find out more about Daniel's mysterious past!

If you have been following this series, you know how far Kat Holloway has come since the first book. Kat Holloway works as a cook, is a mother, an amateur sleuth, and is building her side business. Daniel has strayed away from working at Scotland Yard but occasionally helps out. Kat and Daniel are eager to marry within the year, but Daniel is curious to know more about his past and where he came from. When someone from Daniel's past approaches him with information on his parents, he is later killed and Kat will do all she can to solve the mystery while juggling her responsibilities. Great changes are coming, but this story was more emotional than the previous books.

There were many twists in this plot along with many tears! Of all the books in the series, this one was my favorite!

Many thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC. This review is voluntary. All thoughts are my own.
Profile Image for Bks43v3r.
425 reviews
September 15, 2026
2 - 2.5 Stars

I am a long time reader of this series. Out of the 14 books (full length and novellas), I have read all but three. I have enjoyed a lot of them. Especially the earlier books. However, I have really been struggling with this series for a bit. At first, reading about a crime solving cook was new and interesting for me. Seeing how Kat was about to do it and still do her job was a kick. BUT (and it's big one) for me, they have become a bit trite.

In this series we just get our FMC, Kat's POV. Ahhh...I wish so much that the author had included Daniel's POV well. Reason? Well, a good portion of the book is Kat being in the kitchen. Being a servant in those days was very limiting. And the reader has to hear about all that dull working life stuff. I also am tired of hearing about cook/food stuff. I am not one of those people who watch cooking shows. I can take it if it's brief but it's not really here. Seems to me, lately, more and more of the books in this series are spending a lot of time on this topis. And there never seems to be another cook that is anywhere near Kat's level of greatness in the kitchen. (She's often critiquing other cooks efforts, and usually it is lacking big time). Besides this, there has been A LOT of fretting in the last few books. Fret, fret, fret. Repeat. Worry, worry, worry. Repeat.

The plot in this book focuses mostly on Daniel's past (with a smaller plots regarding Kat's daughter and a big change in the area as well as FINALLY getting her side hustle started). The reader follows the slow plot and doling out of clues. Once the pace finally picks up, it was interesting. It's a sad story is all I will say. But leading up to that, it was a bit of a slog for me. And the romance. Oh, my! How much longer is it doing to be draaaaaaged out? They been together for like I believe five years!!! I hate been TVs and books prolong a romance. At this point, I don't even care if/when they finally get married. Whatever.

I think I am done with this series. It has run it's course for me. It was a mostly good ride while it lasted.

CONTENT
Intimacy: Only some kissing. And it not really described, so pretty clean.
Violence: Violent things happen, there is a murder, threats etc. However, again, not really described much.
Language: Do not recall anything objectionable.

Profile Image for Renee.
1,552 reviews228 followers
August 12, 2026
Nowadays I don't bother with a series that I don't love. And this is one of the best! In this adventure, Kat researches the story of her fiancé Daniel's childhood & says a temporary goodbye to her daughter Grace. It's a winner!
19 reviews1 follower
September 15, 2026
The Best Story Ever - A love Story

This storyline was the best. A story of family love and mystery.
Also, the story revealed several murder mysteries solved. I hope the series will continue after Kat and Daniel marry. After the marriage, the storyline will be filled with adventures and mysteries.
Profile Image for BrandyD.
711 reviews89 followers
November 12, 2026
This was so good! Lots of story progression for all the characters. Can’t wait for the next book.
Profile Image for Kat.
1,109 reviews43 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 9, 2026
Murder in Blackfriars is the 9th book in Jennifer Ashley's popular Victorian mystery series Below Stairs Mysteries. I actually started this series with books 0.5 and 1. How about that?! Yet, unfortunately, this is the next one that I read. I have all the others, but sometimes time, and books, pass me by. I remembered I loved both of those, so I was eager to jump back in the world of Kat Holloway. And I was so glad I did! This story stands alone, but there's so much I missed between books that I am quite eager to find out what I missed!

Kat Holloway’s beau, Daniel McAdam, has always had a past shrouded in mystery. He knows nothing about his origins, only that he was rescued from the streets many years ago. So when someone claiming to know where Daniel came from turns up dead moments before meeting with him, Daniel goes on the hunt for the killer. It soon becomes clear that to see justice served, Daniel will have to figure out who he truly is. When he asks Kat for her assistance, she readily complies, knowing she’ll do whatever she must to protect the man she’s come to love. The quest takes Kat and Daniel deep into the East End, where they face dangerous foes from Daniel’s rugged past who will stop at nothing to keep Kat and Daniel from uncovering their secrets. As Kat begins to learn things about Daniel’s history, she fears that the darkest secret—his true name and lineage—will tear apart the tender bonds they’ve begun to form.

So many historical mysteries and romances involve at least one character who is a peer, if not both. What I loved about this one is that neither of the leads comes from a title. Kat is a cook for a well-to-do family, and Daniel doesn't even know who his family is, plus he is a deliveryman who's also worked for Scotland Yard. It's definitely a nice change of pace. Apparently much has happened between books 1 and 9. Kat and Daniel are now betrothed. Kat's daughter Grace lives with her friends Joanna and Sam Millburn, and Kat is having trouble dealing with the fact that the Millburns and their family - including Grace - are going to be moving out of London to a town hours away because Sam got a promotion. Kat is also dealing with setting up a stall in a market area selling her wares on her time off, hoping perhaps she can have her own business. Meanwhile, Daniel is no longer working for Scotland Yard and is back to his delivery business with his son James, though he's available if Scotland Yard should need him. So there's a lot going on for both of them when someone contacts Daniel, claiming to have knowledge of his past. When Daniel and Kat go to look for the man who didn't show up for their meeting, they do find him. Dead. So now not only are they trying to figure out what Daniel's past is, but also looking for a murderer. Assisting them is Zachariah Grimes, a man with a criminal history who is their friend and has saved them in the past. Also joining the hunt is Mr. Errol Fielding, a vicar in the East End who happens to have shared a foster parent with Daniel. Let's say he is not a particularly Godly vicar! Another character I simply adored was a woman Kat met who was. a bookseller; Kat was trying to track down the connection between a book about the seaside and Daniel's past, and the woman goes well beyond what Kat expected. And then there's Hannah, a woman at the market who is friends with Kat and Grace. I love the characters in this book, particularly Kat and Daniel, of course. Kat is tough, having had to work for others and keeping the secret of her daughter from her employers. Daniel is a strong character as well, having grown up on the streets, running a delivery service and having a 19-year-old-son, James. The mystery herein was a great one, with plenty of red herrings to keep one guessing. My favorite part, of course, deals with Daniel discovering who he actually is and who his family was. I hope this series continues to go on for a good long while. And I also hope I find time to read all that I missed!

I received an ARC of this book courtesy of the publisher and NetGalley. I received no compensation for my review, and all thoughts and opinions expressed are entirely my own.
Professional ReaderReviews PublishedFrequently Auto-ApprovedCamp NetGalley 2024500 Book Reviews
Profile Image for Caitie’s  Reading Nook.
100 reviews1 follower
August 14, 2026
Another good installment of the series. The change in narrator threw me for a loop. I forgot some characters relevance by change in voices.
Profile Image for Lady Penny.
144 reviews2 followers
October 10, 2026
I didn’t finish this book because after reading this whole series it felt like I’d read this book several times already and I am tired of same old, same old. Like the Mikaela and Brodie series I am sick to death of the romance (tepid as it is) between Kat and Daniel.
I think the final straw came when Daniel, sitting in the kitchen sipping tea and eating Kat’s leftovers at midnight (for about the eleventy billionth time), confesses that he is “Quite fond of you Kat”. Good grief. Some basis for marriage … and after about five years of almost courting and the occasional chaste kiss. Crikey. How boring.
At that mind-blowingly inane comment, I put down the kindle, opened up Libby and returned my loan.
Am finished with this pair. Good luck to them and their relationship. I couldn’t care less.
Profile Image for Amalia.
148 reviews4 followers
August 27, 2026
Five reasons I'm giving Five Stars to Murder in Blackfriars by Jennifer Ashley:

1. The series - We are in 1880 London and Kat Holloway is a cook in a posh house. There is an interesting upstairs-downstairs scenario, there is a mysterious Daniel, and there are of course bodies.

2. The protagonist - Kat is always the smartest, kindest and most capable person in the room
AND she's a fantastic cook. But I'm not holding it against her because, relatively speaking, she is a
product of her time.

3. The sensibility - So many protagonists of historical mysteries are liberal feminists with modern
sensibilities that you forget how difficult it was for a single woman to make her way. These books
feel more authentic in this respect.

4. The domestic details - I love details of daily life and these books take the time to let us know how
a cook in Victorian London went about her day. There are a LOT of yummy food descriptions.

5. The atmosphere - If you are in the market for a light and gentle read, fast paced but without gore,
with a likeable heroine, a nice feeling for the period and a bit of romance, this could be the series for you.
Profile Image for Mindy B (reader_of_the_lost_arcs) .
796 reviews20 followers
August 22, 2026
I was very interested to find out about Daniel's past in this book. A roller-coaster of emotions! I know these books aren't technically romance, but I read them just to see the progress of the relationship between Kat and Daniel. They've come such a long way!!

The narrator was good, but not as good as the previous one. It's always difficult to try to get used to a different voice so far into the series.
Thank you to Dreamscape Media for the copy of this book. Opinions are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 123 reviews