Creepy, eerie, and filled with a twisted kind of unending dread, Whistle was everything I could want in a classic-style horror novel. From the supernatural plot to the early aughts feel, Barclay suffused this tale with the type of thrills and chills that make you question reality despite knowing it’s a fictional tale. The first horror-esque novel that I’ve ever read, I was pleasantly surprised by how he managed to slowly drop me into the hair-raising storyline without putting me off. You see, with every additional page, this twisty plot became more and more unhinged. Bringing to life your very worst nightmares, the storyline gave me a very Stephen King-like vibe as I became fully invested in each of the characters—even the bad ones.
Speaking of those characters, they were beyond well-crafted in my eyes. Pairing a villain who will make your blood run cold with two protagonists who you’ll cheer on as you watch the monster creep closer, it was the quintessential face-off that will have you flying through the pages at speed. Just be sure not to get too attached to any of the characters. You see, more than once I was shocked down to my bones when someone dropped dead. Don’t get me wrong, it added an element of unpredictability that kept me on the edge of my seat. Tense, clever, and taunting, I had goosebumps from the fear as the spine-tingling foreboding ensured that my sleep would be disturbed long after I was done.
All said and done, I’ve now come to realize that I’m a fan of old-school horror in all of its glory. With a sinister tone and twists that were unguessable in the extreme, I was well beyond my armchair sleuthing abilities. You see, thanks to dual timelines and multiple POVs, there was no seeing around the well-plotted blind turns. Just be aware that it was indeed more horror than thriller and had some truly grisly scenes. Nevertheless, the gradually building tension in this slow burn was almost perfect. Could it have been edited just a bit? Well, maybe. After all, it did drag here and there. Despite this, however, I was won over hook, line, and sinker and now can’t wait to explore more horror novels in the future. Rating of 4.5 stars.
SYNOPSIS:
Annie Blunt has had an unimaginably terrible year. First, her husband was killed in a tragic hit-and-run accident, then one of the children’s books she’s built her writing and illustrating career on ignited a major scandal. Desperate for a fresh start, she moves with her son Charlie to a charming small town in upstate New York where they can begin to heal.
But Annie’s year is about to get worse.
Bored and lonely in their isolated new surroundings, Charlie is thrilled when he finds a forgotten train set in a locked shed on their property. Annie is glad to see Charlie happy, but there’s something unsettling about his new toy. Strange sounds wake Annie in the night—she could swear she hears a train, but there isn’t an active track for miles—and bizarre things begin happening in the neighborhood. Worse, Annie can’t seem to stop drawing a disturbing new character that has no place in a children’s book.
Grief can do strange things to the mind, but Annie is beginning to think she’s walked out of one nightmare straight into another, only this one is far more terrifying…
Thank you to Linwood Barclay and William Morrow Books for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
PUB DATE: May 20, 2025
Content warning: cursing, death of a husband, suicide, animal death, knife violence, mention of: fatal hit-and-run accident