This book is a YA supernatural adventure/ rescue story which is part of a series. It's exuberance reminds me of Lloyd Alexander in his Prydain Chronicles. Their spirit of adventure is the same. While our protagonist is a strong female is this book, Lloyd's is a male, it make's little difference – they both have that special something that makes a series great. K.B. Hoyle should be proud to create such a series as this for young adults. I remember reading the Alexander books as a kid, as well as to my kids and the enjoyment was the same both times – in fact, I think it was better reading it out loud to my kids when they were eight or nine, we all enjoyed it immensely. The only books they enjoyed as much as Alexander were His Dark Materials series by Phillip Pullman. I think my kids would have loved this series, it has all the hallmarks of books they loved: adventure, magic, good friendships, loyalty, monsters, evil, wizards, technology, other worlds, mysteries, teenagers solving things on their own, battles, magical items, magical creatures, a magical system, swords, chivalry, honor, and everything else that goes with a thumping good read for kids and teenagers and that is what this is.
THE PLOT: Six teenagers from our world are transported through a magical gate at summer camp each year to a world called Alitheia. Darcy, our protagonist, is a strong, teenaged girl who works for her father at the family furniture store. She is harassed at school ,based on her Father's sign on his store, but she handles it because she thinks of Alitheia and the things that she has to do there. Sam – a girl, is her friend. Lewis, is also her friend and is a brain in chemistry and math. Perry is a jock. Amelia is a musician. Dean is a friend of Perry's and is also a jock. Darcy and Perry have been chatting over the computer during the year that has just passed and kind of “like” each other.. Now it is summer – time for camp. Time for Alitheia. Darcy has a mission. She has to rescue her friend, Yahto Vehli – a nark who had the Oracle set Darcy free last year by offering his life up to the Oracle. As her third trip to Alitheia draws near, will Darcy be able to save Yahto Veli? Will her friends help her? Is there more to this rescue then meets the eye? And what of the royals in Alitheia? How do they fit in? Will they be a part of this? Will Darcy go it alone? Will other narks help her? Will this rescue be a grand and glorious adventure or a gigantic flop? And what of the evil that lurks in the land in the form of Tselloch? What is he doing and how will it effect Alitheia? There are so many twists and turns in this plot, it's like you never know which way you are facing – like playing blind man's bluff – put a blindfold on. Have someone spin you around, then ou ttry to find someone. You are truly disoriented. That is the type of plot this book has. There are so many options in this book that it is like a labyrinth, one wrong turn and you are lost. For plot, I give the book, 9/10.
THE CHARACTERIZATION: The characterization mostly centered on Darcy – our protagonist. She got the royal treatment, with frills and all. She was completely detailed, human, three dimensional, technicolor with flaws, foibles, and quirks. The other teenagers got the next best treatment. I have to include Tellius in this – a Prince of Alitheia, who is supposed to marry one of teenagers and become King of Alitheia. Sam, Amelia, Lewis, Perry, Dean, Tellius were all rather human, but not as detailed as Darcy. Even the wizard Rubidius who played quite a role in the book, saving people with his magic and figuring out situations was not as detailed as Darcy. I really liked Rubidius, he was portrayed as a cranky old wizard – a trope, I know, but one I liked. Cranky wizards can be funny if done right, and this one was. The other people in the book were not detailed, even Eleanor, who I thought would have been treated quite differently, as she was an elder in Alitheia and quite important to the royals as well as to Rubidius. You got some glimpses of her personality, but that was all. Maybe in future books, or in past books, that detailing was provided and I missed it. But, consistency is not over-rated in my opinion, so I would think that the characterization would flow through all of the books. I give this part of the novel a 6/10
THE DIALOGUE: The dialogue of the book was not the slang you expect from teenagers, and neither was it true of any of the great books mentioned before in the introduction. Too much slang, and you are dragged away from the story, in fact the teenagers made a serious effort to stay away from slang and any mention of technology or anything from their world in Alitheia, which made sense considering they were in a different world where magic reigned and they had adult responsibilities which put them in league with the royals of Alitheia on a day to day basis. This meant that their dialogue had to be quite formal in Alitheia and they played their parts quite well – only slipping up once, when Perry made an analogy to a video game system which went over everyone's head except the teenagers. When they get back home, the dialogue is business as usual. I give this section a 9/10.
THE GORE SCORE: There is very little to almost no gore in this book – being YA, I expected little gore. There is only one scene in the book, where a monster which islanders think is a goddess eats a man. It is not bloodless, but not bloody either, but rather dramatic. I give the gore score a 2/10
THE IMAGERY: the imagery in the book was really quite good. Hoyle was quite imaginative in describing the magical characters and places where they found themselves, along with the sequences of action that occurred through the novel. While not quite movie quality – it gave the imagination all it needed to create Alitheia in full detail, including: islands, a castle, a town, a bridge, a dwarf town, battles, a volcano, a grotto, snake infested lily pads, an island village, the royal ship, a village riot, several nightmares, the Oracle's Labyrinth, and other places. There was more than enough information in the book's sentences, adjectives, adverbs and sentence structure to create these places in your mind without any trouble. The imagery for young people will be all they need to create the world of Alitheia in their heads because of that, I give this an 8/10. As for worldbudiling, that is another story completely, and will not be addressed here.
THE PACING: The pacing in the book – with it's exuberance – is so swift, that you feel like you are being dragged behind a horse galloping along at full speed without stopping for anything. When the novel is done, then you are let go. Of course – this is not a painful process, more like a runaway wagon on a arrow straight road running full out, with no hope of stopping. You are hooked – fully in the power of the book. You don't want to leave off reading it. You don't want to close the book. You want to keep reading and reading until you are done. The pacing doesn't let up. It doesn't slow down. It just keeps going and going and going. That is how adventures ought to be. Full throttle – foot to the floor – all out. No one likes an adventure that drags, at least I don't. That's why the pacing on this one works. If it was a car – this is how it would play out. Ultra high-speed, nitrous oxide spraying, barreling down the road, faster than anything out there, red lining the engine, big meats squealing, 25” rubber grabbing traction, fishtailing back and forth down the road as everything moves into the rear-view mirror. I give this a 10/10 for pacing.
THE ENDING: The ending of the book was a little too convenient as well as a cliffhanger. Once they got what they wanted, and were faced with another trial, they were swiftly picked up by an invisible hand and carried away to the gate – as another year had passed. They were deposited on the Earth side of the gate. Summer camp was over. It was time to leave for home. Frustrated that they did not get to face this new trial, they checked out a hunch at the summer camp, and found a surprise – which will be addressed in the next book I am sure. While one storyline came to full closure, many more were opened up. Evil is running unchecked from two sources and the royals and in a worse position than ever. Someone's life hangs in the balance. But whose? This is such a cliffhanger of an ending that I felt little to no closure, which unsettled and surprised me. While I really enjoyed the book, the ending chopped off the adventure at a seriously weird place adding a twist and a mystery as well that left me wondering just what the heck was the author thinking ending the book this way. It may have seemed natural to her, but it just pissed me off. Yes, I want to read the next book because I am hooked, but at the same time, I am thoroughly frustrated at the outcome of the this book – leaving me swinging in the wind with one hand on a root and no footing whatsoever. So, I hope the next book comes out soon, so I can overcome this frustration. It is not nice to frustrate readers. They can decide with their feet – and walk away. If the book wasn't so good, that is what I would do. But it is, so I will carry on. K.B. Hoyle, please – no more cliffhangers! I hate them. They tease and frustrate the reader. It just isn't fair. I give this section a 6/10.
THE UPSHOT: The book and the series is definitely worth reading. Start at the beginning and buy the whole thing. Read them one by one, until you get to this book and its cliffhanger. At least you will know it is coming. I will try to get some hints of what is coming in my interview with K. B. Hoyle. I really like this series. I recommend it for pre-teens and teenagers who like adventures with magic and magical creatures, evil, battles, swords, other worlds, warriors, Kings, Princes, teenagers who makes their own decisions and do their own thing. Friendships are a big part of these books as well as loyalty to each other. That's what makes these teenagers stronger that normal – that and their magic. They each gain magical powers when they cross to Alitheia. Then there is the prophecy about the six teenagers – but that is another story for another day. Parents – buy these books and read them aloud to your kids, you will be a hero if you read these. They will beg for more after each book and after each chapter. The girls will especially love Darcy with her wind magic and her deductive powers of reasoning and her bravery. She is strong, kind and loyal. Just like the Lyra Belacqua in His Dark Materials by Phillip Pullman, but older and wiser, less impulsive. She takes her responsibilities seriously. She is a humble hero. She always worries about her friends and the affect her actions have on them. A perfect role model for your children. These are good stories for your girls as well as your boys. For the boys have role models as well: Tellius, Perry, Dean and Lewis, Wal Wyn, Yahto Veli and the other narks are all role models for your boys. The honesty, the loyalty, the bravery, the heroics, the humbleness all goes back to the days of chivalry – which is when men were good to women and protected what was good without reward, or thinking of themselves before acting. That is why these books are so endearing. They also remind me in a small way of some of the Sabatini books, but without the magic, just the chivalry. Sabatini was so good at chivalry – maybe the best. He is another one I would read to your children, if heroes are what they like, and adventure is what lights their fire. But, to get back to White Thread – put chivalry together with adventure, magic, magical creatures, evil enemies and mysteries abounding – what you have is a series which represents one thumping good read for young adults.You can't beat that one with a stick! The overall MLB score (see below for score card) is 48/60 which means a high 4 stars. (about 4.8 stars)
MLB Scoring System
50 – 60 5 STARS
40 – 49 4 STARS
30 – 39 3 STARS
20 – 29 2 STARS
10 – 19 1 STARS
0 - 9 0 STARS