I really enjoyed reading this non-fiction book concerning a holiday-"holy day" about a Catholic Saint's Day, in this case Saint Patrick. Of course it did not ignore how and why Patricius (the Latin name given to him by the Pope in 432) became a saint and why we celebrate his Catholic Feast Day, how could it? Saint Patrick was a Catholic Bishop who did missionary work in Ireland. This is another fine non-fiction book by Gail Gibbons. It is informative and interesting.
I noted that while this is a children's book and it is relatively easy to read, apparently it is also very easy to misunderstand. One person went so far as to find "questionable" information in it in the legends presented. Catholics will not find anything "questionable" in this book. Others may find it "questionable," but I firmly believe it is only due to a lack of understanding.
First and foremost, the legends are not meant to be taken literally. The individual who found the information "questionable" seems to have a limited knowledge of literature and especially a limited knowledge of folklore. She also seems to have a limited understanding of Christianity and the history of religion.
At the end of the story, several legends are presented. These legends are used as symbolism. Symbolism is used in many kinds of writings. For example, if one slept on a hard bed one might write that they slept on a stack of bricks. Is it easy for most people to understand that the mattress was very hard and not actually made of bricks? How about a 4 or 5 year old? Some people and children will understand and some won’t. In fact, some listeners will imagine a person literally sleeping on a mattress made of bricks!
Symbolism in literature is very important. In all of the legends presented in Gail Gibbon’s book, symbolism makes an appearance. It makes sense that legends about a Catholic Saint would contain symbolism. The Bible, Catholicism and religion in general tends to contain many symbolisms. The cross, the rosary, the snake, the dove—are all symbols representing Catholic beliefs. In addition, these symbols sometimes appear in non-symbolic literal ways. The legends presented are Catholic stories that are and were used to teach about God and it is natural that they should also contain symbols. It is important to read these legends understanding those facts. It is important to read all literary works based on religious figures with an open mind and a lot of caution especially if the religious figure or religious work is outside of one’s religion (as is evident in the person who found the legends "questionable" and is obviously not Catholic).
If a person happens upon a book that takes a religious slant, they should either quit reading it, or they should try to find out what that particular religion believes and what that religion's symbolism is and THEN they should interpret the work. If they can’t or decide they do not want to do that, then they should probably exercise caution in their reviews and interpretations, which is the intelligent thing to do. Ignorance and actions taken upon ignorance often lead to misunderstandings and hate that is un-Christian, wrong, and mean. Why not ask for help with the interpretations or simply state that it was unfamiliar to you and that others would get more from it if they shared the same beliefs represented in the work?
When people read literature, even a story as simple as one in a child’s book, they only do right by the story when they take the time to understand why the story was written, what message it is meant to convey, who the audience is, and any literary devices (symbolism, etc) the author used that might affect how it is meant to be interpreted. When reviewing a story, it is also very important to be knowledgeable about what type of work one is reading so as to be fair in one’s interpretation (and review) and the historical context of the work if it is important. In this case all of the above is important.
Interpreting the Legends:
Saint Patrick and the snakes: In this one the snakes represent paganism and evil. Saint Patrick got rid of evil paganism in Ireland and replaced it with Christianity. No literal snakes…. Sorry.
Saint Patrick and the poison: In this one, the wizard represents a Druid (a pagan priest), the cup and drink means the message St. Patrick was telling, and the ice means that St. Patrick quickly showed that there was no merit in the lies (poison) the Druid tried to put in it. It can also mean that a Druid literally tried to kill St. Patrick and was unable to when St. Patrick stopped him cold (the ice!). More likely than not, neither the cup, nor the ice, nor the poison are literally real.
Saint Patrick and the Cloak: In this one, a convert (the friend) has been saved from evil or Hell (the big fire) by Saint Patrick’s cloak (the message given by Saint Patrick---or a belief in God attributed to Saint Patrick’s preaching that the friend was able to use as protection).
Saint Patrick and the shamrock: This one is easy. St. Patrick needed a teaching tool and so he picked up a three leaf clover (there are a lot of these in Ireland), and so he used it as a visual aid to show how three things (The Blessed Holy Trinity) could have the same stem (God). No, the shamrock is not really Jesus, The Holy Spirit and God.
Saint Patrick and the fish: The sea is the life giving water, which is also the Living Water: Who is Jesus Christ. The fish are men/people. Fish are pretty standard symbolism for men (people) in Catholicism. The altar of Saint Patrick—simply means Saint Patrick is taking the men (fish)to Jesus and God, which is why they are passing by his altar (the altar represents Saint Patrick’s life of preaching against paganism).
Saint Patrick and the Sunset: The sun didn’t set for 12 days and nights when Patrick died. This one just means that Patrick was given a 12 day send off when he died. He was very special and deserved a long funeral. He was so special he was declared a saint.
Saints play in important role in Catholicism. They aren’t just people to have fun holidays over. They were humans who lead exemplary lives. According to the Catholic Church they are worthy of being looked up to as role models. (Who needs actors or models or singers to emulate, when you have a whole bunch of people who lead holy lives and who loved God so much they dedicated their entire lives to HIM?) Patrick was special and became a saint. It doesn’t mean that Patrick was perfect. It only means that it was decided that, “Patrick must be in Heaven with God."
Saint Patrick lived over 1500 years ago. It was a time when people didn’t have books and didn’t even know how to read. There weren’t schools and the world was certainly not modern. And so, men like Saint Patrick used stories like Jesus did---it was a traditional way --to teach important lessons and to convert people to Christianity. When others told stories about Saint Patrick, they used the same forms of story-telling.
Saint Patrick is a Catholic Saint and presented in Bishop’s attire in the cover, which is a clue that his religious aspects will be mentioned in the story book. Saint Patrick’s Catholic Heritage does and should affect the stories that are told about him, as they do in this book. Gail Gibbons got it 100% right.
Like many religions, Catholics have ways and reasons to pray. We pray in gratitude and we pray in times of need. We pray for our children, our spouses, for health, etc. We pray when we are lonely, sad, depressed and sick or when someone we love is. We pray for people we know and for complete strangers. Saints can have an important role in our prayer if we have that desire, so they are special to us and not just another excuse for a holiday. We can ASK any of the Saints to pray for us to God—we can pray ourselves to God as well of course, but the bigger and more saintly our prayer chain the better, wouldn’t you agree?
While it can be fun to celebrate Saint Patrick’s Day with parties, parades, wearing green, pinching those not wearing green, making crafts, decorating, eating green foods and deserts, reading books and learning about Saint Patrick, hitting the Irish Pubs, having a green beer and doing an Irish jig, it is a Catholic Saint Feast Day and its Catholic Heritage should be respected.
The facts about Saint Patrick's Day. Saint Patrick is a patron saint of Ireland. Patrick was a real man. His name wasn't Patrick at first, though. He was given the name Patrick by Pope Celestine I. He became a Catholic Biship and decided to help Christianize pagan Ireland---which the Catholic Church is grateful for. Saint Patricks's missionary work is why he achieved Catholic Sainthood. After Patrick died he was declared a saint. His Feast Day is celebrated on March 17th which is the day he died and went to Heaven. Saint Patrick is one of many Catholic Saints. Saint Patrick is so popular that many non-Catholics have heard about him and have celebrated his Feast Day at least once or twice---maybe even more! Nowadays, a lot of non-Irish people (don't worry, Patrick wasn't Irish either!) and a lot of non-Catholics celebrate Saint Patrick's Day. It is a lot of fun!