What do you think?
Rate this book
Thinking of Winter: From the Bestselling Author of I came upon the lighthouse, Shantanu Naidu | A Moving Memoir of Love, Healing & Bond Between a Man and His Dog
When Shantanu left for the United States, the promise of a new life felt quiet, isolating and cold.
Then Winter arrived. A puppy adopted selfishly.
Shantanu did not realize how much this decision would shape his life.
Everyone loves their dogs, naturally. Every dog is a good boy, naturally. But Winter is no ordinary dog. With old soul eyes and a heart that made room for everything, Winter skipped the chaos that any puppy is entitled to. Instead, he chose a unique path, like a gentleman who had wandered in from another time, and decided he would share it with the world.
From the snowed-in streets of Ithaca to the restless rain of Mumbai, between these pages is an adventure of a lost adult and a special dog. In Winter’s stillness, lie lessons on how to stay. In his charm, one learns how to meet the world with softness. In his quiet daily life, are buried hints on how to heal.
These adventures are a tender chronicle of companionship, resilience and the small, surprising ways in which a four-legged friend set out to change a few many worlds.
Then Winter arrived. A puppy adopted selfishly.
Shantanu did not realize how much this decision would shape his life.
Everyone loves their dogs, naturally. Every dog is a good boy, naturally. But Winter is no ordinary dog. With old soul eyes and a heart that made room for everything, Winter skipped the chaos that any puppy is entitled to. Instead, he chose a unique path, like a gentleman who had wandered in from another time, and decided he would share it with the world.
From the snowed-in streets of Ithaca to the restless rain of Mumbai, between these pages is an adventure of a lost adult and a special dog. In Winter’s stillness, lie lessons on how to stay. In his charm, one learns how to meet the world with softness. In his quiet daily life, are buried hints on how to heal.
These adventures are a tender chronicle of companionship, resilience and the small, surprising ways in which a four-legged friend set out to change a few many worlds.
129 pages, Kindle Edition
Published December 22, 2025
21 people are currently reading
74 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 77 reviews
December 30, 2025
I am posting this review as if I am writing a letter to the Author so here it goes....
Dear Shantanu,
Penning down few memories out of the abundant incidents you have lived with Winter and making us part of your personal diary isn't easy.
But you still managed to do it so effortlessly that it didn't feel like I was reading them. One day I was Manasi restlessly worried for PUPPYA (loved this cutu name btw) or taking care of Sir Charles. Another day I was those doctors in pain for injecting Winter to recover faster while the next I was Amruta seeing how the Holden brothers were enjoying in wilderness. And that indeed is a sign of effevtive writing/storytelling.
Life doesn't come with a manual so does a parenting chapter but I believe having a Pet makes you a better one because if you can provide your warmth, care, support, love, and understanding to animals (who can't speak) you have certainly outdid.
And Shantanu never ever I repeat NEVER EVER doubt yourself on "IFs and BUTs" & that you have deprived Winter of anything. You have outshined as a pet parent and did everything best he could have asked for. You are not just a father you are his PawPaw🤗🐾🐕🦺whose PRESENCE matters the MOST.
The use of certain Italian words were apt enough to hear what you really wanted to say and we heard it😆😆 And I have cried endlessly in "Peecasso" and "Every Second Counts" Chapter😭😭
My favourite line from the book: When Winter was in the sun, you couldn't tell where the warmth was coming from.
Finally WHOSSSSS THE GOODEST BUOY???
WINTER IS OUR GOODEST BOUY🐕🦺😘
Dear Shantanu,
Penning down few memories out of the abundant incidents you have lived with Winter and making us part of your personal diary isn't easy.
But you still managed to do it so effortlessly that it didn't feel like I was reading them. One day I was Manasi restlessly worried for PUPPYA (loved this cutu name btw) or taking care of Sir Charles. Another day I was those doctors in pain for injecting Winter to recover faster while the next I was Amruta seeing how the Holden brothers were enjoying in wilderness. And that indeed is a sign of effevtive writing/storytelling.
Life doesn't come with a manual so does a parenting chapter but I believe having a Pet makes you a better one because if you can provide your warmth, care, support, love, and understanding to animals (who can't speak) you have certainly outdid.
And Shantanu never ever I repeat NEVER EVER doubt yourself on "IFs and BUTs" & that you have deprived Winter of anything. You have outshined as a pet parent and did everything best he could have asked for. You are not just a father you are his PawPaw🤗🐾🐕🦺whose PRESENCE matters the MOST.
The use of certain Italian words were apt enough to hear what you really wanted to say and we heard it😆😆 And I have cried endlessly in "Peecasso" and "Every Second Counts" Chapter😭😭
My favourite line from the book: When Winter was in the sun, you couldn't tell where the warmth was coming from.
Finally WHOSSSSS THE GOODEST BUOY???
WINTER IS OUR GOODEST BOUY🐕🦺😘
January 4, 2026
Shantanu can never disappoint as an author, the way he writes is like going through someone's personal diary.
The book on the other hand made me cry twice. I remember reading "I came upon a lighthouse" and not writing much about that here but it gave a different perspective to life.
"Thinking of Winter" made me go through a rollercoaster ride, my love for dogs has been crazy since my childhood and I think the book articulated it so well. The parts where the author might be losing his mind .. were the parts I could see myself in distress and hence I chose the words "personal diary". Unfortunately or Fortunately I do realise why even at the age of 25, my parents don't want me to have a pet. It's not just a responsibility it's a life which we are bringing in our lives and we are accountable for their every single emotion. I have lost some of my indies .. sat by them buried and realised how unfair it is, but reading it gave me much more depth of what goes on in one's mind when it's their whole world. I think every chapter takes you on a journey of Winter, Yobo , fostered pigeons, Sir Charles, Shadow making you realise "Until one has loved an animal, a part of one’s soul remains unawakened".(Anatole France)
The book on the other hand made me cry twice. I remember reading "I came upon a lighthouse" and not writing much about that here but it gave a different perspective to life.
"Thinking of Winter" made me go through a rollercoaster ride, my love for dogs has been crazy since my childhood and I think the book articulated it so well. The parts where the author might be losing his mind .. were the parts I could see myself in distress and hence I chose the words "personal diary". Unfortunately or Fortunately I do realise why even at the age of 25, my parents don't want me to have a pet. It's not just a responsibility it's a life which we are bringing in our lives and we are accountable for their every single emotion. I have lost some of my indies .. sat by them buried and realised how unfair it is, but reading it gave me much more depth of what goes on in one's mind when it's their whole world. I think every chapter takes you on a journey of Winter, Yobo , fostered pigeons, Sir Charles, Shadow making you realise "Until one has loved an animal, a part of one’s soul remains unawakened".(Anatole France)
December 31, 2025
After finishing the book, I found myself going back to the very first page just to read that line again:
“But what did giving up even mean?”
There was a whole library of answers to that question. I chose the most selfish one.
His name was winter .
Reading that again made me pause.
This book isn’t just a story about a dog named Winter. It’s a book filled with quiet life lessons ones that stay with you long after you’ve turned the last page. I can honestly say this is probably the only book I’ve ever read with tears and I’m writing this message with them too.
Your writing is gentle, beautiful, and deeply relatable. You put into words so many things we never say out loud. And somehow, someone sitting far away from you, living a completely different life, can still feel seen through your words. That’s a rare gift.
I loved that you left a few pages empty at the end. Because even though the book ends, it doesn’t really end. It feels like something that could go on foreverand in some way, it does.
Reading this made me realize that maybe it’s okay to feel everything, to feel too much sometimeseven if it comes with a few scratches along the way.
Thank you for writing this book. Thank you for making us feel all the feelings.
Lots of love, always. 💙
“But what did giving up even mean?”
There was a whole library of answers to that question. I chose the most selfish one.
His name was winter .
Reading that again made me pause.
This book isn’t just a story about a dog named Winter. It’s a book filled with quiet life lessons ones that stay with you long after you’ve turned the last page. I can honestly say this is probably the only book I’ve ever read with tears and I’m writing this message with them too.
Your writing is gentle, beautiful, and deeply relatable. You put into words so many things we never say out loud. And somehow, someone sitting far away from you, living a completely different life, can still feel seen through your words. That’s a rare gift.
I loved that you left a few pages empty at the end. Because even though the book ends, it doesn’t really end. It feels like something that could go on foreverand in some way, it does.
Reading this made me realize that maybe it’s okay to feel everything, to feel too much sometimeseven if it comes with a few scratches along the way.
Thank you for writing this book. Thank you for making us feel all the feelings.
Lots of love, always. 💙
January 2, 2026
Reading Thinking of Winter was such a serene experience. ✨ Your words captured the unspoken bond between you and Winter so beautifully, turning everyday moments into profound lessons on presence, healing, and the kind of love that asks for nothing but simply is. What moved me most was how you described Winter—a soul so pure that he wants to help every living creature, regardless of their species . Thinking of Winter is a masterpiece of empathy.❤️ The stories of Winter’s kindness toward other species really stayed with me. He is the personification of pure, unconditional love. Thinking of Winter is such a soul-stirring read. ❄️Absolutely stunning. It has found a permanent home on my shelf and in my reflections. Dear Shantanu , Thank you for sharing this beautiful and tender memoir with us. Sending lots of love and warm hugs to Winter 🐾and best wishes to you too.🌟🍀
December 26, 2025
It was Shantanu's first book "I Came Upon A Lighthouse" that introduced me to reading & i haven't stopped since then.
The one's who've met or heard Shantanu would know that there's no Ghost writtings taking over the charm.
It his the very wit he talks to you is what his writings would sound too in this book.
Dogs are souls on earth that are jam packed with abundance of love & they shower it through every twitch, snout & tail wag you see.
Thank you for sharing Winter's love with us & making him a part of our lives.
Can't stop Thinking about Winter.
The one's who've met or heard Shantanu would know that there's no Ghost writtings taking over the charm.
It his the very wit he talks to you is what his writings would sound too in this book.
Dogs are souls on earth that are jam packed with abundance of love & they shower it through every twitch, snout & tail wag you see.
Thank you for sharing Winter's love with us & making him a part of our lives.
Can't stop Thinking about Winter.
January 13, 2026
Some books find you at exactly the right moment in your life, and this was one of them.
Winter’s story unfolds gently, and that softness is what makes it so powerful. It does not rely on loud moments or dramatic twists. Instead, it quietly reminds you of kindness without conditions, love without expectations, and gratitude for the smallest moments that make life meaningful.
What stayed with me the most was how naturally the story teaches you to be kind simply because you can. There is something deeply moving about being on both sides of love, giving it freely and learning how to receive it with grace. Winter’s presence feels pure and grounding, like a reminder to stay human in a world that often asks us to harden ourselves.
The cute illustrations added an extra layer of warmth to the reading experience. They felt comforting and thoughtful, almost like little pauses that let the emotions sink in more deeply.
Reading this book felt like entering a safe, quiet space. Shantanu’s writing carries a calm honesty that does not try to impress, but instead connects. By the time I reached the end, the story did not feel finished. It felt like it had settled somewhere inside me. Winter, Yobo, Sir Charles, Shadow, and the two poodles are characters I know I will carry with me for a long time. Thank you, Shantanu, for sharing Winter's story and a big part of your life with us.
Winter’s story unfolds gently, and that softness is what makes it so powerful. It does not rely on loud moments or dramatic twists. Instead, it quietly reminds you of kindness without conditions, love without expectations, and gratitude for the smallest moments that make life meaningful.
What stayed with me the most was how naturally the story teaches you to be kind simply because you can. There is something deeply moving about being on both sides of love, giving it freely and learning how to receive it with grace. Winter’s presence feels pure and grounding, like a reminder to stay human in a world that often asks us to harden ourselves.
The cute illustrations added an extra layer of warmth to the reading experience. They felt comforting and thoughtful, almost like little pauses that let the emotions sink in more deeply.
Reading this book felt like entering a safe, quiet space. Shantanu’s writing carries a calm honesty that does not try to impress, but instead connects. By the time I reached the end, the story did not feel finished. It felt like it had settled somewhere inside me. Winter, Yobo, Sir Charles, Shadow, and the two poodles are characters I know I will carry with me for a long time. Thank you, Shantanu, for sharing Winter's story and a big part of your life with us.
January 12, 2026
The plots of this book are indeed remarkable. They are cautiously, lovingly and truthfully written. All of them remain in your mind even after reading. The most remarkable thing was the compassion and sympathy of the writing making the stories seem real and moving!
I am totally agree with the book possesses authentic emotions. It is a source of smiles and tears, and that is its peculiarity. It is wintertime, which is about living with a dreamy mood, and love is about challenges. The story is told in a soothing way and makes the reader sink into the touching scenes. It produces a profound association without bombarding the senses. Love, companionship, loss and loyalty are also expressed in a very simplistic and in-depth way that creates an impression!
It is to the credit of Shantanu that he shares these heartfelt recollections and insights with readers. It has touched my heart and has been a very moving and meaningful experience that I will not forget soon. I highly recommend this book to every pet parents!
I am totally agree with the book possesses authentic emotions. It is a source of smiles and tears, and that is its peculiarity. It is wintertime, which is about living with a dreamy mood, and love is about challenges. The story is told in a soothing way and makes the reader sink into the touching scenes. It produces a profound association without bombarding the senses. Love, companionship, loss and loyalty are also expressed in a very simplistic and in-depth way that creates an impression!
It is to the credit of Shantanu that he shares these heartfelt recollections and insights with readers. It has touched my heart and has been a very moving and meaningful experience that I will not forget soon. I highly recommend this book to every pet parents!
January 5, 2026
Light and touching read!
My wife bought this book at airport while our gates got changed. While I successfully failed looking for something for myself in the same book store, I looked over the book and thought of flipping some pages.
What caught my eye were illustrations about the narrative every other time I kept on flipping the pages. Winter is the hero of the book and Shan-taaanu captures it so well. The story is about bonding, unexpected life companions, places and how we are shaped with what we go through and with whom by our side.
Very touching and loving story.
My wife bought this book at airport while our gates got changed. While I successfully failed looking for something for myself in the same book store, I looked over the book and thought of flipping some pages.
What caught my eye were illustrations about the narrative every other time I kept on flipping the pages. Winter is the hero of the book and Shan-taaanu captures it so well. The story is about bonding, unexpected life companions, places and how we are shaped with what we go through and with whom by our side.
Very touching and loving story.
January 5, 2026
Finished reading this book as I commuted to and from the office in the Mumbai local. As I read the book, each page felt like a connection. I could visualise the scenes as I turned the pages. I knew I was going to love this book. And that’s what happened. ♥️
I felt happy and smiled as I read the happy memories. I would feel the pain if something went wrong.
The book was a beautiful journey. I enjoyed reading it.
I felt happy and smiled as I read the happy memories. I would feel the pain if something went wrong.
The book was a beautiful journey. I enjoyed reading it.
December 28, 2025
I have finished reading the book today and now I am thinking of WINTER now. 😊
I have enjoyed reading it….was always in the excitement to know what happens next while reading. I loved the way Shantanu has bonded with Winter. It’s more than just the bond between a pet and his owner….its like a father and son relationship. The description about his bonding with Winter is so well written that I could imagine all of it as if I was present there. Him describing tiny details about Winter made me think, what if Winter could also describe how it felt about Shantanu in the same way. I know one can understand it from its behaviour but in a fantasy or imaginary world what if Winter could speak and express its emotions in the same way. 🙂
Also, I loved the illustrations by Sumouli Dutta.
My kid was very excited after receiving the book. Although she can’t read it but the illustrations excited her to know about the story.
I would recommend this book especially to those who are fond of pets and illustrations.
I have enjoyed reading it….was always in the excitement to know what happens next while reading. I loved the way Shantanu has bonded with Winter. It’s more than just the bond between a pet and his owner….its like a father and son relationship. The description about his bonding with Winter is so well written that I could imagine all of it as if I was present there. Him describing tiny details about Winter made me think, what if Winter could also describe how it felt about Shantanu in the same way. I know one can understand it from its behaviour but in a fantasy or imaginary world what if Winter could speak and express its emotions in the same way. 🙂
Also, I loved the illustrations by Sumouli Dutta.
My kid was very excited after receiving the book. Although she can’t read it but the illustrations excited her to know about the story.
I would recommend this book especially to those who are fond of pets and illustrations.
December 28, 2025
I truly loved the book. I especially appreciated how beautifully Shantanu had portrayed Winter’s unconditional love, while also contrasting it with human love—which is often conditional and shaped by our mistakes. What stood out to me was how he reflected on those mistakes, learned from them, and made things right for Winter.
Winter feels like an old soul, and this story is a powerful reminder of what unconditional love truly looks like—how we sometimes take it for granted, knowingly or unknowingly. At the same time, it shows us that it’s never too late to fix things and make the most of the second chances we’re given. After reading this, you can’t help but want to meet Winter. I was lucky enough to meet him once at the book launch, and I already want to meet him again. ❤️
Thank you, Shantanu, for sharing your journey with Winter. It’s inspired me to try convincing my family to get a puppy—though right now, that feels like mission impossible 😅
Winter feels like an old soul, and this story is a powerful reminder of what unconditional love truly looks like—how we sometimes take it for granted, knowingly or unknowingly. At the same time, it shows us that it’s never too late to fix things and make the most of the second chances we’re given. After reading this, you can’t help but want to meet Winter. I was lucky enough to meet him once at the book launch, and I already want to meet him again. ❤️
Thank you, Shantanu, for sharing your journey with Winter. It’s inspired me to try convincing my family to get a puppy—though right now, that feels like mission impossible 😅
December 28, 2025
Dear Shantanu,
I can't begin to tell you about how your book found me at the perfect time. My dad is in the hospital and reading about Winter during his treatment made me feel as though you were talking about my situation. Being is the hospital can be really isolating, but somehow reading about your experience comforted me. In the chapter, when he finally pees, I gasped and was almost in tears.
Thank you for sharing your stories with the world. I've heard you speak about Winter with a lot of love, but I only now understand what you really meant, how it impacted you and shaped you.
I'll keep Winter in my prayers, especially his tail. The world needs those tail wags.
Always cheering for you and looking forward to your heartwarming stories.
I can't begin to tell you about how your book found me at the perfect time. My dad is in the hospital and reading about Winter during his treatment made me feel as though you were talking about my situation. Being is the hospital can be really isolating, but somehow reading about your experience comforted me. In the chapter, when he finally pees, I gasped and was almost in tears.
Thank you for sharing your stories with the world. I've heard you speak about Winter with a lot of love, but I only now understand what you really meant, how it impacted you and shaped you.
I'll keep Winter in my prayers, especially his tail. The world needs those tail wags.
Always cheering for you and looking forward to your heartwarming stories.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 27, 2025
I just finished reading Thinking of Winter, and it’s truly beautiful.
While reading it, I kept thinking about Winter and also about my dog, Jacky.
The book made me feel so many emotions, especially the thought that I missed a lot of time and memories with Jacky and wasn’t always there when he needed me the most. I cried through most of it. It really showed me what true love looks like.
Thank you for this book. “Thank you” honestly doesn’t feel enough.
And I don’t even know what good I did to be able to meet Winter.
While reading it, I kept thinking about Winter and also about my dog, Jacky.
The book made me feel so many emotions, especially the thought that I missed a lot of time and memories with Jacky and wasn’t always there when he needed me the most. I cried through most of it. It really showed me what true love looks like.
Thank you for this book. “Thank you” honestly doesn’t feel enough.
And I don’t even know what good I did to be able to meet Winter.
December 28, 2025
A book written straight from the heart and a must read for everyone who has ever loved an animal. The truest emotions of every pet parent are captured in the most beautiful way possible. And Winter literally shines through every story and every page - sure to steal your heart by the end of the book. Winter's perspective and sheer innocence towards the world makes the book feel like a warm embrace! An absolute MUST READ!!! A book you won't keep down until done!
December 25, 2025
A book so good it made me want to make a Goodreads account just to write a review. I finished this book in a couple of hours because it made me feel so invested. It's a slice of life book peppered with bits of advice on how we can be happier and more compassionate and learn from all those around us (not just humans!).
The book made me smile, made me cry, made me feel a roller coaster of emotions and more than anything made me want to give Winter a hug. It's the perfect cosy comforting book to lose yourself in and end up feeling overwhelmed in the best possible way.
The book made me smile, made me cry, made me feel a roller coaster of emotions and more than anything made me want to give Winter a hug. It's the perfect cosy comforting book to lose yourself in and end up feeling overwhelmed in the best possible way.
December 24, 2025
The most cutest and wholesome read of 2025, showcasing the raw love between a pet parent and their little child 💗🥹
This has rode me through endless emotions, from smiling wide to giggling to even sobbing at times !
Not for the tiniest moment I felt like putting it down and finished it in less than 12 hours !
And the best part were the illustrations😭
The fact that I hate annotating books, but I couldn't stop for this one (though with a pencil but I did)
A read worth of your time, money and thoughts 🤍
Pre-ordering it was the best decision 🤌🏻
This has rode me through endless emotions, from smiling wide to giggling to even sobbing at times !
Not for the tiniest moment I felt like putting it down and finished it in less than 12 hours !
And the best part were the illustrations😭
The fact that I hate annotating books, but I couldn't stop for this one (though with a pencil but I did)
A read worth of your time, money and thoughts 🤍
Pre-ordering it was the best decision 🤌🏻
December 28, 2025
I finished Thinking of Winter yesterday while travelling from Mumbai to Nashik, and I felt compelled to write this review because the book touched me deeply.
From the very first pages, the narration made me feel like I wasn’t just reading, but living every moment alongside the author and Winter. Each scene unfolds so vividly, as if it is happening right in front of your eyes. I was especially drawn to the chapter titles, and how their meaning slowly reveals itself as you read.
The illustrations add a gentle warmth to the story. Seeing Winter in them brought a small smile to my face, as if I was sharing those moments of happiness.
The chapter on Yobo connected with me instantly. I once rescued a two to three day old puppy, and reading about the effort and care that went into saving Yobo felt like I was reliving those days again. My mum named our puppy Tuntun because she used to walk around saying “tun tun chalte” in Marathi. The simplicity of that reminded me of how Brownie was named in the book.
The Picasso chapter broke my heart. I cried while reading it because my dog Tuntun went through the same pain. The sleepless nights, constant worry, and helplessness of not being able to save them brought back memories I still carry.
Brownie reminded me of my first pet, an indie ginger cat named Shiro, who is an angel now. Sir Charles reminded me of my second pet, a black indie cat we adopted and named Mau. And in Forgotten Sun, I saw my current Mau reflected in every emotion, that quiet, steady companionship.
My favorite line from the last chapter, Every Second Counts, was “Winter is the reminder that life isn’t meant to be reinvented every morning.” That stayed with me as such a gentle truth.
This book felt incredibly personal to me, as if the author was telling my own story. I am sure many pet parents will find pieces of their lives in these pages. Thinking of Winter is a beautiful book about love, loss, and the simple moments that shape us. It will stay with me for a long time.
~ Janhavi Vaidya
From the very first pages, the narration made me feel like I wasn’t just reading, but living every moment alongside the author and Winter. Each scene unfolds so vividly, as if it is happening right in front of your eyes. I was especially drawn to the chapter titles, and how their meaning slowly reveals itself as you read.
The illustrations add a gentle warmth to the story. Seeing Winter in them brought a small smile to my face, as if I was sharing those moments of happiness.
The chapter on Yobo connected with me instantly. I once rescued a two to three day old puppy, and reading about the effort and care that went into saving Yobo felt like I was reliving those days again. My mum named our puppy Tuntun because she used to walk around saying “tun tun chalte” in Marathi. The simplicity of that reminded me of how Brownie was named in the book.
The Picasso chapter broke my heart. I cried while reading it because my dog Tuntun went through the same pain. The sleepless nights, constant worry, and helplessness of not being able to save them brought back memories I still carry.
Brownie reminded me of my first pet, an indie ginger cat named Shiro, who is an angel now. Sir Charles reminded me of my second pet, a black indie cat we adopted and named Mau. And in Forgotten Sun, I saw my current Mau reflected in every emotion, that quiet, steady companionship.
My favorite line from the last chapter, Every Second Counts, was “Winter is the reminder that life isn’t meant to be reinvented every morning.” That stayed with me as such a gentle truth.
This book felt incredibly personal to me, as if the author was telling my own story. I am sure many pet parents will find pieces of their lives in these pages. Thinking of Winter is a beautiful book about love, loss, and the simple moments that shape us. It will stay with me for a long time.
~ Janhavi Vaidya
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 26, 2025
Finished reading #ThinkingOfWinter, and the best way I can describe this book is: a warm hug on cold winter days.🐶
Right in the 1st chapter, when Shantanu says “there are no bad dogs”, it instantly took me back to my own dog. We had him for 14 years. From being the mischievous puppy of the house, he grew into a wise old guardian. It’s been 3 years since he passed away, and there’s still a quiet hole in my heart as I write this.
One story stays with me. One day, he stopped eating because a stray puppy had appeared on our street. He refused food until we fed her first. This became a daily ritual. Eventually, he demanded that we take her in — and just like that, Moti got a puppy adopted.
We cared for her, but something was wrong. I think Moti always knew. After scans, we found she had a brain tumor — something that couldn’t be treated. She lived with us for a year, and when she passed away, Moti didn’t eat for a week. 🦮
After that, our home slowly became a safe spot — for stray dogs and cats, sparrows, and birds. Even our cat, who grew up around Moti, carries that kindness forward. She sneaks in stray kittens while we’re asleep, shares her food, and sometimes meows until we help a kitten in trouble. And if I catch her doing this while I’m working late, she’ll bring me a treat (a half-killed mouse) the very next day — her way of saying thanks for not “rat”-ting her out.😹
Winter, in this book, represents all of this — quiet kindness, unconditional love, and the purity animals bring into our lives. It reminds us that warmth doesn’t always come from the sun; sometimes it comes from compassion, presence, and care.
Thinking of Winter is a comforter full of love, and honestly, the world needs more reminders like this.
Very well written and could not ask for a better Christmas celebration.
#thinkingofwinter #doglove #unconditionallove❤️
Right in the 1st chapter, when Shantanu says “there are no bad dogs”, it instantly took me back to my own dog. We had him for 14 years. From being the mischievous puppy of the house, he grew into a wise old guardian. It’s been 3 years since he passed away, and there’s still a quiet hole in my heart as I write this.
One story stays with me. One day, he stopped eating because a stray puppy had appeared on our street. He refused food until we fed her first. This became a daily ritual. Eventually, he demanded that we take her in — and just like that, Moti got a puppy adopted.
We cared for her, but something was wrong. I think Moti always knew. After scans, we found she had a brain tumor — something that couldn’t be treated. She lived with us for a year, and when she passed away, Moti didn’t eat for a week. 🦮
After that, our home slowly became a safe spot — for stray dogs and cats, sparrows, and birds. Even our cat, who grew up around Moti, carries that kindness forward. She sneaks in stray kittens while we’re asleep, shares her food, and sometimes meows until we help a kitten in trouble. And if I catch her doing this while I’m working late, she’ll bring me a treat (a half-killed mouse) the very next day — her way of saying thanks for not “rat”-ting her out.😹
Winter, in this book, represents all of this — quiet kindness, unconditional love, and the purity animals bring into our lives. It reminds us that warmth doesn’t always come from the sun; sometimes it comes from compassion, presence, and care.
Thinking of Winter is a comforter full of love, and honestly, the world needs more reminders like this.
Very well written and could not ask for a better Christmas celebration.
#thinkingofwinter #doglove #unconditionallove❤️
December 28, 2025
It was a comforting experience with Thinking of Winter and then *Learning from Winter*.
This book or rather a memoir of Winter through your pen is a warm read with free style writing (how it seems in the beginning) and simplicity of connection with the characters and plot. The cute, colorful Doodles eases mind's hardwork to imagine the story while letting the reader flow through it. While on second chapter of this book it made me realize from where the lines in one of your insta reels might be inspired from "Helped people, can help people"....feels like lines inspired by Winter. My other key take aways from this book were slow living/living in the moment, not giving up just after one failure (ref. Gorges bleeding deer) and many such more which are about to be on my 2026 vision board. I appreciate how you have delivered the exact same thing which you promised to the readers through cover/title of the book, it was purely just Winter through each and every page, may it be as the main character or supporting one in Sir Charles' story. As much as I loved the entire book *Peecasso* is my favorite chapter, cause the way Winter and you survived that phase. Personally it reminded me of my lost companion Sweety, she was my very first non-human companion on this planet during toddler-hood....if that's even a word.
The entire journey through Thinking of Winter was special and comforting for me and I pray for him to be blessed with happy, healthy moments in future and ofcourse more lush green spaces around, wherever you guys move to. I don't really repeat once read books but this I will. It'll be my comfort read. Thank you for letting us readers know, yours and Winter's journey. May you both be blessed with more and joyous time together🤞. Lots of love to Winter ❤️
This book or rather a memoir of Winter through your pen is a warm read with free style writing (how it seems in the beginning) and simplicity of connection with the characters and plot. The cute, colorful Doodles eases mind's hardwork to imagine the story while letting the reader flow through it. While on second chapter of this book it made me realize from where the lines in one of your insta reels might be inspired from "Helped people, can help people"....feels like lines inspired by Winter. My other key take aways from this book were slow living/living in the moment, not giving up just after one failure (ref. Gorges bleeding deer) and many such more which are about to be on my 2026 vision board. I appreciate how you have delivered the exact same thing which you promised to the readers through cover/title of the book, it was purely just Winter through each and every page, may it be as the main character or supporting one in Sir Charles' story. As much as I loved the entire book *Peecasso* is my favorite chapter, cause the way Winter and you survived that phase. Personally it reminded me of my lost companion Sweety, she was my very first non-human companion on this planet during toddler-hood....if that's even a word.
The entire journey through Thinking of Winter was special and comforting for me and I pray for him to be blessed with happy, healthy moments in future and ofcourse more lush green spaces around, wherever you guys move to. I don't really repeat once read books but this I will. It'll be my comfort read. Thank you for letting us readers know, yours and Winter's journey. May you both be blessed with more and joyous time together🤞. Lots of love to Winter ❤️
December 30, 2025
Hello to my favourite @Shantanu Naidu,
I just finished reading Thinking of Winter, and I honestly don’t know how to thank you enough for writing this book. It didn’t feel like I was reading a story—it felt like I was reliving a part of my own life.
As a pet mom, every page hit close to my heart. When you spoke about Winter’s journey—from a tiny puppy to a strong companion—and then the moment of his diagnosis, the fear, the helplessness, the waiting, the quiet prayers… it broke me. My dog Jack went through the same phase. He couldn’t walk, couldn’t stand, couldn’t even do the most basic things, and I remember feeling exactly what you described—watching someone you love suffer and feeling so powerless.
There were moments while reading when I had tears in my eyes because your words were the same emotions I once felt but never knew how to put into words. The way you wrote about loving someone knowing you can’t have them forever, and questioning why the universe gives us souls we must someday let go of—that line stayed with me. It’s painful, yet so beautifully true.
Thank you for writing with such honesty and vulnerability. Thinking of Winter made me feel seen, understood, and less alone. It reminded me that the love we share with our pets, no matter how short their lives are, is pure, unconditional, and eternal. This book will always have a special place in my heart.
With gratitude and love,
A fellow pet parent 🤍
—Janhavi
I just finished reading Thinking of Winter, and I honestly don’t know how to thank you enough for writing this book. It didn’t feel like I was reading a story—it felt like I was reliving a part of my own life.
As a pet mom, every page hit close to my heart. When you spoke about Winter’s journey—from a tiny puppy to a strong companion—and then the moment of his diagnosis, the fear, the helplessness, the waiting, the quiet prayers… it broke me. My dog Jack went through the same phase. He couldn’t walk, couldn’t stand, couldn’t even do the most basic things, and I remember feeling exactly what you described—watching someone you love suffer and feeling so powerless.
There were moments while reading when I had tears in my eyes because your words were the same emotions I once felt but never knew how to put into words. The way you wrote about loving someone knowing you can’t have them forever, and questioning why the universe gives us souls we must someday let go of—that line stayed with me. It’s painful, yet so beautifully true.
Thank you for writing with such honesty and vulnerability. Thinking of Winter made me feel seen, understood, and less alone. It reminded me that the love we share with our pets, no matter how short their lives are, is pure, unconditional, and eternal. This book will always have a special place in my heart.
With gratitude and love,
A fellow pet parent 🤍
—Janhavi
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 15, 2026
4.5/5
I don’t even know where to begin. This is one of the most wholesome books I have ever read. It made me laugh, cry, and giggle over a golden ball of fur I’ve never met in my life—and yet, I didn’t know a book could make me feel this much.
Oh, Winter. I’ve never had the privilege of meeting you, but it feels like I’ve known you forever. My heart felt impossibly full after reading about you for just 130 pages, and I can only imagine how unbearably lovesick I’d feel if I ever met you in real life. There is so much to learn from you—your strength, your fight, your affection and kindness towards every living soul you’ve encountered, and your completely selfless love for Shantanu. And even though you don’t know I exist, if I ever get the chance to meet you, I will absolutely greet you with a “whoozagoodboy”, expecting the only correct reply: “heezagoodboy.”
Shantanu, credit where it’s due. Making readers feel this deeply is no easy task, and you delivered—beautifully. That said, I’m going to steal some of that credit and give it to Winter, because it’s his love and warmth that allowed these emotions to pour out so naturally and honestly. This is, without a doubt, one of the most beautifully written books I’ve read.
To anyone even thinking about picking this up—please do. Winter teaches you more about life and love than most humans ever could.
May Winter’s collection of oversized sticks only grow bigger for many, many years to come.
Loads of love to the best boy. 🐾❤️🧿
I don’t even know where to begin. This is one of the most wholesome books I have ever read. It made me laugh, cry, and giggle over a golden ball of fur I’ve never met in my life—and yet, I didn’t know a book could make me feel this much.
Oh, Winter. I’ve never had the privilege of meeting you, but it feels like I’ve known you forever. My heart felt impossibly full after reading about you for just 130 pages, and I can only imagine how unbearably lovesick I’d feel if I ever met you in real life. There is so much to learn from you—your strength, your fight, your affection and kindness towards every living soul you’ve encountered, and your completely selfless love for Shantanu. And even though you don’t know I exist, if I ever get the chance to meet you, I will absolutely greet you with a “whoozagoodboy”, expecting the only correct reply: “heezagoodboy.”
Shantanu, credit where it’s due. Making readers feel this deeply is no easy task, and you delivered—beautifully. That said, I’m going to steal some of that credit and give it to Winter, because it’s his love and warmth that allowed these emotions to pour out so naturally and honestly. This is, without a doubt, one of the most beautifully written books I’ve read.
To anyone even thinking about picking this up—please do. Winter teaches you more about life and love than most humans ever could.
May Winter’s collection of oversized sticks only grow bigger for many, many years to come.
Loads of love to the best boy. 🐾❤️🧿
December 29, 2025
Life lessons from Winter, a son with four paws 🐾 ❤️🧿
I finished this book last night, and it touched my heart in the most beautiful way. I felt emotional at several points, and I already know this is a book I’ll return to again.
I’m not a big reader and am still discovering what kind of books I enjoy, but this one gave me complete clarity — whatever genre this book belongs to, I love it. I’ve never felt such a strong emotional connection or reading comfort before.
The stories in this book are written with immense sensitivity, warmth, and honesty. Each one leaves an impression and stays with you long after you turn the page. What stood out the most to me was the kindness, empathy, and understanding woven throughout the narrative — qualities that made the reading experience deeply human and heartfelt.
The book has a quiet way of making you feel present in its moments, allowing you to connect deeply without being overwhelming. It speaks about love, companionship, loss, and loyalty in the simplest yet most powerful way.
A special mention to the illustrations, which add so much charm and emotion and beautifully complement the writing.
Thank you, Shantanu, for sharing these memories and lessons with readers. This was a truly touching and meaningful read, and one I’ll always carry with me.
I finished this book last night, and it touched my heart in the most beautiful way. I felt emotional at several points, and I already know this is a book I’ll return to again.
I’m not a big reader and am still discovering what kind of books I enjoy, but this one gave me complete clarity — whatever genre this book belongs to, I love it. I’ve never felt such a strong emotional connection or reading comfort before.
The stories in this book are written with immense sensitivity, warmth, and honesty. Each one leaves an impression and stays with you long after you turn the page. What stood out the most to me was the kindness, empathy, and understanding woven throughout the narrative — qualities that made the reading experience deeply human and heartfelt.
The book has a quiet way of making you feel present in its moments, allowing you to connect deeply without being overwhelming. It speaks about love, companionship, loss, and loyalty in the simplest yet most powerful way.
A special mention to the illustrations, which add so much charm and emotion and beautifully complement the writing.
Thank you, Shantanu, for sharing these memories and lessons with readers. This was a truly touching and meaningful read, and one I’ll always carry with me.
January 7, 2026
I have just finished the reading🌈 its a book in which you have shared all you memories there are the story where my heart get full my eyes get wet🥹 and I don't have much to say this the best book i have read in 2026 and till will be very close to my heart always❤️ while finishing the reading the thoughts going in my mind now also is that there are the more memories left to know it's not ending
Jitna tarif karungi utna kam hai 😂
You not just only tell that mumbai bookies are family to you on special day of Christmas launching this book with us while reading am feeling like you are sitting in front of us and telling everything this is a family bonding have 🤝
Thank you for having this all lovely story of winter and you with us❤️🥹😍🥰
I wanna tell everyone that something is that when we write something from our heart we never see the line and time while reading this book i get to know that
Har insaan ke life mein taklif hoti hai and jahan aap ho wahan pochne ke liye aapne life mein bhot se ups and downs dekhe hai
Am very happy for the author that wherever he is in life today it's because of its hardwork his kindness his love and respect towards the people is from heart
❤️🤗
Jitna tarif karungi utna kam hai 😂
You not just only tell that mumbai bookies are family to you on special day of Christmas launching this book with us while reading am feeling like you are sitting in front of us and telling everything this is a family bonding have 🤝
Thank you for having this all lovely story of winter and you with us❤️🥹😍🥰
I wanna tell everyone that something is that when we write something from our heart we never see the line and time while reading this book i get to know that
Har insaan ke life mein taklif hoti hai and jahan aap ho wahan pochne ke liye aapne life mein bhot se ups and downs dekhe hai
Am very happy for the author that wherever he is in life today it's because of its hardwork his kindness his love and respect towards the people is from heart
❤️🤗
January 14, 2026
I absolutely loved this book! Shantanu has written this book straight from his heart! He understands the soul of his dog and this is very apparent when he touches on their non verbal communication. Both of them have such a strong bond of love and understanding, as it is with many people who have loved a dog. I cried a lot while reading some of these descriptions.
When u look into the eyes of a dog you see so much wisdom there, so much love and understanding.
To love a dog is to have a large part of your heart , home and life taken over by them- and I for one would not have it any other way. Shantanu in this book describes his own moments of understanding his dog and touchingly promising him everything he can do for him .
And this is how it is . Our dogs live for the moments they can spend with us and we in turn should love and care for them without reserve .
Shantanu you are a wonderful soul! I thank you for reminding me of the love of our pets - as we so often take them for granted.
Having a dog in your life is worth every chewed slipper, every stolen titbit off the dining table , every outburst of loud indignant barking and every sloppy kiss on your face when u are trying to sleep !
God bless you both- Winter and Shantanu !
When u look into the eyes of a dog you see so much wisdom there, so much love and understanding.
To love a dog is to have a large part of your heart , home and life taken over by them- and I for one would not have it any other way. Shantanu in this book describes his own moments of understanding his dog and touchingly promising him everything he can do for him .
And this is how it is . Our dogs live for the moments they can spend with us and we in turn should love and care for them without reserve .
Shantanu you are a wonderful soul! I thank you for reminding me of the love of our pets - as we so often take them for granted.
Having a dog in your life is worth every chewed slipper, every stolen titbit off the dining table , every outburst of loud indignant barking and every sloppy kiss on your face when u are trying to sleep !
God bless you both- Winter and Shantanu !
January 5, 2026
First book of the year!
Started last year with I came upon a lighthouse, reading it in between work, at every break I got. People thought I was crazy, but it was me and the book against the corporate giants. This year, Christmas came early when, Shantanu released his new book for pre-orders. I quickly pre-ordered it, patiently waited for the annual break, and read the entire book in one sitting.
Trust him to write a book to send you on an emotional rollercoaster.
I’ve never really been much of a pet person — I never quite understood how people manage to be responsible for another living being. But flipping through these pages made me realise it’s kind of like having a younger sibling… except here, you get to choose them.
And Winter especially — oh my god. I absolutely love him for the way he looks after everyone: kittens, birds, humans. That quiet kindness stays with you long after you finish the book.
The writing is effortless, extremely readable, and such a page-turner that honestly, anyone would want to read it.
Started last year with I came upon a lighthouse, reading it in between work, at every break I got. People thought I was crazy, but it was me and the book against the corporate giants. This year, Christmas came early when, Shantanu released his new book for pre-orders. I quickly pre-ordered it, patiently waited for the annual break, and read the entire book in one sitting.
Trust him to write a book to send you on an emotional rollercoaster.
I’ve never really been much of a pet person — I never quite understood how people manage to be responsible for another living being. But flipping through these pages made me realise it’s kind of like having a younger sibling… except here, you get to choose them.
And Winter especially — oh my god. I absolutely love him for the way he looks after everyone: kittens, birds, humans. That quiet kindness stays with you long after you finish the book.
The writing is effortless, extremely readable, and such a page-turner that honestly, anyone would want to read it.
December 28, 2025
Letter to the Author
Dearest
@Shantanu Naidu
In your words...I'll stay somewhere in the middle.
Even though the book came to an end your journey with Winter has left an imprint on my heart as a reader and on my soul as a human.
Winter definitely left me with some profound lessons of being present and what hope, love, resilience look and feel like in the face of love that he found in you.
The last chapter- Every second counts made me deeply reflect on things we take for granted not out of negligence but lack of understanding and life has its own way of giving us a second chance, I am so happy for you to have found that in Winter.
You too are a goodest boy just like Winter to have shared your story with such authencity and affection, giving us readers a beautiful closure to the year gone by.
Once again- In your words I agree this not to be an ending where people stop writing.
😇🐕🎁
Dearest
@Shantanu Naidu
In your words...I'll stay somewhere in the middle.
Even though the book came to an end your journey with Winter has left an imprint on my heart as a reader and on my soul as a human.
Winter definitely left me with some profound lessons of being present and what hope, love, resilience look and feel like in the face of love that he found in you.
The last chapter- Every second counts made me deeply reflect on things we take for granted not out of negligence but lack of understanding and life has its own way of giving us a second chance, I am so happy for you to have found that in Winter.
You too are a goodest boy just like Winter to have shared your story with such authencity and affection, giving us readers a beautiful closure to the year gone by.
Once again- In your words I agree this not to be an ending where people stop writing.
😇🐕🎁
December 29, 2025
Santanu Naidu moves abroad for studies, and thats when he finds Winter that ends up being his main support. In a new place where nothing feels stable, the dog brings some routine and comfort, like a real sense of home. The way he describes their daily stuff, walks or just hanging out, makes it seem so real. I think thats what pulls you in, those small moments.
Then when he goes back home, the dog gets sick, and it hits on all those fears that come with having a pet. The worry about losing them, feeling helpless during illness, and how dogs just get you without needing words back. Naidu doesnt overdo it, he keeps it honest, lets the feelings come out on their own. That part gets a bit heavy, but in a way that makes sense for anyone whos had a dog.
What stands out is how the book shows the dogs side, their natural sweetness and how they love without holding back. Through that, Naidus own kindness grows, and it touches on caring for animals in general.
January 9, 2026
This book felt incredibly close to my heart. Years ago, during my JEE prep, shantanu's first novel was my go-to stress buster. Five years later, on a random low day in a completely different phase of life, this novel once again came to my rescue. From the first few pages, it felt like I was part of the journey.
The story made me revisit memories of the dogs and cats I’ve grown up with, but this time from their POV, which was surprisingly emotional. It even reminded me of my first dog, Brownie, and the beautiful but short time we had together. By the end, it left me with a deeper respect for my pets and the realization that, to them, we are their whole world.
The writing is raw, emotional, and deeply connecting. Though I mostly read fiction, both of the author’s novels kept me hooked till the end. I just love Shantanu's writing. This book is more than a story—it stays with you. Highly recommend it🥹
The story made me revisit memories of the dogs and cats I’ve grown up with, but this time from their POV, which was surprisingly emotional. It even reminded me of my first dog, Brownie, and the beautiful but short time we had together. By the end, it left me with a deeper respect for my pets and the realization that, to them, we are their whole world.
The writing is raw, emotional, and deeply connecting. Though I mostly read fiction, both of the author’s novels kept me hooked till the end. I just love Shantanu's writing. This book is more than a story—it stays with you. Highly recommend it🥹
January 18, 2026
I didn’t know that a book had the ability to provide me with such warmth and comfort , but I guess that’s the power of a good book or good writing and this book had it all. There were so many moments in the book where I have found myself relating to it on another level having a dog myself and then some giggling cause how funny was winter and also a river of tears as I just can’t see an animal in pain it aches my heart and makes my stomach twist and turn with a very unsettling feeling . I would always pick this book up for my friends ‘cause they should also feel the yearning of wanting a dog hehe but all n all I think everyone should read this book once in their life if they want to experience the joy of loving a dog choosing a dog and the dog choosing you back …….. and no I won’t rate the book because how could anyone?
December 29, 2025
Thinking of Winter was such a good read. It’s such a sweet book it made me feel happy, sad, dumb, and confident all at once.😭
At first, I felt like I was in that stage (mentally) where I needed one winter for myself. By halfway through, I was confident enough that I could adopt a pet until the Peecasso chapter came.
I was travelling to my hometown while reading that chapter and I was crying. People were staring at me, then at the book, and then at me again. A few even searched for the book and I really hope some of them read it.😭
It also felt like I was reading your daily diary.
THANK YOU
For the stories and for the lessons.
I really want to meet Winter again and look at him with those eyes you know what to do (rescue me).
At first, I felt like I was in that stage (mentally) where I needed one winter for myself. By halfway through, I was confident enough that I could adopt a pet until the Peecasso chapter came.
I was travelling to my hometown while reading that chapter and I was crying. People were staring at me, then at the book, and then at me again. A few even searched for the book and I really hope some of them read it.😭
It also felt like I was reading your daily diary.
THANK YOU
For the stories and for the lessons.
I really want to meet Winter again and look at him with those eyes you know what to do (rescue me).
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 77 reviews