What do you think?
Rate this book
PAHL #3
Jingle Bats
Come spend the holidays with Aries, Vin, Nix, Evan, and Gem.
Between starting their careers playing professionally in the PAHL, finding new love, and making friends it’s already been a crazy season. Taking a few days to celebrate Christmas turns into a holiday to remember. Aries explores his little side with his brothers while Vin supports his every need. Nix finally gets to see Evan’s dragon. And who is Gem’s mysterious texter? It might only be a few short days between games, but the triplets will make the most of it.
The warmest holiday wishes for you from the characters of the Paranormal American Hockey League.
This holiday special follows the vents of PAHL Book 2. It is recommended to first read Aries & Nix before enjoying this story.
Between starting their careers playing professionally in the PAHL, finding new love, and making friends it’s already been a crazy season. Taking a few days to celebrate Christmas turns into a holiday to remember. Aries explores his little side with his brothers while Vin supports his every need. Nix finally gets to see Evan’s dragon. And who is Gem’s mysterious texter? It might only be a few short days between games, but the triplets will make the most of it.
The warmest holiday wishes for you from the characters of the Paranormal American Hockey League.
This holiday special follows the vents of PAHL Book 2. It is recommended to first read Aries & Nix before enjoying this story.
186 pages, Kindle Edition
Published December 23, 2025
34 people are currently reading
14 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 20 of 20 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
ARC Review
I adored getting to see all the triplets and their dynamics. I'm so excited to find out more about Gem and "Ty". The inside look into how the brother’s react to one another, seeing more in depth details about Evan's dragon, and how much everyone loves each other is so precious. I can't wait to see what's next!
I adored getting to see all the triplets and their dynamics. I'm so excited to find out more about Gem and "Ty". The inside look into how the brother’s react to one another, seeing more in depth details about Evan's dragon, and how much everyone loves each other is so precious. I can't wait to see what's next!
January 24, 2026
MM Romance | Paranormal: Shifters | Found Family | Size Difference | GrumpySunshine | Daddy Dom | BDSM | Ageplay | Bondage
Me llevé una grata sorpresa con esta historia! Al principio pensé que sería un historia corto donde los trillizos solo aparecerían en un par de escenas, pero me equivoqué. En realidad, pudimos verlos en todas sus facetas: la relación entre ellos, con sus parejas, con sus padres e incluso explorando sus cambios de forma.
La relación de Aries y Vin me encantó; son tan lindos que disfruté cada una de sus escenas. Por otro lado, Nix y Evan también me gustaron mucho. Debo admitir que ahora entiendo mejor lo que implica que Evan sea un shifter de dragón y cómo su bestia es una identidad "aparte" de él mismo. Sus momentos fueron súper divertidos, me reí muchísimo.
Y finalmente tenemos a Gem. Tengo que confesar que es el trillizo que más me intriga; me siento muy identificada con él y eso hace que su historia me llame aún más la atención. Tengo varias teorías sobre quién será su famoso sumiso... 👀 Muero de ganas por leer su libro!
〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️
I was so pleasantly surprised by this story! I started reading thinking it would be a short story where the triplets would only pop up in a couple of scenes, but I was so wrong. We actually get to see them in all their different facets—their bond with each other, their dynamics with their partners and parents, and even their shifting.
Aries and Vin’s relationship is so sweet; I truly enjoyed reading about them. Nix and Evan were great too! I have to admit, I finally understand the whole "dragon shifter" aspect better now, and how the dragon is almost a separate identity from Evan himself. Their scenes were so funny, I loved them! lol.
And then there’s Gem. I have to admit, he’s the triplet that intrigues me the most! I relate to him so much, which makes his character even more fascinating to me. I have a few guesses about who his famous submissive might be... 👀 I am dying to read his story!
Me llevé una grata sorpresa con esta historia! Al principio pensé que sería un historia corto donde los trillizos solo aparecerían en un par de escenas, pero me equivoqué. En realidad, pudimos verlos en todas sus facetas: la relación entre ellos, con sus parejas, con sus padres e incluso explorando sus cambios de forma.
La relación de Aries y Vin me encantó; son tan lindos que disfruté cada una de sus escenas. Por otro lado, Nix y Evan también me gustaron mucho. Debo admitir que ahora entiendo mejor lo que implica que Evan sea un shifter de dragón y cómo su bestia es una identidad "aparte" de él mismo. Sus momentos fueron súper divertidos, me reí muchísimo.
Y finalmente tenemos a Gem. Tengo que confesar que es el trillizo que más me intriga; me siento muy identificada con él y eso hace que su historia me llame aún más la atención. Tengo varias teorías sobre quién será su famoso sumiso... 👀 Muero de ganas por leer su libro!
〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️〰️
I was so pleasantly surprised by this story! I started reading thinking it would be a short story where the triplets would only pop up in a couple of scenes, but I was so wrong. We actually get to see them in all their different facets—their bond with each other, their dynamics with their partners and parents, and even their shifting.
Aries and Vin’s relationship is so sweet; I truly enjoyed reading about them. Nix and Evan were great too! I have to admit, I finally understand the whole "dragon shifter" aspect better now, and how the dragon is almost a separate identity from Evan himself. Their scenes were so funny, I loved them! lol.
And then there’s Gem. I have to admit, he’s the triplet that intrigues me the most! I relate to him so much, which makes his character even more fascinating to me. I have a few guesses about who his famous submissive might be... 👀 I am dying to read his story!
December 29, 2025
The PAHL triplets — Aries, Nix, and Gem — take a short break from their whirlwind first season of professional paranormal hockey to celebrate Christmas with their partners and friends. Amid the festivities, Aries gets the chance to fully embrace his little side with the support of Vin, Nix finally experiences Evan’s dragon form, and Gem finds himself intrigued by a mysterious new texter. It’s only a few days between games, but the brothers make the most of the holiday magic, deepening relationships, strengthening bonds, and sharing a cosy, chaotic, love‑filled Christmas together.
I loved this novella with the triplets and their partners. Their party piece was just adorable! I loved that this was a warm, joyful pause between games, giving Aries, Nix, Gem, and their partners a chance to breathe, reconnect, and celebrate the season together. What makes it shine is how it blends festive fun with the deeper emotional threads that run through the series. Aries gets space to explore his little side in a way that feels safe, supported, and genuinely tender, with Vin offering the kind of steady, grounding care that lets him relax into himself. Nix and Evan bring their own brand of magic — quite literally — as Nix finally gets to see Evan’s dragon form, a moment that beautifully reinforces trust and intimacy. And then there’s Gem, whose mysterious texter adds a spark of anticipation and the promise of new beginnings. Underneath the holiday lights and sibling chaos, the story celebrates found family, acceptance, and the comfort of being fully seen by the people who matter. It’s a sweet, heartwarming interlude that deepens the bonds between characters while delivering all the charm, humor, and paranormal hockey energy fans love. A delightful seasonal treat for anyone invested in the PAHL world. This was an MM story with mature content and BDSM-like dynamics.
** Please note - this festive novella is a companion to Nix: PAHL Book 2 and is best enjoyed after reading Aries and Nix.
I loved this novella with the triplets and their partners. Their party piece was just adorable! I loved that this was a warm, joyful pause between games, giving Aries, Nix, Gem, and their partners a chance to breathe, reconnect, and celebrate the season together. What makes it shine is how it blends festive fun with the deeper emotional threads that run through the series. Aries gets space to explore his little side in a way that feels safe, supported, and genuinely tender, with Vin offering the kind of steady, grounding care that lets him relax into himself. Nix and Evan bring their own brand of magic — quite literally — as Nix finally gets to see Evan’s dragon form, a moment that beautifully reinforces trust and intimacy. And then there’s Gem, whose mysterious texter adds a spark of anticipation and the promise of new beginnings. Underneath the holiday lights and sibling chaos, the story celebrates found family, acceptance, and the comfort of being fully seen by the people who matter. It’s a sweet, heartwarming interlude that deepens the bonds between characters while delivering all the charm, humor, and paranormal hockey energy fans love. A delightful seasonal treat for anyone invested in the PAHL world. This was an MM story with mature content and BDSM-like dynamics.
** Please note - this festive novella is a companion to Nix: PAHL Book 2 and is best enjoyed after reading Aries and Nix.
January 1, 2026
“Jingle Bats” is exactly the kind of book you open “just for a moment” — and suddenly realize you’re at the end, smiling, and thinking about what — and who — fills your life with happiness and love.
The characters are charming, vividly written, and have just enough flaws for us to love them — while still letting us laugh at them now and then.
What I enjoyed most was the sibling dynamic. They work as a team. When one of them stumbles or feels unsure, the other two hold him up; when needed, they can tease each other, but they also stand by one another without question. This support gives the story warmth and a sense of home that blends beautifully with the spicier moments.
If you’re looking for a romance that combines a festive mood, contrasting personalities, a healthy dose of kink positivity, and the strength of family support, “Jingle Bats” is a wonderful choice.
I’m really looking forward to the big reveal :) Gem and “Ty” :)
The characters are charming, vividly written, and have just enough flaws for us to love them — while still letting us laugh at them now and then.
What I enjoyed most was the sibling dynamic. They work as a team. When one of them stumbles or feels unsure, the other two hold him up; when needed, they can tease each other, but they also stand by one another without question. This support gives the story warmth and a sense of home that blends beautifully with the spicier moments.
If you’re looking for a romance that combines a festive mood, contrasting personalities, a healthy dose of kink positivity, and the strength of family support, “Jingle Bats” is a wonderful choice.
I’m really looking forward to the big reveal :) Gem and “Ty” :)
December 26, 2025
Fun holiday book, some inconsistencies really stuck out
Overall, if you liked the first couple books then this is a fun holiday read with the two couples that are already established.
I would like more focus on the shifters part of the stories. Other than being cute and little and liking fruit, there's really not much going on with the fruit bat shifter part, which was one of the main reasons I started the series.
Also, there were some inconsistencies that threw me off, mainly Evan and his dragon. In his book, it was said he was born human and at 10yo went up a mountain to search for his dragon, which took two years. In this book, it's said that he was born into a coven and his dragon was given to him at 4 weeks old. It's not a huge deal, but a pretty big difference in back stories that just threw me off.
Overall, if you liked the first couple books then this is a fun holiday read with the two couples that are already established.
I would like more focus on the shifters part of the stories. Other than being cute and little and liking fruit, there's really not much going on with the fruit bat shifter part, which was one of the main reasons I started the series.
Also, there were some inconsistencies that threw me off, mainly Evan and his dragon. In his book, it was said he was born human and at 10yo went up a mountain to search for his dragon, which took two years. In this book, it's said that he was born into a coven and his dragon was given to him at 4 weeks old. It's not a huge deal, but a pretty big difference in back stories that just threw me off.
December 23, 2025
Another Good Book
********** Contains Spoilers**********
I really enjoyed this book and thought that it was another good addition to the PAHL Series. I loved being able to catch up with Aries and Vin, Nix and Evan and getting to know Gem a bit more. I thoroughly enjoyed that they all got to spend time together as a family during the Christmas holidays. Vin and Evan are now part of the family, the triplets Mama wouldn’t accept anything less. I was already excited about reading Gem’s book but I’m but even more so after learning about the dynamic of his secret relationship. I’m also looking forward to reading more books by Athena in the future. I’d recommend this book, series and author to everyone.
********** Contains Spoilers**********
I really enjoyed this book and thought that it was another good addition to the PAHL Series. I loved being able to catch up with Aries and Vin, Nix and Evan and getting to know Gem a bit more. I thoroughly enjoyed that they all got to spend time together as a family during the Christmas holidays. Vin and Evan are now part of the family, the triplets Mama wouldn’t accept anything less. I was already excited about reading Gem’s book but I’m but even more so after learning about the dynamic of his secret relationship. I’m also looking forward to reading more books by Athena in the future. I’d recommend this book, series and author to everyone.
December 18, 2025
What an adorable little festive addition to the PAHL series! I thoroughly enjoyed this book and seeing the triplets together and enjoying the holidays with their family and men was so lovely! I’m very curious about Gem’s story the glimpse into his relationship so far is so interesting and I can’t wait to see where it goes! The JingleBats were so cute and perfect I was giggling at my screen when reading that part! I love these triplets so much!
Also Evan’s dragon is such a cutie! I hope we see more of him!
I was kindly given an arc copy of this wonderful book.
Also Evan’s dragon is such a cutie! I hope we see more of him!
I was kindly given an arc copy of this wonderful book.
Review of advance copy received from Author
When invited to Evan’s mountain cabin to spend Christmas together, the triplets together with their parents overcome all in their path to make it to the cabin to spend their first Christmas together.
With Nix meticulous planning, Gems secret relationship and Aries asking his Daddy a special question this a lovely holiday read that had a special performance done by the triplets.
I absolutely loved it and can’t wait for Gems story next.
With Nix meticulous planning, Gems secret relationship and Aries asking his Daddy a special question this a lovely holiday read that had a special performance done by the triplets.
I absolutely loved it and can’t wait for Gems story next.
December 24, 2025
Great Addition to Series
I enjoyed reconnecting with the MCs of the first two books. I was happy to get to know Gem better and I'm intrigued about his mysterious boy. There were definitely sweet moments threaded throughout with some added heat. I'm excited to see the author expand this world. I have so many supporting characters that I want to see get their own stories and HEA. I'm looking forward to the next book. Can't wait!
I enjoyed reconnecting with the MCs of the first two books. I was happy to get to know Gem better and I'm intrigued about his mysterious boy. There were definitely sweet moments threaded throughout with some added heat. I'm excited to see the author expand this world. I have so many supporting characters that I want to see get their own stories and HEA. I'm looking forward to the next book. Can't wait!
December 24, 2025
I love this book! Such a cute and sweet Christmas visit with Aries, Vin, Nix, Evan, and Gem. Even mom and dad visit. This book is a nice long weekend with the family and a hint at what’s coming in Gem’s book. I really love this whole book and can’t wait for more from this series. I will say you really need to read Aries and Nix’s books for this one to make sense.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Absolutely adorable. I loved being able to see even more of the triplets during Christmas. Aries is such a sweetheart while Nix is a total brat. We finally get to see Nix meet Evan’s dragon which was sweet. I’m excited to see who Gems secret sub is. Getting a little glimpse into Gem was a treat.
December 23, 2025
SOOOO GOOD
Jingle bats is so good. It was wonderful to see all three of the brothers together and finally meet Evans Dragon. A heart warming holiday story. And we get a sneak peek at Gem's true self. Vin and Aries are adorable. AND....Who could our mystery person be....
Jingle bats is so good. It was wonderful to see all three of the brothers together and finally meet Evans Dragon. A heart warming holiday story. And we get a sneak peek at Gem's true self. Vin and Aries are adorable. AND....Who could our mystery person be....
December 19, 2025
This world is so stinky adorable add the Christmas aspect and it’s the star on the tree. I can’t wait to read Gem’s book and hopefully a couple more from this world. A great little festive read.
December 24, 2025
Story 3.5⭐️ Spice 2.5🌶️
It was nice to catch up with Aries and Nix and to meet Gem. And of course it’s exciting to meet a dragon. Looking forward to the rest of the series.
It was nice to catch up with Aries and Nix and to meet Gem. And of course it’s exciting to meet a dragon. Looking forward to the rest of the series.
December 25, 2025
Recommend
Great book, loved seeing the three triplets back again. It was great catching up with Aries, Nic and their partners and I can’t wait for Gems story.
Great book, loved seeing the three triplets back again. It was great catching up with Aries, Nic and their partners and I can’t wait for Gems story.
December 25, 2025
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️
Enjoyment: ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Enjoyment: ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
December 26, 2025
such adorableness
The triplets are such little troublemakers, but adorable doing it! Always love seeing their antics and interactions with the men they love.
The triplets are such little troublemakers, but adorable doing it! Always love seeing their antics and interactions with the men they love.
December 27, 2025
love this story
Love the Christmas Bats!! Can’t wait for Gem’s story , hopefully more stories will come from the secondary characters!! Please
Love the Christmas Bats!! Can’t wait for Gem’s story , hopefully more stories will come from the secondary characters!! Please
January 6, 2026
Holiday Hijinks
Such a fun read!!! I loved all of Aries and Nix’s antics and poor Gem just got dragged into it all!! Can’t wait for his story!!
Such a fun read!!! I loved all of Aries and Nix’s antics and poor Gem just got dragged into it all!! Can’t wait for his story!!
January 1, 2026
⭐️4.5/5
🌶️4/5
💧2/5
😂4/5
🎄🎁🦇🍎🎃🍇🐲🧛♂️📱🪢⛓️🖍️🏒🥅😈🧷
📍Colorado/Boston/Vegas
💜sequel/prequel
💜mm/mm/mm
💜established relationships
💜hockey players
💜paranormal novella
💜fruit bat shifter x vampire
💜 fruit bat shifter x dragon shifter
💜 fruit bat shifter x tbd
💜christmas novella
💜bdsm
💜bondage
💜ddlb
💜age play
💜abdl
💜24/7 dynamic
💜long distance
💜secret identities
💜holiday
🌶️4/5
💧2/5
😂4/5
🎄🎁🦇🍎🎃🍇🐲🧛♂️📱🪢⛓️🖍️🏒🥅😈🧷
📍Colorado/Boston/Vegas
💜sequel/prequel
💜mm/mm/mm
💜established relationships
💜hockey players
💜paranormal novella
💜fruit bat shifter x vampire
💜 fruit bat shifter x dragon shifter
💜 fruit bat shifter x tbd
💜christmas novella
💜bdsm
💜bondage
💜ddlb
💜age play
💜abdl
💜24/7 dynamic
💜long distance
💜secret identities
💜holiday
Displaying 1 - 20 of 20 reviews