An urgent case that the survival of democracy depends on reinventing the press, with ten pioneering reforms to help journalism better serve the public—from the co-author of the classic The Elements of Journalism.
The crisis in journalism reflects a crisis in American democracy. Faith in news outlets has dwindled, news deserts are expanding, and audiences are turning away from alarmist, partisan, and fragmented coverage.
In The Next Journalism, Tom Rosenstiel—veteran journalist, researcher, novelist, and co-author of The Elements of Journalism—argues that the roots of journalism’s failure are intellectual, not just financial or technological. He outlines ten fundamental ways journalism must change to become more useful, trustworthy, and collaborative with the communities it serves.
From redefining news as a service rather than a product, to embracing transparency, to harnessing AI responsibly, Rosenstiel provides a bold, practical framework for rebuilding a press that empowers citizens instead of alienating them. With case studies, historical insight, and forward-looking ideas, this book offers journalists, policymakers, and readers alike a roadmap to ensuring democracy’s survival in the twenty-first century.
Tom Rosenstiel is a journalist, media critic, researcher, novelist, and professor. He is the author of seven influential nonfiction books, including The Elements of Journalism, and four novels. Rosenstiel has been a press critic for the Los Angeles Times, chief congressional correspondent for Newsweek, press critic for MSNBC, and director of media studies at the Pew Research Center. He also led the American Press Institute and now serves as Eleanor Merrill Professor on the Future of Journalism at the University of Maryland. He lives in Washington, D.C.
For more reviews, Margin Notes: Sourcing, Misinformation, and the Decline of Fact-Checking, and bookish posts visit: https://www.ManOfLaBook.com
The Next Journalism: How the Press Must Change to Serve Democracy by Tom Rosenstiel criticizes the modern press for using antiquated and irrelevant practices, offering clear alternatives. Mr. Rosenstiel is a journalist, scholar, and best-selling author.
I'd be the first to admit that this book is not geared towards schmos like me. I decided to read it because I have an interest in misinformation and disinformation and noticed, the past three years or so, that legacy media has dropped their due diligence for factfinding and embraced immediacy "breaking news" coverage.
I subscribe to several digital newspapers, because I thought that I'd be able to get facts, not clickbait headlines. Quickly I realized that I am getting clickbait headlines under the guise of "reliable journalism", with a political agenda added on for good measure. Not only that, but tracing back sources for such prestigious publications I often ended with a tweet, reddit or TikTok posts used by "journalist" to push a view point or an agenda. Shameful.
Mr. Rosenstiel cemented my suspicion that previously respectable news organizations are prioritizing clicks over truth, and that current journalism has little value. In fairness, journalism had little value since the "intellectualization" of the field, when journalists stopped being the guys that hung out at the docks or city hall, to use two cliché examples, to write stories which have relevance to people's everyday lives. Everybody wants to be "in the room where it happens", but most people don't care.
The Next Journalism argues that journalists need to shift focus from inflammatory content to that which helps regular people navigate the complex, often glacially paced, matters that are of concern to them, and I couldn't agree more. Sure, it's not as sexy as getting your picture taken in the White House, but it's of interest to people.
The book doesn't just criticize, it offers solutions in the form of roadmaps on how journalists can change the trajectory of their occupation from prioritizing meme-news to that of a serious, fact-based stories. I still remember the first time someone told me, in all seriousness, that TikTok is a great news source. I waved the whole thing off thinking it was a fluke, but I was wrong, and sadly it's getting worse as today news are consumes through humor and memes.
In my case, and it's anecdotal of course, I found that The New York Times often relied on unverified viral posts (heavily upvoted tweets or reddit comments, and actually admit it: "Reddit is a gem of the internet, and a trusted source of news and entertainment for millions of people") which, to me, undermined their whole brand and damaged trust and readership. Sadly, they haven't learned their lesson and keep promoting misleading narratives, spreading misinformation under the guise of a trusted source. I mean, they used reddit as a trusted source.
Overall, the book is both insightful and thoughtful, putting forth good ideas which, as I understand, are neither new nor novel, in an organized and disciplinary manner. I think I can speak for most of us when I say that we expect the media to question policy and be skeptical of what government is trying to sell us. If only that would sell newspapers.
How depressing! This work attempts to provide a kind of blueprint for resurrecting journalism. I agree with much of what the author writes here. My problem is that I believe it is already too late. When the powerful figured out how to manipulate the hive mind mentality of those who follow politics and get away with it the game was over. The presidential debate between Barack Obama and Mitt Romney in which moderator Candy Crowley interjected and sided with Obama about a question of the timing of the act of terror designation for Benghazi is a key indicator of the problem. This problem would seem to be exacerbated by the prescriptions given by the author who indicated that there need to be not necessarily a change in the “just the facts” type of reporting from ages ago, but a revolution in how the facts are seasoned for who is listening to them. I think we have had enough “seasoning” already. If we as a public are too stupid to interpret facts perhaps we don’t deserve this republic after all.
The author does a good job of writing and the work is not hard to swim through. It is frustrating, though, that we have come to the point where we have to talk about how to get the public to listen to the facts mostly because those “Reporting” the facts have gotten it wrong so many times. 3 stars.