What do you think?
Rate this book
Ada Holloway's Had Enough
Ada Holloway just needs to survive her final semester as a high school senior, but nothing's going her way.
Star quarterback Beckett Forsythe relies on Ada to do his homework for him, her rebellious cousin Molly has no where else to go but the Holloway's house, and to top it all off, Ada doesn't really know what she wants to do with her life—even though her parents already decided for her.
The one thing she does know is the topic for her senior the life of Freeport's founder, Everett J. Washington. But the Mayor of Freeport has pulled Washington's biography from library shelves among a massive book ban. Ada needs that book, she needs to write her essay, and her best friend David has a perfect a banned book club run by the public library. What could go wrong?
Star quarterback Beckett Forsythe relies on Ada to do his homework for him, her rebellious cousin Molly has no where else to go but the Holloway's house, and to top it all off, Ada doesn't really know what she wants to do with her life—even though her parents already decided for her.
The one thing she does know is the topic for her senior the life of Freeport's founder, Everett J. Washington. But the Mayor of Freeport has pulled Washington's biography from library shelves among a massive book ban. Ada needs that book, she needs to write her essay, and her best friend David has a perfect a banned book club run by the public library. What could go wrong?
- GenresYoung Adult
258 pages, Paperback
Published April 21, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 50 reviews
October 13, 2026
This read was completed in honor of Banned Books Week and the pressing concern of censorship in society. Through Ada Holloway’s experiences, this issue comes full circle, challenging us as readers to look beyond our own limited perspectives and consider the broader implications of banned literature.
When Ada Holloway finds herself caught up in a book-banning controversy in her small town of Freeport Ohio, she is challenged to consider how far she is willing to go, not only to pursue knowledge for a school project, but also to protect the stories of those who voices came before her.
This is one thing I believe Randi did really well when creating this story— as readers, we are able to see Ada go from a soft-spoken student who has always subjected herself to the expectations of others to a bold, passionate individual with a desire to let the truth speak for itself. Of course, this transformation is largely influenced by the book club that forms to support her initial ambition of completing a compelling senior essay. Her best friend David, cousin Molly, and other members of the library staff play a large role in the emotional development of the story, an aspect that I think really drives the idea of community-based groups when it comes to preserving access to literature.
However, that being said, I wish I had felt more invested in Ada’s relationship with her parents and brothers. Personally, I found much of Mrs. Holloway’s anger unwarranted, and at times, distracting to the story itself. While I understand her role in the larger plot, I would have liked to see a more developed version of her character that explored the reasoning behind her anger and how it might stem from her own ideals and concerns as a mother. I believe this would have feel the overall family dynamic more complex, especially since the rest of the family is quick to bow to her opinions. In large, while I appreciated that Randi explored the dynamic of young adults navigating their parents’ expectations, these tensions could have been further developed to contrast the idea of Ada’s growing independence and her family’s preconceived ideals regarding education and literature.
As someone who was not often exposed to the dangers of book banning growing up, I really appreciated Randi’s grit and passion for developing a story like this. Looking forward, this book provided a taste for what it means for schools and states to be affected by both local and widespread book bans.
As a college student, I do think that readers of all ages could gain meaningful awareness from this story. However, the language and readability seem better suited to younger readers, particularly those in late elementary and early middle school. I think this is important to keep in mind when approaching this book, as older readers may occasionally feel a disconnect due to its simpler language and presentation of the topic at hand.
When Ada Holloway finds herself caught up in a book-banning controversy in her small town of Freeport Ohio, she is challenged to consider how far she is willing to go, not only to pursue knowledge for a school project, but also to protect the stories of those who voices came before her.
This is one thing I believe Randi did really well when creating this story— as readers, we are able to see Ada go from a soft-spoken student who has always subjected herself to the expectations of others to a bold, passionate individual with a desire to let the truth speak for itself. Of course, this transformation is largely influenced by the book club that forms to support her initial ambition of completing a compelling senior essay. Her best friend David, cousin Molly, and other members of the library staff play a large role in the emotional development of the story, an aspect that I think really drives the idea of community-based groups when it comes to preserving access to literature.
However, that being said, I wish I had felt more invested in Ada’s relationship with her parents and brothers. Personally, I found much of Mrs. Holloway’s anger unwarranted, and at times, distracting to the story itself. While I understand her role in the larger plot, I would have liked to see a more developed version of her character that explored the reasoning behind her anger and how it might stem from her own ideals and concerns as a mother. I believe this would have feel the overall family dynamic more complex, especially since the rest of the family is quick to bow to her opinions. In large, while I appreciated that Randi explored the dynamic of young adults navigating their parents’ expectations, these tensions could have been further developed to contrast the idea of Ada’s growing independence and her family’s preconceived ideals regarding education and literature.
As someone who was not often exposed to the dangers of book banning growing up, I really appreciated Randi’s grit and passion for developing a story like this. Looking forward, this book provided a taste for what it means for schools and states to be affected by both local and widespread book bans.
As a college student, I do think that readers of all ages could gain meaningful awareness from this story. However, the language and readability seem better suited to younger readers, particularly those in late elementary and early middle school. I think this is important to keep in mind when approaching this book, as older readers may occasionally feel a disconnect due to its simpler language and presentation of the topic at hand.
October 15, 2026
As the title suggests, Randi Smith’s novel follows young Ada Holloway, who quite simply has had enough after her town’s mayor unjustly removes some “problematic” books from her local library. One of these books happens to be the story that Ada decided to write her senior paper on, and she is determined to read it. Despite her rule-following nature, she forms a secret book club dedicated to reading the banned books.
ADA HOLLOWAY’S HAD ENOUGH! was a fairly easy read. The story did not thrill me, nor did it bore me. While reading, I always kept in mind that this was Smith’s debut novel—and for that, I gave her credit for simply being able to capture her story so that I could engage with it. It’s clear that book banning is a topic Smith is passionate about, so to cleverly weave the topic into an accessible story for teens is an inspiring way to educate readers on the issue.
The most successful thing that Smith pulls off is her concept: a secret book club lead by a good-two-shoes protagonist who has a disapproving family? Yes, please! Every element of Smith’s concept nicely served the theme of book banning.
That being said, the elements that I took issue with were largely character based. I appreciated what Smith was trying to do with certain characters (like Ada and her strict mother), however, these characters often fell flat for me. I hoped for a bit more emotional depth and complexity. The side characters also felt a bit underdeveloped (with the exception being Ada’s rebellious cousin Molly, who I thought was entertaining).
While I had my issues with this book, I think it is important to understand that AHHE would probably be best for younger readers. I would have absolutely adored this novel if I had read it in middle school, and I think it is perfect for that age range.
Despite being an avid reader, I haven’t really participated in the conversation around book banning much. Like Ada, I am somewhat conflict-averse. So, to read a story about book banning not only pushed me out of my comfort zone, but it was also a delightful way to engage in the issue. Smith demonstrates the power reading has to educate ourselves while having a good time.
For those who might be more reluctant to enter the conversation on book banning—or those who know nothing about it—this book is a great place to start.
ADA HOLLOWAY’S HAD ENOUGH! was a fairly easy read. The story did not thrill me, nor did it bore me. While reading, I always kept in mind that this was Smith’s debut novel—and for that, I gave her credit for simply being able to capture her story so that I could engage with it. It’s clear that book banning is a topic Smith is passionate about, so to cleverly weave the topic into an accessible story for teens is an inspiring way to educate readers on the issue.
The most successful thing that Smith pulls off is her concept: a secret book club lead by a good-two-shoes protagonist who has a disapproving family? Yes, please! Every element of Smith’s concept nicely served the theme of book banning.
That being said, the elements that I took issue with were largely character based. I appreciated what Smith was trying to do with certain characters (like Ada and her strict mother), however, these characters often fell flat for me. I hoped for a bit more emotional depth and complexity. The side characters also felt a bit underdeveloped (with the exception being Ada’s rebellious cousin Molly, who I thought was entertaining).
While I had my issues with this book, I think it is important to understand that AHHE would probably be best for younger readers. I would have absolutely adored this novel if I had read it in middle school, and I think it is perfect for that age range.
Despite being an avid reader, I haven’t really participated in the conversation around book banning much. Like Ada, I am somewhat conflict-averse. So, to read a story about book banning not only pushed me out of my comfort zone, but it was also a delightful way to engage in the issue. Smith demonstrates the power reading has to educate ourselves while having a good time.
For those who might be more reluctant to enter the conversation on book banning—or those who know nothing about it—this book is a great place to start.
April 6, 2026
As a high school English teacher, I would love to put this book in the hands of my students. Writer Randi Smith has developed a relatable teenage character in Ada, a young woman finding her voice while navigating the pressures of family expectations. In order to graduate, Ada must write an essay centered on her hometown of Freeport, and she has an idea that has been percolating for a while: an essay on founder Everett J. Washington. When a book ban stands in the way of this graduation requirement, Ada learns not only how to speak out but also how to express her values and beliefs to some important people who don’t fully understand her.
First and foremost: fabulous title. Second, the supporting characters confirm what we all know: bookish people make the best friends. Finally, Smith has tackled a topic (book banning and library censorship) that needs our attention, and she does it in such an intelligent and authentic way.
After receiving my ARC from the author, I’m happy to recommend this to anyone—adult, teen, or child—who needs the encouragement that the things that matter are worth fighting for.
First and foremost: fabulous title. Second, the supporting characters confirm what we all know: bookish people make the best friends. Finally, Smith has tackled a topic (book banning and library censorship) that needs our attention, and she does it in such an intelligent and authentic way.
After receiving my ARC from the author, I’m happy to recommend this to anyone—adult, teen, or child—who needs the encouragement that the things that matter are worth fighting for.
Read
January 6, 2026Ada Holloway’s Had Enough is a sharp, emotionally grounded coming of age story that captures the quiet pressure of expectation, responsibility, and self-discovery. Ada is a deeply relatable protagonist overworked, uncertain, and carrying the weight of other people’s choices while trying to survive her final semester of high school. The author skillfully weaves humor, tension, and vulnerability into Ada’s everyday struggles, making her journey feel authentic and compelling.
What elevates this novel is how it tackles timely themes such as censorship, intellectual freedom, and identity without losing its heart. The banned book storyline adds urgency and relevance, while the supporting cast particularly Beckett, Molly, and David bring texture and contrast to Ada’s world. Randi Smith’s writing is engaging and thoughtful, offering readers a story that feels both personal and socially resonant. Had Enough is a meaningful, well paced novel that lingers long after the final page
What elevates this novel is how it tackles timely themes such as censorship, intellectual freedom, and identity without losing its heart. The banned book storyline adds urgency and relevance, while the supporting cast particularly Beckett, Molly, and David bring texture and contrast to Ada’s world. Randi Smith’s writing is engaging and thoughtful, offering readers a story that feels both personal and socially resonant. Had Enough is a meaningful, well paced novel that lingers long after the final page
April 7, 2026
I wish I’d had this book when I was a young teenager!!
Randi does an incredible job of breaking down the importance of libraries—and the dangers of controlling access to information—in a way that people of all ages can easily understand. But this book isn’t just about censorship: It’s also about standing up for yourself and using your voice, and how that’s something you can do even when you’re the “quiet kid.” It was really nice (as an adult who had a lot in common with Ada when I was a teen) to see her learn to do what she wants instead of what is expected of her. Ada is such a fun and easy character to root for!
So glad I was able to read an ARC!
Randi does an incredible job of breaking down the importance of libraries—and the dangers of controlling access to information—in a way that people of all ages can easily understand. But this book isn’t just about censorship: It’s also about standing up for yourself and using your voice, and how that’s something you can do even when you’re the “quiet kid.” It was really nice (as an adult who had a lot in common with Ada when I was a teen) to see her learn to do what she wants instead of what is expected of her. Ada is such a fun and easy character to root for!
So glad I was able to read an ARC!
April 27, 2026
Thank you to Netgalley and Betty Fay Publishing for an early copy of this book.
Ada Holloway's Had Enough follows Ada, an anxious high school senior tasked with writing her senior essay about her small town of Freeport. For years, she was dead set on writing about Everett J. Washington, a formally enslaved man that founded her town over a century ago. However, just as time rolls around for her to pull out Washington’s biography and get to work, the Freeport mayor bans multiple books from the public library, including Washington’s biography. Lost and crushed by the news, Ada decides to stay true to her essay topic, opening a secret book club in the Freeport library to learn about Freeport’s founder and eventually work up the courage to challenge the book ban directly.
TW: Mentions of verbal abuse
There was a major part of this book that I vehemently disliked. Ada is an anxious girl that absolutely abhors confrontation. This trait, we come to learn, came to be due to heavy conditioning in her childhood, specifically from Ada’s mother, Adeline Holloway. Mrs. Holloway is a controlling, egotistical, and abusive mother, to the point that it became nearly impossible for me to read this book in full without being triggered by her words. Mrs. Holloway constantly criticizes, micromanages, guilt-trips, and otherwise abuses and manipulates Ada in multiple ways. Had I known beforehand what type of character Mrs. Holloway was, I would not have approached this book.
I of course think that topics such as verbal abuse absolutely should be discussed in books, but this was handled very poorly, coming from a child of abuse. Despite Ada being—by all definitions—a victim, the book seems to downplay this. Ada describes her relationship with her family as “complicated”. It’s not. It’s abusive.
Near the end of the book (MINOR SPOILERS), Ada and Mrs. Holloway have a sit-down where Mrs. Holloway says that she will try to work on her abusive behaviour. Ada feels very hopeful about this, but as someone with an abusive mother, this does not feel earned. Mrs. Holloway has done nothing to change until this point in the book, and the only scene the reader sees after this confrontation describes Mrs. Holloway as “forced” when attempting to praise her daughter. I spent the entire book getting to know this character, so all this scene tells me is that Mrs. Holloway is bottling up her emotions, turning her into a bomb waiting to go off instead of rattling off micro-attacks. That’s not trustworthy behaviour.
I think Ada Holloway’s Had Enough is very timely, as book bans have become an incessant plague in recent times. Forcing an innocent girl to face that plague humanizes the effects that bans have on common people. I think that overall, the plot is straightforward and easy to follow since it’s realistic fiction, and I would categorize this book for middle-school to high-school readers. That being said, I would not recommend AHHE to anyone I know.
Ada Holloway's Had Enough follows Ada, an anxious high school senior tasked with writing her senior essay about her small town of Freeport. For years, she was dead set on writing about Everett J. Washington, a formally enslaved man that founded her town over a century ago. However, just as time rolls around for her to pull out Washington’s biography and get to work, the Freeport mayor bans multiple books from the public library, including Washington’s biography. Lost and crushed by the news, Ada decides to stay true to her essay topic, opening a secret book club in the Freeport library to learn about Freeport’s founder and eventually work up the courage to challenge the book ban directly.
TW: Mentions of verbal abuse
There was a major part of this book that I vehemently disliked. Ada is an anxious girl that absolutely abhors confrontation. This trait, we come to learn, came to be due to heavy conditioning in her childhood, specifically from Ada’s mother, Adeline Holloway. Mrs. Holloway is a controlling, egotistical, and abusive mother, to the point that it became nearly impossible for me to read this book in full without being triggered by her words. Mrs. Holloway constantly criticizes, micromanages, guilt-trips, and otherwise abuses and manipulates Ada in multiple ways. Had I known beforehand what type of character Mrs. Holloway was, I would not have approached this book.
I of course think that topics such as verbal abuse absolutely should be discussed in books, but this was handled very poorly, coming from a child of abuse. Despite Ada being—by all definitions—a victim, the book seems to downplay this. Ada describes her relationship with her family as “complicated”. It’s not. It’s abusive.
Near the end of the book (MINOR SPOILERS), Ada and Mrs. Holloway have a sit-down where Mrs. Holloway says that she will try to work on her abusive behaviour. Ada feels very hopeful about this, but as someone with an abusive mother, this does not feel earned. Mrs. Holloway has done nothing to change until this point in the book, and the only scene the reader sees after this confrontation describes Mrs. Holloway as “forced” when attempting to praise her daughter. I spent the entire book getting to know this character, so all this scene tells me is that Mrs. Holloway is bottling up her emotions, turning her into a bomb waiting to go off instead of rattling off micro-attacks. That’s not trustworthy behaviour.
I think Ada Holloway’s Had Enough is very timely, as book bans have become an incessant plague in recent times. Forcing an innocent girl to face that plague humanizes the effects that bans have on common people. I think that overall, the plot is straightforward and easy to follow since it’s realistic fiction, and I would categorize this book for middle-school to high-school readers. That being said, I would not recommend AHHE to anyone I know.
October 7, 2026
Ada Holloway’s Had Enough of book banning– and so has Randi Smith. In Smith’s debut YA novel, Smith carefully knits the intricacies of book bannings and the familial and relational struggles of a high school senior all in one. Ada Halloway is at her breaking point. Senior year is hard enough and between homework assignments (for two), strained home relationships, and parental collegiate pressures, Ada can hardly catch a break. The only solace Ada finds is the local Freeport library and knowing what she wants to focus her senior research paper on: Everett J. Washington, founder of Freeport. Everything is going to plan for Ada until Washington’s biography is pulled from library shelves following a book ban. Discovering this, Ada, her best friend, cousin, and the Freeport library’s small crew of employees form a bookclub bent on reinstating the banned books.
I was thoroughly impressed by Smith’s ability to attack such a serious, convoluted topic such as book banning in such a digestible manner. Using Ada and her companions as vessels, Smith appropriately highlights the diverse perspectives that are in play during a book ban as well as highlighting the fact that not just the reader is affected by a book ban. Through the use of Smith’s characters, young readers are given a pre-marked map of how-to’s in case they find themselves in similar scenarios. Speaking of readers…
AHHE is marketed towards young adults; however, given the characters, plot intricacies, and language present within the novel, this book is more suitable for middle grade readers. I found that Ada as well as her friend, David, were substantially one-dimensional characters. Though Ada did experience a beautiful character arc, I believe that it matched the depth of arcs present in other middle grade novels. Similarly, the plot itself seems to lend itself to a younger audience. Though the central theme is serious, the reasons that books are frequently banned such as explicit or sexual content are not explored, a facet that I think may be a little lack-luster to older audiences.
Just because a book is fiction doesn’t mean it isn’t true. As an avid reader and enjoyer of books, I have found that a gross number of my own favorite books have been challenged or banned. It is heartbreaking to know that some of the texts that formed me into the reader, activist, and human I am now are being censored from young readers. This book was inspiring to me and got me thinking, “What can I do?”
I would absolutely recommend this book to a middle grade reader who I feel can digest this material. I will note that this book does contain themes of familial verbal abuse and that parents should have a conversation with their child before or after reading in order to talk through the heavier subjects.
Whether or not the marketing changes the message still stays the same: Ada Holloway’s Had Enough and we have too!
I was thoroughly impressed by Smith’s ability to attack such a serious, convoluted topic such as book banning in such a digestible manner. Using Ada and her companions as vessels, Smith appropriately highlights the diverse perspectives that are in play during a book ban as well as highlighting the fact that not just the reader is affected by a book ban. Through the use of Smith’s characters, young readers are given a pre-marked map of how-to’s in case they find themselves in similar scenarios. Speaking of readers…
AHHE is marketed towards young adults; however, given the characters, plot intricacies, and language present within the novel, this book is more suitable for middle grade readers. I found that Ada as well as her friend, David, were substantially one-dimensional characters. Though Ada did experience a beautiful character arc, I believe that it matched the depth of arcs present in other middle grade novels. Similarly, the plot itself seems to lend itself to a younger audience. Though the central theme is serious, the reasons that books are frequently banned such as explicit or sexual content are not explored, a facet that I think may be a little lack-luster to older audiences.
Just because a book is fiction doesn’t mean it isn’t true. As an avid reader and enjoyer of books, I have found that a gross number of my own favorite books have been challenged or banned. It is heartbreaking to know that some of the texts that formed me into the reader, activist, and human I am now are being censored from young readers. This book was inspiring to me and got me thinking, “What can I do?”
I would absolutely recommend this book to a middle grade reader who I feel can digest this material. I will note that this book does contain themes of familial verbal abuse and that parents should have a conversation with their child before or after reading in order to talk through the heavier subjects.
Whether or not the marketing changes the message still stays the same: Ada Holloway’s Had Enough and we have too!
October 15, 2026
Randi Smith’s Ada Holloway’s Had Enough offers an insightful look at how banned books affect readers and how a ban ripples through a community. The novel follows Ada Holloway, an overachieving high school senior in the small town of Freeport. Her senior English project is on the history of Freeport, and she knows exactly what she wants to write about: the town’s founder, Everett J. Washington. But when the book she needs for her research is suddenly banned, Ada has to find another way to get it. She starts an after-hours banned books club, where she, her friends, and her cousin secretly push back against the new reading restrictions.
Thematically, the novel is a coming-of-age story. Ada fights not only government restrictions but also the heavy restrictions her own family places on her. Along the way, she gains confidence in defending what she believes are fundamental rights and grows in personal autonomy. I find these themes admirable and motivating for younger readers. Defying expectations and finding your voice are important lessons to learn young, and Ada is a strong role model. She encourages readers to question what is right and wrong in their own communities and to consider what they can do to change it.
Although the themes are strong, the book has some weaknesses. Ada and her friend David are established characters with a firm foundation, giving a clear sense of their morals and personalities. However, many additional characters outside of the main few contribute little to the plot and make the story muddy and confusing, especially for younger readers. Some characterization also relies on clichés. Beckett Forsythe, for instance, is a textbook “dumb jock,” and little distinguishes him from the stereotype apart from his association with the humane society near the end of the novel. Some scenes are also unrealistic. The Book Ban March, which ends almost immediately in arrests, could intimidate young readers and give them a false picture of how law enforcement operates. Finally, there are a few copyediting errors, such as the surname Tailer changing to Tailor on the next page.
Despite these flaws, the book succeeds at what it sets out to do: empowering young people to stand up for the truths and rights they find fundamental, and it introduces young audiences to the subject of book bans. Although I am older than the intended audience, I felt motivated to look for places where my own community or government fails to meet my needs and rights, and to advocate for change. There is no age limit to advocacy, and sometimes the younger the voice, the more powerful the message.
I believe this is a great introduction to book banning for middle schoolers. Its accessible language and simple scenarios make the issue easy to grasp for grades 6–8. I would also recommend it to anyone interested in book bans who wants to see why advocacy on the issue is both necessary and beneficial.
Thematically, the novel is a coming-of-age story. Ada fights not only government restrictions but also the heavy restrictions her own family places on her. Along the way, she gains confidence in defending what she believes are fundamental rights and grows in personal autonomy. I find these themes admirable and motivating for younger readers. Defying expectations and finding your voice are important lessons to learn young, and Ada is a strong role model. She encourages readers to question what is right and wrong in their own communities and to consider what they can do to change it.
Although the themes are strong, the book has some weaknesses. Ada and her friend David are established characters with a firm foundation, giving a clear sense of their morals and personalities. However, many additional characters outside of the main few contribute little to the plot and make the story muddy and confusing, especially for younger readers. Some characterization also relies on clichés. Beckett Forsythe, for instance, is a textbook “dumb jock,” and little distinguishes him from the stereotype apart from his association with the humane society near the end of the novel. Some scenes are also unrealistic. The Book Ban March, which ends almost immediately in arrests, could intimidate young readers and give them a false picture of how law enforcement operates. Finally, there are a few copyediting errors, such as the surname Tailer changing to Tailor on the next page.
Despite these flaws, the book succeeds at what it sets out to do: empowering young people to stand up for the truths and rights they find fundamental, and it introduces young audiences to the subject of book bans. Although I am older than the intended audience, I felt motivated to look for places where my own community or government fails to meet my needs and rights, and to advocate for change. There is no age limit to advocacy, and sometimes the younger the voice, the more powerful the message.
I believe this is a great introduction to book banning for middle schoolers. Its accessible language and simple scenarios make the issue easy to grasp for grades 6–8. I would also recommend it to anyone interested in book bans who wants to see why advocacy on the issue is both necessary and beneficial.
April 26, 2026
Ada Halloway’s Had Enough follows Ada, a quiet and intelligent high school senior navigating the tension between respecting authority and advocating for what’s important to her. After the mayor makes a decision that directly impacts her academic journey, Ada begins to discover passions within herself that she never noticed before. As she learns more about what she values, she practices speaking up and standing up for what she believes in.
This was such an insightful read. It was easily digestible in terms of size and pacing without sacrificing precision or care. You can tell that Randi Smith put a lot of thought into each character and scene because of how much growth is embedded throughout the story. Everything feels intentional and necessary. I especially appreciated that the book stayed away from romance. I think authors can sometimes spread themselves thin trying to tell too many stories at once, but here, each character supports Ada’s journey without taking away from her spotlight.
One aspect felt slightly unrealistic. Ada’s hesitation to ask her parents to go to the library stood out to me. While I understand that being part of a banned books club is controversial, their lack of support for her academic aspirations in general felt a bit extreme. At the same time, I recognize that this tension was important to the story and helped raise the stakes. But if they wanted her to go to college and were planning on supporting her through that next step in her academic career, wouldn't they realistically show the same support for her going to the library to conduct research for a project?
As a former overachieving high school student, this book impacted me on a deeper level. There are so many students who genuinely want to work hard and do their best, and watching Ada be stripped of her resources created a real sense of unfairness. I really resonated with her determination to overcome the obstacles placed in her way.
I had the privilege of hearing Randi Smith speak at Belmont University, which added another layer to my experience and perception of Ada's story. Hearing about how this story developed ( how it grew from a small assignment into a full manuscript ) made me appreciate the book even more.
This story made me reflect on my own life and ask: how far would I go to stand up for what I believe in? Ada’s passion made me more aware of how easy it is to stay passive, and it challenged me to think differently.
I would recommend this book especially for middle and high school students, but it can resonate beyond that. It has the potential to inspire younger readers to form their own beliefs and stand by them, which makes it a really meaningful read.
This was such an insightful read. It was easily digestible in terms of size and pacing without sacrificing precision or care. You can tell that Randi Smith put a lot of thought into each character and scene because of how much growth is embedded throughout the story. Everything feels intentional and necessary. I especially appreciated that the book stayed away from romance. I think authors can sometimes spread themselves thin trying to tell too many stories at once, but here, each character supports Ada’s journey without taking away from her spotlight.
One aspect felt slightly unrealistic. Ada’s hesitation to ask her parents to go to the library stood out to me. While I understand that being part of a banned books club is controversial, their lack of support for her academic aspirations in general felt a bit extreme. At the same time, I recognize that this tension was important to the story and helped raise the stakes. But if they wanted her to go to college and were planning on supporting her through that next step in her academic career, wouldn't they realistically show the same support for her going to the library to conduct research for a project?
As a former overachieving high school student, this book impacted me on a deeper level. There are so many students who genuinely want to work hard and do their best, and watching Ada be stripped of her resources created a real sense of unfairness. I really resonated with her determination to overcome the obstacles placed in her way.
I had the privilege of hearing Randi Smith speak at Belmont University, which added another layer to my experience and perception of Ada's story. Hearing about how this story developed ( how it grew from a small assignment into a full manuscript ) made me appreciate the book even more.
This story made me reflect on my own life and ask: how far would I go to stand up for what I believe in? Ada’s passion made me more aware of how easy it is to stay passive, and it challenged me to think differently.
I would recommend this book especially for middle and high school students, but it can resonate beyond that. It has the potential to inspire younger readers to form their own beliefs and stand by them, which makes it a really meaningful read.
October 6, 2026
I read this book for my college publishing class, and I want to be clear about that up front. I am not the book’s intended reader. It is a young adult novel about a high school senior, and I read it as an assignment rather than as someone looking for a story about a seventeen- or eighteen-year-old finding her voice. That distance shaped how I read it.
Ada Holloway is a rule-following senior in Freeport, Ohio, whose senior essay on the town’s founder runs into a library book ban. With her best friend David and her cousin Molly, she joins an after-hours banned-book club so she can still use the biography she needs. Around that plot, Smith sets family pressure, a classmate who leans on Ada for homework, and Ada’s uncertainty about a future her parents have already sketched for her. The premise is timely, and the choice to put a modern book challenge inside a small-town library is a clear one. Readers who want a story about censorship, and about a quiet student learning to speak, will find the subject handled directly.
My biggest disconnect with this novel was perhaps the familial dynamic. Ada’s hesitation throughout the novel is understandable, as her mother is quite strict and quick to shut Ada down, but I tend to want messier consequences in a story about someone pushing boundaries like Ada does. I also found it a bit unusual that the behaviors of Ada’s older brothers, Theo and Sam, are not frequently addressed by Mrs. Holloway, as they are depicted at the start of the novel as being unemployed and lounging around the house all day, Sam even going so far as to lie to the parents that he got a job interview. I thought maybe since Ada was being punished for sneaking out of the house and lying to her parents, Theo and Sam would also face repercussions for their behavior. Of course, this is personal preference.
I did find it refreshing seeing Ada slowly learn to stand up for herself both at home and at school. I read a similar book that talked about teens pushing back against book-banning when I was in middle school, and having been the target audience, it resonated much cleaner with me. I think book-banning is an increasingly common topic in our society, especially in the realm of publishing, and it is a topic that should be addressed in both real life and fiction such as this.
Again, since this book was assigned to read in college and I am already outside the target audience, it did not resonate as much with me, but I can see why the book would land for a teen who feels over-managed and wants a story about the freedom to read the books they want. Teen readers who want a story about standing up to a book ban and like a quieter main character, are the right audience for this one.
Ada Holloway is a rule-following senior in Freeport, Ohio, whose senior essay on the town’s founder runs into a library book ban. With her best friend David and her cousin Molly, she joins an after-hours banned-book club so she can still use the biography she needs. Around that plot, Smith sets family pressure, a classmate who leans on Ada for homework, and Ada’s uncertainty about a future her parents have already sketched for her. The premise is timely, and the choice to put a modern book challenge inside a small-town library is a clear one. Readers who want a story about censorship, and about a quiet student learning to speak, will find the subject handled directly.
My biggest disconnect with this novel was perhaps the familial dynamic. Ada’s hesitation throughout the novel is understandable, as her mother is quite strict and quick to shut Ada down, but I tend to want messier consequences in a story about someone pushing boundaries like Ada does. I also found it a bit unusual that the behaviors of Ada’s older brothers, Theo and Sam, are not frequently addressed by Mrs. Holloway, as they are depicted at the start of the novel as being unemployed and lounging around the house all day, Sam even going so far as to lie to the parents that he got a job interview. I thought maybe since Ada was being punished for sneaking out of the house and lying to her parents, Theo and Sam would also face repercussions for their behavior. Of course, this is personal preference.
I did find it refreshing seeing Ada slowly learn to stand up for herself both at home and at school. I read a similar book that talked about teens pushing back against book-banning when I was in middle school, and having been the target audience, it resonated much cleaner with me. I think book-banning is an increasingly common topic in our society, especially in the realm of publishing, and it is a topic that should be addressed in both real life and fiction such as this.
Again, since this book was assigned to read in college and I am already outside the target audience, it did not resonate as much with me, but I can see why the book would land for a teen who feels over-managed and wants a story about the freedom to read the books they want. Teen readers who want a story about standing up to a book ban and like a quieter main character, are the right audience for this one.
June 7, 2026
I didn’t get an ARC from Net Galley. I paid real paycheck dollars to own this book. I’m glad I did.
A couple of things seemed noticeably absent - the use of laptops when phones were restricted, but the complete absence of email or Google chat to communicate. I also was waiting to hear why Everett Washington’s (excuse me Everett *J* Washington’s) book was objectionable. That was enticing information that kept me reading, but never came. The story mentioned speeches from ‘both sides’ but never included perspectives of opposition.
I genuinely liked Ada, Molly, David, and Beckett. The compelling tension other than the unrevealed reason for the contested books was inside Ada’s emotionally bereft home. I felt Ada’s mother was flat-out abusive by way of intentionally withholding affection or approval of any kind. I was appalled by the environment Ada had to navigate. There were words to describe Ada’s mother’s reaction to Ada - vitriol, disgust, ruin, embarrass, shame, anger, betrayal, criminal, ungrateful, cold silence, the removal of food before Ada was finished, the threat of removing the opportunity of college. We saw Ada shivering and hugging herself because she received zero affection from her parents. Not even concern for the trauma of being arrested. Not a single, “Are you okay?” Parents can disapprove of choices while also being affectionate, supportive and instructive.
I just felt so anxious for Ada. The narration had no take on this behavior from Ada’s mother. It almost seemed to portray it as normal. I could hardly handle it. But I did admire Ada and how she handled it even if she did see herself as the problem instead of her mother’s emotional neglect.
I’d LOVE to see a follow-up novel in which Ada and Molly discover what a healthy, supportive parent-child relationship looks like. Heck - maybe even Mr. And Mrs. Holloway discovering it and their horror upon self-actualizing.
But if Ada is to work as a journalist covering book challenges at public libraries, I want follow up novels to show the nitty-gritty of what content is most often contested, and why it really matters that people -especially teens - are able to see their own selves and experiences, both good and bad, reflected inside books. I believe this author could do it justice.
Well - that was a long review for a relatively short book, BUT - it goes to show that the book gripped me emotionally and kept me reading and reflecting at every chapter. I’d gladly recommend this book to teens in my life.
A couple of things seemed noticeably absent - the use of laptops when phones were restricted, but the complete absence of email or Google chat to communicate. I also was waiting to hear why Everett Washington’s (excuse me Everett *J* Washington’s) book was objectionable. That was enticing information that kept me reading, but never came. The story mentioned speeches from ‘both sides’ but never included perspectives of opposition.
I genuinely liked Ada, Molly, David, and Beckett. The compelling tension other than the unrevealed reason for the contested books was inside Ada’s emotionally bereft home. I felt Ada’s mother was flat-out abusive by way of intentionally withholding affection or approval of any kind. I was appalled by the environment Ada had to navigate. There were words to describe Ada’s mother’s reaction to Ada - vitriol, disgust, ruin, embarrass, shame, anger, betrayal, criminal, ungrateful, cold silence, the removal of food before Ada was finished, the threat of removing the opportunity of college. We saw Ada shivering and hugging herself because she received zero affection from her parents. Not even concern for the trauma of being arrested. Not a single, “Are you okay?” Parents can disapprove of choices while also being affectionate, supportive and instructive.
I just felt so anxious for Ada. The narration had no take on this behavior from Ada’s mother. It almost seemed to portray it as normal. I could hardly handle it. But I did admire Ada and how she handled it even if she did see herself as the problem instead of her mother’s emotional neglect.
I’d LOVE to see a follow-up novel in which Ada and Molly discover what a healthy, supportive parent-child relationship looks like. Heck - maybe even Mr. And Mrs. Holloway discovering it and their horror upon self-actualizing.
But if Ada is to work as a journalist covering book challenges at public libraries, I want follow up novels to show the nitty-gritty of what content is most often contested, and why it really matters that people -especially teens - are able to see their own selves and experiences, both good and bad, reflected inside books. I believe this author could do it justice.
Well - that was a long review for a relatively short book, BUT - it goes to show that the book gripped me emotionally and kept me reading and reflecting at every chapter. I’d gladly recommend this book to teens in my life.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 15, 2026
In Randi Smith’s Young Adult novel, Ada Holloway, a High School senior in Freeport, Ohio, comes across a roadblock when handed the English paper that seniors before her have had to complete.
Ada is a black sheep in a community that doesn’t see reading and writing as a necessity for youth. She values education in a way her family and peers around her do not, and with this conflict in interest, it makes going above and beyond as a student difficult for her. Ada feels like she is living a life that is planned for her, but her first act of defiance is choosing a topic for her senior essay that has never been written about: the town’s founder, Everett J. Washington, a formally enslaved African American man who fought in the Civil War as a union soldier. But along with that first act of defiance, comes with her first hurdle she must jump. The only book in the town about their founder has been banned by their mayor. Being a pushover in a family that has always walked over and going to a school where she is seen as a superior academic and is constantly taken advantage of because of that, she has no intention of pushing against the removal of the book she needs for her essay. But after some motivation and support from her close friend, David, and some librarian staff, Ada decides to start a secret book club where they read her needed documents. But with the ban being put in place by the mayor, there is more at stake than just sneaking around behind her mothers back to get to her book club meetings.
This novel was strong and had very important themes that young readers need in today’s society. Though the general writing and storytelling in this novel is very strong, it seems very young for the age group that it is being advertised as. The themes are definitely too old for a grade school reader, but the writing and storytelling is a little bit too simple to be considered a Young Adult novel. Aside from that, the character development was very articulate and was actually one of the strongest and most engaging attributes of the novel.
Throughout the novel, young readers are not only encouraged and given inspired to make a difference in their community, but to also stand up for their beliefs and in their personal lives. Reading this novel led me through a number of emotions that I was not expecting to feel while reading a novel about banned books. It made me realize how banned books can mean so much more to those who already don’t have a number of resources and made me realize just how important the message really is.
Ada is a black sheep in a community that doesn’t see reading and writing as a necessity for youth. She values education in a way her family and peers around her do not, and with this conflict in interest, it makes going above and beyond as a student difficult for her. Ada feels like she is living a life that is planned for her, but her first act of defiance is choosing a topic for her senior essay that has never been written about: the town’s founder, Everett J. Washington, a formally enslaved African American man who fought in the Civil War as a union soldier. But along with that first act of defiance, comes with her first hurdle she must jump. The only book in the town about their founder has been banned by their mayor. Being a pushover in a family that has always walked over and going to a school where she is seen as a superior academic and is constantly taken advantage of because of that, she has no intention of pushing against the removal of the book she needs for her essay. But after some motivation and support from her close friend, David, and some librarian staff, Ada decides to start a secret book club where they read her needed documents. But with the ban being put in place by the mayor, there is more at stake than just sneaking around behind her mothers back to get to her book club meetings.
This novel was strong and had very important themes that young readers need in today’s society. Though the general writing and storytelling in this novel is very strong, it seems very young for the age group that it is being advertised as. The themes are definitely too old for a grade school reader, but the writing and storytelling is a little bit too simple to be considered a Young Adult novel. Aside from that, the character development was very articulate and was actually one of the strongest and most engaging attributes of the novel.
Throughout the novel, young readers are not only encouraged and given inspired to make a difference in their community, but to also stand up for their beliefs and in their personal lives. Reading this novel led me through a number of emotions that I was not expecting to feel while reading a novel about banned books. It made me realize how banned books can mean so much more to those who already don’t have a number of resources and made me realize just how important the message really is.
April 27, 2026
Ada Holloway's Had Enough is a Y/A fictional novel that follows Ada, a passionate but timid high school senior, as she tries to stand up for her rights as a reader, attempting to stop book bans at her local public library. As Ada realizes that the book she wants to write her senior English paper on is being banned, along with many others, she decides to get her friends together to start a banned books after-school club. The readers see Ada begin to grow in her character as she stands up for what she believes in, as well as navigating her complicated relationship with her parents.
I think Randi Smith did a great job of giving a voice to the voiceless in this book. Every character had their own quirks and distinct personalities, especially Ada. The teenage nature of the book's main character was something I can easily find myself relating to when thinking about my time in high school. I also appreciate that while the novel did have a touch of romance, it did not stray from following Ada's goals and dreams as a character. Having her storyline stand alone was really impactful and important for the strength of her character.
As for Ada's relationship with her parents, I think it seemed a bit extreme at times. I feel like Ada's parents, especially her mother, could have been more supportive of her throughout the novel. It seemed a little unrealistic to see Ada have to cover up and lie about her plans with the club just because she thought her mother would disapprove. If her parents were wanting her to have a college education, wouldn't they be supportive of her dreams to advocate for her rights as a student and reader?
Reading this book left me with even more appreciation for banned books than before. As a writer myself, I found it really inspiring to hear Randi's story and how this novel came to be. I liked Ada's character and seeing her storyline progress was really awesome. I think Randi did a good job of using the characters of high schoolers to show the impact that banned books has specifically on students and readers.
I would recommend this book to middle and high school students. At times, it did feel a little juvenile, but I think that this book is perfect for younger audiences. The message itself could apply to those older, however.
I think Randi Smith did a great job of giving a voice to the voiceless in this book. Every character had their own quirks and distinct personalities, especially Ada. The teenage nature of the book's main character was something I can easily find myself relating to when thinking about my time in high school. I also appreciate that while the novel did have a touch of romance, it did not stray from following Ada's goals and dreams as a character. Having her storyline stand alone was really impactful and important for the strength of her character.
As for Ada's relationship with her parents, I think it seemed a bit extreme at times. I feel like Ada's parents, especially her mother, could have been more supportive of her throughout the novel. It seemed a little unrealistic to see Ada have to cover up and lie about her plans with the club just because she thought her mother would disapprove. If her parents were wanting her to have a college education, wouldn't they be supportive of her dreams to advocate for her rights as a student and reader?
Reading this book left me with even more appreciation for banned books than before. As a writer myself, I found it really inspiring to hear Randi's story and how this novel came to be. I liked Ada's character and seeing her storyline progress was really awesome. I think Randi did a good job of using the characters of high schoolers to show the impact that banned books has specifically on students and readers.
I would recommend this book to middle and high school students. At times, it did feel a little juvenile, but I think that this book is perfect for younger audiences. The message itself could apply to those older, however.
October 15, 2026
Ada Holloway’s Had Enough was an easy to read, educational and compelling story. Through her writing, Randi Smith takes the reader on a journey of time in Ada Holloways’s life where she is personally affected by book banning and how she overcomes this issue.
Ada Holloway, a senior in high school, is required to write an essay about anything in her town. For her essay, she decides to write about the town’s founder, Everett J. Washington. Not too long after she is assigned this project, the mayor bans several books, including the biography of the town’s founder. Upon learning this, Ada embarks on a journey filled with banned book clubs, repairing family relationships, and learning how to stand up for what she believes in.
My favorite thing about this book was how it portrayed book banning. Smith’s writing and pace of the book help the readers to stay focused on the book ban as the main plot point of the book. I think it could be easy to get lost in side plots, in any book really, but Smith keeps the readers attention with her intelligent yet simple style of writing. While learning about the book banning, we get to see Ada grow from a shy, more introverted person, into the kind of person who can challenge authority and stand up for what she believes in. This is so inspiring and Smith does an amazing job of taking the reader through this journey. After reading this, I feel compelled to learn more about this issue and to take action against book banning.
As a college student, it was refreshing to read a book specifically meant to target a pressing political issue, without reading a political piece. Although this book is marketed for middle grade readers, I found it to be an enjoyable read. Book banning is an issue that continues to grow today and because it is so prevalent, I think we all need a book like this that focuses on a specific issue, without losing sight of the issue by connecting it to other issues.
I would recommend this book first to middle and high school students. It is a good pace for them as well as easy enough to grasp a complex and ever expanding issue. While it is more geared towards this younger audience, I think anyone can read this book and still gain something from it.
Ada Holloway, a senior in high school, is required to write an essay about anything in her town. For her essay, she decides to write about the town’s founder, Everett J. Washington. Not too long after she is assigned this project, the mayor bans several books, including the biography of the town’s founder. Upon learning this, Ada embarks on a journey filled with banned book clubs, repairing family relationships, and learning how to stand up for what she believes in.
My favorite thing about this book was how it portrayed book banning. Smith’s writing and pace of the book help the readers to stay focused on the book ban as the main plot point of the book. I think it could be easy to get lost in side plots, in any book really, but Smith keeps the readers attention with her intelligent yet simple style of writing. While learning about the book banning, we get to see Ada grow from a shy, more introverted person, into the kind of person who can challenge authority and stand up for what she believes in. This is so inspiring and Smith does an amazing job of taking the reader through this journey. After reading this, I feel compelled to learn more about this issue and to take action against book banning.
As a college student, it was refreshing to read a book specifically meant to target a pressing political issue, without reading a political piece. Although this book is marketed for middle grade readers, I found it to be an enjoyable read. Book banning is an issue that continues to grow today and because it is so prevalent, I think we all need a book like this that focuses on a specific issue, without losing sight of the issue by connecting it to other issues.
I would recommend this book first to middle and high school students. It is a good pace for them as well as easy enough to grasp a complex and ever expanding issue. While it is more geared towards this younger audience, I think anyone can read this book and still gain something from it.
April 28, 2026
Ada Holloways Had Enough by Randi Smith is the perfect book for middle-scholers and teens to teach them about the effects of book bans. The book features our main character, Ada Holloway and tells the tale of her struggle to protect books that the people in her town want to ban. The book starts with Ada being assigned an essay in her senior English class. However, when she starts to research for her paper on the founder of her town, Everett J. Washington (a formerly enslaved man), she finds that his biography has been taken off the shelves. This book and many others have been removed as part of a book ban by the mayor of their small town, Freeport. This lights a fire in Ada and causes her to start a secret book club reading banned books in the library. Throughout the book, Ada grows as a character and gains the confidence she needs to stand up for what is right against the people who support the book bans.
I think this book is a great way to teach teens and middle schoolers about book bans and what they can do to help stop them. This book was really engaging from start to finish, and there was never a dull moment. It was fast-paced, but it also took the time for well-needed emotional moments between characters. I loved the relationship between Ada and her cousin Molly the most; they both had a lot to learn from each other. I attribute a lot of Ada’s growth to Molly.
This book surprisingly made me take a look at myself and how I think I would react in the face of what Ada has to stand up to. As someone who struggles a lot during confrontation and who wants to make my parents proud, it was nice to see a character who feels the same as I do. It was also nice to see Ada’s growth and watch as she stands up for what she believes in. I hope someday I will have the courage to as well.
If I were to recommend this book to someone, I would recommend it to teens and jr high kids to read. This book tackles important issues going on in the world today that the younger generations need to know about. However, I also feel like this book is for a very specific age group, and adults would not connect with it as much as teens do.
I think this book is a great way to teach teens and middle schoolers about book bans and what they can do to help stop them. This book was really engaging from start to finish, and there was never a dull moment. It was fast-paced, but it also took the time for well-needed emotional moments between characters. I loved the relationship between Ada and her cousin Molly the most; they both had a lot to learn from each other. I attribute a lot of Ada’s growth to Molly.
This book surprisingly made me take a look at myself and how I think I would react in the face of what Ada has to stand up to. As someone who struggles a lot during confrontation and who wants to make my parents proud, it was nice to see a character who feels the same as I do. It was also nice to see Ada’s growth and watch as she stands up for what she believes in. I hope someday I will have the courage to as well.
If I were to recommend this book to someone, I would recommend it to teens and jr high kids to read. This book tackles important issues going on in the world today that the younger generations need to know about. However, I also feel like this book is for a very specific age group, and adults would not connect with it as much as teens do.
October 15, 2026
In her debut novel, Randi Smith creates the story of a high school senior named Ada fighting a pressing book ban in her town. Ada is a reserved, people-pleasing, and meek teen. She finds issue with the fact a biography on her town’s founder is banned in her local library, alongside other books. She creates a club for banned books with her close friend and cousin where they read segments of banned books. Throughout the novel, Ada raises awareness for banned books among her peers to ultimately lift the restrictions.
I thought this novel was very well written. The characters felt realistic, as well as the events. Ada was a strong character. Her motives were very clear and her beliefs were a driving point to her character. Her willingness to stand up for her beliefs despite her fears made her a very likeable character. Ada’s family also felt well developed. Their relationship felt realistic and thought out. Molly’s role in the novel felt very important as she influenced Ada to stand up for her beliefs. However, I felt that the book read younger than the intended audience. It is marketed for ages up to eighteen and is considered young adult fiction. But to me, the writing felt younger. I felt that Smith’s writing, despite being very strong, read to me like a middle-grade novel. I’m not saying that this is necessarily a bad thing. Rather, I believe that if it were to be a young adult novel, per my standards, it should be read more maturely. I’m unsure of how these changes could be made, yet I still believe this to be a very strong novel.
I felt that this book was very insightful. It explained book banning in a simple way. It felt very realistic to how I imagine serious book bans to be. However, I’m not very educated on book bans and don’t have loads of personal experience. By my ideas of it, I felt that it was realistic.
I would recommend this novel to anyone who wants to broaden their understanding of book bans. I would also suggest this book to someone to introduce them to knowledge on bans. The writing style explained the concept simply. All in all, I quite enjoyed this read!
I thought this novel was very well written. The characters felt realistic, as well as the events. Ada was a strong character. Her motives were very clear and her beliefs were a driving point to her character. Her willingness to stand up for her beliefs despite her fears made her a very likeable character. Ada’s family also felt well developed. Their relationship felt realistic and thought out. Molly’s role in the novel felt very important as she influenced Ada to stand up for her beliefs. However, I felt that the book read younger than the intended audience. It is marketed for ages up to eighteen and is considered young adult fiction. But to me, the writing felt younger. I felt that Smith’s writing, despite being very strong, read to me like a middle-grade novel. I’m not saying that this is necessarily a bad thing. Rather, I believe that if it were to be a young adult novel, per my standards, it should be read more maturely. I’m unsure of how these changes could be made, yet I still believe this to be a very strong novel.
I felt that this book was very insightful. It explained book banning in a simple way. It felt very realistic to how I imagine serious book bans to be. However, I’m not very educated on book bans and don’t have loads of personal experience. By my ideas of it, I felt that it was realistic.
I would recommend this novel to anyone who wants to broaden their understanding of book bans. I would also suggest this book to someone to introduce them to knowledge on bans. The writing style explained the concept simply. All in all, I quite enjoyed this read!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Ada is kept quiet for all her life - her brothers also need to obey their mother, but Sam can get away with watching television the entire day and lying about applying to jobs and Theo is the eldest and does not face repercussions if/when he decides it's time to go outside/away. Ada's most used phrased at home seems to be "Sorry" even though she's an absolute angel, doing her homework diligently, loving school as much as the next teenager who doesn't hate school loves school.
Her parents have saved money for her to go to college, become an accountant and work in the family firm - Ada's been accepted here and there but she does NOT like Maths and DOES like English.
She needs to write an essay and she wants it to be good, and different and in the library she finds a book on the founder of Freeport. To her dismay the book is banned, before she can read it - alongside other books, it really makes no sense- and obedient, quiet (and usually unheard anyway) Ada finds herself in a bookclub reading banned books, and with help of a cousin who's thrown her way (they literally have to share Ada's room, Ada's not asked for her opinion, of course) in hopes of finding the right path again Ada finds her voice, slowly, but surely.
The book does a good job in showing how wild "banning books" is - as I said: it makes no sense (I live in a country where the only banned book is Hitler's Mein Kampf, so topic wise banning books is far from my lived and cultural experience). I like how the book stays away from picking one particular topic as to why a mayor (or government) would ban a book, leaving "banning books" as a problem, and not, say, "books about slavery" or whatever other topic might apparently have books banned. IN that sense it's a brilliant book for class discussions, I think.
While there's a classmate she fancies, and while he has his own little story arch, there's no romance in this book, and it's all the better because of it.
expected April 21
I received an eARC of NetGalley in return for my honest opinion
Her parents have saved money for her to go to college, become an accountant and work in the family firm - Ada's been accepted here and there but she does NOT like Maths and DOES like English.
She needs to write an essay and she wants it to be good, and different and in the library she finds a book on the founder of Freeport. To her dismay the book is banned, before she can read it - alongside other books, it really makes no sense- and obedient, quiet (and usually unheard anyway) Ada finds herself in a bookclub reading banned books, and with help of a cousin who's thrown her way (they literally have to share Ada's room, Ada's not asked for her opinion, of course) in hopes of finding the right path again Ada finds her voice, slowly, but surely.
The book does a good job in showing how wild "banning books" is - as I said: it makes no sense (I live in a country where the only banned book is Hitler's Mein Kampf, so topic wise banning books is far from my lived and cultural experience). I like how the book stays away from picking one particular topic as to why a mayor (or government) would ban a book, leaving "banning books" as a problem, and not, say, "books about slavery" or whatever other topic might apparently have books banned. IN that sense it's a brilliant book for class discussions, I think.
While there's a classmate she fancies, and while he has his own little story arch, there's no romance in this book, and it's all the better because of it.
expected April 21
I received an eARC of NetGalley in return for my honest opinion
April 27, 2026
** Thank you to NetGalley and Betty Fay Publishing for providing me a copy of this book to review
I love books, as do many people on this app. Book banning is a topic that comes up often in bookish communities, and it’s a very important topic we can’t forget about. Randi Smith decided to take this topic and make it into a novel, and it was a fantastic choice.
Ada Holloway doesn’t make too many ripples. She lets the jock copy her homework, because what would happen if she tells him no? She doesn’t speak up much to her parents, because what would happen if they got upset? Ada is content enough to move through life and go away to college before coming back home and working at her father’s business. And, of course, write the best essay on Freeport’s founder, Everett J. Washington. However, the only resource available on the founder is suddenly target by a book ban, ruining Ada’s chance at writing an essay. Unless, she, her best friend, her handful of a cousin, and the local library staff members form a secret book club to read the book? What could go wrong!
This book was a really fun read for me. It does read at an age level younger than me, which was a struggle at first. I’d definitely aim this book towards middle schoolers and high schoolers. Luckily, the message is still evident despite this. I enjoyed following Ada’s journey as she realizes she does want to make ripples, maybe even waves, because she finally has something she cares so deeply about. Reading this reminded me of my own passion for books, and it fired me up over book bans as well.
The character dynamics are well-written and interesting to dive into, and the development between Ada and several others is done well and worth it in the end. While there are some things that bother me a bit, the end of this book is more than worth it.
Thank you again to NetGalley and Betty Fay Books for providing me with a copy of this book to read! It was a great experience and something I think every student (or anyone!) should read.
Rating: 3.75/5
Recommend? Yes
I love books, as do many people on this app. Book banning is a topic that comes up often in bookish communities, and it’s a very important topic we can’t forget about. Randi Smith decided to take this topic and make it into a novel, and it was a fantastic choice.
Ada Holloway doesn’t make too many ripples. She lets the jock copy her homework, because what would happen if she tells him no? She doesn’t speak up much to her parents, because what would happen if they got upset? Ada is content enough to move through life and go away to college before coming back home and working at her father’s business. And, of course, write the best essay on Freeport’s founder, Everett J. Washington. However, the only resource available on the founder is suddenly target by a book ban, ruining Ada’s chance at writing an essay. Unless, she, her best friend, her handful of a cousin, and the local library staff members form a secret book club to read the book? What could go wrong!
This book was a really fun read for me. It does read at an age level younger than me, which was a struggle at first. I’d definitely aim this book towards middle schoolers and high schoolers. Luckily, the message is still evident despite this. I enjoyed following Ada’s journey as she realizes she does want to make ripples, maybe even waves, because she finally has something she cares so deeply about. Reading this reminded me of my own passion for books, and it fired me up over book bans as well.
The character dynamics are well-written and interesting to dive into, and the development between Ada and several others is done well and worth it in the end. While there are some things that bother me a bit, the end of this book is more than worth it.
Thank you again to NetGalley and Betty Fay Books for providing me with a copy of this book to read! It was a great experience and something I think every student (or anyone!) should read.
Rating: 3.75/5
Recommend? Yes
April 27, 2026
Ada Holloway Had Enough follows the young Ada Holloway during her senior year as she sets out to write a paper on her town's founder, Everett J Washington, when she runs into a big problem. The town's mayor has put the book, along with others, on a list to be reviewed for banned books. Ada, along with her friends, starts a secret book club so she can finish her paper and continue being the amazing student she is.
Ada is a main character I wish I had growing up. Being a rule-following kid myself, I found reading about her journey very real and inspiring. We, the readers, follow her as she begins her journey to become an adult, with her own opinions and beliefs that differ from her parents'. This book does a very good job of setting this situation in reality. Ada, who has not previously pushed back against her parents, has to learn how to do that, which she does not do well at first. Ada runs away, disobeys her parents, and lies, but doesn’t get away with any of it. She learns valuable lessons throughout, making her a great role model for YA readers.
Another great aspect of this book is that, while it is a strong topic in political discourse, it’s not political. Instead, it is a book that invites conversation and offers good ways to approach conversations with people, specifically parents, when you don’t agree with them.
Something I also appreciated throughout the book is the idea that goals change and evolve. This is never outright stated in the book or spelled out for the reader, but it is a strong developmental aspect of Ada’s character. She starts off doing the book club for a paper, but then starts developing her own stance on book bans.
I would recommend this book to anyone who wants to explore the issue of book banning further. While this is definitely a book I believe I would have enjoyed more as a sophomore in high school, even as a college student, I can see great themes and had a good time reading this.
Ada is a main character I wish I had growing up. Being a rule-following kid myself, I found reading about her journey very real and inspiring. We, the readers, follow her as she begins her journey to become an adult, with her own opinions and beliefs that differ from her parents'. This book does a very good job of setting this situation in reality. Ada, who has not previously pushed back against her parents, has to learn how to do that, which she does not do well at first. Ada runs away, disobeys her parents, and lies, but doesn’t get away with any of it. She learns valuable lessons throughout, making her a great role model for YA readers.
Another great aspect of this book is that, while it is a strong topic in political discourse, it’s not political. Instead, it is a book that invites conversation and offers good ways to approach conversations with people, specifically parents, when you don’t agree with them.
Something I also appreciated throughout the book is the idea that goals change and evolve. This is never outright stated in the book or spelled out for the reader, but it is a strong developmental aspect of Ada’s character. She starts off doing the book club for a paper, but then starts developing her own stance on book bans.
I would recommend this book to anyone who wants to explore the issue of book banning further. While this is definitely a book I believe I would have enjoyed more as a sophomore in high school, even as a college student, I can see great themes and had a good time reading this.
April 28, 2026
Ada Holloway's Had enough is the story of a young woman trying to figure out what she wants out of life. And in the process of that, has to deal with a book ban jeapordizing her final essay. The book features conflict as Ada's parents don't want her to read a banned book, which creates tension in their household.
The thing that I liked the most about this book are the characters. I loved seeing Ada grow into someone that she wants to be, while making a lot of mistakes along the way. I also like the fact that none of the characters are one sided. There are pieces to them that make them more complex that we get to see as the story progresses. While Ada's mom is opposed to her, she isn't some generic villain out to stop Ada from learning. By the end we get to understand her, and the two manage to communicate about their differences. We get to see this in other characters such as how her brothers or her dad aren't quite who she thought they were in the beginning of the book. Even a character you would assume to be just a stereotypical jock copying homework has a different side to them that we get to see.
I think one thing I took away from this book is how to deal with conflict in a family. This book shows that even when family members disagree, they can still understand each other and come to common ground. It shows that conflict isn't just about proving which side is "right."
I would definitely recommend this book to anyone. It's a young adult book, but I think it's accessible to pretty much anyone. The book is complex enough for adults to enjoy, and it doesn't have any content that wouldn't be appropriate to younger readers. The story explores the topic of book banning, but it doesn't go into depth on the actual content of the banned book. It instead spends time exploring how the characters feel about it and what they want to do to prevent it. It explores the topic in a way that I think is very approachable.
The thing that I liked the most about this book are the characters. I loved seeing Ada grow into someone that she wants to be, while making a lot of mistakes along the way. I also like the fact that none of the characters are one sided. There are pieces to them that make them more complex that we get to see as the story progresses. While Ada's mom is opposed to her, she isn't some generic villain out to stop Ada from learning. By the end we get to understand her, and the two manage to communicate about their differences. We get to see this in other characters such as how her brothers or her dad aren't quite who she thought they were in the beginning of the book. Even a character you would assume to be just a stereotypical jock copying homework has a different side to them that we get to see.
I think one thing I took away from this book is how to deal with conflict in a family. This book shows that even when family members disagree, they can still understand each other and come to common ground. It shows that conflict isn't just about proving which side is "right."
I would definitely recommend this book to anyone. It's a young adult book, but I think it's accessible to pretty much anyone. The book is complex enough for adults to enjoy, and it doesn't have any content that wouldn't be appropriate to younger readers. The story explores the topic of book banning, but it doesn't go into depth on the actual content of the banned book. It instead spends time exploring how the characters feel about it and what they want to do to prevent it. It explores the topic in a way that I think is very approachable.
Read
October 9, 2026Ada Holloway’s Had Enough is a book I wish I had read when I was in middle school. As a lover of books, protecting people’s access to them is very important, and this book speaks very practically about how to do that and why it matters.
Ada Holloway is just an average high school student whose interests and school work have been inhibited by a book ban in her town. The novel follows her journey as she joins a banned book club and fights against a book challenge, culminating in her learning to use her voice for good along the way.
I think this book is an excellent story for middle grade readers. Ada is becoming herself and this story does a nice job of showing how, through stepping into a role she never anticipated, she is able to discover parts of herself that she didn’t know existed. It teaches young girls that doing things that are confusing or difficult can lead to gaining new relationships, new passions, and new opportunities. Also, it accurately and clearly exhibits the processes of a book challenge and teaches students why book bans are harmful, not just to students, but to whole communities. I do think some parts of the story portray stereotypes about the workload and relationships in high school that are not fully accurate. There were some moments when I was skeptical of the arcs of some characters. There were also so MANY characters that I was sometimes confused by who was who. But on the whole, I believe this book is enjoyable for middle grade readers.
As someone who has previously led book clubs for middle school aged kids, this book is perfect for conversations and teaching about book bans, starting from a young age. I did not become aware of book bans until I was older, and this story is a perfect introduction to the reality of book bans that librarians, authors, and readers all face.
Ada Holloway is just an average high school student whose interests and school work have been inhibited by a book ban in her town. The novel follows her journey as she joins a banned book club and fights against a book challenge, culminating in her learning to use her voice for good along the way.
I think this book is an excellent story for middle grade readers. Ada is becoming herself and this story does a nice job of showing how, through stepping into a role she never anticipated, she is able to discover parts of herself that she didn’t know existed. It teaches young girls that doing things that are confusing or difficult can lead to gaining new relationships, new passions, and new opportunities. Also, it accurately and clearly exhibits the processes of a book challenge and teaches students why book bans are harmful, not just to students, but to whole communities. I do think some parts of the story portray stereotypes about the workload and relationships in high school that are not fully accurate. There were some moments when I was skeptical of the arcs of some characters. There were also so MANY characters that I was sometimes confused by who was who. But on the whole, I believe this book is enjoyable for middle grade readers.
As someone who has previously led book clubs for middle school aged kids, this book is perfect for conversations and teaching about book bans, starting from a young age. I did not become aware of book bans until I was older, and this story is a perfect introduction to the reality of book bans that librarians, authors, and readers all face.
October 8, 2026
Ada Holloway’s Had Enough was a very enjoyable read. The ability to experience her character development with her throughout the story was very interesting. She went from a shy girl who didn’t stand up for herself, into a strong leader in her community. She found her voice, earned respect, and inspired change on a major issue. Readers follow Ada as she is assigned to write an essay about her town, an assignment she was looking forward to. Ada decided to write about the town's founder and her main source was a banned book. With motivation to get her paper done, Ada seeks help from her best friend David and cousin Molly to start a secret book club and read the book. Ada learns to take risks and challenge herself to get her essay done, and in the process uncovers a major secret.
While this book is meant for a younger audience than myself, I would say middle school to high school, I still enjoyed reading it. I would recommend it to anyone that wants to know about book banning and negative it can have. My favorite part of this book was slowly seeing Ada’s confidence in herself grow. Between her home life, and people at school, she found ways to overcome her challenges and it was very powerful to read as she made each achievement. I have a lot of respect for Ada because she was able to earn respect from people who weren’t willing to give it to her. She turned a bad situation into a positive change and became a leader in her town.
This book has inspired me. Ada proved that even when every sign points the other direction, you can still change the direction and do what needs to be done. She grew confident in her abilities. That came from her passion. Now, I would love to see where that passion takes her in her future.
While this book is meant for a younger audience than myself, I would say middle school to high school, I still enjoyed reading it. I would recommend it to anyone that wants to know about book banning and negative it can have. My favorite part of this book was slowly seeing Ada’s confidence in herself grow. Between her home life, and people at school, she found ways to overcome her challenges and it was very powerful to read as she made each achievement. I have a lot of respect for Ada because she was able to earn respect from people who weren’t willing to give it to her. She turned a bad situation into a positive change and became a leader in her town.
This book has inspired me. Ada proved that even when every sign points the other direction, you can still change the direction and do what needs to be done. She grew confident in her abilities. That came from her passion. Now, I would love to see where that passion takes her in her future.
October 14, 2026
This book follows the story of Ada Holloway, a senior in high school looking to complete her senior essay for her English class around her town’s founder. However, the book that she needs for her essay is banned in the town’s local library. The story (without spoilers) then progresses into Ada ultimately facing a crisis that is sadly becoming more and more common today: being able to fulfill the right to read and the right to information, regardless of the content within a book.
Overall, I thought this book did a fair job at delivering the message. The storyline and the idea for the book has a great catch, and could be inspiring for younger students that wish to understand the basis of book banning and its harm. I would emphasize the idea of it being directed towards a younger audience rather than high school or college, as with the pacing and the grammar within the book (such as the characterization and how quick certain conflicts were resolved) it could definitely be an enjoyable read for a young adult audience/a more middle grade audience.
I thought that being able to share this message with a younger audience could definitely be beneficial. While young adults may not always fully understand why certain books are banned (for sexual contact or heavy violence purposes), the concept of book banning and restricting material because of different viewpoints is a great lesson for kids to realize that it’s okay for people to think differently. Exposure to different ideas is how people encourage empathy and creativity, rather than polarization and hate towards opposing viewpoints. Again, I would definitely say that this book would be great for a middle school reader, especially one that could be introduced to understanding the basics of book banning.
Overall, I thought this book did a fair job at delivering the message. The storyline and the idea for the book has a great catch, and could be inspiring for younger students that wish to understand the basis of book banning and its harm. I would emphasize the idea of it being directed towards a younger audience rather than high school or college, as with the pacing and the grammar within the book (such as the characterization and how quick certain conflicts were resolved) it could definitely be an enjoyable read for a young adult audience/a more middle grade audience.
I thought that being able to share this message with a younger audience could definitely be beneficial. While young adults may not always fully understand why certain books are banned (for sexual contact or heavy violence purposes), the concept of book banning and restricting material because of different viewpoints is a great lesson for kids to realize that it’s okay for people to think differently. Exposure to different ideas is how people encourage empathy and creativity, rather than polarization and hate towards opposing viewpoints. Again, I would definitely say that this book would be great for a middle school reader, especially one that could be introduced to understanding the basics of book banning.
April 28, 2026
Randi Smith's debut novel "Ada Holloway's Had Enough" is a charming and thought-provoking YA adjacent work centered around high school senior Ada Holloway (as the title implies), a bright student who gets thrusted into a position of activism in her community when the city threatens to enact a large sweeping book ban, including the book she needs to write her essay on the town's founder. In the process, Ada forms a banned book club, challenges the city, and develops a greater personal strength in expressing herself and her morals, particularly with her tense relationship with her mother. The book has a great heart to it and YA story surrounding book bans and taking action, and how our protagonist grows and connects with others in the process of this, was very effective. The introspective and very authentic-feeling POV of Ada and her growth is nice. There are times where the plot feels a bit lackluster in stakes or scope (many chapters with conversations feel slightly redundant or almost aimless) and some of the choice of language feeling generic in some legs. For readers who find YA novels to be their speed, this isn't anything too elevating. But the overall reading experience comes together and has many valuable qualities to it; it would be a good middle school or early high school read, for a young person wanting to get more into reading and discovering the love of books and self-expression. Anyone who would like to have a story centered on young people pushing for positive change in their community and very heartfelt interpersonal character arcs in a nice straightforward little novel can also absolutely take the time to give this a read.
October 15, 2026
Randi Smith’s Ada Holloway’s Had Enough is a story for girls with a heroine mindset but
are unlikely through their timid nature. However, through their fears, they triumph over them and
succeed in standing for what they believe in. In this story, a teen girl Ada Holloway is simply just
trying to get her assignment done when she is hit with a roadblock. The one book she needs to
research is banned from her library. Struck with such a problem, she begins to make efforts to
appeal the books ban with the help of the library staff. Eventually Ada is faced with a test to
outwardly show her faith to the book club, which is what leads her into unexpected aggression.
This shows how deep some people may take book banning and how important it might be for
them in their lives. After the mayor implements a massive book ban doubling down after the
aggression, leads Ada and her friends to create a secret banned book club in order to complete
their assignment which proves her independence she didn’t know she had at the beginning of the
book.
The character growth of Ada herself is really profound in this novel alone. The way she
went from a gentle, people-pleaser to an independent rebel standing up for what she knows is
right really turns the whole book around. I also appreciated how there was no romance, although
you thought she’d have it with Beckett or David the author chose neither for the characters
growth arc which I appreciate. I can see why it is a hard read for some since it is kind of slow,
however the personal growth pays off and the focus on the real issues is what drives the story
and makes it whole to me
are unlikely through their timid nature. However, through their fears, they triumph over them and
succeed in standing for what they believe in. In this story, a teen girl Ada Holloway is simply just
trying to get her assignment done when she is hit with a roadblock. The one book she needs to
research is banned from her library. Struck with such a problem, she begins to make efforts to
appeal the books ban with the help of the library staff. Eventually Ada is faced with a test to
outwardly show her faith to the book club, which is what leads her into unexpected aggression.
This shows how deep some people may take book banning and how important it might be for
them in their lives. After the mayor implements a massive book ban doubling down after the
aggression, leads Ada and her friends to create a secret banned book club in order to complete
their assignment which proves her independence she didn’t know she had at the beginning of the
book.
The character growth of Ada herself is really profound in this novel alone. The way she
went from a gentle, people-pleaser to an independent rebel standing up for what she knows is
right really turns the whole book around. I also appreciated how there was no romance, although
you thought she’d have it with Beckett or David the author chose neither for the characters
growth arc which I appreciate. I can see why it is a hard read for some since it is kind of slow,
however the personal growth pays off and the focus on the real issues is what drives the story
and makes it whole to me
November 20, 2025
I love this book. I'm pretty biased because it was born in my classroom—first as a short story, then as the first 1/3 draft of a novel, and finally, after the author Randi Smith graduated college, I began working with her to complete writing, publish, and now market ADA HOLLOWAY'S HAD ENOUGH.
I care about libraries and families, and to me the library has always been a symbol of love, safety, and education. I went weekly as a child with my family, and my love of reading really bloomed under the care of librarians and their stacks. Seeing them defunded is a travesty, and celebrating the "freedom to read" is something I hope people from all political bents can agree on one day— censorship hurts everyone, and it doesn't help anybody.
Not only does Smiths' debut novel help teens understand what censorship, first amendment rights, and book challenges are, but it does so in a fun way with kids who are just trying to solve their everyday problems. A great younger YA/teen read.
An additional layer is the tension between generations, and seeing how Randi Smith resolves that (treating parents with empathy and showing how teens and their "old people" can communicate and share, without it at all being cheesy) so that the Holloway family can agree to disagree. We need more books that educate without alienating, and one with a secret library book club is my new favorite way to do that!
I care about libraries and families, and to me the library has always been a symbol of love, safety, and education. I went weekly as a child with my family, and my love of reading really bloomed under the care of librarians and their stacks. Seeing them defunded is a travesty, and celebrating the "freedom to read" is something I hope people from all political bents can agree on one day— censorship hurts everyone, and it doesn't help anybody.
Not only does Smiths' debut novel help teens understand what censorship, first amendment rights, and book challenges are, but it does so in a fun way with kids who are just trying to solve their everyday problems. A great younger YA/teen read.
An additional layer is the tension between generations, and seeing how Randi Smith resolves that (treating parents with empathy and showing how teens and their "old people" can communicate and share, without it at all being cheesy) so that the Holloway family can agree to disagree. We need more books that educate without alienating, and one with a secret library book club is my new favorite way to do that!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I really enjoyed reading Ada Holloway's Had Enough. As Ada Holloway navigates all of the typical teenage challenges (school stress, parental pressure, lack of knowledge on career path) it feels like you're literally reading your friend's diary entries.
What I find most unique in this story is how these normal, everyday adolescent problems are connected to larger concerns such as censorship and who has control over history. The entire banned biography plot is incredibly well-written. Who would have thought a senior thesis could evolve into such a powerful voice against the status quo?
Randi Smith also does a fantastic job of incorporating humor, frustration, and heartfelt emotion into Ada's journey, which made me both laugh at her misadventures, and cheer for her growth.
The friendships within the story are authentic and realistic as well. The friendship with her best friend and the chaos associated with her rebellious cousin add warmth and messiness to the story that accurately represent what it is to be a teenager.
My favorite aspect of the story was that it never felt like the author was lecturing me, rather it drew me into Ada's world, allowing me to reflect upon why certain stories are censored and why it is important to fight for the telling of those stories.
If you are either a teenager struggling with all of the challenges that come with being an adolescent or an educator searching for a meaningful story to share with students, I highly recommend this book!
What I find most unique in this story is how these normal, everyday adolescent problems are connected to larger concerns such as censorship and who has control over history. The entire banned biography plot is incredibly well-written. Who would have thought a senior thesis could evolve into such a powerful voice against the status quo?
Randi Smith also does a fantastic job of incorporating humor, frustration, and heartfelt emotion into Ada's journey, which made me both laugh at her misadventures, and cheer for her growth.
The friendships within the story are authentic and realistic as well. The friendship with her best friend and the chaos associated with her rebellious cousin add warmth and messiness to the story that accurately represent what it is to be a teenager.
My favorite aspect of the story was that it never felt like the author was lecturing me, rather it drew me into Ada's world, allowing me to reflect upon why certain stories are censored and why it is important to fight for the telling of those stories.
If you are either a teenager struggling with all of the challenges that come with being an adolescent or an educator searching for a meaningful story to share with students, I highly recommend this book!
April 27, 2026
Ada Holloway Had Enough was something I had not read before when it comes to book banning. I have never experienced books being banned, so this story brought me into a world of what it was like to try to save books just because some people disagree on some books.
Throughout the book, there were some surprising moments that I did not expect, as they did not relate to my personal experience. Some parts were the intense conversations, especially between Ada and her mom, because they really brought my attention towards a real-world problematic situation about book banning. I wish there were more conversations like that between other people throughout the book because it shows different perspectives on what books should or should not be read for different age groups, and makes the reader think about every viewpoint, since it can be so black and white.
I can see middle schoolers reading this book for a class because there’s no foul language or inappropriate scenes, and the level of reading does not seem difficult. Kids who read this in school could relate to Ada because she is also a student trying to get through her school year with an important assignment to do.
For kids who dislike reading, this book could get their attention because the kids I have worked with as a teacher do not like what they are reading. If they like what is banned, then they should be allowed to read them (only if it’s okay with their parents).
Throughout the book, there were some surprising moments that I did not expect, as they did not relate to my personal experience. Some parts were the intense conversations, especially between Ada and her mom, because they really brought my attention towards a real-world problematic situation about book banning. I wish there were more conversations like that between other people throughout the book because it shows different perspectives on what books should or should not be read for different age groups, and makes the reader think about every viewpoint, since it can be so black and white.
I can see middle schoolers reading this book for a class because there’s no foul language or inappropriate scenes, and the level of reading does not seem difficult. Kids who read this in school could relate to Ada because she is also a student trying to get through her school year with an important assignment to do.
For kids who dislike reading, this book could get their attention because the kids I have worked with as a teacher do not like what they are reading. If they like what is banned, then they should be allowed to read them (only if it’s okay with their parents).
March 29, 2026
I was privileged to receive an ARC of this incredible book.
Ada Holloway is a good girl. She's always followed the rules, always done her homework, has always been respectful. The problem is, she doesn't know how to speak her mind or stand up for herself, even when others take advantage of her passive nature. But when a proposed ban on books at the local library threatens to derail plans for her senior essay, she connects with a cousin and some special friends who help her finally find her voice.
Ada is a character that I feel is underrepresented in today's YA fiction. She doesn't possess magical powers, and she's not a survivor of some severe childhood trauma. Instead, she provides a very relatable model for teens (and everyone, for that matter) on how to stand up for what you believe in without alienating those who may disagree. She's the perfect example of a teen struggling to figure out who they are and how to take a stand while caught in that no man's land between childhood and young adulthood. The way Ada handles conflict with those around her (especially her mother) is a realistic example of how teens can make mistakes, disagree, and still maintain connections with the people they care about. This book teaches teens that it's important to stand up for what you believe in, but you don't have to have super powers (or be a villain) to do it.
Ada Holloway is a good girl. She's always followed the rules, always done her homework, has always been respectful. The problem is, she doesn't know how to speak her mind or stand up for herself, even when others take advantage of her passive nature. But when a proposed ban on books at the local library threatens to derail plans for her senior essay, she connects with a cousin and some special friends who help her finally find her voice.
Ada is a character that I feel is underrepresented in today's YA fiction. She doesn't possess magical powers, and she's not a survivor of some severe childhood trauma. Instead, she provides a very relatable model for teens (and everyone, for that matter) on how to stand up for what you believe in without alienating those who may disagree. She's the perfect example of a teen struggling to figure out who they are and how to take a stand while caught in that no man's land between childhood and young adulthood. The way Ada handles conflict with those around her (especially her mother) is a realistic example of how teens can make mistakes, disagree, and still maintain connections with the people they care about. This book teaches teens that it's important to stand up for what you believe in, but you don't have to have super powers (or be a villain) to do it.
April 28, 2026
Ada Holloway’s Had Enough is a timely and important book for our time. Written as a Young Adult novel, the book covers many important topics for young readers. However, beyond its intended audience, it is also widely relevant and suitable for all ages. Book banning in the US affects thousands of books every year. With low thresholds and barriers for book challenges, individuals and organized groups can challenge books for almost any reason, leading to committees reviewing them and potentially removing them from library and retail shelves. This is a serious threat to readers’, authors’ and publishers’ first amendment rights. In AHHE, Randi Smith utilizes a story of a teenager who needs to write an essay but can’t access the books and materials she needs for it, in order o shed light on this important issue. The book allows readers to understand the circumstances of book banning in a digestible and accessible way. She also sheds light on personal growth and development as Ada navigates standing up and speaking up for herself as she matures into adulthood. While the book addresses issues that are relevant to all ages, I personally would’ve loved for it to be written for a more mature audience (since I am personally outside the YA demographic), though I understand it was intended to be a YA novel!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 50 reviews