Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

A Good Puck

Rate this book
It was just supposed to be one night. Just a good puck to forget all about the stress of her upcoming hockey game…

Charlie Lajoie is no stranger to hard work. One of the best players in the PWHL for the Toronto Succubi and the daughter of one of the best hockey players in the world, there’s a lot of pressure for her to succeed on Team Canada in the Milan Winter Games.

When Olive Miller is unceremoniously dumped by her girlfriend before their big Italy vacation, she decides to go on it alone to finally get the long-awaited break from work she so desperately needs.

A night of rest and relaxation is what both women need, and who better to turn to than a fellow Torontonian in Italy? What starts as one night to release some stress quickly turns into more as Charlie can’t help but fall for Olive. But can their whirlwind fling go from a good puck to lasting an entire season?

From cozy sapphic author Rochelle Wolf comes a new hockey romance full of high heat and low stakes.

A Good Puck is part of the Love On The Podium shared queer romance series.

139 pages, Kindle Edition

Published January 26, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Rochelle Wolf

13 books71 followers
Rochelle Wolf is a Toronto-based queer writer, interested in warm love stories and books that feel like a hug. They have perfected the art of making their special interest (books) their entire career. Formerly a librarian, they now run their own book editing business. When they’re not reading or writing, they enjoy watching reality TV shows and traveling. To learn more, please visit their website, www.rochellewolf.com.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
42 (15%)
4 stars
103 (37%)
3 stars
83 (30%)
2 stars
34 (12%)
1 star
10 (3%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 117 reviews
Profile Image for phoenix *ੈ✩‧₊˚.
397 reviews117 followers
September 10, 2026
3.5 ⭐️

This was my second book by Rochelle Wolf, and I enjoyed this one as well. Charlie and Olive had great chemistry, and I really liked their dynamic together. The romance was sweet and the spice was definitely well written. I had a great time with it.

However, I wish this had more depth. There were some interesting things going on with both characters, but I would have loved to explore those parts more. The story is fairly short, so everything moves along quickly, which worked for the lighthearted romance but left me wanting more emotional development.

Overall, this was a cute sapphic hockey romance with plenty of spice and good chemistry. It didn’t blow me away, but I enjoyed my time with it and would happily pick up another book from the author.
Profile Image for Kelly.
554 reviews41 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
December 26, 2025
4⭐️ 4🌶

A perfect winter novella, this cute Olympic themed tale is heavy on the spice. If you like the Olympics and will be watching the games in a few short weeks then this is a great appetizer before they start.

Charlie plays for the Canadian women's hockey team. Olive is on vacation in Italy trying to get over an abrupt breakup.

Each FMC is working through their own issues regarding boundaries and relationships. Although, their chemistry is off the charts. Will they trust the attraction or will they fall into old habits. Can you build a solid relationship based on sexual compatibility? Certainly doesn't hurt to try😉 I can't wait to read the other books in this sports series.

I received an advanced copy for an honest review.
Profile Image for Nicole.
525 reviews68 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
January 4, 2026
A Good Puck by Rochelle Wolf is a romping good time in Milan. Two Canadians meet by chance in Italy. Charlie is a hockey player in town for the Olympics, and Olive is on the vacation she was supposed to be taking with her girlfriend. Said girlfriend broke up with her just before the trip, but her sister convinced her to go anyway.
The two hit it off immediately and spend a steamy night together. They both decide to continue seeing one another while they are in Milan. As they get to know each other, they consider the idea of continuing the relationship when they return to Toronto.
There are several spicy scenes and some sweet bonding moments. Gender identity and career paths are discussed as they grow closer.
Both main characters have distinct, likable personalities, making them easy to root for.
I enjoyed this short, sweet, and spicy sports-themed sapphic romance. It is one of my favorites by Wolf. I am giving it 3.75 stars, rounded up.
#Milan #Italy #Toronto #Canada #oppositesattract #vacationromance #onenighttoforever #Olympics #hockey #mascfemme #nonbinaryrep #strapscenes #vibescenes #facesitting #steamy #spicy #sweet #genderexploration #HEA #epilogue
I received an ARC from the author. This is my honest opinion.
Profile Image for MJ.
539 reviews150 followers
October 11, 2026
I enjoyed that! It was a nice short story and the audiobook was well done as well. Had some great rep and the spicy scenes were very good!! 🔥

Written in Third Person with 2x POV’s. Narrated by Robin Amanda and Ann Dahlia. Starting Over
Vacation, Sports: Ice Hockey, One Night to Forever, Self Discovery, Short & Spicy, Non Binary Rep. 4x Spicy Scenes.
Profile Image for Bee.
143 reviews46 followers
August 26, 2026
3.5 stars for me. 🎀

This was a very sweet, fluffy, smutty lesbian love story that I greatly enjoyed. I'm so glad that lesbians are getting the tastefully corny and adorable representation we deserve.

I will definitely be recommending this one to my friends who will enjoy this short, heartwarming book.

Thank you to Netgalley for letting me listen to the audiobook version. I definitely recommend listening to/reading this one in private!
Profile Image for Brittany.
391 reviews8 followers
September 4, 2026
ALC from NetGalley

This steamy novella had some great spice and the beginning of a sweet relationship. This book is short so you quickly get to a spicy scene that didn't feel awkward and actually made me blush. Something that surprised me was that it had more of the sport than other sports romances I read. I would definitely recommend this to anyone who likes spicy hockey romance.
Profile Image for szreads.
399 reviews24 followers
January 5, 2026
Perfect for the Olympics!! Or just as a spicy queer winter novella!!

The story centres on Olive 29 who is broken up with before her trip to Milan, and Charlie 27 Team Canada hockey player, who also plays in the PWHL.

This book was spicier than anticipated with 4 sex scenes.

Notes:
- Consent 👏🏻
- Strap on used
- discussions on gender

Charlie being superstitious as a hockey player is so on brand. The chocolate muffin and cardboard bed references made me giggle.

Could the story have been flushed out more? Yes. It’s a novella tho so go in with that in mind.

Thank you to the author for the ARC!
Profile Image for Rhys.
278 reviews163 followers
December 24, 2025
I received an ARC copy from the author.

This was EVERYTHING I had hoped for! 😭🙂‍↕️

When Rochelle Wolf says high spice, they mean HIGH SPICE 😌

This was such a great novella with a sapphic romance AND a gender awakening. If you love hockey, and you want a sapphic romance with a nonbinary MC, definitely have this on your list for January!!

Also absolutely loved that it’s set at the 2026 Winter Olympics. I’m SO excited for Olympic hockey again, especially the women’s hockey 🙂‍↕️
Profile Image for Ivy.
470 reviews46 followers
January 2, 2026
When in the midst of Heated Rivalry psychosis, it’s ideal to continue with as much queer hockey romance as possible. Thanks to Olive and Charlie, I was able to continue my obsession with a sapphic hockey romance, and I was rewarded with the winter extension of femme top fall.

Rochelle Wolff promises low stakes, but that doesn’t mean there’s not depth here. Olive and Charlie both have so much heart—Olive is constantly undervalued for hers, while Charlie rarely lets anyone see theirs. Together, they bring out the best in one another and create a safe space during a whirlwind romance in a foreign country, capping off their time with a gender awakening and opening the door to a future relationship that we luckily see on the page in the epilogue.

A Good Puck—come for the strap, stay for the swoon.
Profile Image for Heather MMRomanceReviewed.
1,853 reviews109 followers
Read
January 26, 2026
I had a great time reading this fairly short novel set in Milan during the upcoming Olympics, especially since they have a hometown connection for me, as both characters reside in Toronto when they aren't jetting off to Milan for vacation or the Olympics! I enjoyed their meet-cute and the way their relationship progressed from vacation fling...

I did struggle with the fact that Olive was in Milan for a 'regular' vacation during the Olympics and I would have liked to see more about Charlie's revelations, but as a quick and sporty read, this definitely put me in the mood to watch more women's hockey at the Olympics! I can't wait to see what's up next for this multi-author series!
Profile Image for Emily .
552 reviews2 followers
August 26, 2026
3.5 rounded up - what a fun spicy time!

This is a sapphic hockey romance set with an Olympic backdrop. You have Charlie, a hockey player, who ends up at the same place as Olive, who is fresh off a break up and ready for a distraction.

There isn't a ton more plot wise to this one, but I'm not sure there needs to be with how short it is. It's mainly spice, but well written and with lots of good banter and cute dialogue in between.

I thought the subplot given to each character was good for making them more well-rounded as characters, and made their romance and relationship together feel a lot more earned. It just generally made the whole story feel well thought out.

The two narrators were top tier in their narration of the two characters. Both Robin Amanda and Ann Dahlia worked hard to make the characters relationship audible... in more ways than one.

Thank you so much to Victoria Editing NetGalley Co-op/Aurora Inkwell Media, NetGalley, Robin Amanda, Ann Dahlia, and Rochelle Wolf for an ALC of this one!
Profile Image for Adri.
238 reviews8 followers
August 22, 2026
Rating: 3.75 ⭐️
Spice: 4 🌶️

Read if you like:
Sapphic Romance
Hockey Player MC
Reluctant Lovers

Things heat up quickly between Charlie and Olive, what’s supposed to be a one night fling leaves them both wanting more.

Both of them have reasons that keep them from going all in. Their hesitancy might be around a relationship but things definitely heat up in different areas.

Charlie being a pro athlete has a lot on their shoulders, not to mention the underlying pressure from family expectations.

Olive might have just been dumped but she’s not as heartbroken as one would expect. Still she has people relying on her, and her own underlying spirals that keep her wanting more for herself and life.

I wish we got more!! I would read another book about them after this.

If you like short and spicy sapphic reads this is one you check out!!
Profile Image for Anna.
2,244 reviews370 followers
September 10, 2026
Eh. If you want a book that's 70% smut, this is the one for you.

There is so little substance in this book that one of the main characters who is on vacation in Italy to get away from her demanding job, we never even find out what her job is. Like are you kidding me? Then the other main character is like this famous hockey player who's playing in the Olympics and they meet up at a bar and have one night stand that turns into more.

I just would like some character plot points is that too much to ask? Even the sex was repetitive and boring. Like I'm so over it. Move on give me some substance. I don't know whatever I think that I need to not read this author anymore cuz they have another book that I absolutely hated and I didn't even realize it was the same author until I was about halfway through.
Profile Image for Mandi.
582 reviews12 followers
August 22, 2026
This was entertaining but nothing groundbreaking, in my opinion.

For me it was too much smut and not enough plot, sadly.

I also think the characters felt one-dimensional and lacked the depth I needed them to have.

I love hockey and as much as I love the Canada Women's Hockey Team, the USA team won gold in the last Olympics (which is the event being depicted in this book) and as a hockey fan I just couldn't get behind that being re-written😭

I also didn't appreciate the perpetuation of the stereotype of who watches women's sports.

Thanks Netgalley, Victory Editing NetGalley Co-op, Aurora Inkwell Media and Rochelle Wolf for giving me access to the ALC in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Kaela.
209 reviews
January 15, 2026
4.5⭐️

UGH I LOVE SAPPHIC ROMANCES!!!! ESPECIALLY SAPPHIC HOCKEY ROMANCES!!!! THIS WAS SO GOOD!!! for a novella so short, the development of olive and charlie as characters and their relationship was soo well done. i appreciated the pacing of the story and the relationship, i appreciated olive and charlie’s realizations about themselves as individuals and who they have been in past relationships so they can grow, and i appreciated the sweet and supportive conversations about gender.

this book is just so fun and sweet and smutty, i guarantee you’ll giggle and twirl your hair the entire time. thank you so much to the author for allowing me to have an arc!!
4 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
December 31, 2025
Review from ARC received from author.

first off, thank you very much to the author for extending an ARC of this book! In exchange for the ARC, this is my honest review.

A Good Puck is a sweet and sexy read featuring a woman who's on the rebound after a breakup and a hockey player on a journey of going after what they want and who they truly are.

Overall, the book is fun, smart and warm. However, I struggled with with it at times. The journeys the characters go through are sometimes inconsistent and contradictory, which makes the book feel a little incoherent at times.

Characters feel like they are going in one direction, only for their journeys to be switched up at the last minute.

To that point, while I am a huge fan of the way the couple end the book (a sweet but not rushed ending), the journey taken by the characters feel a little obsolete if things were going to end that way.

I did very much enjoy the breeziness of the book, so let me explore what i enjoyed.

The characters have great chemistry and it's clear from the get-go that they're a great pairing. The spice is pretty well done! When the author says, "high spice", they definitely meant it!

the side characters were great too! I enjoyed the world that was built with these characters. and the pacing was also quite well done too!

overall, I did enjoy it. I just wished some parts had been more articulate and there was a clear common thread for characters. but 3/5 for a fun, sexy and warm romance!
Profile Image for Star.
788 reviews285 followers
September 9, 2026
Not exactly sure how I feel about this one.
There was a lot more smut than I was expecting for something so short.
I think I was expecting a bit more depth to this one, even though it is a novella.
There were some parts of this book that didn't sit right with me, but that is a me thing.
For a sports romance, this was pretty okay!


Rep: cis white lesbian MC, vaguely gender questioning/enby MC (can't remember their sexuality) who uses she/they pronouns (only at the end of the book)
Profile Image for Michaela Jancarova.
31 reviews
October 20, 2026
thank you NetGalley for the copy

this was my first book/novella from Rochelle Wolf - it was very fluffy, cute and also very spicy. liked that even though it was short it had a good balance of romance, plot, sports and spice.
it is a nice read, if you want to read something short and sweet with a happy ending.
Profile Image for Aster.
385 reviews176 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
January 23, 2026
I think me giving 3 stars is maybe a bit too high for this book. There's something so off with the writing and/or editing of A Good Puck that it distracted me throughout the whole book. Not only it's very simplistic but it just doesn't flow well together. But overall I found that it lacked substance, cramming that many sex scenes when they don't really help character/relationship development is a miss for me.
Profile Image for Arcadia Barrile.
122 reviews26 followers
August 25, 2026
Thank you to Victory Editing for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.

This novella, which I listened to as an audiobook, is set during the 2026 Winter Olympics in Milan, and follows Olive and Charlie. Olive has just been dumped and is unexpectedly alone on the vacation she and her ex had planned on taking together, and Charlie is in Italy to compete in the Olympics on the Canadian women’s hockey team. This is an open door sapphic romance written by an Own Voices author (nonbinary and queer, I believe), and has a lot of spice.

Both of the MCs were very lovable and fun to read about, but Charlie was definitely my favorite. Their romance was very sweet, and it was super refreshing to read a mostly healthy, supportive romance plot where miscommunication wasn’t used as plot fodder and the two characters genuinely seemed to like and respect each other. They were both very supportive and made sure that they always had consent and everyone was comfortable and having a good time, both during sex and over the progression of their romantic relationship. I also really liked that the author didn’t go with the stereotypical experienced masc/shy femme. Olive was definitely the more experienced and confident of the pair.

As a hockey fan, it was awesome to see the PWHL rep in this story! That said, hockey nerds like myself will probably notice that there were some aspects of the story that will require you to forget some of the things you know about hockey and just enjoy the romance (for example, at one point Charlie is assessed a penalty for fighting rather than a game misconduct and ejection, which is what the Olympic rules would have called for). Nothing huge, though.

As far as the narration went, I thought that both of the narrators were very good. The one that read Charlie’s POV had absolutely the perfect voice for the character, in my opinion. The only issue I had was the voice that the other narrator used for Olive’s sister, which I found extremely obnoxious and took me out of the story a little bit. Thankfully, Olive’s sister doesn’t have too many lines so it didn’t happen very frequently. The pacing was great, and the different narrators really helped to differentiate the dual POVs for me.

This was a quick, enjoyable read that I would recommend to anyone who enjoys sapphic sports/contemporary romance, especially for fans of hockey. It’s short and sweet, the perfect way to spend some of the few remaining days before the beginning of hockey season if you’re as excited about that as I am!

SLIGHT SPOILERS PAST THIS POINT

My biggest issue with this story was that, about 75% of the way through, Olive asks Charlie out of the blue about their gender identity and Charlie says that they’re nonbinary. I love the nonbinary representation, but I felt like this scene came out of nowhere, especially since half of the novella is from Charlie’s POV. I really wish there had been more exploration of Charlie’s gender identity throughout the story so that this revelation felt more natural. I feel like it was a good fit for the character, just not really revealed through their narrative as much as I would have liked. It also didn’t really make sense to me that Charlie was worried about coming out as nonbinary while playing in the PWHL, seeing as there are out nonbinary players in the league both in real life and in the story. I did end up taking one star off due to how awkward this aspect felt for me, but I still really liked the book.
Profile Image for Jamie (Books and Ladders).
1,500 reviews209 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
January 3, 2026
See this review and more on Books and Ladders!

Content Warnings: gender dysphoria, ending of relationship, on-screen sexual activities

Disclaimer: I received a free copy of this book from the author in exchange for an honest review. As always, my thoughts and opinions are entirely my own.

Rating: 4.5/5, rounded up

This was so cute and spicy! I was in between squealing and fanning myself with every new chapter. This isn't going to give you a detailed insider's look into women's hockey culture, but it's definitely going to give you a sweet, compelling story about finding yourself when you least expect it.

I loved the change up between the POVs and seeing how Charlie and Olive each dealt with their inner emotions and feelings towards themselves and each other. There was a lot of great communication, especially in terms of consent during the spicy scenes, that led to a really enjoyable and thoughtful read. Which doesn't typically seem like the case when you're reading this type of novel.

I liked Charlie's POV better than Olive's as Charlie explored what it meant to be who they are, how "luck" plays into the opportunities you are provided, and what it means to be passionate and fully invested in something. I really liked her growth throughout and a lot of care and heart was put into Charlie's story. Olive is still a great character and I appreciated her taking a chance on herself and love by being with Charlie and going on a solo trip to Italy. Together, they are perfect for balancing one another out.

Because this is a novella, I don't think we got as much emotional pay-off as I would have liked from the conversation about gender exploration (Charlie) and being emotionally closed off (Olive). It still was great to have on-page and be so embraced by themselves and each other. The support they gave one another was very touching and I really appreciated seeing softness within this romance.

I also wanted so much more from the scene where .

However, the length was perfect for what felt like a whirlwind romance and getaway, leading to me already planning on a reread once the Team Canada women's team wins gold at the Olympics this year.

This was a sweet, enjoyable story about two people finding themselves and each other as they navigate big stressors that lead them to come together.

Pick this one up on January 26, 2026! (Please) (Then also watch the Olympics) (And the PWHL)

Favourite Quote: “The fact that she even knows what the PWHL is means she’s gay,” Blake pointed out matter-of-factly.

Like my reviews? Buy me a Ko-Fi!
Profile Image for Connie (Rain Check and Read).
140 reviews58 followers
September 27, 2026
🏒 OVERALL THOUGHTS

A Good Puck was a sweet, fluffy sapphic hockey romance, and I especially loved seeing that representation within the world of Olympic hockey. There was something refreshing about getting a queer love story in that setting, and this was an easy, feel-good read.

💕 ROMANCE

The romance was very sweet, but I found myself wanting a little more connection, depth, and chemistry between Charlie and Olive. Because this is a novella, their relationship develops pretty quickly, and I would have loved more conversations, vulnerability, and little moments that showed me why these two were falling for each other.

Olive was understandably more guarded because of her previous relationship. However, because that relationship had ended so recently, it felt like there was still quite a bit of emotional baggage hanging over the new romance. I think that ultimately contributed to the story ending with more of a happy-for-now rather than the happily-ever-after I was hoping for.

🌈 CHARACTERS & REPRESENTATION

Charlie was definitely my favorite character. I loved their honesty and the self-discovery they were navigating throughout the story. There was a vulnerability to their journey that felt genuine, and I really enjoyed watching them become more comfortable understanding and expressing who they are.

I also really appreciated the sapphic and queer representation, particularly within Olympic hockey. That setting made the representation feel especially meaningful and was one of my favorite aspects of the novella.

✨ FINAL THOUGHTS

This is definitely one for readers looking for something short, low-angst, sweet, and fluffy. I enjoyed my time with Charlie and Olive, but I think I would have connected with their romance much more if the story had been longer and given them additional space to develop emotionally.

And selfishly? I wanted that HEA! Give me the epilogue. Give me Charlie and Olive down the road. I wanted to close the book knowing these two had truly made it. 💕

TROPES & VIBES

🏒 Sapphic hockey romance
🏅 Olympic athletes
🌈 Queer representation
💕 Sweet & fluffy
🫶 Self-discovery
💔 Recently ended relationship
🌱 Emotional healing
✨ Low angst
📖 Novella
💗 Happy-for-now
Profile Image for Jennifer MD Cox.
Author 1 book6 followers
February 17, 2026
I was honored to be an ARC reader for this novella and I have nothing but praise for this one.

I've been reading Wolf novellas since their debut with "Act Two." In that ARC review specifically I recall writing something along the lines of, "I can't wait to follow this author and see how they grow." That review came to mind for me as I was reading this one, because I felt like I was seeing Wolf's hard work and growth shine through the pages in a whole new light. Through the second-chances, the friend-to-lover, the gender-discoveries, and now to sports romance, there is one thing that has been consistently growing stronger and stronger: Mx. Wolf's ability to bring the reader into the chemistry of the moment. And "A Good Puck" is the strongest writing yet.

Mx. Wolf's novellas are helping me heal my relationship with the romance genre in general. (Y'know, my internal misogyny "I'm-not-like-other-girls" combined with my attachment wounds, combined into a big "reading other people kissing makes me feel both amazing and terrible" sensation.) I can solidly say with certainty that this is the first time I have read a romance novella - and a spicy one at that - and been not only completely comfortable, but excited and focused. I didn't need "a more important plot" to distract me from my discomfort or to "justify" the characters' affections for each other. I was completely content - more than content, really - to read about these two individuals growing their affection and libido for each other.

The spice? You'll melt. The characters? You'll want to coddle. The setting? Just exciting enough. But what's the most important and exciting for me? Mx. Wolf's narrative voice is stronger than ever. No hesitations, no lack of belief in themselves as a storyteller, no holding back.

(Okay, only one nitpick. I would have loved for Olive to chew out her ex a little more. But that's literally my only nitpick.)

Do not skip this novella if you're looking for good heartwarming feelings with beautiful sensuality. Sometimes, reading about a relationship going right in exceptional circumstances is such a healing thing.
Profile Image for Romantic.Rainbow.Reads.
187 reviews10 followers
September 11, 2026
Charlie is in Milan to play hockey for Team Canada, while Olive is there alone during what was supposed to be a romantic vacation with her now-ex-girlfriend. The two women are enjoying an Italian fling but are left wondering whether their relationship can survive when they are back in their real lives in Toronto.

The blurb on the book promised high heat and low stakes, and it definitely delivered that. I actually wish there were fewer spicy scenes so certain aspects of the plot could be explored more deeply. Charlie is struggling with comparisons to her famous father and a public perception that says her success is based on luck rather than earned. Olive went through a recent break up and is trying to decide what she wants for her future, in her career and more broadly. However, none of those topics were explored in depth. This is a novella, so I understand that there are constraints. I think perhaps the book was trying to do too much given its length.

Charlie is non-binary and I appreciated seeing non-binary representation. The author is non-binary as well! Charlie’s experience with gender isn’t a major part of the plot. Books that explore a character’s journey with gender in depth are valuable, but I think it is also valuable to have books where a character’s non-binary identity is just one facet of who they are.

I did struggle with the writing on a sentence and word choice level. The writing felt clunky, stilted and too formal. That was especially apparent to me during spicy scenes in a way I found distracting. Hearing a *toy* described as a “device” really took me out of it.

There were two narrators for the audiobook and each character had a distinctive voice, so it was easy to tell Olive and Charlie apart.

Highlights:
- non-binary protagonist
- Olympic setting
- written by a non-binary author
- low angst, high spice
- novella (~3 hours)
Profile Image for Jeimy.
5,932 reviews31 followers
August 23, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley for the ALC of this novella, published earlier this year. Robin Amanda and Ann Dahlia do a good job bringing Charlie and Olive to life, particularly because the two women approach their relationship from very different places. I loved that Charlie, the masc who is still figuring out her relationship with gender, is the one who more readily admits that they caught feelings. I also appreciated how, once Charlie's gender identity comes into the conversation, Wolf seamlessly moves between she and they pronouns when referring to Charlie. It feels natural and nicely reflects where Charlie is in figuring out what feels right.

Meanwhile, Olive knows exactly what she wants from a sexual partner and is self-aware enough to recognize that, at this point in her life, she isn't looking for anything more. And there is a lot of sex. Beyond Charlie's desire to win Olympic gold and the, albeit minimal, hockey surrounding that goal, there isn't much plot holding the encounters together. This felt like a sapphic Heated Rivalry, except the novella format and the fact that it takes place in just a few days gives Charlie and Olive even less time to develop the emotional connection that might have made their transition from hookup to something more convincing. And, alas, no one gets invited to the cottage.

There was also one detail my suspension of disbelief simply couldn't survive:

If high spice and minimal plot are what you're looking for, this may be for you. I had fun with parts of it, but ultimately I needed more from the story (and from the relationship).
Profile Image for SullenSapphic.
174 reviews8 followers
September 3, 2026
Spice Level: 4/5 Explicit Open-Door

Not only is Charlie Lajoie one of the best players in the PWHL, but she is also on Canada’s national hockey team. Charlie, along with the rest of Team Canada, is in Italy for the Milan Winter Games. She needs a night off to relax and maybe to blow off a little steam and just so happens to find a fellow Torontonian to turn to.

Olive Miller was dumped by her girlfriend right before their trip to Milan, Italy. Out at a bar, she is runs into a fellow Torontonian that she would be more than happy to release some stress with. Will this be a one-night stand? Will their explorations lead to more?

I received this audiobook from NetGalley and the Author in return for my honest review. This audiobook starts out of the gate on fire. The author says this is a spicy book and it is spi-cy. However, for me, the scenes feel a little forced. The main characters lacked connection. That feeling, for me, lasted throughout most of the book. You didn’t feel a real connection with the characters pretty much until the end of the book. So, for me, even though there was a ton of spicy scenes, they were lackluster due to the lack of connection.

Where I do feel this book is successful is the identification and handling of the gender dysphoria that one of the characters is going through. It is handled with love, and it shows that the author approaches the subject with care.

Robin Amanda and Ann Dahlia are the narrators for this audiobook. I felt that they were great choices for the characters.

🏒 Hockey Romance
🏒 One Night Stand
🏒 Sapphic Romance
🏒 High Spice
🏒 One Night to Forever
🏒 Secret Relationship
🏒 Gender Awakening
🏒 Gender Dysphoria
🏒 HEA
Profile Image for Yessie.
6 reviews104 followers
September 8, 2026
As a lover of hockey romance and a queer woman, I had high expectations for my first spicy, sapphic sports romance read; however, this unfortunately came up short for me. While a fast-paced and spicy novella, I found that inconsistencies in the narration and language in the text were abundant and left the story falling flat. In no particular order: the room is alternately called a hotel and an apartment to describe the same space, gender/pronoun mismatches between they/them and she/her when describing a character, and language to describe sex toys and sexual activities between AFAB characters feeling sterile or clinical and impersonal.

The story felt rushed with very little time for depth and development of the amount of character growth the author was trying to accomplish. Additionally, the hockey scenes felt like an afterthought with it not really adding to the story. Finally, the design around the Olympics/Olympic village and the means of getting the characters to get together requires some suspension of disbelief. For an 'insta-love' type story, this isn't altogether a bad thing, but I expected a little more cohesion in my sports to go with my romance.

Most dual POV audiobooks in my experience feel more like the narrators embracing the characters they are narrating, whereas this felt more like two women simply reading a book out loud. I think I would have enjoyed this story more in its original written form, but it was ultimately an enjoyable, fast, and easy listen.

Thank you to NetGalley and the author for providing this ALC in exchange for a honest review; I will be giving additional works by the author a second chance in their original written format!
Profile Image for Maven_Reads.
2,092 reviews27 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
January 22, 2026
A Good Puck by Rochelle Wolf

A Good Puck is a spicy sapphic hockey romance novella where Charlie Lajoie, a star player for the Toronto Succubi striving to make Team Canada for the Milan Winter Games, has one night off the ice that leads her straight into the arms of Olive Miller, a woman newly single and craving a break from her own stresses. What begins as a carefree rendezvous in Italy quickly deepens into something that complicates both women’s expectations, blending sweet flirtation with the thrill of falling for someone unexpected against a backdrop of shared hometown roots and athletic ambition. The story is part of the Love On The Podium queer romance series and offers a cozy, low-stakes yet emotionally engaging read.

I liked how naturally the chemistry between Charlie and Olive arose, making me care about their tentative steps toward something real beyond one night, and how their individual pressures (family, performance expectations, self-discovery) gave emotional weight to their connection. While it leans short and breezy, the warmth and tender exploration of attraction and vulnerability left me smiling long after the final page.

Rating: 4 out of 5
Because it balances heartfelt sapphic romance with tender character moments in a delightfully intimate hockey setting.
5 reviews
August 24, 2026
This was a quick read - and maybe not one that I should have been listening to in the Costco self checkout line on a Sunday. There was a LOT of spice, and it started very early on with the potential one-night stand turned more.

The character development didn’t go deep, but was able to give enough of a background as to why both Olive and Charlie approached life in the way that they did. I would have loved to know a bit more about Charlie’s relationship with her dad, the dynamic between Olive and her family, the friendship with Blake, the woman that dumped Olive, Charlie’s gender journey, etc.

There was a lot that could have been detailed further, but I almost appreciate that this book skates (see what I did there?) right past it and focused on two people just hooking up. When you’re just fooling around with someone, there isn’t time to get into everything and the book really echoes that.

I really enjoyed the dual narration, especially the way that once gender is questioned, different pronouns are used. It wasn’t a huge conversation, but I noticed the switch immediately, which probably means that Charlie did too.

Epilogue was super cute. Great end to the book, because it only made we want more of these two! That’s to NetGalley and the author for access to the audiobook for an honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 117 reviews