What do you think?
Rate this book
Triple Overtime #1
Puck Me Thrice
Mira doesn't expect to fall for all three of her impossibly hot, antagonistic roommates… or discover they're willing to share her rather than make her choose.
When my figure skating partner destroys my Olympic dreams for another woman, I never expect to find salvation in a house full of hockey players who hate everything about my sport.
A clerical error forces me into their house, straight into a world of early morning collisions with shirtless athletes, testosterone-fueled arguments, and more romantic tension than my innocent heart knows how to handle.
As their new performance coach, I'm supposed to maintain professional boundaries. Instead, I'm drowning in the proximity to three very different men who awaken parts of me I've kept frozen.
Blake looks like he could kill someone with his bare hands but treats me like I'm made of spun glass, his gentle giant soul recognizing a fellow caretaker who's never learned to accept care.
Nolan commands the ice like he was born to lead, but beneath his grumpy captain facade beats a heart that chooses me over his father's legacy.
Logan's golden retriever energy masks anxiety that mirrors my own perfectionism, his overthinking brain finding peace only when we're together.
They go from trying to run me out to fighting sophomore players who dare to look at me wrong.
These men fight for me like I'm worth an entire team, proving that found family doesn't follow conventional rules.
They compete for my attention with home-cooked meals, and protective instincts that make my exes' control look like indifference.
When they discover I've been fantasizing about all three of them, when they admit they're willing to share rather than make me choose, I realize this enemies to lovers story was never about choosing sides.
So maybe I'm falling for all three of my roommates. Sue me. At least this time, when I fall, I know they'll catch me.
When my figure skating partner destroys my Olympic dreams for another woman, I never expect to find salvation in a house full of hockey players who hate everything about my sport.
A clerical error forces me into their house, straight into a world of early morning collisions with shirtless athletes, testosterone-fueled arguments, and more romantic tension than my innocent heart knows how to handle.
As their new performance coach, I'm supposed to maintain professional boundaries. Instead, I'm drowning in the proximity to three very different men who awaken parts of me I've kept frozen.
Blake looks like he could kill someone with his bare hands but treats me like I'm made of spun glass, his gentle giant soul recognizing a fellow caretaker who's never learned to accept care.
Nolan commands the ice like he was born to lead, but beneath his grumpy captain facade beats a heart that chooses me over his father's legacy.
Logan's golden retriever energy masks anxiety that mirrors my own perfectionism, his overthinking brain finding peace only when we're together.
They go from trying to run me out to fighting sophomore players who dare to look at me wrong.
These men fight for me like I'm worth an entire team, proving that found family doesn't follow conventional rules.
They compete for my attention with home-cooked meals, and protective instincts that make my exes' control look like indifference.
When they discover I've been fantasizing about all three of them, when they admit they're willing to share rather than make me choose, I realize this enemies to lovers story was never about choosing sides.
So maybe I'm falling for all three of my roommates. Sue me. At least this time, when I fall, I know they'll catch me.
222 pages, Kindle Edition
Published November 28, 2025
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 10 of 10 reviews
June 14, 2026
I was really confused how this girl had so much liberty regularly jumping onto the ice, how she was coaching as a student and literally never attending classes, barely practicing her routines… none of it really made realistic sense. By the end of the book it was unclear if she was even a student or an employee? She’s also been published in respected journals yet is going enough to be in competition for the Olympics?
Also are they in a separate house or a dorm? I thought it was a house but then the RA lets his dad into his house? That makes no sense.
And an eating disorder that pops up after 90%?? Honestly didn’t notice any sign of control or eating/stress difficulties leading up to this. Just out of the blue. First time a therapist is mentioned.
I liked the characters themselves fine enough. Not sure there was really a plot happening but 🤷♀️ it was fine
Also are they in a separate house or a dorm? I thought it was a house but then the RA lets his dad into his house? That makes no sense.
And an eating disorder that pops up after 90%?? Honestly didn’t notice any sign of control or eating/stress difficulties leading up to this. Just out of the blue. First time a therapist is mentioned.
I liked the characters themselves fine enough. Not sure there was really a plot happening but 🤷♀️ it was fine
March 6, 2026
I love everything about this I love how they put anxiety and mental health I love that the author put the struggles of a couple and how they can go through it no matter how hard it is I love that they kept trying and kept pushing each other to their limits cuz they knew they could do it I love how they support each other through everything I love how they don't give up on each other I love that they're always there for each other and very different ways to help each other I love that no matter how hard things get they always find a positive thing I think this is an amazing I think it's the best short book I've read in a long time and I'm definitely going to have to get the physical copy this book was so adorable it's worth listening to and I think that the author did an amazing job and the last episode where they're all playing hockey in their own way that's so cute the fact that the boys are carrying her around and mixing hockey and figure skating together to make their own version of hockey just shows that they're making their own life together their own version of a family I love that I thought that was so cute it just melted my heart...
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 30, 2025
Puck Me Thrice is my first time reading Riley Keenan and I’m confident it won’t be my last. I loved the development of these characters. I loved that they had flaws and were willing to accept them and communicate through them.
Blake was my absolute favorite in this story. The giant teddy bear who can cook? Yes, please. I want one! Logan and Nolan were dreamy too but Blake called to a part of me that the other two just didn’t hit.
I appreciated that there was not a third act breakup and even though a few things were predictable I still enjoyed the overall story line.
Definite must read for fans of why choose, hockey, steam, and building your own family when the one you have isn’t quite the best.
Blake was my absolute favorite in this story. The giant teddy bear who can cook? Yes, please. I want one! Logan and Nolan were dreamy too but Blake called to a part of me that the other two just didn’t hit.
I appreciated that there was not a third act breakup and even though a few things were predictable I still enjoyed the overall story line.
Definite must read for fans of why choose, hockey, steam, and building your own family when the one you have isn’t quite the best.
January 18, 2026
The story had promise but it was so short and nothing was developed at all. Just kept going to the next thing to the next thing without any substance. I sort of just skipped the end because it was way too predictable and cheesy. Polyamorous relationships only are successful in books when relationships are built with each coupling. Also there was a best friend that literally showed up in a phone call and that’s it? Character development is important especially with slightly taboo topics like having more than one partner. There are much better storylines out there.
December 1, 2025
Totally delightful story of three hickey players and the woman who loves them.
The characters were so very appealing and likeable and complex and complicated and absolutely perfect together. Plot was well written and developed. World building was excellent and impressive. Thoroughly enjoyed and highly recommend
Grab a copy, kick back and enjoy!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
The characters were so very appealing and likeable and complex and complicated and absolutely perfect together. Plot was well written and developed. World building was excellent and impressive. Thoroughly enjoyed and highly recommend
Grab a copy, kick back and enjoy!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
February 4, 2026
difficult to finish
The story itself has potential, but the execution really misses the mark. The author desperately needs a new editor. The continuity is atrocious. it feels like entire chapters were deleted, and the author seems to forget what she wrote earlier in the book. At one point, the wrong name is even used for the female character. The constant inconsistencies make the book frustrating and difficult to finish.
The story itself has potential, but the execution really misses the mark. The author desperately needs a new editor. The continuity is atrocious. it feels like entire chapters were deleted, and the author seems to forget what she wrote earlier in the book. At one point, the wrong name is even used for the female character. The constant inconsistencies make the book frustrating and difficult to finish.
December 5, 2025
Mira and her three hockey players, Blake, Nolan and Logan as she becomes their new performance coach. The story is exceptionally well written, featuring a compelling storyline and great, memorable characters. I was particularly pleased with the happy ending, which was very satisfying. I received a copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.
December 23, 2025
This was a DNF for me, I just got so confused and bored. The plot was missing, entirely, we had one conflict which was solved in about 6 pages. The story line was giving very wattpad.
February 12, 2026
I loved this book! The relationship between these four people was pure magic. They all knew what each other needed and worked together to make each other happy
February 17, 2026
there was potential for so much more but to me it was kind of giving nothing
Displaying 1 - 10 of 10 reviews