(4.75 rounded up)
This was a really strong debut from Ray Leigh and honestly a great first impression as an author. The characters feel well realized and layered, especially J, whose POV made the story really work for me. The emotional beats surrounding J’s family were handled extremely well, and I was genuinely impressed by how the subject matter in general was approached. The murders themselves are never used for shock value, nor are they sensationalized, the focus stays on the impact, the aftermath, and the cost. Because much of the book is told through J’s POV, his way of assessing situations felt very true to character. His thought process reads like that of an experienced detective, which added a lot of realism and immersion for me.
That said, this won’t be for everyone, and I think that’s worth mentioning. The subject matter—particularly a serial killer targeting children—is heavy, and while the events are not depicted graphically, the aftermath is present and detailed. Readers sensitive to that may find it upsetting. Structurally, the book follows a pretty true crime–style progression: investigation, information gathering, connecting dots, and then building toward a climax. This is perfect for crime and procedural fans, but readers looking for constant action might find the pacing lacking. The prose feels like a debut voice, very readable, occasionally more descriptive, which might not be for everyone, but it worked for me.
Overall, this is a solid and confident debut from an author who clearly understands the genre and how to tell a story within it. As a supernatural crime novel, it absolutely worked for me. I would highly recommend it to readers who enjoy shows like Supernatural, or books centered around urban monster hunting and investigative narratives. The characters are compelling, the story is focused and engaging, and it left a strong impression. This is very much an author I’ll be keeping an eye on going forward 👀