Set in Victorian London during Jack the Ripper’s reign of terror, this gripping, original novel is perfect for fans of V. E. Schwab, Dana Schwartz, and Sarah Penner.
When Caroline Foster arrives at the Whitechapel Full Moon Society in search of her missing brother, she finds a dilapidated façade belying an interior as opulent as any exclusive gentlemen’s club. In exchange for room and board, Caroline is hired as the Full Moon’s maid, where she is given three orders: don’t ask personal questions, stay out of the iron-barred room on the second floor, and remain in her bedroom from sunup to sundown on the full moon.
But when it is revealed that the previous maid was murdered—an early victim of Jack the Ripper—and her brother has left behind no answers, only more questions, Caroline begins to suspect her hosts might be hiding something. As more bodies turn up with a connection to the Society, Caroline fears she may have unwittingly stumbled into a bedtime story, the kind with monsters and curses, family secrets and ancient lore.
Tantalizing and pulsing, Elizabeth DeLozier’s sophomore novel gives an exciting alternative look into the infamous Jack the Ripper story with a major, supernatural twist.
Elizabeth DeLozier holds a BA in Spanish literature, a BS in biological anthropology, and a doctorate in physical therapy. An avid traveler, animal lover, and history nerd, she lives in Southern California with her husband, twin sons, and rescue dogs. Eleanore of Avignon is her debut novel. For more, follow her on instagram at @elizabethdelozierwrites.
When I got my hands on this arc, I was so excited to dive in, but the beginning was so slow that it brought me into a reading slump.
Set in Victorian London during Jack the Ripper’s reign of terror, the novel follows Caroline Foster, who arrives at the mysterious Whitechapel Full Moon Society searching for her missing brother. Behind its crumbling exterior lies an opulent gentlemen’s club with strict rules: 1. Don’t ask personal questions 2. Stay out of the iron-barred room on the second floor 3. Remain in your bedroom from sunup to sundown on the full moon
The supernatural storyline promises gothic suspense, while the Ripper thread leans into historical crime. But rather than amplifying each other, they pull focus, leaving both underdeveloped. The paranormal elements were present in atmosphere without fully delivering while the Jack the Ripper investigation accelerates too quickly, leading to a rushed, underwhelming conclusion.
Overall, it had a good potential with a good storyline.
𝐏𝐫𝐞-𝐫𝐞𝐚𝐝:
I received an uncorrected ARC of this book from NetGalley and the Dutton Publishers in exchange for an honest review.
The Whitechapel Full Moon Society follows Caroline Foster as she travels to London in search of her brother, Charlie. Caroline grew up in a wealthy family, but unfortunately that family unit has crumbled to nothing.
After the recent death of her father, Caroline has been left alone and the family estate sold off. Caroline's deepest connection in the world now is with Charlie, who she's only spent sporadic time with over the course of her life.
Following clues from his correspondence, Caroline ends up at the Whitechapel Full Moon Society, a dilapidated building currently serving as a gentleman's boarding house.
After an appeal to the landlady, Caroline, under slightly false pretenses, is hired on as the Full Moon's maid in exchange for room and board. She's hoping locating Charlie after this will be easy, but we all know, nothing is ever easy.
There are very strict rules at the Full Moon, at least for Caroline. She's not to ask the residents personal questions, or to enter the iron-barred room on the second-floor, and oh yeah, she must remain locked in her bedroom from sundown to sunup on full moon nights.
Even though to most of us, these rules may be suspicious as heck, it doesn't phase Caroline in the slightest. When she finds no signs of Charlie though, and when she finds out that the previous maid was brutally murdered, she starts to suspect the Full Moon may be more than your average boarding house.
This novel is set in Victorian London during the time of the Jack the Ripper slayings, and those historical crimes, as well as the corresponding fear that permeated the city, play a large role in this story.
I loved the inclusion of that, and how the author wove in those historical elements, it made the story feel that much more realistic. The atmosphere was oozing off the page, and as an atmosphere girlie, that was something I truly appreciated. I could picture everything perfectly.
I was actually surprised how immersed I became in this novel. This is far from my typical read, but I was swept up into it. She's a slow burn, it's true, but just such an enjoyable read nevertheless.
DeLozier's writing is very pleasing and engaging. It's straight-forward and accessible for Readers who don't read a lot of historical fiction, like myself. I was drawn to this because of the cover and the inclusion of the Jack the Ripper slayings, but ended up really impressed by the full package.
Thank you to the publisher, Dutton, for providing me with a copy to read and review. I'd definitely be interested in pick up DeLozier's future works!
A chilling and mysterious story of historical fiction set in London during the period when Jack the Ripper stalked the streets and murderously preyed on young women.
I was drawn to this book because the author's debut novel Eleanor of Avignon was one of my favorite books in 2024. [https://www.goodreads.com/review/show....] Even though this book, The White Chapel Full Moon Society, did not score as highly with me, I still enjoyed it.
Caroline Foster became homeless and penniless after the death of her father. In search of her brother, Caroline travels to London and takes a position as a maid in a boarding house for gentlemen, where her brother may have once lived. There are strange secretive rules that she must follow, and the residents are all very unusual. Will Caroline be able to solve the mystery of her brother's disappearance and reveal the secrets of the White Chapel Full Moon Society before it's too late or will she become the next victim of Jack the Ripper?
This eerie and strange story is perfect for this time of year and for fans of spooky and paranormal activities set in history. Unfortunately, it all became a little bit too peculiar for me near the end. I encourage others to check out the reviews of readers who may have seen this book differently.
We’re cooking with gas now!! I enjoyed this one a lot. The setting is London in the late 1880s, the time of Jack the Ripper. In fact, scattered throughout the book there are letters written by the Ripper himself. Caroline is hired as a maid at the Whitechapel Full Moon Society, where the woman before her was killed by, you guessed it, Jack the Ripper. All the while she’s looking for her brother Charlie who’s disappeared, but her investigation leaves her with more questions than answers. She even gets attacked at a point as things start to evolve. The twist I didn’t see coming, it left my jaw on the floor. Which brings me to the only thing that’s lowering my rating a bit: the fantasy-ish element. I don’t know, it kind of read like a cop out, I thought it would work but it didn’t really in the end, it took me out of the story. It could’ve been left out and I would’ve liked the book more overall. But that’s fine because everything else was top tier. And I do know it’s an important part of the book. I just didn’t like it lol. I would still wholeheartedly recommend though. If you like Victorian London with a murder-y, paranormal twist, this is the book for you. Thank you to NetGalley for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
After falling head over heels in love with Eleanore of Avignon, I will follow Elizabeth DeLozier to the ends of the earth. Or, in this case, I'll follow her to 1888 London during the reign of terror of Jack the Ripper. Another female lead, mystery, supernatural elements....I'm truly blessed to be getting an advance copy of this one. Good thing it was offered, because I may have taken the publisher's office by storm had it not been. (I lift. Just hand over the ARC.)
Click here to hear more about this book and my other anticipated releases of the upcoming quarter over on my Booktube channel, abookolive!
I was craving a read set in Victorian England and this novel definitely whetted my appetite. There were great descriptions that really set the mood for the story. It was equal parts mysterious and repulsive (we're talking questionable hygiene, casual racism, and prevalent sexism), so at least this book was true to the time period.
This will be a bit of a minor spoiler, but I was hoping that the paranormal/supernatural plot points that was promised by the genre would've actually been at the forefront of the story. Instead, these elements were mostly in the background and didn't actually show themselves until the climax and ending. This wouldn't be a dealbreaker if I only wanted a historical mystery novel. But being advertised as a fantasy novel, having to wait so long for something fantastical to happen became a huge letdown.
With the FMC being young and extremely ignorant to the realities of how both the real world and the working world functioned, this book felt more older YA than an adult novel. This didn't really bother me as much as I thought it would because I enjoyed exploring Victorian London through Caroline's eyes. But unfortunately, the YA tone (the dialogue, the character's observations and actions, etc.) made this novel feel more silly than serious at times when the scene called for a serious mood.
At least this was a quick and fun read. Great for a library borrow, but nothing phenomenal.
This is an interesting little Jack the Ripper retelling. This story has all the late 1800's very poor East London vibes, with a side of a desperate sister looking for her missing brother.
Minor Spoilers Ahead:
Caroline Foster is a young women who has recently lost her parents, who were her only means of support. So, she decides to move to Whitechapel in East London to try and locate her half brother that she hasn't heard from in several months. Upon arriving at the boaring house that he used to live at, she finds that according to his fellow boarders that he also mysteriously disappeared.
Caroline agrees to stay at the all male boarding house as their new maid in order to investigate each of the boarders more throughly in order to see if they had anything to do with her brother's disappearance.
At the same time, there is a serial killer on the loose in Whitechapel, who has already killed two young women who were on the streets running errands un-accompanied. The serial killer leaves notes and has dubbed himself "Jack the Ripper" in reference to the absolutely graphic and gruesome way that he un-alives his victims.
Highly recommend to any readers to love Jack the Ripper re-tellings, murder mysteries, or Jane Eyre/Bronte or poor Victorian London vibes.
Themes/Tropes: 🍁The Lived Reality and Constraints of 🍁Victorian Women 🍁Socioeconomic Disparity and Class Realities 🍁The Power of Agency and Self-Actualization 🍁Found Family 🍁Gothic Creepiness / Bedtime Stories with Teeth 🍁Forced Proximity 🍁The Missing Relative / Armchair Detective 🍁History with a Supernatural Twist
TW: ✨Violence and Murder ✨Sexual Assault (Off-Screen) ✨Prejudice and Bigotry ✨Ableism ✨Substance Abuse ✨Grief and Trauma ✨Paranormal Horror
Yeah, so this was fine. Historical fantasy Jack the Ripper reimagining with werewolves. It was a good pace, the plot was fine, the characters were fine, but I think that's the problem. It was just *fine*. Nothing stood out, nothing really grabbed me and sucked me in. It was a good time, but not a great time. I'm glad I gave it a read, but it wouldn't be a reread for me.
When Caroline arrives in gritty Victorian London searching for her missing brother, she finds herself with nowhere to go and nothing to do other than take a job as a maid at the gentlemen's club where he last stayed. The city is gripped by a developing string of murders, and the mood is thick and tense both inside and outside the walls of the home. While there, Caroline starts digging into her brother's disappearance and the club's secrets, only to find the mystery runs stranger and darker than she could have imagined.
I absolutely adored "Eleanore of Avignon," so I was thrilled when I heard DeLozier was bringing her talent for historical fiction to the story of Jack the Ripper. Unfortunately, this one just didn't match my expectations. The writing quality and character development are still strong, and just like in "Eleanore," DeLozier shows real skill at painting women's lives from a time when the female experience was so often an afterthought. The atmosphere is fantastic, with a heavy, gloomy weight that suits the setting and time perfectly. I struggled with the paranormal thread to the story, however. There's a lot going on in the plot — juggling historical fiction, murder mystery, and fantasy themes — and as a result, it felt like none of the angles were fully developed. Still, if you want an atmosphere-soaked book that's heavy on the female experience, this could be a good fit for you. Just go into it knowing that it won't have the same traditional historical fiction feel as DeLozier's previous work.
Side note: can we talk about how gorgeous this cover is? Well done to the book's production team!
Thank you to Dutton and NetGalley for providing an advance copy for honest review.
4.75 ⭐️ Thank you NetGalley and Dutton publishing for the ARC - this one started a little slow but I got lost in the details of domestic servant life in England in the 1800s so I dint really mind. And then the mystery started unfolding with increasing momentum. I became so engrossed during the final 40% of the book that relived my 11 year old nights staying up under the covers on a school night, furiously reading with a flashlight, consequences be damned when I have to wake up in the morning! It was a satisfying conclusion, even with the kooky supernatural twist that mostly served as a distraction from the mysteries at the heart of the story: where was Charlie, and who was Jack the Ripper? If you enjoy a mystery, don’t mind a little supernatural twist to your story, enjoy some ancient lore, and are fascinated by the mystery of Jack the Ripper, this niche book will really hit the sweet spot for you!
Overall, I enjoyed this story, but it was very predictable. I liked our main character and the sort of found family she developed within the Whitechapel Full Moon Society. I was interested in her backstory, even though I could easily see where the big reveal about her was headed.
It was also painfully obvious who Jack the Ripper was from the very first scene we met them. I’m not even sure why that storyline was included in the first place. It felt more like a side plot that eventually circled back around to the main story.
Despite the predictability, I still had a good time with this story. It’s a smooth, entertaining read with likable characters, an interesting premise, and a certain charm that kept me invested.
I loved this. An impressively layered, beautifully written mystery, devastating at turns, with great characters and just the right balance of atmosphere and speculative intrigue. A perfect read for fall.
The Whitechapel Full Moon Society by Elizabeth DeLozier was a great historical fiction novel centered on the hunt for Jack the Ripper. The author did an excellent job immersing the reader in Victorian England. I truly felt like I was there alongside the characters. I especially enjoyed the main character’s storyline and found it engaging and well developed.
That said, I did wish the gentlemen attending the Full Moon events weren’t tied to mythical creatures. I think it would have been more impactful if their secret society was rooted in something more realistic…such as being 🏳️🌈 and having a safe place to gather during a time when society wasn’t accepting. That angle could have added even more emotional depth and realism to the story.
Overall, this was a very enjoyable read, and I would definitely recommend it to anyone who enjoys historical fiction set in this time period. 👏👏👏
Jack the Ripper, supernatural intrigue, rain-soaked London streets, and decadent dinners? This sounded like the perfect recipe for an atmospheric fall read!
The Whitechapel Full Moon Society takes the familiar history of Jack the Ripper and adds a supernatural twist, a premise that immediately caught my attention. Elizabeth DeLozier did a wonderful job bringing the setting to life. From the damp, gloomy streets of London to the lavish dinners, the atmosphere was immersive and exactly what I wanted for a rainy fall day.
One aspect I particularly appreciated was the way DeLozier humanized the women who fell victim to Jack the Ripper. Rather than allowing them to remain faceless names in a notorious historical mystery, she reminded readers that these were real women with lives, experiences, and stories beyond the circumstances of their deaths. That was one of the most meaningful parts of the book for me.
Unfortunately, the supernatural elements didn't feel nearly as developed as I had hoped. While I loved the concept, the execution sometimes felt like throwing paint at a wall to see what would stick. There were interesting ideas scattered throughout, but they didn't always feel fully explored or woven together into something cohesive. I wanted more depth and intention behind the supernatural aspects, especially given how much potential the premise had.
The ending was also fairly predictable, which took away some of the excitement I typically look for in a mystery. Between that and the underdeveloped supernatural elements, the story never quite delivered the wow factor I was hoping for.
Overall, The Whitechapel Full Moon Society was an enjoyable, atmospheric read with a compelling premise and a thoughtful portrayal of the women at the center of its history. While the execution left something to be desired, I still appreciated the experience. A fitting read for a rainy autumn afternoon, particularly if you enjoy historical mysteries with a supernatural twist.
Caroline Foster arrives in Whitechapel looking for her missing brother, which already feels like a terrible life choice in 1888 London. The newspapers are screaming about Jack the Ripper, women are being murdered, everyone is suspicious, and Caroline's response is basically, "Well, my brother used to live here, so let's see what happens."
What happens is she gets a job at a boarding house called The Whitechapel Full Moon Society, which immediately sounds like the kind of place where absolutely nobody is telling the truth.
The rules alone would have had me running in the opposite direction. Don't ask questions. Stay away from the locked room. Lock yourself in your bedroom during the full moon. Listen, I've read enough books to know that when someone hands you a list of oddly specific rules, they're not protecting you from inconvenience. They're protecting you from the plot.
So naturally Caroline stays. And honestly, I liked Caroline. She's sheltered, anxious, and completely out of her depth, but she's also stubborn in that very specific way that makes mystery protagonists both lovable and incredibly stressful. Every time she got close to an answer, she'd immediately find three more questions. Every time she uncovered one secret, she'd accidentally trip over another. The poor woman came to London looking for one missing brother and ended up with enough conspiracy material to fill a corkboard.
The atmosphere absolutely carried this book for me. Victorian Whitechapel is already creepy before you add secret societies, strange boarders, mysterious disappearances, and whatever the hell is happening behind that locked door. The city feels filthy, dangerous, and one bad decision away from disaster at all times. Which is unfortunate because this entire cast specializes in bad decisions.
The boarding house residents were probably my favorite part. Everybody feels like they're hiding something, which they usually are. There's this constant sense that Caroline is the last person to realize she's wandered into the middle of somebody else's very weird business. Meanwhile I'm sitting there watching all these suspicious men gather under the name "Full Moon Society" like, guys, you're not exactly being subtle.
I will say the mystery is playing with cards that aren't exactly hidden. I figured out some of the bigger reveals pretty early, and there were moments where I felt like Caroline and I were reading different books. But weirdly, it didn't bother me that much because I was having fun watching everything unfold. Sometimes knowing a train is headed toward a cliff doesn't make it less entertaining. You just become invested in how spectacular the crash is going to be.
What surprised me most was how much heart the story has underneath all the murder and secrets. At its core, this is really about lonely people trying to find family in unexpected places. Caroline spends most of the book searching for someone she loves and slowly discovering connections she never expected to make. That's where the story worked best for me. Not the Ripper investigation. Not the supernatural mystery. Just people desperately wanting to belong somewhere.
The biggest issue for me was the pacing. The first half takes its sweet Victorian time getting where it's going, and then the ending shows up like it just remembered it had somewhere to be. I actually wanted more time with some of the reveals and with the Society itself because that's where the most interesting stuff was happening.
Still, I had a good time with this one. The Whitechapel Full Moon Society is creepy, atmospheric, full of secrets, and deeply committed to making life difficult for its protagonist. It won't be my favorite historical horror of the year, but I happily landed around 3.5 stars and immediately wanted to gossip about it with somebody.
Whodunity Award: For Hosting The World's Most Suspicious Monthly Meeting And Somehow Thinking Nobody Would Notice
Huge thanks to Dutton and NetGalley for the ARC. I came for Jack the Ripper, stayed for the increasingly alarming boarding house rules, and spent most of the book wondering how many red flags a building is legally allowed to have before someone investigates.
I've just finished an ARC on The Whitechapel Full Moon Society from Netgalley and wow! 5 Stars!
spoiler free review.
There was a huge twist at the end which definitely took me by surprise. I'd like to think I'm usually pretty good at guessing characters intentions but this one I completely missed and genuinely had me gasping out loud when I read it. I always enjoy rereading books to see if I can pick up on any clues I missed the first time so I can't wait to reread this one.
I will definitely be purchasing this when its released August '26.
Audiobook (9 hours) narrated by the Saskia Maarleveld Publisher: Books on Tape
Saskia Maarleveld is awesome, as is her narration. She is a deserving award winning narrator who does great work, including with accents that really bring to life a specific area where a story is taking place, as in this book. The audio is flawless.
The Whitechapel Full Moon Society is beautifully written by Elizabeth DeLozier.
I was immediately struck by the Victorian London feel of this story both by the words written and the narration of Saskia Maarleveld. The accents. The prose. The echoes of people and horse shoes on the stone and wood block paving. This is my long way of saying that the world is a very distinct character in this story. Full of life.
The story is a twist on Jack the Ripper. It's well thought out and written. So much so that I would love a prequel or a sequel that goes back in time to tell the story before the story. Not that this one isn't complete and fulfilling as told. I just want more! Yeah, yeah, I can be greedy when I read something I like and I really liked this one!
The characters are decent. This is more of a story first style, where our characters come into focus as the story progresses, as it makes sense to do so. Everything is told with intention. Details are not hidden, they are revealed throughout the novel at the right time and place.
This is the second book by this author, and the second that I have read. Her debut novel was Eleanore of Avignon, which I 5 star loved. That book was also very steeped in it's location of time and place, and was also narrated by Saskia. I recommend both books and I will be looking out for her next. Good stuff!
The Whitechapel Full Moon Society was a fun read that I finished in a sitting, but I was a bit underwhelmed.
I really enjoyed the cast of characters and the mystery surrounding Charlie's disappearance. I really wanted to know what happened to Charlie which kept me from putting the book down. The writing was also descriptive enough for me to visualize everything in my head, which helped keep me in the mood despite the still summer weather outside.
However, is it weird to say that I wish that this book weren't about Jack the Ripper? The mystery surrounding who is killing women was interesting, but it would have been better if it were a fictitious murderer. The inserts from Jack the Ripper didn't really mesh well with the rest of the book, and I found myself not really caring about figuring out who Jack the Ripper was as I was more invested in the main plot involving werewolves. Speaking of which, I'm sure it was predictable to everyone from the title that this is about werewolves, but it's written in such a way that it is supposed to come as a shock. I kept waiting for the reveal about werewolves and it didn't come until the end as if it were a plot twist, which was a tad disappointing for me.
Overall I would rate this 3.25 stars. It was a fun little palate cleanser for Summerween or Spooky Season. If you like historical fiction and supernatural cozy mysteries, you'd probably enjoy this.
Thank you to NetGalley and Dutton for an advanced digital copy in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I liked the idea of this, but ended up being disappointed by the execution. The historic theme (Jack the Ripper) and paranormal theme never really jelled together. And it was soooooo slow.
Caroline Foster is a girl in Victorian England who has to go to London to find her brother after her father dies, leaving her penniless after covering all of his debts. Unfortunately, when Caroline gets to London her brother is missing, so all she can do is become a maid at the boardinghouse where her brother lived in hopes of finding out about his disappearance, but what if she ends up missing herself at the hands of Jack the Ripper?
This had a bit of a slow start to the point that I wasn’t sure if I wanted to continue with it, but I’m very glad that I did! Caroline is a very entertaining heroine and her persistence in finding out what happened to her brother Charlie really draws you in. I also really loved the residents of the boardinghouse, particularly Mrs. Easton and Rab.
The ending also has such a fun twist that you kind of start to see hinted at but it was so entertaining I really loved it.
In this book, we are following Caroline Foster through London while Jack the Ripper is active. And somehow that’s the side plot. Caroline is searching for her brother who warns her not to come since it isn’t safe, and true to being a main character, Caroline goes anyways.
I found this book hard to put down! The mystery of her brother’s disappearance, the boarding house’s eccentric characters, and reading as Caroline learns how to be a maid (funny, a little stressful, and at times bleak) were all fascinating components that came together beautifully.
This book is described as "...a bedtime story, the kind with monsters and curses, family secrets and ancient lore" and "...[an] alternative look into the infamous Jack the Ripper story with a major, supernatural twist." Instead, it is an extremely slow burning mystery (around the 70% mark, our protagonist laments that she hasn't discovered anything despite months of subtle investigation) with zero supernatural elements. Yes, the (I don't consider this a spoiler due to the title and description laying it on quite thick) werewolves are revealed at the very end, but they are almost unrecognizable from the traditional morphing monsters we know, and their lycanthropy is only ever a red herring to the main mystery.
I wanted to like this book so much that I finished it despite wanting to DNF at the 50% mark, hoping it would redeem itself. Once I'd reached the end and it hadn't, I tried to view it retrospectively without the lens of its Goodreads description, but that only improved it slightly. From that perspective, it was easier to focus on the positives: DeLozier's descriptions of 1888 London are visceral and immersive, Caroline is a realistic depiction of an anxious heiress, and as she uncovers information at a glacial pace, there's something that keeps the pages turning. Whether it's empathy for the protagonist, true curiosity for the twist on the Ripper murders, or something else, I can't tell. I will say I was very moved by the final scene, though.
Despite a diverse and interesting cast of boarders, they are underutilized in the narrative since our focus is so clearly on Caroline and (as one of her rules as a maid) she cannot interact with them. Like many mysteries, this book ends with an enormous info dump, but there are still (somehow) questions left unanswered. I think there are definitely people out there that will enjoy this book, but I am unfortunately not one of them.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an advance copy of this book!
I finished The Whitechapel Full Moon Society in less than 24 hours. This novel carried a quiet, persistent pull that made setting it down feel almost impossible.
While it begins a bit slowly, around page 53 I realized I was itching to return to it whenever I put it down.
Delozier does a delightful job of feeding us bits of information, one drop at a time, just enough to keep our curiosity involved, but not too much to overwhelm us. They effectively humanize the women of this period: figures so often overshadowed by the frenzy surrounding the mysterious Jack the Ripper. While some elements of the story were predictable, they were predictably satisfying. Like a well-constructed music box, the narrative gradually clicks into place, each turn more gratifying than the last.
There was a moment in the story where I feared Delozier might lead us a certain way, but to my delight, the author took us on a much more effective, timely, and engaging journey.
This book is extremely readable. A true delight for readers who enjoy historical fiction, folklore, crime novels, or all three.
It's an interesting thought that folklore, especially that which shares common threads across cultures, must be based in some reality. It's often dismissed because those mythos couldn't possibly real, or could they? DeLozier takes that concept and runs with it in this novel, while blending in historical realness that those lines between folklore and history become blurred in a way that is entertaining and contemplative.
Upon the death of her father, Caroline discovers that her family's wealth has been all but gambled away. Her only remaining family and hope is her brother Charlie, who resides in a gentleman's boarding house in the east end of London. She travels to London to find him in the hopes of beginning anew, only to find he has mysteriously disappeared. Even more mysterious are the residents of the Full Moon Society, the boardinghouse where Charlie has been living. Her search for her missing brother brings her on a collision course with a sinister serial unaliver, known as Jack the Ripper as well as a strange series of folktales that begin to feel less like a fairy tale and more like a nightmare...
Fans of historical fiction will be delighted with the level of historical detail in this novel. I am by no means an expert on Victorian London or Jack the Ripper, but I felt very immersed in this world as I was reading. The pacing and tone of the story added to the air of mystery and tension, making this book actually hard to put down at times. Caroline is a fantastic lead and I really enjoyed her transformation from a timid socialite into a fiercely loyal and determined sister.
A nice balance is achieved between the historical aspects and paranormal in this book, which I think will appeal to readers looking for one or the other, or even both (that's me!). The humanity and authenticity of the characters DeLozier has created is truly the connective tissue throughout the novel. In her author's note, she mentions her intention of bringing Jack the Ripper's victims to life and giving them a story of their own which to me was marvelous. The members of the Full Moon Society were also richly depicted and had interesting stories of their own. It's been said that a truly strong standalone novel is one that you want more of once you finish it. I would gladly read stories about all of these characters for how authentic their lives feel. The paranormal elements of the story are at just the right amount. I think the author wants you to have just enough information to believe it is real, but not enough that the story would fall apart under intense scrutiny. Just like how real folklores are supposed to feel.
Bottom line: this is a delightful read that will appeal to many readers due to the author's wonderful ability to blend genres of historical fiction, murder mystery, thriller, and paranormal horror (I think the fantasy tag here is inaccurate). A great read to get you ready for spooky season!
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Spice Level: 🫑
Immense gratitude and thanks to NetGalley and the publisher Dutton for the wonderful opportunity to read and review this ARC. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
The Whitechapel Full Moon Society was such a fun blend of historical fiction, gothic mystery, and the supernatural. Elizabeth DeLozier takes the already unsettling backdrop of Victorian London during the Jack the Ripper murders and gives it a completely different spin with monsters, ancient lore, and a very secretive society.
I really enjoyed Caroline as our FMC, especially watching her go from a sheltered young woman searching desperately for her missing brother, Charlie, to someone willing to break every rule in the house to get answers. Her relationship with Charlie also gave the story a surprisingly emotional core underneath all of the murder and mystery.
The Full Moon Society itself was easily one of my favorite parts. The strange rules, the locked room, the monthly dinners, and the eclectic group of residents made the entire house feel like its own character. I loved slowly uncovering why these people were together and what exactly Caroline had walked into.
I also appreciated the way DeLozier handled the Jack the Ripper element. Rather than making the story solely about the killer, she gives more attention and humanity to the women living through the fear of these murders while weaving the historical elements into her own supernatural mystery. There were a few moments where I wanted the mystery to move a little faster, but once everything started coming together, I was completely invested. Overall, this was atmospheric, creepy, imaginative, and such an interesting take on a piece of history that has been retold so many times.
Definitely one for historical fantasy readers who like their Victorian London with a little more bite.
I’m always weak for crime fiction set in Victorian London, so I keep picking up pretty much anything that falls into this category, even when it involves yet another reimagining of the Jack the Ripper murders. I’m not particularly fond of this kind of historical revisionism, and I knew I probably wouldn’t be convinced by this book’s take on it, but curiosity got the better of me. And while the Jack the Ripper angle indeed didn't work for me, that actually wasn't my biggest issue with this story.
On the plus side, I really enjoyed the general atmosphere of late 19th-century Whitechapel, as well as the way the mystery was constructed and eventually solved. In fact, I think the story could’ve worked perfectly well on its own, without bringing Jack the Ripper into the picture. I might’ve enjoyed it considerably more that way.
What really threw me off though, were the paranormal elements that seemed to come out of nowhere towards the end. Once again, I think the story could’ve taken a more plausible route without resorting to the supernatural.
All in all, I had a fine time reading this book, and there was enough to keep me interested. But it didn’t quite win me over. I’d recommend it primarily to readers who, like me, have a particular weakness for Victorian crime fiction.
Books set in Victorian England are a special interest of mine, so I had to grab this one when I saw it! I also love retellings in general, and Jack the Ripper theories are pretty much a must read for me.
This was everything I hoped for and more! The character development, the thrills, the paranormal aspect and the setting were all spot on. I definitely recommend for anyone interested in historical fiction, Victorian settings, paranormal fun and Jack stories - like me!
Thank you so much to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity!
I love a good genre-bender! Enjoyed this. The supernatural aspects offer up some lovely gothic suspense and the historical crime aspects serve up some crime mystery. All on all this adds up to great vibes and a solid storyline. The pacing was my only qualm, with the front half burning a little slower than I’d prefer and all the moving action crammed into the last bit. Even the «slow burn» bit was engaging and well-written though, paints a vivid picture of Victorian London.
4/5. Not my favorite ever but a great book. Murder with a paranormal twist.