Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Flash (2011)

The Flash, Vol. 5: History Lessons

Rate this book
Find out how Barry Allen adjusts after his battle with Reverse-Flash! Plus, witness the first meeting of The Flash and Green Lantern!

Collecting: The Flash 26-29, Annual 2

138 pages, Kindle Edition

First published September 9, 2014

29 people are currently reading
1210 people want to read

About the author

Brian Buccellato

722 books67 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
376 (26%)
4 stars
462 (32%)
3 stars
478 (33%)
2 stars
101 (7%)
1 star
20 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 125 reviews
Profile Image for Anne.
4,745 reviews71.3k followers
May 10, 2015
I don't know what to say about this.
It's just...I have yet to feel fully captured by a solo Flash title.
I honestly love Barry Allen's character. He's sweet, funny, loyal, and makes a great addition to any team-up, but... on his own?
Woof.
Such a blah story.
I would lovelovelove to see a writer take this title on, and then make it exciting and fun. I know it can be done. And I know it can be done without turning Barry into a dark version of himself or some other nonsense.

description

As it is, I'm still ambivalent to this title.

description

Up first was a nice team-up with Hal Jordan that showed how they met.
Green Lantern & Flash! BFF's FOREVAH!

description

The story had an old school feel to it that was sorta sweet & fun, but there wasn't any real meat to that one.

Ok, I'm going to be completely honest here.
I don't actually remember much about most of this volume. Mostly random villains, and unconnected stories...I think.
Sadly, the majority of it just left me with a vague feeling of meh.

The last few issues were my favorites. Barry accidentally frees an evil spirit who is intent exacting revenge on the descendants of the man who killed him.
There's an actual story here that's relevant to Barry's life, and it made all the difference.
I wish the whole volume had been as interesting as the stuff at the end.

The Flash is just one of those characters (like Aquaman) that I simply refuse to give up on. I like what he stands for, so I'm going to continue on with his comics in the hopes that some writer will eventually knock my socks off.

description

Get this review and more at:

Profile Image for Calista.
5,432 reviews31.3k followers
February 14, 2019
This kinda goes all over the place. There isn't really a through storyline right now. It's interesting. I just finished reading The Justice League Dark for the first time and that was my introduction to Deadman. He is this guy who is dead or something like that and now he is able to possess people. He is a strange new hero I'm introduced to. Well, he shows up in this story. It's a good thing to as Flash is dealing with an angry ghost who can possess people.

I thought this book was good and I enjoyed the last story arch that did include Deadman, but it wasn't as well done as the previous volumes. Same energetic artwork and thrust to the story. Flash is fast and he's moving forward. I don't have much else to say. This volume is fairly forgettable. I hope the next volume picks up the thread again.
Profile Image for Donovan.
734 reviews107 followers
January 1, 2017


SURPRISING, not knowing what to expect. But the creative team is chaotic. Former co-writer Brian Buccellato solo writes Volume 5, Manapul illustrates one cover, and random illustrators do each issue with no consistency whatsoever. If I have one big complaint it's that Francis Manapul, former writer and illustrator, is totally gone.

Unlike the previous volumes, which had large story arcs, this contains three unrelated stories that feel somewhat shoehorned. I can imagine Buccellato freaking out and DC says, "chill out, Brian, just write whatever and Robert will take over in four issues." That's pretty much what happens.

The first two issues are okay, not bad, but nothing special. The last three easily should have been expanded into a larger five issue story arc with several sub plots. But oh well. I guess that's why Buccellato leaves the project after this volume.

The Quick and the Green is the first issue, a somewhat predictable "otherworld" story: Flash and Green Lantern Hal Jordan get sucked into an alternate dimension battle world and rescue child slaves, and of course battle aliens to the near death. But the humor between Barry and Hal is great. That's the only good thing about this one.

Flash Out of Water is the second issue and a typical Rogue story, featuring a new but one dimensional daredevil villain named Sky Pirate. This one's at least exciting, with Flash jumping off helicopters and planes. And surprise, he catches the baddie. But nothing we haven't seen before, let alone in the four previous volumes to greater effect.

History Lessons, the title story, is where it's at. Part mystery, supernatural horror, and crime procedural, this story has real depth and audacity. A 19th century Central City (say that five times fast) gold miner comes back to murder and exact vengeance upon his killer's descendants, whom he cursed with his last dying breath. So there's murder, ghosts, possession, the very minor but cool character Deadman, police corruption, and some "who killed my mom" drama from Barry. This story actually has a very "old Gotham" Batman feel to it. But it's too quick!

Not an essential read by any means, but actually better than it should be considering Manapul is gone and you've got twenty different illustrators. The last story is pretty solid, better illustrated than the rest, and is surprisingly different with its subject matter. However, after Manapul's talent, this just doesn't feel the same, which is why they didn't include it in the new Flash Omnibus.
Profile Image for Jesse A.
1,672 reviews100 followers
March 29, 2024
Fun collection. Not especially deep or meaningful but just entertaining. Extra half star for the pitch perfect first story team up of Flash/Green Lantern.
Profile Image for Subham.
3,072 reviews102 followers
February 14, 2022
This was a great collection of short stories like one with team up with my fav character Hal Jordan aka GL and well we see how they first up to rescue some missing children and then in the present how they defeated those same aliens who abducted them nd a gladitorial fight which was fun and then some story where Flash has to fight a villain named Spit fire who is doing some danger stunts and that was a boring, weird story for sure.

But the big one with the return of Keystone killer and his connections to Barry and the founding of Gem cities and well the rivalry of Sutters and Fletchers and how it connects to Frye and his parentage and lineage and its a haunting-possessing story and also involves Deadman and its so fun and really gives a insight iinto Barry and well an emotional arc for him and great spotlight on Frye and others, a fun haunting story and yeah a great read with solid art again! Must recommend!
Profile Image for Lost Planet Airman.
1,283 reviews90 followers
June 13, 2020
Well-paced mystery adventure of the flash -- and guest star(s) -- against... well, why spoil the surprise?
Profile Image for Matt.
183 reviews
March 4, 2015
I went back and bumped this from 4 to 5 stars. Why am I being so generous? Because this collection had a little bit of everything I love about superhero comics:
1. A good annual story - Flash & Hal Jordan team up in an off-Earth adventure that is good ol' space-opera fun, plus a bonus little back-up that's a solid meditation on the profound impact that our seemingly small decisions make on those around us.
2. A solid one-and-done - The next issue is a story that proves The Flash's awesomeness as a hero. After the trademark opening ("I am the fastest man alive") is the inevitable "Are you faster than Superman?" question. The rest of the issue showcases all of the weird awesome physics behind what The Flash can do and why he is every bit the hero the Big Blue Bore is.
3. A solid arc - This is a bit of a mystery complete with Deadman. It's got murder, history, ghosts, serial killers, and everything I could want from a story with all those ingredients.
I might have just been in the right mood, but this was an absolute delight.
Profile Image for Lashaan Balasingam.
1,476 reviews4,623 followers
December 31, 2019
Since the departure of Francis Manapul from this series, things seemed much more unhinged for the The Flash's series. This volume is an stellar example of this very issue as it collects a bunch of random and unconnected stories together.

Not only are these smaller story arcs superficial with barely any real pertinence, and sometimes bordering mediocrity both in story and art, it is worth noting that the final story was the most interesting as it looks into Barry Allen's obsession over his mother's real killer to finally release his father from prison.

Yours truly,

Lashaan | Blogger and Book Reviewer
Official blog: https://bookidote.com/
Profile Image for David.
2,565 reviews87 followers
February 22, 2015
Aside from the opening short story, a pleasing Green Lantern, Hal Jordan team-up, this one's a bit of a dud. Disappointed as this title's been regularly enjoyable.
Profile Image for Gavin.
1,264 reviews89 followers
November 10, 2015
Mixed bag...I for one DID NOT like the Hal/Barry teamup meet cute recall issue. Lame-o. Too cartoony. Also, has EVERYONE worn Hal's ring now?

Then a few single issues, including a lame villain Spitfire...best part there was Barry running on clouds because they have tiny ice crystals...lol.

Then we get onto the main storyline of the book,which is where things look up from a near failure first half...

Stupid Rogue rejects, Chroma and Tar Pit get caught, accidentally unearthing a burial ground for a serial killer.

This one was arrested when Barry was a baby, but of course, more to the story! This ties into the founding of the Gemstone cities, and a killer spirit, who has a descendant involved in the story! Also, is Barry going to find out a shocking truth? Tune in next time, featuring Deadman! A highly underrated character, who's now free to roam, like Frankenstein, now that JL Dark "disbanded" ie. Got cancelled.

The artwork is the prize here, and Brian Buccellato has started to salvage what Francis Manapul was leading down to crapville.

Once again we have to hear about the secret of Nora Allen's killer, between Barry's dad and Capt. Frye, and a subtle (not subtle) hint about who is involved!

Good recovery issue, but still room to grow, and still not a great handle on Barry Allen except that he's driven to find his mother's killer. No Gorillas or Iris West this time, which is something.
Profile Image for Jen.
1,468 reviews
September 14, 2016
This series is just really not that great for me. This was actually a little more interesting, since I like Deadman (Blackest Night or Darkest Day, when he comes back is where I mostly have experience with this character and I liked Boston Brand a lot).

The beginning stories didn't really have anything to do with the previous volumes; we had a few stories on Flash and Green Lantern, and that was more stand alone. That was just OK also, there was more that should have been explained but wasn't (or was only half-ass thrown in).
Profile Image for Kyle.
936 reviews28 followers
April 24, 2016
There is not much development of the Flash universe in this storyline other than a mild murder mystery that sheds light on the corrupt origins of the gem cities. Then again, did anyone out there have a burning need to know the origins of the gem cities?

Some solid writing, good story-boarding and okay artwork.... Still, this volume just didn't seem to carry much weight.

3/5
Profile Image for max.
196 reviews20 followers
May 31, 2016
Actual rating: 3.5 stars

A bit short but interesting enough, the plot twists are certainly mind-boggling in this one. I found the art a bit dull and too edgy though.
Profile Image for Michael Church.
683 reviews4 followers
September 24, 2015
Look...with Francis Manapul gone, this book is going to suffer. There is just no way around it. That look was iconic and those stories were made all the better for it. What can I say, I'm a guy who forgives a mediocre story for great art.

Speaking of mediocre stories, you've got a handful here. The Annual is a fun team up with Green Lantern, but it assumes a level of familiarity between these two that really has no reason to be there yet in the New 52. It's a fun story, but nothing unique or outstanding.

The other standalone stories are alright and have some fun little highlights. Seeing how everyday little changes can add up to something big and some of the really insane uses of the Flash's powers were pretty sweet. The main story is alright. The twists were a bit predictable and worn out, but it was still a good time. And Deadman can only improve the concept.

Zircher is adequate on art with a few moments that shine. Again, anything following up from Manapul would've been tough.

This is still a pretty decent book, it's just a shame the creative team had to change.
Profile Image for Travis Duke.
1,137 reviews15 followers
June 2, 2016
2.5 stars, author and artist change over on this volume. Francis Manapul had a great run on flash and this is pale in comparison. The first 3 mini stories in this book are pretty shallow and boring, with the exception of the green lantern ( buddy cop) arena world story. The main story "history lessons" is o.k. its entertaining but nothing great. It revolves around the "keystone killer" which is an old west story about claim jumpers that turned into ghosts. The art is also a downturn but surprising it is still Brian Buccellato at least in some of the stories. I suppose if you really like the flash they you will like this volume but casual readers might just pass it over. I am torn because I am not sure ill pick up volume 6.
Profile Image for Cale.
3,919 reviews26 followers
November 1, 2016
This volume collects an annual, which features a fairly silly story where Flash and Green Lantern meet for the first time and end up on a fairly random interplanetary adventure. It's fun but slight. The main body of the collection focuses on a discovery of bodies that points to a past serial killer that Barry thinks may be a key to his own family mysteries. Thinks take a weirdly supernatural turn, including a rather random crossover character, and ultimately a few questions are answered, a few false leads are brought up and disposed of, and Barry ends in a place not far off from where he started.
The art is serviceable if not memorable. The writing works too, but it's a fairly average collection overall.
Profile Image for Daniel Sepúlveda.
846 reviews85 followers
December 7, 2015
En resúmen:
1. Barry se enfrenta con fuerzas sobrenaturales, y necesita la ayuda de Deadman.
2. El padre de Barry puede que no sea realmente su padre.
3. La mamá de Barry era un poco traviesa, o le mintió a su marido...
4. Muchas cosas salen a la luz.

Le doy 4 estrellas exactas, ni más ni menos.
Profile Image for Eli.
870 reviews132 followers
September 30, 2024
This entire volume leading up to the last page was filler, ending with a tease to the upcoming plot for future volumes. But it was cool to see Flash/Green Lantern and Flash/Deadman team-ups.
Profile Image for Megan.
230 reviews24 followers
January 24, 2016
This is one of those books that was overall enjoyable to read, but I'm not going to really remember it after a bit. It was good, but nothing really grabbed my attention in any of the stories.

The first half of the book is a few one shot issues, while the second half tells a longer story. First is a team-up between the Flash and Green Lantern that shows how they first met. The two friends' dynamic is always fun, and the story did a good job of showing their strengths, but the plot itself didn't particularly interest me. Children are being kidnapped, and the two meet while trying to find them. Aliens end up being behind the kidnapping, but they didn't make for engaging villains. But Barry and Hal are fun to watch banter at least.

The next story was a short one about how even the smallest of actions can change someone's life. The main plot was about a fire from the Flash's past where he was unable to save a woman due to her already having died before the fire even started. However, her husband blames the Flash and wants revenge. It was an ultimately bittersweet story. I liked the start and end of the story where the small actions changing lives come in. At the start of the story, the Flash is performing random acts of kindness as he rushes to a party he's late for. At the very end, you see how his random acts changed each person's life in the short and long term. It's usually the smaller acts of kindness that move me more than the grand heroic deeds when it comes to superheroes.

The next story was basically an extended chase as the Flash tried to catch the woman responsible for the death of his former teacher. I don't really have feelings about it one way or another. It wasn't bad. But it didn't really draw me in either.

And the longer story had the Flash obsessing over catching a serial killer that he suspects might be responsible for his mothers murder. This story actually related to Barry's life and involved the people around him, which made it more engaging than the other stories. We even got a team up with Deadman. But the story didn't quite work for me. The villain had a nice and tragic background, but wasn't very compelling. While I like Deadman, he didn't really make much of an impression here. And the solution to the problem felt rather simple ultimately.

This wasn't a bad book. It just wasn't the best I've read of the Flash.
Profile Image for Connor.
22 reviews1 follower
April 1, 2017
Originally reviewed at Bookwraiths.

The Flash is one of my favorite DC characters. I watch The Flash television show; I read all the comics; and I can’t wait to see him in the Justice League movie. Not that those things make me an expert on him, but I do know when a story about Flash is good and when it isn’t. Well, this comic story was pretty cool, so let me tell you why

description

The beginning of this one was a little bit lame I have to warn you. Green Lantern is in it, and the team up story didn’t make a lot of sense to me. Plus is there anyone who hasn’t worn a GL power ring by now?

Once the GL junk finished up though, things started getting better. A burial ground of a serial killer getting unearthed, letting this rampaging spirit lose to start killing people. Flash gets involved, but finds he needs some serious help from someone who is undead! Guess who that is?

description

Well, it is an oversimplification, I guess. But you don’t want me to give too much of the story away, right? And I did give you a hint about the undead guy.

What is really cool here was the art work during the second part of the story and the fact the author, Brian Buccellato got Flash moving in a fun direction again (except for the GL stuff). It might just be me, but I think Barry Allen has it too hard. Nothing ever goes his way. So I was glad there was a little hope for Barry in here.

description

Well, I hope you liked this review, and friend me any time to talk about my reviews or comic books.
Profile Image for J.
1,559 reviews37 followers
August 7, 2017
In this latest volume of the no-longer coded New 52 Flash, Barry Allen goes through his paces in a series of tales that are very Bronze-Ageish. It starts with Flash Annual #2, which gives us the first meeting of Flash and Hal Jordan, and ends in a three part murder mystery that has Cary Bates stamped all over it.

Nothing really moves forward in this volume (heh), but we do learn a little more about Barry's relationship with Captain Frye, which deepens the mystery behind the murder of Barry's mom. Barry is still something of a dull boy, however, although living with his girlfriend is the one modern touch that compares rather humorously with the classic Barry Allen trying to date Fiona whatsherface back before the original Crisis. I wish Barry had more personality, but other than being driven to find his mom's murderer, that's about it. I understand why people miss the classic Wally West, but there is no reason why Barry can't be just as interesting a character. These books have lots of Flash action, but a little more Barry would be great, to make the readers care a bit more about him.

Overall, I enjoyed these stories, a little better than most people, but I think the throwback style (as I perceive it) has a lot to do with it.
Profile Image for Nikki in Niagara.
4,384 reviews172 followers
June 25, 2015
Very good! Starts off with two one-offs establishing Buccellato as the new writer with different illustrators. The Green Lantern one was good while the other was only okay. Then the book finishes up with the main entry, the titular story commencing Zircher on art. A great mix of noir detective and paranormal as a ghost from the diamond mining 1800s returns, crosses paths with a modern day serial killer and Flash finds clues to his mother's death as help comes along from, one of my favourite DC characters, Deadman. Fun book, that turns the tide for Flash from the previous volumes in the New 52.
Profile Image for Christine.
348 reviews
March 11, 2017
I enjoyed this one- the art continues to be lovely, I actually laughed at Barry's interactions with Hal Jordan, and the rest of the story lines were swiftly tied up but interesting. Plus, it had a decided lack of any of the characters that typically don't fall on my "enjoyable" list, which was great.
Profile Image for Scott.
1,416 reviews121 followers
July 30, 2016
Really enjoyed this one. Great art. Really enjoyed the storyline with the Sutters vs. Fletchers - it was a deep enough story to get me interested and different enough to keep me intrigued.

I'm still not a "DC guy" but I'll keep reading Flash.
43 reviews1 follower
February 8, 2015
What a great DC comic. Love this one so glad I one it from Goodreads! It's a keeper.
Profile Image for Sean Kennedy.
Author 44 books1,014 followers
May 12, 2015
The arc for this volume seemed too rushed and needed to be fleshed out into more than three issues.
Profile Image for Madison.
429 reviews38 followers
June 11, 2016
~4.5⭐️~

Didn't love the art as much
Profile Image for Mohamed Ahmed.
274 reviews26 followers
March 29, 2018
Way Below the Previous Stories ( Except For the Annual 2 Which I Already read in the Omnibus )
Profile Image for Henry Blackwood.
657 reviews2 followers
March 22, 2021
Im so glad that for me, this is over. I don’t think I’ll ever dip into Flash comics again. I don’t believe that he has very interesting stories and certainly this new 52 version of Barry Allen is the worst I’ve ever seen. I don’t care about the speed force And i don’t care about many of his villains. But that’s not even the worst part, the worst part of this run is that Captain Cold is an interesting character with an interesting arch in the new 52 and yet he’s not focused on nearly as much as he should’ve. The other big issue is that Reverse Flash (Eobard Thawne) is Flash’s best villain, and in the new 52 they completely fucked that villain up for no rhyme or reason and made it completely shit. And don’t get me started on the Iris West/Barry relationship in this.

This is the thing, if you’re going to redo classic stories and villain struggles at least make them better. This has been pathetic.
Profile Image for Kieran McAndrew.
3,066 reviews20 followers
November 4, 2024
The Flash Vol. 5: History Lessons

The vengeful spirit of a Central City serial killer may finally explain the mystery behind Nora Allen's death. As Barry races to uncover the truth, Captain Frye tries to ensure some secrets remain buried.

The artwork lends a sense of the otherworldly to this storyline and the use of shading and colouring helps add a good dollop of atmosphere to this gloomy adventure.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 125 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.