Naughty Or Nice

by Samantha Barrett

Forgive me, Santa, I have been a naughty, naughty girl.

I don’t care if my stocking is filled with coal. I’d gladly stay on the naughty list as long as they keep filling me with their release every night.

Oh, Santa. They may dress like you, fill my bedroom with naughty little treats, and make all my secret Christmas wishes come true, but I have one last request...

Help me uncover who the three masked men are. The ones that chase me through my office, stalk me like I’m their prey, and make my body hum with pleasure like they own every inch of me.

Your naughtiest girl always,

Holly xx

Genres: Christmas, Novella, Dark Romance, Why Choose, Holiday, LGBT, Dark

132 pages, Paperback

Published November 30, 2025

About the author

Samantha Barrett is originally from Auckland, New Zealand but living in Brisbane, Australia.

Sam writes all things dirty dark and delicious with a side of twisted mind fu*k.

She is a lover of all things red flags and an anti-hero is a must.

Reviews

[Cocolici · Rating 5 out of 5]

Smutmas has blessed me, babes, because this little novella? Five flaming, candy-cane-twisted stars. 🍭🍭🍭🍭🍭

Don’t cry, babe.... I absolutely loved Holly and her three men. You gave me heat, heart, and a whole lot of holi-yay. The scenes were utterly hawt, the chemistry was chaotic in the best way, and the vibes were pure festive filth. Exactly what my December needed.

Short, dirty, delicious chef’s kiss.
Bring on more Smutmas novellas, I am thriving.

[Tia · Rating 5 out of 5]

4.5⭐️ every day is a school day 🤣 this was just pure Xmas Smut with a side of plot and I loved it!! 🥵🥵

[Lynnmarie542_books · Rating 5 out of 5]

OH. MY. LAWD. You had me hooked at the dedication— I gasped, then immediately burst into giggles.

And when figging was mentioned? I straight-up yelled oh no into the void, then cackled because I actually knew what it was… yet have never seen it show up in a book before now!

Samantha is the undisputed queen of super spice with just enough plot—and let me tell you, that “little” plot? It’s addictive, delicious, and dangerously good.

[catiesbooksandthings · Rating 5 out of 5]

Well this was a spicy little novella that I didn't know I needed. Smutmas in July! Sign me up!

I have not dabbled a lot in why choose, but this spicy little listen was a great introduction to the why choose world and I was totally here for it! I could not put it down! This book was addictive with a bada$$ FMC who did not give two sh*ts.

I highly recommend the audiobook as the narrators were perfection - Autumn Ivy, Bryant Walker, Gabriel Spires and Walker Williams. They were chefs kiss and had me eating up this goodness!

While these characters are completely unhinged and filthy little freaks, the cast of narrators were absolute perfection and complimented each other very well! They definitely were able to bring these characters to life!

Thank you Samantha Barrett and BlueNose for the ALC in exchange for my honest thoughts and review!

Read if you like:
-Christmas Spice
-MMFM
-Why Choose
-Workplace Romance
-Masked Men
-Found Family

[Tay · Rating 5 out of 5]

I liked it Sam always surprises us with books out of no where she’s my fave author

[Ashley · Rating 4 out of 5]

Well this was such a fun short listen, and would be absolutely perfect for a festive read!

This one starts strong and jumps straight into the hot, spicy and downright filthy scenes from the start! Holly is one lucky girl at the office Christmas party when she is cornered in an office by three masked strangers, Saint, Nick and Chris. Oh and these men do absolutely filthy things to her during the party and she loved every minute of it! At the end of the night she thought it was over, oh far from it!

The plot had more to it than just the spice with an undercurrent of love and betrayal that when it all came to a head was explosive! Let’s just say these men terribly underestimated Holly and how strong she really was. But in the end yes it is a HEA and everyone does eventually get a Merry Christmas, but the road to it is bumpy to say the least.

I have listened to a few Walker Williams audios now and love listening to him! This was my first listen of Autumn Ivy, Bryant Walker and Gabriel Spires and I was so impressed they fit the characters perfectly and I would enjoy listening to them all again.

[Chelsi Lowe · Rating 5 out of 5]

Ohh boyyyy!! That was a wild ride of naughty masked men and the depraved things they do!

Twin brothers, exes brother, masked men, kinky af things happening that I had to Google ✅

This story was a short, easy and spicy af read that I loved everyday depraved minute of. Noelle is an assistant to her hot bosses that she longs to be more with, she also has 3 masked stalkers that she loves being naughty for.

Full of secrets and slight betrayal this story is worth the read!!

[Glenda · Rating 5 out of 5]

If you’re looking for a naughty little Christmas read, look no further. Naughty or Nice was such a fun ride and delivered all the extra spice I’ve come to expect from Samantha Barrett, along with a surprisingly solid plot. While this is considered a novella, Samantha does an excellent job weaving in a complete story without sacrificing any of the heat. You’ll definitely land yourself on Santa’s naughty list after reading this one but trust me, it’s worth every second.

[Sarah Bennett · Rating 4 out of 5]

Ok so this book made me learn a new term on what Figging is and all I gotta say is ouch! Another great book by Samantha! 3 masked man and their assistant this time! I loved the plot in this one, because it was different and the revenge was sweet! Not going to lie Holly is good at what she does, even if she wasn't hired for it. I can't wait to see what this series shows us!

[Marmom · Rating 3 out of 5]

I didn’t see a trigger list, so here’s a warning for 🩸 play. I find it unlikely she couldn’t figure out they were the same people.

[Suzi McWhinney · Rating 5 out of 5]

Oh sinner…... Forgive me Santa, for I am gonna sin...over and over and over again!!!
Wowsers!! What can one say about a book as filthy, depraved and thrilling as Naughty or Nice?
Please, be sure to read the TW's for this book, as some content may definitely stun the reader....LOL. As my TW's are non existent, I found this ride thrilling....3 masked men, set out to capture and defile Holly, in the best way possible. And they have Holly right where they want her......
As Holly is introduced to her 3 mystery masked men at the work Christmas party, she revelled in every filthy act that they inflicted upon her at the time...unknown to her, she meets them when she fronts up to work on Monday.
Monday comes around way too soon for Holly, as she is still recovering from her tryst at the Christmas party! When she gets to work she is met with not one but 3 bosses. Seems Nick has recruited help in the merger bid that he was filing for....His twin brother, Chris and Saint are an eyeful.....all three men are gorgeous and Holly cannot believe her luck at having these men as her bosses!
So yeh you guessed it....Nick, Saint and Chris are her mystery masked men!
If you loved @SamanthaBarrett #filthy and #dirty series then you are going to love this new Sinners series. Book 1 is a great start and am sure looking forward to further books in this series!

"I take it back, Santa, don’t f3cking forgive me because I plan on f3cking sinning every night for the rest of my damned life!"

[Brea · Rating 5 out of 5]

Christmas in July? Absolutely. Hallmark could never.

I'm convinced Samantha Barrett has a running list titled "Things That Absolutely Shouldn't Be Kinks." Every book she picks one, smiles to herself, and says, "Challenge accepted." Somewhere there's an innocent office supply just trying to do its job, and Samantha Barrett is about to ruin it forever.

This is everything I love about Samantha's books. Masked men, workplace tension, a heroine who refuses to back down, and just enough mystery to keep the pages turning between all the chaos. Holly was witty, confident, and more than capable of holding her own. And that boardroom scene? She absolutely understood the assignment.

The audiobook somehow made it even better. Autumn Ivy gave Holly so much personality, humor, and confidence that I was hooked from the first chapter. And Bryant Walker? Samantha Barrett could write a company handbook, somehow turn it into a kink, hand Bryant Walker the mic, and I'd still be reaching for my earbuds. His voice was smooth, charismatic, and the perfect fit for these heroes. Together, he and Autumn Ivy had fantastic chemistry that made the banter, tension, and emotional moments land perfectly.

I flew through this in one sitting and had the best time. Samantha Barrett has officially earned my trust to take the most random premise, make it completely unhinged, and somehow have me asking for more.

Thank you, Samantha Barrett, for the opportunity to listen to and review this audiobook.

[BookishMarineMama03 · Rating 4 out of 5]

O Samantha Barrett, you are the QUEEN of all things masked men and spice! Naughty or Nice is the first book in the new Malevolent Sinners series and as always, Samantha gives us a depraved, filthy and always unhinged story! Masked men, taboo, forbidden, should I keep going?! Did I mention twins?!

We follow Holly and her three men, twins Nick, Chris and Saint, (Chris's boyfriend) She meets her 3 masked men at her work Christmas party having no idea it’s actually her boss, his brother and his boyfriend. And the HEAT begins. I can't even describe the PURE SPICE in this book! As Holly works through her feelings for these three men who are her bosses at work and her masked men at night secretly wishing they were the same, little does she know! Throw in a stupid ex, (Saint’s brother), and Holly standing as the tough girl she is.

If you loved Samantha Barrett’s Filthy and Dirty series, then you are going to love this new Malevolent series. It’s everything taboo, forbidden and HOT! Book 1 is a great start and I am sure looking forward to further books in this series!

Rate: 4/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 5/5🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️

🖤Masked Men
🖤Primal Play
🖤Twin brothers
🖤MMFM
🖤Forbidden
🖤Why choose
🖤Ex’s brother

🖤THANK YOU Samanth Barrett for being a part of your ARC team!🖤

[Mother Of Dragons 86 · Rating 3 out of 5]

ALC Review provided by Blue Nose audio:

📖: ⭐⭐⭐| 🎧: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️


Girls... if you're looking for a deep plot, this isn't it.

This is a dark, spicy Christmas romance made for one thing: pure steam. Three masked men, an MMFM dynamic, and enough kinks to make Santa blush. Seriously... everything is on the menu. 😏🔥

The plot is pretty light and mostly there to connect one spicy scene to the next, which honestly didn't surprise me. That's pretty much what I expected going into a Samantha Barrett book and this series & just one second, SAMANTHA!! A BANANA!!?

NOW... can we talk about the narrators for a second?! 🥵

Autumn Ivy, Bryant Walker, Walker Williams, and Gabriel Spires absolutely understood the assignment. They brought these characters to life so well that I was sweating right along with them. Their chemistry, emotions, and delivery completely elevated the experience for me. Without them, I don't think I would've enjoyed it nearly as much.

So if you're craving a dark, masked-men, why choose Christmas romance that's more spice than plot, grab your headphones because this cast absolutely delivers. 🔥🎭

[Kristy aka Brooksie · Rating 3 out of 5]

It's Christmas in July, and Santa's helpers are up to no good with a novella in the Malevolent Sinners series

🎧 @bluenoseaudio Presents an ALC of Naughty or Nice by @author.samantha.barrett, Book 1 in the Malevolent Sinners series
🎤Performed in duet multicast (Holly) @autumnivyactsby (Nick) Bryant Walker (Chris) Gabriel Spires & (Saint) @walkerwilliamsvo
⏳Approximate listening time: 3 hours and 15 minutes
📆Release Date: July 15th - bonus content available for free download exclusively in the Blue Nose AUDIO app starting on release day
Preorder Date: July 10th

When Holly starts off her night with a text from her jerk now ex boyfriend saying he didn't want to be in a relationship anymore, the last thing she wants to do is go to a stupid holiday office party. The only good thing about it will be seeing her hot boss who treats her better than any she has had before and pays her way more than any other assistant job out there could offer. When she steps away from the party to use her bosses private bathroom, she comes out to see 3 masked men dressed up in the holiday spirit in his office. The only present they plan on unwrapping is her.

Tropes:
🖤3 Bosses x 1 Assistant
🖤Reverse Harem
🖤Why Choose
🖤Stalking
🖤Masked Men
🖤Forced Proximity
🖤Forbidden Office Romance
🖤Ex's Brother
🖤Twin Brothers
🖤Primal Play
🖤Why Choose
🖤Polyamory Quad

If you are looking for a whole lot of spice with a side of plot for the holidays, ho ho ho, you have found it! This is extra spicy, everyone is involved and most times all at once. If you are squeamish about some open-door romance scenarios, check the menu list before reading this book. It may include things that are not your cup of tea. If you are down for anything, sit back and enjoy the ride.

Thank you to Bluenose Audio for the ALC of this in exchange for an honest review. This was very steamy, and with the summer heat on top of all that, I need an ice bath.

[Shedevilreads Bookstagram · Rating 5 out of 5]

Naughty or Nice by Samantha Barrett is a why choose masked men romance novella that I listened to on audio narrated by Autumn Ivy, Bryant Walker, Walker Williams, and Gabriel Spires. This is the first book in the Malevolent Sinners series and can be read as a standalone.

This is the third book of Samantha's that I have read, and it won't be my last. I was pulled in from the first chapter and couldn't help but binge the book in one sitting. I loved the chemistry between Chris, Nick, Saint, and Holly. I really enjoyed getting all of their points of views throughout the book. It really brought the story to life.

Autumn, Bryant, Walker, and Gabriel did an amazing job on the narration. They all really know how to bring a story to life. I look forward to listening to more of their work in the future.

I would recommend this book if you're looking for a quick steamy read with masked men, why choose, and an office romance.

[Kelly · Rating 2 out of 5]

2.5 stars for Holly, Nick, Chris and Saint's story.

Holly works for Nick. He hired her even though she has little to no experience. Chris is Nick's twin and Saint's boyfriend. All three men work together. At the company Christmas party Holly is visited by 3 men in masks and gets the present she's been wishing for, and more.

The plot isn't there until the last half of the story. The spice is there from the beginning. For me to get to a 5 star, the whole story should have been rearranged and the plot made known from the start--it's not a bad plot! As for the characters? Holly is just stupid to not have seen what was going on and who with. Her come back was great but would have been better had she realized things sooner and kept quiet about it. The spice? If anything, read it for this.

[Jennifer Wycech · Rating 5 out of 5]

Office setting
Boss x employee
MMFM why choose
Masked MMC’s
Christmas time
Multi POV - 1st person

Duet multicast narration - Autumn Ivy, Bryant Walker, Gabriel Spires, & Walker Williams

Merry Christmas in July to me! First off thank you Blue Nose Audio for this ALC.

I had a wonderful experience listening to this smutty little Christmas book. Samantha Barrett writes some fantastic spice and the plot along side the spice was an added bonus. I enjoyed the characters and the story. The spice was spicing hard in this short listen.

The duet multicast narration was chefs kiss! Autumn was a fantastic choice for the FMC she performed her perfectly. Bryant, Gabriel, and Walker were fabulous MMC voices. I have a soft spot for Gabriel Spires I freaking love his voice.

Overall, if you’re in the mood for some spice with a side of plot and a holiday vibe then this is the book you need.

[Kathy · Rating 4 out of 5]

If you’re looking for a holiday read to make your summer festively hotter or something to add to your TBR for the winter months that will warm you up…This one brings the heat 🔥 It’s a good, quick listen that’s light on the plot and heavy on the spice and definitely more naughty than nice. I enjoyed it.

Performed in duet multicast by Autumn Ivy, Bryant Walker, Gabriel Spires, & Walker Williams.
They did not disappoint with their performances. Their voices worked so well for the characters. Great cast! 👏

Don’t miss out on the bonus content that will be available for free download exclusively in the Blue Nose Audio app starting on release day. Loved it!

Thank you Blue Nose Audio for the opportunity to listen to this ALC!

Story 3.75 ⭐️’s
Narration 5 ⭐️’s
Spice 4 🌶️’s

This does come with trigger warnings so check them if you need to.

[Hayley Edwards · Rating 5 out of 5]

✨Book Review ✨

I've just Finished Naughty or Nice by @author.samantha.barrett

This book was short, dirty and addictive from the very first page

Smut is the plot and I loved every single second of it

It was fast paced one handed Christmas read.

The chemistry was hot and the vibes were sizzling between them all and it was pure festive filth

I love Samantha Barrett books and this one was up there with all the others she has wrote

I won't look at another candy cane in the same light.

Can't wait for the next one in the series

Please check your trigger warnings

What to expect:
🎅Masked Santas
🎅Why choose Romance
🎅Taboo
🎅MM in harem
🎅Peroid Play
🎅Candy canes

Out Now on kindle unlimited and ebook and paperback.

[Jomy · Rating 5 out of 5]

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Naughty or Nice by Samantha Barrett is everything I wanted in a bold, festive read and more. This book blends holiday charm with that deliciously wicked edge Barrett does so well — it’s playful, flirty, and full of tension that keeps you smiling (and swooning). The setting gave me warm, cozy vibes mixed with spicy fun, and I was totally here for every scene.

What really makes this a 5-star read for me is how it balances sweet moments with irresistible chemistry and fun holiday chaos. The characters are magnetic, the banter is sharp, and the romance hits those perfect joyful-with-a-side-of-heat vibes. If you’re looking for a Christmas read that’s both merry and memorable, Naughty or Nice is absolutely worth your time. 🎄

[Corrie · Rating 3 out of 5]

Audiobook - 3/5

I went into this audio completely blind, and I’ll just say that this is probably one of the dirtiest books I’ve ever listened to…and that says A LOT!! “Naughty or Nice” is definitely one of those books that’s 10% plot and 90% spice, so you have to definitely be in the mood for this one HAHA!

Ermmm…I wasn’t really a fan, but I also didn’t hate it. It made me laugh out loud several times, so I think that’s a win. I learned about some kinks that I had never heard of before, so I’m considering this a learning experience lol.

When it comes to the narrators of this novel, I think they did a spectacular job! The voice acting was executed flawlessly!

- Characters: ⭐️⭐️
- Storyline: ⭐️
- Narration: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
- Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️+

[MHT Books · Rating 5 out of 5]

Samantha Barrett NEVER disappoints with the wild smut filled stories (especially the seasonal ones). I love the fact that she can teach me about new kinks I never knew existed. Figging! It’s wild. I’m 1000% here for it. Holly (FMC) gets more than her stocking stuffed by Chris, Nick and Saint. Picture this, 3 masked men with Santa beards and woman they’ve been stalking. It’s so hot. Do not read this in public unless you can do it with a straight face, I could not. I was gasping and ended up in a damn puddle. We get a duet multi cast with this audio book performed by Autumn Ivy, Bryant Walker, Gabriel Spires, & Walker Williams. These 4 were chefs kiss working together. Please check those trigger warnings as this book has some taboo things not everyone will be comfortable with.

[Lian Carver · Rating 5 out of 5]

Who wouldn't wanna be on Santa's naughty list if you are ravaged by three masked men?
This book is filthy? depraved and pure deliciousness!!!

Do check TWs before reading as theu may trigger some.
Anyway... I loved the MMCs and what makes it better there are TWINS! and I wish I was the FMC in this club sandwich.

I absolutely live this book amd is up there with all of Samantha's books. I cannot wait for more, and hope i dont need to wait too long!!!

I will always recommend these books to anyone and everyone who will listen - oh and P.S. make sure you have enough batteries on hand - if you know what I mean 😉 😏

[Stacey · Rating 4 out of 5]

Naughty or Nice is the first book in the Malevolent Sinners series and well there certainly was a whole lot of naughty going on from the first chapter of this little Christmas tale. We jump straight into the story with Holly attending the work Christmas party where she is introduced to her three masked men who have had their eyes on her for longer than she knows. Nick, Saint and Chris turn out to be more than she had planned for this holiday but they are not going to let their snowflake go. Check your warnings before starting this story to make sure it is something you would enjoy but if you like very naughty Santa's with masks then this will be a Christmas tale you will enjoy!!!

[Kacie Mummawh0reads.x · Rating 4 out of 5]

⭐️4🌶️3💧0

A lot of naughty and a truckload of spice! This smutfest has minimal plot that leaves you wanting more but my god what we do get is delicious!
Be warned. This one does contain some unhinged males who like to *ahem* “play” with food to make things interesting lol


#smutreader #darkromancereader #steamybooks #bookrecs #steamyreads #audiobook #bookaholic #readingtime #bookshelf #instabooks #bookblogger #bookreview #booktok #reading #booklover #bookworm #booknerd #goodreads #aussiebookstagrammers #aussies #australianreaders #bookstagram #bookstagrammer #readersofinstagram #instabook #booksofinstagram #booksarelife #spicybooklover

[MissWho · Rating 5 out of 5]

HO HO Holy Fork That Was HOT! 🥵

Holly gets ravaged by three masked Santas on her boss's desk at her office Christmas party... the rest is history!

🎅 Masked Men
🎄 Why Choose Romance
❄️ MM in the Harem ⚔️
🎅 Taboo
🎄 Period Play
❄️ Candy Canes on Tour 👀🤣

Don't be coming into this expecting some cheesy Hallmark Christmas love story because you won't get one. The smut is the plot, and boy, do the smut be smutting!!!

This is a fast-paced one-handed Christmas read and randomly not the first book with figging in that I have read this week (I don't know what that says about me 🙈).

Read the content warnings beforehand and happy reading! 😊

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶🌶🌶🌶🌶

[Fiona Reads ☁️🧸🪬🎧🗡️ · Rating 4 out of 5]

Forgive me Santa I know I’ve been a naughty girl you can put me on the naughty list 😂

Audiobook 5 stars the narrators were perfect I love a multicast audio it’s my fave and this was perfect. If you’re looking for a fast pace spicy book with some plot throwing in to give ya that little bit of happiness in your life you think you’re missing this is perfect 😜

Why choose
Masked men
Boss x employee
Extra spicy 🌶️


I love how they become obsessed with her and then growl near the end cause she’s done taking shit, and when she’s called snowflake ❄️ I’m sorry but I’m obsessed.

Fave paced spicy palette cleanser sure treat yourself you naughty little slut 😜😂 masked men are waiting 👀🎧 do the audiobook trust me you’ll be thankful you did

[Sara · Rating 2 out of 5]

2.5 ⭐️

If you’re looking for Christmas smut and little plot than this book is for you but be prepared for lots of period s|e|x (I swear this FMC was always on her damn period 😐) and to learn about figging (ouch!)

I would’ve gave it more stars but the FMC was just dumb for not realizing who her three masked men were. Some things were just too damn corny, like them all painting their 🍆 as candy canes lol.

It was a fun listen (thanks Blue Nose Audio) but even that was a bit much. There were moments that the FMC narrator was overly dramatic and seemed like she was screaming into the mic.

BUT if you want to read a Christmas p0rno check it out.

[Billie Leonard · Rating 5 out of 5]

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Samantha Barrett does no wrong! I haven't read a single book by her that I didn't love. Now, I'm not usually a huge why choose fan, but this one had me absolutely hooked.

This book is basically all spice from beginning to end, and I am not complaining. It's a fast, addictive read that I flew through in one sitting. At this point, I'm slowly building my Samantha Barrett shelf because she just doesn't miss.

A girl. Three masked men. Every fantasy she's ever wanted coming true. Honestly... what more could you ask for?

If you're looking for a quick, steamy read that delivers exactly what it promises, this one's definitely worth picking up.