Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Something Wicked: Why Feminism Can't Be Fused with Christianity

Rate this book
The culture wars have raged for decades, but with seemingly little success. Christians are losing the cultural battle for family, life, and faith. But why?

In this riveting look at the underbelly of feminism, Dr. Carrie Gress lays out why pro-life and pro-family efforts have failed to deliver. Feminism has quietly captured the minds and hearts of women by mimicking aspects of Christianity. Through its own “commandments,” “virtues,” “evangelization,” and even “a sacrament,” feminism has become an exceedingly powerful megachurch.

While Christians have targeted the specific products of the feminist ideology, such as abortion and transgenderism, we have missed the bigger picture of how feminism’s shadow church has captured the psyche of Western women.

Feminism is all too often perceived, even among Christians, as something virtuous that affords women true equality and freedom. Dr. Gress overturns this misconception, smashing the idol of feminism and exposing its deeply anti-Christian origins.

Drawing from history, psychology, philosophy, culture, and common sense, Dr. Gress

How early feminists opposed traditional Christianity and espoused occultic practicesSix ways feminism has become its own religion that mimics the Christian faithWhy the feminist idol of women’s autonomy can never lead to happinessHow the prioritization of masculine virtues devalued the vital gifts of womenWhat happens when Christians try to blend their faith with feminismWhy the restless search for identity by many adrift in culture is really a grasping for homeThe vital role that men and the patriarchy play in meeting the needs of all of societyDr. Gress lays out solutions to how womanhood can be viewed afresh, without feminism’s menace, healing the ever-growing rift between the sexes, reconnecting the essential bond of empathy between mother and child, and restoring God to his rightful place in the hearts of all women.

263 pages, Kindle Edition

Published January 20, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Carrie Gress

17 books234 followers
Carrie Gress is a Fellow at the Washington, D.C.-based think-tank, Ethics and Public Policy Center and a Scholar at the Institute for Human Ecology at Catholic University of America.

Carrie Gress has a doctorate in philosophy from the Catholic University of America and was the Rome bureau chief of Zenit's English edition. She is the co-author with George Weigel of City of Saints: A Pilgrimage to John Paul II s Krakow and the author of Nudging Conversions, published by Beacon Publishing in 2015.

A mother of four, she and her family live in Virginia.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
61 (48%)
4 stars
39 (31%)
3 stars
16 (12%)
2 stars
6 (4%)
1 star
3 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 22 of 22 reviews
288 reviews5 followers
January 22, 2026
Interesting book. The main point is that as the subtitle says Feminism is not compatible with Christianity. In fact as the book points out it is working against it from its 1st wave roots to the very current time. The founders for example hated the Christian way and found it to be slavery.

The book traces the waves of feminism and the ever expanding philosophy that want to cancel out all others. This philosophy now encourages the outright competition and cancelation of men while having women try to act or be more like men.

Feminism now has cast women as only being fulfilled when they work and have their own money do not have the shackles of kids or even the need for a man. This has led to many unhappy women and men for that matter who try to fill the vacuum with lesbian lovers or multiple lovers etc. This has led to a much more medicated and suicidal group of women.

Chapter 4 is brilliant, withe the 3 commandments:
1. Thou shalt be promiscuous. This leads to high body counts and a make and break pattern that is hard to undo. It points out that it leads to hating men while becoming like them. Shallow and only wanting to satisfy a bases sexual desire.

2. Thou shalt hate men:
This chapter points out how feminism has, maybe without knowing it ruined men and by disallowing their God given directives of protecting (women), providing, and procreating. see pg 91. During the sexual revolution this gave men great access to sex but without clear direction of who to protect and provide for. This is most obvious in the black community where there are very few real fathers of households.

3. Thou shalt engage in the occult:
I had no idea about the long history of connection of feminism and the occult. It makes sense though as furtherance of destruction of image of God in humans.
I learned of celebrities who are open about their occult involvement: Gisele Bundchen called herself a "witch of love" Actress Emma Watson publicly expressed her gratitude for her coven. Vanessa Hudgens of series Dead Hot about witches and spirits filmed in Salem Massachusetts.

This book is well worth a re-read. It goes far past its subtitle to highlight the impossibility of fusion of Feminism and Christianity to solutions for us as Christians and our response to the pressure of the world to be like them.

The section on new neurological look at left and right human brain theory is fascinating. How we all need both left and right brain harmony to be complete humans in God's image. This is take it seems from the book by McGilchrist "The Master and His Emissary"

I am not sure what to do with chapter 8 on Pope John Paul II and the broader topic of what to do with Catholicism. I took away 2 things: 1. I am not Catholic, this I knew but ... 2. Not everything Catholic is bad and we can learn much from the Catholics who love our Savior.

Contents:
Introduction

Part I The New Woman
1. Dismantling Christianity (1790-1900)
2. Building the New Woman (1900-1960)

Part II The Shadow Church
3. A New Idol: Autonomy
4. Three Commandments
5. The Sacred Rite: Work
6. The Gospel of Discontent and the Sacrament of Abortion

Part III Christian Feminism
7. Christian Feminist Fusion
8. Pope John Paul II's New Feminism

Part IV Restoration
9. Ideological Exit
10. Restoring What has been Lost
Profile Image for Emma Wright.
53 reviews6 followers
April 9, 2026
Full disclosure that I had already read quite a few (negative) reviews of this book before getting around to reading it, and was previously somewhat biased against Dr Gress from a previous read of her “Anti-Mary Exposed”. It seems there is quite a lot I agree with Dr Gress on in the grand scheme of things, and I am not in any way particularly married to the necessity of the term feminist, so my objections here are certainly not due to wildly different worldviews or priorities.

My objection is primarily that her thesis is poorly structured and supported, and smells frequently of cherry picking, confirmation bias, and common neo-conservative intellectual cop outs.

My main objections:

- she cherry picks who she counts as feminist and who she doesn’t, and only uses as examples women who support her theory of feminism as inherently tied to Unitarianism, the occult, failed relationships, and socialism. There certainly are are plenty of these women, and plenty of threads of feminism that bear the impact of that, but it’s a narrow and clearly self serving definition that she takes

- she makes HUGE and frankly absurd logical leaps (“Pope Leo 13th was a virulent anti feminist! I mean he never said that and didn’t even know what feminism was but he spoke out against socialism so basically the same thing”) and in a lot of places will drop something crucial and then dip without ever supporting it, as if she assumes (or hopes?) we are just automatically on board

- she attributes a lot of rightly named ills (aggressive individualism, breakdown of gender relations, loss of thick community, abortion/divorce/birth control/etc etc) to feminism as inherent to feminism, when they are imo more rightly attributed to other movements of modernity (the Industrial Revolution, enlightenment philosophy, dualism, etc) and are not necessarily inherent to feminism at all

- she consistently sets up Catholicism as a patriarchy and uses patriarchy as an ideal, but does not ever define what she means by a patriarchy, what that looks like politically, what rights women can or should have in it, and how it may or may not differ from other religions’/cultures’ patriarchy. This actually is one of my biggest objections because my personal hot take is that a lot of what modern Catholic trads look at lovingly as a patriarchy is a very modern, very Protestant understanding that flies in the face of Catholic patriarchy

- there is zero acknowledgement of the ugliness of the historical sexism that gave rise to feminism and zero acknowledgement of ANY good coming out of feminism, despite her own PHD and the litany of review quotes from female doctors, lawyers, and professors….. need I say more?

This book was not a waste of time to read, but it’s recklessly confident enough that I’d be quite cautious recommending it to anyone who didn’t have a firm grasp of the subject matter ahead of time.
Profile Image for Kathryn.
93 reviews7 followers
April 9, 2026
I only got about halfway through. I can't disagree with any of her facts or analysis, but there is something off-putting about her writing that doesn't sit well. Her views may not technically be inaccurate, but seem very narrow and missing an even larger picture about the cause of our current cultural crisis.
Profile Image for Abby Jones.
Author 1 book42 followers
March 19, 2026
I bought this book as soon as I heard it had been published... then waited weeks and weeks for it to ship because it was backlogged for a while. This is going to be a short review. I would like to write a longer review, but I'm not sure I'm going to have time to do that. It may have to wait for a re-read down the line.
The main thoughts I have are a comparison between this and The End of Woman: How Smashing the Patriarchy Has Destroyed Us. This was actually an easier read, but I didn't devour it and immediately re-read it like I did *The End of Woman*. I would recommend it if you want to start studying how feminism has hurt women and where it has taken us and why. I would recommend *The End of Woman* more.
I appreciated Gress attempting to stick to the basic tenants of Christianity so this book could be read by both Protestants and Roman Catholics. Overall, she did a great job, but due to the nature of this book, her Catholicism is part of the point, and so there were places of vast theological differences. If you aren't relatively familiar with these theological differences, I would hesitate to recommend this book and simply point you back to *The End of Woman*.
I enjoy reading this so close to The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self: Cultural Amnesia, Expressive Individualism, and the Road to Sexual Revolution. They quote from a lot of the same authors, and it helped me understand the context of Wicked.
I loved the chapter on work. It was very balanced and beautiful.
This book had a lot to chew on. It produced a lot of discouragement with the women of our world and a lot of encouragement for the woman attempting to divest herself of the feminist mentality. After reading *The End of Woman*, I began to loath much modern storytelling because all I could see was the feminist message. This happened again. I could only see the ugly rage in all the women in all the modern shows. Our nurturing and compassion are almost never on display. More things ruined. :-)
I think my biggest takeaway was having my growing frustration that all my favorite decorating and fashion things are currently associated with witchcraft fed. I, as a woman, a Christian, and a homemaker, have to be careful having things like feathers, bells, shiny rocks, cool sticks, bones, candles, and herbs in my home. I'm not a witch. I don't want to be associated with something that is the occult. I do love long black dresses, boots, skulls, the phases of the moon, and stars. I get irritated thinking these beautiful parts of creation are assumed to only belong to the witchy-feminists. This book made me feel that vexation even more.
Profile Image for Dawn Stowell.
228 reviews13 followers
September 29, 2026
Her cure is a trap. Something Wicked makes a confrontational and grossly aberrant claim: feminism is an irreformable “shadow church,” and women must dethrone autonomy and return to a traditional, Catholic vision of womanhood. It’s a powerful articulation of a certain traditionalist longing, while also a deeply flawed guide for actual women.

The author gets the diagnosis right. The modern corporate world is a meat-grinder. Hyper-individualism and careerism have left many women exhausted, lonely, and burnt out. She isn’t wrong about that alienation. Wanting an escape hatch from that grind is a logical defense against burnout.

If the book stopped there, it would be sharp. It doesn’t.

Gress’s origin story is simple: history begins with a God-ordained patriarchal order, nothing exists prior to that. Ancient goddess worship and matrifocal societies, in her view, are pagan deviations born from Eve’s sin of seeking autonomy. Archaeological records show widespread female‑centered religious symbolism and matrifocal patterns in Neolithic Europe and Anatolia long before the rise of Israelite patriarchy.

Her history is myopic. Long before patriarchal religions consolidated power, human spirituality centered on female generative power, fertility, and earth cycles. For thousands of years, the divine was understood as matrifocal, centered on the Great Mother and the rhythms of life. Gress treats this era as mythical or at the very least fabricated. In reality, it’s the foundation her own tradition later suppressed, absorbed, and rebranded.

The Catholic tradition cherry-picked from these so-called "demonic" baskets of berries to extract the very elements they could process and claim as their own. They mashed ancestral goddess lineages into their own theological jams, preserves, and spreads, adding it to their own pemmican because it nourished the human need to make sense of a random, chaotic, and seemingly meaninglessly violent world. By rendering these ancient traditions palatable, they could then rebrand them under a single, patriarchal banner.

It is a historical truth that they took their conquered subjects, stripped away their so-called, "primitive" contexts, and then cast them anew into sanctified forms, turning Celtic goddesses like Brigid into Catholic saints. Gress acts like a witch hunter who doesn’t realize her own lineage is built directly on top of the historically ancestral lines she demonizes. She frames history as Church vs. occult feminism, completely erasing how the institutional Church grew by co-opting these earth-centered traditions to build its holidays, shrines, and calendar. Let alone adopting some of its precepts

Gress argues women are freely choosing a holy homecoming in traditional patriarchy. I see something colder: collective Stockholm syndrome.

Many of these women aren’t reacting to personal corporate trauma. They’re channeling the grievances of a disemployed, economically fractured male population. They’ve learned to hate the modern system by proxy, converting male resentment into female spiritual duty. These women most likely already are living in a male dominated household that slants exposure to the external world towards these male perspectives. They're captive audiences listening to dominant interpretations by the men in their lives. They're secondhand assimilating the news or the radio or the social media through their lenses. Not having established their own, yet.

Then there’s the empathy gap. Gress claims secular women are lost because they reject traditional roles. The truth: many traditionalist women operate from a sheltered vacuum. Protected from systemic inequality, financial abandonment, and domestic abuse, their anti-feminism is purely theoretical. They’ve never fought a real battle for survival, so they can’t comprehend why secular women fought for safety nets.

Gress thinks these women are jumping into a safe haven. They’re jumping into a trap. They’re trading corporate alienation for fragile dependence. It isn’t deep philosophy; it’s an intellectual excuse for a regressive subculture that only works for those already insulated from the consequences.


Gress in her moralistic posturing is actually both amoral and immoral in her positioning. She is incisive on the disease, malformed on the cure, and historically willfully blind to her own foundations. Worth reading if you want to understand Catholic traditionalism’s view of feminism. Not worth reading if you want a framework that accounts for real history and real-world risks.

Provocative, yes. Grounded in truth, no. A firmly declared and declarative, "NO."
1 review
March 16, 2026
Overall a good book. I don’t think the audio version did the book justice. I think reading the physical book would have been much better. But I still enjoyed the content and would recommend to others.
Profile Image for Kayla.
205 reviews2 followers
June 26, 2026
Notable quotations:

The engine driving the fertility fiasco is the empty promise of sexual and financial freedom now believed by most women and endorsed by bad men. It sits well in the adolescent heart, but at some point, the adolescent needs to grow up and realize that life is about much more than having a lot of friends, flying first class, and being able to fit into leather pants. The female heart is made for much more. A look at the data related to happiness metrics, such as divorce, substance abuse, STDs, suicide rates, and use of antidepressants (now used by one in four women in the United States) reveals that women are not happier because of feminism and its many waves, even if they are more medicated (p. 69).


Abortion is offered as a panacea, with women turning to abortion not just as a possibility but as a right to safeguard themselves from the consequences of their behavior if their bodies betray them by functioning precisely as they were designed and they conceive a child (p. 87).


Misplaced compassion, then, is the spirited and idealistic motivation behind women "saving the world." Women have been sold the idea that they can love and serve people abstractly, people "out there," while ignoring, neglecting, or avoiding altogether the people we are supposed to be loving who are close to us. This is how we get the woman who works for PETA but aborts her own children or the repeatedly divorced social justice warrior. "Love" in this form of misplaced compassion is an abstraction, something out there. It requires very little intimacy, vulnerability, and self-sacrifice, although appearing to be godly. It creates the noble narcissist (p. 117).


As Luke Burgis explains, "Ideologies [like feminism] are closed systems of desire. They provide clear constraints about what is acceptable or not acceptable to want." With feminism, it is acceptable to want to go to work, get a college education (no matter what debt you might incur), forgo having a family, and freeze your eggs for future use when it might be a more convenient time to have children. What isn't acceptable to want, as the feminist propaganda makes clear, is getting married young, having lots of children, and not working outside the home. But what is even more sinister than the options that feminism restricts is the way in which they are restricted. Anything that doesn't fit the feminist narrative is either ignored as irrelevant or demolished as oppressive. Burgis explains, "The salient feature of any ideology is the violence that it both covers up and constrains. In other words, an ideology keeps a group safe from intruders who might bring with them an infectious strain of thought. There is no room for opposition." Ideas that don't quite align with the feminist narrative have to be crushed to maintain control of how and what people think (p. 73).
Profile Image for Cassidy Elaine.
36 reviews6 followers
August 1, 2026
Extremely powerful book by Dr. Gress. Her analysis of early feminists and the philosophy of feminism itself is very revealing. This book will only appeal to people with genuine open mindedness about feminism. If you view feminism rigidly as the only solution for women’s challenges in the world, you will have a hard time with this analysis. Not because it’s not persuasive (it is very persuasive), but because many feminist women intentionally isolate themselves away from anyone who presents an alternate view. Feminists seek an echo chamber — many of them will engage in “mean girl” behavior towards you if you challenge the ethical-ness or correctness of their philosophy. I think many reviews of this book reflect that narrow-mindedness. It reminds me of the fact that early feminists were this way too — very impacted by personal traumas (and chronically unhealed), and therefore sometimes quite reactive when triggered. If you believe your only safety as a female from oppression is in feminism — you can see how someone with significant past personal traumas that are unhealed may react with the intention to cause personal harm to Dr. Gress or those agree with her (like me) when feminism is rebuked. Attacks are not objective analyses. They are a reminder that wounds exist — and that feminism has failed to rescue them from this hurt. The path to healing and meaningful relationships is found in the Lord Jesus Himself. As it’s been said by Sheologians, “Feminism won’t save you.” But Jesus will. Restoration of our personal relationships with God, psychological healing from personal traumas, and regaining our ability to value men and family are essential to gaining health and wholeness as women. Dr. Gress emphasizes these points powerfully in “Something Wicked.”

I will note one way Dr. Gress and I differ. I am a Protestant and therefore do not agree with some of the Catholic theology presented in the book. But, majority speaking, we are on the same page that feminism has been extremely damaging to our world and is the engine behind abortion.

Thank you, Dr. Gress, for your boldness and moral clarity. I love your book and I love your mind. You are a rare intellectual.
Profile Image for Lindsay.
65 reviews2 followers
June 24, 2026
I was really hoping for more from this book, but I was left underwhelmed and with many complaints. I will say, though, the narrator for the audiobook, Lisa Baarns, didn't do the text any favors. Her style led me to wonder many times if she were AI and if the book were written or supplemented by AI. (To be fair, there were plenty of sentences, sections, and throw away call-outs that *did* feel like AI and made me wonder about the quality of her other books.)

Gress came in strong with quotes and stories from heavy hitters of First Wave Feminism. I had hoped that she would continue in this vein, but instead of following the influences on Feminism, she breaks away too soon and focuses on how the different facets of later waves harm women. Many of these don't get nearly as much air time as they should. There were many times where I knew about extra context that would've supported her arguments that she didn't include. On the other hand, there were also many things she mentioned that did nothing to support her arguments and that should have been omitted. For example, *she cites a TikTok video, y'all.* I could not believe it, and I had to do a double take and check that, yes, she was indeed a PhD. She also has a couple paragraphs about how the Enneagram is demonic and uses this to share how New Age spirituality and feminism are deeply entwined. (While it's true that the origins of Feminism often involve folks deep in the Occult, the Enneagram is not worth her time here.)

I digress.

I would have loved for her to expound on the idea of "instead of calling yourself a Christian Feminist, call yourself a Christian," because there are loads of historical accounts of Christianity doing more for the elevation of women than Feminism.

As an alternative, I'm afraid I would have to mention a podcast published by (Orthodox Chritian) Dr. Zachary Porcu. His series on _The Roots of Everything_ (hosted on Substack) titled "Feminism" first got me pulling on this thread, and it was from a commenter there that I first learned about _Something Wicked._
88 reviews4 followers
January 26, 2026
So, to my surprise, this book doesn't actually talk about the musical Wicked (the title and the rainbow on the cover threw me off), though it does mention The Wizard of Oz in a couple of places. This is fine. Actually, Gress goes to work examining the ideological roots of feminism, which turn out to to be Enlightenment Rationalism and Marxism. This puts the movement at odds with Christianity since both sources are distinctively anti-Christian and often anti-woman.

Gress is a talented and clear writer who approaches her subject with a wealth of knowledge. Still, I wish she handled more of the common objections that stress the victories of the feminist movements (like voting and access to the professions) instead of going into the weeds of the phenomenological philosophies of St. Edith Stein and St. John Paul II. Maybe the hope was to rise above these disputes and go deeper? I guess this is fine for the most part, this is fine, but it can feel a little academic and dry sometimes.

All that said, it's still a great read and highly informative for anyone interested in this important issue.
27 reviews
April 10, 2026
How many modern women think they have arrived at their view of a woman through their own clever, independent self-discovery? Wrong. Women have been duped into thinking this way about themselves by centuries of lies and manipulation. Gress explores the history of feminism, helping the reader make connections and recognize the ideas that have "passed like a kind of contagion from one person to the next," ultimately leading to the destruction of true femininity and, by extension, the family. Today, you are a heretic if you go against feminism. Faithful biblical thinking about womanhood (and even personhood) demands it anyway. Want to know why feminism can't be fused with Christianity? Let Gress tell you why.
17 reviews
October 25, 2026
I feel like I would give it 3.5 starts for 2 main reasons that are totally subjective to me.
1. It is very scholarly, so for those looking for an informative deep dive into feminism, this book indeed accomplishes that. However, for the average reader, it may be a bit heavier of a read. I found it a bit difficult at times to keep track of the names within history, ect.

2. I found the book wore me down slightly because the content was pretty depressing for most of it. It's Definitely not light reading, and it is serious in subject matter.

All things considered, Dr.Gress did a very thorough job investigating and explaining feminism, even though I struggled to understand all of it.

Good book. Not for light reading though!
Profile Image for cellomerl.
657 reviews1 follower
March 18, 2026
This is a pretty special book. We’ve all been well trained to believe that feminism is a force for good, and in fact Gress shows that it’s exactly the opposite. “Feminism” is by definition a divisive Marxist philosophy and is responsible for many decades of unhappiness among some of the richest people in the world. Despite its “caring face” it is hypocritical and completely incompatible with Christianity.
(Note that anything called an “ism” doesn’t have much going for it, usually it is some garbage based on unchallenged assumptions and only causes a lot of human misery.)
82 reviews2 followers
March 1, 2026
Great premise

This book has a great premise. It's just slow on delivery. If you have a degree in philosophy it will be a great read for you. Its a struggle to stay engaged in a book that speaks so far above your head that Google becomes an interpreter of sorts.

I loved the premise and I loved Gress's points. I wished that she had spoken so succinctly throughout her book as she did in the beginning and the end.

Profile Image for Christy Wedding.
16 reviews
October 18, 2026
Putting to words what I felt happening

Carrie Griess shows us how feminism only tears down the fabric of society by destroying women. We see the fruit of this with women cheering for abortion and cheering for a woman who murdered her children. Something Wicked shines the light on how I felt as a young mom. I wasn't supposed to be happy and it was so confusing. I wish I had Carrie's book back then.
Profile Image for Carole Duff.
Author 2 books10 followers
June 28, 2026
A clear-eyed view of feminism and the bargain with Marxism, both allied in destroying Christian values, and how Christian Feminism is an oxymoron. There is hope—and a way back. Well-written; I took tons of notes. Highly recommend.
87 reviews2 followers
July 8, 2026
Something Wicked

I found this book difficult to read as well as to fully understand. And I have to admit I skimmed significant parts. I believe a strong foundation for the evolution of feminism over the decades is a must to grasp and synthesize all this work provides.
Profile Image for Stephanie Sabo.
16 reviews
November 19, 2026
I don't disagree with anything, and I think it's an important topic. I just didn't really find anything about it profoundly enlightening that sets it apart from her other books. Also, the audiobook is awful. The voices and accents were insufferably pretentious.
27 reviews3 followers
February 18, 2026
Excellent and important work by Dr Carrie Gress stresses the importance of men and women to complementary not in conflict.
Profile Image for Noelle.
4 reviews
March 22, 2026
Good but her Anti- Mary Exposed was better for my taste.
Profile Image for Laura.
118 reviews
May 10, 2026
Worth the read in a culture trying to destroy Christian women and real values. Gives an interesting history of the roots of tearing women away from Jesus and the church.
Displaying 1 - 22 of 22 reviews