In 50,000 acres of remote Scottish mountains and moor sits Dorcha a former hunting lodge nestling amongst ancient forests, on the shores of the enigmatic 'Black Loch'. At night, lights glow from within, smoke curls from its chimneys, and in the forgiving murk of the gloaming, it looks magical. In daylight, its mouldering plasterwork and failing plumbing present a less romantic reality.
Dr Ava Dickens has come to Dorcha to visit her godson, Alastair – a young man whose parents' sudden death has taken him from a quiet life in academia to owning Loch Dorcha. He and his very new wife are convinced the only way to make the estate work is to run the Hall as a hotel. But Ava is a rigorous scientist, her specialty animal behaviour, and she is by no means certain that the evidence is indicative of a successful outcome.
When one of the hotel guests is found dead in his bed, having gulped down poisonous insect repellant rather than the whisky sitting next to it, Ava's knowledge of the female Culicoides impunctatus – aka the Highland midge – leads her to doubt that it was an accident. And worse is to come…
I appreciate the author’s attempt to weave fragments of her extensive knowledge into the book, but unfortunately, I didn’t find the plot compelling enough to sustain such lengthy descriptions of wasps or bees or mushrooms.While these details are clearly well researched, they seemed to overshadow the story rather than enrich it. I pushed myself to keep reading but unfortunately, I couldn’t bring myself to finish it.
I may be an outlier here, I found the plot to be plodding and padded out with an excess of technical detail. I had sussed the murderer about 3/4 of the way through mainly because the character was so unbelievable. There was a twist of sorts but when a book needs a chapter to explain the links between the many facets of the plot I do question the plot. Descriptions of the Scottish Highlands are very rewarding, but I found the characters to be a little 2 dimensional with Ava being one of the most irritating amateur sleuths I have encountered.
The Scottish Highlands are one of my favourite places to visit, after many wonderful summer holidays over the years, so reading this brought back lots of great memories. Couple that with a deeply atmospheric whodunit ( one of my favourite genres ), and this really was right up my street.
With a wonderfully crafted and varied cast of characters, each and every one I found to believe and to feel real, and a storyline packed to the brim with great twists and turns, I flew through this in two sittings.
I picked this book up thinking it was a murder mystery with a Loch Ness Monster they would have to deal with. Unfortunatley I was wrong and it was the worst beasts in the Scottish Highlands... Midges.
A great murder mystery despite catching on slowly in the middle but a great story nonetheless.
Loses half a star because there's no monster.
I recommend this to anyone who is a fan of murder mysteries.
Good yarn, and very nicely written. The natural history bit got a bit repetitive, but the characters were fun and broadly enjoyable. Maybe more of a 3.5 star from me, but good all the same.
‘The Beasts of the Black Loch’ is the brilliant beginning to a beastly new series! This was the first book of the author’s that I have read, but it won’t be the last as I thoroughly enjoyed everything about it. It has all the hallmarks of ‘golden age’ crime fiction, with a female protagonist that is quirky, intelligent, and just goddamn interesting!
Dr Ava Dickens, an eminent zoologist, is on her way to Loch Dorcha to spend time with her godson, the new Laird. Alastair’s parents have recently passed away in a car accident, and he is struggling with the new responsibility. He and his wife have turned The Hall into a hotel and have a merry band of guests staying. One of whom is found dead after a night of heavy drinking; the police believe it is an accident, but Ava isn’t quite so sure, and it is all down to midgies…
This has the feel of the best type of crime fiction— that of the period that Agatha Christie, Ngaio Marsh, et al., were writing. Big house— check. Great cast of characters— check. A plucky older woman— check. Feeling of isolation— check. In fact, pick this up from its time period and put it in the interwar years, and it would feel the same for me. Maybe it is the isolation of the house and the relatively antiquated village that gives it that air. All this wrapped up in an assiduously plotted mystery meant that I was a very happy reader.
I flew through this in a couple of sittings, as I was hooked from the start! The writing was engaging, the protagonist was well developed, and the plotting was on point. All the natural history was a lovely bonus. It could have ended up boring, but Ava was unintentionally hilarious whilst spouting her facts! I just adored her, and I can’t wait to see what she gets up to next!
Ava Dickens, zoologist and adventurer, feels more at home in the wild than with people. So much so that she would have happily continued exploring the world but for the sudden death of her closest friends. Now tasked with helping their only child Alistair -- a naïve young university graduate and newlywed -- to transform the family estate into a hotel, she finds herself back in the UK and thrust into the role of godmother. But things start to go wrong almost immediately when a guest dies and her scientific instincts tell her it was not an accident.
What develops is a delightfully plotted whodunit contrasting the richness and beauty of the Scottish Highlands in the seventies with the deadly killing spree of a would be serial killer. A charming cast of local personalities and Intricately woven storylines converge to a devious and fulfilling climax well worth the read. The Beasts of the Black Loch is a strong start for this first time amateur detective and one sure to gain Dr Ava Dickens a large following. If you like the style of Sherlock Holmes or Miss Marple, you will feel right at home with this master sleuth.
This book was provided as an advanced reader copy through #NetGalley.
All the references to insect species and their various attributes could have been really boring, but they weren’t. They made the book for me. It was often hilarious.
‘Do you know how many sensory receptors a female midge has on her antennae?’ Dr Ava Wickens asks Professor Wick. ‘Go on guess.’ ‘Surprisingly, no, doctor.’ ‘Have a guess.’ ‘Ten.’ ‘More.’ ‘A million.’ ‘Don’t be ridiculous! The answer is approximately two hundred and forty-one.’
However, I did guess the murderer quite early on even if, like Wick I didn’t know anything about the female Culicoides impunctatus – aka the Highland midge – and I was glad that I was right. Ghastly person!
Ava is like a younger version of Miss Marple, unmarried, no children, and the tenacious grip of a Jack Russell with a frisbee. She’s not going let it go. She bounces her ideas off Wick.
Ava’s godson Alistair has been married to Fiona for barely a year. His parents both died in a car crash. His father was known to be a drunk and no foul play was ever considered. But then Mr Baumgarten is found poisoned in his bed, and the police say he mistook the insect repellent for his whisky, but Ava is not so sure they are right.
My only criticism of the book is that it is rather long, but so many novels are these days. Once I started reading for its own sake rather than getting to the denouement, I really enjoyed it.
Many thanks to @annecater for inviting me to be part of #BeastsoftheBlackLoch #blogtour
What an absolute gem of a book. Bought it while on holiday in Scotland, and read it every evening after days of seeing lochs, mountains and moors. Best combination ever, and every time my brain wasn't actively engaged with something else and just rumbling along at its own pace, I found myself pondering this book. Who of the many interesting characters could have done it, and how? And especially, why? I knew there had to be connections I wasn't seeing, and like Ava and Wick I was making my own lists and endlessly ruminating. I absolutely adored Ava - she's a prime example of how you write a strong female character in a male-dominated world. She's not demonstratively trying to overthrow the patriarchy, she doesn't waste time being offended, she just does her own thing with never a thought about how the men (or women, for that matter) around her might feel about her not keeping her 'proper place'. I see how that's not an option for everyone, but in this book, it works gloriously. The setting was great, the different characters were so well worked out, the plot was clever and interesting and rather funny at times. I loved seeing the world through Ava's consciousness, and even if the book slowed down here and there, I was never bored. A new personal favourite, and a great souvenir.
The first in the Natural History of Murder series set in the 1970’s and I enjoyed meeting unexpected amateur sleuth and zoologist Dr Ava Wheatsheaf Dickens. Called away from her travels Ava is returning to Scotland to help her godson Alistair Muirhead who, following the sudden death of his parents, has inherited the Loch Dorcha estate comprising 50,000 acres of land, including the aforementioned loch and the rather ramshackle Dorcha Hall.
Briefly, Alistair and his wife Fiona have been working at transforming the hall into a hotel and Ava is coming home to provide moral support. However, the death of one of the hotel guests is not the best advertisement for the hotel and to make matters worse Ava is convinced it isn’t an accident. With a lot of potential suspects this is not going to be an easy case and there is more horror to come.
I really liked Ava. She’s a great protagonist, determined and intelligent, a nature loving Miss Marple on steroids! A good plot with a number of threads that all merge seamlessly in an interesting climax. A enjoyable and entertaining crime drama and I’ll definitely be looking out for the next in the series. 4.5⭐️
I loved this book. Gay Marris sets herself a difficult task - controlling a lot of characters and a lot of plot - but she pulls it off with enormous style.
The ensemble cast could, in less skilful hands, become a bit of a Christie parody with its showgirls, German ornithologists and dowdy housewives, but instead the residents of Dorcha Hall are vividly and cleverly sketched, becoming believable and very human. The natural history that is spread throughout the story is neatly done; this is a book that wears its learning lightly. The Hall itself is intensely atmospheric. You can almost smell the dust and the damp.
There are moments of wit and moments of sadness, especially when we are given a fleeting glimpse into Ava's heart. There are also moments of genuine horror. No spoilers, but I for one will never knowingly eat a candied cherry after reading this book.
Overall a thoroughly satisfying read. I am very glad that this is going to be a series because I am looking forward to meeting Ava again.
If you enjoy murder mysteries where the setting is a character in itself and the forensics are grounded in reality, The Beasts of the Black Loch by Dr. Gay Marris is a fantastic read.
Set in a remote, brooding corner of the Scottish Highlands, the story kicks off when a body is discovered near the Black Loch. Traditional forensic avenues quickly dry up, forcing the investigation to look at environmental evidence—soil composition, plant ecology, and insect behavior—to piece together what happened.
Having an actual research scientist write this makes a world of difference. The forensic details feel authentic and fascinating rather than info-dumped, seamlessly weaving natural history into the core of the plot. Marris constructs a wonderfully eerie atmosphere that keeps you immersed in the moody Highland backdrop, paired with a web of local secrets and ecological intrigue that keeps the pages turning.
A brilliant, intelligent crime thriller that stands out from standard procedurals. Highly recommended for fans of atmospheric mysteries and scientific thrillers!
I was kindly sent a free copy of this book as part of a book tour in exchange for an honest review. This book is part of “the natural history of murder” series but reads perfectly well as a standalone. I found the book enjoyable but sometimes found the scientific details a bit overpowering and the language was quite complex in places. It was quite different and I found the writing style quite quirky and almost academic. It’s clear the author has put a lot of research into the book and it really shows. I enjoyed Ava, our main character - she was quite unique and funny and I loved seeing the world through her eyes. I did guess the murderer before the end but it was still a fun read and I thought it was quite a refreshing change from the normal style of murder mysteries. The authors strong point was definitely her vivid descriptions of the setting - the backdrop of the house and the loch almost became characters in their own right they were described with such rich, artistic detail. I will definitely read more books in the series. 3.5 stars rounded up to 4 on Goodreads.
Set in the 1970s in the Scottish highlands, the story starts with the death of Duncan and Shiela in a car crash, the car swerving to avoid a man, although everyone thinks it was a deer. Alastair has inherited the estate and now runs Dorcha house as a hotel. Unfortunately the business is struggling and he has sought help from his godmother Ava. When Ava arrives she meets again, although she cannot remember him, Alastair’s other godparent Wick. There is an eclectic mix of visitors to the hotel, with just Alastair and his wife running everything with the help of a local girl Maggie. Then one of the guest dies, Ava is suspicious but it is ruled unsuspicious. Alasdair seems to be struggling, watched constantly by his wife. A very well written book with lots of twists and an ending I didn’t expect. My thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for the arc
Set against the atmospheric backdrop of the Scottish Highlands, Ava arrives at the stately home of her godson, Alistair, who has inherited his parents’ grand estate and transformed it into a hotel.
With the business struggling and an assortment of eccentric and demanding guests in residence, tensions simmer beneath the surface. When one of the guests is discovered dead in his bed, Ava’s scientific background makes her question whether the death was really due to natural causes.
This was an enjoyable and atmospheric whodunnit with an engaging cast of characters, good pacing, and plenty of well-placed twists and clues. The mystery unfolds cleverly, leading to a surprising and satisfying end. Recommended.
Think of this book as a Nat Geo but with a whodunnit twist!
I loved dr Ava, she’s a big vibe! She’s a scientist that went back to the highlands to visit her godson Alastair, who just (un)fortunately inherited a grand Hall and is trying to turn into a hotel. It’s not going well. And it gets worse when a guest is found dead in their room! The police has ruled out as an accident but Dr Ava has a suspicion it wasn’t, will the hotel survive (unlike its guest) or will this be a dead end for it too?
A perfect locked room mystery, but with enough Latin species naming that it could be a perfect mystery spin off of a Nat Geo documentary.
Thanks to the author, publisher and tour host for this copy in exchange of my review.
3.5 stars. After absolutely loving A curtain Twitchers Book of Murder I was really excited to start the author’s new series. In The beasts of the black we follow our main character Ava, a zoologist, as she goes to stay with her Godson Alistair and his wife who are struggling both financially and with the grief of Alistair’s parents. What proceeds is pretty much a classic murder mystery with lots of suspects and red herrings. My interest was held throughout and I had a fun time although I did predict the villain pretty early on, it was still good to see how it would all play out.
I will definitely read anything this author writes in the future.
I enjoyed this book, which is the start of a new series by the author. I had in mind a younger version of Miss Marple, who had an encyclopaedic knowledge of midges and a keen humour. I did have to read it in a couple of sittings as there’s a lot of information packed into the book and I didn’t want to miss the main storyline points. It’s definitely a fun read and I recommend it. I also look forward to reading more in the series. With thanks to Anne Cater, the publisher and author for the advanced reading copy of this book.
Même si j’ai trouvé le coupable et les explications allant avec peu après la moitié du livre, j’ai aimé le style et le personnage principal. Sa façon de penser et de déduire les choses. Cette petite touche d’humour dans ses explications scientifiques. Je vois que la plupart des reviews négatives sont justement en lien avec la longueur et la répétition de ces tirades de zoologie mais pourtant elles sont clairement bien amenées et au final pour moi, le seul point négatif est que le mystère n’en reste pas un assez longtemps sur l’identité du/de la meurtrier.e
I really enjoyed this book. It was funny, dark and quirky, all at the same time! I love how Gay has used her professional knowledge to create a character who lives her life through her understanding of animals, particularly insects. This enables Ava, (the main character) to see and understand things in ways others cannot. It gives her an edge in the crime solving world. The book has an exciting build up towards the end, where the murderer is revealed! I think the premise of this book is fresh, new and exciting, and I look forward to more adventures in the Natural History of Murder series ❤️
I really enjoyed this murder mystery set on the banks of a Scottish Loch. A fun array of characters especially the female protagonist who I would love to see in more books, a zoologist Marple type. Solid plot and a decent ending it was a good time, though it did not feel like it was set in the 70s but apart from that recommended.The cover is what piqued my interest first. 4 stars.
Even though I guessed the murderer, I LOVED this book. So intelligent and brilliant dialogue and descriptions of characters. Loved Murdoch’s vernacular too. Definitely keen to read other works by the same author. The acknowledgements to the author’s mother brought a tear to my eye. Yey to random finds in the library!
Really enjoyable murder mystery. Lovely writing that really took you up to the Highlands - the flora, fauna, and fabulous Hall! Just the right number of characters for you to understand and keep track of. I'll definitely check out her first novel too