So this book is about two characters, Amelia and Nestore, who were held captive together in the basement of his family manor by her father. They go through a lot of trauma, they are rescued, and the story follows how messed up they are afterward and how their relationship basically comes from surviving all that together. It sounds like it should have a strong plot, but honestly… it doesn’t really feel that way when you read it.
Here’s why:
1. Yes, the book technically has a plot
The main storyline is actually simple and clear:
• They suffer trauma in captivity
• They get physically free, but mentally they’re still stuck
• Amelia leaves because she can’t handle the place anymore
• Nestore spends two years looking for her
• They reunite
• They finally deal with the past (her dad, the manor, his dad)
So it does have a beginning, middle, and end.
But that’s pretty much the bare bones of the story. Nothing is developed as much as it should be.
2. The structure is weak and all over the place
The book jumps around a lot without giving anything real depth.
A. The beginning is the strongest part
The captivity, the trauma, the emotional mess afterward: good setup, clear conflict. It works.
B. The middle completely loses direction
Nestore finding Amelia should be this huge emotional moment, but:
• His anger doesn’t go anywhere
• The whole “I want to hurt you but I can’t” thing gets dropped instantly
• He gets over her leaving way too fast
• Their mental health issues don’t get explored deeply at all
So the emotional tension just fizzles out.
C. Then it throws in random drama
Stuff like:
• Amelia’s little brother getting kidnapped
• The Bratva using a random junkie to attack her
These moments felt like action filler rather than real plot development. They don’t connect to the main emotional story, and they don’t change anything for the characters.
D. The ending is super rushed
Suddenly:
• Amelia kills her father
• Nestore’s dad situation gets one quick scene
• They tear down the manor
• Everything gets “fixed” really fast
None of these moments have enough build-up or emotional weight.
3. The book is more about vibes than an actual plot
Instead of building a strong storyline, it leans on:
• Trauma bonding
• Dark romance vibes
• Psychological tension
• Emotional dependence
But it never really digs into these. It just shows them and then moves on.
4. Final verdict on the plot:
Yes, the book has a plot.
But it’s:
• Underdeveloped
• Rushed
• Kinda episodic (like separate scenes instead of a real story)
• Emotionally shallow in key parts
• Full of random moments that don’t matter
• Missing buildup and payoff
It seriously feels like the author made an outline and never filled in the emotional or psychological depth that should’ve been there.
If you finished the book and felt like it didn’t really have a proper plot, you’re not imagining it. The story moves, but it doesn’t actually develop. It’s like watching someone flip through the highlight reel instead of letting you experience the full movie.
Despite all this, I read the book in just a couple of hours. So even if the plot didn’t fully work for me, it still kept me hooked the whole time.
With my biggest gripe about the book out of the way let's move on to the next section.
Other thoughts (aka the messy part of my brain):
1. The book felt like a mash-up of other Cora books
I kept noticing scenes that felt pulled straight from her other couples:
• Growl/Cara – captivity with a “kept safe but still captive” dynamic
• Romero/Lily – SA attempt, stabbing, rescue
• Luca/Aria – cutting the wedding dress, forgiveness after her “betrayal”
• Matteo/Gianna – running away + wedding right after finding her
• Nino/Kiara – cage-fight scene at Roger’s arena, same worried-from-the-crowd vibe
• Max/Sara – shared trauma from being kidnapped together
It wasn’t bad, but it didn’t feel original sometimes. If you’ve read her other books, you’ll notice it immediately.
2. I actually loved the “we’re each other’s only” thing
Finally Cora listened to readers and gave us a virgin hero.
They were exclusive the whole time, even during the separation.
All their firsts and onlys belonged to each other. I loved that.
3. The fairytale vibes were cute
There was this whole romantic fairytale feeling:
• Nestore’s poetic lines
• Amelia going from broke to luxury
• Beauty and the Beast parallels
• The library
• The rose maze
• The Peter Rabbit detail (their comfort story)
• Reading to each other
Those parts were sweet and worked really well.
4. Nestore’s weird eccentric king/monster personality was interesting
He literally calls himself a king and wants her to be his queen.
He has thrones.
An arena like he’s a Roman emperor.
Exotic animals.
Always wearing that fur coat (the “beast”).
Bone crowns.
A bone knife made from her father’s bone.
Crazy, dramatic, symbolic: very him.
5. But the blood stuff took me out of it
He plays with blood way too much.
And all I could think was:
• HIV
• infections
• what if someone has a cut
• WHY are they always doing this??
It was distracting and kinda gross.
6. And I hated most of the spice
For real:
• The constant ass-eating… no thank you
• Letting other guys see her having sex just because they are going to die after... why??
• Being horny while people are literally dying right there??
It wasn’t sexy. It killed the vibe for me completely. I liked their first time together though, it just went downhill after that.
7. I’m annoyed they didn’t have kids in the epilogue
It’s not far in the future, so I’m hoping it means they’ll have kids later.
She’s 21, he’s 23, they say they don’t feel ready yet.
But I really hope their kids show up in second gen, or I’m going to lose it.
8. The Falcone brothers + Fabiano cameo = highlight of the book
Honestly one of the best parts.
Nestore really fit with Remo.
Remo truly had a soft spot for him.
The brothers + Fabi together were great.
It reminded me of their dynamic before all the wives showed up.
Cora needs to write that prequel so badly.
9. The side characters were actually good
I liked:
• Niccolo (Nestore’s cousin)
• Flavia (Amelia’s stepmother)
• Francoise (the seamstress)
I thought Niccolo might end up with one of them, but no romance happened. Still, he was decent and refreshing.
And finally: a good stepmother for once.
10. About them as a couple
Even though the story didn’t hit perfectly for me, the love between Nestore and Amelia did. Their dynamic worked because of how deeply they’re tied to each other, not just romantically, but emotionally and psychologically.
I loved:
• How obsessed he is with her
Nestore’s devotion is intense in the best way. She’s his only exception, his one and only, the one person he can’t live without. The fact that he can’t stand another woman’s touch, that he wants only her, makes their bond feel true.
• How understanding she is of him
Despite everything that happened, Amelia gets him. She knows his trauma, his darkness, his softness underneath all the eccentricity. Their shared childhood, shared wounds, and shared loneliness make them fit together in a way that feels inevitable.
• Their “we’re everything to each other” dynamic
Lines like “I won’t ever leave you, Amelia. Together forever.” hit hard. He meant it literally. That’s why her leaving hurt him so deeply, it wasn’t just heartbreak, it was betrayal of the one thing he believed he still had in the world.
• Their chemistry was fire
Whatever the plot did or didn’t do for me, their chemistry was undeniable. The tension, the obsession, the tenderness, all of it worked.
• Childhood-friends-to-lovers is my weakness
This trope always gets to me, so I naturally had a soft spot for them from the beginning. The “we grew up together and survived together” foundation made their bond feel stronger and more believable.
That’s why this book felt confusing emotionally, I loved them as a couple, but the overall story didn’t fully match the intensity of my feelings for them.
In the end I feel conflicted. I loved Nestore and Amelia together, I loved their bond, I loved the way they loved each other. The couple themselves worked perfectly for me. The story around them just didn’t live up to what they deserved. So I’m leaving this book with weird mixed feelings. I cared about them a lot, but the book as a whole didn’t hit the way I expected. And maybe that is okay. You can love the characters and still feel like the story wasn’t everything it could have been.