A dark and mesmerizing retelling of Camelot—where magic and destiny entwine with sibling rivalries, forbidden love, and looming rebellion.
Morgause rules as Queen of Orkney. Her doting husband is oblivious of her dalliances, and most everyone is ignorant of her sorcery training and the dark magic she can now wield. Her sister, Morgan, is next in line to become Lady of the Lake, and, together, they are a force to be reckoned with.
When an unknown, modest youth named Arthur pulls the sword they enchanted from the stone at an honorary tournament for the deceased Uther Pendragon, the two sisters gather their considerable power to thwart him. Merlin has been preparing for Arthur's kingship for years, but even he doesn't realize the extent of the sisters' hatred for their half-brother, born of his father Uther's violation of their mother. So begins a plot to bring Arthur down, but Arthur, traveling the country and counseled by Merlin, grows in confidence and in his determination to reign as King, no matter the cost.
Sam Davey's next in this powerful series is a deliciously dark retelling that will cast a spell over fans of the Arthurian legend and historical fantasy fans everywhere.
Arthurian retellings that don’t completely overlook Morgause and the character she is and her role in the story? The best kind of Arthurian retellings. This book focuses not only on Morgause but also on Morgan. But not only the part they play in the legend, there are so many other characters we all know and love, so many twists and turns (we should’ve anticipated, and probably did, but still gasped at the reveals) in the story. And so much more. Arthur is more properly explored as a character, and he’s also the specific brand of Arthur I love. Because I’m a little picky with my Arthurs, and this one was just right. The classic scene of him pulling out the sword from the stone like it was nothing? It will never not give me chills. And also all the other soon-to-be knights! Loved them. Then there’s of course Merlin and all his questionable choices, including (but not limited to) murdering children in cold blood. We all know why the situation unfolded that way, the prophecy of the Beltane child. But still. Cold, Merlin. Cold. Morgause and Morgan do take the lead in this one though. They’re just so interesting to follow, as per usual. The women you know, if you know anything about Arthuriana, aren’t going to end up being the good guys, and the women who still deserve compassion. Understanding, in more than one way. I seriously can’t stress how good this book is enough. While I really enjoyed book one too, this book transcends every expectation I had. I found the writing much more engaging this time around as well, maybe it’s because of the storyline and the way it progressed, but this was just top tier. It’s almost reminiscent of og Arthuriana, and by that I mean retellings that are considered modern classics in the genre. The way Davey describes things, even the most gruesome, is just so vivid. There’s this one scene that felt so real I could see it happening before my eyes. In fact, I’d check trigger warnings, as there are many intense scenes. I absolutely need the next book, stat. This series is just amazing, it keeps getting better. It’s not very short, but I still binge read it in one sitting. What does that tell you? I could go on and on! I’d give this book a 4.5/5⭐️ I loved this. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This is a dark , yet sexy, retelling of Morgan and Arthur's illicit affair that lead to the May Day massacre. I personally really enjoyed this book much more then the first. Morgause is a powerhouse charicter with a saucy attitude and raw sexuality, love her! Morgan is the more conflicted sister but in following Morgause she seduces Arthur with the shape shifting to hide her face. This book proposes many interesting questions surrounding just how far a person will go to achieve a goal. what is to far? What within society and culture defines actions as just or unjust? All these aspects and more are asked in these pages! This is a must for any fan of Arthurian literature and Arthurian legend! Also loved the side characters of Gawain and Agravain.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
In The Sisters and the Sword, Sam Davey constructs an Arthurian landscape that operates less as a traditional heroic tapestry and more as a dark, psychological study of generational trauma, gendered power, and the terrifying idea/concept of fate.
This second installment of The Pendragon Prophecy series gracefully deconstructs the foundational myth of Camelot by pivoting the narrative lens away from Arthur’s burgeoning glory and centering it instead on the fierce, sorcerous interior of his half-sisters: the overlooked Morgause and the infamous Morgan le Fey.
Davey's prose functions like the visions which she made such a pivotal part fo her sorry; an elegant, unhurried, and distinctly melancholy insight into the world of someone else, someone we don’t empathize with inherently. A look into the future or the past to enlighten us further.
The text operates on a structural duality, contrasting Arthur’s external, political ascension with his sisters' internal, ancestral rebellion. SamDavey brilliantly frames Morgause and Morgan's hostility toward Arthur not as arbitrary villainy, but as a righteous, deeply localized fury born of their mother Igraine's historical violation by Uther Pendragon. However, she does not exclude the injustice of there actions. She does not try to absolve them of there crimes or redeem them, she merely offers and explanation. Further context to the story.
She acknowledges the evil of the “bed-trick” and realizes the hypocrisy of it while simultaneously making you feel for these villainous sisters.
The sort of novel acts as an interrogation of patriarchal lineage. The "Sword in the Stone" -traditionally viewed as an artifact of divine endorsement- is reimagined here as a n o next which accelerates and shapes sibling division, a weaponized fracture point that forces women to claim the dark magic of the margins when the center circle of knights excludes them.
Mothers against sons, sisters against brothers, children against fathers, and heroes as mass executioners.
The author handles the psychological nuances of the castes with deliberate intentions.
Morgause’s rule as the Queen of Orkney is captured in layers of artificial compliance and powerful sorcery, which is hidden and yet also succeeds in defining much of the court politics and familial tropes.
Her dynamic with Morgan provides the book with its heart (in the emotional sense) sisterhood forged in the trials of a separated, yet similarly traumatic childhood.
The portrayal of Merlin as a detached, reserved, removed and chilling architect of prophecy emphasizes the stories i nterest in the friction caused by coexistence of agency and determinism.
When Merlin introduces the plain disgusting and brutal solution to the Beltane prophecy, the author elevates the narrative from simple fantasy or feminist retelling to a tragic examination o ff the ethical cost of building an empire.
The prose excels when leaning into imagery detail. the heavy mist of Avalon, the cold geography of Caer Lundein, and the metaphor of a crown purchased through the erasure of the vulnerable.
Yet- the novel can feel stiff at times, as though it is packed to fully with mythological and folkloric elements to allow the story to breathe.
But overall this was such a wonderful book with such a beautiful story!
**ARC Reader disclaimer: I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.**
As someone who'd previously enjoyed going down the occasional rabbit hole on the internet about Arthurian myth and legend, I'd grown somewhat attached and definitely curious about the role of Morgan and the Lady of the Lake — in fact, I'd grown quite dissatisfied by how poorly media reflected them.
So this book was, most definitely, a breath of fresh air — moreover, I was able to learn about Morgeuse, a character I'd never quite knew this much. The first thing I'd like to mention is, how good the character portrayal is in this book: not one-dimensional character (mayhaps a bit shallow, yes, when it came to secondary characters), and our main protagonists were so well written it was a pleasure to read every chapter they were a part of. Even Arthur, the typical hero, was portrayed with such humanity that it caught me a bit out of guard (alas, I did expect the typical hero trope...).
The world-building is quite good, as well, and the politics are explained simply enough anyone could comprehend the court intrigues. The landscapes described, too, are very vivid; detailed enough one could imagine them clearly, but with enough vagueness for the reader to fill in the blank spaces with which felt more natural to them. And the language! The way the characters spoke were such a good detail, and works wonders to induce the reader into the world the author's building.
When it comes to critiques, I can only say that I'd wish there had been a bigger focus on Morgan from the beginning (although I do understand why her sister has the ''spotlight'', per se; she's a somewhat unknown character within Arthurian legend and I understand the author wanting to give her a well-deserved highlight). I'd like, at least, to anticipate with eagerness the arrival of our other protagonist — which I did not.
Besides this, it was a well-paced book, deserving of 4 stars on all of my standards.
Thank you, NetGalley, for the ARC. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Favorite quote(s):
‘"Arthur, the tales we are told as children are full of stories of those who, in a desperate desire to prevent the fulfillment of a prophecy, take actions which inexorably lead to its realisation. Do not be so rash as to become another such misguided fool." Lot reached out and laid his hand upon Arthur's arm.’
Review:
I enjoyed this book and the take it had on the Arthurian Legend. It's the second book in the series, but I think it can also be read as a standalone novel. It's been called a feminist take, but I don't know that I would really call it such. It does tend to focus more on the female relationships and characters than other versions, so maybe in that particular way. The writing is descriptive and pulls you into the story. I did like that there was a focus on friendships and relationships of women. I found both Morgause and Morgan interesting. The prophecy stuff annoyed me in a way because it felt like the characters were making them come true instead of just seeing if they really would on their own. It also felt like Morgause and Morgan were using Arthur as an outlet for their feelings for his father because they couldn't get to Uther after his death. Which isn't fair to Arthur. Arthur was a kind young man who really was just trying his best. I did enjoy him spending time with Morgause’s children. Overall, I enjoyed this and am eager for what comes next with Arthur, Morgause, Morgan, the child, and more.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Thank you to Diversion Books for the ARC through NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
I would describe this book’s essential tale as, “you either die a hero or live long enough to see yourself become a villain.”
I’m in my Arthurian tales era, and The Chosen Queen was a great entry into the subgenre. The Sisters and the Sword is the next edition in Sam Davey’s Pendragon Prophecy series, following The Chosen Queen. We see Queen Morgause (wife of King Lot of Orkney) and her sister Morgan (would it kill people to give their kids more distinct names?), half sisters to the legendary not-yet-King Arthur.
When the young Arthur pulls a sword from the stone during the tournament in honor of the late Uther Pendragon, he unknowingly sets a course of events in motion that will not end until he is King of Britain. But Morgan and Morgause will not cede power to their younger brother so easily.
It was harder to become absorbed in this story compared to the first one. The plot is considerably slower and the characters feel less defined. Especially with Morgause's kids, keeping them straight while reading is a task of its own. The characters’ morals devolve over the course of the story, hence “living long enough to see yourself become the villain,” so that by the end I wasn’t really cheering for anyone’s success, a hard pill to swallow for a reader.
If you like your Arthurian retellings dark, dramatic, and centered on the women usually pushed to the sidelines, The Sisters and the Sword has a lot to offer. [Sam Davey]() leans into Morgan and Morgause as forces in their own right, and that shift gives this Camelot story a sharper, more unsettling edge. I especially appreciated the novel’s willingness to explore how trauma, power, and prophecy shape its characters—even when those choices make them difficult to love.
That said, this was ultimately a 3-star read for me. I admired the premise and the feminist framing, but the pacing felt uneven, and some timeline shifts pulled me out of the story. Even so, readers who enjoy morally messy characters, mythic drama, and darker fantasy retellings will likely find plenty here to discuss.
Content note: this book includes incest, sexual violence, and other brutal material, so I’d recommend it for mature readers.
An intriguing premise let down by its execution. I loved the focus on Morgause and Morgan. They are the heart of the book, ambitious, wounded, and compelling. The atmosphere of Orkney and the dark faerie magic are top notch. However, the male characters, especially Merlin, lack comparable depth. Arthur has more dimension, but his transformation from a naive boy into a king is largely told rather than convincingly developed. His decision to orchestrate the murder of three infants and sacrifice everyone around them feels rushed and psychologically unearned. The book tackles incredibly heavy themes but lacks the psychological weight to truly do them justice. Worth reading for the female characters, but do not expect the emotional depth of Mists of Avalon.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This book takes us where other Arthurian ones don't. I did read book one before I started this one and it does give a great foundation for what happens here. Morgause was a bit of a shock to me as she was quite headstrong and manipulative. Morgan who we are used to being that way is more sneaky and knows how to plant dissention. Poor Arthur is a victim, unwittingly trusting, and Merlin plays a huge role is leading him astray. His half-sisters blinded by how their mother was manipulated and deceived, concoct a plan and do the exact same thing to Arthur. I would have liked a little on Igraine-is she still happy and alive, or did something happen to her? The closing chapters will send a chill through you!
The Sisters and the Sword offers a dark and thought-provoking take on Arthurian legend by placing Morgan and Morgause at the center of the story, giving voice to characters who are often relegated to the background. I appreciated the focus on power, prophecy, and the lasting effects of trauma, and the morally complex cast made for an intriguing reinterpretation of a familiar tale. While the premise was compelling, I found the pacing somewhat uneven, and the shifts in the timeline occasionally disrupted my immersion in the story. Even so, fans of darker mythological retellings and character-driven fantasy may find plenty to enjoy here. Content warnings: incest, sexual violence, abuse, graphic violence, and other mature, disturbing themes, making this a novel best suited for readers comfortable with heavy subject matter.
Camelot retellings always have my heart, and this continues my love for the series. I think Sam's writing can pull you in well, it's so descriptive and has a dramatic flair for the retelling. This book has kept me glued!