This book deserves 5 stars not because it was perfect. Heck, it was FAR from perfect. Some lines were too repetitive, and there were too many internal dialogues that dragged on for way too long. BUT IF A BOOK CAN MAKE ME CRY MORE THAN 20 TIMES, IT DESERVES FUCKING 5 STARS!!
So many things happened. So much pain, trauma, and so many happy moments that I can’t even wrap my head around it. I probably will never forget this series, THEM. 😭
Salvatore’s and Ruslan’s story came like a fucking slap in the face as well. I literally didn’t expect any kind of ending for them or for them to even have any chapters?? BUT THEY DID, AND IT WAS FUCKING PERFECT AND ENOUGH.
I haven’t written long reviews in a REALLY long time, but it came so easily for them 💗🥹
preread :p OMG, I READ SOME REVIEWS AND APPARENTLY THE SECOND BOOK IS EVEN BETTER THAN THE FIRST??? I’M SO FUCKING STOKED!!! 😭😭
This sequel gave me everything I was hoping for after the first book! The plot is significantly stronger here, and the emotion is intense.
Vincenzo carrying that secret alone for eight years was heartbreaking and set the scene for all the yearning. I devoured it. I did get horrified for a minute we were about to get a reincarnation trope unexpectedly. It really broke my heart at the end.
Still, I have to say my heart belongs to Salvatore and Ruslan. Their love story is so sweet, and the pain of their wasted years hurt, but their reunion was absolutely beautiful. I could have read an entire book just about them and their love story, them picking up the pieces of their rough lives, and repairing their relationships with their sons. I needed so much more time with them!
Although I enjoyed this one a lot, I still think this really didn't need to be a duet. With some tighter editing, this could have been a strong single book story. I do love this author's writing and am excited to continue in this universe. I was surprised by the setup for future books. The lack of teasing makes me so curious about who ends up with who!
Honestly night and day from book 1!! I think my review made it pretty clear that I didn't really like most of Conquest, and I was annoyed that I needed to keep reading to find out what happened to Vincenzo and Nikolaj. I usually enjoy this authors books, so it was a surprise to me how much I disliked Conquest, but then the Empire novella was so good and reignited my interest in Vincenzo and Nikolaj, and the conclusion to their story was so, so good!!
I do still have questions which is why I'm not 100% on the 5 star rating, but this book grabbed my attention right from the start and didn't let go. I liked that there was a significant period of time between Conquest and Reign, mostly because it added that emotion and angst that was needed to really want to root for these two to get their HEA. The love between Nikolaj and Vincenzo was so strong in this book. I loved the way they found their way back to each other, and although the price they paid was extreme, the ending felt like exactly what they needed. I do wish we'd seen a bit more of the after though!
I did see the twist coming, but I really liked how it played out and OMG I cried SO MUCH!!!! My eyes are still sore now 😂😂
The relationship between Ruslan and Salvatore was also so sweet to see, but I do wish there was more about them! I loved seeing their relationship in Empire but it was mainly the implosion, so I'd really like to see what happened with their reunion and how they are moving forwards.
The bonus scene with the phonecall was super intriguing too, but it also left me with more questions that I hope are addressed in either the upcoming Dragovich series, or the upcoming Vintmoor series, otherwise it's going to annoy me and make me question why the events at the end of this book even happened!
I am happy to see that Arseniy, Kai, Maksim and Tatiana are getting books because I want to know more about them, I'm just unsure on what the pairings in their books are going to be, particularly because I don't really read MF romance...
I am speechless... this book was so good I don't know how to describe it other than simply incredible. Avery, what have you done? Written? You had my heart in my throat the ENTIRE time. The angst and the yearning between these men had me in a chokehold until the very last pages. I could feel their love through the pages in every look, touch, breath, and moment they were near each other. What I felt in Empire for their fathers came out tenfold in this book, with every part that makes me love romance and heartbreak in the same breath.
These two nearly put me on my knees with how much love was between them and how much it took from them in the end to make sure nothing and no one would keep them apart.
Nikolaj. Pakhan. The Blade. Cuore mio. The Russian who would speak first with his fists before words. He had grown in the years since Vintermoor, and coming out of that, he was not the same. But what he had grown into was someone who let the vulnerability come through and the blade soften to protect the one man he began to remember and would tear the world apart for. No longer afraid to hide, cater to the wills of other men, or let what happened to others in the past dictate his future.
Vincenzo. Italian Lover. Capo dei Capi. Beloved. A man who had to endure eight years of watching the man he loved no longer recognize what they had once started, only to watch that same man undo him with his returning memories and a love of a lifetime for him to hold onto. A man who would give up everything to make sure he never looked in his own eyes and saw the regret Vieri men carried when decisions became no longer their own.
A love that endured more than anyone should, but still found a way to shine brightly, no matter the blood, death, destruction, and violence desperately trying to get in their way. I am so excited to see more behind the Dragovich curtain next. Just brilliant, Avery.
Reign is the intense emotional conclusion to mafia king Vincenzo and bratva Pakhan Nikolaj's love story. Their reunion after eight years of separation, after being set down their their predetermined paths, is filled with unresolved tension and unsettling tension as one remembers their past while another only has glimmers of moments that are left unspoken. This duet brought tears, joy and shock while leaving me exciting for the future of all of these complex characters.
I really loved this concluding entry in their duet. I felt every emotion possible while reading this story. Vincenzo and Nikolaj have been through so much and seeing them not only reunite but finally get their long awaited HEA was more than I could have hoped for, but of course there are shocking moments of distress, pain and utter devastation that made this story almost impossible to put down.
Overall I love returning to this world. It is full of surprises, beautiful heart moments and also moments of complete dread. Vincenzo and Nikolaj are strong, capable leaders and I love where the author took these characters and their future is bright and leaves me very intrigued.
I HAVE NO IDEA what the hell Conquest was and how these two books are supposed to be a duet 🤯 Because from THE FIRST PAGES, this book felt exactly like Empire did.
The pain laced into every line. That condemned longing that guts you before you've even had a chance to prepare yourself. It was there immediately, and my apparently very masochistic self was content.
It was an absolutely exquisite kind of pain to witness one man carrying all the memories and all the loss alone while the other is trapped in fractured flashes and nightmares, trying to find his way back to something he doesn’t even know he lost.
“I don’t just love one man. I love a ghost. I love a version of him that no longer exists anywhere except inside of me.”
Everything was so intense at times that I actually had to take several breaks because I was too overwhelmed by my own emotions 😭 My actual stupid work even managed to be useful for once by providing some much-needed distraction 🫠
“I remember enough to know I’ve been missing half my soul and calling it survival.”
😭😭😭
Honestly, I didn't even care about the occasionally ridiculous endearments, nicknames, all the kings and lyubimiys. None of that mattered anymore.
Because of how they found their way back to each other. Because of how they ACTUALLY COMMUNICATED. Because of a LOVE so powerful that it felt like something soulmate-level. Something that had survived loss, time, and even the forgetting.
“I thought I’d lost every trace of my heart,” he whispers against my skin. “And you… You carried me on yours.”
EXCUSE ME WHILE I PICK UP MYSELF FROM THE PIECES 😭
And it wasn't just Nico and Enzo who got to me emotionally. The way Enzo was with Arabella was beautiful. And then. SALVATORE AND RUSLAN 😭😭😭 My crying pillow was already drenched anyway.
The dramatic ending wasn't exactly unexpected. Let's be honest, we could all see where things were heading and what we’re going to get. BUT THAT DIDN'T MAKE IT ANY LESS DEVASTATING!! Watching Nico suffer absolutely gutted me 😭 Knowing what these characters mean to each other, and seeing that pain unfold, made it almost impossible to bear.
“Some wounds keep their own calendar. They throb when memory gets too close and pulse in bad weather. They remind a man where the knife entered, even when the skin itself has long since healed into something the mirror can live with.”
I mean. COME ON!!
There was, however, some confusion with their ages. In Conquest, Enzo says: “I’ve spent twenty-six years studying this man” But here, we get: “the twenty-two-year-old version of myself that Nikolaj first fell in love with” 🤷🏻♀️ Unless I'm missing something, the math isn't mathing.
But honestly I didin't care, it's just an observation. That doesn't change how I feel about this book. I actually think that there were more flaws. maybe some overdramatic moments, but whatever.
This was AMAZING. An absolutely fantastic journey, and even though Conquest was a ridiculous book in its own right, it's clear why it is a crucial part of their story. I have ZERO regrets about reading it. And now I have a completely different problem. HOW THE HELL AM I SUPPOSED TO FIND ANOTHER BOOK THAT MAKES ME FEEL LIKE THIS?! 😭
Can I give a book infinity stars? 🌟 well if I could it would definitely go to reign.
I can’t tell you how many tears I shed at night refusing to put this book down and determined to read it all at once as well as trying to savour each word.
My absolute favourites: nikolaj and his king, ruslan and salvatore finally getting their happy ending😭 my heart is so full I loved everything about this book
ARC Review An absolute masterpiece!! This was so perfect! Angst so well written that you cry your way through till the end. Cute banter that pulls at your heartstrings. Yearning and love that rivals that of soulmates. Pain so raw that you might need a break. Heartbreak so palpable that you can feel it come alive. Stolen peace that settles deep in your bones. Vulnerability and tenderness in it's rawest form. Grief written so well, it feels so real.Healing as realistic as you could get from a book.Overall, a masterpiece you do not want to miss.
Nikolaj and Vincenzo went through exceptional character development, you could literally see them change through the chapters. Parts of them that was locked down, started opening up, apologies given from the very men who hurt them, them giving apologies to the very people they hurt in the name of duty. It was beautiful to see, family bonds trying so hard to repair the fractures. Yes there was betrayal from some, but all in all it was an amazing process. The way Vincenzo handled the situation with his wife was perfect. The way they learnt to lean into each other, open up to each other and communicate properly was all I needed. They have grown so much from when they were in Vintermoor.
Ruslan and Salvatore finally letting their prides asides and apologising to each other as well as their sons was what I needed. Finally, something that sets them apart from their fathers.
Arseniy, Maksim, Tatiana, Kai helping in ways they can. I love them especially Tatiana. That scene with her made me ugly cry 😭.
The slow process of healing till the end from that event was painful to read but necessary. I loved it, even better than Conquest and Empire. This was so, emotionally loaded and conflicting,so don't forget to read the trigger warnings.
Plus I think I have a new trigger word from this book, iykyk.
my heart and stomach barely survived this series. i love all of them with my whole heart. vincenzo, nikolaj, salvatore and ruslan are finally got their happy endings together. the kiss salvatore and ruslan shared?! it nearly undone me. i really fucking hate that crying doesn't come to me naturally and my body takes on the damage, but I loved the pain all the same. this series has become one of my favorites all of time.
It's genuinely hard to believe both books were written by the same author because the improvement here is remarkable. I loved everything about this sequel. The characters felt more developed, the POV transitions were seamless, and the romance felt believable and earned rather than forced.
The plot was also much stronger and built toward an amazing ending. As an added bonus, we got POV chapters from two other important characters in the world, and I loved every minute of it.
Book 1 wasn't a favorite for me. Some of the dialogue felt overly sweet and out of character, and the pacing could be choppy at times. However, I still recommend reading it because Book 2 makes the journey completely worthwhile.
Although the series is set in a dark world, I personally wouldn't consider it a dark romance or dark series. The trigger warnings seemed more intimidating than the actual content. If you've read truly dark books, this one is fairly mild by comparison, so I wouldn't let the warnings scare you away.
I was excited for this one after really enjoying Conquest. However, I closed out the book frustrated and disappointed. There were so many parts of the story that felt like they shouldn't have been in the book while other parts felt like they were missing pieces. The "mafia" parts felt forced and messy. Books are definitely full of fiction and how the author portrays their vision of their worlds but the mafia bits fell flat because they felt so far from general mafia rules and structures. I was also confused by Ruslan. In Conquest he is abusive and cruel. In Reign he is not. Change is possible but we get no reasoning for that change. It felt off and disconnected.
I loved Niko and Vin, however the ending of their story just didn't hit.
Oh I’ve laughed I’ve cried I’ve screamed and I’ve begged what a ride this duet was I’ve loved every word of it I will miss Vincenzo and nikolaj a lot and I will def be coming back for a re read in the future thank you
"The family loved me, turned my into a blade, and then acted shocked when i learnt to cut."
5 ☆
This series has altered me. The first book was also five stars but the way Avery added so much emotional impact to Reign absolutely destroyed me. Nikolaj and Vincenzo are my Roman empire. This book added so much more complexity to both of these characters, it was tragic and heartbreaking yet so beautiful. Niko and Enzo have had such a hard life and it hurt me so much reading about how they struggled so much just to be accepted for the person and way they loved, and even in the end they weren't. Im going to cry again thinking about this.
Niko is such a gentle yet ruthless character, Vincenzo is so soft yet he's lethal as well. I love the way these two characters came together and brought out the best in each other. The way Niko grieved ripped my heart out. His bond with Tatiana was the cutest thing ever to me, and the loyalty his friends had towards him was everything. It's said Niko did something that's definitely horrible, but honestly he kind of redeemed himself for me because how would you blame someone for literally acting like what you raised them to be, if he was brutal it's because he was conditioned to be. The way these two characters communicate with eachother is so healthy and the way they love eachother. It's not perfect, they have their flaws but it's so wholesome.
This is easily one of my new mafia series, possibly even top three favorites. The writing was so beautiful and hit so hard when you correlated it deeply with the storyline. No it was perfection. It's potentially a six ☆ series for me. I can't say more without spoiling and crying
I was expecting more from the ending. I don't like that they never ruled together, unifying their houses. I wanted them to actually reign side by side, a superpower couple. But nope, we didn't get that. Very sad. 😔
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I feel like I’ve been waiting just as long as Nikolaj and Vincenzo for this book, and now that I’ve read it, I don’t know where to start. I mean Nikolaj and Vincenzo are EVERYTHING, this book literally consumed me, my thoughts, and my life, and god it was one hell of a hard earned HEA. I went through EVERY SINGLE EMOTION while reading this, and I do mean EVERY emotion. I laughed, yelled, swore, blushed, was giddy, was astounded, I cried, held my breath, and even wanted to throw my kindle. It was an emotional rollercoaster from start to finish. I honestly thought I was prepared going into this book … but I was so, so, so wrong.
Vincenzo, the Italian mafia leader, the King of the Five Families, a brutal leader who is also feared. But he’s also the one who remembers every touch, every kiss, every look, every stolen moment with Nikolaj and holds it in silence. Never believing he’d have that again … until Nikolaj’s memories start to return. With Nikolaj, Vincenzo is a completely different man. He’s bratty, he complains, he pouts, he banters, and he comes back to life in way that’s beautiful to watch.
Nikolaj, the blade, the Pakhan, a leader forged out of blood, this man was a firecracker as a boy but as the Pakhan he’s something entirely different. He holds himself higher, calculates while looking indifferent, and doesn’t allow anything to distract him … until Vincenzo walks back into his life. Until his memories start to come back and dreams start to take shape and he can longer deny what he’s heart has always known … someone is missing. Nikolaj goes through some heart wrenching moments and I felt EVERY-FUCKING-THING he did.
This is one of those books where I couldn’t pick my favourite MC because I love them both whole heartedly, but in such different ways. Seriously Avery has outdone herself with book!!
Story 5🌟 Steam 3❤️🔥 Swoon 💯🫠 ………………………. Nikolaj and Vincenzo are 💯❤️🔥💞🔥🤯 one of my best and favourite reads of 2026 so far. I loved the book 1 and this one was an amazing completion of their love story.
I enjoyed the world building the side characters their fathers’ love story their pain heartache pining the ❤️🔥🔥 and banter and of course the island 🏝️
I’ll come back for a second read and can’t wait for Arseniy’s story What a beautiful work of art this book is. Wow 🤩
Overall rating 5🌟 An absolute recommendation for mm romance lovers
——————— 2nd read Sep 2026
Still love and enjoyed everything about the story and characters. What a perfect romance brutal beautiful tearful heartbreaking 💔 Wow! My favourite book in 2026so far
I definitely liked this one a lot more than the previous book, and I’m really glad Vincenzo and Nikolaj got their happy ending. There was so much more emotion in this one, and I really appreciated how much the story focused on them learning how to be vulnerable with each other, trust each other, open up, and actually communicate. I really loved that aspect of their relationship.
I even found myself crying at some parts, which honestly caught me off guard 😭 So yeah, this book definitely managed to get to me emotionally.
That being said, there were still quite a few things that didn’t really work for me.
First, the whole mafia aspect felt extremely surface-level. It honestly felt like it was mostly there to give the story a darker background rather than being something actually developed. We hear about supply routes, money, meetings, their “business,” etc., but whenever they talk about their actual jobs, it basically comes down to they kill people all the time. And that’s… kind of it. 😑
I kept thinking, okay, but what does this world actually look like beyond that? Because the mafia does serve a purpose in the plot and is involved in several storylines, but I never felt like we really got any depth when it came to the actual mafia world. It sometimes felt like it was mostly there to make them dangerous and give the story that darker atmosphere, rather than being a world that was genuinely fleshed out and explored. I really wish we’d gotten more of that, because as it is, some parts of it just felt a little unconvincing to me.
Then there’s the whole thing with their fathers, which I weirdly really enjoyed unwillingly…
In the first book, these two men were portrayed as absolute tyrants. The MMCs were genuinely terrified of them, and I absolutely hated them. So when we got to see more of their love story in this book, including their reunion, I was actually so intrigued. And honestly, I really enjoyed those scenes.
BUT… I also didn’t really understand what happened with them?? Suddenly they’re nice? They apologize to their sons? The MMCs’ relationships with their fathers feel completely different from what we saw in the first book. It just kind of comes out of nowhere.
Like, I spent the entire first book absolutely despising these men, and now they barely feel like the same characters. I actually would have loved this development if it had been explored more, but because it happens so suddenly, it just didn’t feel entirely coherent to me.
There is also one thing I couldn’t stop thinking about the entire book because it was NEVER addressed.
In the first book, Vincenzo was supposed to kill his own brother in order to take the throne, right? And he didn’t want to do it. He was devastated by the idea of having to kill his brother, and his father was the one ordering him to do it…
Well… what happened to that brother?!
Did he kill him? Did he not? Did the author just abandon that plot point? Because when Vincenzo eventually abdicates and gives the power back to his father, there is zero mention of his brother. No mention of whether he actually killed him, no trauma, no regret, nothing.
Did he even exist in this book?! 😭 It’s like he literally never existed, which actually made me doubt myself so much that I went back to the first book to make sure I hadn’t completely hallucinated that whole storyline.
It drove me insane that we never got an answer. And I hate with my whole heart when books leave you with random holes and unanswered questions. Like, why introduce something in the first place if you’re never going to address it?! 😭
Anyway, this bothered me WAY more than it probably should have, because I kept waiting for it to come back somehow, and it just… never did.
Also… they’re supposed to live in Moscow and Rome, respectively, but sometimes they act like they live five minutes away from each other 😐 The logistics of their relationship were definitely not always very convincing.
Despite all of that, though, I really enjoyed this book. The story itself was somewhat predictable, but it honestly didn’t stop me from being emotionally invested. I really loved seeing Vincenzo and Nikolaj become more vulnerable with each other, and I think the emotional depth is what made this book work for me.
I really like these two MMCs, and I’m genuinely happy with where their story ended. The book definitely has its flaws, but it touched me, and that counts for a lot.
A good read, just not one that completely blew me away.
Their story may have ended but a new one will come from it.
What a conclusion to an amazingly angsty duet. I loved every moment of this read, even when parts of it had me questioning why I agreed to read this.
As painful as some of the parts in this story was, I wouldn’t change it for anything. Nothing about these two was every going to be easy or painless. That’s not who they or the world they were born into. Pain and heartache go hand and hand in their world even if they’re only shown behind closed doors, when the eyes and ears of those around them finally fade into darkness.
My heart broke at the start of this story reading Vincenzo’s parts especially after he and Nikolaj meet again. The break in scene shouldn’t have hurt as much as it did and honestly, I’m still mad at Avery for that. Of all things for Vincenzo to say at the end, you just had to put that freakin paragraph.
Like the first part there’s some spicy moments between them and they’re definitely hot however I absolutely adored watching them slowly find themselves again and build their relationship back together. They won’t ever have what they had at Vintermoor and Nikolaj will never be the man he was back then, even if all his memories return.
Nikolaj didn’t just lose his memories, he lost the love of his life and in the process took half of Vincenzo’s heart with him. They lost a lot of time, something that’ll never change no matter how hard they wish for it. What they build starts of rocky and unstable. Both aware of how dangerous it is for them and what it’ll cause if the love they have to for each other got out.
Ruslan and Salvatore finally meeting up again after all the years apart was beautiful. Did Salvatore surprise? Absolutely. I was right there was Ruslan when I read that part and then re-read it to make sure I hadn’t just made that scene up in my head. Something I can’t believe I’m going to say and I fully blame Avery for this one.
Part of me really wishes those two got a chance to go back and actually have the life they had dreamt of. I’m aware without what had happened Vincenzo and Nikolaj wouldn’t have their own story but I can dream.
The idea of what their story could have looked like had their lives been different is something my imagination will be thinking about for a while. Going from absolutely despising these two to my heart bleeding for both of them and their sons. Yeah, not many stories can do that to me.
To say this was an enjoyable story and conclusion would be a sever understatement. While yes, it took me a little bit to get really into the story and fall back into this world. I won’t ever stop talking about this story or this duet.
This right here is one of the best mafia stories I’ve read and won’t ever forget. The hurt, angst, emotional grip and freakin mental devastation this book put me through hurt like hell but with these two. I’d expect nothing less. Vincenzo and Nikolaj are so like their parents its poetic.
Is there a lot more I could say about this story? Absolutely, however spilling everything I really want to say would spoil a lot more than I want. What I can say is ……….
The last five chapters took me out so much that I had to take a few minutes to breathe. MY GOD!!!! What the hell was that?! I physically sobbed reading those especially the moment between Nikolaj and his sister and what happened after that.
I never expected picking up Conquest would lead to this kind of emotion at the end of their story. I should’ve know by now that Avery has a way of breaking your heart only to repair it but not to an undamaged state. The cracks are still there but the stories help fill them.
Another beautifully painful story, that I will forever remember. I can’t wait to see what happens next.
Hablando con brutal honestidad me gustó mucho pero siento que te hacía sufrir innecesariamente entiendo porque decidieron acabar el libro anterior así ya después de leer este. Puesto que sinceramente no veo como hubieran podido acabar juntos si ninguno tenía poder o influencia siendo jóvenes
Pero forzar la trama de fingir una muerte siento que ya estuvo feo, entiendo el drama del primero libro pero ese fue excesivo, y sabes porque????? Porque si al final van a jugar. A ser directores y salir del anonimato prácticamente fue estúpida esa trama
Si se hubieran quedado en el anonimato la considero fea pero pues valió la pena. Si al final no sirve de nada solo es otra trama buscando drama
No puedo calificar mal al libro porque honestamente me gustó mucho, lo devoré en un día. Sin hacer absolutamente nada más que estar absorbida por las palabras y páginas, así que un mal libro NO ES pero esas tramas no son mi estilo, amo el drama pero no amo ese estilo de trama solo para impactar al lector
The emotional roller coaster I went through reading this book was HUGE. I loved every second of it. You could already feel the emotions in the first book, but the second one took everything to another level. The writing felt more beautiful, more refined, and it made the whole reading experience even more special,this is easily my best read of the year💜💜 I’m so in love with Enzo and Nico. The power dynamics, their love story, the heartbreak… everything about them had me hooked. And of course,can’t forget Salvatore and Ruslan, who made me cry à loot 😭 They were incredible
I loved this book so much. All the stars for this one!
-mm romance -dark mafia -8 years of pining -star crossed second chance -violent devotion -memory loss -“my king”
welllll fuck. i basically read this crawled up in a ball in the fetal position the entire time. & the dads?? THE DADS!! ughhh i just can't! that plot twist toward the end too? i was about to crash out but damn, avery again, came in & obliterated me with her words of love of these two boys & it was everything i needed it to be!!
this broke my heart and put it back together again in the most visceral way. i don’t think ill ever forget about nikolaj and vincenzo. they’re perfect and TRUE soulmates.
Reign is the second book in Of Ruin and Royalty, and I knew from the start I’d have to buckle up and I was right. This story broke my heart, made me laugh, scream, hold my breath, and that plot twist nearly did me in, but the way it all came together was flawless. From childhood to becoming men and leaders, Nikolaj and Vincenzo endured so much, and even when they were at odds or fighting to survive, their constant was always their love. If I could experience it all for the first time again, I absolutely would. For anyone who hasn’t started reading Of Ruin and Royalty, I highly recommend beginning with Conquest, then Empire, and finishing with Reign.