Inheritance brings us the kind of small-town horror that starts with a so-called “normal” tragedy. A teen is found dead in the woods, the community seeks closure with a simple explanation, and a few kids begin to feel the story is missing something. The story has side glances, unspoken truths, and a handful of adults who fidget the moment the woods are mentioned. The story transitions into a comprehensive folk horror and mystery. The woods are alive with secrets and the town’s history is a loaded spring, ready to snap. The biggest fear is not what is in the woods, the big fear is what the people Living there are willing, or unwilling, to do to protect their fragile lives. And yes, I also like Chuck. I get that many people might hate him for his many bad choices. He’s not a good guy, but I like that he is the only one who really acts and keeps the story moving when everyone is politically paralyzed or just plain in denial. Chuck embodies the “do the ugly thing to fix the bigger problem” type. Frustrating, messy, and impossible to ignore. The book is really well written, and it kept me hooked - I had to keep reading to see what would happen next.
The goods
- The small-town secrecy feels real, and it makes everything more tense
- The woods atmosphere is creepy without needing nonstop shocks
- The mystery pulls you through - you keep reading because the town clearly knows more than it’s saying
- Chuck is a great “love-to-hate” character who actually moves the story
The bads
- If you want clear heroes and clean choices, this book is not that
- A few moments lean hard into mood and buildup instead of quick answers
- The town’s silence and denial can be frustrating (even when it makes sense)
- The aftermath/ending might feel a little different from the pure horror rush earlier
Why I’d recommend it
I’d recommend Inheritance if you enjoy horror that revolves around people and feelings as opposed to just surface level horror. It has that “there's something wrong here and everyone's ignoring it” vibe, with a slow build to bigger and darker realities. It is tense, super creepy, and very easy to get hooked to. Even if characters frustrate you (like Chuck), it makes the story that much better because people don’t do the right thing, they do what they think is right.
Every book hits differently for every reader.
Thanks for reading my review.
- Corey