“The internet doesn’t just watch people fail—it turns their collapse into entertainment.”
Don't know what a lolcow is? Welcome to a new and unique genre of internet entertainment. The Internet’s Never-Ending Tragedy is the first book to explore this uniquely modern phenomenon in depth.
A lolcow is someone endlessly baited or tricked into responding to trolls thereby “milking” them for amusing reactions. Once targeted, escape is rare.
Behind the memes and mockery lies a darker audience manipulation, emotional breakdowns, public humiliations, drug use, shameless grifting, lies, and often financial ruin—played out in real time before a global audience.
These are not fictional villains or scripted characters. They are real people whose rise and fall mirrors classic tragedy, amplified by the internet’s endless memory and appetite for spectacle.
Each lolcow provides a tragic rise and fall story, but also an opportunity to learn. This book will explore the lessons in lolcows and how they can serve as examples for us.
Inside, you’ll
How lolcows are created—and why they can’t break the cycle
The traits and behaviors that make someone vulnerable
The role of trolls, audiences, and platforms in sustaining the phenomenon
Six in-depth case studies spanning multiple internet eras and
DarkSydePhil aka Philip Burnell - Burnell has been called “the internet cockroach” for his longevity, persistence, and behavior. An early pioneer of the video game genre, his career spiraled out of control due to his angry reactions to trolls. His lies, e-begging, and manipulation have made him an internet outcast.WingsofRedemption aka Jordie Jordan - Jordan was once a respected video game commentator. Despite his early success, his lack of conception around being a public figure led to him getting repeatedly trolled. His reactions to trolling has created a cottage industry of people dedicated to watching him fail.Boogie2988 aka Steven Williams - Williams was once called the “Mister Rogers of the Internet”. He was an early Youtuber who went viral for his angry Francis character and vulnerable storytelling. He was the ultimate underdog. However, it wasn’t long till his true self was revealed. His wholesome image hid a mountain of lies and manipulations.Rekieta Law aka Nick Rekieta - Rekieta was a pioneer of the “Law Tube” genre on Youtube. His colorful commentary on legal issues and cases built an audience of millions all over the world. His wholesome small town lawyer image was shattered by revelations of his other life. His legal issues surrounding child neglect, drug possession, and losing his license to practice made him the subject of the Law Tube genre he helped to create.Ian Johma aka iDubbbz - Johma ran a successful comedy channel that also offered social commentary. He was known for his wit and edgy humor. He collaborated with the biggest Youtubers of his era. After a series of controversies, lashing out at his fans, and an unsuccessful stint as a boxing promoter, he has become the very creator his used to lampoon.Jeremy Hambly aka TheQuartering - Hambly rose to prominence making content calling out the politicization of popular culture. He was able to translate complaining about movies, celebrities, and corporations into millions of views. However, his channels quickly turned into a content factory of slop with diminishing returns.
As if the world needed more coverage of Lolcowdom. Yet another long form essay of drecky, wikiscraped information that would like to be thought of as "unbiased" by making all its claims about the subject a bunch of unfalsifiable fluff. Except it's not a Youtube video! Now it's a book! Like it's real or something! Take me seriously!
Would be perfectly fine if it was entertaining, but it isn't. Truly a book for nobody. Any young teens looking for a crash course on internet lore will be bored out of their mind by the overly clinical approach. I'd sooner point them to more brainrot about these people. That would at least give them the formation of a real opinion to start with. Anyone already familiar with these people and looking for a bit more in depth analysis will be sorely disappointed, as the author isn't insightful enough to anything but recite that which is already canonized.
The only faction who might be tempted to stick around in that case would be the curious offline boomer. Of all possible audiences, this is the last who should be reading, as I think this sort of coverage would give them the wrong idea about what a "lolcow" is or how the internet works.
The first third of the book is a ceaseless barrage of describing the qualities and circumstances of the lolcow, but it gives no concrete information. No names, no statistics, no anything that might ground the discussion in relatable terms. Just relations of vague behaviors they exhibit. That is when the author isn't waxing trivial with lengthy platitudes. "You see in Hollywood, there are gatekeepers to keep all the crazies from getting exposure. With the internet, that doesn't happen!" Imagine that, much less succinct, multiple paragraphs in length, several times a chapter. Except the allegory changes from time to time. Movies, bands, theater, Roman Polanski for some reason. I can usually forgive the "Look at me! I know things!" School of critique, but this is all shit anyone with half a brain would already be familiar with implicitly. Spending too much time on the internet gives you issues with self esteem?! What a shocker! I had some physical health issues from spending too much time in the alligator pit. He even goes on a lengthy tanget about how the internet used to be like the Wild West if you can believe it. Luther. My man. The Wild West is probably the one thing of these boomers would not need explained!
What's especially odious of this form of lolcow coverage is how dehumanizing it is. A common trend I notice with the people who cover lolcows, is how anthropologically distant they try to keep from the cow. Like an anthropologist observing cannibal tribe in New Guinea. I suspect this stems from the urge to deny the idea that you or I could never ever be anything like that. Sad to say for you or I, these people are not good objects of anthropological objects of study (least of all for someone with no degree in anthropology.) The spiritual gap between any of us and Chris-Chan is orders of magnitude smaller than that between Chris and my hypothetical cannibal.
Worst of all, the book seems to resist conversation. How does any of this happen? "Well it just does" the book seems to say.
Not sure why you would open the book saying you aren’t going to recount YouTube drama and then do just that the entire time. It was almost interesting but had nothing new to say that you couldn’t get from any of the thousands of “video essays” on each person mentioned in the book. It sets itself up to be an in-depth look at the phenomenon itself, why people continuously choose to humiliate themselves (other than monetary gain) publicly, the aftermath and parasociality of having the entire internet laughing at you. It isn’t that at all. I was very intrigued, especially given the false description of what the book would contain in the first segment. But instead of focusing on the nuances or anything specific, the whole book is spent just talking about various lolcows as though they’re fictional characters in a TV show. No research, not even really analytical, based on how much of the author's personal POV and opinions bleed into each ‘case’ being discussed. Really missed the mark with me; I am disappointed but not surprised. Comparing iDubbbz and H3H3 to Macbeth and Macduff did give me a chuckle, though, even if it was done 100% seriously over and over.
felt more like an extended recap of the last ~10 years of YouTube drama than an actual study of how the internet treats these figures; not any more challenging or thought-provoking than the average video essay
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
The content of this book disappointed me, which is ultimately the fault of my own expectations. It was recommended to me as an audiobook on Spotify, and given that I had to expend a limited number of monthly audiobook listening hours to hear it, I had anticipated a level of quality somewhat higher than you would get from a YouTube essay ported over to podcast form. Unfortunately, that is exactly how I would describe the caliber of this book.
It’s self published, and (ironically, as the author himself points out) since no one was there to oversee production I can’t really fault the many duplicate line readings, the fact that “saline” is pronounced like “selene,” the unprofessionalism of using language like “glazed” and “SJW” unironically, or the inexplicable and inconsistent censorship of curse words. Certainly if this was a YouTube essay it would be a relatively competent one. But I would never in a thousand years have clicked on a video expose cataloguing the various failed careers of assorted Let’s Players, and that’s all this book is.
Maybe that sounds interesting to some people, but the author is correct in saying that barely any literature on the “lolcow” exists, and for the person breaking that story to miss so many opportunities for analysis was a real bummer. I don’t care that a man wasted the money he coerced from fans on a WWE gambling addiction. The fascinating part of that story is the fact that random internet users tuned into his bankruptcy hearing, found his SSN, and called his bank account to figure that information out. What compelled them to do this? What did it accomplish? Who are these “trolls detractors” (as the narrator reads it—I assume in the text there was a ‘/‘ there) as people?
For a book about Lolcows to gloss over the existence of Kiwifarms is unfathomable to me. It seems nearly impossible to even breach the topic without providing some analysis of what happened to “Chris Chan.” I agree with and commend the author’s decision to avoid bringing more exposure to Chandler, an evidently vulnerable and mentally ill person, but he could have done an anonymized summary of the event. Without that background, all of this is meaningless. Without any interrogation of the people who create the lolcow, it’s meaningless. And based on some of the sentiments the author casually tosses out about the subjects of his book, I suspect the lack of investigation there is because he is one of the “detractors.” Detractors, in this book, are given a nominally elevated status from “trolls,” despite the fact that they are constantly referred to as doing the exact same things.
This is not investigative journalism. It’s a dry recap of various sad men from YouTube who have resorted to e-begging after repeatedly embarrassing themselves in public. I don’t care to finish it. I hope the author, if he’s reading this, feels accomplished for the admittedly enormous task of writing a nonfiction book, and that he writes a better one next time.
Edit: I made the mistake of listening to more of this; I went too easy on it. It would not be a competent video essay. It is pointless reactionary dreck. Sorry to be harsh.
The book is not well written. Based on the intro and first few chapters, it is written for an audience that has never been on the internet before, which is bewildering when the book is written on a slightly niche internet topic. The words have poor flow, and spends too long on basic things, reiterating the information in a boring, simple writing style.
I enjoy reading books that are written to take an academic approach to a topic, however, this is not it. In academics, you learn that you can assume your target audience has a baseline of knowledge, and if your target audience lacks knowledge they need for the topic you are writing on, only then do you explain the basics.
This was a light, enjoyable read, but could have covered way more ground. It attempts to analyze the lolcow phenomena and trace the life cycle of a YouTube content creator until they reach lolcow status (a person whose eccentric, foolish, or vulnerable behavior is exploited by online communities for mockery and entertainment). It does a decent job and uses a handful of case studies from some popular YouTubers like idubbz, DarkSydePhil, and The Quartering.
But the book explicitly refuses to cover the biggest, most popular lolcow of them all, Chris Chan, due to him being "severely mentally ill." But why would that matter? The author admits that all lolcows have some sort of mental illness or "personality flaw". I just feel like you can't discuss the lolcow phenomena without talking about Chris Chan to some degree.
Another thing that is only glossed over are the forums like Kiwi Farms or lolcow.farm or even 4chan and Reddit. It would have been great to learn the history of those sites, who runs them, or how these online communities operate and stay afloat, navigate shut downs, and dodge accountability as they skirt the line between documentation and harassment.
The author also claims that men are more inclined to be lolcows than women, but I don't think that's true (Eugenia Cooney comes to mind). There are forums like Pretty Ugly Little Liar that have countless threads about female content creators being scrutinized by other women. Not to mention the popularity of snark communities on Reddit. People love to gossip about celebrities and hate on influencers. How different are those from lolcows?
Despite my criticisms, this book was enough to whet my appetite for "academic" or objective analysis of terminally online behavior. It's been fascinating to watch certain channels rise and fall and struggle to remain relevant in a cutthroat industry that dehumanizes people.
This book could have zoomed out even further into a critique of late stage capitalism or into philosophy, but that's asking too much out of this book. You'll get better internet anthropology of the terminally online from the likes of Katherine Dee (Default Friend), Taylor Lorenz, or Angela Nagle's book Kill All Normies. Or if you really want the Chris Chan deep dive, go watch the ongoing 80+ part documentary series by Geno Samuel on YouTube.
My final take is that "Lolcows" is a self-published book to supplement and boost the authority of the author's YouTube channel. It covers enough to give a layperson an interesting snapshot, and gives enough overview for those already familiar to be an entertaining trip down memory lane.
It's fine, I guess. Although I was hoping for a more well-rounded deep dive into the phenomenon of a Lolcow and the culture that permeates its landscape. Instead, the flow was more of what is commonly found on a YouTube drama channel that summarises the life of someone's career, which, while it can be a guilty pleasure, is more effective in video format rather than a book listing a bunch of washed E-celebs. It doesn't help that its tone feels uninspired, dull, and clumsy (Equating a YouTuber spat to Macbeth?). Ultimately, it's just an author interested in the fascinating topic of public humiliation platformed on a world stage. A decent first book, but if you're familiar with this topic at all, I doubt you'll learn much. My advice would be to delve deeper into the relationships of internet culture itself and to discuss the human psyche in this amalgamation, utilising academic research, rather than just listing off a he-said-she-said, which is the majority of the book.
Also, calling The Quartering a 'politically neutral grift' made me wince.
An interesting deep dive into multiple 'lolcows' that kept it as objective as possible. It's a real shame how some of the real world scenarios played out but it was a really fresh perspective on such wildly different personalities from such wildly different times in the history of YouTube.
A key point I really enjoyed was the fact that the author reached out to friends, detractors and almost anyone connected to these people. It made for a good chance to see why some people think the way they do and it helped generate an overall picture of the situation much more clearly.
Growing up with the internet, especially YouTube, it's interesting to see how it's morphed from the wild west to how it is now. Same goes for the creators that are examined here. I've vaguely knew of these people but hearing their stories puts in perspective how much it takes to be moderately successful in YouTube. Their downfall into lolcow status is a good warning to those who try to stay relevant on any social media platform.
I was unimpressed with the book and felt like the author was at times sympathizing with Ethan Klein who is essentially a Lolcow himself. I wish it was just a video essay instead of a book because it was hard to follow along with some of the featured stories and would work better than a book format. Over all a disappointing listen.
A fun read into the internet lolcow phenomenon. I enjoyed the look at it from an analytical interpretation than the more common troll point of view. I would recommend reading if you are interested in online drama.
I devoured this in an afternoon after listening to Luther’s CBC investigation series on YouTube. Very interesting and unique take on the lolcows. Not the usual point and laugh method. I’d love to see an analysis of Amberlynn Reid, pertaining to when and how she followed the steps into lolcow-dom.