Revenge with Benefits: Straight to Gay MM First Time

by Lucas Blaze

I’m straight. He’s straight. This is just revenge.

When I find out I’m sharing my girlfriend with another guy, and not in a fun way, we skip the fight and team up. We want payback. The plan is pretend we’re into each other and rub it in her cheating face.

It’s all fake. We’re not really gay. We’re just two guys who got played.

At least that’s what I tell myself. But when I’m pressed against this muscular jock with his tongue in my mouth, it’s hard to remember what’s real and what’s not.

Genres: M M Romance, Novella, LGBT, Contemporary

66 pages, Kindle Edition

Published December 8, 2025

Reviews

[laura cabezas · Rating 4 out of 5]

finn & chase - 4 stars ❤️

[Lady Macbeth · Rating 4 out of 5]

4 stars
Lately I got the chance to read a few books by Lucas Blaze and I have to say I love his writing.
Like I said about another of his books, in his stories there always something a little different from other MM romance that make me like them very much.

I'm not going to spoil the story but I have to say that Chase and Anderson, besides having a great chemistry in the bedroom, have also a deep emotional connection that I wasn't expecting. I adored how Chase took care of Finn and how he appreciated and cherished him way better than his cheating girlfriend.

What prevented me from giving a higher rate:
I understand that the point of short novellas is to provide a quick fun read, but I still believe that the author could write a two pages epilogue to give us a little more about the MCs and their future together.

I'd really really love for this author to write a full novel.

I received an ARC of this book from Booksprout and this is my honest review.

[Maggie May · Rating 4 out of 5]

Another fun and smutty story from Lucas Blaze. As per usual, there is a good setup, which is of a decent length for a short novella. Then we have a long and detailed sex scene with a good amount of chemistry and a bit of emotional connection. Lastly, a quick wrap up, in this case even a very short epilogue. To be perfectly honest, I don’t get anything from all the “but I’m straight” stuff, so having pages of it detracts slightly from the story for me. Still, I find the extremely well written smutty details worth dealing that microtrope. The only thing that keeps me from rating this (and the other Blaze stories I have read) as 5 stars is that I really believe that less setup and more follow up would be better. Insta-lust is fine for short smutty stories, what I want to spend more time on is the lust turning to love part.

[Alix · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is a short and smutty read by Lucas Blaze, one of my fave authors of this (smutty short) genre. Chase and Finn encounter each other and realize that they've been dating the same woman for several months. So, they devise a plan for revenge! Things take an unexpected turn (for them, lol) to the super spicy side in the best way. I absolutely loved this story and that surprised me a bit. Mind you - I have read most if not all of this author's catalog and I adore the stories (yay for smut!). However, for me, this one was more special - we get a depth of emotion that was lovely and brought tears to my eyes at one point - yes, I'm a crier, but I wasn't expecting this! And there were places where the writing itself was so lovely and well done. And the hint of their HEA was just so cute.

What to Expect:
*straight to gay MM short/smut
*football player MC + artsy MC
*meet cute
*revenge plot
*cheating
*OW drama
*porn as research
*helping each other out
*dirty talk
*smut ofc
*first times
*fair bit of kissing
*swoony/emotions (some)
*hint of HEA
*winter holiday elements

[K · Rating 5 out of 5]

1st person POV Dual
Plot 3.5/5- it's a short story but it's got a solid plot but don't go in excepting world building or some drawn out thing here, you know what you're getting reading a Lucas Blaze book! 🤣
Spice 4/5
First times
Cheating gf
revenge plan
"maybe we should practice"

If you want a short spicy 🔥 quite frankly down right hot story then this book is right up your alley!

Finn and Chase find out they are dating the same chick, so instead of just confronting her, they decide to flip the script! She walks in and "catches" them in the middle of some sexy time! *gasp* completely accidental of course!

Well it blossoms from there and a " research session" turns into a gotta have you moment that is hot enough to melt metal!🥵

so again if you wanna pass an hour or so with a comical hot book, it should be this one!

[Book Hoarder · Rating 5 out of 5]

Finn and Chase are two straight guys at the same university. Chase is a jock and Finn is a music major. They meet while at the jewelry store to pick up their girlfriend’s Christmas present. Making small talk, girlfriend is Brittany, girlfriend is a cheerleader, Brittany Foster.
Chase invites Finn to his dorm, Brittany is coming over at eight. The guys hatch a revenge plot. Tell Brittany they have decided to become a couple so they’re dumping her. Need to practice to make it more realistic. And practice they do.
Lucas Blaze writes the best erotic short stories, usually the gay guy(s) showing the straight guy how to. Revenge is a quirky little twist with two straight guys, and a cheating girlfriend. Definitely an HEA

[J.J. · Rating 4 out of 5]

As someone who's incredibly petty and holds grudges, I approve of this story.

I would have liked the revenge part to be even longer because it was really satisfying. Pretending to hook up with your cheating girlfriend's other boyfriend? And then actually hooking up? This was the best.

I need more petty revenge stories! Their relationship was kind of cute, too, considering this was erotica.

[Kirstie Close · Rating 5 out of 5]

If your wanting a quick steamy mm romance with little story then run to a Lucas Blaze book. 


This is the best Revenge I've ever read! Two straight guys find out they are dating the same girl and decide to team up and get revenge but things get out of hand when intense feelings are flowing. 

Hot is a understatement these two have some intense chemistry, you'll be squirming in your seats.

[Debbie Benson · Rating 4 out of 5]

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review. I liked the revenge Chase and Anderson get on their cheating girlfriend. Even better is their discovery of a better relationship between them.

[Jennifer R · Rating 5 out of 5]

Being 66 pages it was as good as it could get in such a short time. I really enjoyed and love little spicy stories like this that don’t need a ton of details. Nice to have between longer heavier reads.

[Scott Royer · Rating 5 out of 5]

Addicted to Lucas Blaze Stories

I started reading one and it brought back memories of my younger years. At 70 I have been through a lot of gay encounters, some close to those in his stories. I have to read more!

[Gavy Vera · Rating 4 out of 5]

⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4/5.

Una historia hot y divertida. Como llegaron a la conclusion de fingir estar juntos y despues "explorar" jajaa.

[Jorja Harrison · Rating 5 out of 5]

revenge

I cannot believe I liked this so much. These two guys are just so likable…Brittany, not so much. This was a first read by the author for me, but it won’t be the last!

[Spencer · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is such a fun and cute story. I love them and wished it was a longer story.

[Sara Jane · Rating 4 out of 5]

🥵🥵 So Hot!
During a chance encounter at a jewelry store these MCs learn they have the same girlfriend.
Chase comes up with the perfect plan to bring her down a peg. They might have kissed to make Brittany jealous but after she left they heated up those sheets.