Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Elder Race #2

Engines of Reason

Rate this book
Visit a world where sorcery intertwines with science by multiple Hugo nominee Adrian Tchaikovsky in this highly-anticipated sequel to his hugely popular Elder Race.

On a planet where stories govern identity, where science and magic are a merely point of view, a fallen princess, a reluctant wizard, and a precocious child must unravel the past to shape the future.

Betrayal, ancient myths, and the clash of worlds converge in this spellbinding tale of courage, friendship, and self-discovery.

A profound exploration of identity, memory, and discovery from one of science fiction’s most compelling voices.

175 pages, Hardcover

First published September 1, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Adrian Tchaikovsky

243 books20.4k followers
ADRIAN TCHAIKOVSKY was born in Lincolnshire and studied zoology and psychology at Reading, before practising law in Leeds. He is a keen live role-player and occasional amateur actor and is trained in stage-fighting. His literary influences include Gene Wolfe, Mervyn Peake, China Miéville, Mary Gently, Steven Erikson, Naomi Novak, Scott Lynch and Alan Campbell.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
396 (26%)
4 stars
689 (45%)
3 stars
358 (23%)
2 stars
66 (4%)
1 star
8 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 202 reviews
Profile Image for Jamie.
1,507 reviews244 followers
September 21, 2026
I enjoyed Engines of Reason quite a bit more than the previous book, Elder Race. The story felt more compelling, with additional pieces of its mysterious world - full of wizards, witches, demons, princesses, brigands and robots - gradually coming into focus. There’s something I find deeply alluring about its setting, where the remnants of ancient, buried technology and those who are able to wield it are perceived as magical by a contemporary feudal type society whose heritage has been lost to the ages. Thematically, Tchaikovsky explores how traditional roles, societal expectations, personal experience and even mythology can shape and even ossify our own inner narratives, giving the story a thoughtful undercurrent beneath its more overt mysteries.
Profile Image for Gyalten Lekden.
853 reviews238 followers
September 7, 2026
Are we the stories we tell about ourselves, or the stories others tell about us? That is the central question in this creative, emotional return to Sophos IV, thirty years after the events of the last novella. As usual, the writing is reflective and charming in equal measure, with more sincerity and less snark but a dry, often self-deprecating wit, all the same. Tchaikovsky again balances between the worlds of science fiction and fantasy, letting characters live in their own worlds, their experiences and understanding shaping what kind of story they are in, what kind of story they are telling. We move across character POVs in each chapter, which keeps the story brisk and moving. The Nyr chapters are all told in first-person narration, bringing us into his wearied, wise world, his world of magic and physics and technology shaping how we understand what is happening. The other chapters are written in a close third-person, setting the narrative import apart from each other, locating the reader in the scientific while refusing to eschew the fantastical. The tone of the writing, including the type of humor, how aspirational vs. reflective it is, and so on, changes according to the different character POVs, which is subtle and effective. It makes the whole world feel much more multi-dimensional, and it reminds us that there are mysteries beyond science and technology.

The story smartly rotates around a single event, and yet it gives every character within that event some backstory, some history, enough to make them feel complete and allow the narrative room to breathe. It feels focused and direct but never rushed, which in turn makes the pages fly by. We get to check in with all the characters from the previous novella and meet some new characters, testing what our characters think they know about themselves and about the world. The themes it is navigating are straightforward but profound. It isn’t a simple struggle between science and technology, but instead it is a struggle to understand what our place is in the world. All the characters think they know themselves; they have written out a script for who and how they are and they follow it. But the world conspires to show them that they can be more than they have circumscribed themselves to be, and in fact maybe they need to be more than that. We all have myriad stories within us, some precise and measurable, others fantastic and beyond belief. This story asks us what needs to happen for us to recognize that, and to break free from habit to embrace whatever stories are needed, swapping from one to the next as required, to care for others and become the best version of ourselves that we can be.

The story is fun, direct, and reflective. It will be nigh impenetrable if you haven’t read the previous novella, even though he does skillfully fill in the details of what happened, but those feel more like reminders than substitutes for reading the story. The story doesn’t have quite the tension the first one does, just due to the nature of its structure, but it has emotional and physical stakes not just for our characters but for the whole world they live in. It reads quickly and feels light and springy, not as heady or heavy as some of Tchaikovsky’s other work, yet I found myself thinking about it quite a bit after finishing it. The ideas are simple, and he states the heart of the story in the prologue (The first words of the story are, literally: “A wise woman once said, we tell stories about ourselves, and that is what makes us human.”). This allows us to sit with this idea as we watch the story unfold, which is quite a rewarding experience.

(Rounded from 3.5)
Profile Image for Jae.
151 reviews9 followers
May 23, 2026
Oh what a breath of fresh air. Engines of Reason is probably one of the few sequels that manage to surpass book 1 of a series - and does not fall into the “book 2 trap”.

I have so many thoughts, but mainly I think this is the point where I will admit Nyr - and the series itself has transcended beyond just another good scifi or Murderbot replica, which I know, is a disservice to the author but holy moly this book really breathed itself to life.

I am just in awe of how Adrian Tchaikovsky redefined the voice of Lyn. One of my biggest nitpicks in book 1 was how young Lyn’s perspective was and just was not something I liked reading about - this book is a direct response to my qualms.

We see the cast of Elder Race after a 15 year time jump - and the tone aligns so well with the maturity of the characters. Lyn is no longer the naive little princess - there are layers and layers of maturity and depth in her pov chapters - and oh boy we are finally getting a glimpse in court politics that I craved in book 1.

I love the fact that the idea of matriarchal society is not used simply for the clickbait, but it’s something that is engrained within the culture of the story - and Engines of Reason explores the worldbuilding much more than the its predecessor.

I have always loved Nyr - the anthropologist robot magician diagnosed with clinical depression - hell yeah give me more. This was such a heart warming read and seeing him deal with conflict and all sorts of earthly emotion is such a fun perspective to read from.

We have a new pov chapter from a character called Sendra - who I was surprised by how easy it took for me to like, I don’t often like authors adding new povs in sequels, but Sendra is a great addition to the cast and he is just so nuanced and with the word count of this book - was well delivered.

I also have to comment on the writing style - it was so much more immersive and descriptive , almost atmospheric to the point of somber humor (two very distinct words, but they both fit for the writing of this book) just grabbed me into the world - I finished the book in one go!!!

Thematically, this is what I adore in books, loneliness, odd friendship and pages where the author makes you read between the lines. Makes me wonder what demons live beneath one’s skin, and whisper underneath one’s voice!!!

I am hoping the author did not end the Esha plotline - I wanna know more, I want to read more from this world, so I’m definitely keeping an eye out to the next book.

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the eARC in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for urwa.
389 reviews320 followers
October 20, 2026
"And now I am still a little sad, but I will put it with all the other small sadnesses of life, and be happy for you."


I hate to be that person advocating that some masterpieces should be left alone; attempting to do a sequel or a spin-off never captures the magic of the original and just feels like a cheap copy milking nostalgia. But alas, here we are, and I never expected to say this about an Adrian Tchaikovsky book of all books. An author who rarely ever misses the mark.

I loved Elder Race, it has the perfect amount of sci-fi, magic, wonder, and the right amount of pulling on my heartstrings. I loved the angst and the contrast between the anthropologist and the locals. The dual POV was amazing, and it really highlights the uncrossable barrier between the two cultures. In Engines of Reason, that magic or sense of mystery is sort of lost with the bridging between cultures. Yes, we have a new unknowable entity, and yes, this was implied with the ending of Elder Race that Nyr will mingle with the locals more, so of course he and the locals are demystified to each other. But I just feel like this book didn't really need to exist. I love this world, and I love the characters, but the angst of the first book is what made it so great. Nyr sitting in a forest and crying up at the stars is a scene that lives with me forever. This new installment just lacks that amount of emotion that I was hoping for. I also feel like the conflict between the two characters felt very unnecessary, and the resolution scene felt a bit rushed. So yeah, color me disappointed. Other fans of the first book have loved it so i am most probably in the minority.
Profile Image for Philip.
1,902 reviews137 followers
October 3, 2026
Surprisingly good follow-up to Elder Race; if Tchaikovsky can keep this up (not easy, as so far the saga seems pretty limited to the planet of Sophos 4), this series could be the next Murderbot. Indeed, there are many analogies/comparisons: short-form novellas set REALLY far from Earth and featuring an emotionally awkward, pretty much indestructible part-human/part-tech protagonist; a cast of otherwise "normal" humans who both fear and don't understand him; various robots, drones and even physics-bending "alien remnants."

Both this and the earlier book are clever mash-ups of fantasy and fairly hard science fiction which should satisfy fans of either genre. Tchaikovsky has only been a full-time writer for less than a decade, but is just crazy prolific, having already produced over 40 novels, novellas and short story collections. With an output like that, he (much like the artist Prince) is by definition going to be hit-or-miss at times; but of the ten books I've read so far, none has been less than three stars, (although so far I've been avoiding his big series and 400-page-plus epics).

This one, however, is most highly recommended, and I can only hope there are more to come.
Profile Image for Brian.
356 reviews22 followers
September 7, 2026
The surprise sequel to one of my most enjoyable reads of 2021, I found this book unnecessary and unengaging. The whole 174 pages felt like one continuous conversation the main character is either having out loud or with himself in his head. The world-building was a whole lot of tell with no show. I felt zero investment in any of the characters. I think this could've been a lot better had it been given much more page space and an expanded plot.

The first book did so well because it was all about the discovery of the main character being from a high tech age walking into a medieval world and the conflict of an antagonist commandeering old tech that only main character could stop. This plot couldn't harness that same novel feeling from the first and the conflict felt unearned and unserious.

Don't get me wrong, I love Tchaikovsky's writing and will continue to read most of his work but man did this one feel like an unnecessary entry. It's like someone at the publishing house just read the first book last year and forced Tchaikovsky into a hasty sequel. At least this gave me a good opportunity to practice my speed-reading.
Profile Image for Jason Snell.
94 reviews913 followers
October 5, 2026
I'm not sure anything could live up to the first story, but this is a great follow-up that is not afraid to show how the characters from the previous book have progressed in their lives. I was a little surprised that it also directly addresses (and expands on) some specific events from "Elder Race" that could easily have been shrugged off in favor of a simple reunion. Now I want more stories set in this universe.
Profile Image for Sarah (menace mode).
695 reviews45 followers
August 28, 2026
I spent all 200 pages trying to diagnose what felt so wrong to me about this novella, and I think it comes down to middle child syndrome - something I would have NO way of knowing until the end where it sets up a clear direction for the rest of the series. Elder Race was a PERFECT one-shot about depression and finding meaning in life, while also having a really fun human science in space magic vibe. This is like everything that SciFi does too much of (colonized become the colonizer/Earth meddling in alien affairs) without offering any kind of hook beyond a stay tuned for next time!!!!! ending. I do love Nyr, Lyn and the child Sara was such a fun add so I will keep reading but only begrudgingly.
Profile Image for Lettie.
75 reviews
October 14, 2026
A very enjoyable return to the world of Nyrgoth Elder. I was impressed as with the first one by how much story Tchaikovsky is able to put into a short book. There was more world building, new characters and character development, intrigue, politics, familial strife, and of course, magic. All told in an endearing and very entertaining way.
Profile Image for Yev.
813 reviews42 followers
September 2, 2026
Roughly 15 years have passed. Those years brought many troubles. During that time Lynesse has gone from young adult to middle aged. For Nyrgoth it hasn't been really any time at all watching her develop since childhood. He hasn't changed in the intervening years. Has she? With age comes maturity, physically, if not emotionally. When the stories we tell about ourselves don't adapt to our circumstances, problems arise. This novella is about the narrative that each character has developed that explains their life. That's true for every character, not only those whose perspective we see. Each has their own way of responding to the external influences trying to change their internal narrative. Most of them fall into maladaptive behaviors: denial, delusion, paranoia, hatred, obsession, and depression. There's still hope yet for them all though.

This borderline novella is told through alternating chapters of Lyn, Nyr, and Sendra. Sendra is both an antagonist and comedic relief. I found the humor to be mildly amusing. He makes for a fine addition. Despite having three POVs in this relatively short book, I feel that it was a good length that accomplished what it needed to with both the characters and plot.

I was surprised when I first saw this. I didn't expect there to be a sequel. I don't know that there needed to be one. The first book did very well as a standalone and now it's lost that distinction. Anyone can of course not continue and leave it as such though. Should I have? Possibly so. I've rated this 3 stars. I like characters, the plot, the humor, the length, and just about everything about it. So what's the problem? The thematic content saps much of my enjoyment. This is yet again a personal issue. For more details on that, read the commentary afterwards. Those who don't have personal hang-ups about whatever will find this to be a good follow-up. The ending definitely sets it up for there to be more to come, with potentially a far more expansive scope.
Profile Image for Cheenu.
185 reviews35 followers
November 13, 2026
Not as good as Elder Race (review) but still a very engrossing read and finishes strong.

Looking forward to reading more of Adrian Tchaikovsky's books and discovering his thought-provoking worlds and characters.
Profile Image for James.
786 reviews59 followers
October 15, 2026
For me, the best part of Elder Race was the juxtaposition of the sci-fi/fantasy depending on the POV. That’s mostly missing here, leaving just the follow-up story, which I was only half interested in.
Author 5 books68 followers
September 6, 2026
I’m a space wizard now. Wubba lubba dub dub.
Profile Image for Wick Welker.
Author 12 books765 followers
October 18, 2026
What a great continuation of a great little novella series. Awesome world and characters. A pleasure to read.
Profile Image for Benghis Kahn.
392 reviews268 followers
September 27, 2026
A worthy sequel to Elder Race, which was honestly a major relief after a string of utter sequel fails for me with Tchaikovsky's various sci-fi worlds.

Tchaikovsky has a very distinctive prose style with this series which feels much more elegant and considered than just about everything else of his I've read, which is apt given one of the major themes around language use/translation across cultures.

I enjoyed the propulsiveness of this novella which picks back up a handful of years after Elder Race and throws us right into a compelling plot with a new POV character added to the mix whom I found to be a great addition.

I felt just as invested in the returning POVs as I remember being a bunch of years back when I last spent time with them, and I feel like they're two of Tchaikovsky's most distinctive character creations who just feel so fully realized in three dimensions. Tchaikovsky has these characters doing a lot of emotional introspection in a way that I find gripping rather than cheesy or melodramatic, and I think the slim size of these books really works in the favor of this approach so it never feels tiring or repetitive. The prose/voice work and character writing here are definitely the main draws.

I'm not sure the final showdown and resolution fully worked for me which is why I went with 4 stars instead of the 5 which I had handed out to Elder Race with no reservations, which had felt like a truly fully formed and satisfying story in 200 pages. This one felt more like it was intentionally leaving room for a sequel to follow, and without giving any spoilers away it's hard to discuss this whole antagonist situation but I just never clicked with the way the conflict unfolded and semi-resolved.

It was quite an engaging read though on the whole and hopefully a sign that all is not lost for me with Tchaikovsky's new sci-fi writing.
Profile Image for ExtraGravy.
600 reviews32 followers
October 3, 2026
This was a strong follow up to the Elder Race, although It wasn't quite as good. The generations of female protagonists got a bit muddled for me, and the villain was indeterminate... which left the ending flat, and the book like a setup for a longer series in this world.

The Jack Vance vibes I enjoyed in the first one were left in the first one. There is still an intriguing mix of science and magic but without the mystery/unknown/adventure of Vance.
Profile Image for Cathy .
2,018 reviews307 followers
September 5, 2026
We return to the world of Elder Race some years later. This is almost the extent of what I took away from this story. Sorry, this was a bust and I almost DNFd it halfway through. The audio just went over my head and I could not take this in.

I don‘t know if it really was the audio or if the story just did nothing for me. I will have to reread this in print to make that distinction. Maybe before the sequel to this comes out?

For now: I had problems telling the characters apart, I could not figure out what was going on for much of the narrative. Nyr is back and Lynesse. More about that in the next novella?

🗼🗼¾☆☆
Profile Image for Jurjen.
170 reviews26 followers
September 20, 2026
Elder Race was the first Tchaikovsky book I read, and it was a pretty strong introduction to his writing. I was a bit surprised at seeing Elder Race getting a sequel as I didn't really feel like it needed one, but I think Engines of Reason largely justifies its existence. I do think it's weaker than Elder Race. It doesn't share the interesting framing device that book has, and the pacing is a bit messy. I had a fair amount of fun with it though, and Tchaikovsky was able to add quite a lot of mystery in the second half of the story. The character work is pretty good, but not outstanding. I wonder what these books would look like in full-length novels.
Profile Image for McKenna.
31 reviews4 followers
November 11, 2026
Unfortunately this one didn't hit in quite the same way that the first one did. I still think Nyr and Lyn's POVs are great, and the writing style is distinct enough that nothing gets muddied or lost in the POV switching. The addition of Sendra's POV was also a welcome one. I enjoyed seeing the world of Sophos IV expanded a bit, and I love that there's no handholding when it comes to worldbuilding. It makes these novellas gripping and intriguing throughout.

I think the premise of the 1st installment, Elder Race, was just so fantastic and deftly executed that this one fell a little flat in comparison. The ending of Engines of Reason felt a bit rushed and not quite as tight as the first book, giving me the impression that this installment was used as more of a setup for future novellas, while the first book can absolutley stand on its own. Regardless, these are novellas are excellently written, and I'll definitely tune in to future installments. Highly recommend if you're looking for some clever, intriguing, bite-sized sci-fi.
Profile Image for gree.books •♡✿⊹ ࣪ ˖♡•.
307 reviews27 followers
October 26, 2026
I’m not sure if I just lost focus while reading, but I don’t think I understood the point of this novella. it’s a direct continuation of Elder Race, and while it was just as mysterious and entertaining, thematically it didn’t feel like it added much to the foundation Elder Race laid out. it also follows a very similar plot structure to Elder Race, which made it feel predictable. we learn more about the world, and the ending suggests more books are coming, so maybe it’ll all be clearer once I’ve read further installments. for now, though, I was entertained but not sure what more Tchaikovsky wanted to say with this series or why it’s being continued.

with books this short, the characters aren’t the main hook for me, since there’s little room to flesh them out properly (though Nyr is iconic). what I’m after is the themes, the questions, the dilemmas, and that’s where Engines of Reason fell short. a step down from Elder Race for me. fun while I was reading it, but not much to think about afterwards.
Profile Image for Denise.
167 reviews79 followers
October 28, 2026
Engines of Reason is the second book in the Elder Race series and is a captivating novella that expands the world-building in this impressive science fiction and fantasy amalgamation. The passage of time from the first novella has added depth to the familiar characters, while also providing new obstacles, political intrigue and unique interpretations of familiar themes.

John Lee has returned as the narrator of the novella and continues to provide an energetic and engrossing performance. The new characters are interesting contrasts to the more somber rendition of Nyr and the lighter rendition of Lynesse. If there is another book in the series, I would continue to listen to it as an audiobook.

While I enjoyed Engines Of Reason, I felt that Elder Race had more of an emotional impact upon me, especially as an examination of isolation and depression. Nevertheless, Engines Of Reason is still an enjoyable sequel. There is a dash of body horror, an intriguing mystery and a conclusion that may not be quite what the listener expects-yet reiterates the themes regarding the nature of stories and how they can be interpreted.

Lynesse has grown from an idealistic girl to a young woman struggling with the consequences of her decisions-both personal and political. The anthropologist or wizard-depending upon who is asked-Nyr has left his tower and become the court magician. A new perspective is also introduced in the form of Sendra, a brigand with control over monstrous creatures and a mysterious ally.

The characters’ interactions with one another remains a highlight in this novella and I’m quite excited to see how the choices that were made will inevitably effect their futures, as well as the overall shape of their world going forward. As someone who doesn’t usually read books in a series due to time constraints, this is one that I would recommend.
Profile Image for Banshee.
847 reviews77 followers
October 7, 2026
It was a fine continuation of a stellar novella, but it didn't wow me.

On one hand, it was comforting to check in with the characters that I grew to like and find out how their lives continued with the passage of time. The world also seems potentially vast, so there's clearly space to fill in more blanks. The witch plotline was definitely intriguing and kept me guessing.

On the other hand, I feel like the character exploration took a back seat. Too much space was taken by a third POV which wasn't even all that interesting. Besides, the humour that stemmed from radically different understanding of the world was no longer prominent and it was what made the first book so original.

It feels to me like the abrupt and unsatisfactory ending is setting up for a continuation, so I'm not counting it towards negatives. Unless there won't be a third book, and then it's definitely a negative.
Profile Image for Tac Anderson.
Author 2 books98 followers
September 6, 2026
Adrian Tchaikovsky has a way of world building that is truly unique. We see that in every series he's written and we see that again here, even in novella form. He's taken what he started in Elder Race and launched it into a whole new plane of the elliptical.
Profile Image for Ellison.
956 reviews3 followers
November 14, 2026
He is using an old trope in a new way to create a short, entertaining and soft-boiled (if I may use a mystery term) story. It is as good as the first one and I will read a third when he writes it.
Profile Image for Leticia.
Author 3 books121 followers
November 3, 2026
At 50%, but I will definitely drop the audiobook. I have rarely seen an audiobook narration that didn't work at all for me like this. I will even note down the narrator so that I never buy an audiobook narrated by him in the future.

It was a lot better to read the ebook. Still, this second book was interesting, but I liked the first book more.
I wonder if this story will continue?
191 reviews6 followers
September 17, 2026
3.5 rounded up. Elder Race is peerless, there was no way the sequel would stand up and it didn't, but I'm now hopeful for more in this world (just not anything like what Elder Race was).
Displaying 1 - 30 of 202 reviews

Join the discussion