In the tradition of The Lost and The Postcard, a powerful novel of loss and restitution in and after wartime, like a detective novel in reverse.
When young French woman marries and moves to her German husband’s small hometown, Bad Arolsen, she finds a world where no one discusses what the locals did during the war. She has no idea that her life will be changed forever when she accepts a job at the secretive International Tracing Service―founded by the Allies at the end of WWII to help trace the fates of millions of wartime dead and displaced. Meticulous and conscientious, Irene quickly becomes obsessed with her work―at the cost of her personal life.
Years later, she is entrusted with returning thousands of confiscated objects, recovered from the liberated camps. Irène pieces together the identity of each object's rightful owner, in order to give the descendants of the victims something to remember their lost relatives by. A faded cloth doll, a medallion, an embroidered handkerchief . . . every object contains its secrets. During her research, Irène meets people who will inspire and guide her from Lublin to Warsaw, from Berlin to Paris, to discover a past that concerns her personally. In so doing, she glimpses humanity―at its worst, but also, its best―and looking for the dead, she finds the living.
Weaving together the trajectories of these individual lives with the collective memory of Europe, this devastatingly beautiful novel is suffused with wisdom and compassion.
Née à Paris en 1973, Gaëlle Nohant vit aujourd’hui à Lyon. La Part des flammes est son deuxième roman après L’Ancre des rêves, 2007 chez Robert Laffont, récompensé par le prix Encre Marine. Elle est également l’auteur d’un document sur le Rugby et d’un recueil de nouvelles, L’homme dérouté.
Gaëlle Nohant se consacre à l’écriture depuis une dizaine d’années. Inspirée notamment par Dickens et par les écrivains victoriens, cette jeune femme qui construit le canevas de sa narration à partir d’une base documentaire importante, défend une littérature à la fois exigeante et populaire.
The inhumane and horrific treatment, the lives lost during the Holocaust, the life long trauma of the survivors, of course, are ultimately the most important things we need to remember and continue bearing witness to . However, we must also remember the lives of the victims stolen from them. The stories told here are of separations from children, gas chambers, firing squads, unimaginable conditions, horrific medical experiments on women at Ravensbruck . The descriptions of these despicable acts of evil against innocent people are difficult to read , but it’s imperative to keep telling these truths. This novel is so powerful, heartbreaking and moving, yet ironically beautiful with unexpected moments of joy and appreciation.
Irene, an archivist at The International Tracing Service, works diligently and with her whole heart to connect descendants of Holocaust victims to their families. She is tasked with taking the initiative of connecting them through objects found - child’s puppet, a locket, an embroidered handkerchief. Through her investigative work, like putting together a puzzle she discovers letters, objects, memories , photographs, records, and the people connected to each other illustrating the extraordinary courage and heart of victims saving and protecting other victims impacting their fate. In doing so, she discovers a personal connection as well.
This is a novel and I was hoping for some explanation of whether any of the characters and their personal stories described were based on real accounts. The Archives in Arolsen and the International Tracing Service are real, times and places events are true. I was hoping to find more about what was true, what was fiction and the author’s inspiration in a note, but there was none at the end of this advanced copy. I was thrilled to find this interview with the author that gave me what I was looking for.
The Bureau of Unknown Fates by Gaëlle Nohant Narrated by Julie Teal
Until this book I wasn't aware of The International Tracing Service (now Arolsen Archives) based in Germany. Founded in 1948, in this historical fiction, long after the service was created, Irene starts working there as an archivist and it's not long before she's obsessed with her work and tracking down people and objects, life stories and relatives. In Irene's present time, years after she has been working at the service, she is tasked with connecting items, which appear to have come from concentration camp victims, with the relatives of those people. We travel with Irene to various locations, meet friends, relatives, camp survivors and their descendants and learn how often the mental and emotional damage is passed down to family due to the suffering of the survivors. The fault is not that of the survivors, who can blame them for not be able to talk about the horrors of what happened before, during, and after the war.
Julie Teal does a wonderful job narrating Irene and the other characters. I do wish that we weren't introduced to so many people because it was difficult to keep track of them all. I listened to the book with the ebook in front of me and this was very important since I would not have been able to pronounce so many of the names in the book but I needed the ebook to help me keep track of all the characters we meet. Having the visual of their names in front of my helped me to enjoy the audiobook more.
At times I would get confused about the timeline, Irene goes back in time in her memories but then so do the people she meets and speaks to during her investigations. So many of these people are hurting. They lost loved ones to the war and those that came home from camps or hiding to try to avoid being imprisoned or exterminated carried those experiences with them forever. As Irene looks for the ancestors of the people who owned or touched certain items, she was often led on a spider web path that might have no end. She makes use of people from all over and often things she learns has her thinking about her own life and beliefs before she took up this overwhelming job. It's obvious this is where she needs to be, no other career would fit her better than this one, although she can neglect her home life for work too easily when she gets carried away with work. I was able to read/hear this book with DeAnn and it always helps to have her to discuss this time period with me, as my mind boggles at the inhumanity of men. But, we also get to see the great sacrifices of others, against hopeless odds, to make life (or death) better for those around them.
Thank you to Macmillan Audio, St. Martin's Press, SMP Early Readers, NetGalley for this ARC
Książka jest fikcją literacką, inspirowaną historią. Rzadko sięgam po takie powieści, kieruję się tym co przyświeca pisarzom i w roli kogo występują bohaterowie. Tutaj mamy tytaniczną walkę w celu zwrócenia części historii i tożsamości rozerwanych istnień. To było dla mnie coś niesamowicie bolesnego, ale i poruszającego.
Powieść jest poruszająca, intryga powieściowa ciekawa, a prawdziwa historia ukryta między fabułą - pasjonująca. Nic dziwnego, że powieść Nohant została doceniona tak przez czytelników, jak i krytyków, a poleca ją sama Valérie Perrin.
‼️Ważne: to wyważona i nieprzesadzona powieść, pisana z myślą, by przybliżyć pracę archiwów.
Un autre roman émouvant et hyper bien écrit par Gaëlle Nohant, dont je suis fan de la plume depuis des années. Ici, elle relate l'histoire d'une archiviste qui a comme mission de rendre aux descendants des camps certains objets ayant appartenu à des déportés. J'ai mis un moment à m'attacher mais le final est très émouvant.
Le meilleur livre que j'ai lu depuis extrêmement longtemps. J'ai à la fois envie de le partager au monde et de le garder pour moi, comme un delicieux secret.
Ce roman a pour personnage principal Irène qui a pour travail le fait de retrouver des descendants de victime du génocide des juifs pendant la seconde guerre mondiale afin de leur donner des objets ayant appartenu à leurs défunts aïeuls.
Alors le processus narratif est assez simple : c’est une suite de traumatismes incessants ayant pour but d’émouvoir le lecteur : divorce, déracinement familial, expatriation, génocide, meurtre, femme enceinte abandonnée, kidnapping, famille monoparentale, héritage familial très lourd, attentats, arrivée de migrants, lutte féministe pour l’avortement et j’en oublie sûrement.
Pour surmonter ces traumatismes, il y a deux types de personnages caricaturaux : les anges du bien contre les bons gros méchants diaboliques.
Les anges du bien ont beaucoup souffert et sont moralement irréprochables et pour la quasi-totalité d’entre eux, il y a une happy end à la fin. C’est la solution finale vue par Disney.
Irène : la française qui part en Allemagne par amour (thème du déracinement), divorce de son mari allemand car beau-papa était peut-être nazi, gère son fils toute seule et est recrutée dans une agence gouvernementale (sans aucune qualification) pour rendre des objets aux enfants de rescapés (donc aider les gens à retrouver leurs racines).
Eva : c’est la supérieure hiérarchique d’Irène, rescapée de camps, toujours le cœur sur la main, pleine d’abnégation en dépit de ses traumatismes, le modèle de vertu.
Hanno : le fils parfait qui s’inquiète pour sa mère, étudiant, donne des cours d’alphabétisation et d’aide administrative à des migrants sur son temps libre (comme si on avait le temps de faire ça pendant ses études... maman n’a pas l’air de rouler sur l’or.)
Witta : la polonaise dont l’enfant fut kidnappé par des SS qui une fois dans les camps prend un p’tit juif sous son aile et préfère mourir avec, que le laisser seul.
Lazar, l’ex Sonderkommando a récupéré le doudou d’un bébé tué et qui depuis, traumatisé, ne veut pas d’enfants car il a beaucoup souffert et meurt sous les coups de couteaux après avoir passé sa vie à rechercher son bourreau.
Rudi : le fils d’un enfant enlevé par les nazis est documentariste et réalise des films sur les migrants.
Et il y en a plein d’autres : le gay de service, deux féministes (dont une aux cheveux bleus, sans déconner…)…
Les méchants : il y a les Nazis, les gardiens de camps et l’ex-directeur de l’agence autoritaire (quasiment tous les membres d’une hiérarchie quelconque sont méchants)
Bref, une suite de portraits sans faille, caricaturaux ne ressemblant aucunement à une personne normale. On voit passer un membre de la Wehrmacht repenti une fois mais ça ne dure qu’une page. Ce genre de personnage me gêne car cela ne rend pas la fiction réaliste. On dirait un feel-good book d’extrême gauche ayant pour thème la solution finale.
Comme dans tout bon feel-good books, ça se finit bien pour tous les personnages vertueux et mal pour les méchants. Or, ce n’est pas toujours le cas dans la réalité. Cela ne rend pas non plus le roman crédible.
Cette vision du génocide juif est gênante. Entre la bienveillance diffuse, le côté vertueux de tous les personnages ou presque et les thématiques constamment connotée politiquement (la référence aux migrants, la marche pro avortement des polonaises, l’asso féministe qui protège les reliques d’un camp de femmes…), on dirait une vision progressiste de la solution finale, une appropriation culturelle de ce thème par les tendances politiques à la mode dans la gauche actuelle, ce que j’ai trouvé malaisant et très anachronique.
Les meilleurs livres sur ce thème sont ceux des rescapés eux-mêmes (Primo Levi, Jorge Semprun, Charlotte Delbo...) voire des historiens. On y apprend la vraie nature de l’homme : que des Allemands pouvaient faire preuve d’humanité et que certains détenus et civils pouvaient commettre des horreurs, que tout n’est pas blanc ou noir, dans la vie ou dans la mort.
C’est mon premier livre de Gaëlle Nohant et ce sera probablement mon dernier, si celui-ci est considéré comme un des meilleurs. Utiliser le procédé des feel-good books pour parler d’un génocide m’a mis mal à l’aise. On dirait un Melichia La Shoah.
Donner une teinte gauchisante au pire événement de l’histoire depuis l’extinction des Amérindiens est assez fou quand on y pense. Cela m’a donné une envie de faire de faire la même chose version écolo. Dolores, une divorcée aux cheveux verts, ayant découvert son lesbianisme sur le tard (car non tolérée en Espagne catholique à l’époque) embauchée au service RSE d’Auschwitz aurait pour but d’améliorer le bilan carbone de la Shoah : « Alors oui, les trains étaient alimentés au charbon et les cheminées relâchaient pas mal de particules fines mais nous avons économisé 5,5 milliards de tonnes de CO2 en tuant tous ces gens (en consommation d’un occidental moyen avec une espérance de vie de 85 ans). » La journée, ils appelleraient les rescapés et descendants pour faire un sondage sur la réduction à la portion congrue de l’utilisation des pesticides sur les chemins d’accès, de pratiquer la tonte raisonnée dans les terrains jouxtant les baraquements et la culture maraîchère bio en permaculture des terrains fertiles entre les différents bâtiments. J’ai déjà le bandeau marketing : « Un livre bouleversant à la racine du mal. Un livre France Inter. » Cela s’appellerait « Le bureau de verdissement des aryens ».
I tend to steer clear of much of the latest trend in WWII historical fiction. Stories that romanticize an era when over 70 million people perished are unappealing to me. It was a time when everyone lost someone, often several loved ones, not a time of finding unexpected love in a concentration camp. All that to say, this book seemed different and I was eager to read it.
The International Tracing Service that is central to this story is real, but the author gives no indication (hopefully will in final published author's note) if there is any truth to the items and characters investigated by the modern day main character. This book isn't truly historical fiction since it takes place in 2016, but the Irene's focus on the past through her work makes it feel like historical fiction. I had never heard of the ITS, so I found that part of the story interesting and enjoyed learning more about the post-war years in Europe. However, the book is unfocused and disjointed, making it difficult to feel truly invested in any of the characters.
It is almost dual timeline with three separate WWII stories that each contain many characters. Irene's personal story is also told but with little impact. The modern portion of the story seems included primarily to lecture the reader on left-wing politics, which pulls one out of the story to say the least. Too many characters are introduced with little purpose rather than focusing on a few that could really have an impact on the reader. To be honest, by halfway through I was just looking forward to it being over. Irene was not a character who made me care about what happened to her.
This story had some great potential but didn't draw me in the way I had hoped it would.
Recommend for those who love WWII histfic and dual timeline stories.
Thank you to NetGalley for my review copy. Opinions are my own.
Une lecture riche dans son ensemble, qui se montre poignante mais pleine de pudeur, et surtout qui questionne sur la filiation, le droit de mémoire et le devoir de vérité (ou pas).
Lorsque l'héroïne de l'histoire se voit confier la mission de restituer des objets récoltés après la libération des camps, elle se lance dans une enquête scrupuleuse, limite obsessionnelle, pour retrouver les descendants des défunts. Un pierrot au tissu usé attire particulièrement son attention. Et de fil en aiguille, Irène va remonter la piste d'un homme au destin bouleversant. D'autres découvertes vont également ponctuer son travail acharné, avec de belles rencontres et la sensation d'accomplir quelque chose d'utile et rédempteur. Car elle se heurte aussi à des refus ou à de la colère (en atteste son histoire personnelle). Imaginez des secrets de famille enfouis, des révélations qui réapparaissent soixante-dix ans plus tard. Imaginez un héritage dont le poids émotionnel est finalement plus lourd que le simple geste de transmission. Gaëlle Nohant réussit, quant à elle, à adresser un message d'espoir et parfois de résilience. Il ne s'agit évidemment que de fiction. Toutefois, on se prête à penser que d'autres Lazar ou Allegra ont réellement compté et mériteraient aussi de reposer en paix.
🎧〰️ Format audio d'une grande élégance. Servi par une interprétation sobre et délicate. J'ai écouté ce titre en seulement quelques jours ! C'était captivant.
Ik mocht "Van wie ze waren", geschreven door Gaëlle Nohant lezen.
Een boek over de doden uit WO II, de kampen, het vernietigen van de Joodse bevolking.
De objecten die deze mensen verplicht moesten achterlaten vertellen elk hun verhaal.
Ouders, kinderen, geliefden werden uit elkaar gehaald. Later wilden overlevende of hun familie meer te weten komen over hen die heengingen, hen die vermoord werden, hen die vluchten.
Kinderen werden verhandeld en kregen nieuwe namen, nieuwe ouders en vergaten hun afkomst.
Door teruggevonden foto's, brieven, spulletjes proberen de archivarisen van het INTERNATIONAL TRACING SERVICE het leven van de onbekende te reconstrueren.
Wita terugvinden werd een uitdaging. Een verhaal van lange adem. Een verhaal dat ondanks alles een mooi einde kent.
Maar er zijn vaak Wita's die niet gevonden worden, waarvan niemand weet wat er met hen gebeurde.
Een verhaal vol emoties, een mooi verhaal over pijnlijke herinneringen.
Ne vjerujem da sam za početak godine odabrala knjigu s tako teškom temom. Mislila sam da je ovo samo još jedna knjiga o ratu... Nije. Nijedna ratna knjiga koju sam dosad pročitala nije imala ovoliko činjenica, ima ih toliko da za neke pojmove nisam ni znala što znače. Zbog toliko činjenica mi je bila pomalo dosadna i razmišljala sam bih li je možda ocijenila s 4 zvjezdice, ali nije loša, a ja nisam od onih kritičnih. Radnja mi se jako svidjela, sve mi se jako svidjelo jedino mi je imalo malo previše, po meni nebitnih, činjenica o ratu i svemu tome. U zahvalama je autorica rekla da su svi likovi i slučajevi izmišljeni, ali da taj centar stvarno postoji i to mi je baš fora, mogla sam se vidjeti kako radim tamo jer mi se sviđa vrsta posla. Nemam ništa puno za prokomentirati, sve sam većinom rekla tako da ću još samo reći da imate preporuku od mene, pogotovo ako volite činjenice o ratu!
Irene est archiviste à l’international tracing service depuis 25 ans et est en charge de restituer des milliers d’objets aux descendants des victimes. Irene est archiviste depuis 25 ans mais pourtant on a la sensation qu’il faut tout lui expliquer. C’est elle qui rencontre les familles mais ses recherches sont réalisées par tout le monde sauf elle… Peu d’empathie pour sa situation familiale personnelle. On se demande ce que ça ajoute à l’histoire, ça fait un peu tache. On se perd avec tous les perso sans vraiment faire un lien entre tous, ou du moins c’est compliqué.. Et la précision FAUSSE des gants de manipulation à chaque fois qu’un document est touché, franchement…. En tant qu’archiviste ça m’a bien énervé
I did not finish the book. I found the story to slow to develop. Having said that, I liked to read about the details shared about WWII and the beautiful “plume” and writing of the author.
I don’t know that I’ve wished for the author’s note in an advanced copy of a book more than I have with Gaelle Nohant’s The Bureau of Unknown Fates.
The book is about World War Two in Europe, which I openly admit to getting burned out on because it’s such a popular subject of historical fiction. Every once in a while I come across a story that approaches it in a way that is new to me, making it worth the read, and this book is one of them.
The book is told in 2016 by Irene, a French woman who married a German man and ended up in Hesse, Germany, working for the International Tracing Service (ITS), trying to reunite possessions of people victimized and killed by the Nazis with their owners or descendants.
This, and Irene’s views on the war end her marriage not long after it begins, but having become fully immersed in the work she is doing at the ITS, and inspired by her mentor Eva, she decides to stay in Hesse and continue her work.
Over the years she experiences the frustration of working for someone who may not be destroying artifacts but is certainly doing his best to limit the group from accomplishing its mission, the sadness and grief associated with the reason her job exists, and the occasional joy of reuniting someone with a possession long assumed lost, or providing some measure of an ancestor’s history to their descendants.
The book primarily follows her attempts to find the stories of three people. One is that of her mentor Eva herself, when her great niece Lucia comes to visit and Irene finds herself regretting not learning more of Eva’s story earlier.
The book also follows her attempts to unravel the mysteries of Wita and Lazar by using possessions and clues left behind.
While I suspect Eva, Wita, and Lazar to be fictional, though possibly based at least somewhat on real people, the ITS, now known as the Arolsen Archives, is very real and open to anyone. Although there is no author’s not in the advanced copy I read, I suspect many of the attempts in the book to bury the past, excuse personal actions, and the fracturing of families are also very real representations of things still happening today in Germany.
The book isn’t perfect. The modern storyline and Irene don’t have a tremendous amount of depth, since it and she serve more as a way to show how the past and present are still very much interconnected. But it is very powerful in telling the role the ITS/Arolsen Archives is doing to shine a light on the victims and make sure we don’t forget about the atrocities that were committed against them, and providing an alternative look at the war through the eyes of someone working there to provide some closure years later.
A complimentary copy of this book was provided by the publisher. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
****Many thanks to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for an advanced eArc in exchange for my honest opinion****
In an effort to not sound so mean perhaps I will keep this on the shorter side.
The premise sounded incredibly interesting, I have never heard of the International Tracing Center before and I always love to read and learn more about a subject I never knew much about or ever. However this "book" reads more like the most dense textbook you've ever had to have the unfortunate fate of having to slog through.
Irene is seems to be the speakerphone of relaying a fair amount of propaganda to the reader. I am not, nor will ever be a fan of popular society ideals to be chewed up and spat back in my mouth. I am a big woman, I can read between the lines and understand the subtle art of trying to get a point across without slapping a reader across the face with it.
This was solely focused on pushing a certain set of opinions and in doing that what could have been a meaningful story was lost in the clutter.
15 mars 2023. J’ai été quelques fois à Bad Arolsen en 1973. L’International Tracins Service n’existait pas encore mais j’y ai sans doute croisé quelques nazis aux passés bien chargés. J’ai accompli mon service militaire à quelques kilomètres de là, entourés d’allemands de cinquante ou soixante ans, acteurs à des degrés divers de la Shoah. A l’époque, cela ne me préoccupait pas trop. Aujourd’hui, ça me hante. Sur une trame très documentée, Gaëlle Nohant a bâti une fiction bouleversante qui nous mène aux confins de l’horreur. Ému aux larmes. « Le bureau d’éclaircissement des destins ». Gaëlle Nohant. Bernard Grasset. Paris. 2023.
Au cœur de l’Allemagne, l’International Tracing Service est le plus grand centre de documentation sur les persécutions nazies. La jeune Irène y trouve un emploi en 1990 et se découvre une vocation pour le travail d’investigation. Méticuleuse, obsessionnelle, elle se laisse happer par ses dossiers, au regret de son fils qu’elle élève seule depuis son divorce d’avec son mari allemand. A l'automne 2016, Irène se voit confier une mission inédite : restituer les milliers d’objets dont le centre a hérité à la libération des camps. Un Pierrot de tissu terni, un médaillon, un mouchoir brodé… Chaque objet, même modeste, renferme ses secrets. Il faut retrouver la trace de son propriétaire déporté, afin de remettre à ses descendants le souvenir de leur parent. Au fil de ses enquêtes, Irène se heurte aux mystères du Centre et à son propre passé. Cherchant les disparus, elle rencontre ses contemporains qui la bouleversent et la guident, de Varsovie à Paris et Berlin, en passant par Thessalonique ou l’Argentine. Au bout du chemin, comment les vivants recevront-ils ces objets hantés ? Le bureau d’éclaircissement des destins, c’est le fil qui unit ces trajectoires individuelles à la mémoire collective de l’Europe. Une fresque brillamment composée, d’une grande intensité émotionnelle, où Gaëlle Nohant donne toute la puissance de son talent.
In Germania esiste ancora oggi un istituto di ricerca, nel quale si indaga sulla sorte di tutte le vittime del Nazismo, cercando anche di restituire ai discendenti i settantamila oggetti contenuti su quegli scaffali. Un pupazzo, un medaglione e un fazzoletto sono all'apparenza oggetti insignificanti, ma che ne "L'archivio dei destini" di Gaëlle Nohant assumono un ruolo fondamentale: diventano porte d'accesso per ridare voce a tutte le vittime del Nazismo. Tra romanzo e ricerca storica, leggerlo significa tirare un filo tra passato e presente dove la memoria si impone come necessaria e doverosa.
The idea is very good, quite intriguing, a different angle of horrifying events that took place mid-2oth century. The execution could have been a lot better. It is very slow paced, many characters, sometimes you get lost between them, some of them, that were not part of the events are really affected by what they do, becoming even annoyed when someone does not want to know their past, does not want to relive some events: "What about the right of the [insert name] that want to know you?" There are quite a few events taking place today, most of them being presented from a far-left of left side of the politics. Almost praised, which, from my point of view should not have been included.
C'est le meilleur livre que j'ai lu sur la shoah depuis que j'ai lu la mort est mon métier. Comment écrire sur le mal absolu tout en dégageant l'humanité des victimes. Je crois que madame Nohant a réussi ce tour de force. Elle réussit à présenter tout ce que représente la shoah pour le XXeme siècle: le mal absolu, l'antisémitisme, la honte des allemands des survivants, notre honte.... Le choix de son héroïne et les enquêtes qu'elle mène y sont pour beaucoup.
Un livre poignant et indispensable sur une période de l'histoire que certains s'ingénient à remanier ou à effacer. Pour ma part, cette lecture a permis la découverte d'un organisme dont j'ignorais totalement l'existence...
Thank you NetGalley and St. Martins Press for the eARC.
Irene works at the International Tracing Service, an organization that helps people affected by the horrors of the Holocaust reunite with their loved ones or long lost belongings. It’s like being a detective working cold cases, in a sense. Irene finds a doll one day and is determined to find its rightful owner.
This was very different from my usual reads. It’s historical fiction, and it’s genuinely been a while since I’ve come across a holocaust story. This was a very fascinating story, with so many turns and obstacles along the way. Irene is a very easy to like character. Her work seems very difficult and I can’t imagine being immersed in this kind of environment daily, being reminded of atrocities and how monstrous humans can be.
The overall story was straightforward but with a lot of detours. It took me about halfway to finally remember who was who and who belonged to which story line (either Eva or Lazar). Between those, you also have other smaller scale stories weaving throughout. It’s all pain and suffering, but there are also uplifting and hopeful moments.
The closest organization to this ITS is probably the Arolsen Archives (based on my search) and I truly applaud people for continuing to educate the public, and to keep the memories of those affected alive.
I do kinda wish there was an author note, just to help walk through her train of thought and if they were inspired by any events.
I was very excited to have the opportunity to read this ARC. I have read so many WWII books, but none have covered this aspect of searching for the survivors and returning the belongings of unfortunate ones that were never able to do so. Not only was it an investigative story of who the survivors were, but it provided so many stories of the final days or of the actions taken by officers or prisoners in the camps. I felt the story was researched well, and the timeframes were described perfectly. I had 2 cons with the book, first one, this book needs to be read in person, it is difficult to listen to via VoiceView and understand what was being said. Quite a few stories were written in italics, and you needed to know in order to understand that the timeframe had changed, and who the speaker was. The second con was there are a lot of characters in here, not only are they the present characters that also bring a lot to the story, but they are prisoners, family of prisoners, past acquaintances, I almost had to write down who they were in order to keep track. Otherwise, this is a very good story, and it has a lot of information about the war and the lives of the survivors. I thank St. Martin’s Press along with NetGalley for the opportunity to read this ARC. Comes in with 4 stars.