What do you think?
Rate this book
The Oxford Guide to Scandal and Lies
Not yet published
Expected 1 Sep 26Set against the backdrop of post-WWII Oxford University, The Oxford Guide to Scandal and Lies is the irresistible debut from Kate Westbury that seamlessly layers mystery, romance, and a dash of academia to introduce the Crown’s newest undercover operatives.
Oxford, England, 1951 - The Honorable Ginevra Bishop likes red lipstick, clever retorts, and earning top marks in her tutorials. She’s following her mother’s footsteps by studying at Oxford, eager to prove she’s more than a debutante.
Sidney Braithwaite likes brooding, Latin, and ignoring his nightmares. He’s determined to forge a new life for himself at Oxford, far from his childhood mining village and free from memories of the war.
Though Gin and Sidney have little in common, the British Security Service is keen to unite her charm with his espionage experience: there’s a Soviet spy at the university, and the agent tracking them down was poisoned. MI5 wants Gin and Sidney to pick up the trail and identify the informant before more sensitive information is compromised. As a team, the pair of undergraduates clash in personality, upbringing, and taste––but have a connection neither can deny. Gin and Sidney must unite their respective talents to follow the clues before they’re caught in the traitor’s crosshairs…if the sparks flying between them don’t blow up the operation first.
Oxford, England, 1951 - The Honorable Ginevra Bishop likes red lipstick, clever retorts, and earning top marks in her tutorials. She’s following her mother’s footsteps by studying at Oxford, eager to prove she’s more than a debutante.
Sidney Braithwaite likes brooding, Latin, and ignoring his nightmares. He’s determined to forge a new life for himself at Oxford, far from his childhood mining village and free from memories of the war.
Though Gin and Sidney have little in common, the British Security Service is keen to unite her charm with his espionage experience: there’s a Soviet spy at the university, and the agent tracking them down was poisoned. MI5 wants Gin and Sidney to pick up the trail and identify the informant before more sensitive information is compromised. As a team, the pair of undergraduates clash in personality, upbringing, and taste––but have a connection neither can deny. Gin and Sidney must unite their respective talents to follow the clues before they’re caught in the traitor’s crosshairs…if the sparks flying between them don’t blow up the operation first.
352 pages, Hardcover
Expected publication September 1, 2026
About the author
Kate Westbury
2 books80 followersKate Westbury grew up a voracious reader of detective fiction, and unraveling plot twists became her favorite pastime. She now puts her whodunnit obsession to good use writing historical mysteries. Beyond the page, Kate teaches Latin and dreams of moving to an English village with crimes to solve.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 111 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
If you tell me a book contains Oxford, spies, murder, and romantic tension, I’m already halfway through it before anyone finishes the sentence. So when I picked up The Oxford Guide to Scandal and Lies by Kate Westbury, I knew I was walking straight into my favorite kind of chaos.
And chaos it is—the clever, tea-stained, bookish kind.
Welcome to Oxford in 1951, where the war may technically be over but the shadows it left behind are still lurking in lecture halls, libraries, and suspiciously polite conversations over tea. Into this slightly tense, very academic world step our two unlikely detectives: Ginevra Bishop and Sidney Braithwaite.
Gin is a viscount’s daughter with impeccable lipstick, razor-sharp wit, and absolutely no interest in being the decorative society ornament everyone expects her to become. She wants to prove she belongs at Oxford on her own merits—and preferably while irritating anyone who thinks otherwise.
Sidney, on the other hand, carries the war in his bones. He’s quiet, guarded, and trying very hard to pretend that espionage and trauma are things he left behind. Unfortunately for him, the universe (and British intelligence) has other plans.
When a spy investigation crashes into Oxford after a suspicious poisoning, these two are recruited to quietly poke around campus and figure out who’s leaking dangerous secrets. Because apparently the best way to catch a spy is to send two argumentative students with unresolved emotional baggage to do the job.
Honestly? Iconic strategy.
What follows is a delicious mix of mystery, espionage, and academic shenanigans. There are secret clues, suspicious professors, coded messages, shady conversations in libraries, and the constant feeling that someone is watching from just around the corner.
And then there’s the dynamic between Gin and Sidney—which is half teamwork, half verbal sparring match.
These two clash in all the best ways. She’s impulsive and fearless, diving headfirst into trouble with the confidence of someone who has never met a boundary she didn’t want to cross. Sidney is cautious, observant, and constantly trying to keep the operation from turning into absolute disaster. Watching them slowly learn to trust each other (while still arguing about nearly everything) was ridiculously entertaining.
Also, the banter deserves a standing ovation.
The romance simmers in the background rather than taking over the story, which I actually loved. It grows quietly between moments of danger and investigation—little looks, reluctant concern, the kind of tension that builds when two people realize they might care about each other more than is strategically wise.
The setting itself is practically a character. Oxford feels alive in this book—old libraries, secret corridors, academic societies, and that wonderful sense that history is hiding behind every door.
And the mystery? It kept me guessing. I had theories. I was suspicious of absolutely everyone. I trusted no one except maybe the library.
The story blends classic whodunnit energy with spy-story intrigue, while also touching on deeper themes—class differences, the lingering scars of war, and the pressure of living up to expectations that were never yours to begin with.
By the time I reached the end, I was fully invested in Gin and Sidney—not just in solving mysteries, but in figuring out what kind of future they want to build for themselves.
Also… that ending? It absolutely whispers “this better become a series.” Because I would happily follow these two into several more academic espionage disasters.
Overall, this was a witty, charming, slightly dangerous historical mystery filled with clever characters, sharp dialogue, and just enough romance to make things interesting.
I’m giving this one four delightfully scandalous stars, and I would gladly return to Oxford with these characters again.
A very huge thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for sharing this intriguing mystery / historical spy thriller romance with me in exchange for my honest feedback. 📚🕵️♀️
medium blog
instagram
facebook
twitter
And chaos it is—the clever, tea-stained, bookish kind.
Welcome to Oxford in 1951, where the war may technically be over but the shadows it left behind are still lurking in lecture halls, libraries, and suspiciously polite conversations over tea. Into this slightly tense, very academic world step our two unlikely detectives: Ginevra Bishop and Sidney Braithwaite.
Gin is a viscount’s daughter with impeccable lipstick, razor-sharp wit, and absolutely no interest in being the decorative society ornament everyone expects her to become. She wants to prove she belongs at Oxford on her own merits—and preferably while irritating anyone who thinks otherwise.
Sidney, on the other hand, carries the war in his bones. He’s quiet, guarded, and trying very hard to pretend that espionage and trauma are things he left behind. Unfortunately for him, the universe (and British intelligence) has other plans.
When a spy investigation crashes into Oxford after a suspicious poisoning, these two are recruited to quietly poke around campus and figure out who’s leaking dangerous secrets. Because apparently the best way to catch a spy is to send two argumentative students with unresolved emotional baggage to do the job.
Honestly? Iconic strategy.
What follows is a delicious mix of mystery, espionage, and academic shenanigans. There are secret clues, suspicious professors, coded messages, shady conversations in libraries, and the constant feeling that someone is watching from just around the corner.
And then there’s the dynamic between Gin and Sidney—which is half teamwork, half verbal sparring match.
These two clash in all the best ways. She’s impulsive and fearless, diving headfirst into trouble with the confidence of someone who has never met a boundary she didn’t want to cross. Sidney is cautious, observant, and constantly trying to keep the operation from turning into absolute disaster. Watching them slowly learn to trust each other (while still arguing about nearly everything) was ridiculously entertaining.
Also, the banter deserves a standing ovation.
The romance simmers in the background rather than taking over the story, which I actually loved. It grows quietly between moments of danger and investigation—little looks, reluctant concern, the kind of tension that builds when two people realize they might care about each other more than is strategically wise.
The setting itself is practically a character. Oxford feels alive in this book—old libraries, secret corridors, academic societies, and that wonderful sense that history is hiding behind every door.
And the mystery? It kept me guessing. I had theories. I was suspicious of absolutely everyone. I trusted no one except maybe the library.
The story blends classic whodunnit energy with spy-story intrigue, while also touching on deeper themes—class differences, the lingering scars of war, and the pressure of living up to expectations that were never yours to begin with.
By the time I reached the end, I was fully invested in Gin and Sidney—not just in solving mysteries, but in figuring out what kind of future they want to build for themselves.
Also… that ending? It absolutely whispers “this better become a series.” Because I would happily follow these two into several more academic espionage disasters.
Overall, this was a witty, charming, slightly dangerous historical mystery filled with clever characters, sharp dialogue, and just enough romance to make things interesting.
I’m giving this one four delightfully scandalous stars, and I would gladly return to Oxford with these characters again.
A very huge thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for sharing this intriguing mystery / historical spy thriller romance with me in exchange for my honest feedback. 📚🕵️♀️
medium blog
Want to Read
March 17, 2026Thank you, St. Martin's Press | Minotaur Books, for sending me this ARC. Mystery, romance, and a dash of academia? Yes, please.
Pub Date Sep 01 2026
As always, all thoughts are my own. 🖤✨
Pub Date Sep 01 2026
As always, all thoughts are my own. 🖤✨
Did Not Finish
April 29, 2026DNF at 55%
Two Oxford students tasked with spying to root out a member of their Uni that's committing treason and leaking intel to Russia. AND has even gone as far as killing the previous agent that had gotten too close.
All that said, this book SHOULD'VE made for a compelling read as murder-mysteries are my jam! Unfortunately, I have to agree with Gin here (the FL) when it came to expecting more subterfuge and excitement with her spying. Whereas, the story was mainly a watch and investigate from the shadows kind of tale. For a book centered around treason and a murder, there was very little action or actual intensity to keep the readers interested. I kept reading on and giving the book more time, but I genuinely don't care to read about sneaking into empty houses in the middle of the night and looking for clues. OR at least have that and then have someone shoot at them or capture one of them or SOMETHING to actually reveal those treacherous stakes that are supposedly at place!
No star rating as I dropped. But! Had I finished this would've gotten a 2 star rating as the characters were well-written and felt realistic but the story itself was slow and boring.
Thank you to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for the arc. All opinions are my own.
Two Oxford students tasked with spying to root out a member of their Uni that's committing treason and leaking intel to Russia. AND has even gone as far as killing the previous agent that had gotten too close.
All that said, this book SHOULD'VE made for a compelling read as murder-mysteries are my jam! Unfortunately, I have to agree with Gin here (the FL) when it came to expecting more subterfuge and excitement with her spying. Whereas, the story was mainly a watch and investigate from the shadows kind of tale. For a book centered around treason and a murder, there was very little action or actual intensity to keep the readers interested. I kept reading on and giving the book more time, but I genuinely don't care to read about sneaking into empty houses in the middle of the night and looking for clues. OR at least have that and then have someone shoot at them or capture one of them or SOMETHING to actually reveal those treacherous stakes that are supposedly at place!
No star rating as I dropped. But! Had I finished this would've gotten a 2 star rating as the characters were well-written and felt realistic but the story itself was slow and boring.
Thank you to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for the arc. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Author
thanks to the author and publisher for inviting me to read this book in exchange for an honest review, all thoughts are my own
4⭐
a super fun historical novel with a strong fmc, supportive mmc, a little rivalry and academic vibe. at times it was a little slow or confusing to read, but i can also blame that on my switching between genres and not reading a historical novel in a while. i recommend for a fun 1920's novel with a fun mystery! < 3
4⭐
a super fun historical novel with a strong fmc, supportive mmc, a little rivalry and academic vibe. at times it was a little slow or confusing to read, but i can also blame that on my switching between genres and not reading a historical novel in a while. i recommend for a fun 1920's novel with a fun mystery! < 3
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This was a delightful mix of Agatha Christie and Nancy Drew! The story starts out with two students at Oxford in a conflict over a study spot in the library and leads in to a delightful mystery involving murder and espionage. The story takes place at the end of the war which is a perfect setting for hunting down spies. The main characters were engaging and the plot had me hooked until the end. Personally I am not a fan of graphic violence and I appreciated that this wasn’t that sort of book. I can only assume, based on the ending, that this is the first in a series. I look forward to reading the next book! Thank you to NetGalley for the advanced reader copy.
March 7, 2026
This little ARC landed in my inbox and has surprised and completely charmed me. If you like Masterpiece Mystery shows, particularly Endeavor or Granchester, you are going to love this. My only issue is with an ending like that I’ll need more Gin and Sidney immediately!
March 27, 2026
Thank you NetGalley and St. Martin’s Publishing Group for the ARC.
Oxford’s Guide to Scandal and Lies is a historical mystery set in 1951 after World War II has ended. Ginevra and Sidney are academics at Oxford who are tasked with investigating the death of a faculty member.
I really enjoyed this book. I found Ginevra and Sidney to be likeable characters and loved the chemistry between them. I look forward to seeing their relationship develop more in future books. While the plot was slow at times, I enjoyed the classic whodunnit vibes. I was glued to the last third of the book and could not put it down. The story was well written and I was able to use the clues they found to solve the case along with the characters. The only thing I did not like (and this is probably more a me thing) was characters sometimes being referred to by first name and sometimes last name or a nickname. It made it difficult for me to keep characters straight until I was 2/3 into the book. Overall, this was a fun read and I look forward to more books in what I believe (based on the ending) is the start of a new series.
Oxford’s Guide to Scandal and Lies is a historical mystery set in 1951 after World War II has ended. Ginevra and Sidney are academics at Oxford who are tasked with investigating the death of a faculty member.
I really enjoyed this book. I found Ginevra and Sidney to be likeable characters and loved the chemistry between them. I look forward to seeing their relationship develop more in future books. While the plot was slow at times, I enjoyed the classic whodunnit vibes. I was glued to the last third of the book and could not put it down. The story was well written and I was able to use the clues they found to solve the case along with the characters. The only thing I did not like (and this is probably more a me thing) was characters sometimes being referred to by first name and sometimes last name or a nickname. It made it difficult for me to keep characters straight until I was 2/3 into the book. Overall, this was a fun read and I look forward to more books in what I believe (based on the ending) is the start of a new series.
March 15, 2026
thank you netgalley for the ARC! this was a cool setting for a mystery. i did not fully understand the ending but the lead up to who all the characters meant to each other was good!
April 8, 2026
Ginevra Bishop is your average 22-year-old Oxford scholar whose detective skills are rarely exercised beyond deducing the location of the last empty table in Bodleian library. Fellow student Sidney Braithwaite is your curmudgeonly grandpa trapped in the body of a 26-year-old.
While begrudgingly sharing a table in said library, Sidney and Ginevra are approached by a member of the British intelligence with an urgent request: uncover the identity of the Soviet spy hiding in the Oxford community.
What follows is your typical grumpy/sunshine slow-burn romance with lots of clever banter and British humor. I did feel, however, that the plot dragged a bit towards the end, and I struggled to follow Ginevra’s logic as she pieced together the last bits of the spy puzzle. Overall, a cute, easy read that I’d recommend to anyone looking for an historical romance with no spice but a whole lot of yearning. For full vibe experience, read while sipping Earl Grey from a fancy teacup.
While begrudgingly sharing a table in said library, Sidney and Ginevra are approached by a member of the British intelligence with an urgent request: uncover the identity of the Soviet spy hiding in the Oxford community.
What follows is your typical grumpy/sunshine slow-burn romance with lots of clever banter and British humor. I did feel, however, that the plot dragged a bit towards the end, and I struggled to follow Ginevra’s logic as she pieced together the last bits of the spy puzzle. Overall, a cute, easy read that I’d recommend to anyone looking for an historical romance with no spice but a whole lot of yearning. For full vibe experience, read while sipping Earl Grey from a fancy teacup.
May 10, 2026
Thank you so much the NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC. I had this book on my list for a while and was absolutely delighted to get a chance to read it earlier. The vibes were absolutely 5 stars. Anything at Oxford is right up my alley. I would say the plot for the first half and last 10% were also 5 stars. It was that middle 40% that had me questioning my rating. I felt like there was so much to keep up with and that there were hints dropped that I somehow missed. This might have been a me thing, but I’m not sure. Anyway, Ginevra and Bishop’s world was so fun to be a part of while I read this book. I hope this author release further books.
April 3, 2026
This was so good! Set in Oxford, 1950, with a cast of characters who lives have been impacted by the war. It's a good old-fashioned mystery, complete with espionage and murder. The main character Gin is delightful and spunky, a quick thinker despite her fairly sheltered life. Sidney comes from another class and has a checkered past. When these two work together, it seems like there's nothing they can't do.
The fact that the ending alluded to a sequel excites me!
Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC copy in exchange for my honest review. This one was a particularly good one.
The fact that the ending alluded to a sequel excites me!
Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC copy in exchange for my honest review. This one was a particularly good one.
Read
April 4, 2026Very cute and fun. I had a lovely time reading it, but I’m wondering if the author went to Oxford and did research beforehand. This is so stupid of me to take issue with but All Souls does not admit undergraduates and the brief mention of a fresher at All Souls really took me out of the story for a moment. Sorry, I’ve finished being insufferable. Can’t wait to see what else the get up to!
March 8, 2026
Pending review
March 27, 2026
The Oxford Guide to Scandal and Lies by Kate Westbury is a charming debut novel for fans of mystery and espionage stories. This isn't a time period I read extensively as far as historical fiction goes, but the characters were appealing and the plot was engaging. There were some pacing issues but overall I enjoyed this read. A big thank you to St. Martin's Press, Minotaur Books, and NetGalley for providing this ARC!
May 2, 2026
Oxford? I'm in!
I love books set in Oxford. Fortunately, this one was a ton of fun to read and I am excited for the next installment!
Set in post-WWII Oxford, Ginevra Bishop is smart, beautiful, and nobody's fool. She's been identified by the Brits as a perfect foil for brooding Sidney Braithwaite as they team up as pair of clandestine operatives. Of course, they don't get along. Of course, there is chemistry. Of course, action unfolds.
This was a really fun book. It lagged a bit in parts, but the last section was nonstop and left me so excited for the next book. I think this series will get better and better! Check it out!
I love books set in Oxford. Fortunately, this one was a ton of fun to read and I am excited for the next installment!
Set in post-WWII Oxford, Ginevra Bishop is smart, beautiful, and nobody's fool. She's been identified by the Brits as a perfect foil for brooding Sidney Braithwaite as they team up as pair of clandestine operatives. Of course, they don't get along. Of course, there is chemistry. Of course, action unfolds.
This was a really fun book. It lagged a bit in parts, but the last section was nonstop and left me so excited for the next book. I think this series will get better and better! Check it out!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to NetGalley, Minotaur Books / St. Martin's Press, & Kate Westbury for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
4.5 stars 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌗
Genres, settings, categories, themes: mystery, historical fiction, spies & espionage, coding/decoding, languages, romance (M/F), Oxford, post-WWII England
💗 Tropes: 💗
> Enemies to Lovers
> Opposites Attract
> Partners in Fighting Crime
> Slow Burn
> Spies (sub-trope of Danger)
all about tropes here
POV: 3rd person, alternating/dual
Series/Sequencing Style: 1st in a dynamic series, case from this book is solved, but there is a minor cliffhanger leading into the next book & the romance has yet to fully develop (no HFN or HEA yet)
understanding series types: dynamic, static, anthology - source 1, source 2
Format: ebook (e-ARC)
🔽🔽🔽
Overall ratings
Heat level: 🍓 0/5 sweet 🍓
(from Ampersand’s guide to heat levels in romance novels – (0) sweet, (1) mild sizzle, (2) sensual steam, (3) spicy seduction, (4) red hot, (5) erotic)
~ Heroine (Gin) ~ 4.5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌗
~ Hero (Sidney) ~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Other characters ~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Plot ~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Pacing ~ 4.5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌗
~ Romance ~ 3/5 🌕🌕🌕🌑🌑 lots of promise, does not come to fruition in this book
~ Mystery~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Writing ~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Reading enjoyability & fun ~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Depth & tone (1 light & fun --> 5 more serious, addresses heavier topics?): 2 (heavier topics, such as war, PTSD, & grief, are all mentioned/handled, but the tone feels fairly cozy in general)
~ Diversity & representation: POC side characters; class differences
~ Angst level: 3/5
~ Sadness level: 2/5
🔽🔽🔽
❗CW/Triggers:❗adultery (historical/off page), classism/snobbery, death of a parent (historical/off page), emotionally absent parent, good ol' boys club, gun(s), mentions of racism (off page), murder, poisoning, PTSD, suicide, treason, wartime espionage (mentioned)
🔽🔽🔽
📝 Review/Notes 📝
Gin & Sidney are opposites; she's a spontaneous, gregarious, extroverted socialite with a viscount father, and he's a methodical, stoic, introverted ex-spy from a coal mining family. I love how they play off each other, and though she can be a little naive, jumping the gun in the beginning, their opposite methodologies and personalities end up working perfectly as partners. She's a feisty feminist with a trio of intelligent, ambitious gal pals, and he's a healing loner, who cares deeply about people and looks out for his one friend. While I was hoping this was a standalone, since I hate having to wait for sequels, I definitely don't mind coming back to this world, and at least the cliffhanger was minor enough that I can come back for a second book without needing to re-read.
The only reason this isn't a full 5-stars for me is because there clearly needs to be a sequel, in which their relationship comes to fruition–and likely they solve another case together & we get an answer to our minor cliffhanger (). I'm leaving room for that growth.
Otherwise, I loved it! It was instantly enthralling, with great characters, plenty of suspects to keep you guessing, and a tightly-woven plot. This one is for the slow burn fans. While there is action and plenty happening with the plot, it is still a bit of a slow burn in the historical setting, and certainly when it comes to the romance and development thereof. The romance is definitely more of a subplot in this book, with the focus on finding the leak/traitor/spy, and laying the ground work for the characters getting to know each other and first working together. While we see some attraction, mostly on his part so far (she's interested, but she's independent), it will be cute to see them really give in to the tension in future books (or at least, I hope).
Looks like I'll be waiting a while for future books, since they haven't been announced yet, and this one is only coming out in September. But I loved reading this and I look forward to the next just as much!
P.S. I have a feeling the author is a chess player, due to the characters named Bishop & Rook, and the whole chess club side quest.
🔽🔽🔽
🤠 Recommended for: fans of spy mysteries on the more light-hearted and fun side (not hard-hitting, gritty espionage thrillers); anyone intrigued by the premise - it delivers
4.5 stars 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌗
Genres, settings, categories, themes: mystery, historical fiction, spies & espionage, coding/decoding, languages, romance (M/F), Oxford, post-WWII England
💗 Tropes: 💗
> Enemies to Lovers
> Opposites Attract
> Partners in Fighting Crime
> Slow Burn
> Spies (sub-trope of Danger)
all about tropes here
POV: 3rd person, alternating/dual
Series/Sequencing Style: 1st in a dynamic series, case from this book is solved, but there is a minor cliffhanger leading into the next book & the romance has yet to fully develop (no HFN or HEA yet)
understanding series types: dynamic, static, anthology - source 1, source 2
Format: ebook (e-ARC)
🔽🔽🔽
Overall ratings
Heat level: 🍓 0/5 sweet 🍓
(from Ampersand’s guide to heat levels in romance novels – (0) sweet, (1) mild sizzle, (2) sensual steam, (3) spicy seduction, (4) red hot, (5) erotic)
~ Heroine (Gin) ~ 4.5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌗
~ Hero (Sidney) ~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Other characters ~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Plot ~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Pacing ~ 4.5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌗
~ Romance ~ 3/5 🌕🌕🌕🌑🌑 lots of promise, does not come to fruition in this book
~ Mystery~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Writing ~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Reading enjoyability & fun ~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Depth & tone (1 light & fun --> 5 more serious, addresses heavier topics?): 2 (heavier topics, such as war, PTSD, & grief, are all mentioned/handled, but the tone feels fairly cozy in general)
~ Diversity & representation: POC side characters; class differences
~ Angst level: 3/5
~ Sadness level: 2/5
🔽🔽🔽
❗CW/Triggers:❗adultery (historical/off page), classism/snobbery, death of a parent (historical/off page), emotionally absent parent, good ol' boys club, gun(s), mentions of racism (off page), murder, poisoning, PTSD, suicide, treason, wartime espionage (mentioned)
🔽🔽🔽
📝 Review/Notes 📝
Gin & Sidney are opposites; she's a spontaneous, gregarious, extroverted socialite with a viscount father, and he's a methodical, stoic, introverted ex-spy from a coal mining family. I love how they play off each other, and though she can be a little naive, jumping the gun in the beginning, their opposite methodologies and personalities end up working perfectly as partners. She's a feisty feminist with a trio of intelligent, ambitious gal pals, and he's a healing loner, who cares deeply about people and looks out for his one friend. While I was hoping this was a standalone, since I hate having to wait for sequels, I definitely don't mind coming back to this world, and at least the cliffhanger was minor enough that I can come back for a second book without needing to re-read.
The only reason this isn't a full 5-stars for me is because there clearly needs to be a sequel, in which their relationship comes to fruition–and likely they solve another case together & we get an answer to our minor cliffhanger (). I'm leaving room for that growth.
Otherwise, I loved it! It was instantly enthralling, with great characters, plenty of suspects to keep you guessing, and a tightly-woven plot. This one is for the slow burn fans. While there is action and plenty happening with the plot, it is still a bit of a slow burn in the historical setting, and certainly when it comes to the romance and development thereof. The romance is definitely more of a subplot in this book, with the focus on finding the leak/traitor/spy, and laying the ground work for the characters getting to know each other and first working together. While we see some attraction, mostly on his part so far (she's interested, but she's independent), it will be cute to see them really give in to the tension in future books (or at least, I hope).
Looks like I'll be waiting a while for future books, since they haven't been announced yet, and this one is only coming out in September. But I loved reading this and I look forward to the next just as much!
P.S. I have a feeling the author is a chess player, due to the characters named Bishop & Rook, and the whole chess club side quest.
🔽🔽🔽
🤠 Recommended for: fans of spy mysteries on the more light-hearted and fun side (not hard-hitting, gritty espionage thrillers); anyone intrigued by the premise - it delivers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thank you St Martin's Press and Kate Westbury for the ARC.
Post war Oxford. A possible Soviet spy. And two students who were never meant to work together.
📚 The Oxford Guide to Scandal and Lies by Kate Westbury
Genre: Historical mystery with romantic tension
Vibes: post WWII academia, MI5 intrigue, opposites attract, secret investigations, British espionage
Oxford, 1951.
Ginevra Bishop arrives with sharp wit, red lipstick, and a determination to prove she is more than a society girl following her mother’s footsteps.
Sidney Braithwaite arrives carrying war scars, a working class past, and a fierce desire to build a life far from the mining village he came from.
Then MI5 recruits them both to find a Soviet spy hiding within the university.
What makes this debut so compelling:
🎓 A richly atmospheric Oxford setting in post war Britain
🕵️♂️ Secret investigation woven into academic life
⚖️ Class differences shaping every interaction
🔥 Slow building chemistry between two unlikely partners
🧩 Plenty of suspects, misdirection, and clever red herrings
Gin and Sidney could not be more different on paper. She is sharp tongued, socially polished, and used to privilege. He is guarded, serious, and shaped by the realities of war and class struggle. Watching their reluctant partnership turn into mutual respect and something quietly romantic is one of the most satisfying parts of the story.
The mystery itself is engaging and layered. Every clue raises new questions about who can be trusted inside Oxford’s historic halls.
The surrounding cast adds even more intrigue. Their friend groups feel alive with potential for future stories, and the mysterious figure known as the Rook introduces questions that linger long after the final page.
I flew through this because I needed to know who the spy was.
If you love historical mysteries with academic settings, clever characters, and espionage tension simmering under the surface, this is a debut to watch.
💬 Do you prefer historical mysteries that lean more toward espionage or classic whodunit investigation?
#KateWestbury #TheOxfordGuideToScandalAndLies #HistoricalMystery #OxfordFiction #Bookstagram
Post war Oxford. A possible Soviet spy. And two students who were never meant to work together.
📚 The Oxford Guide to Scandal and Lies by Kate Westbury
Genre: Historical mystery with romantic tension
Vibes: post WWII academia, MI5 intrigue, opposites attract, secret investigations, British espionage
Oxford, 1951.
Ginevra Bishop arrives with sharp wit, red lipstick, and a determination to prove she is more than a society girl following her mother’s footsteps.
Sidney Braithwaite arrives carrying war scars, a working class past, and a fierce desire to build a life far from the mining village he came from.
Then MI5 recruits them both to find a Soviet spy hiding within the university.
What makes this debut so compelling:
🎓 A richly atmospheric Oxford setting in post war Britain
🕵️♂️ Secret investigation woven into academic life
⚖️ Class differences shaping every interaction
🔥 Slow building chemistry between two unlikely partners
🧩 Plenty of suspects, misdirection, and clever red herrings
Gin and Sidney could not be more different on paper. She is sharp tongued, socially polished, and used to privilege. He is guarded, serious, and shaped by the realities of war and class struggle. Watching their reluctant partnership turn into mutual respect and something quietly romantic is one of the most satisfying parts of the story.
The mystery itself is engaging and layered. Every clue raises new questions about who can be trusted inside Oxford’s historic halls.
The surrounding cast adds even more intrigue. Their friend groups feel alive with potential for future stories, and the mysterious figure known as the Rook introduces questions that linger long after the final page.
I flew through this because I needed to know who the spy was.
If you love historical mysteries with academic settings, clever characters, and espionage tension simmering under the surface, this is a debut to watch.
💬 Do you prefer historical mysteries that lean more toward espionage or classic whodunit investigation?
#KateWestbury #TheOxfordGuideToScandalAndLies #HistoricalMystery #OxfordFiction #Bookstagram
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to NetGalley and to St. Martin's Press for the ARC of The Oxford Guide to Scandal and Lies by Kate Westbury.
This is such a fun debut! Westbury is a strong, new voice in the historical cozy mystery genre.
I've been looking for something to fill the void of Ashley Weaver's Electra McDonnell series and waiting for the new release from Julia Kelly's Evelyne Redfern's series and this was the perfect addition.
I love that it takes place in the early 1950s, so we still see the lasting repercussions of WWII but also the growing shadow of the Soviet Union and the building of the cold war. and rise of espionage It was cool to see this from the British perspective, and it was a newer angle of historical mystery for me filled with really interesting socioeconomic, gender, and other layers in addition to the growing political intrigue. It did take me a few tries at certain points to understand all the Oxford nuances (watching Young Sherlock and learning what a Scout was was surprising helpful) and I do wish there was sort of a few lowly American explainers for the Oxford College system, the finishing school system of the 1950s, etc. to better place myself in that time and place.
Gin and Sidney are both well-developed and interesting characters, with built out backstories that really place them in different ways in British society and culture. Their standoffishness with each other over miscommunications and misunderstandings gave a lot of depth to the time period and to the social structure they both grew up in, and it allowed for the development of their friendship to feel more realistic, especially given each of their own personal hang-ups and internal conflicts.
The mystery itself was thought out with lots of potential avenues for criminality and misbehavior. Westbury did a great job of making nearly all characters multilayered, so while I had a general guess at who the murderer was, my reasoning to get there was not at all correct. You could tell a lot of research and a lot of moving pieces were at play to bring everything around and together, and I appreciate all those efforts into creating a truly entertaining story.
I loved the final chapter and am really excited to see what comes next.
This is such a fun debut! Westbury is a strong, new voice in the historical cozy mystery genre.
I've been looking for something to fill the void of Ashley Weaver's Electra McDonnell series and waiting for the new release from Julia Kelly's Evelyne Redfern's series and this was the perfect addition.
I love that it takes place in the early 1950s, so we still see the lasting repercussions of WWII but also the growing shadow of the Soviet Union and the building of the cold war. and rise of espionage It was cool to see this from the British perspective, and it was a newer angle of historical mystery for me filled with really interesting socioeconomic, gender, and other layers in addition to the growing political intrigue. It did take me a few tries at certain points to understand all the Oxford nuances (watching Young Sherlock and learning what a Scout was was surprising helpful) and I do wish there was sort of a few lowly American explainers for the Oxford College system, the finishing school system of the 1950s, etc. to better place myself in that time and place.
Gin and Sidney are both well-developed and interesting characters, with built out backstories that really place them in different ways in British society and culture. Their standoffishness with each other over miscommunications and misunderstandings gave a lot of depth to the time period and to the social structure they both grew up in, and it allowed for the development of their friendship to feel more realistic, especially given each of their own personal hang-ups and internal conflicts.
The mystery itself was thought out with lots of potential avenues for criminality and misbehavior. Westbury did a great job of making nearly all characters multilayered, so while I had a general guess at who the murderer was, my reasoning to get there was not at all correct. You could tell a lot of research and a lot of moving pieces were at play to bring everything around and together, and I appreciate all those efforts into creating a truly entertaining story.
I loved the final chapter and am really excited to see what comes next.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thank you to NetGalley and Kate Westbury for the ARC of The Oxford Guide to Scandal & Lies.
I really loved this one.
Set in 1950s Oxford, this blends mystery, academia, and espionage in a way that completely pulled me in. The setting alone had me—especially anything involving the Bodleian Library (and I loved Tolliver).
Gin is such an interesting main character. She is clever and determined, but also a little impulsive in the way she throws herself into things. There is this strong sense that she is trying to prove herself—not only as a woman in the 1950s, but as someone expected to follow a very specific path. As a viscount’s daughter, her independence feels harder-won than you might expect, which I thought was really well done. I also loved how her knowledge of languages actually mattered to solving the mystery.
Sidney is a great contrast. He is older, more guarded, and clearly shaped by the war. His backstory adds real weight, especially as he navigates Oxford coming from a completely different class background.
And together… they are both so prickly. Truly. At times I wanted to knock them together and say, please figure this out already.
The mystery kept me engaged the whole way through. I loved the inclusion of the Oxford societies and the chess references—it gave everything a slightly strategic, layered feel. I was able to piece together parts of it, but not all, which is always my favorite place to be in a mystery.
There are also quieter ideas underneath about identity, expectation, and how people carry heartbreak into the choices they make. Those moments stayed with me.
By the end, I was completely invested. Gin carving out a future for herself (and escaping her truly terrible father) and Sidney finding some peace both felt earned.
This is very much my kind of mystery - smart, character-driven, and just a little bit sharp around the edges.
I really hope this turns into a series. I would absolutely keep reading.
I really loved this one.
Set in 1950s Oxford, this blends mystery, academia, and espionage in a way that completely pulled me in. The setting alone had me—especially anything involving the Bodleian Library (and I loved Tolliver).
Gin is such an interesting main character. She is clever and determined, but also a little impulsive in the way she throws herself into things. There is this strong sense that she is trying to prove herself—not only as a woman in the 1950s, but as someone expected to follow a very specific path. As a viscount’s daughter, her independence feels harder-won than you might expect, which I thought was really well done. I also loved how her knowledge of languages actually mattered to solving the mystery.
Sidney is a great contrast. He is older, more guarded, and clearly shaped by the war. His backstory adds real weight, especially as he navigates Oxford coming from a completely different class background.
And together… they are both so prickly. Truly. At times I wanted to knock them together and say, please figure this out already.
The mystery kept me engaged the whole way through. I loved the inclusion of the Oxford societies and the chess references—it gave everything a slightly strategic, layered feel. I was able to piece together parts of it, but not all, which is always my favorite place to be in a mystery.
There are also quieter ideas underneath about identity, expectation, and how people carry heartbreak into the choices they make. Those moments stayed with me.
By the end, I was completely invested. Gin carving out a future for herself (and escaping her truly terrible father) and Sidney finding some peace both felt earned.
This is very much my kind of mystery - smart, character-driven, and just a little bit sharp around the edges.
I really hope this turns into a series. I would absolutely keep reading.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Book Review: The Oxford Guide to Scandal and Lies by Kate Westbury
This book is what happens when you take a spy thriller and politely remind it that it’s set at Oxford, so it should really keep things civilized. The premise is genuinely fun: two students, one a socially strategic debutante and the other a brooding war veteran, are recruited by MI5 to uncover a Soviet spy hiding among academics. It sounds like chaos. It is, technically. It’s just very well-mannered chaos, delivered through tense conversations, careful observation, and an impressive amount of reading between the lines.
Gin easily carries the book. She’s sharp, perceptive, and fully aware that people underestimate her, which she uses with almost alarming efficiency. Sidney balances her out as the emotionally repressed, quietly competent counterpart who seems like he’d rather be anywhere else. Their dynamic does most of the heavy lifting, shifting from mutual skepticism to something more trusting, with a slow undercurrent of romantic tension that never quite takes over the plot but definitely lingers in the background.
The mystery itself is solid, though not exactly earth-shattering. The clues are there, the structure works, and the reveal makes sense in a way that feels earned rather than shocking. The pacing, however, leans a bit slow, especially in the middle, and the stakes can feel oddly academic for a story about espionage. You’re not exactly on the edge of your seat, but you are paying attention in that “this will matter later” kind of way.
Overall, it’s a charming, understated take on a spy story that’s more interested in atmosphere and character than big twists or action. It knows exactly what kind of book it is and sticks to it. Not something that will completely blow you away, but definitely enjoyable if you’re in the mood for something clever, a little restrained, and quietly dramatic.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC. This is my honest and voluntary review.
This book is what happens when you take a spy thriller and politely remind it that it’s set at Oxford, so it should really keep things civilized. The premise is genuinely fun: two students, one a socially strategic debutante and the other a brooding war veteran, are recruited by MI5 to uncover a Soviet spy hiding among academics. It sounds like chaos. It is, technically. It’s just very well-mannered chaos, delivered through tense conversations, careful observation, and an impressive amount of reading between the lines.
Gin easily carries the book. She’s sharp, perceptive, and fully aware that people underestimate her, which she uses with almost alarming efficiency. Sidney balances her out as the emotionally repressed, quietly competent counterpart who seems like he’d rather be anywhere else. Their dynamic does most of the heavy lifting, shifting from mutual skepticism to something more trusting, with a slow undercurrent of romantic tension that never quite takes over the plot but definitely lingers in the background.
The mystery itself is solid, though not exactly earth-shattering. The clues are there, the structure works, and the reveal makes sense in a way that feels earned rather than shocking. The pacing, however, leans a bit slow, especially in the middle, and the stakes can feel oddly academic for a story about espionage. You’re not exactly on the edge of your seat, but you are paying attention in that “this will matter later” kind of way.
Overall, it’s a charming, understated take on a spy story that’s more interested in atmosphere and character than big twists or action. It knows exactly what kind of book it is and sticks to it. Not something that will completely blow you away, but definitely enjoyable if you’re in the mood for something clever, a little restrained, and quietly dramatic.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC. This is my honest and voluntary review.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Meet Ginverva and Sidney, Gin and Sid, opposites that come together, reluctantly, to solve a crime at Oxford University in the 1950s. That one sentence sums up the story, but it doesn’t take you on the journey that keeps you reading long into the night when you know you have work the next morning.
Gin and Sid’s meet-cute had a little of the enemies-to-lovers vibe, but only a little. I was left wondering if there had been puppet strings at work. Anyway, they are opposites and complement each other well, as we soon find out. Enter Rook. I love the play on chess and the mystique that is written around this character. Gin wants to jump at the opportunity to save her family home without marrying. Sid wants to run from the opportunity and continue to bury his past. Call it chivalry, sense of duty, or his inability not to help, but he ends up allowing Gin to talk him into agreeing to Rook’s request. This is helped along with the death of beloved librarian, Mr. Tolliver. From here, the adventures begin.
The somewhat diverse group of characters is filled with strong-willed female characters. Gin’s friends, Iris, Sarita, and Annette. Throw into the mix troublemaker Marion, and the men have their hands full keeping up with these women.
Not only did this multilayered mystery intrigue, but several subplots kept me guessing and wanting more. Not to give too much away, but Gin had a unique upbringing with her mother. Sid comments on Gin’s mom being a bit of an odd duck. There were gasp-worthy moments that, in my mind, have the potential for additional stories. I hope that I just missed the “book 1” designation and that this is not a one-and-done. If it were, I’d be majorly sore about it.
I want to read more about the adventures of Gin and Sid!
Thank you, #StMartinsPress and #NetGalley for the opportunity for an early read and to share my thoughts.
Happy Reading!
Gin and Sid’s meet-cute had a little of the enemies-to-lovers vibe, but only a little. I was left wondering if there had been puppet strings at work. Anyway, they are opposites and complement each other well, as we soon find out. Enter Rook. I love the play on chess and the mystique that is written around this character. Gin wants to jump at the opportunity to save her family home without marrying. Sid wants to run from the opportunity and continue to bury his past. Call it chivalry, sense of duty, or his inability not to help, but he ends up allowing Gin to talk him into agreeing to Rook’s request. This is helped along with the death of beloved librarian, Mr. Tolliver. From here, the adventures begin.
The somewhat diverse group of characters is filled with strong-willed female characters. Gin’s friends, Iris, Sarita, and Annette. Throw into the mix troublemaker Marion, and the men have their hands full keeping up with these women.
Not only did this multilayered mystery intrigue, but several subplots kept me guessing and wanting more. Not to give too much away, but Gin had a unique upbringing with her mother. Sid comments on Gin’s mom being a bit of an odd duck. There were gasp-worthy moments that, in my mind, have the potential for additional stories. I hope that I just missed the “book 1” designation and that this is not a one-and-done. If it were, I’d be majorly sore about it.
I want to read more about the adventures of Gin and Sid!
Thank you, #StMartinsPress and #NetGalley for the opportunity for an early read and to share my thoughts.
Happy Reading!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Oxford University in the early 1950’s. Great Britain, just 5 years beyond a devastating war, still on food rationing and the changing geo-political world order. Ginevra Bishop, daughter of an impoverished Viscount, 1st year Oxford student, former debutante and an extroverted, smart young woman who wants nothing to do with the antiquated aristocratic class system. Sidney Braithwaite, upperclassman at Oxford, former WWII soldier and Special Services field agent (aka spy), son of and former miner and an introverted, haunted (aka PTSD) serious man. I’m paper, these two have nothing in common other than they’re British and Oxford students. Nevertheless, Sidney’s wartime operative commander now works for the British equivalent of the CIA and thinks they would make a splendid team to catch the traitor passing top secret info to the Soviets…..they don’t agree with this assessment. Sidney wants nothing to do with spying because it brings up all his war torments plus he thinks Gin is too frivolous and impetuous to be safe and successful doing clandestine work. Gin knows that Sidney thinks she’s a flighty deb and she really doesn’t appreciate his condescending dismissal of her abilities. But, as they follow clues, investigate suspects and uncover old betrayals, the spark between them grows and they begin to acknowledge to themselves and each other that their personalities and unique skills compliment rather than hinder their pursuit of the traitor. I really enjoyed the story and setting but, be forewarned, while the central mystery is solved, the book ends on a cliffhanger for the characters, I really hope Kate signed a deal for at least 2 published books…. Thanks to #netgalley for the ARC of this book .
Review of advance copy received from Goodreads Giveaways
This delightful British mystery was sitting in my mailbox for me yesterday. I read a quarter of it last night and then sat down today and finished the rest. I am delighted to have gotten this ARC and am happy to review it.
If you enjoy British mystery shows or historical fiction, then you will enjoy The Oxford Guide to Scandal and Lies. Two Oxford students are approached by the secret service after one of their secret agents winds up dead. There are very good reasons these two were chosen for the task, and while one is unwilling and reluctant, the other wants to plough full steam ahead. They both come from different worlds and do not care for one another upon first meeting. But after spending more time together to solve this mystery and the clues left behind from the agent they begin to see each other in a different light. This is rather slow paced to start and it does feel like the author spends a lot of time on each portion of their sleuthing, including simple surveillance, which can get a little boring at times, thus the 4 star rating and not 5. However, if you can stick it out you will find there are several little mysteries in this book to solve. I was able to solve two of them early on, but I was quite wrong about the last one. I definitely look forward to more in this series and will be keeping an eye out hoping that Gin and Sydney continue their partnership as well as to find out more about "The Rook."
If you enjoy British mystery shows or historical fiction, then you will enjoy The Oxford Guide to Scandal and Lies. Two Oxford students are approached by the secret service after one of their secret agents winds up dead. There are very good reasons these two were chosen for the task, and while one is unwilling and reluctant, the other wants to plough full steam ahead. They both come from different worlds and do not care for one another upon first meeting. But after spending more time together to solve this mystery and the clues left behind from the agent they begin to see each other in a different light. This is rather slow paced to start and it does feel like the author spends a lot of time on each portion of their sleuthing, including simple surveillance, which can get a little boring at times, thus the 4 star rating and not 5. However, if you can stick it out you will find there are several little mysteries in this book to solve. I was able to solve two of them early on, but I was quite wrong about the last one. I definitely look forward to more in this series and will be keeping an eye out hoping that Gin and Sydney continue their partnership as well as to find out more about "The Rook."
April 16, 2026
The kind of book I could read over and over again, The Oxford Guide to Scandal and Lies blends the best aspects of mystery and academia into a perfect whirlwind which kept me on my toes from the very first page.
As an avid mystery and historical fiction reader, the combination of the two genres is something I hold near and dear to my heart. To find a story which so expertly entwines them is a real and rare treat.
Even to the final moments, I had no idea where things were going to go (in the absolute best way)! I was constantly trying to cull my memory for details I may have missed, trying to keep pace with our clever agents.
Who, speaking of, were both incredibly engaging main characters. Even with Oxford as their main backdrop (which I adored), we still got to see who they were outside of its hallowed halls. Whether it be the forefront of the war or the foyer of their childhood homes, they never felt confined to the originating setting.
I don’t even know how to express the joy I experienced reading this without giving anything away, and so I really must insist that you read it for yourself.
Perfect for fans of Enola Holmes and A Study in Charlotte, this is a fun and suspenseful mystery that is sure to have you second guessing yourself to the absolute end.
(AND THAT CLIFFHANGER? HELLO?!!!)
Thank you so much to NetGalley and St. Martins Press for the ARC in exchange for an honest review! :)
As an avid mystery and historical fiction reader, the combination of the two genres is something I hold near and dear to my heart. To find a story which so expertly entwines them is a real and rare treat.
Even to the final moments, I had no idea where things were going to go (in the absolute best way)! I was constantly trying to cull my memory for details I may have missed, trying to keep pace with our clever agents.
Who, speaking of, were both incredibly engaging main characters. Even with Oxford as their main backdrop (which I adored), we still got to see who they were outside of its hallowed halls. Whether it be the forefront of the war or the foyer of their childhood homes, they never felt confined to the originating setting.
I don’t even know how to express the joy I experienced reading this without giving anything away, and so I really must insist that you read it for yourself.
Perfect for fans of Enola Holmes and A Study in Charlotte, this is a fun and suspenseful mystery that is sure to have you second guessing yourself to the absolute end.
(AND THAT CLIFFHANGER? HELLO?!!!)
Thank you so much to NetGalley and St. Martins Press for the ARC in exchange for an honest review! :)
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This book reminds me of the Electra McDonnell series by Ashley Weaver, which I have been on the hunt for its replacement since the series ended, and I am more than certain I have found it!! The Oxford Guide exceeded my expectations with fantastic writing, a well-captured essence of post-war Oxford, and delightful chemistry between the two main characters. This is probably one of the most excellent mysteries that will be released this year!
Westbury mentions being inspired by Agatha Christie from a young age, and it shows in this book. A captivating job of weaving and plotting, leaving just the right delectable bread crumbs for readers to follow and become hooked. My one critique would be the revelation of the main whodunnit/spy - it was a character, in my opinion, who had too much distance with Gin & Sidney for the reveal to actually be "shocking". Readers were given bare minimum details about the character, not enough intrigue was created around them that when the reveal came, there wasn't the high level of surprise that usually comes with mysteries of this caliber.
However, I seriously cannot wait for the next installment of The Oxford Guide because it seems the horizon is wide, just waiting to be discovered by Gin & Sidney. Thank you Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for the advanced digital ARC!
Westbury mentions being inspired by Agatha Christie from a young age, and it shows in this book. A captivating job of weaving and plotting, leaving just the right delectable bread crumbs for readers to follow and become hooked. My one critique would be the revelation of the main whodunnit/spy - it was a character, in my opinion, who had too much distance with Gin & Sidney for the reveal to actually be "shocking". Readers were given bare minimum details about the character, not enough intrigue was created around them that when the reveal came, there wasn't the high level of surprise that usually comes with mysteries of this caliber.
However, I seriously cannot wait for the next installment of The Oxford Guide because it seems the horizon is wide, just waiting to be discovered by Gin & Sidney. Thank you Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for the advanced digital ARC!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
A sharp, engaging historical mystery that balances intrigue, wit, and just the right amount of drama. The Oxford Guide to Scandal and Lies draws you in quickly with its academic setting and layered sense of secrecy, where reputations are fragile and nothing is quite as it seems. The atmosphere feels rich and immersive, and the Oxford backdrop adds a wonderful sense of tradition mixed with quiet tension.
The characters are well-drawn, especially the protagonist, whose intelligence and determination make her easy to root for. I enjoyed how the story slowly unfolded, revealing connections and hidden motives in a way that kept me guessing without feeling overly complicated or confusing. There’s a nice rhythm to the pacing, with enough twists and revelations to keep things moving while still allowing space for character development.
The writing strikes a good balance between clever and accessible, and the tone fits the academic mystery setting well. At times, I wished a few threads had been explored just a bit more deeply, but overall the story felt satisfying and well put together.
A solid and enjoyable read for fans of historical mysteries with a strong sense of place and a focus on secrets, reputation, and unraveling the truth.
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
The characters are well-drawn, especially the protagonist, whose intelligence and determination make her easy to root for. I enjoyed how the story slowly unfolded, revealing connections and hidden motives in a way that kept me guessing without feeling overly complicated or confusing. There’s a nice rhythm to the pacing, with enough twists and revelations to keep things moving while still allowing space for character development.
The writing strikes a good balance between clever and accessible, and the tone fits the academic mystery setting well. At times, I wished a few threads had been explored just a bit more deeply, but overall the story felt satisfying and well put together.
A solid and enjoyable read for fans of historical mysteries with a strong sense of place and a focus on secrets, reputation, and unraveling the truth.
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This book was a great blend of mystery, historical fiction and suspense. Ginerva was clever, sharp, and determined to figure out who is responsible for Tolliver’s m!rder and unlock clues by whatever means necessary. Sidney was quiet, reserved, and experienced due to his training during World War II to keep eyes on potential suspects while struggling with trauma related to participating in said war also. The main characters were often snarky to each other, especially in the beginning, but it was great to watch them build trust with each other as the investigation went on. I also appreciated the author talking about topics such as grief, classism, old money vs new, and the pursuit of truth and justice handled with honesty and a sort of vulnerability that many in our world are reluctant to talk about even now. There were many well-written plot twists and the ending resolved the mystery with a little revelation to tease perhaps another story in the future. Overall, if you like post World War II historical fiction, disguises, secrets, complex characters, and a clever whodunnit with Oxford students/informants butting heads with hints of very slow burn romantic elements, then I highly recommend this book. I got a NetGalley copy and these opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This spy/detective novel based in 1950 England was a wee bit slow to get off the ground. The first chapters have a little too much infodumping… for instance, an explanation of former spy Sidney’s WWII-related trauma that would be better left to the reader to fill in as the story progresses. It also does contain some slightly predictable tropes like a character quickly learning to pick locks and a rather drawn out cipher cracking scenes. There’s a set of suspects all too conveniently discovered in a notebook. Nevertheless once the plot builds up some steam it’s a fully enjoyable, rompy thriller with two very likeable and fun leads. The conflict between stubborn society debutante Gin, and brooding working class Sidney, is believable and sparky. The pacing is just quick enough and the writing zingy enough to keep me reading. So I would recommend this if you like mystery/thrillers in the tradition of Christie’s Tommy and Tuppence. I will be looking for more from this author. Many thanks to St Martin’s Press/Minotaur Books and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review this delightful novel.
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
As soon as I finished this book, I looked at my husband and said, “This better be a series!” I wanted more of these wonderful characters.
Sidney and Ginevra are from two different worlds yet share common struggles with family, past trauma, and how to find their place in 1950s Post War Britain as its rigid class system was unraveling. These two characters get recruited to uncover if there is a Soviet spy at Oxford where they both are studying.
Westbury includes an interesting friend group, both his and hers, rife with potential future stories. And of course the enigmatic character of the Rook, who generates unanswered questions about what he knows about both Gin and Sidney from the past. There is a friendship that develops between the MCs and romantic sparks. I hope the author allows them to progress romantically since they are wonderful together.
Characters I became invested in, lots of suspects, and red herrings…could not put this book down.
Thank you Edelweiss+ and Minotaur Books for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Sidney and Ginevra are from two different worlds yet share common struggles with family, past trauma, and how to find their place in 1950s Post War Britain as its rigid class system was unraveling. These two characters get recruited to uncover if there is a Soviet spy at Oxford where they both are studying.
Westbury includes an interesting friend group, both his and hers, rife with potential future stories. And of course the enigmatic character of the Rook, who generates unanswered questions about what he knows about both Gin and Sidney from the past. There is a friendship that develops between the MCs and romantic sparks. I hope the author allows them to progress romantically since they are wonderful together.
Characters I became invested in, lots of suspects, and red herrings…could not put this book down.
Thank you Edelweiss+ and Minotaur Books for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thank you to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press | Minotaur Books for the ARC.
Set in post-WWII Oxford, The Oxford Guide to Scandal and Lies follows undergraduate students Ginevra Bishop and Sidney Braithwaite. Sidney is a veteran who wants to leave his intelligence work during the war behind. Ginevra is the daughter of a viscount who desperately wants to achieve independence from her father. After ending up in the wrong place at the wrong time the pair agrees to work together to help solve a chilling murder - one reluctantly, one eagerly.
I really enjoyed Kate Westburys first book. The mystery kept me guessing and was ultimately satisfying, I loved the setting, and Gin and Sidney were really likeable main characters with great chemistry. They both had depth to them and I enjoyed their dynamic and how it evolved throughout the novel. I would eagerly spend more time with Gin and Sidney (and their charming friends) if this series is continued!
Thank you to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press | Minotaur Books for the ARC.
Set in post-WWII Oxford, The Oxford Guide to Scandal and Lies follows undergraduate students Ginevra Bishop and Sidney Braithwaite. Sidney is a veteran who wants to leave his intelligence work during the war behind. Ginevra is the daughter of a viscount who desperately wants to achieve independence from her father. After ending up in the wrong place at the wrong time the pair agrees to work together to help solve a chilling murder - one reluctantly, one eagerly.
I really enjoyed Kate Westburys first book. The mystery kept me guessing and was ultimately satisfying, I loved the setting, and Gin and Sidney were really likeable main characters with great chemistry. They both had depth to them and I enjoyed their dynamic and how it evolved throughout the novel. I would eagerly spend more time with Gin and Sidney (and their charming friends) if this series is continued!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 111 reviews