⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ 💫
Critical Score: B+
Reader Score: B
Reading Experience: 📚 📚
In the wide range of Cooper’s voices, I’d classify this set of stories as literary melancholia. Drab, well done, vague, artsy. Not much fun, but accomplished.
My ranking:
“A Herd” A- / B+. A gradual but moving meditation on hazy loss and violent lust.
“Dear Secret Diary” A- / B+. Wonderfully scattered and engaging. I wish this were much longer than a few pages, and in fact it’s really incomplete at this length.
“Dinner” A- / B+. Really hot but also quietly depressing. Subtle and understated, which I’ve warmed up to.
“Wrong” A- / B+. Melancholy and smartly modern. A worthy title piece.
“Container” B+ / B+. This gripping flash piece pulls an evocative metaphor out of its meta finish, even if it doesn’t have much more to it than that.
“Square One” A- / B-. The braininess is admirable and inventive, if a bit of a mental gymnastic.
“He Cried” B / B. Mysterious but sparse. Evidence that Cooper’s gay serial killer content never tires, but packs a weaker punch in this shorter story.
“Epilogue” B+ / B-. Feels incomplete, but on to something. The meta element is a little nauseating for me.
“Introducing Horror Hospital” B / B-. Effectively grungy and sad, but also pretty sluggish.
“Safe” B / D+. Super long and I can barely tell you what it’s about. But I’m pretty sure it was beautifully written. Struggled to get through it, found myself lost most of the time.