From bestselling author Stephen Kinzer, the untold story of the secret 75-year American campaign that set the stage for war in Ukraine
Until the Russian invasion in 2022, few Americans could find Ukraine on a map. Once the fighting began, however, support for its cause surged. The reason was clear: Russia was the aggressor, Ukraine its victim.
Yet this war did not explode out of nowhere. For seventy-five years, Moscow and Washington have fought over Ukraine. It is the most sustained covert conflict in modern history. Both sides sought to keep this story secret. They succeeded―until now.
In his groundbreaking new book, Stephen Kinzer tells this long-hidden story. Beginning in the refugee camps of postwar Europe, where CIA officers recruited their first Ukrainian agents, it follows generations of rebels, exiles, traitors, and covert operatives through decades of clandestine missions. Although nearly all of the guerrilla warriors that the CIA sent into Ukraine were captured or killed, it never gave up. From the late 1940s through the end of the Cold War, American leaders saw Ukrainians as their most effective weapon against Moscow. They continued to press that strategy after Ukraine’s independence and the eastward expansion of the US-dominated NATO alliance.
Richly detailed and plot-driven, Boiling Point shows how the United States made Ukraine its most important European project of the twenty-first century, culminating in the escalation that led to war. From battlefields in the Carpathians to smoke-filled offices in New York to the Olympic Games, it is full of the wild stories and improbable characters that made All the Shah’s Men a classic. This is the last great untold spy-versus-spy story of our time.
Stephen Kinzer is an award-winning foreign correspondent who has covered more than 50 countries on five continents. His articles and books have led the Washington Post to place him "among the best in popular foreign policy storytelling." (source)
Stephen Kinzer’s detailed history of America’s intervention in the Ukraine is engrossing and enraging.
At the end of WWII, the CIA began undercover operations to sway the Ukraine away from Soviet Russia. They recruited operatives from within the Ukraine, many of whom were dedicated Nazis. They failed to plant these operatives, who were intercepted and never heard of again.
Presidents changed, but advisors with a personal interest in intervention in the Ukraine swayed them to what became accepted policy, including increasing NATO membership when it could have been disbanded at the end of the Cold War.
Kinzer contends that American presidents over the last half century share responsibility for the war in the Ukraine, American policy forcing Putin to protect Russia.
Kinzer states that “the United States has intervened in more countries farther from its own shores than any other nation,” and that the interventions are “the core to American foreign policy.”
Regardless of one’s agreement of Kinzer’s core belief, the book is well researched, engaging, and will make you think deeper on America’s actions.
Thank you Henry Holt and Company for sending me a free copy!
When Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022 it stunned many people. Let’s face it, the average American wasn’t paying much attention to Ukraine before that point. I jumped at the chance to read BOILING POINT as it covers America’s involvement in the country from right after World War Two to the present. It’s fair to say the U.S. has stirred the pot, fanned the flames, whatever you want to call it and can take partial blame for the current war.
I went to town tabbing my copy as I learned a lot and found it to be an insightful read. The CIA was founded in 1947 and soon after began covert action in Ukraine. Russia was viewed as an enemy and Ukraine was used as a pawn. Nazi war criminals aided the U.S. during the Cold War, many of them paid by the government and given false identities and visas. The book covers the different presidents over the decades as well as the founding of NATO and the political games over membership. It gave me a much clearer picture as to what led to this war. While it might be shocking for some, for others it’s another example of US meddling in foreign affairs.
I started reading Boiling Point: How America Brought War to Ukraine by Stephen Kinzer, narrated by Gordon Rothman, and was immediately struck by how much misleading information appeared in just the first few pages.
I continued reading, hoping things would improve, but by the first quarter of the book, I simply couldn't go on.
The author's research appears extremely one-sided, presenting a selective version of events that is nowhere near a complete or accurate account of the realities and historical facts surrounding Ukraine. Even basic historical facts seem to be misrepresented or overlooked in favor of pushing a particular narrative.
This is not what serious historical research should look like. Writing about such a devastating war requires responsibility, balance, and respect for historical truth, not selective research and misleading interpretations.
Shame on the author for producing and profiting from a book that, in my view, does a disservice to readers and to the people affected by this war.
Absolutely awful. A deeply disappointing read that I couldn't bring myself to finish.
In this history of U.S. foreign policy towards Ukraine, Stephen Kinzer convincingly states the case that decades of aggressive promotion of Ukrainian nationalism significantly influenced the course of Ukrainian politics at key intervals and made the ongoing conflict with Russia more or less inevitable. Despite covering decades of history, often in close detail, Kinzer keeps the text highly readable and understandable for readers who may have little background understanding of the subject matter.
The Cold War era promotion of anti-Soviet militants and, more significantly, pro-nationalist messaging in Ukraine is a story that is probably known by few Americans. The exact impact of these efforts is hard to measure, but Kinzer’s concurrent tracing of the pivotal influence over American policy towards Ukraine held by a relatively small number of U.S. officials with familial history in the region is direct, largely based on their own statements, and disturbing.
None of the U.S. presidents come off particularly well in the narrative, but Clinton and Biden figure particularly negatively. Clinton’s gleeful promotion of Boris Yeltsin’s shambolic oversight of the looting of Russia over the way for Putin. Biden’s insistence on avoiding potential off-ramps for escalation looks deeply wrong-headed in hindsight.
Kinzer takes pains to make it clear that the book is not an apologia for Russia or an endorsement of the invasion. Rather, it is an explanation of how years of American influence clearly had an impact. As with any conflict, the starting point that one chooses determines much of which parties will be seen as at fault. At the very least, Kinzer makes a strong argument that when looking at the causes of the Ukraine war, we should not start in 2022, or 2014, or even 1996, but in the period after the end of World War II. Considering how much money the U.S. has spent on Ukraine, more Americans should have at least a passing familiarity with the history.
Thanks to Henry Holt/Macmillan for providing an ARC for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
Kinzer does a great job documenting the history of NATO/US involvement in Ukraine following world war 2 ending with the 2022 war. My main issues with this book are the same as with any book by Kinzer. His latent anti-communist attitudes create a gap in explanatory power that weakens the work.
Much of his narrative of early years sounds to be intentionally neutral about the events as he discussed the Gehlen organization and the mass recruitment of Nasi officers into the Western defense apparatus. The scale of evil committed by the west following world war 2 is unconscionable. War criminals of the most grotesque type were directly imported into the national security state of the US, West Germany and NATO itself. These individuals were the ones providing the "intelligence" as it relates to Soviet intentions and means of combating these intentions. This behavior is covered in the book but Kinzer discusses it in a matter of fact way that does not include the scope of horror, the mockery of "liberal" values that America allegedly stands for, or any other notion of gross illegality that it is.
Additionally the inherent anti-communist tendencies also drive Kinzer to not provide any real Soviet sources. Sources exist to prove that western expansionist goals were not present in the Soviet Union as the war ended and a peace was forming. Stalin wanted a peaceful coexistence with the West as they rebuilt after a genocidal onslaught. There was no intention of invading toward West Germany etc. Instead Kinzer discusses that the US had these security concerns, mainly skips over that they were imported by Nazis, and then skips over providing any documents that prove it was entirely fanciful and false.
The book is greatly informative on the topic at large.
For the most part these people are criminals of the highest caliber, the US national security state in the years following world war two have killed countless millions through direct warfare, millions more in proxy wars and even millions more through intentional starvation via sanctions and embargo. They have no right to say one word about another states actions being legal or not. These people do not deserve a breath of free air. They are the truest distillation of scum that can possibly exist. Just like the Nazis they provided safe haven to, they are monsters. Even if they did not themselves pull the trigger or lead soldiers on mass murder operations against civilians, the nat sec state of the west is in the same class and deserves the same punishment.
One additional item, if we are discussing an illegal war, operation aerodynamic is that war. The illegal insertion of terrorists to commit acts of mass murder, assassination and attempt an insurrection is by definition an act of war. The fact that these CIA freedom fighters were former fascist terrorists, einsatzgruppen members, and various other components of the genocidal Nazi machine is beyond absurd. In the mind of the average liberal how does this fit within the world view? Where are all the Soviet inserted terrorists into the contiguous United States? Oh wait there weren't any.
Title & Author: Boiling Point by Stephen Kinzer Publisher: Henry Holt & Co. Pages: 384 in hardback Pub date: November 3, 2026
A sincere thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an ARC copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Conclusion up top: Boiling Point is a detailed and comprehensive presentation of the U.S. proxy war waged against Russia through Ukraine. But it fails to break free of its own premise: it finds itself trapped in the ineffable trap of western perspective.
Stephen Kinzer, an author, historian, and journalist, brings us his eleventh book, Boiling Point, at a time where Ukraine is at the forefront of world politics. As of writing, Ukraine and Russia are 12 years deep into a war that, since 2022, has been escalating rapidly into the largest conflict in Europe since WWII. The UN reports that Russia is committing horrific human rights violations in the approximately 20% of Ukraine it currently occupies. Mass-kidnapping of Ukrainian children has been reported, and the ICC is actively investigating Russia for war crimes, crimes against humanity, and genocide related to its invasion. Millions of Ukrainians have been internally displaced, and millions more have fled the country, causing a massive humanitarian and refugee crisis. The World Bank Group estimates that it will cost somewhere in the neighborhood of 600 billion U.S.D to reconstruct the damage in Ukraine. The damage related to Russia's destruction of Ukraine's agriculture and environment has been described as ecocide. Peace negotiations have been stalled for years.
Unsurprisingly, America has found a way to Make it About Us. I'm writing amidst a scandal where, under immense political pressure to save himself from the self-imposed Iran War tailspin tanking Republicans in the midterm elections, President Trump has waived sanctions on Russian diesel. These sanctions, of course, are part of a battery of international condemnation of Russia's 2014 invasion. Even more fun, Elon Musk (with Trump's support???) recently ordered a purposeful slowdown of a version of SpaceX's Starlink, leaving Ukraine's drones virtually inoperable. Musk is a fucking ghoul and, god help us, he is one of many ghouls that haunts the halls of U.S. power. All of this is to say that, faced with layers of deep anguish and human suffering, the U.S. always finds a way to force things into a western lens.
To boil it down (pun-intended) Boiling Point makes a well-supported and well-documented argument that the U.S. has waged a proxy war against Russia by fomenting and capitalizing on Ukrainian nationalist sentiment. Even as Ukraine struggled for its independence, began to stretch its legs, and potentially eye a spot in NATO on the international stage, the U.S. mostly saw it as a weapon to undermine Moscow.
I can't argue against that premise - I don't know enough about geo-politics. I am absolutely not an expert on Russo-Ukranian relations nor should I be relied upon to capture a complex subject in a book review. Kinzer certainly knows more than I do about geo-politics. But what I do know is when I can smell an American re-frame from a mile away.
Here's my major gripe: the lens through which we are invited to view this entire conflict is purely American. So while ostensibly critiquing U.S. meddling, it nonetheless fails to acknowledge the complexity of Ukraine and its people. Especially as I read the first 30% or so of this book, I got the sense that I am supposed to take for granted that Ukrainians had no independent perspective aside from what grew from its relationship with Russia or what was planted within it by the U.S. Even Russia is given a pretty flat treatment. So I found myself with a dual perspective where I'm being told that the U.S. sees Ukraine as a plaything while being given very little reason to think otherwise.
Again - I can't pretend this isn't full of detail. It's definitely a thick'em. Nor can I say that the argument is not well-presented. Kinzer has been in this business long enough that he's honed those skills. I just found myself craving more. I wanted to break out of the little narrative box created by the U.S. I won't assume, but maybe Ukrainians are feeling the same way.
Stephen Kinzer’s new book, Boiling Point: How America Brought War to Ukraine is detailed, well-researched, engrossing, and infuriating. If you think you understand the history of the region, you will find the book fills the gaps in your knowledge, and if you think you know nothing, this book will give you a primer.
The US had interests in the Ukraine for decades, and started working angles decades ago. Even as the US administration changed, and eventually the Cold War ended, the goals for Ukraine remained. We didn't stop working to get between Russia and Ukraine. US interventions in other countries have grown to be the core of our foreign policy, and the manipulation often increases political tensions.
It is a well-researched and intriguing book. I didn't know that I agreed with all of Kinzer's arguments, but I respected it. I found the book thought-provoking and it pushed me outside my own comfort zone, which is always a good thing with this subgenre.
Boiling Point: How America Brought War to Ukraine by Stephen Kinzer Henry Holt and Co., November 3, 2026 ★★★★☆ (4/5)
As someone with minimal knowledge of post-WWII Eastern Europe, I picked up Stephen Kinzer's Boiling Point looking for background context on the war in Ukraine. While the daily news makes clear that Russia is the aggressor in an unprovoked invasion, Kinzer argues the conflict didn't appear out of nowhere. Instead, he traces it through a 75-year history of American involvement in the region. For a novice reader, Kinzer's fast-paced, journalistic style is a major plus.
Given his past books like All the Shah's Men and Overthrow, Kinzer's angle here is no surprise. He has built a career around exposing how American foreign interventions often backfire and cause long-term crises. He applies that exact same lens to Ukraine, building an intriguing case around a few core arguments:
Post-WWII Spy Games: The CIA began recruiting Ukrainian agents right after World War II to destabilize Moscow, cementing Russia's long-term paranoia.
NATO Expansion: Political decisions in the 1990s and 2000s pushed NATO closer to Russia's borders despite warnings that Moscow would see it as a direct threat.
Ukraine as a Project: The US increasingly treated Ukraine as a major geopolitical project, even as Ukraine itself was pursuing closer ties with the West as a sovereign choice, ignoring Russia's "red lines" until the situation exploded.
I found these points fascinating, and the book gave me a solid introduction to the "Realist" school of foreign policy, which looks at global events through the lens of big-power competition.
However, because I am a novice on this subject, I want to be careful not to completely buy into one writer's perspective. Kinzer's arguments are compelling, but his heavy focus on Washington's decisions sometimes crowds out Ukraine's own agency and voice as a sovereign nation defending itself, and I don't think the book fully reckons with how much of this ultimately comes down to Vladimir Putin's own choice to invade.
Ultimately, Boiling Point is a worthwhile read for anyone looking to understand the deeper historical roots of this conflict, though I disagreed with how far Kinzer pushes his argument at times. It gave me a useful foundation, but to truly form my own independent conclusions, I need to balance this out with sources that center the Ukrainian perspective. Any suggestions?
I received an advance review copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Standard Russian and neo-conservative propaganda. To make things short, this is the XIX-th century colonial view of a XXI-st century world. Forget everything you thought you knew about how the world works, the story this book tells you is simple if you embrace the colonial view : There are colonial empires and colonies. Massive countries like the US, Russia, China and a few others are colonial empires. Their neighboring countries are their colonies. A colonial empire has the right to dictate what its colony does and the right to intervene even militarily if it thinks it should (again, you are talking about their own colony after all). For the propagators of the (Nato/CIA/ etc advanced too close to Russia, therefore Russia had to act rhetoric) the reason for which Russia started the invasion of Ukraine and the industrial scale massacre of its citizens, is that the US tried to intervene into another country's colony and that country reacted. For such people international law, national sovereignty and independence, the fact that Ukraine has its own elected representatives and the Ukrainian people are the ones who should decide what direction they choose, mean absolutely nothing.
Again : you interfere with my colony, I go and crush them showing them who's their owner. That's your book in a nutshell.
This book is so biased on the relationship between the US and Ukraine that it hard to take seriously. Putin is present as a passive victim who is unable to act or make decisions on his own. There’s a case to be made that the US pushed too hard, too fast. But positing that Putin didn’t have other choices or isn’t a murderous thug is irresponsible at best.
This book tracks Western and US-Ukraine relations from WW II to the start of the current war with Russia. This paints Ukraine as largely aligned against Russia (or USSR) with internal inconsistencies while being used by the US espionage as something to prod and poke more with the goal of hurting Moscow than helping Kiev. This really rather dysfunctional relationship tracks back all the way to the final days and just after WW II with Operation Aerodynamic.
This is an enlightening book giving a lot of background on what could be, IMHO, a WW III flashpoint.
Boiling Point by Stephen Kinzer is a timely thought-provoking look at the events that led up to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and why after four years it is still ongoing. Kinzer lays out the path that has been taken since World War 2 by the United States in that region has basically encouraged Russia to take action to in their eyes protect their country. During the Cold War Era, the United States took great effort in recruiting Ukrainians to work to destabilize the Soviet Union. Then even though the agreement was Ukraine never becoming part of NATO, the US government has made it a part of every administration either verbally or through actions. The United States has crossed Russia’s red line yet seemed shocked and bewildered of their actions in return. Kinzer goes to great lengths to say he is not a Russian apologist. That being said, I did come away feeling that Russia felt they had to do something. Ukraine did as the United States asked and gave up all the nuclear weapons in exchange for the US giving them protection of their sovereignty. But as the years go and different administrations both Republican and Democrat poke the bear, when it finally explodes, the US is slow to offer any real assistance/protection.
Stephen Kinzer writes in such an accessible way that no mater how knowledgable you are on the subject matter, he brings it to a level of understanding. I would recommend this book to everyone. It gives great historical facts that are backed up. This book will also give you a wonderful look at the United States and how the perceive global affairs.
Stephen Kinzer is one of my favorite authors that doesn’t hold back in his writing on how the policies and the politics of the United States has led to many conflicts through the world with many disastrous repercussions.
I was lucky enough to read and listen to this book and found the narrator, Gordon Rothman to be a very good choice. His pronunciation and pace of reading made this book an easy listen and engaging.
Thank you, Stephen Kinzer, Henry Holt & Company and MacMillan Audio for providing the ARC and ALC via NetGalley for review.
Thanks to Netgalley and Macmillan Audio for the opportunity to review an advance copy of this audiobook.
Stephen Kinzer's Boiling Point is an excellent history of the interplay between Ukraine, Russia, the United States, the EU, and others that does a masterful job of explaining how we reached the point where Russia invaded Ukraine again in 2022. Kinzer explains how Putin's ambitions and insecurities, decisions on NATO enlargement, senior international policy makers' support for certain candidates, and other factors affected Ukraine's trajectory. It was a really interesting book and helped me understand how we reached today's state of play.
The narration in the audiobook version was also quite good and made for a pleasant listening experience.
A review based on ARC audiobook provided by NetGalley and MacMillan Audio.
A powerful and detailed dive into the US's involvement in Ukraine from the end of WW2 to present day. It is truly only focused on the US involvement and doesn't get into internal movements beyond the foreign involvement. Keep that focus in mind as you read and don't expect a ton of judgement drawn. He favors no administration and critically looks into all of them.
Living in Eastern Europe, I thought I was abreast of a lot of details, but I learned a ton! Added some nuance and history behind some positions and clarified other positions.
Great book. Many political leaders and commentators in Western countries have been incredibly dishonest in how they’ve portrayed this conflict. Kinzer’s book corrects the record. His book deserves a wide audience.