What do you think?
Rate this book
Win a free print copy of this book!
7 days and 08:49:31
25 copies available
U.S. only
The Mystic and the Missing Girl
Not yet published
Expected 8 Sep 26Win a free print copy of this book!
7 days and 08:49:31
25 copies available
U.S. only
Reluctant psychic Drew Benson can read tarot cards and get impressions from objects—she just never expected to use her gifts to investigate an infamous cold case.
Drew Benson has a secret. She gets visions, something she hasn’t tapped into since she was a teenager, when her late aunt, a TV psychic known as Hannah Mystic, became the scapegoat in the unsolved disappearance of a local teenager. Twenty years later, Drew is happy to ignore her gift, focusing instead on keeping the metaphysical shop she inherited from Hannah afloat, wrangling her sole, astrology-obsessed employee, and dodging local rake Foster Banks in her picturesque lakeside hometown.
But when Drew's arch-nemesis from high school, now a big city reporter, decides to investigate the cold case from all those years ago, it’s Drew’s ability that could finally make a break in the decades old mystery. With bills piling up, a disapproving mother laying on the guilt, and a local vandal who wants Drew and her witchy store gone, Drew has a lot to lose. But what she stands to gain—finding out what happened to the missing teen, clearing her aunt’s name, and a second chance at belonging—could change everything.
In The Mystic and the Missing Girl, Vikki VanSickle seamlessly draws readers into an utterly charming world in this unputdownable, small town mystery.
Drew Benson has a secret. She gets visions, something she hasn’t tapped into since she was a teenager, when her late aunt, a TV psychic known as Hannah Mystic, became the scapegoat in the unsolved disappearance of a local teenager. Twenty years later, Drew is happy to ignore her gift, focusing instead on keeping the metaphysical shop she inherited from Hannah afloat, wrangling her sole, astrology-obsessed employee, and dodging local rake Foster Banks in her picturesque lakeside hometown.
But when Drew's arch-nemesis from high school, now a big city reporter, decides to investigate the cold case from all those years ago, it’s Drew’s ability that could finally make a break in the decades old mystery. With bills piling up, a disapproving mother laying on the guilt, and a local vandal who wants Drew and her witchy store gone, Drew has a lot to lose. But what she stands to gain—finding out what happened to the missing teen, clearing her aunt’s name, and a second chance at belonging—could change everything.
In The Mystic and the Missing Girl, Vikki VanSickle seamlessly draws readers into an utterly charming world in this unputdownable, small town mystery.
336 pages, Hardcover
Expected publication September 8, 2026
About the author
Vikki VanSickle
23 books319 followersReader, writer, Taurus. My work ranges from cozy mysteries featuring snarky detectives to contemporary middle grade fiction to magical, storytime-ready picture books. I am always exploring a new writing era.
Currently, I live and work in Toronto. Everything I do, I do for my cat.
Currently, I live and work in Toronto. Everything I do, I do for my cat.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 223 reviews
Read
August 23, 2026Vikki VanSickle's "The Mystic and the Missing Girl" is a beautifully written mystery novel with paranormal elements. Written with wit and a touch of humor, it features Drew Benson, a likable and intelligent female protagonist, as she uncovers an engaging decades-old mystery surrounding the disappearance of a teenage girl. It has heart-warming themes of discovering one's hidden talents, finding oneself, and the satisfaction of helping others. I especially enjoyed the Witches' New Year party, a night of reverence and remembrance, celebrated with laughter, food, and community, and the gratifying conclusion. This novel has even prompted me to look into Janeane Garafalo's role as a tarot card reader in the movie "Now and Then." Many thanks to St. Martin's Press/Minotaur books, Vikki VanSickle, and NetGalley, who provided me with an advanced reader copy of this fabulous novel. This is my honest opinion.
July 31, 2026
I had so much fun with this one. Give me a small-town cozy mystery with a little paranormal twist and I’m happy. I flew through it.
Drew was such a likable main character, and I loved watching her return home and get pulled into a decades-old mystery connected to her aunt. The psychic element made the story feel a little different from your typical cozy mystery without taking over the plot.
The town was charming, the shop cat was adorable, and the whole cast just worked. I kept changing my mind about what had happened, which is always a good sign. I love when a mystery actually keeps me guessing instead of making the ending obvious.
If cozy mysteries are your thing but you want one with a little extra magic mixed in, definitely pick this one up. It was cozy, entertaining, and just a really enjoyable read.
Drew was such a likable main character, and I loved watching her return home and get pulled into a decades-old mystery connected to her aunt. The psychic element made the story feel a little different from your typical cozy mystery without taking over the plot.
The town was charming, the shop cat was adorable, and the whole cast just worked. I kept changing my mind about what had happened, which is always a good sign. I love when a mystery actually keeps me guessing instead of making the ending obvious.
If cozy mysteries are your thing but you want one with a little extra magic mixed in, definitely pick this one up. It was cozy, entertaining, and just a really enjoyable read.
April 30, 2026
This was a very good book and I’m so grateful to have been offered by the publisher to read and review this book. I read it in one breath, it has captivated me from the first page. I loved the main character and her tenacity and persistence in cracking the case. I also loved the ending of the book, specifically mother-daughter connection. Definitely recommend to all my followers.
August 9, 2026
I really loved this one! The psychic abilities, tarot cards, metaphysical shop and decades old missing girl case were all right up my alley. I loved Drew, but I especially loved the friendship that developed between her and Nick while they investigated the case together.
My only real issue was the pacing. I don't think the book necessarily needed to be shorter, just tighter. The chapters are short but there’s quite a bit of repetition, so at times it felt like we spent 90% of the book dragging our feet toward the ending. I also figured out what happened to the missing girl pretty easily once the pieces were presented, so the actual reveal was a little meh for me, even though the tension getting there was great.
Still, this was such a fun read and I believe it's the author's first adult novel, so I'm definitely interested in seeing where she goes from here. If this turns into a series, I will absolutely be back for more Drew!
I listened to the audiobook and Veronica Hortiguela was fantastic. She IS Drew to me now.
My only real issue was the pacing. I don't think the book necessarily needed to be shorter, just tighter. The chapters are short but there’s quite a bit of repetition, so at times it felt like we spent 90% of the book dragging our feet toward the ending. I also figured out what happened to the missing girl pretty easily once the pieces were presented, so the actual reveal was a little meh for me, even though the tension getting there was great.
Still, this was such a fun read and I believe it's the author's first adult novel, so I'm definitely interested in seeing where she goes from here. If this turns into a series, I will absolutely be back for more Drew!
I listened to the audiobook and Veronica Hortiguela was fantastic. She IS Drew to me now.
August 14, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a copy of this arc!
This was a good book overall. I liked the idea of incorporating a psychic with a disappearance investigation and I thought those parts of the story were unique. However, the pacing seemed off for me at times. Parts of the story really had my interest and I wanted to keep reading, but then there were other parts of the story that did seem to drag a bit at times. Because of this, it took me a lot longer than usual to get through the book. Overall, I did enjoy the plot and the ending wrapped up nicely. A solid 4 stars.
This was a good book overall. I liked the idea of incorporating a psychic with a disappearance investigation and I thought those parts of the story were unique. However, the pacing seemed off for me at times. Parts of the story really had my interest and I wanted to keep reading, but then there were other parts of the story that did seem to drag a bit at times. Because of this, it took me a lot longer than usual to get through the book. Overall, I did enjoy the plot and the ending wrapped up nicely. A solid 4 stars.
August 29, 2026
This mystery kept me guessing until the end! I really enjoyed this book. It was a great story with well-developed characters and relationships threaded together by the tarot. It also had a wonderful narrator.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
ARC provided by Netgalley.
Everyone was a fan of Hannah until her mystical gifts seemingly failed to find a missing teen from 20 years in the past. Now Hannah has passed on leaving her shop and upstairs apartment to her niece who seems to share a similar gift. Drew Benson has returned to her small coastal town trying to decide if she is going to keep the shop or move on. When a reporter who has a shared past with Drew turns up to write an expose on both the missing teen and Hannah, Drew has to decide whether or not to use her gifts to help out.
Besides Drew, there is the non-gender employee named George and a cat (of course there is a shop cat) named Willow that bring an extra sparkle to this tale. Two men also catch the eye of Drew but are either really available to her? And then there is the defacing of the shop, broken windows, and a watcher. No one really wants the niece of Hannah here stirring the spirits.
I easily figured out the mystery but stayed for not only the side characters but the mother daughter relationship and growth of the main character, Drew. I also learned a thing or two about Mystics and Psychics.
The Mystic and the Missing Girl will definitely appeal to those into small town mysteries with a bit of mysticism.
Everyone was a fan of Hannah until her mystical gifts seemingly failed to find a missing teen from 20 years in the past. Now Hannah has passed on leaving her shop and upstairs apartment to her niece who seems to share a similar gift. Drew Benson has returned to her small coastal town trying to decide if she is going to keep the shop or move on. When a reporter who has a shared past with Drew turns up to write an expose on both the missing teen and Hannah, Drew has to decide whether or not to use her gifts to help out.
Besides Drew, there is the non-gender employee named George and a cat (of course there is a shop cat) named Willow that bring an extra sparkle to this tale. Two men also catch the eye of Drew but are either really available to her? And then there is the defacing of the shop, broken windows, and a watcher. No one really wants the niece of Hannah here stirring the spirits.
I easily figured out the mystery but stayed for not only the side characters but the mother daughter relationship and growth of the main character, Drew. I also learned a thing or two about Mystics and Psychics.
The Mystic and the Missing Girl will definitely appeal to those into small town mysteries with a bit of mysticism.
May 8, 2026
I was lucky enough to receive an advanced copy of this book, and I’m genuinely so glad I did.
This cozy mystery completely pulled me in from the very first page. Drew was such an easy character to root for, and I quickly fell in love with both her and the wonderfully eclectic cast surrounding her. The relationships and small-town feel made this such a comforting, immersive read.
One of my favorite parts of the story was the tarot and metaphysical witchy atmosphere woven throughout the mystery. It gave the book such a unique, cozy charm and made it feel absolutely perfect for fall reading. And if you’re someone who knows nothing about tarot (hi, me), don’t let that scare you away—the author explains everything in a way that feels natural, authentic, and easy to follow without ever slowing the story down.
This is exactly the kind of book I want to curl up with on a chilly fall evening, preferably with a candle lit and a drink nearby. With a September release date, the timing honestly couldn’t be more perfect. Definitely add this one to your fall reading list.
Title: The Mystic and the Missing Girl
Author: Vikki VanSickle
Page Count: 336 pages
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Publish Date: September 8, 2026
This cozy mystery completely pulled me in from the very first page. Drew was such an easy character to root for, and I quickly fell in love with both her and the wonderfully eclectic cast surrounding her. The relationships and small-town feel made this such a comforting, immersive read.
One of my favorite parts of the story was the tarot and metaphysical witchy atmosphere woven throughout the mystery. It gave the book such a unique, cozy charm and made it feel absolutely perfect for fall reading. And if you’re someone who knows nothing about tarot (hi, me), don’t let that scare you away—the author explains everything in a way that feels natural, authentic, and easy to follow without ever slowing the story down.
This is exactly the kind of book I want to curl up with on a chilly fall evening, preferably with a candle lit and a drink nearby. With a September release date, the timing honestly couldn’t be more perfect. Definitely add this one to your fall reading list.
Title: The Mystic and the Missing Girl
Author: Vikki VanSickle
Page Count: 336 pages
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Publish Date: September 8, 2026
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Drew Benson inherited her beloved Aunt Hannah's mystical shop and is trying to keep the business afloat when a former classmate begins digging into the disappearance of a missing teenager. Her psychic aunt had been unable to solve the case 20 years ago, but the notes her aunt left behind and Drew's forgotten psychic ability may be enough to solve the mystery.
The author slowly pulls you, along with Drew, deeper into the mystery. As Drew's psychic abilities are revealed, you learn the meaning of Tarot cards and how things are not always what they seem.
I enjoyed this mystery and would enjoy getting to know Drew below her snarky exterior. Use of pronouns for one character made for a confusing read but this was limited. Overall, a good start to a mystery series!
Special thanks to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for the advanced digital copy in exchange for my honest review!
The author slowly pulls you, along with Drew, deeper into the mystery. As Drew's psychic abilities are revealed, you learn the meaning of Tarot cards and how things are not always what they seem.
I enjoyed this mystery and would enjoy getting to know Drew below her snarky exterior. Use of pronouns for one character made for a confusing read but this was limited. Overall, a good start to a mystery series!
Special thanks to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for the advanced digital copy in exchange for my honest review!
May 23, 2026
When Hannah passes away, Drew Benson inherits her metaphysical store. Struggling to stay afloat and keeping way too busy another huge weight is put on her- a missing persons case from 20 years ago is getting reopened. Hannah was the psychic on the case and got a lot of pushback. Drew finds out there is a connection between her and the missing girl. Can she figure out the subtle, obscure, and possibly fatal connection to Ginny before it’s too late?
Whatttt I did not see the twist with Ginny’s Death and the actual truth behind it. Poor girl she possibly could have been saved. I really liked the light-heartedness of this story. Crime/Thrillers don’t always have to be crazy to be good.
Whatttt I did not see the twist with Ginny’s Death and the actual truth behind it. Poor girl she possibly could have been saved. I really liked the light-heartedness of this story. Crime/Thrillers don’t always have to be crazy to be good.
Want to Read
April 21, 2026A huge thank you to the author and publisher for providing an e-ARC via Netgalley. This does not affect my opinion regarding the book.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you NetGalley and Minotaur Books for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!
“The Mystic and the Missing Girl” by Vikki VanSickle is one of those cozy-but-intriguing mysteries that mixes small-town drama with realistic magic, and it works surprisingly well.
The story follows Drew, a reluctant psychic who has spent years not using her abilities after watching her aunt get completely torn apart by the town. Twenty years ago, her aunt tried to help solve a missing girl case using her visions, and when it didn’t lead anywhere, the town basically blamed her for everything. So yeah, Drew has every reason to keep that part of herself buried.
But of course, that doesn’t last.
When a reporter comes back to town to reopen the cold case, Drew ends up teaming up with him and slowly starts tapping back into her abilities. The magic here is pretty low-key (think tarot cards, visions, and vibes rather than anything flashy), so it feels more like magical realism than fantasy. If anything, it’s mostly a mystery with a mystical twist.
And the mystery itself is really solid. The whole town is still obsessed with this missing girl decades later, and as Drew and the reporter (Nick) start digging, you get a ton of suspects, secrets, and connections to keep track of. It can feel like a lot at times, but everything eventually clicks into place in a way that’s actually satisfying. The final reveal is one of those “wait—how did I not see that?” moments. The mystery had many layers, and I thoroughly enjoyed it, especially when Drew’s magic became involved.
Character-wise, Drew is a standout. She feels very real; she’s not overly dramatic, she’s emotionally mature, and she actually thinks through her decisions (which is rare and refreshing). Her relationships are also a highlight, especially her friendship with Nick. They balance each other really well; he’s more logical and grounded, while she leans into the intuitive, mystical side, and their dynamic makes the investigation more fun to follow.
There’s also a bit of romantic tension with her ex, Foster, which is complicated, to say the least. The book doesn’t romanticize it, though, which is nice. Drew is very aware that their relationship isn’t exactly healthy, and she treats it that way.
Another thing this book does well is atmosphere. The small-town setting feels real; everyone knows everyone, rumors spread fast, and old grudges never really go away. It also touches on how badly the original investigation was handled, especially how quickly the town turned on Drew’s aunt instead of actually solving the case.
And honestly, the tarot/psychic elements are just cool. You get little bits of information about tarot cards and spiritual practices without it feeling overwhelming, which adds to the vibe without taking over the story.
The ending is super satisfying. There’s a big, tension-filled climax where everything comes together, followed by a longer epilogue that actually gives you closure, not just for the mystery, but for Drew’s personal life too. It wraps things up in a way that feels complete but still leaves room for potential future stories.
Also, there’s a black kitten. That alone adds points.
Overall, this is a great pick if you like character-driven mysteries with a cozy, slightly witchy vibe. It’s not super high-stakes or action-packed, but it’s thoughtful, well-constructed, and easy to get invested in. This definitely feels like the kind of book that could turn into a series. I’d 100% read more cases with Drew and Nick.
“The Mystic and the Missing Girl” by Vikki VanSickle is one of those cozy-but-intriguing mysteries that mixes small-town drama with realistic magic, and it works surprisingly well.
The story follows Drew, a reluctant psychic who has spent years not using her abilities after watching her aunt get completely torn apart by the town. Twenty years ago, her aunt tried to help solve a missing girl case using her visions, and when it didn’t lead anywhere, the town basically blamed her for everything. So yeah, Drew has every reason to keep that part of herself buried.
But of course, that doesn’t last.
When a reporter comes back to town to reopen the cold case, Drew ends up teaming up with him and slowly starts tapping back into her abilities. The magic here is pretty low-key (think tarot cards, visions, and vibes rather than anything flashy), so it feels more like magical realism than fantasy. If anything, it’s mostly a mystery with a mystical twist.
And the mystery itself is really solid. The whole town is still obsessed with this missing girl decades later, and as Drew and the reporter (Nick) start digging, you get a ton of suspects, secrets, and connections to keep track of. It can feel like a lot at times, but everything eventually clicks into place in a way that’s actually satisfying. The final reveal is one of those “wait—how did I not see that?” moments. The mystery had many layers, and I thoroughly enjoyed it, especially when Drew’s magic became involved.
Character-wise, Drew is a standout. She feels very real; she’s not overly dramatic, she’s emotionally mature, and she actually thinks through her decisions (which is rare and refreshing). Her relationships are also a highlight, especially her friendship with Nick. They balance each other really well; he’s more logical and grounded, while she leans into the intuitive, mystical side, and their dynamic makes the investigation more fun to follow.
There’s also a bit of romantic tension with her ex, Foster, which is complicated, to say the least. The book doesn’t romanticize it, though, which is nice. Drew is very aware that their relationship isn’t exactly healthy, and she treats it that way.
Another thing this book does well is atmosphere. The small-town setting feels real; everyone knows everyone, rumors spread fast, and old grudges never really go away. It also touches on how badly the original investigation was handled, especially how quickly the town turned on Drew’s aunt instead of actually solving the case.
And honestly, the tarot/psychic elements are just cool. You get little bits of information about tarot cards and spiritual practices without it feeling overwhelming, which adds to the vibe without taking over the story.
The ending is super satisfying. There’s a big, tension-filled climax where everything comes together, followed by a longer epilogue that actually gives you closure, not just for the mystery, but for Drew’s personal life too. It wraps things up in a way that feels complete but still leaves room for potential future stories.
Also, there’s a black kitten. That alone adds points.
Overall, this is a great pick if you like character-driven mysteries with a cozy, slightly witchy vibe. It’s not super high-stakes or action-packed, but it’s thoughtful, well-constructed, and easy to get invested in. This definitely feels like the kind of book that could turn into a series. I’d 100% read more cases with Drew and Nick.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I absolutely loved The Mystic and the Missing Girl! A cozy mystery with a strong FMC, witchcraft, and tarot themes is exactly the kind of book I enjoy, but I was pleasantly surprised by how much more this story had to offer.
As a professional tarot reader, I was especially impressed by how deftly Vikki VanSickle incorporated tarot into the story. The descriptions of both predictive and reflective approaches to reading felt accurate and thoughtfully handled. Likewise, the references to witchcraft felt authentic, as though they were written by someone who actually understands and practices it rather than simply adding “witchy” elements because they fit the story.
The characters felt equally believable and natural. I particularly appreciated the book’s subtle feminist empowerment and queer representation. Despite the obvious research and care that went into all of these elements, none of it ever felt shoehorned in. Everything felt like a natural part of the characters and their world, and the story flowed beautifully.
The setting was another highlight. The descriptions did a wonderful job of putting me right into the time and place without bogging the story down with unnecessary details. The result was a quick, light, and thoroughly entertaining read. There were also quite a few wonderfully appealing descriptions of food and beverages. This is actually something I tend to avoid in books because I’m unable to eat and am tube fed. However, I was so invested in this story and its characters that I didn’t mind. In fact, I found myself appreciating how the descriptions brought back pleasant memories of a time when I could eat.
On a more personal level, I connected with Drew’s experiences with psychic abilities. Like Drew, I have experienced psychic activity since childhood and have struggled with whether to talk openly about it because of the fear of ridicule and the inevitable self-doubt that can come with experiences that other people may not understand. I thought VanSickle handled both the psychic elements and the emotions surrounding them with so much care and relatability.
And, of course, there’s the mystery itself. The cold case surrounding the disappearance of a local teenager is genuinely interesting and compelling, with exactly the kind of true-crime sleuthing vibe that I love. Watching Drew reluctantly confront her abilities while trying to uncover what happened made the mystery especially engaging.
Take it from a queer psychic witch: I could not put this book down. I predict The Mystic and the Missing Girl will become one of my comfort reads I return to from time to time.
I highly recommend this one, especially to readers who enjoy cozy mysteries, tarot, witchcraft, psychic mysteries, and small-town sleuthing. And with its release arriving just in time for Halloween season, I can’t think of a better time to pick it up!
Many thanks to NetGalley, Vikki VanSickle, and Macmillan Audio for this ARC to review
As a professional tarot reader, I was especially impressed by how deftly Vikki VanSickle incorporated tarot into the story. The descriptions of both predictive and reflective approaches to reading felt accurate and thoughtfully handled. Likewise, the references to witchcraft felt authentic, as though they were written by someone who actually understands and practices it rather than simply adding “witchy” elements because they fit the story.
The characters felt equally believable and natural. I particularly appreciated the book’s subtle feminist empowerment and queer representation. Despite the obvious research and care that went into all of these elements, none of it ever felt shoehorned in. Everything felt like a natural part of the characters and their world, and the story flowed beautifully.
The setting was another highlight. The descriptions did a wonderful job of putting me right into the time and place without bogging the story down with unnecessary details. The result was a quick, light, and thoroughly entertaining read. There were also quite a few wonderfully appealing descriptions of food and beverages. This is actually something I tend to avoid in books because I’m unable to eat and am tube fed. However, I was so invested in this story and its characters that I didn’t mind. In fact, I found myself appreciating how the descriptions brought back pleasant memories of a time when I could eat.
On a more personal level, I connected with Drew’s experiences with psychic abilities. Like Drew, I have experienced psychic activity since childhood and have struggled with whether to talk openly about it because of the fear of ridicule and the inevitable self-doubt that can come with experiences that other people may not understand. I thought VanSickle handled both the psychic elements and the emotions surrounding them with so much care and relatability.
And, of course, there’s the mystery itself. The cold case surrounding the disappearance of a local teenager is genuinely interesting and compelling, with exactly the kind of true-crime sleuthing vibe that I love. Watching Drew reluctantly confront her abilities while trying to uncover what happened made the mystery especially engaging.
Take it from a queer psychic witch: I could not put this book down. I predict The Mystic and the Missing Girl will become one of my comfort reads I return to from time to time.
I highly recommend this one, especially to readers who enjoy cozy mysteries, tarot, witchcraft, psychic mysteries, and small-town sleuthing. And with its release arriving just in time for Halloween season, I can’t think of a better time to pick it up!
Many thanks to NetGalley, Vikki VanSickle, and Macmillan Audio for this ARC to review
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for providing me with an advanced copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
4.5 rounded up.
This was SO good!! I originally requested an ARC of this story based on the title alone. Due to this, I didn't really have any expectations going into it because I really didn't know what to expect. This quickly became one of my favourite reads this year though!
One of my favourite aspects of this story is that it offers something unique. I've read an insane amount of mysteries and thrillers, but never once has the main character been a psychic who uses their gift to help solve a cold case. I honestly found this new aspect to be really refreshing!
Aside from its originality, I also found the extra magic aspect to be super fun. It gave the story an extra bit of whimsy, which I always adore in cozy mysteries. More than that though, I grew up with an aunt who did tarot readings for family and That's So Raven was one of my favourite shows to watch. As a result, this book brought up a lot of nostalgia and good feelings!
Now, where the book really shines comes from the characters, especially Drew. While this book mainly was focused on figuring out what happened to Ginny, it was also a journey of self-discovery. Readers are taken on a journey where Drew gains confidence, security, and a sense of purpose, as she starts to give herself permission to lean into her gifts.
Additionally, in regards to Drew, I really loved her badass attitude. She is such a strong female character and I loved that she didn't back down in the face of powerful men (even though sometimes I questioned if the woman had a death wish 😅😜). As someone who also feels a lot of anger towards injustices, I couldn't help but root for her! I love me a sassy queen 👑
Even outside of Drew, all of the characters came off very realistic and multidimensional to me. They all had different distinct personalities that included little quirks, beliefs, values, strengths, and flaws, which really allowed them to feel relatable.
In terms of the mystery itself, i thought that it was really well done. It had complexities and had me questioning several different people at various times. In the end, I don't think the story was entirely perdoctable, as I myself didn't correctly guess everything, but I also don't think it was super unpredictable and shocking either. This honestly was fine with me because I truly enjoyed the journey Drew and Nick went on to find the answers.
Lastly, bonus points for this story being set in Canada! 🇨🇦
Overall, I highly recommend that any fans of cozy mysteries, especially those with some extra magic, check this book out! It releases Tuesday, August 25th, 2026!
Now, here's hoping this becomes a series! The author left it open for that to happen and I really hope it does! 🤞🏻
4.5 rounded up.
This was SO good!! I originally requested an ARC of this story based on the title alone. Due to this, I didn't really have any expectations going into it because I really didn't know what to expect. This quickly became one of my favourite reads this year though!
One of my favourite aspects of this story is that it offers something unique. I've read an insane amount of mysteries and thrillers, but never once has the main character been a psychic who uses their gift to help solve a cold case. I honestly found this new aspect to be really refreshing!
Aside from its originality, I also found the extra magic aspect to be super fun. It gave the story an extra bit of whimsy, which I always adore in cozy mysteries. More than that though, I grew up with an aunt who did tarot readings for family and That's So Raven was one of my favourite shows to watch. As a result, this book brought up a lot of nostalgia and good feelings!
Now, where the book really shines comes from the characters, especially Drew. While this book mainly was focused on figuring out what happened to Ginny, it was also a journey of self-discovery. Readers are taken on a journey where Drew gains confidence, security, and a sense of purpose, as she starts to give herself permission to lean into her gifts.
Additionally, in regards to Drew, I really loved her badass attitude. She is such a strong female character and I loved that she didn't back down in the face of powerful men (even though sometimes I questioned if the woman had a death wish 😅😜). As someone who also feels a lot of anger towards injustices, I couldn't help but root for her! I love me a sassy queen 👑
Even outside of Drew, all of the characters came off very realistic and multidimensional to me. They all had different distinct personalities that included little quirks, beliefs, values, strengths, and flaws, which really allowed them to feel relatable.
In terms of the mystery itself, i thought that it was really well done. It had complexities and had me questioning several different people at various times. In the end, I don't think the story was entirely perdoctable, as I myself didn't correctly guess everything, but I also don't think it was super unpredictable and shocking either. This honestly was fine with me because I truly enjoyed the journey Drew and Nick went on to find the answers.
Lastly, bonus points for this story being set in Canada! 🇨🇦
Overall, I highly recommend that any fans of cozy mysteries, especially those with some extra magic, check this book out! It releases Tuesday, August 25th, 2026!
Now, here's hoping this becomes a series! The author left it open for that to happen and I really hope it does! 🤞🏻
August 13, 2026
Vikki VanSickle’s The Mystic and the Missing Girl was exactly the kind of mystery I wanted with my coffee—small-town secrets, tarot cards, a decades-old disappearance, and just enough mystical weirdness to make me suspicious of absolutely everyone. Thank you to Minotaur Books for the gifted copy. Tell me I’m not the only one who immediately starts playing detective the second a cold case shows up in a book?
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Drew Benson has returned to her hometown after inheriting her late Aunt Hannah’s metaphysical shop, Good Vibrations. Hannah was once a well-known psychic, but twenty years ago she became the town scapegoat when her visions failed to solve the disappearance of teenager Ginny Evans.
Now Nick, Drew’s former high school nemesis turned reporter, is digging into Ginny’s case again, and he wants Hannah’s old journals. Drew would rather leave the past alone, but unfortunately for her, those psychic abilities she stopped using years ago have other ideas.
I really liked Drew. She’s sarcastic, uncertain about what she wants, carrying some complicated feelings about Hannah, and trying to keep a struggling shop alive while her mother would very much prefer she make completely different life choices. Basically, she has enough problems before anybody starts asking her to solve a twenty-year-old mystery.
Drew and Nick investigating together ended up being one of my favorite parts. Their history gives them some fun banter, but I also loved watching the trust slowly build between them. George was another favorite, and honestly, give me a metaphysical shop with tarot cards, astrology talk, quirky customers, and a little black shop cat and I’m already pretty happy.
The tarot and psychic elements were woven into the mystery without taking over the story. Drew’s abilities give her impressions and clues, but she still has to do the work and figure out what they mean. I appreciated that because no magical shortcut was coming along to neatly solve everything.
I did start putting some pieces together before Drew did, but I definitely didn’t have every detail right. And by the end, I was surprisingly invested in more than just finding out what happened to Ginny. This became a story about family, belonging, old reputations, and finally deciding who you want to be when everyone else seems to have an opinion.
I’m really hoping this isn’t the last we see of Drew, Nick, George, and Good Vibrations.
Which would tempt you into investigating first—the twenty-year-old cold case, the mysterious aunt’s journals, or the tarot cards?
#TheMysticAndTheMissingGirl #VikkiVanSickle #MinotaurBooks #CozyMystery #MysteryBooks #ParanormalMystery #FallReads #Bookstagram
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Drew Benson has returned to her hometown after inheriting her late Aunt Hannah’s metaphysical shop, Good Vibrations. Hannah was once a well-known psychic, but twenty years ago she became the town scapegoat when her visions failed to solve the disappearance of teenager Ginny Evans.
Now Nick, Drew’s former high school nemesis turned reporter, is digging into Ginny’s case again, and he wants Hannah’s old journals. Drew would rather leave the past alone, but unfortunately for her, those psychic abilities she stopped using years ago have other ideas.
I really liked Drew. She’s sarcastic, uncertain about what she wants, carrying some complicated feelings about Hannah, and trying to keep a struggling shop alive while her mother would very much prefer she make completely different life choices. Basically, she has enough problems before anybody starts asking her to solve a twenty-year-old mystery.
Drew and Nick investigating together ended up being one of my favorite parts. Their history gives them some fun banter, but I also loved watching the trust slowly build between them. George was another favorite, and honestly, give me a metaphysical shop with tarot cards, astrology talk, quirky customers, and a little black shop cat and I’m already pretty happy.
The tarot and psychic elements were woven into the mystery without taking over the story. Drew’s abilities give her impressions and clues, but she still has to do the work and figure out what they mean. I appreciated that because no magical shortcut was coming along to neatly solve everything.
I did start putting some pieces together before Drew did, but I definitely didn’t have every detail right. And by the end, I was surprisingly invested in more than just finding out what happened to Ginny. This became a story about family, belonging, old reputations, and finally deciding who you want to be when everyone else seems to have an opinion.
I’m really hoping this isn’t the last we see of Drew, Nick, George, and Good Vibrations.
Which would tempt you into investigating first—the twenty-year-old cold case, the mysterious aunt’s journals, or the tarot cards?
#TheMysticAndTheMissingGirl #VikkiVanSickle #MinotaurBooks #CozyMystery #MysteryBooks #ParanormalMystery #FallReads #Bookstagram
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Call it intuition, but I knew as soon as I read the synopsis for this book that it was going to be such a fun, unique mystery. Maybe I am psychic like the protagonist, because this book was such a delight!
Drew Benson is a reluctant psychic who finds herself in the middle of 20 year-old mystery after inheriting her late aunt's metaphysical shop. Her aunt, Hannah Mystic, was a well known psychic with a tarnished reputation in the community. 20 years earlier, she utilized her psychic visions to assist with the case of a local missing girl. When her assistance led to dead ends, she became the town outcast. After witnessing the backlash and torment that her aunt had faced, Drew kept her own psychic abilities a secret. It isn't until a reporter shows up one day, enthusiastic and ready to finally solve the 20 year-old mystery, that Drew realizes her gifts may be the only way to solve this case. It also may be the only way to finally clear her aunt's name.
As someone who personally loves astrology, the paranormal, and everything metaphysical, this book was right up my alley. If you are someone who reads or is familiar with tarot, you will appreciate the way in which it was used throughout the story to help solve the core mystery. I LOVED it. Parts of the book were broken down into corresponding cards and their meaning; it helped set the tone for the narrative and characters that were to follow.
I appreciated the relationship growth between Drew and the reporter, Nick. Their characters complimented each other well, and I would certainly read another adventure with these two at the center of it.
This book was also the first book where I have seen gender fluid representation. Drew employs George, a gender fluid character, who is referred to as the pronouns they/them/their. Not only was George a fun, eclectic character to read, but it was refreshing to see this type of representation in modern fiction.
Overall, this was a fun, cozy mystery that I would recommend to anyone who enjoys the genre. However, if you are someone like me, who looks to the stars for wisdom and to the moon for guidance, then I BEG you to read this! The mystical aspect added so much to the story.
I also must mention, the ending is heartwarming, which left me teary eyed. It is rare I read a mystery book where I laugh, I cry, and still be biting my nails, suspecting everyone and anyone as the villain in the story. Oh how I loved this!
Special thanks to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for the advanced digital copy in exchange for my honest review!
Drew Benson is a reluctant psychic who finds herself in the middle of 20 year-old mystery after inheriting her late aunt's metaphysical shop. Her aunt, Hannah Mystic, was a well known psychic with a tarnished reputation in the community. 20 years earlier, she utilized her psychic visions to assist with the case of a local missing girl. When her assistance led to dead ends, she became the town outcast. After witnessing the backlash and torment that her aunt had faced, Drew kept her own psychic abilities a secret. It isn't until a reporter shows up one day, enthusiastic and ready to finally solve the 20 year-old mystery, that Drew realizes her gifts may be the only way to solve this case. It also may be the only way to finally clear her aunt's name.
As someone who personally loves astrology, the paranormal, and everything metaphysical, this book was right up my alley. If you are someone who reads or is familiar with tarot, you will appreciate the way in which it was used throughout the story to help solve the core mystery. I LOVED it. Parts of the book were broken down into corresponding cards and their meaning; it helped set the tone for the narrative and characters that were to follow.
I appreciated the relationship growth between Drew and the reporter, Nick. Their characters complimented each other well, and I would certainly read another adventure with these two at the center of it.
This book was also the first book where I have seen gender fluid representation. Drew employs George, a gender fluid character, who is referred to as the pronouns they/them/their. Not only was George a fun, eclectic character to read, but it was refreshing to see this type of representation in modern fiction.
Overall, this was a fun, cozy mystery that I would recommend to anyone who enjoys the genre. However, if you are someone like me, who looks to the stars for wisdom and to the moon for guidance, then I BEG you to read this! The mystical aspect added so much to the story.
I also must mention, the ending is heartwarming, which left me teary eyed. It is rare I read a mystery book where I laugh, I cry, and still be biting my nails, suspecting everyone and anyone as the villain in the story. Oh how I loved this!
Special thanks to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for the advanced digital copy in exchange for my honest review!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
📱📖 Read on Kindle 📃 336 pages ⏱ Duration: 5 hours
Genre: Cozy Mystery 🏷️ Publisher: Minotaur Books
🙏 ARC provided by NetGalley in exchange for an honest review
The thing that drew (LOL, that's the name of the MC — DREW) me to this book is the title 'mystic' and the blurb describing tarot reading. I recently got myself hooked up to a tarot card set, and since then, have found tarot to be fascinating, and oddly specific in my cases. So this was captivating to me, thinking I might learn a bit more about tarot while also enjoying a murder mystery.
I rightly assumed about the tarot learning. Every start of a chapter gives a small description of one random tarot card. These cards aren't necessarily related to the chapter (or I didn't feel so), which avoids giving any spoilers to the chapter story coming up. That worked in two ways: one is that the spoiler is avoided and you're excited to see where the story is going, and second is that you learn a bit about tarot cards and what to look for when you get certain ones. I really enjoyed that ploy, and want to give big kudos to Vikki VanSickle. This technique works!!
I enjoyed the character relationships. Drew and her aunt Hannah have a relationship that survived being out of touch for a very long time. I adored that. Not putting Nick in as a romantic interest was so off the mark from a traditional cozy story that I totally enjoyed it. Their friendship is beautifully drawn out. The story itself felt a bit slow to proceed but was still fun to keep at it.
One issue I have is the fair play mystery concept. The killer took some time coming on stage, as a person. There was a small hint around the start, but it was such a blink-and-miss hint that I wouldn't consider it much. Yes, once the killer comes on stage, things start moving fast, but until then, I didn't find any inclination towards considering them for the crime, which leaves me a bit surly.
But I won't hold it against Vikki. This story has potential, and I can't wait to see where she goes on to write in the future.
Would I recommend it?
Yes, I'd recommend The Mystic and the Missing Girl, especially if you're at all curious about tarot or looking for a cozy mystery that skips the obvious romantic subplot. Drew and Hannah's relationship carries real weight, and the tarot chapter openers are a genuinely clever touch. The mystery itself moves slower than I'd like. The fair play element could use tightening. But Vikki VanSickle has a strong foundation here. Mark your calendar for September 8, because this one's worth adding to your TBR.
Genre: Cozy Mystery 🏷️ Publisher: Minotaur Books
🙏 ARC provided by NetGalley in exchange for an honest review
The thing that drew (LOL, that's the name of the MC — DREW) me to this book is the title 'mystic' and the blurb describing tarot reading. I recently got myself hooked up to a tarot card set, and since then, have found tarot to be fascinating, and oddly specific in my cases. So this was captivating to me, thinking I might learn a bit more about tarot while also enjoying a murder mystery.
I rightly assumed about the tarot learning. Every start of a chapter gives a small description of one random tarot card. These cards aren't necessarily related to the chapter (or I didn't feel so), which avoids giving any spoilers to the chapter story coming up. That worked in two ways: one is that the spoiler is avoided and you're excited to see where the story is going, and second is that you learn a bit about tarot cards and what to look for when you get certain ones. I really enjoyed that ploy, and want to give big kudos to Vikki VanSickle. This technique works!!
I enjoyed the character relationships. Drew and her aunt Hannah have a relationship that survived being out of touch for a very long time. I adored that. Not putting Nick in as a romantic interest was so off the mark from a traditional cozy story that I totally enjoyed it. Their friendship is beautifully drawn out. The story itself felt a bit slow to proceed but was still fun to keep at it.
One issue I have is the fair play mystery concept. The killer took some time coming on stage, as a person. There was a small hint around the start, but it was such a blink-and-miss hint that I wouldn't consider it much. Yes, once the killer comes on stage, things start moving fast, but until then, I didn't find any inclination towards considering them for the crime, which leaves me a bit surly.
But I won't hold it against Vikki. This story has potential, and I can't wait to see where she goes on to write in the future.
Would I recommend it?
Yes, I'd recommend The Mystic and the Missing Girl, especially if you're at all curious about tarot or looking for a cozy mystery that skips the obvious romantic subplot. Drew and Hannah's relationship carries real weight, and the tarot chapter openers are a genuinely clever touch. The mystery itself moves slower than I'd like. The fair play element could use tightening. But Vikki VanSickle has a strong foundation here. Mark your calendar for September 8, because this one's worth adding to your TBR.
August 14, 2026
You know those insanely addictive shows that have you on the edge of your seat, blank stare on your face, while you mindlessly shovel popcorn into your mouth? This is that, but in book form. The Mystic and the Missing Girl is a cozy blend of connecting strings to solve a crime, learning more about the characters and their lives, and plenty of witchy moments. There’s even a tiny sprinkle of teary-eyed moments for good measure. 😂
Drew inherited her aunt’s Mystic shop… and it’s not going well. Twenty years ago, a local girl went missing, and Drew’s aunt, a Mystic in her own right, attempted to help. The mystery has remained unsolved ever since, and much of the town has neither forgotten nor let go of the fact that her aunt failed to assist the investigation, ruining her reputation as a psychic in the process.
Then an old classmate, Nick, shows up. He’s reopening the investigation on his own and hopes that Drew, and her aunt’s journals, may be able to help. This is where the story really takes off.
The vibes of this book were so unique. The explanations of tarot, for example, could have easily felt dragged out or boring rather than informative, but they never did. I was entranced by every little detail and every glimmer of witchy goodness woven throughout the story.
The characters also meshed incredibly well. The balance between Nick and Drew’s personalities and their friendship was so entertaining. One is a thirty-something Mystic who is still figuring her life out, while the other is a well-put-together, very successful reporter who seems to have all his ducks in a row. George and Gigi were also notable side characters, and I thoroughly enjoyed what they added to the story.
Honestly, I wasn’t sure if something could qualify as a cozy mystery when there’s a possible murder, or, at the very least, a missing girl, but that’s exactly what this felt like. 😂 It had all of the intrigue I wanted from the mystery while somehow maintaining this wonderfully cozy, mystic atmosphere.
The audiobook was also fantastic. The narration fit the tone of the story beautifully and made an already addictive mystery even easier to get completely lost in.
No notes. ❤️ If there ever happens to be a sequel or another story set in this world, I’m fully on board and would return immediately.
Thank you to Macmillan Audio and NetGalley for providing me with an advanced listening copy in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Drew inherited her aunt’s Mystic shop… and it’s not going well. Twenty years ago, a local girl went missing, and Drew’s aunt, a Mystic in her own right, attempted to help. The mystery has remained unsolved ever since, and much of the town has neither forgotten nor let go of the fact that her aunt failed to assist the investigation, ruining her reputation as a psychic in the process.
Then an old classmate, Nick, shows up. He’s reopening the investigation on his own and hopes that Drew, and her aunt’s journals, may be able to help. This is where the story really takes off.
The vibes of this book were so unique. The explanations of tarot, for example, could have easily felt dragged out or boring rather than informative, but they never did. I was entranced by every little detail and every glimmer of witchy goodness woven throughout the story.
The characters also meshed incredibly well. The balance between Nick and Drew’s personalities and their friendship was so entertaining. One is a thirty-something Mystic who is still figuring her life out, while the other is a well-put-together, very successful reporter who seems to have all his ducks in a row. George and Gigi were also notable side characters, and I thoroughly enjoyed what they added to the story.
Honestly, I wasn’t sure if something could qualify as a cozy mystery when there’s a possible murder, or, at the very least, a missing girl, but that’s exactly what this felt like. 😂 It had all of the intrigue I wanted from the mystery while somehow maintaining this wonderfully cozy, mystic atmosphere.
The audiobook was also fantastic. The narration fit the tone of the story beautifully and made an already addictive mystery even easier to get completely lost in.
No notes. ❤️ If there ever happens to be a sequel or another story set in this world, I’m fully on board and would return immediately.
Thank you to Macmillan Audio and NetGalley for providing me with an advanced listening copy in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
As someone who loves tarot and all things witchy, "The Mystic and the Missing Girl" immediately felt like a book written for readers like me.
I absolutely loved the cozy atmosphere. The inherited metaphysical shop was one of my favorite parts of the story, especially after the main character made it her own. It became one of those fictional places I wished actually existed because I'd happily spend an afternoon wandering the shelves.
What really stood out to me was how tarot was incorporated into the story. It never felt like it was there just for aesthetics. The readings and card meanings were woven naturally into the plot, and I actually found myself learning along the way. As someone who practices tarot myself, the interpretations felt thoughtful and authentic, which made the story even more immersive.
I also really liked the main character. She was intelligent, capable, and confident, but she was still figuring out her psychic abilities instead of magically knowing everything from the start. Her growth felt believable. Gigi was such a fun best friend, Nick was a great addition, and I'd happily read another mystery with this cast.
The mystery kept me guessing. Looking back, there were clues I probably should have picked up on, but I was so invested in the story that I didn't put everything together until the reveal. That's always a win for me.
One aspect I wasn't expecting was how much the relationship between the protagonist and her mother resonated with me. Their conversations about religion and boundaries hit close to home and added an emotional layer that made the story feel even more grounded.
I'm usually drawn to fantasy with expansive worlds and complex magic systems, and sometimes cozy fantasy leaves me wanting a little more. This book was the exception. Instead of relying on grand magical lore, it created something comforting and familiar. The magic felt like it belonged in our world, and that made it incredibly easy to sink into.
If you're looking for a cozy autumn read filled with tarot, psychic abilities, a charming metaphysical shop, and a mystery that keeps you turning the pages, I'd definitely recommend this one. I genuinely hope this becomes a series because I'd love to spend more time with these characters.
I absolutely loved the cozy atmosphere. The inherited metaphysical shop was one of my favorite parts of the story, especially after the main character made it her own. It became one of those fictional places I wished actually existed because I'd happily spend an afternoon wandering the shelves.
What really stood out to me was how tarot was incorporated into the story. It never felt like it was there just for aesthetics. The readings and card meanings were woven naturally into the plot, and I actually found myself learning along the way. As someone who practices tarot myself, the interpretations felt thoughtful and authentic, which made the story even more immersive.
I also really liked the main character. She was intelligent, capable, and confident, but she was still figuring out her psychic abilities instead of magically knowing everything from the start. Her growth felt believable. Gigi was such a fun best friend, Nick was a great addition, and I'd happily read another mystery with this cast.
The mystery kept me guessing. Looking back, there were clues I probably should have picked up on, but I was so invested in the story that I didn't put everything together until the reveal. That's always a win for me.
One aspect I wasn't expecting was how much the relationship between the protagonist and her mother resonated with me. Their conversations about religion and boundaries hit close to home and added an emotional layer that made the story feel even more grounded.
I'm usually drawn to fantasy with expansive worlds and complex magic systems, and sometimes cozy fantasy leaves me wanting a little more. This book was the exception. Instead of relying on grand magical lore, it created something comforting and familiar. The magic felt like it belonged in our world, and that made it incredibly easy to sink into.
If you're looking for a cozy autumn read filled with tarot, psychic abilities, a charming metaphysical shop, and a mystery that keeps you turning the pages, I'd definitely recommend this one. I genuinely hope this becomes a series because I'd love to spend more time with these characters.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for an ARC of The Mystic and the Missing Girl by Vikki VanSickle.
Drew Benson is the niece of famed (and perhaps infamous) Hannah “Mystic” Benson. Hannah was intimately involved in trying to solve the disappearance of Ginny, a teenage girl, 20 years ago, and when her insights only led to dead ends, the press, and the community, turned against her. Present day Drew has just inherited Hannah’s Good Vibrations store (specializing in tarot, crystals, and the metaphysical) and begins to reconnect with her own psychic powers. When Nick (who Drew knows from school and is now a journalist), reaches out to her about writing a story regarding Ginny’s disappearance and Hannah’s involvement, Drew goes on a hunt through Hannah’s old journals. A new discovery there flings Drew directly into the middle of the current mystery. Can she tune into her psychic powers for good, without becoming alienated from her community like her aunt?
GIVE ME MORE OF WHERE THIS CAME FROM! I have zero complaints about this book, and only wonderful things to say. Writing? Great. Character development? Lovely. Story? Awesome. History will reveal I love a good mystery, but I am also a lover of the spiritual, of tarot, and of intuition. VanSickle was excellent at mixing every important part of a book together here, while also including some unique and fun elements I also loved. I am obsessed. I need her to write more. I felt emotionally, mentally, and physically connected to this book. I feel like the end COULD indicate a series with Drew and Nick so I’m just going to advocate for that here. And either way, VanSickle needs to write more!!! She’s making me pull out my tarot cards again. Sick in the best interpretation of the word. I know this sounds dramatic, but you must read this! Caveat that it would be helpful if you’re into spiritual mysteries (is that even a category? it should be) but regardless, the writing, character development, and pacing is still wonderful so I think you should read it anyway. Highly highly recommend. I will buy this when it comes out.
Drew Benson is the niece of famed (and perhaps infamous) Hannah “Mystic” Benson. Hannah was intimately involved in trying to solve the disappearance of Ginny, a teenage girl, 20 years ago, and when her insights only led to dead ends, the press, and the community, turned against her. Present day Drew has just inherited Hannah’s Good Vibrations store (specializing in tarot, crystals, and the metaphysical) and begins to reconnect with her own psychic powers. When Nick (who Drew knows from school and is now a journalist), reaches out to her about writing a story regarding Ginny’s disappearance and Hannah’s involvement, Drew goes on a hunt through Hannah’s old journals. A new discovery there flings Drew directly into the middle of the current mystery. Can she tune into her psychic powers for good, without becoming alienated from her community like her aunt?
GIVE ME MORE OF WHERE THIS CAME FROM! I have zero complaints about this book, and only wonderful things to say. Writing? Great. Character development? Lovely. Story? Awesome. History will reveal I love a good mystery, but I am also a lover of the spiritual, of tarot, and of intuition. VanSickle was excellent at mixing every important part of a book together here, while also including some unique and fun elements I also loved. I am obsessed. I need her to write more. I felt emotionally, mentally, and physically connected to this book. I feel like the end COULD indicate a series with Drew and Nick so I’m just going to advocate for that here. And either way, VanSickle needs to write more!!! She’s making me pull out my tarot cards again. Sick in the best interpretation of the word. I know this sounds dramatic, but you must read this! Caveat that it would be helpful if you’re into spiritual mysteries (is that even a category? it should be) but regardless, the writing, character development, and pacing is still wonderful so I think you should read it anyway. Highly highly recommend. I will buy this when it comes out.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to NetGalley and to St. Martin's Press for the ARC of The Mystic and the Missing Girl
This is a cute and cozy debut - perfect for millennials, and a fun blend of mysticism and mystery. It reminded me a bit of Lina Chern's Play the Fool series and Cherie Priest's Booking Agent series.
I do feel the book description is a bit off or a big of an exaggeration - The Mystic and the Missing Girl follows Drew Benson, a 32 year old woman who has moved back home to take over her recently deceased aunt's failing mystic shop. Drew doesn't really know what she wants from her own life, and is torn between her own dreams, her mother's expectations, and the general malaise when you find yourself in your 30s and half your friends have kids and new lives and the other half haven't matured - she's unmoored, lonely, and a bit helpless on next steps. When her former high school chemistry lab partner, now a reporter, comes to her asking about an old cold case her aunt was consulted on that led to a lot of trauma and a continuing mystery, Drew realizes her aunt left a journal that pushes Drew into action. From here the mystery develops and grows, providing twists and turns as Drew digs into the past and into her forgotten gift of reading objects for memories, while also trying to figure out who she wants to become, who her friends are, what her aunt was trying to tell her, and how to stop falling into bed with a man who is just no good for her.
It's a fun novel - VanSickle brings tarot information out in a way that is understandable and approachable, she makes the small town characters feel nosy and secretive and exasperating, the scenes with all the pastries and coffees from Bev's are always funny, .I think she writes from a place where millennials will really identify with Drew and her friends.
The whodunit did become a bit obvious as the book moved along, but despite that it was still a fun read. If it ends up becoming a series, I would tune in for the next mystery.
This is a cute and cozy debut - perfect for millennials, and a fun blend of mysticism and mystery. It reminded me a bit of Lina Chern's Play the Fool series and Cherie Priest's Booking Agent series.
I do feel the book description is a bit off or a big of an exaggeration - The Mystic and the Missing Girl follows Drew Benson, a 32 year old woman who has moved back home to take over her recently deceased aunt's failing mystic shop. Drew doesn't really know what she wants from her own life, and is torn between her own dreams, her mother's expectations, and the general malaise when you find yourself in your 30s and half your friends have kids and new lives and the other half haven't matured - she's unmoored, lonely, and a bit helpless on next steps. When her former high school chemistry lab partner, now a reporter, comes to her asking about an old cold case her aunt was consulted on that led to a lot of trauma and a continuing mystery, Drew realizes her aunt left a journal that pushes Drew into action. From here the mystery develops and grows, providing twists and turns as Drew digs into the past and into her forgotten gift of reading objects for memories, while also trying to figure out who she wants to become, who her friends are, what her aunt was trying to tell her, and how to stop falling into bed with a man who is just no good for her.
It's a fun novel - VanSickle brings tarot information out in a way that is understandable and approachable, she makes the small town characters feel nosy and secretive and exasperating, the scenes with all the pastries and coffees from Bev's are always funny, .I think she writes from a place where millennials will really identify with Drew and her friends.
The whodunit did become a bit obvious as the book moved along, but despite that it was still a fun read. If it ends up becoming a series, I would tune in for the next mystery.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
BOOK REPORT
Received a complimentary copy of The Mystic and the Missing Girl, by Vikki VanSickle, from St. Martin's Press | Minotaur Books/NetGalley, for which I am appreciative, in exchange for a fair and honest review. Scroll past the BOOK REPORT section for a cut-and-paste of the DESCRIPTION of it from them if you want to read my thoughts on the book in the context of that summary.
⭐ 3 ⭐
Good comfort food.
Read like the beginning of a series…..I hope this is the case, as I would’ve happily read a few more in a row if such imaginary books were, like, you know. Real. And published.
DESCRIPTION
Small town secrets, a reluctant psychic, and a cold case that could expose them all.
Drew Benson can read tarot cards and get impressions from objects—she just never expected to use her gifts to investigate an infamous cold case.
Drew Benson has a secret. She gets visions, something she hasn’t tapped into since she was a teenager, when her late aunt, a TV psychic known as Hannah Mystic, became the scapegoat in the unsolved disappearance of a local teenager. Twenty years later, Drew is happy to ignore her gift, focusing instead on keeping the metaphysical shop she inherited from Hannah afloat, wrangling her sole, astrology-obsessed employee, and dodging local rake Foster Banks in her picturesque lakeside hometown.
But when Drew's arch-nemesis from high school, now a big city reporter, decides to investigate the cold case from all those years ago, it’s Drew’s ability that could finally make a break in the decades old mystery. With bills piling up, a disapproving mother laying on the guilt, and a local vandal who wants Drew and her witchy store gone, Drew has a lot to lose. But what she stands to gain—finding out what happened to the missing teen, clearing her aunt’s name, and a second chance at belonging—could change everything.
In The Mystic and the Missing Girl, Vikki VanSickle seamlessly draws readers into an utterly charming world in this unputdownable, small town mystery.
Received a complimentary copy of The Mystic and the Missing Girl, by Vikki VanSickle, from St. Martin's Press | Minotaur Books/NetGalley, for which I am appreciative, in exchange for a fair and honest review. Scroll past the BOOK REPORT section for a cut-and-paste of the DESCRIPTION of it from them if you want to read my thoughts on the book in the context of that summary.
⭐ 3 ⭐
Good comfort food.
Read like the beginning of a series…..I hope this is the case, as I would’ve happily read a few more in a row if such imaginary books were, like, you know. Real. And published.
DESCRIPTION
Small town secrets, a reluctant psychic, and a cold case that could expose them all.
Drew Benson can read tarot cards and get impressions from objects—she just never expected to use her gifts to investigate an infamous cold case.
Drew Benson has a secret. She gets visions, something she hasn’t tapped into since she was a teenager, when her late aunt, a TV psychic known as Hannah Mystic, became the scapegoat in the unsolved disappearance of a local teenager. Twenty years later, Drew is happy to ignore her gift, focusing instead on keeping the metaphysical shop she inherited from Hannah afloat, wrangling her sole, astrology-obsessed employee, and dodging local rake Foster Banks in her picturesque lakeside hometown.
But when Drew's arch-nemesis from high school, now a big city reporter, decides to investigate the cold case from all those years ago, it’s Drew’s ability that could finally make a break in the decades old mystery. With bills piling up, a disapproving mother laying on the guilt, and a local vandal who wants Drew and her witchy store gone, Drew has a lot to lose. But what she stands to gain—finding out what happened to the missing teen, clearing her aunt’s name, and a second chance at belonging—could change everything.
In The Mystic and the Missing Girl, Vikki VanSickle seamlessly draws readers into an utterly charming world in this unputdownable, small town mystery.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Wait to read this one when the weather is cool, leaves have changed and are readying themselves to fall from the trees because this one is the PERFECT fall read!
It follows Drew Benson, former corporate lackey who has returned to her small hometown after the death of her beloved aunt. Bequeathed the store her aunt once loved, Drew finds herself in the position to keep it open...but is struggling financially to do so. When she is, for lack of a better word, called to assist in the investigation of a teenage girl who had gone missing more than 20 years before, she initially hesitates. But when she finds herself connected to the missing in unknown ways, Drew has no choice but to let the cards to do the work for her.
I absolutely loved Drew's character: she is like any other woman in her 30s who is struggling with her life, both professionally and romantically. The only daughter of well-to-do parents, she wants nothing more than to make them proud, while simultaneously keeping the memory of her beloved aunt alive through the metaphysical store she had inherited. Drew isn't complex, by any means. She tells you like it is, and doesn't have any regrets about it. She is the perfect MFC I've come across in a long while, especially in a debut novel.
Our side characters are just as intriguing. We have Drew's enigmatic best friend, the former chemistry lab partner turned partner in "crime", the faithful store employee who relies on Drew in more ways than just financially, along with several others who truly bring the story together.
If you are a fan of Practical Magic, Charmed or any of the other beloved witchy shows and movies from the 90s, this one is definitely something you should pick up. September is the perfect release month for this!
Thank you to Vikki VanSickle, Netgalley and St. Martin's/Minotaur publishing for entrusting me with this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
It follows Drew Benson, former corporate lackey who has returned to her small hometown after the death of her beloved aunt. Bequeathed the store her aunt once loved, Drew finds herself in the position to keep it open...but is struggling financially to do so. When she is, for lack of a better word, called to assist in the investigation of a teenage girl who had gone missing more than 20 years before, she initially hesitates. But when she finds herself connected to the missing in unknown ways, Drew has no choice but to let the cards to do the work for her.
I absolutely loved Drew's character: she is like any other woman in her 30s who is struggling with her life, both professionally and romantically. The only daughter of well-to-do parents, she wants nothing more than to make them proud, while simultaneously keeping the memory of her beloved aunt alive through the metaphysical store she had inherited. Drew isn't complex, by any means. She tells you like it is, and doesn't have any regrets about it. She is the perfect MFC I've come across in a long while, especially in a debut novel.
Our side characters are just as intriguing. We have Drew's enigmatic best friend, the former chemistry lab partner turned partner in "crime", the faithful store employee who relies on Drew in more ways than just financially, along with several others who truly bring the story together.
If you are a fan of Practical Magic, Charmed or any of the other beloved witchy shows and movies from the 90s, this one is definitely something you should pick up. September is the perfect release month for this!
Thank you to Vikki VanSickle, Netgalley and St. Martin's/Minotaur publishing for entrusting me with this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
August 26, 2026
Cozy, magical, and so refreshing to read.
As someone who has my very own set of tarot cards, have gotten a few readings, and have attended full moon circles with the girlies, I finished this in two days. If you’re looking for a good pallet cleanser during a seasonal change, this is it.
I loved everything about this. The characters were likable and the author was very intentional about introducing a new character at the right time, with the prefect amount of background. Each character had their own layers that were slowly being peeled away as the story unfolded. Even in such a short book, she found the perfect way to introduce new characters without it being overwhelming to the reader. I truly believe she added her own kind of magic when writing this thing because each character felt like a real human. *If she was real, Drew and I could actually be friends and I love that for me.*
In addition to the characters as individuals, it was SO incredibly refreshing to read a story with platonic friendships. Even though there was a romantic connection between Drew and another character, it wasn’t just there for romance. It added depth without taking away from the story. Their banter was great and ultimately helped Drew grow into her own version of herself, which I found to be far more satisfying.
Now, the STORY itself was [again] very intentional. With some astrology, the supernatural, and store cats, what more do you need in a cozy seasonal read!? I had so much fun imagining me and my friends running around a cozy autumn town, following a lead, and discovering something new. I was on the edge of my seat at times and making my own predictions throughout the whole story. The supernatural aspect of it all was also such a joy to read, adding some unpredictability and suspense, too.
I cannot wait to get my hands on a physical copy of this book. If you’re looking for an easy read during the transition into fall, I would highly recommend.
As someone who has my very own set of tarot cards, have gotten a few readings, and have attended full moon circles with the girlies, I finished this in two days. If you’re looking for a good pallet cleanser during a seasonal change, this is it.
I loved everything about this. The characters were likable and the author was very intentional about introducing a new character at the right time, with the prefect amount of background. Each character had their own layers that were slowly being peeled away as the story unfolded. Even in such a short book, she found the perfect way to introduce new characters without it being overwhelming to the reader. I truly believe she added her own kind of magic when writing this thing because each character felt like a real human. *If she was real, Drew and I could actually be friends and I love that for me.*
In addition to the characters as individuals, it was SO incredibly refreshing to read a story with platonic friendships. Even though there was a romantic connection between Drew and another character, it wasn’t just there for romance. It added depth without taking away from the story. Their banter was great and ultimately helped Drew grow into her own version of herself, which I found to be far more satisfying.
Now, the STORY itself was [again] very intentional. With some astrology, the supernatural, and store cats, what more do you need in a cozy seasonal read!? I had so much fun imagining me and my friends running around a cozy autumn town, following a lead, and discovering something new. I was on the edge of my seat at times and making my own predictions throughout the whole story. The supernatural aspect of it all was also such a joy to read, adding some unpredictability and suspense, too.
I cannot wait to get my hands on a physical copy of this book. If you’re looking for an easy read during the transition into fall, I would highly recommend.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
4⭐️ The Mystic and The Missing Girl by Vikki VanSickle
Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!
This was such a cozy, atmospheric mystery with the perfect touch of fall magic woven throughout. Between the metaphysical shop setting, tarot readings, small-town secrets, and a decades-old missing persons case, this book completely pulled me in.
After inheriting her late Aunt Hannah’s mystical shop, Drew Benson is already struggling to keep the business afloat when a missing girl case from twenty years ago is suddenly reopened. Hannah had once been involved in the investigation as a psychic, and as Drew starts uncovering her aunt’s old notes, she realizes the case may be tied to her in ways she never expected.
One of my favorite things about this book was the vibe. It feels tailor-made for crisp autumn nights with a candle burning nearby. The tarot and psychic elements added such a fun layer to the mystery without ever becoming overwhelming, and even if you know nothing about tarot, the story makes it approachable and easy to follow.
The mystery itself unfolded at a steady pace, slowly revealing pieces alongside Drew, and I genuinely did not see the twist coming. The emotional truth behind Ginny’s disappearance hit harder than I expected, and the ending left me thinking about how differently things could have turned out.
Drew was easy to root for, and I really enjoyed the quirky cast of side characters and the cozy small-town atmosphere surrounding the shop. This felt less like an intense thriller and more like the kind of comforting mystery you sink into over a weekend.
If you love cozy mysteries with witchy vibes, tarot cards, psychic abilities, and small-town secrets, definitely add this one to your fall reading list.
Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!
This was such a cozy, atmospheric mystery with the perfect touch of fall magic woven throughout. Between the metaphysical shop setting, tarot readings, small-town secrets, and a decades-old missing persons case, this book completely pulled me in.
After inheriting her late Aunt Hannah’s mystical shop, Drew Benson is already struggling to keep the business afloat when a missing girl case from twenty years ago is suddenly reopened. Hannah had once been involved in the investigation as a psychic, and as Drew starts uncovering her aunt’s old notes, she realizes the case may be tied to her in ways she never expected.
One of my favorite things about this book was the vibe. It feels tailor-made for crisp autumn nights with a candle burning nearby. The tarot and psychic elements added such a fun layer to the mystery without ever becoming overwhelming, and even if you know nothing about tarot, the story makes it approachable and easy to follow.
The mystery itself unfolded at a steady pace, slowly revealing pieces alongside Drew, and I genuinely did not see the twist coming. The emotional truth behind Ginny’s disappearance hit harder than I expected, and the ending left me thinking about how differently things could have turned out.
Drew was easy to root for, and I really enjoyed the quirky cast of side characters and the cozy small-town atmosphere surrounding the shop. This felt less like an intense thriller and more like the kind of comforting mystery you sink into over a weekend.
If you love cozy mysteries with witchy vibes, tarot cards, psychic abilities, and small-town secrets, definitely add this one to your fall reading list.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to Penguin Random House Canada and Macmillan Audio for the ARC & ALC of The Mystic and the Missing Girl
4.5 ⭐️
Twenty years ago, a teenager went missing in a small town and a psychic known as Hannah Mystic became the scapegoat. With no body, witnesses, or evidence, the disappearance remained unsolved. Now, Drew Benson finds herself determined to solve the mystery alongside her old schoolmate who is now an investigative journal. Drew inherited her late aunt Hannah’s physic abilities along with her metaphysical shop, and in her journey restarting in her hometown, she must solve the mystery for justice, to clear her aunts name, and to feel a sense of belonging in the town that judged mystic / physic abilities so harshly.
This was an interesting read for me! I went in (more or less) blind, and found myself immersed in a charming small town with multidimensional characters and a touch whimsy. The mystic element was unique for me and I enjoyed way the author explained everything. The overall mystery was well done, keeping you guessing throughout - it’s also a true mystery in that you’re learning things along with the characters, guessing based on the information you have rather than crazy twists for shock value which I appreciated. The pacing is well done, Drew is a tenacious and fun FMC making her easy to root for, the side characters and relationships are wonderful, and I really enjoyed the writing - it has a strong voice and is really well suited to the unique vibe of the story. Love that it’s a Canadian author!!
I alternated between the ebook and audiobook for this one, and both are great! Narrated by Veronica Hortiguela, the audio is so well suited to the tone of the novel, she does a great job bringing the characters to life with great emotional inflection, clear speech, and unique character voices making it easy to follow along!
4.5 ⭐️
Twenty years ago, a teenager went missing in a small town and a psychic known as Hannah Mystic became the scapegoat. With no body, witnesses, or evidence, the disappearance remained unsolved. Now, Drew Benson finds herself determined to solve the mystery alongside her old schoolmate who is now an investigative journal. Drew inherited her late aunt Hannah’s physic abilities along with her metaphysical shop, and in her journey restarting in her hometown, she must solve the mystery for justice, to clear her aunts name, and to feel a sense of belonging in the town that judged mystic / physic abilities so harshly.
This was an interesting read for me! I went in (more or less) blind, and found myself immersed in a charming small town with multidimensional characters and a touch whimsy. The mystic element was unique for me and I enjoyed way the author explained everything. The overall mystery was well done, keeping you guessing throughout - it’s also a true mystery in that you’re learning things along with the characters, guessing based on the information you have rather than crazy twists for shock value which I appreciated. The pacing is well done, Drew is a tenacious and fun FMC making her easy to root for, the side characters and relationships are wonderful, and I really enjoyed the writing - it has a strong voice and is really well suited to the unique vibe of the story. Love that it’s a Canadian author!!
I alternated between the ebook and audiobook for this one, and both are great! Narrated by Veronica Hortiguela, the audio is so well suited to the tone of the novel, she does a great job bringing the characters to life with great emotional inflection, clear speech, and unique character voices making it easy to follow along!
August 10, 2026
I received an ARC of this book through a Goodreads giveaway. Thank you to Minotaur Books for giving me a chance to read this book in advance of its release. The following is my honest review.
This was a fun read that checked so many boxes for me. I've actually been looking for media with tarot themes/motifs because I've always found them interesting so when I saw the giveaway for this book I had to sign up. I'm right between Drew and Ginny in age, so I connected with both their middle and high school experiences as described in flashbacks, but also where Drew and those around her are in their lives now. All of the struggles the characters were working through were so grounded and I could feel their anxiety, exhaustion, and even hope myself every step of the way.
The mystery aspect was good. Even when a character introduction sent up a red flag and there were many clues along the way, each of the suspects presented seemed just as possible and I was left questioning how sure I was of anything until the last 50 pages when it all starts to come together.
The books moves at a nice brisk pace and made me want to keep reading much later into the night than I should. The one issue was with the ending which suffers from 'Return of the King' syndrome. There were four or five vignettes at the end which each could have served as a satisfying conclusion to the novel, but in order to make sure none of the story threads were left hanging we had to go through all of them to tie them up. Each one independently was sweet and well done, but having them all back to back made it feel like the party guests were overstaying their welcome.
All in all VanSickle has created a great cast of characters in a charming town and I hope that there really are more adventures for Drew and Nick in the cards.
This was a fun read that checked so many boxes for me. I've actually been looking for media with tarot themes/motifs because I've always found them interesting so when I saw the giveaway for this book I had to sign up. I'm right between Drew and Ginny in age, so I connected with both their middle and high school experiences as described in flashbacks, but also where Drew and those around her are in their lives now. All of the struggles the characters were working through were so grounded and I could feel their anxiety, exhaustion, and even hope myself every step of the way.
The mystery aspect was good. Even when a character introduction sent up a red flag and there were many clues along the way, each of the suspects presented seemed just as possible and I was left questioning how sure I was of anything until the last 50 pages when it all starts to come together.
The books moves at a nice brisk pace and made me want to keep reading much later into the night than I should. The one issue was with the ending which suffers from 'Return of the King' syndrome. There were four or five vignettes at the end which each could have served as a satisfying conclusion to the novel, but in order to make sure none of the story threads were left hanging we had to go through all of them to tie them up. Each one independently was sweet and well done, but having them all back to back made it feel like the party guests were overstaying their welcome.
All in all VanSickle has created a great cast of characters in a charming town and I hope that there really are more adventures for Drew and Nick in the cards.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I’m not sure I believe in psychic phenomena, but a part of me really wants to. That’s what pulled me into this book.
Drew Benson, the protagonist, has psychic abilities, but she tamps them down. She realizes many folks think psychics are just kooky frauds, and she’s seen what happened to Hannah, her favorite aunt, who tried to use her second sight to find a missing teenager years ago. All she got for it was grief and ridicule. When Hannah dies, she leaves her mystic store to Drew, who gets pulled into the same mystery. She joins forces with an old classmate, now a reporter, to use her own abilities and her aunt’s journal to find the answers that have so far eluded everyone else.
I don’t pick up many cozies, but I’m glad I listened to this one. The plot unfolds a little slowly, but not sluggishly. Tensions are mild and revelations are few until Drew experiences the “glimmers’ that point her to the clues that solve the case. I enjoy complex thrillers, but every now and then I like one like this that doesn’t leave me wrung out from constant danger and cascading crises. I also enjoy a book that teaches me a little something, in this case a bit about tarot. And any book with a cute cat in it gets an automatic thumbs up from me.
The narrator does a good job of subtly differentiating most of the characters, and does a particularly good job with Drew. I was a bit chagrined at how she made an older woman sound so stereotypically weak with a raspy, feeble voice that lots of readers use but no people I know have. Minor gripe about what is otherwise a good performance.
I’m no psychic, but I’m astute enough to recognize an entertaining book when I find it. It didn’t keep me up listening all night, but it was fun enough to leave me hoping for a second installment.
Thanks to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for a review recording of this book.
Drew Benson, the protagonist, has psychic abilities, but she tamps them down. She realizes many folks think psychics are just kooky frauds, and she’s seen what happened to Hannah, her favorite aunt, who tried to use her second sight to find a missing teenager years ago. All she got for it was grief and ridicule. When Hannah dies, she leaves her mystic store to Drew, who gets pulled into the same mystery. She joins forces with an old classmate, now a reporter, to use her own abilities and her aunt’s journal to find the answers that have so far eluded everyone else.
I don’t pick up many cozies, but I’m glad I listened to this one. The plot unfolds a little slowly, but not sluggishly. Tensions are mild and revelations are few until Drew experiences the “glimmers’ that point her to the clues that solve the case. I enjoy complex thrillers, but every now and then I like one like this that doesn’t leave me wrung out from constant danger and cascading crises. I also enjoy a book that teaches me a little something, in this case a bit about tarot. And any book with a cute cat in it gets an automatic thumbs up from me.
The narrator does a good job of subtly differentiating most of the characters, and does a particularly good job with Drew. I was a bit chagrined at how she made an older woman sound so stereotypically weak with a raspy, feeble voice that lots of readers use but no people I know have. Minor gripe about what is otherwise a good performance.
I’m no psychic, but I’m astute enough to recognize an entertaining book when I find it. It didn’t keep me up listening all night, but it was fun enough to leave me hoping for a second installment.
Thanks to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for a review recording of this book.
June 9, 2026
A fusion of mystery and mysticism was something I hoped would be right up my alley and I was right! The Mystic and the missing girl was a cozy mystery where, in the small town of Stanfield, a 17-year-old girl went missing 20 years ago. At that time, the local Mystic did her best to help but the visions/clues she saw did not leave the answers. Now, that Mystic has unfortunately passed but her niece has returned to town and gets drawn into the investigation by an old classmate.
There’s a lot to love about this book. The way the mysticism and witchy components feel natural rather than over the top, it really does justice to those practices. I really loved the queer representation, as well as diversity in race and culture. I think we really got to know not just Drew but the entire ensemble, and they each played such an important an interesting part. Even some of the suspects turned friends really grew on me and sort of made me emotional? And yes, I was crying at the end during the celebration of remembrance and as drew gained a sort of closure amongst more than one relationship.
I don’t really have a lot negative to say, other than I’ve read enough mysteries to suspect who was central to the mystery. However, the plot and revelation was shared in a way that still felt fresh and entertaining, even though I had a hunch. Sometimes when you imagine what’s coming, the plot falls flat which did not happen at all with this book.
Anyway, if you are in the mood for a cozy mystical mystery book, PLEASE check out this story!!!
Thank you so very much to Vicky VanSickle and her publisher and NetGalley for an advanced reader copy of this book… this access does not change my review/opinion.
There’s a lot to love about this book. The way the mysticism and witchy components feel natural rather than over the top, it really does justice to those practices. I really loved the queer representation, as well as diversity in race and culture. I think we really got to know not just Drew but the entire ensemble, and they each played such an important an interesting part. Even some of the suspects turned friends really grew on me and sort of made me emotional? And yes, I was crying at the end during the celebration of remembrance and as drew gained a sort of closure amongst more than one relationship.
I don’t really have a lot negative to say, other than I’ve read enough mysteries to suspect who was central to the mystery. However, the plot and revelation was shared in a way that still felt fresh and entertaining, even though I had a hunch. Sometimes when you imagine what’s coming, the plot falls flat which did not happen at all with this book.
Anyway, if you are in the mood for a cozy mystical mystery book, PLEASE check out this story!!!
Thank you so very much to Vicky VanSickle and her publisher and NetGalley for an advanced reader copy of this book… this access does not change my review/opinion.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
The Mystic and the Missing Girl follows a reluctant psychic living in a quiet lakeside town who becomes entangled in the decades-old disappearance of a teenage girl. Blending cozy mystery, paranormal elements, and emotional family drama, the story focuses just as much on grief, reputation, and belonging as it does on uncovering the truth behind the case itself.
What completely won me over was VanSickle’s immersive lakeside atmosphere, emotionally layered mystery, and wonderfully grounded heroine. One thing that really sets this apart from many paranormal cozies is how restrained the supernatural elements feel. Drew’s psychic abilities never come across as overpowered or gimmicky. Instead, the visions, tarot readings, and subtle impressions deepen the mystery without simply handing over the answers, which keeps the investigation compelling and believable.
I also thought the mystery itself was genuinely well constructed. There were enough suspects, secrets, and twists to keep me guessing without the resolution feeling random or overly dramatic. The ending delivered both an emotional payoff and a satisfying reveal.
The middle section does slow somewhat under the weight of the town’s history and interpersonal conflicts, though the gentler pacing ultimately adds to the immersive cozy atmosphere, so it mostly worked for me.
Overall, The Mystic and the Missing Girl is less of a high-stakes thriller and more of a witchy, emotionally driven mystery filled with cozy vibes and sharp emotional undercurrents. Readers looking for atmosphere, heart, and a touch of the paranormal will likely find a lot to love here.
What completely won me over was VanSickle’s immersive lakeside atmosphere, emotionally layered mystery, and wonderfully grounded heroine. One thing that really sets this apart from many paranormal cozies is how restrained the supernatural elements feel. Drew’s psychic abilities never come across as overpowered or gimmicky. Instead, the visions, tarot readings, and subtle impressions deepen the mystery without simply handing over the answers, which keeps the investigation compelling and believable.
I also thought the mystery itself was genuinely well constructed. There were enough suspects, secrets, and twists to keep me guessing without the resolution feeling random or overly dramatic. The ending delivered both an emotional payoff and a satisfying reveal.
The middle section does slow somewhat under the weight of the town’s history and interpersonal conflicts, though the gentler pacing ultimately adds to the immersive cozy atmosphere, so it mostly worked for me.
Overall, The Mystic and the Missing Girl is less of a high-stakes thriller and more of a witchy, emotionally driven mystery filled with cozy vibes and sharp emotional undercurrents. Readers looking for atmosphere, heart, and a touch of the paranormal will likely find a lot to love here.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 223 reviews