Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Sugar and Spice Bookshop Bakery: the perfect small-town cosy romance to curl up with this autumn

Rate this book
Louise Dearnley has spent her life editing perfectly neat love stories, where heartbreak leads to fresh starts, charming small businesses bloom, and happily-ever-afters are guaranteed.

But now in her forties, she's quit her job – and no, she doesn't want to talk about why – and returned home to Applethwaite, the small Yorkshire village where she grew up. Starting over doesn't feel nearly so much fun in real life as it does in fiction.

It also doesn't help that her mother is convinced she's here to run the family bakery, especially as the locals can't get enough of Louise's legendary ginger cake and scrumptious scones. Between renovations, a quirky ex-stepdaughter (who's unexpectedly come to stay) and a gorgeous Italian who seems too good to be true, Louise's second chance begins to take shape.

After a lifetime spent polishing other people's happy endings, will Louise finally have one of her own?

352 pages, Paperback

Published October 8, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Jennifer Page

30 books11 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
72 (20%)
4 stars
142 (40%)
3 stars
107 (30%)
2 stars
27 (7%)
1 star
2 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 202 reviews
Profile Image for holly &#x1f5a4;.
72 reviews3 followers
September 27, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and the author for the ALC

3 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️


I really wanted to love The Sugar and Spice Bookshop Bakery because I thought the premise was so cute, but unfortunately I just didn't connect with Louise. I found myself liking Maddie much more, and honestly, she was probably my favourite character throughout the book! I also didn't really feel the chemistry between Louise and Jack as strongly as I would have liked, so their relationship didn't quite pull me into the story in the way I was hoping it would. I think a lot of my enjoyment of a romance comes down to how much I connect with the characters, and because I struggled with Louise, I never quite felt completely invested in the story.

That being said, there were definitely parts that I really enjoyed. I particularly loved the redemption arc for Louise's old teacher, which completely surprised me because I didn't expect that storyline to affect me so much. There were actually moments where I found myself welling up a little, and I thought that was such a lovely and emotional part of the book. I also really liked the overall premise and there was plenty here that I found enjoyable, even if the book as a whole wasn't quite my usual cup of tea. So while I wouldn't say this was a new favourite for me, I did enjoy the experience and I'm glad I picked it up. Sometimes you can enjoy a book even when you know it's just not quite your kind of book, and that's definitely how I felt about this one.
Profile Image for Axellesbooks.
958 reviews161 followers
August 12, 2026
In this small town cosy romance, we follow Louise Dearnley who quit her job as editor and decides to run the family bakery. She returns to Applethwaite, the small town where she grew up. Her mother wants her to run the bakery, but Louise wants another concept. Oh, and there's a gorgeous Italian man who seems really interesting...

First of all, the writing style was really smooth. It really makes the story cosy and easy to read. If I could visit this bookshop bakery, I would definitely go there! The author really did a great job on making this visual.

For the characters and their relationships, I especially liked reading about Louise and her ex-stepdaughter Maddie. It just shows that even when things end, you can still have normal relationships with people who were sort of involved. I also liked that even if Louise is in her forties, she still able to start over again. Louise and Jack: it was nice to read about them getting closer and closer. But, I don't think it was really my kind of romance. It's just a preference thing.

Overall, I liked reading this book and would highly recommend it if you're into small town cosy romance books! It was a nice and fun read, but I wasn't totally blown away with the chemistry. I would want to read more of this author though because I loved the writing style! 3,5 stars!

Thank you Netgalley for this e-arc!
Profile Image for Emma (ejm_reads).
239 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
September 20, 2026

3.5 stars

After reading The Sugar and Spice Bookshop Bakery, my desires to own a cute little bookshop in a quaint English village are at an all time high! This book is the perfect cosy read for a rainy autumnal afternoon, preferably with a slice of cake (ginger or otherwise!).

Louise is back in her small hometown, Applethwaite in Yorkshire, after running away from a mistake she made in her editing job in London. She ends up deciding she will turn her mum’s bakery into a bookshop bakery with the help of handsome stranger Jack and her stepdaughter Maddie. I particularly liked Maddie and Louise’s relationship - the support they had for each other and their ideas was heartwarming and they clearly needed each other to move forward with their lives. I did like Louise and Jack’s relationship although some lines felt a bit cheesy (dot, dot, dot in particular). At times it felt a little repetitive why they couldn’t be together so I was glad when that was finally nipped in the bud!

Louise struggling with her life and not really knowing what to do in her early 40s hit quite close to home at times so it was uplifiting to see her life turn around. She was able to repair some relationships and focus on her new adventure. I’m looking forward to seeing where this series goes!

An easy to read book perfect for fans of:

- Gilmore Girls
- Cosy romance 
- All things bookish
- Sweet treats
- Found family

Thank you to the publisher Head of Zeus for sending me an ARC of this book.
Profile Image for Brittany.
265 reviews
May 13, 2026
Sometimes, the best kind of healing can be done surrounded by pastries and books. As someone who loves both baking and reading, this is something I can relate to with the female lead in this book, Louise.

After a divorce and leaving the job that she desperately loved, Louise feels lost and doesn’t know where to go next. This is how she ends up back in her home town of Applethwaite, where she soon finds herself thrust into the life of bakery owner surrounded by the antics of her caring mother, eager locals, her peppy stepdaughter and the tall, dark and deliciously accented Italian.

From the get-go, this book felt like a Hallmark movie put to page. It was so cozy and the vibes were immaculate all throughout. It left me yearning for my own cup of coffee and to take a stroll through their bookshop, because the space they created sounded so magical and interesting that it made me wish it actually existed somewhere for me to visit.

My major qualm with the book, however, was the relationship between our female and male lead. There were multiple parts where I was left wishing for chemistry, wishing for that tension between the two of them to appear, and it would often get close but it would just be missing something to give it that final little push. Even as a slow burn relationship, there were just points where I think a little extra nudge could have elevated their relationship a little further and helped to sell readers on their connection.

All in all, it was a good read. If you’re a fan of cozy vibes, book-ish topics, and small town antics, I’d recommend picking this one up.

Thank you Netgalley and The Aria & Aries team for an advanced readers copy!
Profile Image for Ritu Bhathal.
Author 5 books159 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 27, 2026
I was looking forward to diving into this after having read Jennifer Page's previous cafe-related series, and I was not disappointed,
Louise, the FMC, has fled London and her prized job as an editor, after making an epic mistake and arrived back in her hometown, Applethwaite, to seek solace in a familiar place, near her mother. Only to find herself back at the bakery her family has run for two generations, and she knows her mother hopes she will continue the business now that she is back.
Poor Louise had a few dilemmas to solve, as well as meeting old and new faces, some more welcome than others. Her ex-stepdaughter, Maddie, also turns up and becomes a genuine support as she tries to decide what she really wants in life.
Then there is Jack, or Giacomo, the gorgeous Italian/Yorkshireman, who is there to support his ailing father.
There is chemistry, along with questions from both of them, as each hides a secret eating at them inside.
I loved how Louise finally followed her dreams and managed to encompass the hopes of her mother with her bookshop bakery, as well as finding happiness in other areas of her life, and I have to say, I would love to visit somewhere like her new business venture!
Profile Image for Elisabete Cunha.
307 reviews11 followers
October 30, 2026
Livrarias, bolos acabados de fazer e uma pequena vila, este livro tem todos os ingredientes para conquistar o meu coração! Uma leitura absolutamente amorosa, fofinha e acolhedora. Daquelas que nos fazem querer preparar uma chávena de chá, aconchegar-nos debaixo de uma manta e esquecer o mundo.
Conhecemos Louise, uma editora de romances que, depois de um episódio complicado na sua vida profissional, decide abandonar Londres e regressar à sua terra natal, Applethwaite, no Yorkshire. De volta à casa da mãe e à padaria da família, Louise vê-se perante uma oportunidade de recomeçar e concretizar um sonho antigo, abrir uma livraria. Mas conciliar livros, bolos, expectativas familiares e os seus próprios desejos nem sempre será tão simples como parece. Pelo caminho, surgem novas amizades, reencontros inesperados e, claro, um certo italiano chamado Giacomo, ou simplesmente Jack.
Adorei a Louise! É uma protagonista amorosa, sobretudo pela sua paixão pelos livros e pela vontade de encontrar o seu próprio caminho. Gostei imenso de acompanhar o seu crescimento, as dúvidas, as inseguranças e, acima de tudo, a coragem de perceber que nunca é tarde para mudar de vida e lutar por aquilo que realmente nos faz felizes.
E a ideia de juntar uma livraria a uma padaria? Absolutamente perfeita um sonho! Adorei acompanhar a transformação do espaço, imaginar os recantos literários, os bolinhos, os scones e o delicioso bolo de gengibre. A autora criou uma atmosfera tão acolhedora.
Também adorei a Maddie, a antiga enteada de Louise, que acaba por ter um papel muito especial nesta aventura. A sua criatividade, as ideias e a forma como apoia Louise fazem dela uma das minhas personagens favoritas. E a dinâmica entre as duas foi uma das partes de que mais gostei!
Quanto ao Jack, um homem charmoso, meio italiano, meio Yorkshireman. Gostei de acompanhar a aproximação entre os dois e de ver nascer uma relação doce, descontraída e cheia de encanto.
Adorei a mensagem tão bonita que este livro transmite, nunca devemos desistir dos nossos sonhos, mesmo quando a vida nos obriga a começar de novo. Às vezes, o caminho que imaginámos não é aquele que acabamos por percorrer, mas isso não significa que não possamos encontrar a felicidade numa direção diferente.
Estava mesmo a precisar de um romance assim, leve, reconfortante e cheio de personagens que nos fazem sentir em casa. Uma verdadeira dose de conforto literário, com romance, amizade, família, bolos deliciosos e uma comunidade que acaba por mostrar que ninguém precisa de enfrentar tudo sozinho.
Jennifer Page, obrigada por esta história tão amorosa! Fiquei com vontade de visitar Applethwaite, conhecer esta livraria-padaria e encostar-me num recanto literário com um belo romance.
Profile Image for Sonia Canario scanario_bookstagram.
207 reviews9 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 15, 2026
Bem-vindos à vila de Applethwaite.🍂

🍁Este livro é um abraço quentinho.
Daqueles que nos aconchegam o coração, entre o aroma delicioso da pastelaria, a magia dos livros e a doçura da Louise.✨

📚Louise tem 41 anos e é ex-editora. Depois de um «incidente» com o livro de uma escritora aclamada, regressa à sua terra natal.

🍰Ali, entre as memórias da falecida avó e a pressão da mãe para assumir o negócio de família, a pastelaria, Louise vê-se perante um futuro que não é aquele com que sonha.

Porque o seu verdadeiro sonho é abrir uma livraria.

🤷🏻‍♀️Mas Louise não sabe dizer que não. Não se impõe. Coloca constantemente as vontades e expectativas dos outros à frente das suas.

E é então que conhece Jack.🥹
E eu, sinceramente, nem sei qual dos dois é mais querido!✨

Louise, com as suas inseguranças e os seus pensamentos negativos, ou Jack, que a ajuda a perceber o seu valor e a acreditar em si.

🪚🧑🏼‍💻No entanto Jack também tem as suas próprias batalhas para enfrentar…

Esta história foi tão, mas tão reconfortante, que eu simplesmente não queria sair dela.💖

🍰Uma história de superação, de afirmação pessoal, de amizade, de laços únicos, de união e, acima de tudo, de amor.

🍰Uma história fictícia, mas tão próxima da realidade.

E as personagens secundárias? Amei! 🥹
A doce Maddie e o amor tão bonito que sente pela sua «ex» madrasta.

Foi tudo tão especial!🙌🏻✨

E o romance entre Louise e Jack? ❤️
Foi acontecendo exatamente como tinha de acontecer.🥰

✨E foi precisamente isso que tornou a história deles tão bonita e única.

🍰Entre livros, bolos, amizades e segundas oportunidades,O Café Livraria Açúcar & Especiarias” lembra-nos que nunca é tarde para seguir os nossos sonhos.

Foi maravilhoso!✨
Profile Image for Joanna.
379 reviews27 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
October 6, 2026
Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for providing me with an advanced copy of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review.

More romances with middle-aged couples, please!

This was such a refreshing take on a small-town romance. Not only was the FMC in early 40s but it was set in Yorkshire and was so self aware. The main character is a book editor and makes a point of pointing out what clichéd things would happen in romance books, which adds a fun irreverence to her voice that I really enjoyed.

While the book is fairly predictable, it was comforting, cosy and fun. Very much character and relationship driven with very little happening in the plot, but I didn't mind that at all.

The narrator was fab with the perfect northern voice, great pacing and characters that were easy to differentiate. She was very easy to listen to and I enjoyed listening to the bulk of this book while on a long drive.

It's the perfect autumn read when you want something with good humour and cosy autumn vibes that will put a smile on your face.
Profile Image for Jen Ryland (jenrylandreviews & yaallday).
2,320 reviews1,132 followers
Read
October 4, 2026

The first few pages of The Sugar and Spice Bookshop Bakery made me think of a favorite Christmas movie, A Castle for Christmas, in which a bestselling author has to flee to Scotland after incurring the wrath of her readers over a plot development.
Louise is a book editor who flees London to her Yorkshire hometown after a career disaster. Her mother always hoped she'd come home and run her Gran's bakery, but Louise has other ideas. A bakery/bookshop.
The funniest part of the book is the locals refusal to consider the bookshop element. They just want the bakery's famous ginger cake, thanks very much. (I want the recipe and hope the finished copy includes it.)
But Louise sticks to her guns, hires a local architect, and orders books. She'll have to contend with the locals, plus face her career disaster head-on. (I loved that too, but it's a spoiler.)

* Publication: 2027 by Aria. Thanks to them for my advance copy.
* Goodreads Rating: 3.7
* Bookstore: The Sugar and Spice Bookshop Bakery in Applethwaite,Yorkshire, UK
* Bookish vibe: Small town bookshop, charmingly cranky locals
* Tropes: Starting over, family expectations, cynics about love
* Spice level: 🌶️🌶️🌶️  Surprisingly spicy for a cozy book, with a couple of not-too-explicit open door scenes.
Profile Image for Namo.
487 reviews32 followers
November 3, 2026
Louise has been an editor because she loves books. However, she quits her job and no one knows why. Maybe she simply wants to join her mum running the bakery business at Applethwaite, the small Yorkshire village town where she grew up. During finding her way through her life after the divorce in her forties, her ex-stepdaughter comes to stay with her. Now, she has to deal with so many things at once, my career, love life, and family.

The story felt so realistic to me. Juggling so many things is so real. Furthermore, all the characters in this book are so lovable. The small-town elements are also very good, not too unrealistic. Very cozy, comforting, and heartwarming, from both atmospheric scenes and the people. I also love the ending and how everything gets resolved.

Thank you the author, the publisher, and NetGalley for an ARC in an exchange for an honest review.

Profile Image for Jess.
740 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 5, 2026
This was a pretty quick read. It was really cozy and sweet, with a bit of angst and drama, but otherwise just an easy read.
The premise was nice - editor leaves job due to drama, flees to hometown and reopens her family bakery. Converts it to a bakery/bookshop, then falls for the man doing the renovations.
But the execution kind of fell flat for me a bit. The third person perspective was a bit of a struggle at times, and it’s not normally something that bothers me.
There were unanswered questions at the end, and even the “big drama” reveal was anticlimactic for me.
There wasn’t any heat or longing or chemistry in the romance elements either. This parts just felt really bland.
It wasn’t bad by any stretch, it just didn’t wow me.

Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC.
Profile Image for Nez.
124 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 7, 2026
This was a super cute and cosy autumn read. Small town romance with coffee and cake. We follow Louise who has recently quit her job at 40, I like the fact she isn't super young! She has moved back to Yorkshire and ends up at her mum's old bakery. She decides she wants something different for herself and wants to open a bookshop. We also have Jack, an interesting Italian man who is also in town. I enjoyed the writing style and the story and how the relationships developed. Louise's relationship with her ex-stepdaughter was well written and overall this was a cute story.
Profile Image for VickydpBooks.
1,351 reviews25 followers
October 8, 2026
There’s something so lovely about a cosy story that reminds you it’s never too late to start over, and this one sounds like the perfect feel-good read! 🥰

Louise Dearnley has spent years editing romance novels and helping other people find their happily-ever-afters, but when she quits her job and returns to her childhood village of Applethwaite, she finds herself facing a fresh start of her own.

Between her mum’s hopes for the family bakery, delicious ginger cake and scones, unexpected house guests, and a gorgeous Italian man, Louise’s new chapter sounds like it’s going to be full of surprises. I love the idea of someone who knows all the tricks of a fictional happy ending having to figure out what that looks like in real life!

With small-town Yorkshire charm, second-chance romance, found family, and plenty of cosy bakery vibes, this sounds like such a heartwarming escape. Perfect for anyone who loves stories about starting over, finding your people, and discovering that sometimes life has a little romance of its own waiting around the corner. 💕📚
Profile Image for Brooke Bartel.
28 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
September 20, 2026
If you love an Older FMC, rediscovering herself while reinventing a book and bakery shop located in a small town then this is for you! I knew that I would love this one right from the beginning.
Did the miscommunication have my eye twitching, yes. Did the group of older women in their 60’s/70’s give me the ick, yes, but the fact that they were nicknamed ‘Geriatric mean girls’ made me giggle! I enjoyed the sassy opinionated (ex) step daughter, the hunky MMC, the really supportive friends that come to help in the last half of the book and of course the setting of a bookshop bakery!
Overall I just really loved the coziness, autumn, small town feel. The story made me feel like I was being given a really nice warm hug. I also really loved the book nooks in the story, they sound magical.
Definitely a beautiful read, great for when you need something a little lighter with some emotional moments.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Barbara Powell.
1,255 reviews70 followers
September 28, 2026
Louise leaves her job and comes back home to lick her wounds but her mother thinks it's to run the family bakery.
Louise decides that rather than continue as a bakery, she will run it as a bookshop, but the people of the town don't understand that and keep coming in looking for baked goods. And next thing you know there's a gorgeous Italian man who seems to be in the shop more than necessary…
If you’re looking for a second chance, starting over later in life story with some romance set in a gorgeous location, you’re not going to want to miss this one. It’s cozy and feels Hallmark-y in the best way.
Thanks to Aria and NetGalley for this eArc in exchange for my review
Profile Image for Sarah Festa.
449 reviews12 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
September 29, 2026
I'm sorry, I am 8% in and I think I must have read about her editing 100 times already, too repetitive for me.
405 reviews3 followers
October 12, 2026
Wonderful

I thoroughly enjoyed this great book , it was warming and comforting all the way through. I actually felt as though I was there with all these brilliant characters. Roll on the next book next year😁
Profile Image for Viki86.
24 reviews3 followers
November 17, 2026
Books,cakes, coffee and a handsome Italian man... cosy and cute, with interesting characters, hidden secrets and new beginnings. A very enjoyable story for rainy autumn evenings ( with a cuppa and a slice of cake).☕️🍰
Profile Image for Omnia Atef.
928 reviews7 followers
October 10, 2026
Unfortunately bad excursion to a cute cozy small town romance. The mixture of the Italian and Yorkshires would have great but ruined it. The only best thing is the stepdaughter enthusiasm but ruined by remaining with Theo till the end. Even the broken board, dog toy, and blood used poorly
Profile Image for Marian..
1,397 reviews69 followers
Did Not Finish
November 16, 2026
DNF at 27%

Profile Image for Susanne Baker.
774 reviews31 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 30, 2026
A bookshop in a bakery? That sounds absolutely amazing! So, I couldn’t wait to dive into this delightful book by Jennifer Page.
It’s the perfect autumn Hallmark movie setting, with fantastic characters and a wonderful opportunity for a fresh start for Louise.
After having to walk away from her career, Louise hopes to make her dream of running a bookshop come true. However, her mother and the local community have very different ideas…
I really enjoyed watching Louise connect with Jack, who has also moved back to the area. It was lovely to see the bookshop come to life and to watch the blossoming romance develop alongside it.
The teacher element of the story added an interesting dimension, and it was uplifting to see Louise overcome her doubts, find her confidence, and finally take the plunge with her dreams.
Such a cosy and heartwarming story, filled with delicious cakes, charming characters, romance, and plenty of hope for the future. 🍂📚🧁❤️
566 reviews12 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 31, 2026
The sugar & Spice Bookshop Bakery by Jennifer Page. Who doesn’t like bookshops and bakeries, then add it to a small town with romance..perfect. What a cute idea for book nooks with different genres. Would have liked to see a little more togetherness in this second chance romance. Overall a great cozy read. Releases Oct 8, 2026. Thank you to #NetGalley and #Aria&Aries for this arc. This is my honest review.
Profile Image for Get Your Tinsel in a Tangle.
2,405 reviews76 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 8, 2026
Louise comes home to quietly recover from a publishing disaster and within approximately five minutes the people of Applethwaite are WALKING INTO HER CLOSED FAMILY BAKERY, demanding ginger cake, and leaving random money on the counter like they’ve invented an honor-system hostage situation. Nobody asks whether she has reopened. Nobody cares what Louise wants. They see this woman standing near a cake and decide she is back in business. Her mother has also already decided Louise has returned to take over the bakery, which is fascinating because Louise has decided absolutely no such thing. She wants a bookshop. Unfortunately, she has returned to a Yorkshire village where boundaries are apparently considered an urban affectation.

And Louise is already hanging on by a thread here. She’s in her forties, divorced, has quit the publishing career she loved after a mistake she is treating like she personally brought down the entire British book industry, and would very much like everyone to stop asking questions. Which, naturally, means she has moved somewhere everybody knows her mother. Excellent strategy. No notes. Also, because she spent years editing romance novels, Louise keeps comparing everything happening to what would happen “in a romance novel.” Louise, I am begging you. There is an attractive man about to enter your life while you renovate a bakery into a bookshop in a picturesque Yorkshire village. You are standing so deep inside a romance novel that I can see the illustrated cover from here.

But first we need to discuss the bakery, because Louise wants books and Applethwaite wants Granny’s ginger cake with the determination of people prepared to riot over baked goods. So eventually we arrive at the bookshop bakery compromise, and THIS PLACE. Maddie helps Louise create themed reading nooks, including a children’s area with a wardrobe entrance, and suddenly I have abandoned every practical concern I’ve ever had. Planning permission? Revenue projections? Staffing? I don’t know her. Put me inside the wardrobe with a latte and tell my family I’ve moved.

Maddie is Louise’s ex-stepdaughter, and honestly, their relationship got me more than I was prepared for. Maddie turns up unexpectedly and immediately throws herself into helping Louise build this ridiculous bookish wonderland because divorce may have ended Louise’s marriage, but apparently nobody informed these two they were supposed to stop being family. GOOD. DON’T. Maddie is creative and funny and dealing with her own questionable boyfriend situation, and I kept waiting for Louise to say, “You know what, since I am no longer technically your stepmother, I believe I am now legally permitted to tell you that this man is exhausting.” Their relationship has that slightly messy tenderness of two people who chose to keep each other after the official reason they belonged together disappeared. That one got me.

And then Jack arrives. Giacomo, if we’re being fancy. Handsome. Half-Italian. Carpenter. Calls her Luisa. Helps with the bookshop. Louise’s internal romance editor immediately clocks in for a shift nobody scheduled. She keeps telling herself this is real life and therefore things are absolutely not going to unfold like one of the books she used to edit, while repeatedly finding herself in situations that would make a romance editor circle the page and write, “Ma’am, be serious.” Jack has his own complications, Louise has trust issues she’s carrying around like emergency supplies, and these two spend a lot of time getting dangerously close to behaving exactly like the fictional people Louise insists they are not.

Although, if I’m picking the relationship I cared about most, it’s still Louise and Louise. Because this woman has convinced herself that one professional mistake means she should abandon an entire career she loved, retreat home, and perhaps quietly become whatever everybody else needs her to be. Her mother wants the bakery. The villagers want the bakery. Louise wants a bookshop. And for a while she acts like wanting something for herself is somehow the least important item on the agenda. Watching her finally start saying, “Actually, what if I want THIS?” felt better than any dramatic romantic declaration could have.

Meanwhile, her old English teacher is STILL THERE. I cannot overstate how unacceptable this would be to me personally. Louise returns home in her forties and discovers that a woman who made her feel terrible about herself at school remains locally available to criticize her decisions. That is not a quaint village. That is a curse. Miss Anderson has opinions about Louise, the business, the bookshop, the planning situation, probably the rotational speed of the earth, and Louise has to keep dealing with her while also managing her mother, Maddie, Jack, the villagers, her own career crisis, and Granny’s ginger cake, which at this point has become the most powerful political force in Yorkshire.

And underneath all that cozy nonsense, I really liked that Louise gets to start over without pretending everything before this was a waste. She isn’t twenty-two discovering herself for the first time. She’s lived. She’s been married. She’s been divorced. She built a career and screwed something up. She became a stepmother and kept the daughter even after losing the husband. There’s something really lovely about watching someone realize that starting again doesn’t mean setting fire to everything that came before. Sometimes you keep the girl. You keep the ginger cake. You keep the parts of yourself that still fit. Then you put a bookshop where everyone told you there had to be only a bakery.

The Sugar and Spice Bookshop Bakery gets 3.5 stars from me, and I would now like Applethwaite to explain why I cannot actually visit this place. Maddie deserves partial ownership for those book nooks, Granny’s ginger cake deserves its own seat on the village council, and Louise desperately needed someone to confiscate the phrase “if this were a romance novel” after about the twentieth use. But watching a forty-something woman run home convinced she has ruined everything and accidentally build something that actually feels like hers? Yeah. That worked on me.

Huge thanks to Aria & Aries and NetGalley for the ARC and for once again encouraging my deeply unrealistic belief that I could absolutely run a bookshop bakery despite having no retail experience, no commercial baking skills, and a customer-service personality that would collapse the first time somebody walked through a clearly locked door asking for ginger cake.
Profile Image for Shree.
197 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
May 14, 2026
I have never been able to resist picking up any book set around a bookshop or a library. And "The Sugar and Spice Bookshop Bakery" is my first book by Jennifer Page.

What I liked about the book

--> The setting—a bustling bakery turned bookshop bakery in the picturesque village of Applewaite— was charming, as expected.
--> The story was a reminder of how we tend to see things as being much worse than they actually are.
--> It is always good to see someone start over and make a success of their second chance. Things may not be as smooth sailing as we see in books and movies. Help may come from the most unexpected places. But if one persists with courage, things will eventually fall into place.
--> Louise feeling a tinge of annoyance at Madie's unannounced visit, and later, her anxiety over Madie's impending move to London made her real, flawed, and relatable.

What didn't work for me

SPOILER


Thanks to Netgalley, the publishers, and the author for sharing an arc of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Calista.
467 reviews50 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 13, 2026
Slow-paced and underwhelming, The Sugar and Spice Bookshop Bakery by Jennifer Page is about a woman who returns to her small hometown to take over her family’s business, but with a bookish twist.

Summary: Louise Delaney leaves her editor job in her 40s after one of her books received backlash and retreats to her hometown, Applethwaite, to lick her wounds. Her mother expects her to take over the family bakery. After some initial resistance, she decides to turn it into a bookshop bakery.

Tropes/Genres:
• strangers to lovers
• family business
• small town
• contemporary romance
• set in Applethwaite, Yorkshire, UK

Review: I usually enjoy this author’s books, but this one didn’t quite hit the mark. While I enjoyed the concept of the bookshop bakery and how it was designed, the characters were difficult to connect with, the plot felt rather bland, and the ending was underwhelming.

Louise can be frustrating and unrelatable. She often links events to bookish tropes, which can be quirky at the start, but it eventually started to be quite annoying. She also has a severe inability to communicate, acting like she has no personal will when she’s in her 40s. However, she does have a passion for literature and tries to help people, so she isn’t all that bad… just a bit immature.

The romance subplot was boring. Giacomo, mostly known as Jack, was a bit of a red flag, especially since the reveal of his real identity proved to be harmful towards Louise’s dreams. That being said, Louise was also a hypocrite because she lied a lot, yet she faulted Jack for being a liar. Those two are simply a disaster together, regardless of the sweet moments in the book, which felt a bit forced since they had little chemistry.

One good thing about this book was Louise and Maddie’s relationship. Maddie was Louise’s stepdaughter from her previous marriage. It was nice to see them maintain their relationship after the divorce. I also liked the realistic complexity of Louise’s feelings about Maddie being in Applethwaite. However, the resolution of Maddie’s relationship with her toxic boyfriend, Theo, was inconclusive. Along with the abrupt ending, this made the story feel incomplete.

While the writing was descriptive, the pacing was odd. Louise spent half the book hinting at the reason she quit her job and whining about how terrible what she did to Sheila Penhalington (the author) was, only for the reveal to be underwhelming. It felt very sanitised, like the author didn’t want to risk making her authors angry at Louise, which ironically contradicts Sheila’s message. Additionally, the ending of the story was sudden and didn’t feel satisfying. The premise was very promising, but it just didn’t play out as well.

Overall, I recommend this book to readers who enjoy the concept of a bookshop bakery with sheds decorated with different themes based on book genres. It’s certainly a place I’d love to visit! Just don’t hope much for the romance and focus more on the protagonist’s relationship with the community.

Thank you, NetGalley, for the read.
Profile Image for Sue.
1,457 reviews
November 2, 2026
Louise Dearnley's career as a book editor has ended rather abruptly with her resignation, following a mix-up with the latest novel of famous author Sheila Penhaligon. The prospect of facing a new start in her forties is daunting, so she heads home to the Yorkshire village of Applethwaite to consider her options.

Her mother is delighted to see her, but is under the misapprehension that Louise has come back to take over the family bakery shop, now she has retired. As much as Louise loves baking, this is not part of her plans. However, spending time in the empty shop gives her an idea...

Having loved Jennifer's Little Board Game Café books, I knew I was going to enjoy this first instalment of her brand new cosy rom-com series - and I was right.

Louise comes home to Applethwaite with her tail between her legs, hiding a secret about the precise circumstances of her abrupt change of career. She knows she wants to continue working with books, rather than take on the family bakery, and comes up with the idea of converting the premises into a bookshop.

But putting her plan into action is not going to be easy - she will need to break bad news to her mother; find the money for renovations; and deal with the locals who are addicted to her grandmother's famous ginger cake... as well as negotiate the unexpected drama that comes with her ex-stepdaughter Maddie needing a place to stay, just when Louise was hoping a romance with handsome Italian Jack might be on the menu.

As the story unfurls, a lovely slow-burn romance develops between Louise and Jack, set against the hurdles of getting the bookshop off the ground. There is a bit more spice than in Jennifer's previous books, which works well with the bakery theme and Louise's occasional reflections on the romantic tropes she is used to vs real life.

Louise, Jack and Maddie end up making a great team, and lots of stuff crops up about all three that delves into themes of parental expectation, bad relationships, guilt, and second chances. The layer of mystery that comes with gradually revealing what lies behind Louise's departure from her previous job is very enjoyable too - and packed with intriguing reflections on the bookish world.

Jennifer always has the right touch when it comes to building a wider community around her central characters, threading storylines into the main event to get you invested in their lives, and saving some nice twists for the end. This book introduces lots of opportunities for future instalments, which I am really looking forward to reading as the series develops.

This was an enchanting gentle read, with a warm and hopeful ending that hits the perfect note for this time of year. I cannot wait to meet the Applethwaite gang again in book two, Love and Lattes at the Bookshop Bakery, which will be about single mum Anna!
Profile Image for Rachel ✨.
304 reviews
August 3, 2026
I was really excited to pick up my first book by Jennifer Page! The Sugar and Spice Bookshop Bakery sounded so up my street!

Louise has just quit her dream job as an editor and returned home to Applethwaite, the small Yorkshire village where she grew up. Now she has to start over and it doesn’t help that her Mum is convinced she’s here to run the family bakery (as does the rest of the village!), but she has her heart set on running a bookshop. With renovations underway, a quirky ex-step daughter’s unexpected arrival and a gorgeous Italian who might be too good to be true, is Louise’s second chance at a happy ending finally coming true?..

A bookshop bakery?? What’s not to like!! This brings all of the lovely cosy small town vibes, will have you drooling over cake and wanting to start a fight with a mean old English teacher!

The setting is wonderful, I could really picture the bakery in a little cosy English village. I loved the concept of Louise starting over in life as a divorcee in her forties, it’s never too late to try something new and follow your dream.

I did chuckle when each day the villagers just continued to turn up to the bakery even though it was closed and demand coffee and cake (whilst just leaving random amounts of money on the side).

I particularly enjoyed them renovating the book store. Maddie, Louise’s step daughter did such a fantastic job at decorating each of the book nooks (I’m desperate to visit the Narnia one!) I really enjoyed what Maddie brought to the story (although she’s in dire need of ditching her boyfriend).

The romance between Louise and Jack was sweet and although I was rooting for them, I would have liked a little bit more chemistry, as at times it felt a little bit clunky.

Unfortunately what didn’t work for me was the amount of repetition, particularly surrounding her ginger cake, quitting her job and who the characters were. I also wasn’t a huge fan of the big reveal for why Louise had left her job, it felt very built up for what it was.

I’d like to see Maddie get her own book next to resolve her romance (we need to see her with Tom!). Overall a sweet and fun small town romance that you can cosy up to this autumn!

If you love the Gilmore Girls and Virgin River small town cosy vibes, a second chance romance, allll the sweet treats, and all the meddling village folk, then I think you’ll really enjoy this one!

Thank you NetGalley, Jennifer Page and Aria for providing an eARC, and Head of Zeus for providing a physical ARC - The Sugar and Spice Bookshop Bakery publishes October 8th.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 202 reviews