NATIONAL BESTSELLER • An intimate, story-driven cookbook that explores the idea of cooking and eating as an act of self-care, with 65 time-tested and nourishing recipes from the James Beard Award–winning author of Where Cooking Begins and New York Times bestseller, That Sounds So Good
Carla has been writing about food, family, and feelings for many years, and she’s always known that her recipes were about more than sustenance. The 65 recipes and 30 essays in Food Is a Feeling are a powerful reminder of the nurturing, fulfilling, and joyful role that food plays in all of our lives, a very human account of beauty and challenges balancing each other like butter and salt.
For her, cooking is an expression of love. That core belief was put to the test the year she got divorced. As Carla started figuring out who she was going to be on the other side of a 24-year marriage, she took note of the cravings she was having and the meals she wanted to make, and honored those desires by making herself something to Lemony Chickpea Stew with Rice; Personal Pot of Beans and Greens; Salad Sandwich, to name a few. She was flooded with delicious memories—her mom’s Saturday Night Alfredo, the Extremely Floofy Vanilla Pancakes she makes for her children, and the Crispy-Skinned Fish with Olives and Lemons and Burnt Caramel Rhubarb Compote she learned on the line in some of New York City’s most demanding restaurant kitchens. Over time, she realizes the creative, transformative work that happens in the kitchen is a potent antidote for the hurdles she has yet to overcome.
The food, the passage of time, and the lessons gained—all of it became perfectly intertwined. In writing that is revealing, relatable, and funny, Carla uses rich context from her own life to make the case that food is so much more than just fuel, and yes, we should eat our feelings. After all, they’re delicious.
Is it too late to change the title to Divorce is a Feeling? Because I wasn’t prepared for how aggressively this book would feature divorce.
The description literally says: “For her, cooking is an expression of love… that belief was put to the test the year she got divorced…” so I went in expecting some divorce. A reasonable amount of divorce (I don’t know what a reasonable amount is, but it feels like an “I’ll know it when I see it” situation).
This was not that.
This book is like that friend who has one personality trait. In this case, that personality is: Divorced.
Every essay and reflection has this constant refrain of “now that I’m divorced…” and after a while it stops feeling insightful and starts feeling like that Euphoria gif.
That’s the vibe the whole time (note to self: watch Euphoria).
I spent a lot of time asking: who is this for???
And then the recipes get pulled into it too. There’s one called separation pork chops. I’m sorry, but if we’re committing to that, can we at least get a pun or a little alliteration? Something? Don’t just say the quiet part out loud like that.
I think my main issue is that I expected more range. More of anything, really. Instead it’s very “woman gets divorced, cooks, and will not stop mentioning that she got divorced.” Which is fair! That’s a huge life event. But when it’s everything, it starts to flatten the whole experience.
There are some genuinely funny insights. "There are a lot of pragmatic, logistical details to take care of... like pretending you're going to miss the dog." I legit cackled. That's cold. I loved it.
Recipe-wise, I wasn’t wowed. A lot of it felt pretty basic and safe, nothing that made me particularly excited to cook. And I cannot let this go: there is a recipe for cereal. Not granola. Not overnight oats. Just… cereal. Get bowl. Add cereal. Pour milk. Optional fruit and maple syrup. What are we doing here? And again: who is this for? Because I feel like most of us have cereal handled.
It’s not all bad. I genuinely love the idea of food as a feeling and honouring your cravings. There’s some lovely messaging around self-care and actually listening to what you want to eat. And the whole “my ex didn’t like this so now I can eat it whenever I want” thing is relatable. When my husband’s away I immediately go, “great, time for takoyaki and gumbo, no one can stop me!"
But also: I am so tired of hearing about the ex.
There are good moments scattered throughout. I just wish the execution had more depth (and maybe one fewer mention of the divorce per page), because it ultimately feels very one-note. This could have been fantastic if it had followed the recipes throughout her life - what did your ma make when you were sick? what did you eat to celebrate your graduation? what did you crave during each pregnancy? That's the book I wanted.
There are little glimpses of that book here and there. They just get overshadowed by the ex.
Kerry, what do you mean you spent your Sunday reading a cookbook? It’s possible to do when that cookbook is actually a collection of essays, with Carla’s recipes as the secondary attraction.
After I finished the cookbook and before summarizing my thoughts, I read some of the other Goodreads reviews on the book, and reader? They are a miss. This book is certainly not for everyone, probably not for most cooks and certainly not for those who were a fan of the Bon Appetit version of Carla. But if we’re honest, self-aware divorcées are also not for everyone.
Centrally, I think other reviewers of this book miss that the experience of getting divorce both fundamentally changes who you are and challenges your worldview; your reintroduction to the world around you requires reflection, uncovering, and a new way of interacting. You reflect, uncover and reintroduce yourself to others and yourself, in real life and in the kitchen, which can result in a seismic shift in the way that you cook.
Is night cereal a recipe? I’d say yes, absolutely, when you have to learn how to satisfy your singular cravings and needs. Now, you alone are responsible for you, so let’s relearn how to act like the head bitch in charge and make decisions with your needs front and center. Sometimes, that means cereal and milk, and what of it?!
While getting divorced, I took comfort in food, in rich flavors and in meals that reminded me of childhood. Cooking itself remains challenging for just one. I’d happily dedicate an afternoon to preparing a meal for my sister, baking for a gathering of friends, or impressing a new love interest. But all this effort just for me? The point of Carla’s book is to say yes to all of it: the high effort, the barely making it to dinner, the ‘have I eaten any protein today,’ the recipes that you can leverage to forge new traditions in a new version of life as you know it.
Divorce can be a ‘dirty’ word, which was confirmed for me as I read through these other Goodreads reviews. I think some think it’s a selfish or flippant choice, when really it’s the opposite. It is terribly hard to propose a new world order for yourself, your immediate family, and all of those who you hold dear. ‘See me differently,’ you plead. Is that so bad? Frankly, I think divorce helped me uncover a new layer of love: if your primary romantic partnership dies off, where do you direct all of your affection? For Carla, this seems obvious, as this book reads as a love letter to her boys, particularly Cosmo. Carla relishes in their time spent as a duo, and seems to appreciate Cosmo’s flexibility as he learns to love evolving versions of his mother. From recipes and stories about PB&J and bolognese and precious copper cookware, Carla’s love for her sons is the through line of this book, and her sincerity jumps off the page with every subsequent essay.
My only feedback about this cookbook is I didn’t understand how the recipes were arranged throughout the book. Perhaps this was intentional, but it was a little hard to follow. But to me, the recipes are secondary- I bought this because I love a book from a reflective divorcee. Carla’s writing is very beautiful, her perspective singular, and her experiences vulnerable in trying to become who she is. Aleppo pepper is featured regularly. I loved it all.
Hard for me to give a star rating for some reason. But after reading others reviews I just think it’s funny how many people are like “this isn’t a cookbook, this is a divorce memoir!” …Is that not what she’s essentially been advertising it as? Does she not address that in the intro? Also I didn’t find it depressing at all like some did, I saw it as an inside look into her reclaiming her new life and the process of getting there. And honestly some of the stories had very little to do with the divorce too.
I like Carla and have loved her other cookbooks and love her on social media. But this cookbook is not really a cookbook but more of a divorce memoir, and not a very good one. The recipes themselves were hit or miss. Some looked appealing, but others felt more like vibes than actual recipes. Unsure who the audience is for this book, probably Carla herself.
This book is for longstanding fans of Carla. Get her previous cookbooks for delicious recipes, curl up with this one if you’re ready to feel the feels through food essays. I’ve been making her pasta e fagiole every fall for years now, I was delighted to find a written-out version of the recipe in this book.
I actually love a cookbook with essays (think Molly Yeh!). I frequently read cookbooks front to back anyway, so this twist was right up my alley. The second I heard Carla talk about it on Modern Love, I knew I had to read it.
But make no mistake - this is not a cookbook and it’s strange to be billed as such. This is a memoir with recipes, and that’s how I read it. As a memoir, I found some essays much better than others (the tomato one was probably my favorite) but always felt the recipes fit the essay. There could have been some better editing, as by the end some characters (like her sons) kept being reintroduced to me like I’d never heard of them whereas they’d been mentioned so much it was strange to suddenly say “Leo, my eldest son” like he was a stranger.
Also bear in mind - when she says feeling she means divorce. Which was clearly important to her to write about, but as I cannot relate to her predicament I needed her to build the connection, help me find what I could relate to, which didn’t happen in most essays. However, her stories about working in kitchens, her sons, and her friends did this much better.
I did not read this to find things to cook and I’d recommend neither do you. Instead, if you’re interested in a different style of memoir that links feelings and food closely, read this like the collection of essays it is. Just be prepared to be inundated with divorce.
Carla's recipes are on repeat in our house, so my stomach and I were excited to have a sneak peek at her next book. I was not prepared for it to wallop me right in the heart. The stories that accompany the recipes are arranged in a non-linear way that still makes sense, particularly to someone who has experienced heartbreak/the end of the life they knew. I especially loved the recipes for the things Carla made when she didn't feel like cooking. You know those have gotta be good. Also, banana bread with cocoa and salted peanuts? Why didn't I think of that? I'm not new to cooking, and I'm also not interested in recipes with 25 ingredients and 10 steps. The recipes in here are familiar enough to not be intimidating but original enough to make me thing, "Oh, that's interesting, I want to try that." Putting the hard copy of this book on my Christmas list right now.
I received a digital ARC of this book via NetGalley.
I like the author’s two previous books but there was a big disconnect in this one. I get that this is a (divorce) memoir but the entire vibe was “ok, now I’m divorced and I can cook and eat whatever I want.” The photos look random and so are the recipes. I hope Carla Lalli was able to fulfill whatever she set out to do with this book but maybe it could’ve been a series in her Substack and not a book.
3.5-3.75 stars. I’ve followed Carla for years now going back to Bon Appetit. Was curious about this half divorce memoir, half cook book recipe book. As a vegetarian who doesn’t cook much, I was more curious about the essay portion. Some were insightful, some felt a bit try hard. As a whole, it felt a bit all over the place, but I can’t say I’m mad for having spent time with it.
To me, food has also always been more than sustenance. Before opening the book, I hoped I’d hear more about the famous divorce - safe to say my desires were heard. While many of the recipes feel slightly haphazard, I did immediately implement the “cereal” recipe in to my rotation. I’ve been eating cereal with wild blueberries and a sprinkle of sugar forever so the upgrade to maple syrup and salt has been a winner.
I’ve been getting back in to the cooking game since being sick and this book has reminded me how soothing and healing the process can be. Time + heat = cooking. The stakes are so low but in turn we are able to feed and nurture ourselves and our families and friends. How lucky!
Thank you to NetGalley, author Carla Lalli, and Clarkson Potter for providing me with a free ARC in exchange for my honest opinion!
Food IS a feeling, and this book is full of all the feelings, foods, and emotions. I did not follow along with Carla during her Bon Appetit days, but I became familiar with her when her second cookbook, That Sounds So Good, came out in 2021. In 2021, I was 23 and had just moved to Houston and was working a "big girl job" for the first time. I did not inherit a love of cooking; my mother despises doing it, and my dad likes to do it but mainly grilling and meats. I was picky growing up (and still am in bizarre ways), so this led to my absolute and total disinterest in cooking for myself. I instead did and still take much pleasure in going out to eat. The communal sharing of a meal is so special to me, and I delight in a beautiful presentation and flawless execution. I did a bad job of cooking and feeding myself in college the previous 4 years before 2021, usually resulting to eating string cheese and a granola bar or getting fast food from Wendy's. If I did cook at all, it was thanks to the meal delivery services HelloFresh or Every Plate, which I do credit in getting me much more comfortable with cooking! However, I knew once I moved to Houston that I needed to at least start trying to do better for myself with cooking, even if I hated every second of it. In comes That Sounds So Good by Carla Lalli. I do not remember how I found it, but this was the first cookbook I ever bought myself. I remember seeing the bright yellow cover, flipping through the pages, and realizing that almost all the recipes DID sound so good. 5 years later, I haven't cooked through as many of the recipes inside as I would like, but I have gained so much confidence in the kitchen and a greater appreciation for food, cookbooks, and culinary writing through that cookbook. Enter Food is a Feeling now. Don't go in expecting a new cookbook-- it is more personal essays with recipes included, which is totally fine by me!! Again, Carla's writing is absolutely transportive with her descriptions of food. Perhaps my favorite installment in this was her essay about the beach peaches or the PB&J. However, beyond just her food descriptions, she is an excellent writer. This book chronicles her journey through divorce and rediscovering herself as an individual, a single parent, and how food plays a role throughout all stages of this journey. It is extremely honest, even more so than I was expecting; I could feel her simultaneous pain, relief, joy, loneliness, confusion, and discovery throughout many of the chapters, which worked so well. The book ebbs and flows naturally and feels like a conversation with a friend. The recipes pair alongside each essay, which from a reading perspective I love; sometimes they are as simple as how Carla eats her cereal at night, as she rediscovers a love for this on a night alone. From a cooking perspective, there are a few intriguing recipes to me, but I would not personally buy for the sole reason to add the recipes to my collection. It's more so the recipes are nice to have upon reading how Carla developed and discovered them among this very personal time of her life. Even though I am not a mother and I am not divorced and I am much younger than Carla, this book resonated so much with me in knowing WHO you ARE intrinsically, as a woman, a friend, an individual, and more. I have a lot of respect for Carla Lalli upon reading her story, and I'm excited to return to some of these stories and reflect upon them while making the recipes. It has inspired me to reflect on what foods and recipes make up my story and feelings, and I am excited to see how this journey changes throughout my lifetime.
My favorite recipe tip was when she said she always uses slay juice to cook the mother rice. I will now be doing this every time :)
To be real though: I think all the people who simply cannot process that this is a genre bending book are boring. To those people: 1) do you even cook? and 2) do you have a life? The whole point here is that the book is not simply putting a recipes and a memoir side-by-side. (If you want that, there are plenty of middling online food blogs that go into some contrived story about their perfect little life and then BAM here's a recipe for wh*te women Thai curry ["just like my mother-in-law makes!!!! authentic!!!!!!"]). Food is a Feeling is a cookbook mixed with a memoir (self-proclaimed! at the front! it's not a surprise or a secret). The book does the really cool thing of generic bleeding back and forth. It's not personal story --> recipe, personal story --> recipes, etc., with solid separation between the two. It brings the memoir into the recipe and pushes the recipes out into the memoir. If you do not like that the recipes are too "simple" then I would ask you consider they are not recipes in a traditional sense, but part of a memoir that has taken the form of a recipe (just as the parts in memoir-form are just as much about technical food and cooking as they are about telling a life in a traditional memoir style). That all said, if you still think the recipes are too "simple," I would also ask you to also consider that you could literally never. What's presumptuous and rude in these reviews is when they are like "can't believe she has a recipe for night cereal :( SAD :( I loved when she made real recipes." Ok, then go take a look at her other recipes then (or her substack - if your goal is to get Carla recipes and not to simply hate b/c you're [trying to be] an Internet Personality Keyboard Warrior, then why aren't you doing that?). Also like, she is obviously making a choice. She *chose* to do this. She could have *chose* to do something else. Could she have written a another hardcore traditional cookbook which super technical recipes? Obviously. That is like, a huge part of the intro, esp when she talks about her self-conscious shift in style in writing recipes. Which begs the further question: is the genre bending cookbook/memoir the problem? Or, dear reader, the problem your literal lack of reading comprehension. If an author tells you what they're going to do, and then does it, then like..... you get mad about it? Remember: the aim is to read (and review) the book, not yourself.
At the end of the day, there's no getting through to numbskulls, but I do think it also bears emphasizing the obvious and potent misogyny in all these reviews. Pretty classic situation (unfortunately): Women writes some sort of book that centers her divorce/personal life/her feelings, and all the comments are "ug. can't believe this women is writing about her divorce personal life feelings." and the additional rider for cookbooks "Why can't she just write REAL recipes that are EMOTIONLESS and HIGHLY TECHNICAL." (This is all of course just saying in veiled terms "why can't she write recipes that are discursively male/masculine;" foucault forever.) To all the negative reviewers who don't have anything to say but are banging away at their keyboards anyway, I would implore you to stop hating women. I think, for you, this could be big.
I realize it does this book a disservice to spend paragraphs yelling at the haters instead of talking about the book itself, but like yeah -- it's very good. It is something to be read, something you should read. I liked it a ton <3
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
"Food is a Feeling" by Carla Lalli is a mix of food-centered essays through which she elaborates certain episodes of her life, and some recipes too. First of all, let me clarify this: even though there are recipes in the book, this is not a cookbook. The book very much revolves around the essays. I also need to clarify this: this is the very definition of a self-indulgent book, a book written very much by the author for the author. This format is very hit and miss and, in this particular instance, it was absolutely a hit for me. Reading through the book felt exactly like cracking open someone else's journal - someone that is a complete stranger to me, someone who is going through major life changes, and someone who lives and breathes food. As someone who loves journalling, sign me up. Peppered through the book are pages that are just free-flowing lists (for example "Things that made me feel free", and then a brain-dump of things), which I'm partial to because in my own journal those are my favourite types of pages. Each chapter starts with a scrapbook-type spread, with personal photos, handwritten recipes, and various digital "stickers". It seems that she uses the essays to process the major changes going on in her life, but they all have in common that they exude utter joy for food, and life in general. And a lot of these express opinions are ones that I share and love to chat about with friends, and love to ramble about in my own journal pages, such as: how utterly ridiculous expressions like "guilty pleasure" or "guilt-free" are, how wonderful it is to honour our cravings, and how great it is to relish the feeling of getting stronger through lifting weights without becoming a calorie-counting, macro-obsessed creature. Honestly, it was pure joy. I'll add my favourite quote in for good measure: "He's pure muscle and I'm a mix of a lot of things, including copious amounts of olive oil. Our body shapes reflect our priorities". Like I said, there are recipes - these feel more like personal notes for a family cookbook or something along those lines, adding to the journal vibes. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC of this book, in exchange for an honest review.
I received an ARC of Food is a Feeling from NetGalley, and this is my honest review. I went into this book not really knowing anything about Carla Lalli, and it turned out to be quite different from what I was expecting. Rather than being purely a cookbook, it’s also a very personal and reflective book about divorce, heartbreak, change, single parenthood, and the role food can play during difficult periods of life. The book explores how cooking and eating can provide comfort, routine, distraction, memories, and even optimism when life feels unsettled. Carla shares stories from different stages of her life alongside the recipes, including her family history, her career journey from intern to culinary school student, line cook, private chef and food writer, and the breakdown of her marriage. There are plenty of personal photographs throughout, which make the book feel intimate and very much rooted in her own experiences. What came across most strongly to me was that Carla is completely unapologetically herself. She cooks what she wants, eats what she likes, and writes very honestly about where she is emotionally. Even when I didn’t personally connect with all of the recipes, I still appreciated the warmth and sincerity behind them and how closely tied they were to particular memories, moods, and moments in her life. I especially enjoyed the lists scattered throughout the book, particularly “things she likes to eat when she doesn’t want to cook” and “things she tells herself when she’s out of sorts.” Those sections felt very relatable and human, and in some ways I found them just as interesting as the recipes themselves. While this wasn’t quite the cookbook I expected, and not all of the recipes appealed to my own tastes, I did appreciate the honesty and personal nature of the book. Readers who enjoy memoir-style cookbooks and food writing that explores emotion, identity, and life transitions may well connect with it more strongly than I did.
This cookbook is unique from most others due to the fact that it also includes memoir-esque essays and ephemera throughout. It was a joy to read the author’s experiences and the ways in which she connected them to food and her love of cooking. Most of the recipes in this book directly connect to/are mentioned in the essays.
It was interesting to read how Lalli dealt with her divorce through cooking. In many ways, her identity shifted and she had to learn how to cook differently to fit her new and happier self. She went from cooking for a family of four, to just herself or herself and one of her sons. She continued experimenting in the kitchen, with and without her son’s input.
Lalli’s writing is often hilarious, as well as relatable and poignant. She writes intimately from her personal experiences, and it was interesting to learn about three facets of her life that I have not experienced—motherhood, divorce, and work in harsh/abusive restaurant environments.
One of my favorite parts involved Lalli starting to cook and eat a particular food more often, as her ex-husband hated it. After the separation, she felt freer to honor her own cravings and desires, and I love that for her.
My partner is very picky, but he is always excited to see the meals and snacks I make for myself. He constantly tells me he thinks it’s wonderful that I make myself such nourishing foods as an act of self-care.
I say this to show that I resonate deeply with the author’s explorations of cooking and eating as acts of self-care. Food not only has the power to nourish us and transport us but also to transform us.
May we all accept ourselves for the tomato sluts that we are!
What I made from this cookbook: ~ turkish cottage cheese egg ~ nutritional yeast vinaigrette ~ coconut chipotle chicken ~ sour patch lemonade
** Thanks to NetGalley & the publisher for access to the e-arc!
Book Review: Food is a Feeling: Recipes & Stories, with Love by Carla Lalli
Rating: ★★☆☆☆
Food Is a Feeling is an intimate, personal cookbook that treats cooking as a form of self-care rather than merely a way to get dinner on the table. Carla Lalli Music combines 65 recipes with around 30 essays about food, family, memory, divorce, motherhood, and the emotional work of starting over. Her central idea is that meals can nurture us in ways that go well beyond basic sustenance—and that sometimes, yes, eating your feelings is completely justified.
A lot of the book grows out of Carla’s experience rebuilding her life after the end of a 24-year marriage. She pays attention to what she craves and cooks accordingly, resulting in recipes like lemony chickpea stew with rice, beans and greens, and a salad sandwich. She also looks back at meaningful dishes from her family and restaurant career, including Alfredo, pancakes, crispy fish, and rhubarb compote. The essays connect these foods to the messy, funny, comforting process of healing and figuring out who you are.
I’ll start with the cover, because it’s genuinely lovely. The writing has some funny and engaging moments, and I appreciated the emotional honesty behind the idea that cooking can be an act of love directed toward yourself.
Unfortunately, the recipes didn’t really work for me. They felt a little unpredictable and, in some cases, more like an extension of Carla’s personal story than dishes I was eager to make. I can understand the appeal, but the food itself didn’t leave me especially inspired. There’s personality here, and occasionally some humor, but overall it was more of a shrug than a revelation.
⚠️This review was written based on personal opinions and experiences with the book. Individual preferences may vary⚠️
It’s not that often that a book is as compelling to read as it is to cook from, but Carla’s new book is true on both counts. Carla does an incredible job detailing her personal circumstances with honesty, rawness and vulnerability, but through it all, recognizes that food and sustenance are still a vital part of this thing we call life. Our food life is not static, and Carla has excelled at giving the reader permission to change and evolve our tastes as she recounts her own experiences, and in particular, how often what we want to cook or eat ourselves is different than what we have to prepare when cooking for others. The recipes are a collection of just those sorts of things: foods she craved or found comforting. The essays really draw you in. You will find yourself wanting immediately to go and make that pot of her buttered rice. There are witty recipes, like her play on surf and turf, and also classic recipes where she shares surprising ingredients such as buttermilk and cornstarch in her cutlets. Clarkson Potter provided me with a free copy of this book, but the opinions and experiences are my own. I have been cooking from this book for over a month, and have been impressed by how unique yet delicious the recipes are. The lemonade recipe is quite tart and sweet, but very refreshing. Her creamless Alfredo recipe is the pinnacle of comfort food. Her treatment for salted crackers is a revelation. But most of all, I am so happy to have tried her bolognese. It is not a quick recipe, but very worth the time and effort. Because the recipes meander throughout the book with her stories, the indexes in the back are particularly helpful. This is a book you will want to read and cook from, and is highly recommended especially for anyone who has experienced a big life change, but still wants to find their way back to the kitchen.
**★★★★★ A Beautiful Celebration of Food, Emotions, and the Stories We Share**
*Food Is a Feeling* is a heartwarming cookbook that beautifully explores the emotional connection between food, memories, and the people we love. What makes this collection especially appealing is its combination of delicious recipes and personal storytelling, reminding readers that cooking is about much more than preparing meals. It is also about expressing affection, preserving traditions, and creating meaningful moments around the table.
I particularly appreciate the thoughtful approach behind this book. The recipes feel connected to everyday experiences and the special occasions that make life memorable. Whether preparing something comforting after a long day, sharing a homemade meal with family, or creating a thoughtful dish for friends, this collection offers inspiration to make cooking a more personal and rewarding experience.
Another highlight is the storytelling. Food has a remarkable ability to bring people together, evoke cherished memories, and create connections across generations. The stories add warmth and personality to the collection, making it enjoyable to read even beyond the kitchen. I love how the book celebrates the idea that familiar flavors can carry deep meaning and that the simplest meals can sometimes become the most unforgettable.
The overall spirit of this cookbook feels inviting, sincere, and uplifting. It encourages readers to slow down, appreciate the process of cooking, and find happiness in sharing food with others.
Overall, this is a lovely addition to any cookbook collection, especially for readers who value meaningful stories alongside delicious recipes. A well-deserved five-star recommendation for anyone who believes that food is not simply nourishment but also an expression of love, connection, and belonging.
In the wake of a separation and divorce, Carla Lalli finds herself downsizing her meal prep and experimenting within new constraints. First it’s the one giant Dutch oven in the apartment rental, then the lack of oven or dishwasher in the saltbox house on Long Island. The rediscovery of a produce staple: tomatoes, and the radical acceptance of smaller parts somehow making a satisfying whole.
I love cookbooks with context. If you’re reading a book like this just for the recipes, you won’t understand the very important why behind it all. Carla is not pretentious about food - she loves it - and that’s why I loved reading this book. There’s a humility to putting buttered rice and a giant bowl of popcorn in a cook book. They seem rudimentary, no? False. Carla shows that food that makes you feel something deserves a spot at the table.
This book has me thinking about annual visits to the east coast to visit my Grandma, the rolled up lefse my great aunt Gail makes at Thanksgiving, the sugar cookies no one has perfected except my mom, being the only person on my study abroad willing to order melon and prosciutto for the table. Those little moments with food and people that make eating feel sacred.
I loved this book and I hope you do too!
Thank you to NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for my honest review.
It was the most depressing book I’ve ever read. Debbie Downer of a cookbook. This feels like a journal printed into a book with “basic” recipes added in to publish and call it a cookbook. None of the recipes were above basic cooking level. All of these recipes most of us make. I would never call my pork chops “separation pork chops.” Then, let’s not forget the “night cereal” — YES AN ENTIRE RECIPE for eating and pouring Chex cereal into a bowl for dinner to “eat in bed or while watching a show.”
“Beach Peaches” = how to each a peach 🍑 WTH?? Don’t we all know how to eat a peach?? This author is writing a cookbook - for who exactly?? My guess - therapy for herself.
The essays we were described in this cookbook as “feelings for food” are pages and pages and chapters of the author’s life story from separation through divorce through somewhat healed. This cookbook seems like a therapists idea to help the author heal after a bitter divorce that was actually mutual so why the hatred for the divorce? Be happy. Find joy. You have kids - yes you can focus on them like a firehose! Kids love being with their parents and hearing their mom laugh! Laugh more and life will hurt less!
Still not sure this cookbook was written for anyone but the author. I hope the next cookbook is focused on cooking as she has a background in cooking SO COOK!!
This kind of cookbook saw me coming. I regularly read cookbooks cover to cover, exclusively during dinner time. Aspirational eating? Occasionally I take photos of recipes that pique my interest before returning to the library. Some of these have become beloved weekly staples (I’m looking at you, Julia Turshen). I’ve never kept track of all the cookbooks I read here on goodreads (though I probably should have, then I wouldn’t be so woefully behind on my reading goal for the year). Since this cookbook is more like a memoir, I am going to document. I enjoyed the format of this book featuring examples of foods that helped her through a transitional time of her life. While there are many recipes listed, there are just as many let’s say, serving suggestions. For example, pretzels dipped into a stick of butter. That’s it. I do feel like it works for the theme of this book. This is Carla’s story to tell after all. My only complaint is one that is really more a “me” problem. The font size on her essays is smaller than the recipes. So when, for instance, I lean forward to have a bite of food the words enter what I call the “blur zone”. Wherein I can’t really distinguish what line I am on anymore, and I find myself having to back up and find my place again. That said, I’ll get readers when my arms are no longer long enough for me to hold the book out.
Food Is a Feeling doesn’t read like a polished celebrity cookbook—it feels like a friend handed you her well-worn recipe binder, complete with scribbled notes, substitutions, and little reminders that only make sense after you’ve cooked the dish a dozen times. I loved that.
It reminded me of my own binders: one for Thanksgiving, which I’ve hosted for about 20 years, and another for my Bunco gang, which is going on 30. Those handwritten notes may look chaotic, but they’re priceless. They’re where you keep the little timing and ingredient tricks that let you pull off a hosting gig with less stress, more confidence… and while having a few Miller Lites along the way.
Carla shares that same spirit, offering not just recipes but the stories, encouragement, and practical wisdom that come from feeding the people you love. My favorite line was, “There are temperatures and times, just as much as there are handfuls and enoughs.” That perfectly captures the balance between precision and improv that makes cooking so much fun.
I’m not vegan, but plenty of the creative pasta dishes and plant-based recipes looked delicious enough to earn a spot in my girl dinner rotation.
Thanks to NetGalley-will probably purchase once it’s on the shelf!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley. All opinions are my own.
I found the introduction to Food Is a Feeling insightful, a little vulnerable, and a nice, honest opening into the book. There’s a clear focus on how food connects with comfort, sharing, emotions, and different stages of life. At times, it also feels like an act of catharsis.
The essays provide a lot of the substance behind the recipes, giving them context and meaning. The recipes themselves are simple, easy to follow, and relatively fuss-free, although I can’t say many of them personally appealed to me.
I’d say this is much more of a story-driven memoir than a traditional cookbook. If you’re looking for innovative recipes or technical cooking advice, this probably isn’t the one for you. The recipes are more general guides than strict instructions, so a bit of intuition is needed.
Overall, it was an okay read, and I appreciated the exploration of food and its place in our lives, but I’m not sure it’s one I’d revisit often.
4.5 stars! This is a (cook)book I'm comfortable reviewing having not cooked a single one of its recipes (which include the best way to eat a peach, PB&J, night cereal, and a porchetta style smoked lamb shoulder).
Food is a Feeling is more of a collection of food-centric essays with recipes than a cookbook and I loved that about it. Carla is a beautiful writer and her descriptions made me curious about tons of combos and ingredients: cocchi Americano martinis, nutritional yeast vinaigrette, her mother's homemade Alfredo.
The book is centered around Carla's divorce, but it's not strictly about that. It's about her finding her footing in this new life context, reconnecting with her love of food, the lives of her kids, and more.
I really enjoyed this and I can't wait to actually try some of the recipes! Thanks very much to NetGalley and Ten Speed Press for the ARC.
Part memoir, part cookbook, and exactly the kind of concept that draws me in. I loved the idea of recipes that weren't just recipes, but extensions of the feelings, and stories surrounding them. Food as memory, food as an emotional archive, food as a way of making sense of the different versions of ourselves. I was much more interested in these connections than in the recipes themselves, most of which didn't particularly appeal to me, but that wasn't really the point for me anyway.
Ultimately, I liked the concept more than the execution. My main gripe was the narrative flow. I could see the logic behind the way the book was divided into sections, each with its own themes and associations, but I sometimes found the transitions between different periods of Lalli's life a little disjointed.
Thanks to NetGalley for the digital ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This book started with an emotional wallop of the author describing her first night alone during a divorce. And as I kept reading, I realized this book couldn’t decide if it was a divorce memoir or a cookbook. I guess I went into this expecting more of a cookbook as I own and enjoy one of her earlier books, but the narrative sections caught me by surprise and was trying hard for resilience but often felt like a bummer. Some of the recipes looked appealing, but some felt more like just vibes (e.g. cereal and milk, seltzer and fresca, etc.). Thank you to NetGalley and Clarkson Potter for the ARC.
"Food is a Feeling" was such a refreshing cookbook to read through! I loved the vulnerability that Carla shared throughout the book and the accessible recipes for those who feel their way through cooking. I always enjoy when authors share various parts of themselves and their stories alongside dishes that feel like home to them. This was such an enjoyable read with great recipes that I can't wait to try! This book was hopeful, strong, emotional, and full of love. Well done!
Disclaimer: I received a free review copy of this book from the publisher Clarkson Potter and Ten Speed Press. All views are my own.
This new cookbook from Carla Lalli, and it's stunning! This book has the perfect blend of recipes and essays. I really enjoyed reading through this and finding recipes that I have to come back to. Her stories really show how food can connect to feelings. I felt that even though the recipe instructions are detailed, it still allows home cooks to go through and find what feels right. The photography is beautiful and really draws you in, making you hungry and wanting to try these recipes for yourself. I'm looking forward to making 'Quick Beans and Rice for When the Avocado is Ripe', and 'Must-Have Coconut Tapioca w/ Tropical Fruits.
I went into this anticipating a cookbook, and instead found a divorce memoir with recipes mixed in. The book was still interesting and the recipes look yummy, but I'll admit, I wasn't expecting this to lean so far into memoir territory. I think this is a beautiful way for the author to process her divorce. It's obviously a life changing situation that brings up all kinds of emotions and this seemed really cathartic for her. I just wish I had realized it going in. Overall, if you go in knowing this book is largely a divorce memoir with the bonus of a bunch of good recipes, I think you'll enjoy it. If you go in expecting a cookbook with some anecdotes about the author's life, you may be disappointed.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the e-ARC. All opinions are my own.
Carla Lalli's writing and voice--decidedly different from typical 'recipe voice'--absolutely sings in this cookbook. It's such a treat to lend an ear to her stories of being a young line cook, of separation, of being a mom, and navigating different chapters of life. It adds such a special touch to the accompanying recipes. Now I feel bad for all the online recipes where I quickly scrolled past the heartfelt story (and ads) to get to the ingredients list. Truly the kind of cookbook you curl up in bed to read! I hope this sets the standard for all cookbook authors; more of this, please.