Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Best Short Stories 2026: The O. Henry Prize Winners

Rate this book
The prestigious annual anthology features prize-winning stories by an international array of talented writers, including Weike Wang, Colm Tóibín, Louise Erdrich, Samanta Schweblin, Jenny Xie, Kevin Wilson, Brandon Taylor, and Catherine Lacey.

Continuing a century-long tradition of cutting-edge literary excellence, this year's edition contains twenty prizewinning stories chosen from the thousands published in magazines over the previous year. Guest editor Tommy Orange has brought his own refreshing perspective to the prize, selecting stories by an engaging mix of celebrated names and emerging voices. The winning stories are accompanied by an introduction by Orange, observations from the winning writers on what inspired them, and an extensive resource list of magazines that publish short fiction.

THE WINNING STORIES

"Five Bridges," Colm Tóibín
"Flowers and Their Meanings," Marie-Helene Bertino
"American Realism," Brandon Taylor
"The Hare," Ismael Ramos, translated from the Galician by Jacob Rogers
"Where Are You and Where Is My Money," Ucheoma Onwutuebe
"Love of My Days," Louise Erdrich
"Stick Season," Jenny Xie
"She-Bear," Evgenia Nekrasova, translated from the Russian by Marianna Suleymanova
"This Time and the Next," Noel Quiñones
"Pretend," Mary Williams
"Case Study," Weike Wang
"Inês," João Pedro Vala
"Tender," Sarah LaBrie
"Earshot," Guka Han, translated from the French by Katie Shireen Assef
"The Masterclass," William Pei Shih
'Welcome to the Club," Samanta Schweblin, translated from the Spanish by Megan McDowell
"Waiting, a Quintet," Kimberly Blaeser
"Muscle to Muscle, Toe to Toe," Kim Samek
"All Stories," Kevin Wilson
"The Ghost Coat," Catherine Lacey

354 pages, Kindle Edition

Published September 29, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Tommy Orange

30 books5,374 followers
Tommy Orange is a recent graduate from the MFA program at the Institute of American Indian Arts. He is a 2014 MacDowell Fellow, and a 2016 Writing by Writers Fellow. He is an enrolled member of the Cheyenne and Arapaho Tribes of Oklahoma. He was born and raised in Oakland, California, and currently lives in Angels Camp, California.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
21 (26%)
4 stars
35 (44%)
3 stars
19 (24%)
2 stars
4 (5%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews
Profile Image for Emma Deplores Goodreads Censorship.
1,522 reviews2,178 followers
October 20, 2026
I’ve gotten into these yearly anthologies and prefer the O. Henry to Best American; I find it to have more engaging stories, and appreciate its inclusion of international voices. This is not the best year of the O. Henry for me (thus far that would be 2025), but then of the recent guest editors, Orange is not my favorite author, either. I liked about 10-12 of the 20 selections.

The stories are varied enough that I don’t have a lot of commentary on the anthology as a whole, except that there’s so many more daughters than sons (several of the stories focus on mothers and daughters or fathers and daughters) that I wondered whether Orange has recently become the father of a daughter himself, or whether this is just the market. Comments on the individual stories:

“Five Bridges” by Colm Toibin: A poor start for me. I recently read another story by this author that sang, but this just fell flat. An “issue” story about an undocumented Irish plumber self-deporting on Trump’s election, which seems to expect the reader to provide the emotion, because the character himself doesn’t display any. He’s leaving behind his whole life because… he can’t be bothered to get a bank account? The dialogue is also a bit off (since when do American teenagers say “mustn’t”?).

“Flowers and Their Meanings” by Marie-Helene Bertino: This one is cute and fun, if not especially memorable to me—a collection of strange happenings a young woman encounters over a summer in a small town, dealing with her convalescing mother, her work, and her friends. The first person present was a terrible choice though, it was crying out for the past tense.

“American Realism” by Brandon Taylor: Twenty boring pages of New Yorkers talking about art.

“The Hare” by Ismael Ramos, translated by Jacob Rogers: The first story I really liked, about a young Galician man and his older sister tentatively reconnecting over a road trip. The characters and emotion felt very real to me, though I still don’t quite get the symbolism of the hare.

“Where Are You and Where Is My Money” by Ucheoma Onwetuebe: An entertaining tour of shortcomings in Nigerian society, kicked off when a woman’s savings are stolen by her boyfriend. The preacher is sanctimonious, the police are corrupt, HR is a font of gossip, and the fastest way to get ahead as a young woman is to become the mistress of a powerful man, or at least have a friend who is. An epistolary story that, like almost all epistolary fiction, reads a little off, a little too expository.

“Love of My Days” by Louise Erdrich: A meh historical story about men chasing an outlaw.

“Stick Season” by Jenny Xie: A strong, evocative story about a couple regretfully breaking off their relationship. Everything about the setting, down to the temporary nature of staying in a hotel, reflects their emotional experience.

“She-Bear” by Evgenia Nekrasova, translated by Marianna Suleymanova: A dark, compelling story that reads like a fable or fairy tale, about a woman kidnapped by a bear and the daughter she gives birth to. My guess is Can also be read as a parable about violence against women and its continuing effects.

“This Time and the Next” by Noel Quiñones: The vanishingly rare epistolary story that reads like real letters (although I did question how short and spaced out they were), exchanged by an incarcerated father and his daughter as she grows up. The author isn’t afraid of honestly reflecting infelicities in the way regular people (especially less educated ones) write, and the flawed, unsentimental portrayal of the father feels authentic too. Unsurprised to learn the author has known people in prison.

“Pretend” by Mary Williams: The shortest story in the anthology, so a surprising favorite. A mother creates fake accounts to interact with (catfish?) her family online. So much to say about how technology destabilizes people’s opinions and identities and relationships, and the types of interactions people have online, and the pursuit of connection.

“Case Study” by Weike Wang: A good story about the fraught relationship between immigrant parents and their adult daughter as they age and face health crises. This one is about disconnection too; for all the daughter wants to separate herself from her parents, she doesn’t seem to have anyone else.

“Ines” by Joao Pedro Vala: An experimental metafictional thing that I didn’t really get or appreciate. The core story isn’t even that interesting: boy meets girl, but is shy and lets her go.

“Tender” by Sarah LaBrie: A day in the life of a bitter, overworked single mother whose decisions leave a lot to be desired. The author says she wrote this story in an attempt to understand her own mother, which is interesting because she wrote a memoir about her mother’s schizophrenia and I didn’t get that vibe from this, but there’s certainly a lot to dig into here as far as why this mother behaves the way she does: feeling lonely, unsupported, overwhelmed, and ashamed.

“Earshot” by Guka Han, translated by Katie Shireen Assef: An odd little story, memorable less for plot than its association of noise with disconnection and distance, vs. silence with connection and authenticity.

“The Masterclass” by William Pei Shih: A piano student is undermined by their own teacher, who seems to view them as being in competition when the reality is that the teacher’s time has passed. My second time reading this story and one of the more striking things about it is the removal of gender markers from all the characters, perhaps in an attempt to keep the story from becoming about particular gender dynamics (but perhaps only calling attention to their absence).

“Welcome to the Club” by Samanta Schweblin, translated by Megan McDowell: A depressed woman gets some terrible advice from her asshole neighbor. Didn’t do much for me.

“Waiting, a Quintet” by Kimberly Blaeser: The death of an indigenous teenager, seen through the perspectives of the teen in question and four others who know him. Deliberately ambiguous and confusing enough I read it twice. The voices are very similar and don’t really sound like teens. My best interpretation is

“Muscle to Muscle, Toe to Toe” by Kim Samek: An intriguing story about the importance of honesty in relationships, the way technology can shape people in a particular direction but also the limits of expecting media you consume to “improve” you. I liked this, though the author’s note feels a bit off-base.

“All Stories” by Kevin Wilson: Surprised to have liked a story about a college kid taking a short story class and getting into his first relationship, but I did—it feels very authentic and vulnerable.

“The Ghost Coat” by Catherine Lacey: A bit of a nutty story, as I expected from this author. I’m taking the ill-fitting coat of unknown provenance as a symbol of gender expectations.
Profile Image for Nancy.
2,100 reviews506 followers
October 16, 2026
Tommy Orange has selected a diverse and unique collection of short stories from 2026. He believes a good short story is a "microcosm of human life itself."

I love a good short story. They can pack a real emotional punch.

The stories include a broad spectrum of voices and styles. Author statements offer insight into their work.

My favorites includes Colm Toibin's Five Bridges, which appeared in his new short stories collection and was a favorite of mine when I read it. The last stories left the deepest impact on me. Kevin Wilson's All Stories was profoundly moving, while Catherine Lacey's The Ghost Coat is an amazing parable of shedding the past.

Thanks to Vintage Books for a free book through NetGalley.
Profile Image for milo.
899 reviews
November 2, 2026
two beautiful things that changed my life and many that at least made me think. this is how it is with stories, which are as numerous and varied as all those crazy new kinds of apples. and they come out in the fall, too. :)
Profile Image for Jax.
346 reviews24 followers
October 23, 2026
This collection of twenty award-winning short stories was gleaned from among thousands published in magazines over the prior year. The themes are mostly weighty and include homelessness, loss, caregiving, deception, emotional abuse, moving on, music, and others. As I worked through the collection, I didn’t find much competition against the first two stories, my favorites. Five Bridges is especially good. The one about homelessness—which I won’t name to avoid a spoiler—is impactful for what it leaves behind more than the read itself, but that is enough. Short story collections include a variety of topics and themes about which some readers have no interest, which might explain my take. Most of all, once Geraldine in Five Bridges stole my heart, there wasn’t much left for any other.

This book includes a forward by Tommy Orange, who found his footing in short form. His readers should enjoy hearing his thoughts. The authors provide insight about their inspiration, and the publication includes a list of magazine sources that will serve as a guide for lovers of this form.

Many thanks to Knopf, Pantheon, Vintage, and Anchor | Vintage and NetGalley for providing this ARC.
48 reviews1 follower
October 30, 2026
I can't pick a fav story! Several of them were quite good! But some made me uncomfy LOL
Profile Image for Kasa Cotugno.
2,898 reviews614 followers
October 17, 2026
Given that these 20 stories were curated by Tommy Orange, it's no surprise to find them excellent and each with a lesson to share. What is surprising is that at the end of the book there are questions for and comments by the authors, unusual to find with a collection of short stories, also a description of the O. Henry Awards, giving a well rounded view of the stories.
Profile Image for Finnegan McBride.
27 reviews2 followers
October 10, 2026
I have to admit, I had a bad feeling going into this one. Series editor Jenny Minton Quigley’s foreword felt scattered and a little bastardizing, and volume editor Tommy Orange’s introduction consisted of fairly trite quotations which he waxed upon as though they were high poetry. In addition, the first story of the collection, Five Bridges, is easily the weakest. There’s nothing bad about the story, but nothing all that good either. I found myself asking: Is this what a good short story is in 2026? A bland, well-controlled story which contains no errors but takes no risks?

Things got better from there, however. A few stories are particularly worthy of mention. American Realism by Brandon Taylor is, per the title, one of the most photorealistic, true-to-life feeling stories I have ever come across. Inês by João Pedro Vala performed the incredible feat of making me absolutely hate it and then winning me over again in the last few pages. Ghost Coat by Catherine Lacey charmed me all the way through. Tender by Sarah LaBrie made me understand bad parents. All Stories by Kevin Wilson is personal in a way almost no stories are brave enough to be. It may be no better than Five Bridges in technical execution, but it shines a thousand times brighter, and will stick with me indefinitely longer, because it dared to be vulnerable.

Jenny and Tommy, I’m sorry I doubted you. So many great selections. I look forward to seeing what next year’s edition brings.

Individual story ratings:
Five Bridges: 3/5
Flowers and Their Meanings: 4/5
American Realism: 5/5
The Hare: 3/5
Where Are You and Where Is My Money?: 4/5
Love of My Days: 3/5
Stick Season: 4/5
She-Bear: 4/5
This Time and the Next: 4/5
Pretend: 3/5
Case Study: 4/5
Inês: 4/5
Tender: 5/5
Earshot: 3/5
The Masterclass: 4/5
Welcome to the Club: 4/5
Waiting, a Quintet: 4/5
Muscle to Muscle, Toe to Toe: 4/5
All Stories: 5/5
The Ghost Coat: 4/5
Profile Image for Arathy.
505 reviews10 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 20, 2026
Like any anthology, there were some stories that I loved and others I didn't care much for. This collection felt more polarizing to me somehow- the ones I liked, I absolutely loved, the ones I didn't, I forgot immediately after reading em. I know some of these- She-Bear, Flowers and their meanings, Where are you and where is my money, Earshot, among others, I will not forget. I know some - Welcome to the Club, Tender, Waiting, a Quintet- I want to forget.
I was also pleasantly surprised by the fact that there already was one story- The Masterclass- that I had already read. It was fun to rediscover it (even if only months later).
I'm also surprised by how many of these stories have motherhood/mother-daughter-relationships as a theme, sometimes violent, sometimes tender, and not always loving. Very interesting.
Overall, I had fun reading this collection and look forward to more!

Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC.
118 reviews7 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 22, 2026
This is a solid collection of short stories featuring a wide range of writers, styles, and perspectives. As with most anthologies, some stories connected with me more than others, but I enjoyed the variety and the opportunity to read authors I might not have picked up otherwise.
The writing throughout is strong, and I liked how different each story felt from the next. There’s a good mix of themes and approaches, which kept the collection interesting even when a particular story wasn’t necessarily for me. I also appreciated being introduced to some new-to-me writers alongside authors I was already familiar with.
Overall, an interesting collection and a good way to experience a variety of contemporary short fiction in one book. Thank you to Knopf, Pantheon, Vintage, and Anchor and NetGalley for providing this ARC for review consideration. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Teresa.
1,044 reviews7 followers
October 28, 2026
A great collection with something for everybody. These stories open up new worlds and ways to see the world, across different genres and formats.

I was delighted to find some familiar names and left in awe from new (to me) authors, authors I'll seek out. Stories that dazzle and leave you wanting more (in the best way). Stories that are haunting, subversive, and surprising.

Each was a little nugget of perfection.

My thanks to NetGalley and Knopf, Pantheon, Vintage, and Anchor | Vintage for the Advance Reader Copy. (pub. date 9/29/2026)
534 reviews1 follower
October 19, 2026
Always hard to rate a short story anthology. Some were great, many were Ok, some a waste of time.

The seven I really liked in ranked order:

My favorite - Love of My Days by by Louise Erdich who wrote Nightwatchman. This shows the power of the short story. In 12 pages of action we get the essential life history of the protagonist laid out in small pieces until the climatic ending when he is reunited with his long dead lover. The reader is moved from confusion to horror that the man killed the sheriff to empathy for him by the end of the story. He had worked for others his whole life and showed up one day at a farm thinking it must belong to him after so much labor. The greatest moment of his life comes when he is driving a team of wonderful horses away from his pursuers. It was worth giving his life for that moment. Erdich adds a sense of myth to it as well by having the woman who took him in tell her grandchildren of how she knew him, knew that he was wounded, and disappointed that he had not made it in life. Quite an ending when the posse man who comes to kill him approaches his wounded body and the ghost of his long gone love says “Don’t mind him.” There’s so much else going on here. The chickens getting killed by the weasel foretells of the rage and confusion unleashed by a posse. The owner of the farm’s obsession with his horses. The posse man who kills the protagonist reminds one of the ICE agents these days. Nobody else would hire him as a sheriff or deputy, but here was his opportunity to kill somebody. Of course he kills the mother of the horse team before getting his man.

Welcome to the Club - Schweiban - Really cool speculative fiction. A woman tries to drown herself but inexplicably walks out of the lake after being under water for quite some time. She interacts with her family and her strange neighbor for an entire day. Apparently she is being given a second chance. Her neighbor who killed himself but continues to inhabit this world must skin animals as a price for staying and urges her to kill her kid’s rabbit so she will feel guilty and stay. She will not and the story ends with her back at the bottom of the lake.

Flowers and their Meanings - Bertino - Did not think too much of it until the ending. It describes a perfectly ordinary life interrupted by 3 extraordinary and unrelated events, but to the protagonist the wildest and most interesting event is when she and her Mom, whom she is caring for, get into the wrong car. Why? Because the other events “were acts that happened to us. Getting into the wrong car felt like something my mother and I enacted. Like we’d stumbled onto a mystery. That it turned out to be a simple mistake only made the mystery wider. But it was generated by us. Our conversation. Our love.”

The Hare - Ramos - Set in Galicia and originally written in Galician. It’s about how little control the poor have over their lives. A brother and sister end up ditching the idea of going to their father’s with a hare dinner. When the brother ignores his sister’s instructions and opens up the trunk of the car he discovers the truth about her life. She is homeless and living in the car. Not knowing that her brother knows this truth, the sister explains that being alone must be a conscious decision. Otherwise you end up like their aunt, “not knowing what to do, thinking one day someone’s going to come and tell you exactly what you need to hear. That’s the worst possible situation: not being in control.” The author concludes that it is just like the hare which “had no choice. Whether it resisted until the very end or couldn’t resist at all. It’s not a choice that gets made. Never.”

Pretend - A Mom transitions from playing pretend with her young children to playing pretend on social media. Good look at how we live in an inauthentic age. She notes that one of her grown children will send her one word texts but will go on for pages in response to some stranger online who disagrees with her.

Five Bridges - Colm Tobin - A father who has overstayed his tourist visa in the US by 30 years and has fathered a young child. With Trump coming into office he decides to return to Ireland knowing he could never return to the US. I took the obscured visions of the 5 bridges to symbolize the future. He hopes his daughter will visit in the future, but that’s all in the distance.





This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Carol.
1,930 reviews21 followers
September 19, 2026
I received an Advance Copy of this book as a win from GoodReads.

Here is what I liked the most in this collection of short stories

1. The introduction by Tommy Orange. Since I am not fan of short stories except for a few, it was great to learn about why he loves short stories. Now I want read some of his short stories. I agree with him that the best make you feel something, and some sentences are intriguing and so memorable.

2. I loved the section of the O. Henry Prize Winners 2026 The Writers on their work. It is great more insight on what caused them to write it.

3. O Henry stories are a long time favorite mine so I enjoyed reading more about his life. I already knew that he was an embezzler and went to prison for it. But I didn't know that he was skilled at hiding when he had a deadline coming up.

4. There were some short stories that I was really drawn to:

She-Bear by Evgenia Nekravsa and translated by Marianna Suleymanova fascinated me,

This Time and the Next by Noel Quinones was intriguing and I wanted to read more.

Tender by Sandra LaBrie made me so angry but it added insight. I will never forget. Now I want to read her memoir, No One Gets to Fall Apart. I have added it to the books I want to buy.

Some of the stories I could not connect with at all. I think that is because of my own life story, some of them left me feeling disconnected.

You may connect with some of the stories that I did not.

Profile Image for Diane Dachota.
1,504 reviews158 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 5, 2026
Interesting collection of short stories, selected by writer Tommy Orange. I enjoyed most of this story collection that explores the frailties and complexities of the human experience. Orange selected a broad selection of authors, some of which are indigenous and other people of color. There were some well known authors in the selection including Louise, Erdrich, Colm Tóibín and Brandon Taylor. Some of my favorites in the collection were: "Stick Season" by Jenny Xie which is about a doomed relationship, "This Time and the Next" by Noel QuÎnones which is about the fractured relationship between an incarcerated father and his daughter and "The Ghost Coat" by Catherine Lacey which is about a mysterious coat that the main character finds and can't identify.

I also appreciated the book editors adding a extensive list of literary journals that accept short story submissions and a section where the various authors give some insight on their inspiration for their stories. There is not a bad one in the bunch here-highly recommend. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a copy of this ARC for review.
Profile Image for Kym.
803 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 7, 2026
I’ve always been a short story fan, so I was thrilled to receive an ARC edition of the new and soon-to-be-published 2026 anthology of O. Henry prize winning stories, The Best Short Stories of 2026, edited by Jenny Minton Quigley with guest editor Tommy Orange (Knopf, Pantheon, Vintage, and Anchor, expected September 29, 2026).

The stories in this collection are timely and relevant, and tie together well as a collection. The stories feature a wide range of literary voices, including both well-known and new authors of international acclaim. As with most short story anthologies, some stories resonated with me more than others, reflecting my personal taste and, of course, my current state of mind as I read. My favorite story in this collection is Marie-Helene Bertino’s "Flowers and Their Meanings." But, really, each story was a treat, and I am eager to add this collection to my personal library.

Thank you to NetGalley and Knoft, Pantheon, Vintage, and Anchor for providing an advance copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. The collection will be published on September 29, 2026.

5 stars
Profile Image for Robert Yokoyama.
261 reviews10 followers
October 20, 2026
The stories in this book are about people trying to make a connection with one another. My favorite story is "Five Bridges". This story is about a father trying to make a connection with his estranged daughter. "Pretend" and "Muscle to Muscle and Toe to Toe are excellent stories about how people connect through social media. "The Hare" is a beautiful story about the facile connection between siblings. "The Hare" motivates me to fortify the relationship I have with my sister. I enjoy the story "All Stories" because it brings back memories of bonding with my classmates by sharing my stories with them in college. "Flowers and Their Meanings' is a superb story about how a young woman tries to connect care for her elderly mother. I know what it feels like to receive care from a family member. I know it is not always easy for caregivers trying to balance a personal life and a personal one so "Flowers and Their Meanings" has poignancy for me. I love reading about the human connection in these short stories.
Profile Image for B K178.
433 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 4, 2026
*The Best Short Stories 2026: The O. Henry Prize Winners* is a diverse collection that highlights the scope of modern short fiction. Edited by guest editor and well-known author Tommy Orange, this year’s anthology features voices like Colm Tóibín, Louise Erdrich, Brandon Taylor, Catherine Lacey, Helene-Marie Bertino, and Kevin Wilson, among others. The collection offers a broad mix, including international stories. The stories range from personal to humorous, exploring themes from identity to more experimental styles.

A key strength of this collection is that readers can find short stories from their favorite authors or discover a new writer to enjoy. It offers a little bit of everything. Like any anthology, some stories will resonate more than others based on what you like, but it provides an insightful look at the variety in short stories. I would suggest it to others. There is plenty to enjoy here. Thanks to Knopf and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Lulu.
609 reviews2 followers
Read
September 19, 2026
"The Best Short Stories 2026" is an impressive and wide-ranging collection that brings together twenty prizewinning stories from both established authors and exciting new voices. The stories cover a broad mix of subjects, styles, and perspectives, making the collection feel varied without losing its overall sense of literary quality. With writers like Louise Erdrich, Colm Tóibín, Weike Wang, Samanta Schweblin, and Kevin Wilson alongside emerging talents, there’s plenty of variety for different tastes. Tommy Orange’s guest editorship adds an interesting perspective, while the introductions and notes from the writers offer a glimpse into how the stories came to life. It’s a strong collection for readers who enjoy discovering fresh voices and seeing just how much can be done with the short story form.
Profile Image for Addison Dean.
297 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 27, 2026
This collection is quite wide ranging, and yet it feels like all of the stories are puzzle pieces that fit together perfectly. I won’t go into each individual story, but a few that I enjoyed were “Flowers and Their Meanings,” “Earshot,” “Where Are You and Where Is My Money,” “Stick Season,” and perhaps the one that sticks with me most because it is so surprising, “She-Bear.” “Muscle to Muscle, Toe to Toe” was another that I appreciated, a particularly timely tale in our algorithmically sculpted era. It took me some time to get through this book because I felt like I needed a breather between stories, but I’m glad I got to be introduced to a lot of new-to-me writers and experience short works from some authors I’ve previously enjoyed.

Many thanks to NetGalley and Vintage for the opportunity to read the ARC of this collection and share my honest feedback!
79 reviews
October 14, 2026
I'm always excited to read (or re-read) the O. Henry Prize winners, but I was more excited to see what Tommy Orange would bring to the table. This collection did not disappoint: great rez-adjacent stories by Erdrich and Blaeser, two really interesting epistolary stories about heartbreak, and several magically realist stories (the marvelous "She-Bear" and the chilling "Welcome to the Club") offer interesting variety. The more traditionally 'realist' stories do not disappoint, particularly the relationship driven stories "Stick Season" by Jenny Xie, the sadly quiet "Five Bridges" by Colm Tobin, and Kevin Wilson's deft "All Stories". There's also a fair touch of the trendy Internet age navel-gazing like "Earshot" and the quasi-Black Mirror vibes of "Muscle to Muscle, Toe to Toe," but the absolute killer is Mary Williams' tiny "Pretend" which shocks and surprises without showing out.
Profile Image for Dana.
186 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 12, 2026
This collection of twenty stories from the O. Henry Prize winners of the year will be published in September 2026, and it is a very good anthology. In his introduction, Tommy Orange shares the information that his agent told him about short story anthologies: they do not sell very well. I hope that this book will defy that point and make its way into book shops and libraries and into the hands of readers who will appreciate the beauty of these stories.

The authors of these stories hail from around the world, and I enjoyed reading about different cultures in a wide variety of voices. I think lovers of short literary fiction will find much to like in this book.

Thanks to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for providing a review copy in exchange for my honest opinion.
Profile Image for Calynne.
193 reviews8 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 16, 2026
This was my first from these annual editions of anthologies and definitely won’t be my last! Kudos to Tommy O.

Each story brought something different to the table. I really appreciated getting to experience so many different voices, perspectives, styles, and ideas all in one book. I also loved how diverse this collection was. Of course I didn’t resonate with every story and a few didn’t fully land for me, but I enjoyed the majority and had a great reading experience overall. Plus I discovered quite a few literary gems and new-to-me authors I can’t wait to read more from.

Looking forward to next year’s collection!

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher—Knopf, Pantheon, Vintage, and Anchor for this ARC!
Profile Image for Lex Ax.
240 reviews
October 28, 2026
I thoroughly enjoyed this collection.

My favorite stories (in the order of of the collection):
Love of My Days by Louise Erdrich
Stick Season by Jenny Xie
This Time and the Next by Noel Quinones
Pretend by Mary Williams
Tender by Sarah Labrie
Welcome to the Club by Samanta Schweblin
Muscle to Muscle, Toe to Toe by Kim Samek
All Stories by Kevin Wilson
The Ghost Coat by Catherine Lacy

My top three:
1. Welcome to the Club by Samanta Schweblin
2. Pretend by Mary Williams
3. Tender by Sarah Labrie
Honorable mention: The Ghost Coat by Catherine Lacy
Honorable mention: Muscle to Muscle, Toe to Toe by Kim Samek
Profile Image for Denice Langley.
5,276 reviews58 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
June 6, 2026
When asked to recommend a book or author, I often offer up my favorite collections of short stories. Short stories are a great snapshot of an author's storytelling skills. The Best Short Stories 2026 offers 20 O Henry Award winners, their winning stories, and a short description of the author's inspiration for their stories. In any collection, some stories will resonate with readers better than others, but these are all winners. I guarantee if you read them, you'll find many authors to add to your "must-read" TBR list.
Profile Image for Alison Hardtmann.
1,555 reviews2 followers
October 2, 2026
This is a stellar collection of short stories, managing to avoid the usual problem of having to include a number of lackluster stories to fill the book. Here, the some of the stories are by big name authors like Louise Erdrich and Colm Toibin, some by new and exciting writers like Marie-Helene Bertino and Weike Wang, a few introduce us to writers like Kim Samek. The real strength of this collection, however, lies in the number of stories in translation, giving us a look at the finest of short stories being published in other countries.

Among the stand-out stories is All Stories by Kevin Wilson, about an awkward college student who meets an intriguing young woman, She-Bear by Evgenia Nekrasova, in which a bear takes a woman captive, and American Realism by Brandon Taylor, about a group of friends in New York that reminded me of what a fine writer Taylor is. But I could have easily pulled another half dozen stories out to use as examples for how good this collection is.
Profile Image for Grace Sarick.
61 reviews
October 29, 2026
Read for class but did not particularly enjoy, although I’m not sure if that is so much the anthology’s fault or mine for disliking short stories and avoiding collections like these when at all possible. Regardless, as far as anthologies go, I could definitely appreciate the through line of this one and enjoyed how particularly the stories were chosen. My favorites were “Love of My Days,” “Iněs,” “The Masterclass,” and “All Stories.” And with peace and love almost all of the other stories were my least favorites
Profile Image for Bennett T.
29 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 22, 2026
Best Short Stories 2026 is a good mix of short stories edited by Tommy Orange. A few standouts for me were:

Welcome to the Club by Samantha Schweblin — also one of my favorite authors! Check out Good and Evil, her collection of short stories

All Stories by Kevin Wilson

The Ghost Cat by Catherine Lacey

Some of the stories lost me, but overall a solid pick for short story fans, and a good way to discover some new authors.
Profile Image for Jifu.
772 reviews70 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 17, 2026
(Note: I read an advanced reader copy of this book courtesy of NetGalley)

It’s quite nice to have the O. Henry Award winners of the year all grouped together in one anthology. This was actually my first time reading any of the annual collections, and even when I didn’t like a story, each one still left an impact, and stayed with me longer than expected. In short - just a collection of genuine contemporary literary jewels.
Profile Image for Tracey.
382 reviews19 followers
October 23, 2026
Thank you Netgally for the digital ARC.

I'm late to the party with my review. I enjoyed some more than others but that's typical in any short story collection. There's definitely a theme going on but also a variety of writing styles so something for everyone which is what is great about these collections. If you lack a lot of time to read it's perfect for having a little something to read before bed.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews