First Shift by Lisa Linden is a solid MM hockey romance that leans far more on emotional depth than spice, and for the most part, it works really well.
Griffin Lapierre is the veteran NHL captain of a brand-new expansion team who has spent sixteen years in the closet; first pushed there by his late father and later kept there by his agent. Being traded forces him to rebuild not only his career, but his sense of self, all while trying to unify a group of individual players into an actual team. His struggle felt painfully real and deeply rooted in fear, responsibility, and habit.
Wesley Hutton, the team’s PR manager, brings his own emotional baggage. After a past scandal involving a closeted player destroyed his career once before, Wesley knows exactly how dangerous a secret relationship can be. He doesn’t want to repeat old mistakes, but his chemistry with Griffin is undeniable.
The romance starts as a slow burn, built on friendship and mutual awareness of the risks involved. I really appreciated how they tried to experience “normal” couple moments in secret, learning each other in small, intimate ways. The book is relatively low on spice, but the emotional connection more than makes up for it.
The hockey content is well balanced, present and engaging without becoming overly technical. Watching Griffin work to shape the team dynamic was a highlight, even if the inclusion of a “bad apple” player felt a bit cliché.
My biggest issue was the length and repetition. Wesley constantly compares Griffin to his ex, and both characters rehash the same fears and internal conflicts repeatedly for a large portion of the book. It became tiring, especially when very little emotional progress was happening for over half the story. At times, they were also frustratingly careless given how aware they were of the risks.
That said, the third act absolutely redeemed the story for me. Griffin’s coming-out journey, and the way he and Wesley protect and stand by each other, was handled with care and emotional weight. Their decision to face the consequences together was powerful and satisfying.
Overall, this was a thoughtful, emotionally driven MM hockey romance with strong characters and a meaningful HEA. Despite some pacing issues, I enjoyed it and will definitely be continuing the series to see where the Stormhawks go next.
⭐ 4 stars
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.