Ten Billion to One has a SUPER strong, creepy premise, and it is this alone that sustained me in turning the pages, as I struggled with parts of it. The subtle point of the elimination of Zero-Day and the Outliers, however, actually passes for creepy believable, and those parts where the training of him to implement policies, for example, sandbag "children," a reward for empathy, and the developing understanding of the true purpose of his assignment, were quite gripping. It is with Anna and the baby, however, that the underlying unfamiliar creepiness becomes enlivened with the blood-and-guts familiarity of life.
However, as one reading participant, I do think that I was able to recall more instances where I was negatively affected by reading than positively, even as I was aware that this novel was also a very well-crafted work. The sense of hopelessness extends throughout and is never relenting from beginning through end, offering little respite even to allow the reader to catch its breath. A human proxy representing this particular society, Trent is also an extremely effective foil that is at the same time also one-dimensional; this is certainly one aspect that I was hoping for less. At points, this novel appears to strike every possible chord within the human realm at every possible point – babies, propaganda songs, punishment by violent means – that can come across as a little bit ham-fisted.
Where, finally, the story did continue to work for me, therefore, was in its commitment to its world and its sense of purpose. The feeling of suspense in regards to the compliance checks and the escape mission is really believable, and I was interested enough in Anna, Morgan, and the baby to see what happens in it, even when I was frustrated with all the darkness. I may wind up with more complains than praise, but I don't think it is a bad book – it is a dark, well-written one, and it does exactly what it set out to do, although whether it’s more effective or smothering has a great deal to do with your feelings towards all of this darkness.
The Goods:
- Dystopian series with a great concept involving the Zero-Day and Outlier kids
- Scenes of training, the checks on compliance, and escape scenes done well and with a good immediate feeling
- The core of feeling for Anna, her baby, and Morgan, which gives such large ideas genuine human significance
The Bads:
– The constantly pessimistic context possesses so few points of reprieve in the book, which might make the task of reading the book emotionally draining.
– A fairly monotonous, brutally sadistic big bad who might let down those expecting more complex villains.
- Emotional notes that are a little too obvious in their dealing with impact points by stacking too many of them in the area rather than allowing them to be self-evident.
I can recommend “Ten Billion to One” to those who might get some enjoyment out of viewing their dystopia in a darker, more intense, more thought-provoking form. I might find this book to have some more negative experiences to it, I don’t know, I can definitely realize how well this book is put together, how good this particular idea is, how true, how likely, this particular idea involving “Zero-Day, Outlier, and just people who are just swept up in this situation where they are basically just enforcing something that’s absolutely appalling to think about, this situation that Anna, Anna’s baby, and Morgan find themselves in.”
Every book hits differently for every reader.
Thanks for reading my review.
- Corey