Reviews can bounce between extremes depending upon the reviewers. It helps to find someone who shares similar taste and that you know that if they like a book, you will most likely enjoy it as well. Oddly enough, this person for me is Tom Hanks. Yes, the actor Tom Hanks. I subscribe to his myspace blog because usually in the Fall he posts the books that he read over the summer and includes commentary. His taste is eclectic, and has caused me to read books I might not have picked up otherwise. Tom Hanks read "North River" in what he calls the luckiest he has been this year, reading it in a mountain cabin, in the rain, all alone except for his dog. He also said that after finishing it, he ordered all of Pete Hamill's books. That was good enough for me. And once again, I agree with him. This was my first Pete Hamill book. Reviewers are saying that "Forever" is much better, so I am really looking forward to reading it since I loved this book so much. Many reviewers have given a synopsis of the story, so I will refrain. I will say, however, that when it comes to creating a setting and ambience, I can't imagine a better writer. He totally created a post-WWII New York for me.. assailing the senses with imagery of snowstorms, the Hudson (North) River, familiar songs of the era, etc. This was my parents' generation, and remembrances of our lives together in the 50's hint at the truth of his descriptions. Some of it was not pleasant to remember, such as the way women were viewed as chattel and my Irish-American mother's acceptance of wife beating as normal and pedestrian. It was still prevalent when I was a little girl. You can sometimes hear Lucy saying "Now, don't hit me, Ricky" on "I Love Lucy"...it was accepted. Also, though, there was a sense of community. People knew their neighbors and looked in on them. Even simple details, such as Hamill describing orange peels floating on the river rings true. People ate fruit in the way of a treat during the Depression and I could see he put so much thought into the authenticity of his descriptions. This book had romance but wasn't drippy...a hint of happily ever after without the easy wrap up. Tom Hanks felt the characters would shine in any decade and I agree. They are fleshed out and admirable, people you would want to know, even some of the mobsters. I really look forward to reading more Pete Hamill. First, though... I'm reading two of the other choices from Tom's summer reading, "Quentins" by Maeve Binchy and "Marjorie Morningstar" by Herman Wouk. I'm a little surprised that more people didn't give "North River" high marks...which leads me back to the importance of finding a reviewer you trust that has similar taste. Odd though it may be, my reading compass is Tom Hanks! I hope he continues to share his reading lists for a long time!